Laserfiche WebLink
JoNE PErMIERAFINSM „�ii✓�,yin��^1"i�{;ins iu��,,nl �i uin�� ,i�,Iiit� �,f�ai��mllp,lil,�lll::ui.^r,ujc�r.�1 <br />yOUr one Single Source l;: I_n^rug r>>irr.:ii9r�l � ,2,r,u� ,�,� �I<. � „`AfIv, . A 'ands ��� ; Aif,hlt o=r;ta.aie <br />December 12, 2018 <br />Division of Engineering <br />1316 County -City Building <br />227 West Jefferson Boulevard <br />South Bend, Indiana 46601 <br />Attn: Ms. Alicia Czarnecki, City of South Bend Project Engineer <br />RE: 118-072 — MCKINLEY AVE & FREMONT PARK IMPROVEMENTS — REVIEW OF QUOTES <br />Dear Alicia, <br />The City of South Bend received three (3) contractor bids from Rieth Riley, Walsh and Kelly, and HRP <br />Construction for the above referenced project. <br />Based on our Bid tabulation review, the total bids for each of the three contractors varies dependent upon the <br />work of each Division of the project. For the Division A work on McKinley Ave, the low bid came in from Rieth <br />Riley in the amount of $92,017. This bid was followed closely by Walsh and Kelly's bid in the amount of $92,700. <br />HRP Construction's bid came in the highest, at $138,132.50. <br />For the work in Division B, the Fremont Park Improvements, the quotes for work came in from Walsh and Kelly at <br />$102,200. The second low bid for Division B work was by Rieth Riley with the bid amount of $124,150.50. HRP <br />Construction's bid again came in highest at $131,729. For each of the three Alternates (61, B2 and 133) Walsh <br />and Kelly was also the low bidder. <br />We have reviewed the quote documents and have attached our summary for your consideration. <br />Based on our review of the submitted quotes the following are our comments: <br />1. Mobilization and Demobilization exceed the allowable 5% max. of the base bid per 2018 INDOT <br />Specification Section 110 requirements. This is true of all three Contractor bids received for both <br />Divisions A and B. <br />2. For further breakdown of the quote comparisons, please see the attached Summary Page and bid <br />tabulations for each of the Divisions and Alternates. Please review and let me know if you have any <br />questions or if you need any additional information. <br />0Si r�elyn <br />is ChockleP AICP <br />Landscape Architect <br />Certified Planner <br />HA2018 Projects\2018-0314\Bidding\2018-12-12_McKinley-Fremont Bid Review.docx <br />jpr1 source.com 200 Nibco Parkway 325 S Lafayette Blvd 108 W Columbia St, <br />Suite 200 South Bend IN 46601 Fort Wayne IN 46802 <br />Elkhail IN 46516 574.232.4388 260.422.2522 <br />574.293.7762 <br />