03-29-16 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

REGULAR MEETING MARCH 29. 2016 and reduce the number of people who start smoking. The research is clear and the time is now to protect all workers. Karl Nichols, 1530 College St., spoke about the assistance Smoke Free St. Joe would offer any business affected by the ordinance. He focused on the implementation benefits that Smoke Free St. Joe was willing to provide to the affected businesses during the implementation period. They would help in three main ways including community education, event promotion, and marketing workshops. This would include sending implementation tool kits to all affected businesses. They would set up a smoke free hotline which would answer questions about the new law, provide information about compliance and other resources. They would help with daily and weekly advertisements about the new law prior to enforcement dates. They would coordinate with the Common Council to identify early implementers who would be interested in promotion from Smoke Free St. Joe and have the Smoke Free St. Joe monthly meetings at some of the early adopters' bars. Promote events and bars on the Smoke Free St. Joe social media sites and interview and profile one business per month. They would hold at least four (4) two (2) hour marketing workshops for the affected businesses regarding marketing via social media, branding and promoting the venue, event planning, and expanding the customer base. Smoke Free St. Joe wants this potential transition to be positive for anyone involved. Jonathan Anderstorm, 526 W Western Ave., stated there are parts of this ordinance that he has questions about such as the inclusion of volunteers as employees as well as the enforcement on non - profits should a complaint be filed. He does however support the ordinance for three (3) reasons. First, as the Executive Director of the Monroe Circle Community Center in South Bend he has a daily reminder of the adverse effects of smoking on this community. Many people have limited options when it comes to employment and many feel their only choice is to work in any place they can find even if it is a smoking establishment. He also sees the results of children who experience the adverse effects of secondhand smoking. This ordinance would prohibit smoking in public housing areas. Secondly, many of the negative affects of secondhand smoke on our city are preventable and our City is in dire need of health protection. Third, people are God's treasure and every person here has eternal value and worth, this ordinance will help extend people's time on earth as long as possible. Yes some may not agree with me but it is hard to keep doing funerals for people dying for heart disease or for a child born six (6) months premature because his mother was a smoker. Yes this may cause some people some personal trouble it has great potential to extend the greatest gift God has given us which is human life. Council Vice President Davis announced the opposition will have forty (40) minutes to speak. Council President Tim Scott made a motion to recess for five (5) minutes. Councilmember Karen White seconded the motion which carried by a voice vote of nine (9) ayes. The Committee of the Whole recessed at 8:41 p.m. The Committee of the Whole reconvened with Council Vice President presided with nine (9) members present at 8:46 p.m. Those wishing to speak in opposition to Bill 11 -16: Frank Julian, 1620 South Bend Ave, stated those speaking in favor of this bill have already won this issue. It is not hard in this county to find a place of business or restaurant that is smoke free. He stated he had to sit down and think of any bars or restaurants that still allow smoking when he was first approached about this. This is no longer the public health issue these statistics make it out to be and the data presented today proves that with widely different claims of how many people would die from secondhand smoke in our area. That data Councilmember Ferlic has used have been debunked as not being of sound basis and that was stated in the Journal of the American Medical Association. This is going to drive people from these bars to the bars in St. Joseph County and Mishawaka. This is going to drive people to the casino and it is funny that the Mayor wants to talk about public safety but takes $2 million dollars from the casino. The studies that showed no economic impact were mostly done in southern states where it is easy to have an outside facility where people can smoke. South Bend is not like that where most of the year patrons cannot comfortably be outside on a patio. The economic studies also look at tax data and those studies do show it all equals out because T.G.1 Friday or Applebees will take in more 10