03-09-2020 Agenda Packet - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:Staff recommends approval of the project as submitted,with the expressed concern that the stone window sill should not be adversely impacted by the addition of the metal roof material. Prepared by Adam Toering Historic Preservation Specialist Recommendation by Elicia Feasel Historic Preservation Administrator PETITIONER COMMENTS: Mr.Bowers explained that the window sill in the back is already blocked by the existing roof line,and that in the front the new roof may impact the sills at the seam locations.. He then supplied additional pictures regarding the proposed installation of the roof material. He further explained previous examples that he had installed that were similar to this project. Ms.McKelvey stated that she wanted to bring it back to a historic condition,and that she didn't paint it. PUBLIC DISCUSSION: Ms.Downs-Krostenko stated that standing-seam metal roofs were not installed in this area north of the Ohio River valley. Does the Commission have any discussion or concerns of color as to metal roofs? She expressed concern that color should be looked into by the Commission going forward. Mr.Bowers responded that he had seen tins roofs installed. COMMISSIONER DISCUSSION: Commissioner Stalheim stated that fortunately they want a dark colored roof. Commissioner Hertel stated that there is concern about color going forward. Commissioner Hertel also expressed concern regarding the front windows. Commissioner Stalheim asked how the flashing is installed into and beneath the windows. Mr.Bowers expressed that they would not adversely impact the windows. Commissioner Hertel expressed that the Commission wants the homeowner to have a long-term roof solution,so is protective on behalf of the applicant. Commissioner Hertel expressed concern regarding moisture infiltration into the existing shingles that could cause other problems. Mr.Bowers explained the various layers that are installed beneath the roof material to both protect the roof material,as well as to create moisture barrier,where it runs the moisture out. Mr.Bowers further discussed historic barn structures that have metal roofs that have lasted one hundred years. Commissioner Stalheim confirmed that laying metal roof over existing shingles is common. Mr.Bowers expressed that these advances have helped measurably. Commissioner Stalheim asked about the widths of the panels themselves. Mr.Bowers explained that the residential width is 16". Commercial widths are 18". Commissioner Ponder asked about the gutters and soffits. Mr.Bowers explained that no change would be made to the gutters or soffits. Commissioner Stalheim mentioned the removal of the stovepipe. Mr.McKelvey joked that he would not be cutting wood. Commissioner Ponder made a motion to approve COA#2019-1011A. Seconded by Commissioner Brazinsky. Four in favor,none opposed. Vote: 4—0. Motion to continue COA#2019-1011A is passed. Commissioner Hertel explained that she hoped that the property owners feel comfortable contacting the Staff if they have any questions regarding their historic property. Administrator Feasel stated that Staff may have information about efficient ways of removing paint from the exterior brick. Commissioner Hertel explained that when the homeowners are ready for that,Staff is ready and willing to help. IV. PRIVILIGE OF THE FLOOR V. REGULAR BUSINESS