May 1998 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING of the HIST_ORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Regular Monthly Meeting County Commissione'r's 7:30 p.m. Conference Room Monday April 20, 1998 7th Floor County -City Building . I'. Call to Order John Oxian, President -of the Commission, brought the.meeting to order.at 7:30 p.m. II. -Roll Call �.. Commission. members present were:,- Martha Choitz,.Adrian .Fine, John .Oxian,. Janeanne Petrass, Edward Talley, Jerry Weiner, Sc Joann Sporleder. Commission. staff• present were:. David Duvall, Director, Rhonda Saunders, Administrative Assistant and "Aladean DeRose, Counsel, arrived at 8:00pm. -Also attending the meeting were: Don Sporleder, Roberto'Junres', Ed Trevino, Anthony Harman," Robert & Sherry Montel, John 0•'Brien, Karen McGrew and Tom Selsor. III: Public Hearing Mr. Oxian stated'that 60500 Bremen Highway will be removed from Standards and 'Maintenance section oU the agenda and place under Public Hearing: Mrs. Choitz moved to place 60500 Bremen Highway under, Public Hearing section of the agenda. Mr. -Talley seconded -the motion. -The motion passed unanimously. A. Certificates of Appropriateness 1) 1998-0330-2pt_. B.- 621 Lincolnway East-'Rear'privacy fence Mr. Duvall 'presented the staff report and circulated photographs. He also noted that this particular property was before the Commission -last month for a garage demolition request and that part "A"..of this application pertained to the,, staff, approved,- rehabilitation of the garage.- Mr. Weiner moved to approve the application as submitted. Mrs. Petrass seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 2. 1998-0331 - 1029 Hudson - Replacement of three attic windows Mr.,. Duvall presented the staff report and circulated photographs. 1• He .also noted that theeowner,-Mr. O'Brien was,present:,.Mr.'Oxian'asked,if Mr. O'Brien had any comments -to make. " Mr. O'Brien' asked if the staff recommendation was proposing that the replacement of.the front and rear windows be approved, but, that the 'replacement of the side- window be denied. 'Mr. Duvall responded ' affirmatively. Mr. O'Brien noted that he and his wife have tried very hard in the past to'work with the Commission "in restoring the house and ,that when they started on this project they contacted a -carpenter out 'of Elkhart to "evaluate the condition of the windows. The carpenter, upon examining the -windows, stated that they could not be restored. Then Mr.. O'Brien went on to note that he,disagreed with statement "that was made in the staff report which declared that the side window was clearly visible from the street and asked to�be-given permission to replace all three windows. .-Mr. Oxian.-noted that Mr.. O'Brien" has not yet, given any indication as to what type of window will replace the side window,- if its replacement is t approved .- Mr. O'Brien stated that Anderson windows come with muntin inserts and what ever muntin-patternis available through that company they would be more:than happy, to use. Mr. Oxian asked if -the owners planned to replicate the - nine.light, pattern .'in the front and rear attic windows and the twelve pattern in the side attic window., Mr." O'Brien "stated that if .the twelve "