HomeMy WebLinkAboutCity Administration’s Response to the South Bend Reparatory Justice Commission’s Final Report (2026) FILED
CITY OF SOUTH BEND
MAYOR JAMES MUELLER
OFFICE OF THE MAYOR
SOUTH BEND CITY HALL ∙ 215 S. DR. MARTIN LUTHER KING, JR. BOULEVARD ∙ SOUTH BEND, INDIANA 46601
PHONE 574/235-9261 ∙ FAX 574/235-9892 ∙ TTY 574/235-5567
November 5, 2026
Members of the South Bend Common Council
Members of the South Bend Reparatory Justice Commission
Re: City Administration’s Response to the South Bend Reparatory Justice Commission’s
Final Report (2026)
Dear President Lee, Members of the Common Council, Chairs Robinson and Heller, and
Members of the Reparatory Justice Commission:
I write to provide the City’s initial formal point-by-point response to each of the sixty-two
recommendations in the Final Report of the South Bend Reparatory Justice Commission,
which the Common Council formally accepted on June 8, 2026.
Eighteen months of research, public testimony, and community participation produced a
report that takes seriously what too many official records have not. I have read the report. I
acknowledge what it documents: a history of racial discrimination in South Bend, in
housing, in employment, in education, in health, in the basic fairness of services, real and
sustained for more than a century. I am sorry for it.
I want to thank Chairs Trina Robinson and Darryl Heller and every member of the
Commission and its subcommittees, as well as the residents whose testimony gave this
report its authority. I also want to thank Council leadership, including former President
McBride, who empaneled this Commission on September 28, 2023, and President Lee, who
carried it through to acceptance. The work belongs to the Commission. The acceptance
belongs to the Council. The responsibility now is shared.
My apology this summer was not an ending point. The Commission’s report does not ask
the City to grieve our history. It asks the City to acknowledge our history and act on it. The
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
2
Council and I took the first formal step by adopting a resolution on June 22, 2026, as
described in the response to Recommendation 1 below. This letter includes the
Administration’s current accounting of all sixty-two recommendations.
This letter is organized to follow the structure of the Commission’s report. For each
recommendation, the Administration first sets out the Commission’s recommendation
verbatim, quoted in full as it appears in the Final Report, so that this letter may serve as a
complete and self-contained record of the recommendations and the City’s response to each.
Following each quoted recommendation, the Administration describes existing City
programming that responds to it where such programming exists and states the
Administration’s position and next steps where new action, further study, or referral to
another unit of government is necessary.
Where existing programming is described, these are not new commitments made in
response to the report. They are existing commitments that the report helps us to see more
clearly and pursue more seriously. Where a recommendation is directed to an entity outside
municipal authority, including the South Bend Community School Corporation (SBCSC),
the St. Joseph County Department of Health, the St. Joseph County Public Library, non-
profit partners, and private employers, the Administration has formally transmitted the
recommendation to that entity, with an offer of the City’s cooperation and support and a
request for a written response.
Each response carries one of the following status designations: Complete; Partially
complete; In place (the recommendation is already being met by a City program that
predates the report and continues); In progress (new or expanded City action now
underway); Under review; Council-led, City supporting; Partner-led, City supporting
(directed to another entity, with the City contributing funding, facilities, staff, or
coordination); and Partner-led, transmitted (directed to another entity, to which the City
has formally transmitted the recommendation).
One standard runs through every response that follows. The report documents harm
inflicted along racial lines, and the remedies will be measured by whether they actually close
the gaps the report identifies: narrowed inequities, expanded opportunity, repaired
neighborhoods. The Administration’s job is to deliver remedies that reach the people and
neighborhoods the report names, designed in ways that hold up under the Constitution and
federal and state law. What matters is whether the gaps close. That is the standard this
Administration expects to be held to, and the standard against which the responses below
should be read.
Several recommendations ask the City to direct public funds, contracts, loans, or programs
to residents or businesses on the basis of race. The Administration states the governing law
once here rather than repeating it throughout this letter. Under the Equal Protection Clause
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
3
of the Fourteenth Amendment, any government program that classifies people by race is
subject to strict scrutiny, a standard the U.S. Supreme Court reaffirmed in Students for Fair
Admissions v. President and Fellows of Harvard College (2023). For public contracting, City of
Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co. (1989) permits race-conscious measures only where current
evidence, of the kind a disparity study provides, establishes a strong basis for them and the
remedy is narrowly tailored; that is why the City is conducting a new disparity study now.
For lending, the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act prohibits creditors from considering
race. Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 applies to every program the City operates with
federal funds. Where these laws prevent the City from doing exactly what a
recommendation asks, the response says so briefly and identifies a lawful path to the same
result: race-neutral programs aimed at the neighborhoods and residents the report identifies,
and the non-governmental Community Fund described in Recommendation 4, which can
complement public dollars.
The Commission’s report establishes a factual record that this city cannot and should not
wish to set aside. The existing programs described in this letter are commitments the report
helps us see more clearly and pursue more seriously. Where the report demands more, this
letter records what more the City will do. The Administration does not regard this letter as
the conclusion of the City’s response but as its baseline. The Administration will report
annually to the Common Council and to the reparatory justice committee on the
implementation status of each of the sixty-two recommendations addressed below,
beginning no later than November 5, 2027, and will treat that reporting as a standing
obligation of this office. The remedies will be measured by whether the gaps close.
The Commission did its work. The Council accepted it. The Administration’s job now is
delivery. That work has begun, and it continues every day. I again thank the Commissioners
for their extraordinary service and thank the residents of South Bend whose testimony gave
this report its authority.
Respectfully submitted,
James Mueller
Mayor, City of South Bend
cc: Office of the City Clerk; Department of Community Investment; Department of Public
Works; Legal Department; South Bend Human Rights Commission
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
C I T Y O F S O U T H B E N D | O F F I C E O F T H E M AY O R
Summar y: Resp onse to the
Reparator y Justice Commission
A summary of the key points made in the Administration’s response. The full
response covers all 62 recommendations, including topics not shown here.
Status of all 62 recommendations
K E Y D AT E S
June 8, 2026 June 9, 2026 June 22, 2026
November 5,
2026
By November 5,
2027
Council’s
acceptance of the
report
Mayor’s apology Joint resolutions This response First annual report
Of the 38 recommendations within City authority, 32 are in place or underway and 6 are under review.
The other 24 rest with the Common Council or outside partners; all have been formally transmitted,
and the City is supporting 15 of them.
W I T H I N C I T Y
A U T H O R I T Y
In place
In progress
Under review
C O U N C I L O R
P A R T N E R S
City supporting
Transmitted to
partners
“In place” includes the
completed apology
(Recommendation 1) and
2 partially completed
items (Recommendations
8 and 22).
B Y R E C O M M E N D AT I O N N U M B E R
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39
40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52
53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62
B Y R E P O R T A R E A
Commission-wide 4
Economic opportunity 13
Housing and neighborhoods 17
Education 13
Health and mental health 10
Environment 5
C I T Y O F S O U T H B E N D | O F F I C E O F T H E M AYO R N OV E M B E R 5 , 2 0 2 6 · PAG E 1
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
Results and Commitments
Where the law sets limits, as federal law does for race-based public contracts, grants, and lending, the
response names a lawful path, such as neighborhood-targeted programs, a new disparity study, and the non-
governmental Community Fund.
R E S U LT S C O M M I T M E N T S
L A S A L L E PA R K
4,600+ tons of lead-impacted soil removed under EPA
oversight in 2022
150 units HUD-subsidized units, broke ground on a
$40 million-plus rehabilitation
The City will help the
neighborhood secure partners
and funding for a health study
and expand blood lead testing for
children.
H O U S I N G
$300 million invested into 1,398 income-qualified
units that were built or renovated
$10 million
in HUD financing is supporting a $63.4
million, 210-home mixed-income project
on Western Avenue
The Home Repair Program
increases 16.7% in the 2027
proposed budget, to $350,000.
B L A C K -O W N E D B U S I N E S S A N D W E A LT H
86%of businesses certified through City
programs are Black-owned
$26 million City spending with diverse businesses,
more than doubled since 2023
The City has helped create two
minority-managed community
development financial institutions
(CDFIs) and is working to
establish a third.
N E I G H B O R H O O D S A N D H E A LT H
$32.4 million in TIF for neighborhood projects, doubled
in 2026
~$60 million invested west side parks and community
centers
A $7 million HUD grant extends
Lead Safe South Bend four years.
What comes next
Annual accountability. A written report on all 62 to the Council and the reparatory justice committee
every year with infrastructure spending reported by neighborhood and lead remediation by ZIP code.
Rec. 3, 33, 58
New fund, partnerships, and policy work. The Mayor will explore the feasibility of a non-governmental
fund with philanthropic, business, and faith leaders. The Administration will also explore a maternal-
care funding partnership, complete the ongoing procurement disparity study, and work with the
Council to evaluate neighborhood-based hiring incentives and stronger repayment provisions for City-
supported development. Rec. 4, 11, 12, 48
Scan this to read the
full response
C I T Y O F S O U T H B E N D | O F F I C E O F T H E M AYO R N OV E M B E R 5 , 2 0 2 6 · PAG E 2
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
1
City Response to the South Bend
Reparatory Justice Commission’s Final
Report
November 5, 2026
Summary
The City of South Bend has answered all 62 recommendations of the Reparatory Justice
Commission, point by point, and expects to be measured by whether the gaps the report
documents close. Of the 38 recommendations within City authority, 32 are in place or
underway and 6 are under review. The other 24 rest with the Common Council or outside
partners; all have been formally transmitted, and the City is supporting 15 of them.
It follows the Council’s June 8 acceptance of the report, the Mayor’s June 9 apology, and
the joint resolutions of June 22, and sets the baseline for annual reporting.
Status Count Recommendations
In place 22 1, 5, 8, 9, 11 to 16, 18 to 24, 26, 27, 29,
30, 34
In progress 10 2, 6, 25, 28, 32, 33, 46, 51, 58, 62
Under review 6 10, 17, 31, 59, 60, 61
Total within City administration
authority
38
City supporting Council or partners 15 3, 4, 7, 37, 38, 40, 45, 48 to 50, 52 to 55,
57
Transmitted to partners 9 35, 36, 39, 41 to 44, 47, 56
Total Council or outside partners 24
“In place” includes the completed apology (Recommendation 1) and 2 partially completed
items (Recommendations 8 and 22.)
Where the law sets limits, as federal law does for race-based public contracts, grants, and
lending, the response names a lawful path, such as neighborhood-targeted programs, a new
disparity study, and the non-governmental Community Fund.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
2
Highlights
LaSalle Park:
• Under EPA oversight in 2022, more than 4,600 tons of lead-impacted soil were
removed and 3.2 acres of the park were capped with clean soil.
• More than 1,000 samples were tested for more than 150 contaminants, including
270+ from homes bordering the park. A risk assessment under EPA oversight found
no current exposure risks.
• A 2026 restrictive covenant bars agricultural use of the park and restricts
groundwater use. EPA’s review of groundwater and residential soil continues.
• LaSalle Park Homes, 150 HUD-subsidized units, broke ground on a $40 million-plus
rehabilitation on July 8, 2026. New housing projects under discussion.
• The City will help the neighborhood secure partners and funding for a health study
and expand blood lead testing for children. The County already offers free lead
assessments and blood tests.
Housing:
• 1,398 income-qualified units built or renovated, with almost $300 million invested;
232 at or below 30% of area median income.
• Eleven City-supported projects have won Low Income Housing Tax Credit awards
from the state since 2023 to renovate older units and build new income-restricted
ones.
• 288 new single-family homes in two years, the most in twenty years, nearly all on
infill lots.
• On the west side, $10 million in HUD financing is supporting a $63.4 million, 210-
home mixed-income project on Western Avenue.
• 1,071 rental safety inspections in 2026. A public lookup of inspection records arrives
with new software in 2027.
• The Home Repair Program increases 16.7% in the 2027 proposed budget, to
$350,000.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
3
Black -owned business and wealth.
• 86% of businesses certified through City programs and 83.5% of business assistance-
suite participants reporting race, are Black-owned.
• City spending with diverse businesses has more than doubled since 2023, to $26
million, and 44 of 78 City revolving loans (56.4%) have gone to minority-owned
businesses.
• Black-owned businesses bidding on City contracts are up 47% since 2023, and more
than 600 potential women- and minority-owned businesses have received training
and start-up support.
• In its first year, 58% of the South Bend Opportunity Fund’s coaching and capital-
access clients were Black (27 of 46).
• The Financial Empowerment Center has served 258 clients, 71% of them minorities.
Minority clients have saved $63,166 and cut non-mortgage debt by $404,930.
• The City has helped create two minority-managed community development financial
institutions (CDFIs) and is working to establish a third.
Neighborhoods and health.
• Almost $60 million in west side parks and community centers; TIF for neighborhood
projects doubled to $32.4 million in 2026.
• Major investments include the new Martin Luther King Jr. Dream Center, the fully
renovated Charles Black Center, Pulaski Park upgrades, and Coal Line Trail Phase
III, which will connect the Dream Center to Notre Dame. Kennedy Park’s $15
million revitalization is supported by a $7.5 million National Park Service grant.
• A $7 million HUD grant extends Lead Safe South Bend four years: 20 homes
repaired in 2026, 29 more enrolled.
• A full-service grocery opened at Western and Olive in November 2025, after the
Western Avenue Kroger closed.
• In 2025, about $10 million went to resurfacing and reconstruction on more than 90
streets (48 lane-miles), with 50+ more in 2026. Street and sidewalk investment will
be reported by neighborhood.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
4
• Over $6 million in American Rescue Plan funds invested to homelessness and mental
health partnerships. The Oaklawn Crisis Center, a walk-in alternative for people in
crisis, served 120 people in its first year.
What comes next
• Annual accountability—A written report on all 62 to the Council and the reparatory
justice committee every year with infrastructure spending reported by neighborhood
and lead remediation by ZIP code.
• A Community Fund and other next steps—The Mayor will explore the feasibility of
a non-governmental fund with philanthropic, business, and faith leaders.
• Other next steps—The Administration will also explore a maternal-care funding
partnership, complete the ongoing procurement disparity study, and work with the
Council to evaluate neighborhood-based hiring incentives and stronger repayment
provisions for City-supported development.
Current Status of All Recommendations
I. Commission-Wide Recommendations
Recommendation 1 (For immediate implementation). “The City should formally acknowledge
and apologize for a long history of racial discrimination.”
City Response: (Status: Complete) On June 9, 2026, the day after the Council’s acceptance
of the report, Mayor James Mueller publicly acknowledged what the report documents and
apologized for it on behalf of the City.
On June 22, 2026, the Common Council adopted, and the Mayor signed, formal resolutions
completing that acknowledgment and apology. Those resolutions: (1) accept the historical
findings of the Reparatory Justice Commission as part of the City’s official record, and
establish the report and its sixty-two recommendations as a framework for future policy
discussions and community efforts; (2) formally acknowledge the history of racial
discrimination, housing segregation, environmental harm, and unequal treatment by local
government documented in the report, and the lasting harm these injustices have caused to
residents and the broader community; (3) formally apologize to the residents of South Bend
and, in particular, to the past and present residents and families of the historically harmed
neighborhood, for the harms caused by policies, practices, and decisions that contributed to
racial inequities, environmental injustice, and community disinvestment; and (4) reaffirm
the City’s commitment to advancing equity, environmental justice, community health, and
meaningful engagement with residents of historically harmed neighborhoods.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
5
The Administration regards the apology not as an ending point but as the foundation for the
actions described throughout this letter.
Recommendation 2 (For immediate implementation). “The City should preserve this report as
a permanent, easily accessible historical public record and commit to creating a robust website where
citizens can learn about this history.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The Administration concurs. The Council’s
resolutions of June 22, 2026, placed the Commission’s findings and its sixty-two
recommendations into the City’s official record. The Administration has asked the Office of
the City Clerk to maintain the Final Report as a permanent public record, and has offered
the Commission City staff and technology to build and maintain a dedicated, publicly
accessible webpage hosting the full report, its appendices, and educational material drawn
from the Commission’s historical research. This recommendation will be complete when
that webpage is live, and the Administration will report its status in the first annual
implementation report.
Recommendation 3 (Within three months). “The Common Council should appoint a permanent
reparatory justice committee that includes experts, City officials, and citizens, the majority of whom
should be Black. Current Commission members should be given priority if they want to continue to
serve. The Committee should be charged with reviewing progress in implementing the recommendation
of the Commission, monitoring compliance with reparatory justice, and identifying further measures
that might come to light to ensure reparatory justice. The committee shall report to the Common
Council the progress toward implementing the Commission’s recommendations and suggestions for the
adoption of any additional measures needed for reparatory justice at least annually.”
City Response: (Status: Council-led, City supporting) Appointment authority for this
committee rests with the Common Council, and if requested, the Administration will lend
the support and staff needed to the Council. The Administration also commits to submitting
no less than an annual written implementation status report to the committee and the
Council, as requested in Council Resolution 5175-26 adopted by the Council on June 22,
2026, and signed by the Mayor. The first annual report will be submitted no later than
November 5, 2027. This response letter is intended to serve as the baseline document
against which annual reporting can be measured.
Recommendation 4 (Within the next three years). “A community Fund should be established
through a non-governmental entity as a repository for donations from charitable foundations, local and
national businesses, individuals, and similar sources to provide monies for repairing past and
preventing future harms as identified in this report.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports
exploring an independently governed, non-governmental Community Fund to help address
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
6
the harms identified in the report. Private philanthropy can complement public investment,
with any proposed programs subject to review under applicable law. The Fund could be a
potential avenue for advancing Recommendations 13, 17, 52, and 57. The Community
Foundation of St. Joseph County, with its African American Community Fund established
in 1999, is a natural potential partner.
The Mayor will explore the Fund’s feasibility with the Community Foundation and
philanthropic, business, and faith leaders, and will help connect potential partners and
donors where useful and appropriate. Decisions on establishing the Fund, its host,
governance, fundraising, and grantmaking will rest with its non-governmental partners.
II. Employment, Economic Opportunity, and the Wealth Gap
Recommendation 5 (Within six months). “Adult Financial Counseling: To assist South Bend
families in building net worth and generational wealth, the City, through its Financial Empowerment
Center and in partnership with area banks, financial institutions and others organizations, should
provide financial counseling and education to low- and moderate-income households in South Bend.
The Commission encourages the City to endow and expand the work it has already begun at the
Financial Empowerment Center by partnering with other neighborhood organizations.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Financial Empowerment Center (FEC) is open and
free to all South Bend residents over the age of eighteen. Counseling sessions are available
in person at the MLK Dream Center, virtually, or by phone. The FEC coordinates with the
City’s Engagement and Economic Empowerment (EEE) team through the quarterly
neighborhood consortium, shares information in bimonthly neighborhood newsletters, and
canvasses during the Linden Avenue Farmers Market season. The FEC maintains a wide
partner network for inbound and outbound client referrals.
To date, the FEC has served 258 clients, of whom 71.31% are minorities and 74.03% are
women, with an average age of 43 and an average household income of approximately
$44,000. FEC clients who identify as minorities have achieved collective savings of $63,166
and a reduction in non-mortgage debt of $404,930. The Administration commits to
sustaining the FEC and to expanding its impact and its neighborhood-organization
partnerships.
Recommendation 6 (Within a year). “Youth Wealth Building Educational Tool: To empower
South Bend’s Black youth to save money and grow wealth, the City through its Financial
Empowerment Center, and with partners including the South Bend Community School Corporation
(SBCSC), IUSB, Ivy Tech, and others, should create or acquire a Financial Basics video program for
use in schools, after school programs within schools, or off site (e.g., Boys & Girls Club), Neighborhood
Centers, public libraries, etc. Topics should include home purchasing and financing, credit use and
risks, the value of a high credit score and how to achieve it, budgeting, the home mortgage process,
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
7
retirement planning, and basic income tax rules. The program should be actively promoted and directed
toward middle school/early high school students. The program should be presented through live
participation of Black leaders in business or finance who can personally inspire and encourage the
youth participants.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) This initiative will succeed most fully if led by the
School Corporation. The City has, however, recently partnered with Pro Resources and 1st
Source Bank to address youth financial literacy. Pro Resources has hired a Youth
Engagement Specialist who will offer financial literacy classes to SBCSC high school
students, with the goals of connecting students with a local bank and teaching them to
manage their future financial health. This program is scheduled to begin in the 2027–2028
school year.
The City’s Summer Jobs Program, launched in 2021 for youth employed at the Charles
Black Center and the Martin Luther King Jr. Dream Center, remains active. Beginning in
2023, a grant-funded Summer Savings Program within it encouraged financially sound
habits and matched the savings of participants who completed all program benchmarks; that
grant-funded component is no longer active. The Administration will evaluate whether a
savings component can be restored with sustainable funding, and will work with community
partners, including the schools, institutions of higher learning, and youth programs, to
expand the scope and reach of youth wealth and financial education.
Recommendation 7 (Within a year). “To better acquaint Black youth with opportunities for
higher paid jobs within the industrial and other skilled trades, the SBCSC should hold a career day
program or job fair annually in all its middle and high schools where industrial and other professional
trade groups participate. It should also furnish students with written information in advance about
skilled trade opportunities as provided by local unions and employers.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) Over the past three years the School
Corporation, in partnership with the University of Notre Dame and the local building trades
unions, has held an annual BLDG DAY. The trade fair connects all city high schoolers with
over 80 local contractors and unions, featuring hands-on activities such as wiring circuits,
welding, and active construction site tours.
This recommendation is directed to the South Bend Community School Corporation, an
independent unit of government separate from the City. The Administration has formally
transmitted this recommendation to the SBCSC Board of Trustees and Superintendent and
has offered the City’s assistance in convening the building trades, local unions, and major
employers to participate in such programming.
Recommendation 8 (Within three months). “The City of South Bend, its agencies, contractors,
and partners, and large employers within the City should eliminate the box or question about past
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
8
criminal convictions on their initial job application forms unless the posted job clearly falls within the
scope of a state law. In these cases, the question should be limited to specific convictions that actually
relate to the job opening.”
City Response: (Status: Partially complete) The City does not inquire about criminal
convictions on initial job application forms except for positions for which state law
mandates such screening (police department, fire department, and programs involving work
with children). The Administration will research the extent to which fair-chance hiring
expectations can lawfully be incorporated into City contracting and partnership standards
and agreements, and will encourage large private employers to adopt the same practice.
Recommendation 9 (Within six months). “Credit checks as a pre-requisite for initial employment
consideration unfairly disqualify Black persons in South Bend whose financial conditions are generally
not the product of any personal fault, but rather the result of a conflux of social conditions affecting
employment and wealth building. Therefore, credit checks for initial employment screening should be
eliminated.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The City does not use credit checks in initial employment
screening except where required for positions that involve handling money or finances with
a specific fiduciary responsibility, or where required by state law, insurance providers, or
state auditors.
Recommendation 10 (Within a year). “On-the-job Management Training and Education: The
City should commit to fund and staff a new program designed to provide on-the-job (or while employed)
training and education for Black employees (both in public and private sector) to enhance or accelerate
their ability to qualify for promotion to management and C-suite positions. This should include:
a. Gathering information from employers re what is missing among Black candidates for
promotion
b. Sourcing materials and teachers
c. Sourcing facilities (which may be virtual)
d. Sourcing resources (e.g. tablet computers)
e. Culturally-competent marketing to recruit eligible employees
An example of such a program could be a Mini-MBA program in connection with IU South Bend,
culminating in an Executive Education Certificate.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The Administration supports the objective of this
recommendation and will evaluate program design and funding options, including a
partnership with IU South Bend on an executive education model. A City-funded program
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
9
cannot limit eligibility by race, but it can be open to City employees and designed around
the barriers to advancement the Commission describes. A component directed specifically
to Black professionals could be supported through the Community Fund described in
Recommendation 4.
The Commission introduces Recommendations 11 through 17 as follows: “The City should
expand efforts to support Black-owned businesses as a means to remedy historical exclusion
and discrimination, including:”
Recommendation 11 (For immediate implementation). “Increase preferential contracting and
purchasing from local Black-owned businesses, including everyday materials and services purchases
such as office supplies, cleaning supplies, and food and beverage services.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The City operates a minority- and women-owned
business enterprise (MWBE) procurement program designed within the legal framework
described in the introduction. It has increased vendor outreach, procurement notification,
and supplier-development efforts directed to Black-owned and minority-owned businesses,
so that these firms are aware of, and positioned to compete for, the City’s routine
purchasing.
The City’s Office of Diversity & Inclusion (ODI) administers the City’s supplier diversity
initiatives. Those efforts include MBE/WBE participation goals on applicable contracting
opportunities, outreach to diverse suppliers, procurement education, certification assistance,
and direct connections among businesses, City departments, and prime contractors.
The program has produced real results, with more minority- and Black-owned businesses in
the City’s bidding pool and winning bids and contracts. ODI certification training has
brought 107 new businesses into the pool, with 15 achieving full state certification,
expanding the vendor base by 12%. Since 2023, the City has more than doubled its diverse
procurement spending, to $26M last year. The number of Black-owned businesses
participating in City bids has increased 47% over the same period. Of the businesses that
achieved MBE/WBE or other recognized certification through City-supported
programming, approximately 86% were Black-owned.
Preferential purchasing from Black-owned businesses, as the Commission recommends, is a
race-conscious measure that requires current disparity evidence and careful program design.
The City is conducting a new disparity study now, as required by law. That study will
supply the data needed to determine what additional measures are legally supportable, and
the City will continue to operate its procurement programs within the law in the meantime.
See also Recommendation 15.
Recommendation 12 (Within six months). “Expand Contract Compliance and Enforcement.
The City should expand and strengthen its enforcement of existing requirements that companies who
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
10
receive City funds either through TIF grants or Tax Abatements utilize minority contractors and create
minority jobs.
This might involve a re-deployment of the efforts of the Contract Compliance Manager to research more
closely and report to the public the extent to which each beneficiary of City dollars is actually creating
new jobs for minorities and/or using minority-owned subcontractors.
The City should enlarge both the carrot and the stick in these programs so that participants are
motivated to succeed (i.e. create more jobs or more business opportunity for Black-owned businesses)
and punished if they do not (e.g. forced to repay public funds).”
City Response: (Status: In place) Contract compliance is part of the Office of Diversity &
Inclusion’s supplier diversity work. ODI monitors compliance with applicable MBE/WBE
participation requirements and tracks subcontracting expenditures with certified minority-
and women-owned businesses. Participation and utilization information is reported publicly
through the City’s Inclusive Procurement and Contracting Board. ODI works with prime
contractors throughout the contracting process to monitor participation commitments and
to review the documentation submitted in support of good-faith efforts when established
participation goals are not achieved. These activities are intended both to strengthen
accountability and to identify the barriers that prevent qualified businesses from
participating in City-funded projects. ODI is continuing to evaluate stronger compliance
mechanisms for cases in which contractors fail to meet established requirements or fail to
adequately demonstrate the required good-faith efforts.
As to the portion of the recommendation addressed to TIF grants and tax abatements: the
City’s tax abatement ordinance requires recipients to report certain information annually,
including the local companies and minority contractors used during the renovation of real
property or installation of new personal property for which the abatement was received, and
the number of minority persons hired following completion of the project. Under the legal
framework described in the introduction, however, the City cannot offer incentives or
impose penalties based on race, so the Administration cannot adopt the race-based incentive
and penalty structure the Commission proposes. The Administration will work with the
Common Council to evaluate lawful, race-neutral measures that reach the same
communities, such as incentives tied to hiring residents of the neighborhoods identified in
the Commission’s report, along with stronger repayment provisions for recipients that fail to
meet their job-creation and investment commitments. Changes to TIF agreements, tax
abatements, repayment provisions, and other financial incentives require broader City
review and Council authorization.
Recommendation 13 (Within one year). “Fund and publicize business start-up and expansion
grants targeted to Black entrepreneurs, either through the existing South Bend Opportunity Fund
program or a new, separate program;”
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
11
City Response: (Status: In place) Because public funds cannot be used for race-based
grants, the City’s tools are race-neutral by design, and they are reaching the entrepreneurs
the Commission seeks to serve. In its first year of operations, 58% of the business clients the
South Bend Opportunity Fund assisted with coaching and access to capital were Black (27
of 46 clients coached). Consistent with federal lending law, the Opportunity Fund’s lending
partner does not track race for its loans.
As discussed further in Recommendation 15, ODI operates a Small Business Assistance
Suite (SBAS), which addresses several of the financial and operational barriers that start-up
and early-stage businesses encounter by delivering professional and technical services at no
cost to the participating business, including legal services, bookkeeping and accounting
support, tax preparation, business formation assistance, business coaching, and other
capacity-building services. Among SBAS participants for whom race data is available,
83.5% identify as Black-owned businesses. Existing City-funded technical assistance is
therefore reaching a substantial population of Black entrepreneurs and removing the cost of
professional services that would otherwise fall on those businesses.
In 2026, the City’s Vibrant Places program paid 16 matching grants totaling $374,526 for
commercial exterior improvements. The 2027 proposed budget includes $325,000 to
continue supporting small, independently owned local businesses, many of which are on the
west side of the city.
The Administration will continue to fund and publicize the Opportunity Fund and SBAS,
will direct marketing and coaching outreach to the neighborhoods identified in the
Commission’s report, and supports continued exploration of strategies that expand access to
resources and capital for entrepreneurs who have historically faced barriers to business
formation and growth. A grant program directed specifically to Black entrepreneurs, of the
kind the Commission envisions, can lawfully be operated by the Community Fund
described in Recommendation 4.
Recommendation 14 (Within one year). “Guarantee small business loans to Black-owned
businesses, either through the Revolving Loan Fund or a new, separate program;”
City Response: (Status: In place) Because the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act bars
lenders from using race as a lending criterion, the City has directed its lending capacity to
underserved communities. In 2020 the City established Revolving Loan Fund II with a
grant from the U.S. Economic Development Administration, and the existing Industrial
Revolving Loan Fund was subsequently expanded and rebranded as the Revolving Business
Enterprise Fund. Since then, these loan funds have closed 78 loans, 44 of which (56.4%)
have gone to minority-owned businesses. In 2026 to date, the City has issued 17 business
loans totaling $4.15 million. The Administration will continue to concentrate this lending
capacity in underserved neighborhoods and will evaluate credit-enhancement structures,
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
12
such as loan guarantees administered through mission lenders and CDFIs, that lawfully
expand access to capital for Black-owned businesses.
Recommendation 15 (Within one year). “Increase funding and expand involvement of Black
entrepreneurs in the Small Business Assistance Suite, where they can access resources in accounting,
legal support, and other professional services;”
City Response: (Status: In place) The ODI Small Business Assistance Suite directly
advances the intent of this recommendation. The City has maintained SBAS since 2020 as
an economic and business-development resource designed to reduce the barriers to business
formation, stabilization, and growth by providing professional services and technical
assistance at no cost to the participating business. Services available through the program
have included legal assistance; bookkeeping and accounting support; tax preparation;
business coaching; business formation assistance; financial and capital-readiness support;
operations assistance; and marketing and business-development education. Business
formation assistance was added in response to participant need, to help entrepreneurs
establish the legal and operational foundations required to compete for business-
development, procurement, and financing opportunities.
More than 600 potential women- and minority-owned small businesses have received small
business training and start-up support through the City’s business development suite, almost
doubling the number of those businesses in the City’s bidding and contracting pool. Among
SBAS participants for whom race data is available, 83.5% identify as Black-owned
businesses.
ODI will continue strengthening the Small Business Assistance Suite by identifying
opportunities to sustain and expand program funding; increasing program capacity as
resources allow; strengthening performance and outcome tracking; connecting participating
businesses with procurement opportunities; strengthening pathways to capital-readiness
resources; expanding awareness of available City resources; and collaborating with
community and business-support organizations to reach entrepreneurs not currently
connected to City programming. The Administration will review current utilization of the
Suite, identify barriers to participation by Black entrepreneurs, and propose funding and
outreach adjustments to expand participation.
Recommendation 16 (Within one year). “Host and promote quarterly educational programs for
Black entrepreneurs and professionals including presentations by local thought-leaders in areas such as
finance, banking, accounting, law, artificial intelligence, and robotics;”
City Response: (Status: In place) ODI already provides recurring educational
programming that addresses much of the substance of this recommendation. Through the
Small Business Assistance Suite, the City delivers structured educational and technical-
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
13
assistance opportunities in the core areas of business development, including legal
fundamentals; finance and accounting; business operations; marketing; and artificial
intelligence and technology integration. The City’s certification and procurement
programming likewise provides recurring education on government contracting,
certification, procurement readiness, and strategies for positioning a business to pursue
public-sector opportunities.
Together, these initiatives constitute existing infrastructure for delivering the kind of
educational resources the Commission identifies. The Administration’s judgment is that the
gap is in coordination and visibility rather than in the existence of programming. ODI will
therefore consolidate this work into a single published educational calendar rather than
creating duplicative programming, and the Administration will request that the Financial
Empowerment Center, the Opportunity Fund’s coaching partners, and local institutions
contribute to that calendar, with topics and presenters developed in consultation with the
permanent reparatory justice committee. Future programming will also engage local
professionals and subject-matter experts in banking, finance, accounting, law, marketing,
technology, and procurement, which is the element of the Commission’s recommendation
that current programming least fully satisfies. ODI will continue working with community
partners to expand outreach and to ensure that Black entrepreneurs and professionals are
aware of, and represented within, these opportunities.
Recommendation 17 (Within one year). “Provide scholarships and grants to cover membership
costs for Black entrepreneurs in business-support organizations such as the Momentum
Entrepreneurship Hub.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The City does not currently administer any
program that pays membership fees for entrepreneurs to participate in external business-
support organizations. The City’s approach to date has been to invest directly in race-neutral
services provided to businesses at no cost, principally through the Small Business Assistance
Suite, so that entrepreneurs can reach professional services, coaching, technical assistance,
and educational resources without holding membership in an outside organization. The
City has also helped fund the Momentum Entrepreneurship Hub itself.
Before establishing a membership-assistance program, the City would need to determine its
intended purpose and the business outcomes expected of it: which organizations and
membership types would qualify, appropriate eligibility requirements, available funding,
which department would administer it, and how assistance would be distributed. The
Administration supports the objective of connecting Black entrepreneurs to business-support
networks and is open to continued discussion with the Commission and other partners
about whether membership assistance would meaningfully address the barriers local
entrepreneurs face. Membership scholarships directed specifically to Black entrepreneurs
could be administered through the Community Fund described in Recommendation 4.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
14
III. Housing
A. Inequitable Home Ownership
Recommendation 18 (Immediate implementation). “Review and amend all current zoning
regulations that are adversely impacting the development of affordable housing.”
City Response: (Status: In place) South Bend is a national leader in the development of
affordable housing, including changes to zoning regulations. The City comprehensively
rewrote its zoning regulations through the adoption of a citywide form-based code, effective
in 2020, which legalized “missing middle” housing types such as duplexes throughout the
city. In 2021, the City further removed minimum parking requirements citywide, reforms
that directly reduce regulatory barriers to affordable housing development. Through the
Build South Bend initiative, the City also publishes pre-approved building plan sets available
to developers at no cost and reimburses up to $20,000 in sewer connection costs for
qualifying small-scale infill projects.
The Administration will direct the Department of Community Investment, working with
the City Plan Commission process, to continue reviewing remaining zoning provisions that
constrain affordable housing development and to bring recommended amendments forward
for public consideration. To date, the Mueller Administration has supported 1,398 income-
qualified housing units either coming newly online or aged units being remodeled, including
replacement of Rabbi Shulman and Monroe Circle and full remodels of Beacon Heights and
LaSalle Park Homes.
Recommendation 19 (Immediate implementation). “Maintain the city-based housing
counselor.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Administration commits to maintaining the city-
based housing counselor position.
Recommendation 20 (Immediate implementation). “Maintain the financial empowerment
center, but add a component specifically designed to support home ownership.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Administration commits to maintaining the FEC.
The City housing counselor provides housing counseling, including pre-purchase
counseling, homebuyer education, and mortgage delinquency and default counseling. FEC
counselors currently share information on homeownership, help clients become mortgage-
ready, and then refer clients to the City housing counselor, other HUD-approved providers,
and Habitat for Humanity.
Recommendation 21 (Immediate implementation). “Support programs for downpayment
assistance.”
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
15
City Response: (Status: In place) The City supports down payment assistance through its
partnership with the Community Homebuyers Corporation (CHC), a non-profit consortium
of financial partners that pool resources to provide mortgages to low- and moderate-income
first-time homebuyers. City staff support CHC’s operations, and the City awards CHC
federal Community Development Block Grant funding that CHC uses for down payment
assistance and a forgivable second mortgage for its clients, paired with homeownership
counseling. In 2026 to date, six homebuyer closings were supported by $962,000 in first
mortgages, $192,400 in forgivable second-mortgage assistance, and $6,000 in closing-cost
assistance.
The CHC board is currently reviewing the structure of the program. The Administration
commits to continuing its funding and staff support for CHC and will encourage the board,
as part of that review, to strengthen outreach to first-generation homebuyers in the
neighborhoods identified in the Commission’s report.
Recommendation 22 (Immediate implementation). “Discontinue aggressive repair orders
against people unable to afford repairs and establish a fine forgiveness program for homeowners who
incur code enforcement fines but are constructively working with the City on the issues.”
City Response: (Status: Partially complete) The goal of code enforcement is compliance
and repair, not fines and litigation. Homeowners receive multiple opportunities to correct a
violation before any fine is assessed, and the City works with homeowners acting in good
faith through repair agreements and connects them to the repair resources described in
Recommendation 24. Because fines are assessed only after those opportunities have been
exhausted, the repair-agreement process already serves this purpose. The Administration
will share this process widely so every homeowner knows about it.
Taken together with Recommendation 27, the City’s approach is deliberate: firm with
landlords who repeatedly fail their tenants, and patient with homeowners who are working
to keep up their homes.
Recommendation 23 (Within three months). “Work with CDFIs and other not-for-profits to
create more affordable housing.”
City Response: (Status: In place) Since 2023, eleven affordable housing projects supported
by the City have received Low Income Housing Tax Credit awards from the Indiana
Housing and Community Development Authority, both to renovate older units and to build
new income-restricted units. These projects are part of the almost $300M in affordable
housing investment described in Recommendation 30. The City has also worked over recent
years to assist with the creation of two minority-managed CDFIs and is currently working
on the establishment of a third.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
16
In addition, the City works with CDFI Friendly South Bend and many not-for-profit
partners, including 466 Works, South Bend Heritage Foundation, Near Northwest
Neighborhood Inc., Habitat for Humanity, Advantix, and Affordable Home Matters, to
create affordable housing in the City. The City has also partnered with CDFI Friendly
South Bend on the Housing Capital Enhancement Pilot, which helps unlock financing to
create more affordable housing. The Administration commits to continuing and expanding
these partnerships.
Recommendation 24 (Within three months). “Support and expand the current grant program
for home maintenance, streamlining the process when possible.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The South Bend Home Repair Program provides repair
grants at no cost to income-qualified owner-occupants, with contractors paid directly by the
City; the current 2026 program round focuses on roof replacements for senior homeowners
enrolled in the City’s Utility Assistance Program. The 2027 proposed budget increases
Home Repair Program funding by 16.7%, to $350,000. In 2026, the City also partnered with
the Indiana Energy Saver Program to fund energy improvements in 87 homes, most serving
households below 80% of Area Median Income, which are expected to reduce household
energy use by an average of 24% and save more than $215 a year.
The City also connects homeowners to complementary repair resources, including Lead
Safe South Bend funding, the NNRO Home Repair program, and Rebuilding Together St.
Joseph County’s neighborhood-based free repair program. The Administration supports
expanding this programming and will review it to identify opportunities to expand funding,
broaden the categories of eligible repairs beyond the current single-repair focus, and simplify
application and eligibility processes for homeowners, in coordination with the repair-
agreement approach described in Recommendation 22.
Recommendation 25 (Within one year). “Robustly review all new developments to be sure they
are not displacing low-income families in favor of gentrification and guaranteeing the inclusion of
affordable housing in all further development.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The City actively advocates for and incentivizes
affordable housing and mixed-income development, and adopted neighborhood plans guide
the City’s involvement in development projects. The Administration will direct planning
staff to prepare a full description of how neighborhood plans and development review
currently address displacement risk, and to recommend whether additional anti-
displacement review standards or affordability requirements should be adopted for projects
receiving City support.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
17
B. Repairing a Broken Rental Market
Recommendation 26 (Immediate implementation). “Human Rights Commission should make
annual reports to the City and the general public relating to incidents of housing discrimination in the
City.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Human Rights Commission already makes an
annual report to the Mayor and City Council, including data on housing discrimination
charges, investigations, and outcomes. Those reports are public documents.
Recommendation 27 (Within three months). “Continue and strengthen the Rental Safety
Verification Program by aggressively collecting against those entities who are either repeat offenders or
have large outstanding balances to the City.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Rental Safety Verification Program responds to
housing-condition complaints and holds landlords accountable as strictly as state law
allows. In 2026, through September 30, the program conducted 1,071 inspections (a unit
may be inspected more than once), and 294 units passed inspection. The Administration
commits to continuing the program and the DCI-Neighborhoods and the Legal Department
will continue to prioritize collection against repeat offenders and entities with large
outstanding balances. Unpaid fines are pursued to judgment through the collections process,
and a judgment applies to any property the owner holds in the county; the Legal
Department will also evaluate whether property-specific liens can strengthen collection. The
Council and Administration are currently working on ordinance amendments that would
clarify violations and strengthen the process.
This is the other half of the approach described in Recommendation 22: firm with landlords
who fail their tenants, patient with homeowners working to make repairs.
Recommendation 28 (Within three months). “Create a public facing website where tenants can
determine if their landlord is registered and whether they have outstanding civil penalties and unpaid
fines.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The Administration supports this recommendation.
The City is developing new Rental Safety Verification software, scheduled to launch in
2027, and commits to including in it a public, searchable lookup of Rental Safety
Verification Program information for rental properties. The Administration will work with
the Legal Department to determine what penalty and fine information can be published
accurately and lawfully. The City’s current software cannot post accurate real-time balances
owed.
Recommendation 29 (Within six months). “Educate the community on the rights and
responsibilities of the Fair Housing Act.”
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
18
City Response: (Status: In place) The Human Rights Commission currently conducts
community education sessions on Fair Housing Act rights and responsibilities, directed to
both tenants and landlords, and distributes educational materials.
Recommendation 30 (Within one year). “Support the construction of housing for those below 80
percent of area mean income, especially those below 30 percent of area mean income.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The City has supported the construction or renovation of
1,398 housing units affordable to households at or below 80% of Area Median Income
(AMI) since the beginning of the Mueller administration; 232 of these units are affordable to
households at or below 30% AMI. In total, almost $300M has been invested in the creation
of affordable housing for those in our city who can least afford it.
During the last two years, 288 new single-family homes have been built in South Bend, the
highest level of new home construction in twenty years, nearly all of them on infill lots. On
July 8, 2026, the City joined federal, private, and community partners in breaking ground
on the rehabilitation of LaSalle Park Homes, a 150-unit HUD-subsidized housing
community on the city’s west side. The more than $40M project is financed through the
federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program and public-private partnerships, including
a $2M City Council investment, and all units will remain income-restricted to households
earning no more than 60% of AMI for a minimum of 15 years. Also on the west side, $10
million in HUD financing is supporting a $63.4 million, 210-home mixed-income project on
Western Avenue. The City will continue to support affordable housing projects through
development agreements, real estate purchase agreements, tax abatements, and PILOT
programs.
Recommendation 31 (Within one year). “Embark on a program of testing to determine the
nature and extent of housing discrimination in the City.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The Administration supports this recommendation
and will work with the Human Rights Commission and qualified fair housing organizations
to conduct testing and include the findings in the Human Rights Commission’s annual
report described in Recommendation 26.
C. Lack of Neighborhood Investment
The City has invested almost $60M over recent years in the parks and community centers of
the west side, including the full renovation of the Charles Black Center, the new Martin
Luther King, Jr. Dream Center, the full renovation of Kennedy Park, upgrades to Pulaski
Park, and Coal Line Trail Phase III, which will connect the Dream Center to the University
of Notre Dame. Kennedy Park’s revitalization is supported by a $7.5M National Park
Service Outdoor Recreation Legacy Partnership grant toward a $15M project, and LaSalle
Park received new paths, a skating loop, restrooms, a pavilion, and parking. Tax increment
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
19
financing is also reaching neighborhoods directly: TIF funds committed to projects outside
of development agreements grew from $15.7M in 2025 to $32.4M in 2026, including
$11.2M for street repaving and streetscape improvements and $14.9M for park and trail
improvements at Kennedy Park, O’Brien Park, and Potawatomi Park.
Recommendation 32 (Immediate implementation). “Maintain sidewalks on City owned
properties, especially vacant lots.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The Administration will direct the Department of
Public Works to review the latest sidewalk conditions inventory for City-owned properties,
including vacant lots, and to incorporate their maintenance into annual public works
programming.
Recommendation 33 (Within six months). “Maintain the infrastructure equally in all
neighborhoods of the City.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The City employs a street rating system that
prioritizes the worst pavement conditions first, citywide, regardless of neighborhood. Every
street is rated on a 0-to-100 surface condition assessment, conducted through video capture
and specialized pavement-distress analysis software, and the lowest-scoring streets are
prioritized for paving each year. In 2025, the City invested approximately $10M in
resurfacing and full reconstruction projects across more than 90 streets covering 48 lane-
miles, and the 2026 paving season will pave more than 50 additional streets, alongside
preventative maintenance.
The Administration concurs with the principle of equitable infrastructure investment and
will provide annual, neighborhood-level reporting on street, sidewalk, and related
infrastructure investment, including pavement condition data, so that equity of investment
can be independently verified rather than asserted.
Recommendation 34 (Within one year). “Create a more equitable road repair program that
focuses on neighborhoods, not scattered streets across the City.”
City Response: (Status: In place) The Administration supports neighborhood-based
programming of road repair. Public Works has prioritized paving neighborhood streets in
recent years and will continue to do so, using the condition-first street rating system
described in the response to Recommendation 33 to guide future paving investments.
IV. Education
Most recommendations in this section are directed to the South Bend Community School
Corporation, an independent unit of government not under municipal authority. The
Administration has formally transmitted each such recommendation to the SBCSC Board of
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
20
Trustees and Superintendent, requested a written response for inclusion in the permanent
reparatory justice committee’s annual review, and offered City cooperation where
identified.
Recommendation 35 (Immediate implementation). “The SBCSC should track and study
expulsions and behavior related discipline and engage professionals from the mental health services and
behavioral sciences to advise and help address and reduce the racial disparities that have historically
existed.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation and has requested that SBCSC’s response include a
plan for disaggregated discipline data reporting.
Recommendation 36 (Immediate implementation). “Free GED preparation programs should
be provided by the SBCSC to any Black former SBCSC student who now desires to obtain their GED
and who quit school within the last 20 years before achieving high school graduation.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation.
Recommendation 37 (Immediate implementation). “After-school tutoring for Black students
should be available in schools or in after school care agencies. Academic support must be made available
as needed to Black students participating in honors or advance placement classes to ensure equitable
success of these students.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) Directed to SBCSC. The
Administration has transmitted this recommendation and has offered City community
centers, including the Charles Black Center and the Martin Luther King Jr. Dream Center,
as partner sites for after-school academic support programming.
Recommendation 38 (Immediate implementation). “Wrap around services within the SBCSC
should be implemented or made available within the SBCSC system to provide personalized support to
South Bend’s Black students and their families which address urgent or persistent issues in housing,
healthcare, hunger, transportation, and similar matters.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) Directed to SBCSC. The
Administration has transmitted this recommendation and commits to coordinating City
housing, utility, and neighborhood services so that school-based navigators have a clear
referral path for students and families into City programs.
Recommendation 39 (Within one year). “The SBCSC should partner with IUSB, Ivy Tech, or
other local higher education programs to provide all high school students with the opportunity for two
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
21
years college credit and an Associate’s degree. This program must be given special promotion and
outreach to Black students and should engage parents of those students.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC and its higher-
education partners. The Administration has transmitted this recommendation to SBCSC,
IU South Bend, and Ivy Tech.
Recommendation 40 (Within three years). “SBCSC will partner with and work affirmatively to
incorporate within the entire SBCSC system Black youth mentorship programs such as 100 Black Men
and will designate a specific SBCSC administrator to coordinate and promote the program activities
within the SBCSC schools. The SBCSC will also provide staff presence in after school events or sessions
of such program.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) Directed to SBCSC. The
Administration has transmitted this recommendation and has offered City facilities and
youth programming staff as partners to mentorship organizations operating under this
model.
Recommendation 41 (Within six months). “To increase the number of Black teachers in the
SBCSC system, the SBCSC should implement a vigorous recruitment program for Black teachers from
the Teacher Education Departments of local, State, and neighboring state colleges and universities.
They should intentionally seek out students from Historically Black Colleges and Universities
(HBCUs).”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation.
Recommendation 42 (Within six months). “The most highly trained, effective Black teachers
should be placed in South Bend schools where the Black student population is at or above 35.58 percent
and in those schools with the historically lowest graduation and highest school suspension rates.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation.
Recommendation 43 (Within one year). “Until cultural competency programs become a
mandatory component of teacher certification, the South Bend Community School Corporation
(SBCSC) should develop or obtain and sponsor an effective annual training on Black racial cultural
competency and sensitivity, classroom management, behavior strategy, child brain development, and
should require that every teacher, including substitutes, attend this program upon hire and once every
three years thereafter.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
22
Recommendation 44 (Within one year). “Certification by all teachers employed in all SBCSC
schools should be effectuated, and teacher certification must be required to teach the Core K-12
curriculum and social studies classes.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to SBCSC. The Administration
has transmitted this recommendation.
Recommendation 45 (Within six months). “Reading programs should be required in all South
Bend daycare centers; and free training or materials on effective preschool reading techniques should be
provided to day care owners and staff.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation. In 2022 and 2023, the Mayor supported the Robinson Community
Learning Center’s successful application to the Lilly Endowment to expand its “Talk With
Your Baby” program, which has since secured six times that initial funding. The City is also
a major funder of Ready to Grow St. Joe and will explore, with childcare licensing
authorities, the St. Joseph County Public Library, and early learning partners, a program to
provide free training and reading materials to daycare providers, recognizing that daycare
licensing authority rests with the State of Indiana.
Recommendation 46 (Within one year). “The City of South Bend, SBCSC, social agencies, and
employers in South Bend should unite to promote and provide early, free, or minimal cost, effective
early childhood education programs to be located within South Bend’s high poverty geographic areas
and should monitor the results of this education upon the participants through their primary school
years.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The City has been a major funding partner of Ready
to Grow St. Joe and will soon announce an expansion of that yearly funding commitment.
American Rescue Plan funds were also directed toward the expansion of pre-K seats within
the City. The Administration has transmitted this recommendation to SBCSC and will work
with SBCSC, Ready to Grow St. Joe, social service agencies, and employers to expand
access to free or low-cost early childhood education in the City’s highest-poverty
neighborhoods, and will request that SBCSC track participant outcomes through the
primary school years.
Recommendation 47 (Within one year). “The South Bend Community Foundation should
partner with the South Bend Branch of the St. Joseph County Library to assure that every preschool
child living in a designated low-income area of South Bend (the former redlined geographic areas) has
received a Dolly Parton free book, and create a program to distribute another book to every such Black
child at ages three and four with opportunities for “book readings” at the closest Library branches.”
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
23
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed to the Community Foundation
and the St. Joseph County Public Library. The Administration has transmitted this
recommendation to both entities.
V. Health and Mental Health
The Commission prefaces its health recommendations as follows: “Because economic well-
being, housing, and education are such important determinants of health, adopting the
recommendation in those areas will also benefit the health of all communities in South
Bend.”
The Administration concurs with these conclusions. Public health authority in our
community rests principally with the St. Joseph County Department of Health, and clinical
care is delivered by independent health systems. The City’s role in this section is therefore
chiefly one of funding, convening, and support, and the Administration has transmitted
these recommendations to the Department of Health and local health systems.
Recommendation 48 (Immediate implementation). “Fund programs that provide prenatal care,
doula services, and postpartum support for Black mothers. Partner with local hospitals to reduce Black
infant mortality and low birth weight disparities”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration will work with
local hospital systems, the St. Joseph County Department of Health’s Maternal Infant
Health Initiatives and Fetal Infant Mortality Review process, and community-based
maternal health organizations, including Community Perinatal Pathways and the Indiana
Minority Health Coalition’s Community Doula Services, which operates a South Bend
office at the Charles Martin Youth Center, to identify a funding partnership for doula
services and prenatal and postpartum support aimed at the infant mortality and low birth
weight disparities documented in the Commission’s report. City-supported services will be
designed to reach the mothers and neighborhoods the report identifies, and the Community
Fund described in Recommendation 4 can support services directed specifically to Black
mothers.
Recommendation 49 (Within one year). “Increase the number of community health workers,
health navigators, and peer support specialists. Hire and train these positions with people from the
Black communities to assist residents in access insurance, scheduling appointments, access mental
health services, and understanding treatment options.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation and will work with the County Department of Health and county partners
to expand community health worker and navigator capacity.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
24
Recommendation 50 (Within one year). “Mandate an annual public report on health disparities,
progress on reparatory initiatives, and community feedback sessions.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation and will work with the County Department of Health and health system
partners to conduct a health disparities study, accompanied by public feedback sessions.
Recommendation 51 (Within one year). “Ensure access to healthy and affordable foods,
especially on the west side.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) The Administration acknowledges candidly that food
access on the west side worsened with the closure of the Kroger on Western Avenue in
2025, and that this recommendation addresses a real and growing need. The City’s response
to date reflects its neighborhood-anchor strategy: a land agreement the City entered in 2021
enabled the opening, in November 2025, of a new 10,000-square-foot full-service
supermarket at the corner of Western Avenue and Olive Street, in the heart of the west side,
and the City’s Engagement and Economic Empowerment team operates the seasonal
Linden Avenue Farmers Market at the MLK Dream Center in partnership with local
farmers, food vendors, and non-profit organizations. In a survey of 288 market attendees,
73% identified as Black, 42% lived within one mile of the market, and most relied on some
form of food assistance.
The Administration will continue to pursue grocery access, healthy corner store, farmers
market, and urban agriculture strategies for the west side, using the City’s economic
development tools to reduce the risk and cost of food retail investment in underserved areas.
Recommendation 52 (Within three years). “Establish a Black Health Equity Fund dedicated to
supporting health initiatives for Black residents, including preventative care, chronic disease
management, and maternal health programs.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports the
objective of this recommendation. A fund dedicated specifically to Black residents is best
established through non-governmental philanthropy, and the Administration will encourage
the Community Fund described in Recommendation 4, together with health system and
philanthropic partners, to establish and capitalize such a fund.
Recommendation 53 (Immediate implementation). “Support efforts in the community to
increase the number of peer counselors.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation. The City funds Oaklawn’s City Outreach Team, which helps unhoused
residents connect to services and get on the coordinated housing list, and supports the
Oaklawn Crisis Center, which opened in March 2024 and served 120 people in its first year
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
25
as a walk-in alternative for residents in a mental health or substance use crisis. The City’s
Coordinator of Homeless Outreach convenes eighteen agencies working on substance use,
which have developed a shared framework to connect residents with treatment and build
supportive community, and provides training in mental health, trauma-informed care, and
de-escalation to agencies, neighborhood organizations, businesses, and congregations. The
Administration will work with Oaklawn and these partner agencies to identify where
additional peer counselor and peer recovery support positions are most needed, and to
pursue state and federal funding to support them.
Recommendation 54 (Within six months). “Establish community-based mental health centers.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The City will continue to support
and assist in the expansion of mental health services, including community-based mental
health centers. The City is a major funding partner of Oaklawn, the state-designated
community mental health center. This partnership has resulted in the opening and
expansion of the Oaklawn Walk-in Crisis Center and the Mobile Crisis Response Team. In
total, the City has invested over $6M in American Rescue Plan funds in partnerships with
St. Joseph County providers on homelessness and mental health resources, services, and
shelters.
Recommendation 55 (Immediate implementation). “Establish a comprehensive directory
showcasing Black therapists, doctors, and nurse practitioners”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation and will encourage health system partners, professional associations, and
community organizations to develop and publicize such a directory, and will offer to host it
alongside the public resources described in Recommendation 2.
Recommendation 56 (Within six months). “Develop culturally competent healthcare teams”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, transmitted) Directed principally to health systems
and providers. The Administration has transmitted this recommendation to local health
systems and has requested the adoption of cultural competency training and team-based
care models responsive to the Commission’s findings on discrimination and distrust in the
medical profession.
Recommendation 57 (Within one year). “Create scholarships and mentorship programs for Black
students pursuing careers in healthcare. Partner with local universities and hospitals to increase
representation in medical fields.”
City Response: (Status: Partner-led, City supporting) The Administration supports this
recommendation and will encourage local universities, hospitals, and philanthropic
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
26
partners, including the Community Fund described in Recommendation 4, to establish
scholarship and mentorship pipelines for Black students entering healthcare fields.
VI. Environmental Issues
Recommendation 58 (Immediate implementation). “Enhance the City lead removal program
supporting the homes in the zip codes with the highest risk to lead exposure (46613, 46619, and
46628).”
City Response: (Status: In progress) Through Lead Safe South Bend, the City provides
lead-safe repairs of up to $30,000 per home, at no cost, to income-qualified households in
homes built before 1978, with priority given to homes where a child under six lives or
frequently visits or where a pregnant person resides. In March 2026, the City’s Department
of Community Investment was awarded a $7M Lead Hazard Reduction Grant from the
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Office of Lead Hazard Control and
Healthy Homes, extending the program’s funding for four additional years. The
Administration commits to continuing and enhancing this programming, to prioritizing
homes in zip codes 46613, 46619, and 46628 consistent with this recommendation, and to
reporting annual remediation counts by zip code to the permanent reparatory justice
committee.
Recommendations 59 through 62 concern the Beck’s Lake site, which is under the
regulatory oversight of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Indiana
Department of Environmental Management. The City’s actions on these recommendations
must be coordinated with, and in several respects approved by, those agencies, and the
Administration’s responses below reflect that shared authority.
Recommendation 59 (Immediate implementation). “The City should embark on a
comprehensive education program in the LaSalle Park regarding safe urban gardening practices,
including distribution of the information provided by the EPA on the superfund site.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The Administration supports this recommendation
and will work on developing a neighborhood education campaign on safe urban gardening
practices with the LaSalle Park Neighborhood Association using EPA-provided materials.
Recommendation 60 (Immediate implementation). “The City should support efforts by the
LaSalle Park Neighborhood Association to do comprehensive health study of the historical LaSalle
Park residents and their families as well as increased testing of the area.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The Administration will assist the Neighborhood
Association in pursuing study partners and funding, including academic institutions and
state and federal environmental health agencies. The City, Honeywell, and EPA,
collectively, gathered more than 1,000 environmental samples, which were analyzed in
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
27
more than 3,000 laboratory tests for more than 150 contaminants, including lead, arsenic,
PCBs, pesticides, petroleum, and chlorinated solvents. More than 270 of those samples were
collected by EPA from residential properties bordering LaSalle Park. Under the oversight of
EPA, a comprehensive health risk assessment was also performed. That assessment found
no current exposure risks and identified potential future risks only from soil excavation and
from growing produce on parkland. To address those risks, the City recorded an
Environmental Restrictive Covenant in 2026 that prohibits agricultural use of the park,
restricts groundwater use, and requires an agency-approved soil management plan for any
excavation. The park and the surrounding neighborhood are served by municipal water.
EPA’s evaluation of groundwater and residential soil is continuing, and EPA’s Record of
Decision will determine whether either requires further action. The health and safety of its
residents remain top priorities for the City, and the City will support measures designed to
improve them.
Because the Superfund process addresses environmental conditions rather than community
health outcomes, any health study of the neighborhood will need to be undertaken
independently of that process.
In the meantime, the St. Joseph County Department of Health offers free lead risk
assessments for the homes of pregnant women and children under the age of 7, as well as
free blood lead tests for these children, and the City encourages any concerned residents to
use these services, as further described in Recommendation 61.
Recommendation 61 (Immediate implementation). “The City should embark on an aggressive
lead testing program for the children who have lived or are currently living in the Beck’s Lake region.”
City Response: (Status: Under review) The Administration supports this recommendation
and will work with the County Department of Health and healthcare providers to expand
blood lead testing for children with current or historical residence in the LaSalle Park
neighborhood, coordinated with the remediation prioritization described in
Recommendation 58.
Recommendation 62 (Immediate implementation). “Accelerate cleanup of toxic sites like Beck’s
Lake and surrounding neighborhoods. Conduct long-term health impact studies and provide free health
screenings for residents exposed to industrial pollutants.”
City Response: (Status: In progress) Under EPA oversight, the City and Honeywell
International completed a time-critical removal action at the Beck’s Lake site in October
2022, excavating more than 4,600 tons of lead-impacted soil from portions of LaSalle Park
and the yards of two neighboring residences. More than 1,200 truckloads of clean soil were
used to backfill and cap 3.2 acres of the park. During a public meeting, EPA confirmed that
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026
28
the park is safe and does not pose a threat to park visitors. The physical remediation of the
park is complete.
The City continues to work with EPA, the Indiana Department of Environmental
Management, and Hyperion Environmental LLLP I, a subsidiary of Honeywell Aerospace,
which is continuing Honeywell’s work toward closure of the Superfund process for the park.
EPA’s evaluation of groundwater and residential soil is continuing, and the Administration
will continue to advocate to EPA and the Indiana Department of Environmental
Management for prompt completion of that process. The recommendation’s calls for health
studies and screenings are addressed in Recommendations 60 and 61.
Filed in Clerk's Office
Bianca Tirado City Clerk, South Bend, IN
Nov 5, 2026