HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024 11-20 Board of Public Safety Meeting MinutesNovember 20, 2024 76
I.EXECUTIVE SESSION
The Board of Public Safety met in the Executive Session on Wednesday, November 20, 2024 at
8:30 a.m. with Board President Dan Jones and Board Members, Darryl Heller (absent), Lee Ross,
Al Kirsits, Pamela Claeys and Attorney Danielle Weiss. Chief Ruszkowski and Attorney Kylie
Connell joined the meeting at 8:47 a.m. The meeting was held at the South Bend Police
Department, 701 West Sample Street, South Bend, Indiana in the Chief’s Conference Room, and
virtually via Microsoft Teams for the purposes specified in I.C. 5-14-1.5-6.1(b)(2)(B) for
discussion of strategy with respect to pending litigation and for purposes as specified in I.C. 5-14-
1.5-6.1(6)(A) to receive information concerning alleged misconduct of an individual(s) over whom
the Board has jurisdiction. The meeting was adjourned at 9:13 a.m.
BOARD OF PUBLIC SAFETY
______________________________
Daniel Jones, Member
______________________________
Lee Ross, Member
______________________________
Al Kirsits, Member
______________________________
Pamela Claeys, Member
ATTEST:
___________________________
Theresa Heffner, Clerk
II. REGULAR MEETING
The Board of Public Safety met for the Regular Meeting at 9:19 a.m. on Wednesday, November
20, 2024, with Board President Dan Jones, and Board Members Darryl Heller (absent), Al Kirsits,
Lee Ross, and Pamela Claey present. Also, Police Chief Scott Ruszkowski, Fire Chief Carl
Buchanon, and Attorneys Danielle Campbell Weiss, Adam Taylor, Kylie Connell, and Board
Clerk Theresa Heffner were all present. The meeting was held at the South Bend Police
Department Auditorium, 701 West Sample Street, South Bend, Indiana, and virtually via Microsoft
Teams at the following link: https://tinyurl.com/2024BPSHybrid
Attorney Weiss asked that everyone mute their microphone when not speaking and reminded
attendees that comments from the public should be saved for the Privilege of the Floor portion of
the meeting. Attorney Weiss then read through the agenda to note any additions or corrections.
A.ROLL CALL OF MEMBERS
Board President Dan Jones welcomed the public, called roll, and confirmed the presence of the
Board Members.
B.APPROVE MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING
Upon a motion by Lee Ross, seconded by Pam Claeys, and carried by roll call, the Board
approved the Minutes of the October 16, 2024, regular meeting.
C.POLICE DEPARTMENT
1.APPROVE HIRING OF PROBATIONARY POLICE OFFICERS
Ian Dale Baker
Ricky Nelson
Colin Michael O’Blenis
Dieter Michael Ruszkowski
Jonathan Blake Phelps
Richard Humbert Springer
November 20, 2024 77
Police Chief Scott Ruszkowski submitted a letter of recommendation for the hiring of the
probationary officers listed above effective November 20, 2024. Captain Kathy Fulnecky
read a brief biography of each officer for the Board Members.
Upon a motion by Pam Claeys, seconded by Lee Ross, and followed by a roll call, the
Board approved the hiring of the probationary police officers.
2.SWEARING IN OF PROBATIONARY POLICE OFFICERS
City Clerk Bianca Tirado administered the Oath which was then followed by
the badge pinning.
3. ACCEPT LETTER OF RESIGNATION – GABRIEL THOM
Police Chief Scott Ruszkowski submitted a letter of resignation for Officer Gabriel Thom.
Chief Ruszkowski stated Officer Thom was sworn into the Department on June 19, 2019,
and his effective date of resignation was November 3, 2024. The Board accepted the letter.
4. ACKNOWLEDGE COMMENDATIONS OF LIFE SAVING AWARD
Zachary Overton
Aaron Omanson
Chief Ruszkowski stated Officer Zachary Overton and Officer Aaron Omanson’s quick
actions and life saving measures saved an individual’s life on September 7, 2024. Chief
Ruszkowski commended their efforts. The Board also commended the officers’ actions and
stated they would be receiving commendation coins.
5.APPROVE LETTER OF RECOMMENDED DISIPLINARY ACTION – DAVID
BOUTSOMSY
Police Chief Ruszkowski submitted a letter of recommended disciplinary action to be
levied against Police Officer David Boutsomsy.
Upon a motion by Lee Ross, seconded by Al Kirsits, and followed by a roll call, the Board
approved Chief Ruszkowski’s letter of recommended disciplinary action.
6.DETERMINE ADMINISTRATIVE LEAVE PAY STATUS PURSUANT TO I.C. 36-8-
3-4(n) – DAVID FINN
Police Chief Ruszkowski submitted a letter asking the board to approve the continuance of
administrative leave and implore the Board’s discretion regarding the paid or unpaid status
of the leave to be effective November 17, 2024.
The Board agreed to change his leave from paid to unpaid due to the charges that have been
brought against him. If he were to be found innocent, his pay would resume retroactively.
7.APPROVE RESOLUTION NO. 03-2024 – ESTABLISHING THE 2025 HOLIDAY
SCHEDULE FOR THE SOUTH BEND POLICE DEPARTMENT
Upon a motion by Pam Claeys, seconded by Lee Ross, and followed by a roll call, the 2025
Holiday Schedule for the South Bend Police Department was approved.
RESOLUTION NO.: 03 - 2024
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF PUBLIC SAFETY OF THE CITY OF SOUTH
BEND, INDIANA ESTABLISHING THE 2025 HOLIDAY SCHEDULE FOR THE
SOUTH BEND POLICE DEPARTMENT
WHEREAS, the Board of Public Safety of the City of South Bend, Indiana, is empowered
by law to establish rules and regulations for the South Bend Police Department; and
WHEREAS, it is in the interest of the City of South Bend that the Police Department
holidays be set with certainty.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of Public Safety of the City of
South Bend:
SECTION I. That for all sworn police officers who are assigned to work as their regular
schedule, Monday through Friday, 5 days on and 2 days off or 4 days on and 3 days off, the
November 20, 2024 78
following holidays shall apply:
New Year’s Day Wednesday, January 1, 2025
Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Monday, January 20, 2025
Memorial Day Monday, May 26, 2025
Juneteenth Thursday, June 19, 2025
Independence Day Friday, July 4, 2025
Labor Day Monday, September 1, 2025
Veteran’s Day Tuesday, November 11, 2025
Thanksgiving Day Thursday, November 28, 2025
Day after Thanksgiving Friday, November 29, 2025
Christmas Day Thursday, December 25, 2025
In addition to the ten (10) designated holidays above, employees may choose one (1)
additional floating holiday subject to South Bend Municipal Code Sec. 2-121 (a), which can be
any day of the employee’s choosing subject to supervisor’s pre-approval.
SECTION II. That for all sworn police officers who are assigned to work as their regular
work schedule, 6 days on and 3 days off, there shall be no paid holidays. The following dates are
designated as Critical Duty Days:
New Year’s Day Wednesday, January 1, 2025
Memorial Day Monday, May 26, 2025
Independence Day Friday, July 4, 2025
Labor Day Monday, September 1, 2025
Thanksgiving Day Thursday, November 27, 2025
Christmas Eve Wednesday, December 24, 2025
Christmas Day Thursday, December 25, 2025
New Year’s Eve Wednesday, December 31, 2025
For purposes of the Critical Duty Day stipend, the Critical Duty Day shall start at 6:00 a.m.,
and last 24 hours.
SECTION III. That officers assigned to the South Bend Community School Corporation
shall, while so assigned, follow the holiday schedule set by the South Bend Community School
Corporation for its clerical employees. Officers so assigned shall be eligible for Critical Duty Day
pay only if assigned temporarily to a regular detail or otherwise eligible.
ADOPTED this 20th day of November, 2024.
s/Daniel Jones, President
s/Lee Ross, Member
s/Alfred Kirsits, Member
s/Pamela Claeys, Member
ATTEST:
s/Theresa Heffner/Clerk
8. APPROVE LEXIPOL POLICIES
316 – Missing Persons
317 – Public Alerts
502 – Vehicle Towing
Attorney Kylie Connell submitted the above Lexipol policies for approval and reminded
the Board Members and the public that the above policies were submitted to the Board at
the October 16, 2024, Board of Public Safety Special Meeting. She noted some of the minor
changes in each of the policies and entertained any questions.
November 20, 2024 79
Upon a motion by Pam Claeys, seconded by Al Kirsits, and followed by a roll call, Lexipol
Policies 316, 317, and 502 were approved.
9. RECEIVE NOTIFICATION OF LESO PROGRAM -NOTIFICATION TO CIVILIAN
GOVERNING BOARD AND LOCAL COMMUNITY
Chief Ruszkowski stated that a lot of people associate this with surplus military which a
lot of it is. The SBPD had a large military mess tent so if there is ever a need for FEMA or
HEMA action, we have that. As far as the LESO program goes, we haven’t used it in
several years, but it’s nice to have if we need it.
10.FILE MONTHLY STATISTICAL ANAYLYSIS REPORT FOR OCTOBER 2024
Chief Scott Ruszkowski submitted the October 2024 Monthly Statistical Analysis Report.
He noted that they had a sixteen percent (16%) decrease in Part One (1) Offenses. He also
added that they had three (3) criminal assault shootings in October. They had a total of fifty
(50)criminal assault shootings all year and eight (8) of those were fatal. That means
firearms were involved.
Pam Claeys noted that rape had gone up significantly and asked why that might be
happening. She also noted that arson has gone up.
Chief Ruszkowski noted that people may be more comfortable coming forward because
they feel safe to do so, unlike in the past. He added that he cannot comment a lot because
the Special Victims Unit handles rape cases. As far as arson goes, it’s a matter of
classification and determination by the fire investigators. He added that the Fire
Department carries the heavy lifting on investigations. This is the time of year that people
are using electric heaters, kerosene heaters, and things like that.
D.FIRE DEPARTMENT
1. APPROVE THE 2025 COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT
Attorney Adam Taylor summarized some key highlights. He noted that the Council handles the
November 20, 2024 80
financial aspect of this, and they have already approved the salary package by ordinance that is
part of this agreement and then the Board of Public Safety is addressing the policies. The things
that are more policy oriented, that's the purpose of the agreement. He addressed the financial
aspects as a reminder for the public. There was a significant wage increase, ten percent (10%), for
most positions in 2025. It is a one (1) year agreement, which means we will be back at the
negotiating table which begins June 25th of next year, so it is coming quick. There is also a
longevity pay increase that was incorporated. The key factor that we are trying to do in this
agreement is move up on what is called the Certified Salary List that the Indiana Pension Fund
puts out. At the time of negotiations, we were at forty-two (42) on that list. The fire department
would be around sixteenth (16th), although other bargaining units rushed to help negotiate in the
area this time. It remains to be seen exactly where we are going to move up to.
Another thing that this contract did was to eliminate firefighter third class, reduce the time it takes
for a firefighter to move up and pay to get to first class, and represents an increase in recruit pay
from $48,000 to $56,000 which represents about a sixteen percent (16%) increase. Those changes
were incorporated within the CBA and that is in Article six (6). We attached an appendix to that
agreement, which includes most of the things that were in the salary ordinance.
Attorney Taylor drew attention to a few key things in the articles, and these are things that affect
really the policies. In article one (1), they referred to a field instructor program. That is something
new that is being rolled out and that is to allow EMS employees to provide training on the
ambulance to new firefighters. That program is viewed as something that is going to really
improve, especially with a lot of new guys that are going to be coming on. In that EMS role they
are going to have to train up a lot of people. Article six (6) he mentioned is new and they changed
it to incorporate the salary ordinance into the agreement in the compensation section.
Attorney Taylor noted the large staffing requirements section. He noted in the section that the
terminology they get used as minimum shift strength and that minimum shift strength number has
always been about sixty percent (67%). That means for any given shift, that is the minimum you
need to make sure that all apparatus’ engines are running. We have staffing shortages right now,
but the Union and City agreed to a temporary measure to try to alleviate some of the mandatory
overtime that that minimum shift strength requires. Minimum shift strength is significant because
once you fall below that number on any given shift, guys from other shifts get mandated and forced
to come work overtime. Obviously, they get paid to work that over time and many guys appreciate
it, but when you are mandating a lot, it gets to be burdensome on the staff. To relieve some pressure
on that, it builds in the ability for that minimum shift strength to be reduced to as low as sixty-one
percent (61%) for any given twelve (12) hour period when there are not sufficient voluntary sign
ups. SBFD employees can still voluntarily sign up to work overtime and we can fill most of those,
but there will likely be situations that arise where they are going to shut down one (1) of those
apparatuses in a way that is thoughtful to make sure that the City is covered. He noted the intent
is not to deprive any area of the city from fire assistance and protection, but there are stations
where there are multiple fire apparatuses where those shutdowns would likely happen. This
temporary provision is incorporated into the agreement, but it has an expiration date of December
30th, 2025. The hope is that a more competitive salary package coupled with aggressive recruiting
efforts will allow this to be something that we can eventually eliminate.
Chief Buchanon stated they want to try to make sure that each of their districts are covered to the
best of their ability. That being said, if they have several different apparatuses at our fire houses,
they will only have one (1) if they had to shut down one (1) of those other apparatuses. He wished
he did not have to shut down any, but they must recognize their staffing shortages. For them not
to have to continue the mandate for personnel to work extensive hours over what they are supposed
to be working, they have to do that. They have to look at shutting down apparatuses for a particular
time period.
Pam Claeys asked if this shutdown would take place for a shift period or for twenty-four (24)
hours. Chief Buchanon stated that it could be up to twenty-four (24) hours, but it may only be
twelve (12) hours and this is what they wanted. They wanted to try to eliminate mandating
personnel to come in on their days off. Firefighters work twenty-four (24) hour shifts, so they don't
have the privilege of going home at five (5) p.m. every day. They work from seven (7) a.m. to
seven (7) a.m. If someone worked a twenty-four (24) hour shift and then they had to also be
mandated for another twelve (12) or twenty-four (24) hour shift, now they are working 48 hours
straight. Some may say, well, they are getting paid overtime, but mental health plays a large part
November 20, 2024 81
in our existence, and it can really take a toll on our employees. We cannot be expecting them to be
their most effective if they are working past the hours that are suitable for them. Unfortunately, in
the fire service it takes roughly six (6) months for us to train a recruit to be able to put out in the
field. The department must also be selective with hiring and vetting recruits, which takes time.
Lee Ross asked when shutting down an apparatus, is that a whole fire house or just a truck. Chief
Buchanon advised that whether it’s a pumper truck or a ladder truck, if an emergency comes, it
will be picked up by another fire station.
Attorney Taylor noted that part of this package also includes double time rather than time and a
half. That will probably increase interest in voluntary overtime, but there is not a good way of
estimating exactly how that will work with that incentive.
Dan Jones asked how much this would cost. Attorney Taylor advised that there was a budget
increase built into this because this is not a budget neutral contract. There was an increase, but
there is an increase in almost every single department in the City of South Bend. He added it cost
more and salaries across the board are increasing. Attorney Taylor noted the fairly conservative
budget increase is because of the reduced personnel. Ultimately there is going to be an increase in
overtime costs, but we are also paying less people, so it kind of balances out.
Pam Claeys asked how many firefighters are part of the union. Chief Buchanon noted that everyone
but the Chief, the five (5) Assistant Fire Chiefs, the six (6) Battalion Chiefs, and the administrative
staff are a part of the union.
Upon a motion by Lee Ross, seconded by Pam Claeys, and followed by a roll call, the 2025
collective bargaining agreement was approved.
2.APPROVE THE RESOLUTION NO. 04-2024 – ESTABLISHING THE 2025
HOLIDAY SCHEDULE FOR THE SOUTH BEND FIRE DEPARTMENT
Upon a motion by Pam Claeys, seconded by Lee Ross, and followed by a roll call, the 2025
Holiday Schedule for the South Bend Fire Department was approved.
RESOLUTION NO. 04 - 2024
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF PUBLIC SAFETY OF THE CITY OF SOUTH
BEND, INDIANA ESTABLISHING THE 2025 HOLIDAY SCHEDULE FOR THE SOUTH
BEND FIRE DEPARTMENT.
WHEREAS, the Board of Public Safety of the City of South Bend, Indiana, is empowered
by law to establish rules and regulations for the South Bend Fire Department; and
WHEREAS, it is in the best interest of the City of South Bend that the Fire Department
holidays be set with certainty.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Board of Public Safety of the City of
South Bend:
SECTION I. That all firefighters who work 24-hour shifts are not entitled to holidays off.
SECTION II. That for all firefighters who work 24-hour shifts, Critical Duty Days are as
set forth in Article 25 of the current Collective Bargaining Agreement which is in force in 2024
per Article 33 of the Agreement.
SECTION III. That all firefighters who are assigned to work a four or five day work week
shall have the following holidays apply, as previously approved by the Board of Public Works:
New Year’s Day (observed) Wednesday, January 1, 2025
Martin Luther King, Jr. Day Monday, January 20, 2025
Memorial Day Monday, May 26, 2025
Juneteenth Thursday, June 19, 2025
Independence Day Friday, July 4, 2025
November 20, 2024 82
Labor Day Monday, September 1, 2025
Veteran’s Day Tuesday, November 11, 2025
Thanksgiving Day Thursday, November 27, 2025
Day after Thanksgiving Friday, November 28, 2025
Christmas Day Thursday, December 25, 2025
SECTION IV. That all firefighters who are assigned to work a four or five day work week
shall have one floating holiday to be taken, upon approval from a supervisor, at the time of their
choosing.
ADOPTED this 20th day of November 2024.
s/Daniel Jones, President
s/Lee Ross, Member
s/Alfred Kirsits, Member
s/Pamela Claey, Member
ATTEST:
s/Theresa Heffner/Clerk
3.FILE MONTHLY STATISTICAL ANALYSIS REPORT FOR OCTOBER 2024
Chief Carl R. Buchanon submitted the monthly statistical analysis report for October 2024.
He stated that the fire index of the incident type breakdown, the number of incidents was
2,160 for October. Another number that stands out is how many times they left the fire
house and that was 6,128 times. Smoke/CO2 alarm detectors for October are pretty steady,
but it could be more because we receive applications for fire alarms daily for residents
needing new smoke detectors or carbon monoxide detectors. Because we are short staffed,
we can not get out there as much as we want to. We do not just pass out smoke alarms to
the public or individuals. We want to make sure that every household has a working one,
so therefore we want a certified firefighter or technician, someone that actually has the
knowledge and experience to be able to install them where they need to be in a home and
we also have them go over a fire escape program with the resident. We do not just give a
household a smoke alarm. We want to make sure that it is properly installed and we want
to make sure that they have an escape plan just in case of a fire.
Pam Claeys noted that only about three percent (3%) of what the Fire Department does is
putting out fires and the rest was everything else they do. Chief Buchanon noted that he
would like to say that that is shrouded to our public education and our fire prevention. They
are out there, their public information officer as well as their fire marshals, inspectors and
investigators, but really credit goes to the entire South Bend Fire Department. Every call
that they go on, even if it is an EMS call, gives them an opportunity to look at that
environment to see if there is some safety component that they need to address. If they are
on a medical call and they notice that the smoke detector appears defective or is non-
existant, they can relay that information to the fire prevention bureau and they send
someone out or at least have someone contact them and see if they can help install one for
them.
November 20, 2024 83
November 20, 2024 84
November 20, 2024 85
November 20, 2024 86
E.DISCUSSION OF TRANSITION TO MERIT BOARDS
Attorney Weiss started the conversation to inform the Board of what is going on and to
answer any questions. She clarified there are still some unknowns at this time, so the
conversation will be ongoing. She advised that a new state law requires that certain units
of local government shall automatically create merit systems for their police and fire
departments, unless the unit and the department members take action to opt out. If not,
you are automatically opted into this merit board system which requires approval from
both the City Council and the Union Memberships. Under this new law, anyone that
November 20, 2024 87
hasn’t already established a merit system for their police or fire department before the
end of the year and has at least twelve (12) full-time, paid members and provides service
to at least 20,000 people will have a merit system established effective January 1st,
2025.
Under Indiana law, the merit boards would be responsible for the hiring, firing,
disciplines, promotions, demotions of police, police officers and firefighters. Currently,
these responsibilities are under the review of the Board of Public Safety. The Police
Department and Fire Department are taking slightly different paths here. The Police
Department, with the support of the Fraternal Order of Police and the Mayor, have
decided to create a merit board ahead of the statute’s December 31st deadline. On
November 13th, there was a proposed ordinance to create the Police Merit Board on the
Common Council's agenda for the first reading, and this would be back before the
Council at its next meeting for potential adoption.
There is a committee meeting tonight for discussion of this at 7:00 p.m. in the County
City Building on the 4th floor. You can attend or listen via teams as well. The Fire
Department, with support from their local union and the mayor, have decided to wait
for the automatic establishment of the Fire Merit Board on January 1st and they will
adhere to the default structure of the Merit Board. There would have to be the selection
of all the Commissioners and then there would have to be an adoption of policies, so
there would be a period of time to get these up and running. In the meantime, the thought
is the Board of Public Safety would continue to function as it until these are fully
operational. After they are fully operational, I think there is still a debate as to what will
happen for the remaining items that are usually under the Board's purview. One (1)
option would be to just keep having those meetings for things like policy updates and
the monthly stats like some of these other things we saw on the agenda today that were
not hiring, promotions, or disciplines. Meetings could be on a less frequent basis which
could be quarterly or as needed. Another option is under state law, there can be a
combined Board of Public Works and Safety. There used to be one (1) Board and then
they were separated some time ago and it could be recombined.
President Jones asked if all the positions would be chosen by Council. Attorney Weiss
stated no, noting that the main difference is the Board of Public Safety members are all
appointed by the Mayor. The Merit Boards would have two (2) selected by the Mayor,
two (2) from the Union membership, and one (1) member chosen by the Common
Council. So, it would be a different makeup of the Board and who appoints them. She
added that she believed there is also a four (4) year term associated with those
appointments. The Board of Safety is just to serve with pleasure, so it can be longer or
shorter than four (4) years if the board member wishes.
Al Kirsits thanked Attorney Weiss for the memo she provided and noted that it explains
everything and is very well done. As it goes forward, there will be two (2) separate merit
Boards, one (1) for the police side, because the people they will choose will probably
be different than the fire side. He asked if they would just combine the leftover items
into the Board of Public Works and Safety. Attorney Weiss advised that what she had
sent to everyone was leaning more in recombining the two (2) boards, but did not know
if that is going to happen. It may be that the Board of safety remains as it is and it just
has limited review.
Pam Claeys asked if the decision is made by the Common Council. Attorney Weiss
advised that there would be a recommendation from the Mayor's office, but it would
require Council approval. The Police Merit Board formation and how that would run is
on their next agenda for approval. She believes there is a first reading for Fire as well.
Attorney Taylor advised that they had talked about that in the past, but the plan is that
there is going to be an ordinance that is read first reading on December 9th that will not
get to final reading until January 2025. The way that the Merit Board statute is written
says it is automatically established, but then the legislation also says it has to be
established by ordinance. We are establishing it by ordinance and the proposed
ordinance is basically going to say that we follow the statute and refer to the statutory
citations. It is also going to say that in the interim, this kind of stopgap measure which
November 20, 2024 88
is built into the police model is that the Board of Public Safety will handle until the
Merit Board is fully convened and functional. The way the Merit Statute is written, the
Commissioners must be appointed no later than March 1st, 2025. We anticipate it is
going to be close to that. The statute says the Board of Public Safety has to give notice
for appointments, so there is a three (3) week notice period. Of the three (3) week notice
period for the membership to vote on their two (2) candidates, there are some time
delays that are built into this that will cause a need for the Board of Public Safety to do
some of these actions. Hopefully, there will not be any disciplines or any other matters
that need to be addressed in the interim, but ultimately we don't know if that will be the
case. It would be ideal if some hiring could be done during that period from January to
April. After they are appointed to their positions, they would have to adopt certain rules
and I think there might be some public hearing requirements, so there are delays that
are built in with all these notice requirements and these other things that have to happen.
Chief Buchanon added that there is a disparity between the Police and Fire. Police had
already submitted their ordinance because of the timeline. He noted Fire did not have
the ability to start having this conversation because of negotiations on the collective
bargaining agreement which took precedence over our time.
Attorney Weiss advised that there is nothing for the Board to really do right now. Since
there has been the first filing of the Police Merit Board ordinance, it has started to bring
public awareness of this.
Chief Ruszkowski noted that the SBPD had a lot of things going on when this came up,
but one (1) size does not fit all. The state is going to do this without any conversation
from an administrative perspective with the FOP in general. The good news is we have
already opted to make the decisions, whether it comes to discipline, hiring, firing, and
promotions. He shared his concerns regarding the community having no input in the
decision. It's not about the ordinance. It's about state law and they are trying to find a
way to maintain the least invasive process of what they have that works. They couldn't
get an answer from anyone downstate. Attorney Connel, our administrative team, and
the FOP tried. They all tried to get some definitive answers on something and there was
nothing definitive.
Ms. Claeys asked how the Civilian Review Board fits into all of this. Chief Ruszkowski
noted that it is just another oversight layer of the proverbial opinion. Attorney Weiss
noted that there's a reference in the Community Review Board ordinance that they
censor reports to the Board of Public Safety. Maybe that would change to the Mayor’s
Board instead, but that is the only reference to the Board of Safety and their structure.
The Board members noted that they have not had anything sent to them from there. They
asked if it was just the recap of their meeting. Attorney Weiss noted that it was from the
first meeting last week.
Attorney Taylor added that he and Attorney Connell tried to keep this very basic. He
stated that the fire perspective on it was always a little different than the police
perspective because the Union was much more in support of this and it makes sense
given that the Professional Firefighters Union of Indiana (PFFUI) was the key. They
were lobbying effort behind the implementation of this. There was a lot more support
on the Fireside Board and I can understand why the state union was in supportive of it.
A lot of that was driven by departments that didn't have as robust of a process.
Attorney Weiss closed by stating that they can continue to provide updates on this topic
once more is available. Some of it is still up in the air right now.
F.PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR
No one was online or in person wanting to speak.
G. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Board, upon a motion by Lee Ross,
November 20, 2024 89
seconded by Pam Claeys, and carried by roll call, the meeting was adjourned at 10:39 a.m.
BOARD OF PUBLIC SAFETY
______________________________
Daniel Jones, Member
______________________________
Lee Ross, Member
______________________________
Al Kirsits, Member
______________________________
Pamela Claeys, Member
ATTEST:
___________________________
Theresa Heffner, Clerk