November 2007 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

567 Joann Sporleder: I move, what is the number for this, I move that C of A 2007-1107 568 for 710 Park Avenue be approved because the proposal... 569 Tim Klusczinski: You don't have to state a reason. 570 Joann Sporleder: I know, but I'd like to. Because it does no harm in any way to the 571 existing structure, it seems to be architecturally appropriate, and it 572 does the public no harm. 573 Linda Riley: Second. 574 Tim Klusczinski: Motion has been made and seconded. 575 Shawn Peterson: For the record, because the motion is to approve, if you vote 576 589 against it, you do not need to state a reason. If you vote to deny is 577 when you need to state your reasons. 578 Joann Sporleder: I understand that, Shawn, I just wanted to state why I was... 579 Tim Klusczinski: For her... 580 Shawn Peterson: So if you vote against this motion you don't have to state your 581 reasons why, but if you had entertained a motion to deny you 582 would have to. 583 Tim Klusczinski: Really? 584 Shawn Peterson: A motion to approve if it fails, does not end. You need a motion to 585 deny to pass. So as far as the rationale in the ordinance, as far as 586 stating your rationale, it's when you vote on a motion to deny, not 587 necessarily a negative motion on a motion to approve. 588 Joann Sporleder: But the same thing applies if you make a positive motion and the 589 motion is defeated. 590 Shawn Peterson: No, that doesn't apply. You have to have a motion to deny. 591 Joann Sporleder: No, that's not right Shawn. 592 Tim Klusczinski: I'll defer to counsel tonight. Motion has been made and seconded. 593 Any other discussion? So, to clarify Shawn, you're suggesting that 594 motions in favor or motions to deny don't require an explanation at _ - - -- 595 this point? 596 Shawn Peterson: A motion has been made to approve, if that motion should fail then 597 action has not been taken by the Commission. It's when a motion 17