HomeMy WebLinkAbout2. 1218 East Wayne Street South_COA 2024-0513 PACKETHISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH COUNTY
Phone: 574/235.9371 Fax: 574/235.9021 Email: hpcsbsjc@southbendin.gov
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Date: May 13, 2024
Application Number: 2024-0513
Property Location: 1218 East Wayne Street South
Architectural Style/Date/Architect or Builder:
Tudor Revival / 1928 /
Property Owner: Edward Murphy and Lucetta Pope
Landmark or District Designation: East Wayne Street LHD,
Ordinance #7796-87
Rating: Contributing
DESCRIPTION OF STRUCTURE/SITE: One and a half story frame, irregular plan; gable roof, asphalt
shingles, large front and rear shed roof dormers; brick below first floor sill line; single and grouped 4/1 double hung
sashes, molded wood trim; gable entry, brackets, beam Stucco and half-timbering.
DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED PROJECT: The applicant has requested approval to:
Add a two-story addition onto the back of the home to include:
Demo of the existing bump-out on back of home, patio
Excavation for new approx. 13’6” x 11 ‘5” crawl space addition
Form/pour 10’ wide and 3’6” wide patio steps
Frame a two-story addition with a vaulted ceiling, gable end facing the back yard-tied into existing
Roofing, soffits, fascia, gutters to match existing as closely as possible
Exterior wall finish to be stucco to match the existing
Exterior paint color to match the existing home
New aluminum clad wood patio door and aluminum clad casement windows.
STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES:
New Construction: Pages 33-35.
SITE VISIT REPORT: N/A
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The proposed addition on the rear of the house will not negatively impact the
integrity of the house. It will be minimally visible from the street. Staff makes a FAVORABLE RECOMMEN -
DATION for removal of the Yankee Gutters and replacement with new.
Prepared by
Ross Van Overberghe, Historic Preservation Administrator
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH COUNTY
Phone: 574/235.9371 Fax: 574/235.9021 Email: hpcsbsjc@southbendin.gov
MAP OF THE AREA — Google Maps view of the subject area.
SATELLITE IMAGERY — Imagery from 2024
A. HISTORIC NAME Wilbur E & Edna Sanders
D. ADDRESS 1218 East Wayne South
B. COUNTY St. Joseph C. NUMBER 141 _5.119a 5194
E. TWP/CITY Portage/South Bend F. QUAD NAME
RATING Outstanding Significant/Notable VContributing/Reference Non -Contributing UTM REFERENCES 11 ,61 11 I 1 1 11 I i 1 1 1 1 1 1
STATE OF INDIANA
1. COMMON NAME
2. OWNERSHIP
3. VISIBLE Yes
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Public X_ Private
No
INDIANA HISTORIC SITES AND STRUCTURES INVENTORY
REVISED
1981
4. PROPERTY'S MAILING ADDRESS
Shakour, Gabriel R & Michelle T.
1218 East Wayne South
South Bend, IN 46615
5. LOCATION NOTES
6th building west of southwest
corner of South Sun ys de and Fast
Wayne South.
6. USE
Residence
Govt./Pol.
Commerce
Industrial
Agriculture
Transportation
Organization
Other
PRESENT
0
0
0
0
PAST
0
Military
Entertainment
Scientific
Religious
Park
Museum
Educational
PRESENT PAST
O
O
O 0
0
O 0
0
10. CONDITION
Excellent
Good
Fair
Deteriorated
Ruins
X
11. BUILDING INTEGRITY
Unaltered
Altered
Moved
Date
X Major
11a. Specify Alterations
Removals
Structural
7. ENDANGERED
Vacant
Neglected
Encroachment
Other
SURVEYS
NR NHL
8. CATEGORY
District
X Building(s)
Structure
Site
Object
91. LOCAL LEGAL PROTECTIONS
Historic District
Landmai k
Deed Re;triction
Other
NABS HAER
Replacement Alum. storm windows
Additions 2' extension on side wing
12. DATE-
1928_ 13. STYLE Tudor Revival 14. ARCHITECT/BUILDER
15. DESCRIPTION 12 story frame, irregular plan; gable roof, asphalt shingles,
large front and rear shed roof dormers; brick below first floor sill line; single
and grouped 4/1 double hung sashes, molded wood trim; gable entry, brackets, beam
Stucco and
Facade Material ha -timbering. Inscriptions
16. OUTBUILDINGS i car, 1 door frame__g.arage, stucco, gable roof.
17. — 14TE-P-LA
18. ENVIRONMENT
Residential; a TV tower at Northeast
corner.
19. AREAS OF SIGNIFICANCE: Specify the significance for each area checke 1
Aboriginal
Arts
Architecture
Commerce
Communications
Community Planning
Education
Engineering
Environs/Neighborhoods
Exploration/Settlement
Humanities
Indian
Landscape Architecture
Military
Politics/Government
Religion
Science/Technology
Social/Ethnicity
Transportation
Vernacular/Construction
According to the Assessors cards, this residence was built in 1925,
however, the first resident, Myron & Cletis Harmon, does not appear in the
City Directories until 1928. Whitcomb & Keller had sold the property to
ATTACH
NEGATIVE
ENVELOPE
HERE
Ira E Ruth in 1926, who, in turn, sold it to Charles & Virginia Snolhorger in 1928,
apparently at the time of the construction of the house. The Sn.olbergers rented the property
until it was sold in a sheriff's sale to Prudential Lnsliranre Company in 1935. The property
was vacant between 1935 and 1940 except when Cline T and Joan R Tucker resided in the house
in 1938, renting it from Prudential.
Beginning in 1941 Wilber E and Edna Sanders resided in the house They did not obtain
the deed for it until 1944. Wilbur Sanders was a plant engineer for Bendix Products Corporation
Mr. Sanders was born in Muncie, INdiana in 1892 and came to South Bend in 1940_ Mr. Sanders marrie_
Edna Parker in 1912, she died in 1944, at which time he married Velma C. Minor. He retired as an
executive of the Bendix Corp., in 1963 at which time he became a consultant for them. Mr. Sanders
resided in this house until his death in 1968 at age 75. Mrs. Velma Sanders continued to reside her
e until her death in 1975 at which time the house was sold by executor, First Bank & Trust Cn , to
Other Judith M. Kroc. Ms. Kroc sold the house in 1977 to Thomas E. & Beverly Steinke (OVER)
Descrp. Cont.: raking trim, concrete stoop, brick half walls with concrete cap and metal railings: one story hip roof
with wide eaves, side wing with 2 foot hip roof extension; brick foundation; rear flat roof with balcony above; brick
chimney with metal cap.
Legal Desc.: L149 Sunnymede 1st Key # 18 6108 3845
20. INFORMATION SOURCES South Bend City Directories; Port.ge Township Assessors; peed Records: Book 196, Page 458;
Book 209, Page 518; Book 271, Page 201; Rook 376.; Page 380_
21. SURVEYOR B. Poland
Revised: R. Saunders 9/98
22. DATE September, 1986