HomeMy WebLinkAbout6I(1) Proposal for TIF Neutralization Workseets~ L ~-~
Redevelopment Commission
Staff Report from Don Inks
Proposal fi-om Crowe Horwath for TIF Neutralization Calculations
6/ 1 /09
This proposal is for Crowe Horwath to prepare the City of South Bend Tax Increment
Financing Neutralization Worksheets, including collecting the necessary data, preparing
t11e worksheets for each TIF area and filing the worksheets with the Auditor's office. The
total cost is not exceed $20,000 for professional fees and $2,500 for incidental costs
related to communication, printing, travel expenses and other similar expenses.
These calculations are necessary every year in which there is a reassessment of all
properties. Historically, these calculations were only required once every ten years when
a general reassessment was done. However, now these calculations are needed every
year, since every year all property values are adjusted for market trending.
This calculation adjusts the base assessed value for each TIF area to "neutralize'" the
effect of the reassessment. To achieve this neutralization, the base assessed values are
adjusted to reflect growth in the County vs. the TIF area, and to achieve the amount of
tax revenue collected in prior year plus tax revenue due to new "real growth" and tax
abatement roll offs. I have attached a Worksheet from the calculations done last year to
further explain this process.
Staff recommends favorable consideration by the Redevelopment Commission.
Department of Local Government Finance
County Auditor's Certificate of Adjustment to the Based Assessed Valuation of TIF Districts
Identify the specific allocation area if more than one allocation area is located in the county.
TIF District 104 -South Bend West Washington
County Name Saint Joseph
Contact Information: Financial Advisor: Crowe Horwath LLP
Name: Michael C. Eby, County Auditor Name: Herschel Frierson
Address: 227 West Jefferson Boulevard, 2nd Floor Address: 10 West Market Street, Suite 2000
South Bend, Indiana 46601 Indianapolis, Indiana 46204-2975
Phone: (574) 235-9668 Phone : (317) 269-2377
1. 2007p2008 Gross Real Estate Valuation' of the allocation area $ 55,397,500
2. 2006p2007 Gross Real Estate Valuation' of the allocation area $ 57,452,625
3. Divide line 1 by line 2 and carry to 5 decimal places
4. 2007p2008 Gross Real Estate Valuation` of the county
5. 2006p2007 Gross Real Estate Valuation' of the county
6. Divide line 4 by line 5 and carry to 5 decimal places
0.
$ 10,225,208,380
$ 9.974,323,521
1.02515
*Any contested amount of assessed value subject to appeal should not be included in the gross assessed
value of real estate.
Amounts do not include non-taxable and government exempt property.
7. Current net base assessed valuation of the allocation area:
8. Lesser of line 3 or line 6
9. Line 8 multiplied by line 7 =tentative new 2007p2008 base assessed value
$ 35.449.399
0.96422
$ 34.181,020
Determination of Adequate Potential Captured Assessment
(This calculation will be specific to each allocation area within the county.)
1 a. Amount of potential captured assessment in 2006p2007.
Amount of net assessed value 2006p2007 minus current base NAV $ 7,890,416
2a. Abatement reductions, if any, in pre-reassessment values, scheduled to roll off in p2008 $ 148,233
3a. Real Growth, estimated in net assessed value first assessed for 2007p2008
4a. Total of line 1a plus line 2a =Adjusted Incremental NAV
5a. 2006p2007 net tax rate of the TIF district
5b. Estimated 2007p2008 tax rate
6a. Tax revenue without reassessment line 4a multiplied by line 5a
6b. Tax revenue on real growth line 3a multiplied by line 5b
6c. Total estimated tax revenue without reassessment line 6a plus line 6b
$ 8,038,649
$ 3.9607
$ 3.9607
$ 318,387
$ 88,905
$ 407,292
7a. Amount of adequate potential captured assessment required in 2007p2008. Line 6c divided by
2007p2008 net tax rate. This rate will need to be estimated. Do not use a net rate in excess of the
2006p2007 tax rate unless you are aware of a large increase in a capital project.
Net tax rate used to divide into Line 6c $3.9607 $ 10,283,330
8a. 2007p2008 total net real estate assessed value of the TIF area
(no deduction for base assessed value)
$ 42,198,500
9a. Less 2007p2008 contested assessed value of the TIF area $ -
(do not include appealed assessed value on real growth shown on line 3a)
10a. Line 8a minus line 9a = 2007p2008 net assessed value of the TIF area $ 42,198.500
11a. Less adequate potential captured assessment from line 7a $ 10,283,330
12a. Line 10a minus line 11a =tentative new base net assessed value $ 31,915,170
13a. Lesser of line 9 or 12a = 2007p2008 base assessed value $ 31,915.170
The amount on Line 13a is the base amount to be used in the certification of the assessed valuation in
those taxing districts containing the specific TIF district. This amount CANNOT be a negative number.
If it does calculate to be a negative number, it must be adjusted to zero in order to continue the calculation.
14a. Line 13a divided by line 7 =factor
(factor multiplied by old parcel base =new base assessed value)
0.90030
The amount of potential captured assessed valuation of the specific TIF district will depend on whether
Line 9 or Line 12a is used in determining Line 13a. (A) if line 9 is used, the potential captured assessment
is line 10a minus line 13a. (B) If line 12a is used, the potential captured assessment is the amount on
Line 11A. If line 13a is a negative number that must be adjusted to zero, the potential captured
assessment is the amount on line 10a.
What is the potential captured assessment?
(A) Line 9 is used for the base assessed valuation for March 1, 2007.
Line 12a < Line 9
(B) Line 12a was used for the base assessed valuation for March 1, 2007. $ 10,283,330
'The amount indicated in either (A) or (8) is the amount shown as a
minus amount in the certification of assessed valuation in those
taxing districts containing the specific TIF district.
15. If applicable. please disclose on the following page any information regarding contractual obligations or
debt service to be paid from the proceeds of the tax increment revenues for the ensuing budget year.
I, .Auditor of .County
certify to the best of my knowledge that the above base assessed valuation calculation is full, true and complete
for the tax increment finance allocation area.
Dated this day of
County Auditor (signature)
200_
County Auditor (printed name)
(Please submit the completed form to John Mailers-Budget Director, Department of Local Government Finance, for action)
DEPARTMENT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT FINANCE
CERTIFICATION OF TIF INFORMATION
District Name:
The base assessed valuation adjustment. as certified. has been approved by the Department of Local Government
Finance this day of .200_
Commissioner. Department of Local Government Finance
DEPARTMENT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT FINANCE
DISCLOSURE OF CONTRACTURAL OBLIGATIONS AND DEBT SERVICE
Please use additional sheets if necessary
1. Describe the contractual obligation or debt service to be paid from the tax increment revenues.
2. List the date the contractual obligation or debt service was issued.
3. List the total amount of tax increment revenues required for the remainder of this contractual
obligation or debt service.
4. List the amount of tax increment revenues required for this contractual obligation
or debt service for the current budget year.
5. Is the contractual obligation or debt service supported by revenues other than tax increment revenues?
If so, please describe. (Ex: CAGIT, COIT, CEDIT, ad valorem property taxes. other)
Crowe Horwath,.,
Crowe Horwath LLP
Member Crowe Horwath International
PROJECT ASSIGNMENT
City of South Bend, Indiana
10 West Market Street, Suite 2000
Indianapolis, Indiana 46204-2975
Tel 317.632.1100
Fax 317.635.6127
www.crowehorwath.com
May 20, 2009
This document is a Project Assignment based on an agreement entered into between the City of
South Bend ("City") and Crowe Horwath LLP (formerly, Crowe Chizek and Company LLC)
("Crowe") dated March 27, 2006.
The title of this Project Assignment is: City of South Bend Tax Increment
Financing Neutralization Worksheets
The scope of financial advisory services provided by Crowe may include the following:
Tax Increment Financin~(TIF) Neutralization Worksheet (the "Worksheet")
1. Collect TIF Data from the St. Joseph County Auditor's Office (the "Auditor's Office")
2. Preparation of the TIF worksheet for each Allocation Area
3. File the Worksheet and all other necessary documents with the Auditor's Office.
Fees
Fees shall be billed for the hours expended on this project. Hourly rates are presented below:
Executive $ 260 to $ 390
Senior Manager 155 to 250
Manager 120 to 155
Staff 90 to 120
Out-of-pocket expenses At Cost
Project Assignment (Continued)
City of South Bend, Indiana
May 20, 2009
Page 2
Professional fees for the scope of services outlined above typically will not exceed $20,000 and
this fee will not be exceeded without the written permission of the City.
Services requested which are outside the scope of services listed herein will be described and
quoted separately.
Incidental costs are usually paid by Crowe and billed to the client at cost. These costs generally
include, but are not limited to, communication, printing, binding and travel expenses incurred
on behalf of the client and not to exceed $2,500.
In the event the City approves the engagement of Crowe for this assignment, please sign, date
and return the enclosed copy of this letter to us.
Respectfully submitted,
~`~~~~~
~''l ~ ,/~~ /~ r
Michael A. Claytor
Agreed and Accepted:
CITY OF SOUTH SEND, INDIANA
By:
Date:
Crone 1 fonralG I_LP is a member oJ~Cron~e Ilonvulb Inlernaliaml: I seorurlion, rr Suds as_so~ra/iort ~l Jm~r~alG). Is'arG memGerfarm of Honualli u a sepaizrle rrnd independent
legal erdity. Crory tlor~natG LLP curd ils a~iliules mr na1 rr ponsible orlable fanny ar7s nr omissions ofHonnatG or any othermember of Hmrvaih and ~perijiarlly dirdaim any
and alL rrspons76ilily or ha/nlily Jor gels or omissiorcr of HorvrrlLr nr any olGer men7ber of Hm~r~atb. Horvath does not under any professional serrrcer and does na! bare an
orr~nerrhip orpm/rrerrGip interest in Ciorvo Harral6 l.l.P. I-]orv~alG and its otter nrenrGer firrn.~~ mr nod re.r/~onsiLle or k~aUle fnr any adr or orrrissrons of Cron~a Honr~atL LLP
mul ~~ieeifreu/ly disrGrmr any and all nr.ponrilnlity rn~ liability for ads or omi.ctions of Crone 1-Ionvrrlh LLP. ~~~ 2008 Crorve Hmrr~alG 1_.LP