HomeMy WebLinkAbout6.B.(3) Staff report Parking Garage ManagementRequest for Proposal Comparison 12/15/08
CITY OF SOUTH BEND, INDIANA
Department of Community & Economic Development
Review of Bids for Parking Garage Management
December 2008
ESTIMATED TOTAL
EXPENSES ANNUALIZED ESTIMATED
(without fees) FEES EXPENSES
AMPCO
Main Street 8 165.610.12 $ 8,472.88 $ 174,083.00
Leighton 242.743.71 22,120.29 264,864.00
Wayne Street 132.158.00 3.000.00 135 158.00
TOTALS $ 540,511.83 $ 33,593.17 $ 574,105.00
DENISON
Main Street $ 182,116.24 $ 14.891.76 $ 197,008.00
Leighton 246.099.48 14,888.52 260,988.00
Wayne Street 161,999.52 14 994.48 176.994.00
TOTALS $ 590,215.24 $ 44,774.76 $ 634,990.00
Differences $ (49,703.41) $ (11,181.59) $ (60,885.00)
(Ampco -Denison)
Summary: Expenses are projected to be $60,885.00 higher under benison's proposal.
Staff recommends continuing the garage management under Ampco.