May 1993 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

No further discussion. The motion passed unanimously. • 5. Historic Landmarks Mr. Oxian announced that 710 N. Cushing had been approved for designation as a local Historic Landmark by the Common Council on May 10, 1993. Mr. Holycross distributed plans recently compiled by the planning committee working on the renovation of Madison Elementary School. He explained that staff had attended two such meetings. He explained that the submitted drawings were preliminary plans submitted by their architects, Hebard and Hebard. Mr. Holycross stated that he wanted to allow NPC members an opportunity to comment on the pians before he attended the next meeting on the following day. He explained that he thought the plan was appropriate because it did not affect the historic facade of the structure on the north, west and south sides; the east side consists of 1950s additions that also would only be affected in a minor way. The interior of the structure would be changed dramatically. Discussion ensued as to the specifics of the plan. Mrs. Sporleder asked if a motion was necessary. Mr. Holycross replied that he was merely allowing the opportunity for comment; he thought the plan as submitted was probably as good as could be expected; with present requirements placed on the school board, it was unrealistic to expect that the building could be saved and utilized while retaining historic features of the interior. He further explained that school employees saw this plan as inadequate for their needs; it seemed that most would prefer a new building; the architects told the committee that the building was well-built and worth saving but would require compromise on the part of all in order to accomplish that. He also stated that Mr. Ron Farrand repeatedly spoke about the "sixty percent formula" wherein the school Corporation would be "forced" to consider a new building if renovation plans exceeded sixty percent of the cost of new construction. Mr. Oxian stated that they could not build a new structure on this space; Mr. Holycross answered that they would then abandon the building for another site. Ms. Hostetler asked if the landmark designation had been approved; Mr. Holycross answered that the measure had been tabled at the Common Council. Ms. Hostetler stated that there were many local families that depended on the school. Mr. Oxian answered that there were many teachers "who wanted the Taj Mahal." He then described the problems at Clay Middle School, including leaks. Ms, Hostetler replied that everything possible should be done to keep schools such as this in the neighborhoods; this area contained three historic districts and was heavily populated by young families with children who needed the schools adjacent to their homes. Mrs. Choitz stated that Cathy Thompson, a teacher at the school, was very much in favor of saving the building, it was evident that not all of the teachers were in favor of losing this building. Mrs. Sporleder stated that the plan "looked good" as it presently stood; it "looked like a good way to ga." There was general agreement among HPC members. Mr. Oxian directed staff to take that message to the committee. 6. Standards and Maintenance