HomeMy WebLinkAbout07-18-08 Redevelopment Commission MinutesSOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
July 18, 2008
10:00 a.m.
Presiding: Marcia I. Jones, President
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present:
Members Absent:
Legal Counsel:
Ms. Marcia Jones, President
Mr. Hardie Blake, Jr.
Dr. David Varner
227 West Jefferson Boulevard
South Bend, Indiana
Mr. Karl King, Vice President
Mr. Greg Downes, Secretary
Mr. Charles S. Leone, Esq.
Mr. Lawrence Meteiver, Esq.
Redevelopment Staf£ Mr. Don Inks, Director
Mrs . Cheryl Phipps, Recording Secretary
Mr. Bill Schalliol, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Robert Mathia, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Nicholas Witwer, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Jitin Kain, Economic Development Specialist
Others Present: Mr. Tom Price, Mayor's Office
Ms Mariam Masri, Mayor's Office
Ms. Rita Kopala
Mr. Marty Wolfson, Community Forum for Economic Dev
Mr. Paul Phair, Holladay Corp.
Mr. Richard Deahl, Barnes & Thornburg
Mr. Richard Nussbaum, Attorney
Mr. Scott Kidder
Mr. James McCune
Ms. Mariann Masi
Mr. Simon Addicott
Ms. Glenda Gamont
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Approval of Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
Friday, June 25, 2008.
Dr. Varner noted that on page nine of the Minutes,
a statement was made that a commitment of $SOM
has been made to the MIND project. He asked if
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES (CONT.)
A. continued...
that was an action of the Commission, or if the
speaker was mistaken. Mr. Inks responded that
every one keeps throwing that $SOM number
around. Neither the city nor the Commission has
taken formal action to commit $SOM to the MIND
project.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by Dr.
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
Friday, September 16, 2008.
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
REGULAR MEETING OF FRIDAY, JULY 25, 2008
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted July 18, 2008 for approval.
305 FUND SBCDA BOND
C & E Excavating, Inc.
324 AIRPORT AEDA
Wightman Petrie
Wightman Petrie
Wightman Petrie
Abonmarche
Abonmarche
R.E. Pitts & Associates, Inc
Phifer Environmental
Services, LLC
R.E. McCloskey
DNA
South Bend Tribune
SBD Reprographics
The Troyer Group
Abonmarche
Demolition of Former Jefferson Apts.
29,580.00 Complex 332 W. Jefferson
1,700.00 PH I ESA 1007 N Bendix Dr.
1,700.00 PH I ESA 1033 N Bendix Dr.
2,100.00 PH I ESA Bendix
4,600.00 Park One Northwest -Lot 5
2,000.00 US 31 & Adams Road Interchange
Former International Harvester/Pool Table
2,650.00 Doctor
1202 S Lafayette Blvd. PH I Environmental
2,640.00 Site Assessment & Asbestos
1202 S Lafayette Blvd. SB IN (International
2,000.00 Harvester Property)
1,547.00 Eckler-Lahey Site
50.40 Studebaker Corridor Area A South
255.80 Studebaker Corridor
17,835.98 SB-Western Ave. Imp-Walnut-Olive St.
400.00 Bendix Drive Rehabilitation Project
2
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS (CONT.)
324 AIRPORT AEDA continued...
Blackthorn Lift Station Force Main Valve
Selge Construction 26,800.00 Replacement
Material HMA 9.5 MM LS Surface Interm
Walsh & Kelly, Inc. 23,737.53 Clock Tower
PCN, LLC 12,000.00 return performance bond on PH I Carbon Mill
420 FUND TIF DISTRICT-SBCDA GENERAL
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit &
Kaczmarek
DTSB
R.E. Pitts & Associates, Inc.
R.E. Pitts & Associates, Inc.
Wightman Petrie
Meridian Title Corp.
Park Department
422 FUND WEST WASHINGTON
Park Department
1,612.50 Legal Service
29,937.50 Beautification Program
1,750.00 Former Fred's Transmission
6,700.00 Gates Toyota
PH I ESA - 200 & 507 Western Ave & Gates
8,524.00 Bock Boundary Survey
Purchase 373 S William St in Coveleski Pk
64,604.10 Neighborhood
24.00 Seasonal Property Maint.
135.50 Seasonal Property Maint.
430 FUND SOUTH SIDE DEVELOPMENT
Park Department
212.00 Seasonal Property Maint.
433 FUND REDEVELOPMENT ADMIN GENERAL
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit &
Kaczmarek 139.75 Legal Service
619 BLACKTHORN GOLF COURSE
Meadowbrook Goflf Group
Inc 8,000.00 Management Fee-June
$ 253,236.06
Dr. Varner thanked the staff for adding the project
column to the Claims list.
3
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS (CONT.)
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by Mr. Blake
and unanimously carried, the Commission approved the
Claims submitted July 18, 2008, and ordered checks to
be released.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
Mr. Inks noted that a Communication from Linda
Rogers of the Golf Course Owners Assn was directed to
Greg Downes as chairman of the Chamber of
Commerce, but copied to the Commission indicating the
position of the owners association that the city was
competing unfairly with private business by subsidizing
its golf course(s), etc. The letter from Ms. Rogers and a
position paper by the Board of Directors of the Golf
Club Owners Association follows:
July 15, 2008
Mr. Gregory S. Downes
Chairman, Chamber of Commerce
President & CEO, Gibson Insurance Group
130 South Main Street
South Bend, IN 46601
Dear Gregory:
I am the owner of two businesses in St Joseph County
both which are members of the Chamber of Commerce.
I would like to personally thank you for serving as the
Chairman for the year 2008. Also, I see that you are a
member of The South Bend Redevelopment Commission.
I am sure that both positions require a great deal of
time.
Having just renewed my Chamber memberships for both
my businesses, I appreciate your thank you letter. You
made a great statement, "The success of our region is
dependent on visionary leadership and the unity of
business, government, education, labor, not profits and
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS
SUBMITTED JULY 18, 2008, AND ORDERED THE
CHECKS TO BE RELEASED
COMMUNICATION FROM LINDA ROGERS, GOLF
COURSE OWNERS ASSOCIATION
4
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
community combined. "However this does not nor
should it imply government and business should be
competitors.
Currently, the city of South Bend owns and operates golf
courses, banquet facilities and a health club. These
operations directly and unfairly compete with private
owned businesses in St Joseph County. Many of the
cities facilities are not able to stand alone financially
and add a burden to taxpayers and the city's budget.
For the city to operate facilities that the private sector
already provides is un American and goes against the
Free Enterprise System. Not only are we faced with
unfair competition from the government but our
property taxes are used to work against ourselves.
We are forming a coalition of businesses that are faced
with unfair municipal competition and the number of
affected businesses is staggering. As the current
Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce I hope that you
will concur with our efforts.
Because I know that you are in the insurance business, I
would like you to imagine if the city of South Bend
decided that it sounded like a good idea to open an
insurance agency. They would not pay property or sales
tax and would utilize staff from other departments to
implement and administer. Of course they would not be
profit motivated so they could offer premiums much
lower than what the private sector does and could use
tax revenue to subsidize the program. Having been in
business for over 35 years I have never had difficulty
finding great insurance from the private sector at
affordable prices. This example isn't any different than
owning and operating golf courses, banquet center and
fitness facilities.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
As a member of the Redevelopment Commission you
have the responsibility of overseeing Blackthorn Golf
Club. It is a fact that since Blackthorn Golf Club opened
in 1994 it has been a financial drain on the city's
budget, specifically a drain of over four million dollars.
These are funds that could have been used to either
reduce property taxes or to have provided essential
services to 100% of the taxpayers. Golf's participation
rate is at the best 10%, so to ask every taxpayer to
subsidize the recreation of those that golf is completely
unreasonable and not the role of government.
It has come to our attention that the city of South Bend
and the Redevelopment Commission are considering
additional food and beverage space to the clubhouse in
the very near future well as potentially a larger scale
banquet facility. It is a well known fact that large food
operations at golf facilities more often than not add
negatively to the bottom line. To continue to add
additional debt to a facility that is already a financial
drain on the cities budget would be improper allocation
of taxpayer dollars. With the passage of HEA 1001 the
city more than ever needs to be fiscally responsible.
It is my understanding that the golf course was built to
entice businesses to locate in the Blackthorn Corporate
Complex. However, does the city need to own the
facility? Golf Courses are bought and sold everyday and
it only makes good business sense to sell the facility.
This would be beneficial to the city's budget in three
ways, first and most simply, there would be revenue
from the sale, secondly the financial bleeding would
stop and finally, private ownership would be a revenue
base by paying property taxes.
As an Officer of the National Golf Courses Owners
Association as well as our the Indiana Chapter, I
6
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
understand the importance of volunteer leadership and
am very well versed in industry trends and best
practices. Virtually all the best owners and operators of
golf courses are members of the National Golf Courses
Owners Association, which is the largest trade
association of its kind with local, state and national
chapters and international affiliates representing a
membership of more than 6, 000 facilities.
I have enclosed our association's position statement for
your review as well as a financial spreadsheet that
shows Blackthorns cash flow since opening. Net income
numbers are directly from the Profit and Loss
statements provided by the city and the debt service
figures come directly from the enclosed amortization
table.
On behalf of the Indiana Golf Course Owners
Association as Vice President, I am addressing these
issues to you in your capacity as the Chair of the
Chamber of Commerce and a member of the
Redevelopment Commission. It is my understanding that
the Chamber is an organization that strives to promote
free enterprise and create a good business environment
for its members and the Redevelopment Commission is
an integral part of overseeing the Blackthorn Golf Club
operations.
I respectfully request that you and the other member of
redevelopment commission support the fiscally
responsible action of not adding any additional
foodservice amenities at Blackthorn Golf Club and
begin the process of selling the facility. Additionally, we
ask that you also consider selling all the cities facilities
that are in direct competition with private enterprise.
7
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
Sincerely,
Linda L. Rogers
National Golf Course Owners Association, Board
Secretary
Indiana Golf Course Owners Association, Vice
President
cc: South Bend Redevelopment Commission Members
cc: South Bend Common Council Members
cc: St. Joseph County Council Members
cc: St. Joseph County Commission Members
cc: South Bend Mayor Stephen Luecke
cc: cc: St. Joseph County Commission Members
cc: St. Joseph County Chamber of Commerce, President & CEO Mr. Mark
Eagan
Position Statement
PUBLICLY SUPPORTED FACILITIES
ADOPTED BY THE NGCOA BOARD OF DIRECTORS
ONNOVEMBER 22, 2004
The privately-owned member facilities of the National
Golf Course Owners Association (NGCOA) have
consistently demonstrated their concern for public
access to the game of golf. Our members' investment of
time, effort and financial resources is proof of their
commitment to provide access to quality facilities for
golfers in every area of the United States, Canada and
throughout the world.
The NGCOA Board of Directors, having carefully
considered the trends within the golf industry, conclude
that government subsidies, tax abatements, water use
agreements and other types of preferential treatment
result in unfair competition between government-
operatedgolf facilities and privately funded and
operated golf enterprises. The NGCOA Board of
Directors believes that all golf courses should play on a
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
level playing field and object to governmental entities
offering such advantages. The existence of these unfair
advantages disrupts the private enterprise system.
It is our preference that no federal, state, municipal or
other public authority should be involved in direct
competition with private enterprise in the development
or operation of golf facilities. The Board believes such
entities that presently exist should be converted to
private enterprise, if private enterprise is willing to
absorb the business. The only exception to the existence
of government golf competition would be in markets
where municipal golf courses can demonstrate no
negative impact on the privately-owned, free-enterprise
component of the golf market.
With regards to the development of new municipal golf
courses, the Board believes a municipality must first
provide evidence of high demand for a new golf course
in that community. If that demand is proven, private
enterprise should be given the first right to apply for
development and ownership rights for the needed golf
facility. Only when private enterprise is unwilling to
develop a golf course should a municipality consider
getting into the business of owning and operating the
golf course. All tcrx payers of the municipality must be
notified of the development need and that no private
enterprise was willing to build and operate the golf
course.
Up until the mid-twentieth century, municipal golf
played an important role in the growth of the game
through providing affordable access to playing fields. At
that time, the primary alternative to government-
supportedgolf was the private equity golf club, which
was not accessible to the mainstream. With the advent
and development of privately-owned, daily fee golf in
the second half the twentieth century came all levels of
9
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
4. COMMUNICATIONS (CONT.)
Golf Course Owners Assn communication:
affordable access to the game and preservation of open
green space. Due to the involvement of private
enterprise in golf course development and operations,
private enterprise adequately supplies access to the
game of golf throughout the United States and beyond.
The Communication also included a copy of
`Blackthorn Golf Club True Net Income and Cash
Flow" created by Meadowbrook Golf and an
Amortization Schedule of the $5,680,000 Principle
Amount of Lease Rental Revenue Bonds of 1992.
Mr. Inks noted that Dr. Varner has previously suggested
that the city sell (or give away) Blackthorn Golf Course.
The city would consider selling the golf course, except
for its obligation to the outstanding bond issue. As the
balance on the bond is paid down, the city may be able
to consider selling the golf course.
Dr. Varner asked if the payment schedule included by
Ms. Rogers is accurate. Mr. Inks responded that it is
not. Dr. Varner asked that a copy of the current bond
payment schedule be provided to the Commissioners.
Dr. Varner also noted that Ms. Rogers and her husband
own Juday Creek Golf Course, hence their interest in
Blackthorn Golf Course. Dr. Varner stated that he
thinks she makes some good points, tax-wise. Cities
need to consider other options as times change.
Blackthorn Golf Course was supposed to do something
for the Corporate Park It has not. Maybe the city
should sell it.
10
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
5. OLD BUSINESS
A. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) Commission authorization requested to
submit Certified Technology Park
Technology Development Grant Fund
Application.
Mr. Inks noted that staff and Project Future
are still working on this application. He
asked that the item be tabled until the August
1 meeting.
There was no objection. Item S.A(1) was
tabled until the August 1, 2008 meeting.
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2464 approving and
accepting a counter offer for the
acquisition of property in the Airport
Economic Development Area. (1624
Maplewood.
Mr. Witwer noted that the Commission
approved an offering price of $58,500 for the
property. The owners have submitted a
counter offer in the amount of $70,000. Staff
recommends accepting the counter offer.
Ms. Jones asked how the staff considers the
fact that the owners were using this property
for rental income. In addition to losing the
property, they lose the income. Mr. Witwer
responded that that is considered in
recommending acceptance of the counter
offer.
Mr. Leone noted that Resolution No. 2464
approves a form of Warranty Deed as
attached. There are issues with the attached
Warranty Deed. He asked that the resolution
ITEM S.A(1) WAS TABLED UNTIL THE AUGUST 1,
2008 MEETING
11
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
5. OLD BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Airport Economic Development Area
(2) continued...
be approved with a Warranty Deed as
corrected by legal counsel.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2464
approving and accepting a counter offer for
the acquisition of property in the Airport
Economic Development Area, with a form of
Warranty Deed as corrected by legal counsel.
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. Public Hearing
(1) Public Hearing on Resolution No. 2467
confirming a resolution of the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission designating
and declaring an amendment to the
Redevelopment Plan for the South Bend
Central Development Area. (East Bank
Master Plan)
Mr. Inks noted that this is the last step in the
process of adding the East Bank Master Plan
to the SBCDA Development Plan. The
Commission approved Resolution No. 2458
on June 13 designating and declaring the
amendment to the plan. The Area Plan
Commission on June 17and South Bend
Common Council on June 23 each
considered and approved the amendment,
and now it has come back to the Commission
for Public Hearing and confirmation.
Mr. Inks noted that the public hearing file is
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2464
APPROVING AND ACCEPTING A COUNTER OFFER
FOR THE ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA,
WITH A FORM OF WARRANTY DEED AS
CORRECTED BY LEGAL COUNSEL
12
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Public Hearing
(1) continued...
complete, containing: (1) a copy of the notice
of hearing, (2) a copy of Resolution
No. 2467, (3) a copy of declaratory
Resolution No. 2458, (4) a copy of the
Common Council's Resolution No. 3879-08,
a copy of the Area Plan Commission's
Resolution No. 189-08, (5) an affidavit from
the South Bend Tribune that the Notice of
Hearing was published in that newspaper on
July 4, 2008, (6) an affidavit from the Tri-
County News that the Notice of Hearing was
published in that newspaper on July 4, 2008,
(7) a statement from Jitin Kain that on June
26, 2008 affected property owners and
registered neighborhood associations were
sent notice of the public hearing, and (8)
there were no written remonstrances received
related to Resolution No. 2467.
Mr. Paul Phair, Holladay Properties, noted
that Holladay Properties was asked to
facilitate the planning process for the East
Bank and they gladly agreed. This plan is for
Phase I, bounded by Jefferson Blvd., LaSalle
Ave., the St. Joseph River and Hill St.
Howard Park was also included in Phase I,
because no matter what the discussion, it
always came back to Howard Park as a key
component of development in the area.
Phase 2 will be the area south of Jefferson
Blvd.
Mr. Phair noted that the city contracted with
JJR, a consulting firm from Chicago to create
the plan. They came to South Bend several
times, meeting with a total of about 150
13
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Public Hearing
(1) continued...
interested people and stakeholders about
what they would like the East Bank to
become. The purpose of that process was to
create a plan for a mixed use, thriving urban
neighborhood that was realistic enough to be
implemented.
The plan envisions the area between Colfax,
LaSalle, Sycamore and the river as an arts
and culture district. That area already has
many such uses and the participants wanted
to strengthen and expand those uses in that
area.
Hill Street contains some technology and
medical uses. The stakeholders wish to see
more of those uses in that part of the area.
There are pockets of retail on Jefferson at
Niles and near the Niles/LaSalle intersection.
These should also be strengthened and
invigorated.
There are some office buildings at Colfax
and Niles Avenues, and the participants
would like to see some more office buildings
of that size near that intersection.
Finally, the Rink Riverside site and the
Wharf site, right on the river, have potential
to be very special sites. On the Rink site, the
plan shows medium density residential; on
the Wharf site a higher density residential
development, possibly a flag hotel.
Mr. Phair noted that the stakeholders
14
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Public Hearing
(1) continued...
recognized the need for several public
improvements in order to facilitate the
private development: (1) reinvigoration of
the river and the East Race, such as using the
East Race more days out of the summer,
building a pier on the river for fishing,
encouraging boat and canoe traffic and
making the pathways along the river more
friendly to bikers and joggers. (2)
Construction of two 400-space parking
structures. One would be on LaSalle and
Sycamore and the other on Washington and
Niles. In order to support the desired
density, parking structures are needed.
After construction of the parking structures,
other public improvements envisioned are a
facelift of Howard Park and Seitz Park. A
compromise was reached between those who
wanted to leave Howard Park untouched and
those who wanted it totally revamped. The
compromise keeps Howard Park mostly as it
is, with perhaps some additional paths, but
rebuilding the community building around
the corner on St. Louis and rebuilding the ice
rink.
Ms. Jones opened the Public Hearing on
Resolution No. 2467 for whoever wished to
be heard. There was no one who wished to
be heard. Ms. Jones closed the Public
Hearing.
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2467.
PUBLIC HEARING ON RESOLUTION NO.2467
CONFIRMING A RESOLUTION OF THE SOUTH
BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
DESIGNATING AND DECLARING AN AMENDMENT
TO THE REDEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR THE SOUTH
BEND CENTRAL DEVELOPMENT AREA. (EAST
BANK MASTER PLAN
15
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Public Hearing
(2) continued...
Dr. Varner asked how the development of
parking will be tied to actual private
investment. Mr. Inks responded that private
investment will precede the public
investment in the parking garages. The
garages will be demand-driven.
Ms. Jones, who participated in the planning
process, noted that there was a budget
developed along with a timeline to show how
development might create revenue to support
infrastructure for additional development.
Mr. Phair noted that that budget/timeline
anticipated the first parking structure being
constructed in 2009.
Mr. Blake asked if that was just discussion,
or if there is actually a plan for follow-up to
that effect. Ms. Jones noted that Holladay
Properties facilitated the planning process.
They are not the master developer for the
area. The consultant, JJR, saw to it that the
plan was not just idealistic, but that there was
laid out a logical flow of development, tied to
numbers. It isn't cast in stone, however:
until a developer steps up and proposes to
invest, nothing will happen.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by COMMISSION arrxovED RESOLUTION No. 2467
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2467
confirming a resolution of the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission designating and
declaring an amendment to the
Redevelopment Plan for the South Bend
16
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
A. Public Hearing
(2) continued...
Central Development Area. (East Bank
Master Plan)
B. Tax Abatements
(1) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2468 approving an
application for real property tax deduction
for property located at 919 and 923 Notre
Dame Avenue in the Northeast
Neigbhorhood Development Area.
(Richard S. and Micki Kidder)
Mr. Mathia gave the staff report on the
project. The Kidders plan to construct a
2,800 sft single family home with three
bedrooms, three bathrooms, a kitchen, dining
room, laundry room, library, and mudroom.
The cost of construction will be
approximately $415,000. Total taxes to be
abated during the five-year abatement period
are $2,216. Total taxes to be paid during the
abatement period are $21, 976.
The Kidders have received no previous tax
abatements. The property is properly zoned
for the proposed use. The property is located
in the Northeast Neighborhood Development
Area; therefore, it must come before the
Redevelopment Commission for approval.
The project qualifies for a residential tax
abatement under the tax abatement
ordinance.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2468
APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR REAL
PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY
17
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(1) continued...
Commission approved Resolution No. 2468
approving an application for real property tax
deduction for property located at 919 and 923
Notre Dame Avenue in the Northeast
Neigbhorhood Development Area. (Richard
S. and Micki Kidder)
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2469 approving an
application for real property tax deduction
for property located at 225 Garst St. in the
Airport Economic Development Area
(James & Sandra McCune)
Mr. Mathia gave the staff report on the
project. The McCunes plan to construct a
3,600 sft addition to an existing building to
house Mr. McCune's masonry business and
provide more rental space for tenants that
share the building. The addition would be a
steel building with an all-brick front. It will
have 1,350 sft of office space and 2, 250 sft
of shop space. Initial plans call for leasing a
portion of the building until the McCune's
business requires the entire space. The total
cost of the project is expected to be
$203,500. Assuming a four year abatement,
total taxes to be abated during that period are
estimated at $6,507. Total taxes to be paid
on the project during that same period are
expected to be $61,491. The project is
expected to create six new, full-time jobs and
one part time job representing a new annual
payroll of $180,000. The project will also
retain twelve existing permanent full-time
LOCATED AT 919 AND 923 NOTRE DAME
AVENUE IN THE NORTHEAST NEIGHBORHOOD
DEVELOPMENT AREA. (RICHARD S. AND MICKI
KIDDER
18
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(2) continued...
jobs representing an annual payroll of
$350,000.
James McCune has been granted one
previous tax abatement for five years on real
property. The property is properly zoned for
the proposed use. The property is in the
Airport Economic Development Area;
therefore the Redevelopment Commission
must give its approval. The project qualifies
for four years of real property tax abatement
under the tax abatement ordinance.
Dr. Varner asked about the point of the two
schedules of abatement, one showing the
abatement cost under the old state tax law,
the other showing the cost of abatement
under HEA 1001, with its circuit breaker cap.
Mr. Inks responded that staff has done an
analysis of the effects of residential tax
abatement after HEA1001. They intend to
do an analysis of commercial tax abatement
also. In the absence of that analysis, they
wanted to show the difference for each
abatement as it is considered, so included
both schedules.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2469
approving an application for real property tax
deduction for property located at 225 Garst
St. in the Airport Economic Development
Area (James & Sandra McCune)
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2469
APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR REAL
PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 225 GARST ST. IN THE AIRPORT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA (JAMES c4~
SANDRA MCCUNE~
19
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(3) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2470 approving an
application for personal property tax
deduction for property located at 1840 N.
Commerce Drive in the Airport Economic
Development Area (Stanz Foodservice,
Inc.)
Mr. Mathia gave the staff report on the
project. Stanz Foodservice is a full line, full
service distribution business. It uses its
warehouse and distribution facility to store
refrigerated and frozen goods, as well as dry
goods and facilitate the transfer of the goods
to customers throughout northern Indiana and
southern Michigan. This project consists of
the acquisition and installation of new
logistical, distribution and information
technology equipment, including warehouse
racking systems, forklifts, pallet movement
mechanisms, GPS monitoring and tracking
systems, etc. The cost of the proposed
project is estimated between $350,000-
$850,000. Total taxes to be abated during
the five-year abatement period are estimated
at $15,119. Total taxes to be paid during the
five-year abatement period are estimated at
$136,325. The project is not expected to
create additional jobs within the first year,
but will enable Stanz to maintain 162
existing full-time and 9 existing part time
jobs with an annual payroll of $7,251,439.
Stanz Foodservice has been associated with
two previous tax abatements and has one
abatement pending from 2007. The property
is properly zoned for the proposed use. The
property is in the Airport Economic
20
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(3) continued...
Development Area; therefore the
Redevelopment Commission must give its
approval. The project qualifies for five years
of personal property tax abatement under the
tax abatement ordinance.
The petitioners have been granted one
previous tax abatement for five years on real
property. The property is properly zoned for
the proposed use. The property is in the
Airport Economic Development Area;
therefore the Redevelopment Commission
must give its approval. The project qualifies
for four years of real property tax abatement
under the tax abatement ordinance.
Mr. Deahl, Barnes & Thornburg, noted that
this project is an extension of the $6M
project to construct an additional warehouse
approved in 2007. At that time they opted to
not change locations, but to expand at their
existing site and acquire additional land
adjacent to that.
Mr. Blake noted that Stanz Foodservice was
always an active member of the Minority and
Women's Business Association.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2470
approving an application for personal
property tax deduction for property located at
1840 N. Commerce Drive in the Airport
Economic Development Area (Stanz
Foodservice, Inc.)
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2470
APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR PERSONAL
PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 1840 N. COMMERCE DRIVE IN THE
AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT UREA
(STANZ FOODSERVICE, INC.
21
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(4) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2471 approving an
application for real property tax deduction
for property located at 4201 Linden
Avenue in the Airport Economic
Development Area (Foxtrot Realty)
Mr. Mathia gave the staff report on the
project. Items 6.B.(4) and 6.B.(5) are related
and the staff report is combined for both.
Mr. Mathia noted that Foxtrot and GTA
containers requested that the city reconsider
the points awarded to them for real property
tax abatement so that they could qualify for
one additional year of abatement (7 years).
Twenty-nine of their thirty-nine employees
are minority, of which seventeen are from
designated distressed census tracts. They
could earn additional points for those
employees and qualify for an additional year
of abatement. Substitute Resolution
No. 2471 was provided to the Commission at
the meeting to reflect the change to seven
years.
GTA Containers and Foxtrot Realty
Corporation, the real estate holding company
for GTA Containers, are proposing to
construct and equip a 90,000 sft building on
an undeveloped portion of a 20-acre site they
already own. The building will be owned by
Foxtrot Realty and leased to GTA
Containers. The project will enable GTA to
more than double its current manufacturing
capacity, allowing the company to bid on
large, multi-year contracts with the U. S.
Department of Defense, and also have the
22
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(4) continued...
capacity for non-military contracts. GTA
Containers manufactures collapsible pillow
tanks for fuel or water storage. The
containers range in size from 3,000 to
210,000 gallons. The estimated cost of the
building is $2,200,000 to $2,800,000. GTA
containers will own the equipment on the
site. The new equipment to be installed will
have an estimated cost of $250,400. It
includes automatic fabric cutting equipment
and various machines for fabric sealing using
hot air and radio frequency technology.
GTA was recently offered two five-year
contracts from the U. S. Army. They had
been expecting only one. With either one,
they could have handled production in their
existing facility. Winning both contracts,
they need the additional space.
Total taxes to be abated during the seven-
year real property abatement are estimated at
$213,032. Total taxes to be paid during that
same period are estimated at $851,108.
Total taxes to be abated during the five-year
personal property abatement are estimated at
$5,725. Total taxes to be paid on the new
personal property during that same period are
estimated at $81,228.
The project is estimated to create six to
eleven permanent, full-time jobs with an
annual payroll of $160,000 to $260,000. The
project will retain thirty-one existing
permanent, full-time jobs (of which twenty-
nine are minority) with an annual payroll of
23
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(4) continued...
$1,125,000.
Foxtrot/GTA Containers have had four
previous tax abatements. The property is
properly zoned for the proposed use. The
property is in the Airport Economic
Development Area; therefore the
Redevelopment Commission must give its
approval. The project qualifies for seven
years of real property tax abatement and five
years of personal property tax abatement
under the tax abatement ordinance.
Mr. Deahl noted that the U. S. government
has a very tight timetable for when a product
has to be tested in a new facility. The
requirement is that within 120 days after
executing a contract an actual unit has to be
produced from the facility which will be used
to serve that contract. So GTA is under a
very tight timeline for constructing the
facility. City staff has been extremely
helpful in getting these tax abatement
applications processed.
Dr. Varner asked if there is a market outside
of the government for this product. Ms.
Gamont responded that there is, but they
have not developed that market.
Mr. Addicott said they are working on a mine
safety tent. Trapped miners would go into
one of GTA's enclosures containing
pressurized air that would be good for 96
hours.
24
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
B. Tax Abatements
(4) continued...
Dr. Varner thought it would be well worth
their while to diversify and not rely totally on
government contracts.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Substitute Resolution
No. 2471 approving an application for real
property tax deduction for property located at
4201 Linden Avenue in the Airport
Economic Development Area (Foxtrot
Realty)
(5) Commission approval requested for
Substitute Resolution No. 2472 approving
an application for personal property tax
deduction for property located at 4201
Linden Avenue in the Airport Economic
Development Area (GTA Containers)
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Substitute Resolution
No. 2472 approving an application for
personal property tax deduction for property
located at 4201 Linden Avenue in the Airport
Economic Development Area (GTA
Containers)
C. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services in the
South Bend Central Development Area.
(Engineering, NW corner St. Joseph &
Jefferson)
COMMISSION APPROVED SUBSTITUTE
RESOLUTION NO. 2471 APPROVING AN
APPLICATION FOR REAL PROPERTY TAX
DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4201
LINDEN AVENUE IN THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT AREA (FOXTROT REALTY
COMMISSION APPROVED SUBSTITUTE
RESOLUTION NO. 2472 APPROVING AN
APPLICATION FOR PERSONAL PROPERTY TAX
DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 4201
LINDEN AVENUE IN THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT AREA (GTA CONTAINERS
25
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
C. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) continued...
Mr. Schalliol noted that staff requested and
Abonmarche submitted a proposal for a
variety of services related to replats and
vacations at the St. Joseph/Jefferson hotel
site. The amount of the proposal is not to
exceed $5,230. Staff requests approval of the
proposal and requests that the Commission
authorize Don Inks to sign any plats or
documentation related to this work.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
proposal for professional services and
accepted the proposal from Abonmarche in
an amount not to exceed $5,230 for the scope
of services proposed. The Commission also
authorized Don Inks to sign any plats or
documentation related to the replats and
vacations.
(2) Commission approval requested for
Contract Addendum to HOK Sport
facility proposal for Stanley Coveleski
Stadium.
Mr. Schalliol noted that when the contract
with HOK Sport was considered by the
Commission on June 13, there were some
changes the Legal Department asked to be
made. Those changes are addressed in this
Contract Addendum. There were no changes
to the scope of services or contract amount.
Dr. Varner asked when staff anticipates a
report from HOK. Mr. Schalliol responded
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROPOSAL FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AND
ACCEPTED THE PROPOSAL FROM ABONMARCHE
IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $5,230 FOR THE
SCOPE OF SERVICES PROPOSED. THE
COMMISSION ALSO AUTHORIZED DON INKS TO
SIGN ANY PLATS OR DOCUMENTATION RELATED
TO THE REPEATS AND VACATIONS
26
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
C. South Bend Central Development Area
(2) continued...
that once the contract is signed, HOK plans
to schedule a visit in August. They need to
have a gap of three days without games in the
stadium. The next availability for that is in
August.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Contract
Addendum to HOK Sport facility proposal
for Stanley Coveleski Stadium.
(3) Commission approval requested for
proposal for aerial photography services.
Mr. Schalliol noted that staff requested a
proposal from AeroVision Aerial
Photography for aerial photography of the
Coveleski Park planning area. Updated
aerial photography is needed to aid in the
planning process. The proposal is in the
amount of $800. Staff requests approval.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
proposal for aerial photography services and
accepted the proposal from AeroVision
Aerial Photography for the scope of services
and fee proposed.
(4) Commission authorization requested from
Steven Thomas Ministries to use
Commission owned property at 520 S.
Lafayette from August 17, 2008 through
August 30, 2008 for Maximum Impact for
Healthy Families/Healthy Communities.
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CONTRACT
ADDENDUM TO HOK SPORT FACILITY PROPOSAL
FOR STANLEY COVELESKI STADIUM
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROPOSAL FOR AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHY SERVICES
AND ACCEPTED THE PROPOSAL FROM
AEROVISION AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHY FOR THE
SCOPE OF SERVICES AND FEE PROPOSED
27
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
C. South Bend Central Development Area
(4) continued...
Item 6. C. (4) was withdrawn by Steven
Thomas Ministries.
D. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2477 related to acquisition
of property in the AEDA (18 Bendix Dr)
Mr. Witwer noted that Resolution No. 2477
sets the offering price for the carwash in
LaSalle Square at $190,000, the average of
two independent appraisals.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2477
related to acquisition of property in the
AEDA (18 Bendix Dr)
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2478 approving and
accepting a counter offer for the
acquisition of property in the AEDA (18
Bendix Dr.)
Mr. Witwer noted that Resolution No. 2478
approves a counter offer from the carwash in
the amount of $210,000. He noted that the
resolution supplied to the Commissioners in
their packet contained numbers from a
previously used word processing document.
A Substitute Resolution has been provided.
ITEM 6.C.(4) WAS WITHDRAWN
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2477
RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
AEDA (18 BENDIX DR~
28
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
D. Airport Economic Development Area
(2) continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Substitute Resolution
No. 2478 approving and accepting a counter
offer for the acquisition of property in the
AEDA (18 Bendix Dr.)
(3) Commission approval requested for
Second Addendum to Option Contract
with CE Capital Group.
Mr. Witwer noted that the Second Addendum
adds two properties to the agreement, one of
which was omitted in the original agreement,
and one is the hotel site for which the
potential developer made no response by the
June 15 deadline set earlier this summer.
Staff recommends approval of the addendum.
Dr. Varner asked about the lot prices listed in
the contract. Mr. Witwer responded that we
had an assessment done in 2004 of the prices
we were then offering. The prices on the list
now are the result of that assessment. Cressy
will reassess whether the market can support
those prices now and adjust them
accordingly. They will bring a revised list of
prices to the Commission for approval.
Dr. Varner asked whether Cressy & Everett
is strictly the marketer of our property. Mr.
Witwer responded that they have options on
the property as well.
Upon a motion by Dr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
COMMISSION APPROVED SUBSTITUTE
RESOLUTION NO. 2478 APPROVING AND
ACCEPTING A COUNTER OFFER FOR THE
ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE AEDA (18
BENDIX DR.~
COMMISSION APPROVED THE SECOND
ADDENDUM TO OPTION CONTRACT WITH CE
CAPITAL GROUP
29
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
D. Airport Economic Development Area
(3) continued...
Commission approved the Second
Addendum to Option Contract with CE
Capital Group.
(4) Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services in the
Airport Economic Development Area.
(Survey work, Franklin/Lafayette)
Mr. Witwer noted that staff requested a
proposal from Ranch Harner & Associates
for survey work related to surveying in the
MIND area of Studebaker Corridor. The
proposal from Danch Harner is in the amount
of $12,390. Staff recommends approval of a
not-to-exceed amount of $13,600.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
proposal and accepted the proposal from
Ranch Harner & Associates for the scope of
services and fee proposed.
(5) Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services in the
Airport Economic Development Area.
(Appraisals, MIND area)
Mr. Witwer noted that staff requested
proposals for appraisal work related to
acquisition of property in the MIND area of
Studebaker Corridor. Two appraisals are
needed for each property. The appraisals
needed were grouped into five sections on
the map. Each appraiser bid on the various
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROPOSAL AND ACCEPTED THE PROPOSAL FROM
RANCH HARNER & ASSOCIATES FOR THE SCOPE
OF SERVICES AND FEE PROPOSED
30
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
D. Airport Economic Development Area
(5) continued...
sections. Staff recommends Rick Pitts for
appraising all the properties, with the second
appraisals split between Richard McCloskey
(Group C & D) and Ralph Lauver (Group A
B, and E). Total cost of the appraisals is
$53,700.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
proposals and accepted the proposals from
Rick Pitts, Ralph Lauver and Richard
McCloskey for the scope of services and fees
proposed.
E. West Washington-Chapin Development Area
There was no business in the West Washington-
Chapin Development Area.
F. South Side Development Area
There was no business in the South Side
Development Area.
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(1) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2473 related to acquisition
of property in the NNDA (1030
Georgiana)
Mr. Schalliol noted that 1030 Georgiana is
just north of the AAY's Rental property and
is vacant land. The property is owned by
Simon & Wilmae Love. Resolution No. 2473
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROPOSALS AND ACCEPTED THE PROPOSALS
FROM RICK PITTS, RALPH LAUVER AND
RICHARD MCCLOSKEY FOR THE SCOPE OF
SERVICES AND FEES PROPOSED
31
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(1) continued...
sets the offering price for the property at
$8,000.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2473
related to acquisition of property in the
NNDA (1030 Georgiana)
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2474 approving and
accepting a counter offer for the
acquisition of property in the NNDA (1030
Georgiana)
Mr. Schalliol noted that the NNRO acts as
the Commission's agent for these
acquisitions. They negotiated with Simon &
Wilmae Love who have made a counter offer
in the amount of $20,000. That value is
similar to what is being paid for other
properties in the area. Staff recommends
accepting the counter offer.
Ms. Jones asked how the budget for these
acquisitions is holding up with these counter
offers. Mr. Schalliol responded that there is
about $265,000 remaining in this year's
budget. After this round of purchases staff
will determine its acquisition strategy for the
remainder of the properties: whether to go
after the Housing Authority properties, which
have a somewhat negotiated price already, or
to go after the other private properties. The
goal is to clear everything north of St.
Vincent as Phase 1.
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2473
RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
NNDA (1030 GEORGIANA)
32
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(2) continued...
Dr. Varner asked if there is a timetable we
are trying to meet for the project. Mr.
Schalliol responded that we need to get
Phase 1 acquisitions completed this year.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2474
approving and accepting a counter offer for
the acquisition of property in the NNDA
(103 0 Georgiana)
(3) Commission approval requested for
Assignment of Interest in Purchase
Agreement from the Northeast
Neighborhood Revitalization
Organization. (1030 Georgiana)
Mr. Schalliol noted that the NNRO secures
the purchase agreements on the on the
Commission's behalf, then transfers them to
the Commission for purchase. Staff
recommends accepting the Assignment of
Interest in Purchase Agreement.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Assignment of
Interest in Purchase Agreement from the
Northeast Neighborhood Revitalization
Organization. (1030 Georgiana)
(4) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2475 related to acquisition
of property in the NNDA (1136 Duey)
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2474
APPROVING AND ACCEPTING A COUNTER OFFER
FOR THE ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
NNDA (1030 GEORGIANA)
COMMISSION APPROVED THE ASSIGNMENT OF
INTEREST IN PURCHASE AGREEMENT FROM THE
NORTHEAST NEIGHBORHOOD REVITALIZATION
ORGANIZATION. (1030 GEORGIANA~
33
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(4) continued...
Mr. Schalliol noted that this property is
owned by Douglas and Gladys Poindexter.
Resolution No. 2475 sets the offering price at
$8,000. It is also vacant land.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No. 2475
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the RELATED To ACQUISITION of PROPERTY IN THE
Commission approved Resolution No. 2475 NNDA (1136 DUEY)
related to acquisition of property in the
NNDA (1136 Duey)
(5) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2476 approving and
accepting a counter offer for the
acquisition of property in the NNDA (1136
Duey)
Mr. Schalliol noted that the Poindexters have
made a counter offer in the amount of
$18,000. Staff recommends accepting the
counter offer.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No. 2476
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND ACCEPTING A coUNTER OFFER
COmmISSIOn apprOVed ReSOlUtlOn NO. 2476 FOR THE ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
NNDA (1136 DUEY)
approving and accepting a counter offer for
the acquisition of property in the NNDA
(1136 Duey)
(6) Commission approval requested for
Assignment of Interest in Purchase
Agreement from the Northeast
Neighborhood Revitalization
Organization. (1136 Duey)
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED THE ASSIGNMENT OF
Dr. Varner and unanimously carried, the INTEREST IN PURCHASE AGREEMENT FROM THE
COmmisslOn apprOVed the Assignment Of NORTHEAST NEIGHBORHOOD REVITALIZATION
ORGANIZATION. (1136 DUEY
34
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(6) continued...
Interest in Purchase Agreement from the
Northeast Neighborhood Revitalization
Organization. (1136 Duey)
H. Douglas Road Economic Development Area
There was no business in the Douglas Road
Economic Development Area.
L Ratification of Services Contracts
Mr. Inks noted that staff entered into these
contracts since the Commission meeting on
June 25, 2008, according to the direction given by
the Commission.
Commission Contract Staff
Property Description Role Contractor Service Provided Amount Member
Hamilton Towing Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $1,800.00 Witwer
Petrie
Hamilton Towing Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $1,800.00 Witwer
Petrie
Hamilton Towing Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $1,800.00 Witwer
Petrie
Ziolkowski Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $2,300.00 Witwer
Petrie
Ziolkowski Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $1,900.00 Witwer
Petrie
Uzelac Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $2,100.00 Witwer
Petrie
Graf Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $1,800.00 Witwer
Petrie
Waste Management Acquisition Wightman Environ Phase I $2,300.00 Witwer
Petrie
TOTAL $15,800.00
35
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
L Ratification of Services Contracts
Dr. Varner asked about the need for Phase 1
Environmental Assessments. Mr. Inks responded
that that is part of the Commission's due diligence
whenever it acquires property.
Upon a motion by Mr. Blake, seconded by Dr.
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission
ratified the contracts approved by staff since
June 25, 2008.
7. PROGRESS REPORTS
Mr. Inks noted that staff intends to give the Commission
an update on the Douglas Road Development Area
project at the August 1 meeting. There was an article in
the paper several weeks ago that started some questions.
Mr. Inks noted that staff has begun putting the full
Commission packet on the city's Web site at the time
the packet is delivered to Commissioners. He noted that
late information that gets e-mailed to the Commissioners
does not necessarily get posted on the Web.
Mr. Inks noted that staff has also created a folder for
meeting notices that change the normal schedule of
Commission meetings, either canceled meetings or
special meetings, etc. The folder under Boards &
Commissions/Redevelopment Commission is called
Current Notices.
Dr. Varner suggested we also put that notice on the
Mayor's announcement page. Staff will look into how
that can be done.
8. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
Mr. Inks announced a Special Meeting to be held on
July 25, 2008 at 10:00 a.m. (That meeting has since
COMMISSION RATIFIED THE CONTRACTS
APPROVED BY STAFF SINCE JUNE 25, 2008
PROGRESS REPORTS
NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
36
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 18, 2008
8. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING (CONT.)
been canceled.) The next Regular Meeting of the
Redevelopment Commission is scheduled for Friday,
August 1, 2008 at 10:00 a.m.
9. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the
Redevelopment Commission, Mr. Blake made a motion
that the meeting be adjourned. Dr. Varner seconded the
motion and the meeting was adjourned at 11:27 a.m.
_ ~~~~
D~~~:~~..inl~; L~ire~.tbr.
ADJOURNMENT
:.
37