07-11-05 Health & Public Safety - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Martha Lewis stated that she lives in a neighborhood where many of these student rental properties are located. On many occasions she has had to "peel herself off the ceiling" as a result of the raucous noises. Ms. Lewis stated that she is also a landlord and supports the proposed ordinance in that capacity also. Council Member White then asked if there were any individuals who wished to speak in opposition to Bill No. 40-05. Dave Smith who provided a post office box number and zip code of 46630 stated that he believes the ordinance is "overkill". He stated that he is a landlord and believes that the fine of $2,500 is too much. He asked the City to enforce the laws which are currently on the books. Cecilia Gild stated that she has only "good things to say about Notre Dame Seniors for the past six years",noting that they live next to her. Bonnie Rain of 1854 Blair Hills Court in Mishawaka stated that there are far less problems when there are responsible students and responsible landlords. She stated that when she lived in South Bend she had students living near her and her disabled children and did not have any problems. Rita Kopola of 66559 Ivy in Lakeville stated that the ordinance "spreads too broad a blanket" and that it is too restrictive for landlords. Deb Albright of 915 Eash Washington stated that the majority of the noise comes from transients going thru the neighborhoods on their way to bars. He stated that when she had problems, she called the police and the problem was handled. She suggested a group solution of all parties. A realtor living at 1715 East Wayne street stated that he rents the house at 724 East Washington and "strongly opposes the ordinance". He stated that he has made investments in marginal properties, and fears that if such houses are sold that the city would have a bigger problem. Mark Kramer who did not provide an address stated that he owns 50 houses which he believes is an investment of about$3 million. He owns several houses on Washington Street and several on St. Peter. He believes that students are "a vital part of our community". He sees the proposed ordinance as specifically targeting students. He voiced concern over "false reports". He noted that occasionally there are large parties which he believes can be addressed thru communication. Lois Steele inquired why the city would not ticket these individuals and work with Notre Dame. Chuck Kemble of 113 Notre Dame Avenue stated that he has already received a noise complaint, noting that"no effort was made by the neighbors to talk to the students". He believes that most people are reasonable and if neighbors would talk to the students concerns could be addressed. Dave Wozniak of 806 East Wayne inquired whether the proposed ordinance is constitutional. Council Member Dieter asked if verbal warning would have to be given first, noting that police are required to document. He stated that this ordinance would be enforced city-wide, 24-hours a day. July 11,2005 Health and Public Safety Committee of the 2005 South Bend Common Council -page 2-