Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOpening of Proposals - SRTS Muessel Primary & Holy Cross Proj No 122-006 - AbonmarcheCE SERVICES FOR SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL AT MUESSEL PRIMARY/HOLY CROSS (DES# 1900447) THE CITY OF SOUTH BEND SOUTH BEND, INDIANA NOVEMBER 28, 2023 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross COVER LETTER November 28, 2023 Gemma Stanton, ERC/Project Engineer City of South Bend 227 W. Jefferson Street South Bend, IN 46601 RE: REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS CE Services for Safe Routes to School at Muessel Primary/Holy Cross (DES# 1900447) Dear Ms. Stanton: Here at Abonmarche we believe that all people are entitled to a safe and accessible route wherever they may travel throughout the City, especially to and from school. These intricate and detailed projects are where the plans of the City meet the realities and unknowns of the real world. All public works projects contain challenges and unknowns that must be managed through the construction inspection process. How this process is managed is the key to controlling the project construction timeline and budget as well as ensuring that the projected overall life expectancy of the improvements are met. We employ a few very basic tenants to the process of construction inspection and oversight for our clients: 1. Be engaged, firm and fair with contractors and convey our expectations. 2. Be great communicators: provide timely project information to our client as well as the contractor. 3. Be a part of the solution to address any challenges that arise. We hope our proposal demonstrates that the team we have assembled has the construction experience, along with the technical knowledge and support staff, to successfully oversee the construction of this project for the City. We believe our qualifications, team, and our firsthand experience with Safe Routes to School Projects set us apart. We hope you agree and look forward to working with you on this great project. If you have any questions or concerns regarding this proposal, please do not hesitate to contact our office at (574)232-8700. Sincerely, Abonmarche Consultants, Inc. John W. Linn, PE Principal & Chairman of the Board Robert A. Nichols Transportation Development Manager 2 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross FIRM INTRODUCTION Over 44 years ago, Abonmarche began shaping communities in the Midwest by offering surveying, civil engineering, and marina development services. As our services, client base, and geographical reach grew, we expanded our offices to better serve our clients and maintain our commitment to customer service. Today, our team of 235 employees operates from 11 offices, undertaking transformative projects in the region. Our expertise spans engineering, architecture, land surveying, site development, landscape architecture, coastal and waterfront development, planning, financing strategies, and digital solutions. Through our comprehensive range of professional services, we deliver exceptional value to private and public-sector clients, often assisting with grant and loan applications in collaboration with state funding agencies. Rather than dictating to our clients, we collaborate closely with them to understand their objectives and aspirations. Leveraging our technical and creative skills, we help create remarkable places. Our principals and staff bring their best to every project, irrespective of its size. We continuously refine our work processes and enhance our teams’ skill sets to ensure top-notch service for our clients. Our strategy involves forming expert project teams that offer effective communication, innovation, and customer service, backed by knowledge and experience. We approach each project with our clients’ best interests at heart, aiming to become true partners throughout its duration. Our business strategy revolves around fostering long-term client relationships. Throughout our proud history, we have earned and maintained clients through the delivery of exceptional customer value. In fact, a significant portion of our work comes from repeat business with loyal clients. ROBERT A. NICHOLS Project Manager HODGE PATEL Client Champion GEMMA STANTON Project Engineer JAMES “JD” MCPHAIL Lead Inspector TRACY MCCORMICK Project Inspector CHAD MARTENSEN Project Inspector JOHN BEER Project Inspector abonmarche.com Engineering Architecture Land Surveying Digital Solutions Landscape Architecture Coastal & Waterfront Planning Site Development Financing Assistance RESPONSIBLE OFFICE ABONMARCHE 315 W. Jefferson Blvd. South Bend, IN 46601 abonmarche.com CONTACT Robert A. Nichols II Transportation Development Manger 574.232.8700 rnichols@abonmarche.com MICHIGAN BENTON HARBOR KALAMAZOO GRAND HAVEN GRAND RAPIDS INDIANA SOUTH BEND VALPARAISO GOSHEN LAFAYETTE HOBART FORT WAYNE 3 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross TEAM OVERVIEW EDUCATION Purdue University Bachelor of Science, Civil Engineering PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS American Society of Civil Engineers Northern Indiana Chapter Past President Former Member American Public Works Association Indiana Chapter, Former Member Indiana Water Environmental Association, Former Member ROBERT A. NICHOLS II TRANSPORTATION DEVELOPMENT MANAGER Rob has over 15 years of combined experience serving both public and private clients. Throughout his career, he has been responsible for the design and administration of projects ranging from $25K to $25 million. Rob’s specialties include design oversight and management of subdivision design and layout, stormwater management, storm sewer sanitary sewer, water main, traffic signals, and other roadway safety improvement projects. In addition to design, Rob’s experience allows him to aid in the management of the construction of projects by providing conflict resolution, schedule management, and oversight of the adherence to project plans and specifications. AREAS OF EXPERTISE: PROJECT MANAGEMENT As project manager, Rob’s priority is understanding the client’s goals and managing the project’s schedule, budget, and Abonmarche staff in such a way that the client’s goals are achieved efficiently, on time, and on budget. Communication between the client and members of the team is key as is understanding what it takes to accomplish a successful project. • South Bend International Airport, FedEx Terminal Manhole Repair, South Bend, IN • Woodford Trails Subdivision, St. Joseph County, IN • Clover Hills Subdivision, St. Joseph County, IN • VA Outpatient Clinic, Benton Harbor, Michigan • Autumn Ridge, Phases 3 and 4, Mishawaka, IN • State Road 19 Corridor Enhancement , Elkhart, IN • Old Cleveland Road Turn Lane Construction, St. Joseph County, IN • Poppy Road Speed Study, St. Joseph County, IN MUNICIPAL AND DOT CONSTRUCTION EXPERIENCE Rob’s experience in municipal engineering includes project management of roadways, water main, sanitary and storm sewer construction projects. Rob has successfully managed the construction process and mediated between subcontractors, municipality/State, residents and business owners during construction on many of the projects listed below. • IR-30143 US 31 Tie Ins, Marshall/St. Joseph County, Indiana • IR-30087 US 33 Relocation, Goshen, Indiana • B-32110 Prairie Street over NSF Railroad, Elkhart, Indiana • R-37645 and R-38157 Kercher Road Reconstruction, Goshen, Indiana • SR 19 Corridor Improvements, Elkhart, Indiana • CR38 Reconstruction, Elkhart County, Indiana • R-39468 PCCP Patching of US31, St. Joseph County, Indiana 4 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross TEAM OVERVIEW EDUCATION High School Graduate CERTIFICATIONS Project Engineer / Supervisor (INDOT) Site Manager Training (INDOT) HMA Field Supervisor Certification (INDOT) Certified Construction Technician (INDOT) Storm Water Manager (INDOT) OSHA 10-hour Safety Training ACI Concrete Field Testing— Level 1 Certification JAMES (JD) MCPHAIL CONSTRUCTION MANAGER James has over ten years of experience in field operations and construction oversight. His responsibilities at Abonmarche include construction inspections, progress meetings, pay estimates, schedule oversight, record keeping, stakeholder communication, construction staking, utility as-builts, and construction administration. AREAS OF EXPERTISE: CONSTRUCTION INSPECTION Southwood Sewer Separation - South Bend, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $2.500,000 project that included new storm sewer and drainage improvements, utility coordination, and new roadway, curb and sidewalks. Mishawaka Traffic Safety Plan & West Vestibule - Mishawaka, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $3.2 million project over seeing all aspects of the construction. This project included the construction of multiple new parking lots, drop off area, new grand entrance into the school. Ensuring ADA accessibility and safe traffic routes for all school traffic. Bremen Highway Added-Travel Lanes Project - Mishawaka, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $3.5 million project over seeing all aspects of the construction and overseeing other inspectors. Mishawaka Sidewalk Replacement Project - Mishawaka, IN JD was the Construction Technician for this $360,000 CDBG funded project that replaced 2,600 lft of sidewalks in an aging neighborhood in Mishawaka. The project also included removal and replacement of twenty (20) sidewalk ramps to comply with ADA standards and included removing trees that were determined to cause sidewalk upheaval. JD worked with engineering staff to determine the limits of construction and worked to save existing residential retaining walls in order to minimize the project costs while maximizing the amount of sidewalk that was replaced. JD also observed construction operations, measured and tracked project quantities, reviewed, and processed pay estimates, processed change orders, led progress meetings, and prepared final construction records. Wild Cherry Ridge Roadway Improvements - Mishawaka, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $600,000 project. La Porte Sidewalk Project - La Porte, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $420,000 sidewalk project over seeing all aspects of the construction. The project included replacement of over 20 sidewalk ramps and over 6,500’ of sidewalk. Fir and Brick Roundabout - Granger, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $880,000 project over seeing all aspects of the construction and overseeing other inspectors. This project included the construction of a roundabout at the busy intersection of Fir Road and Brick Road in northern St. Joseph County to alleviate traffic back ups from the previous 4 way stop intersection. CR 17 Improvements - Elkhart County, IN JD performed the role of primary construction inspector for this $800,000 project that included new roadway construction, earthwork, and associated improvements. 5 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross TEAM OVERVIEW CERTIFICATION/TRAINING MDOT Density Technology Certification Storm Water Operator Certification MDOT Prevailing Wage Training Michigan Concrete Field Testing, Level 1 MDOT Bituminous Paving Operations Certification MDOT Materials Acceptance CHAD MARTENSEN CONSTRUCTION TECHNICIAN Chad has performed construction inspection services and material testing on municipal and MDOT roadway construction projects. His inspection services include HMA paving projects and concrete replacement. Chad completes paving inspection including depth and grade checks on cold milling, completing In-Place Nuclear Density Testing during HMA placement, verifying HMA yield calculations and temperature checks. During concrete inspection, Chad checks forms and elevations on curb and gutter, sidewalk ramp construction, and performs concrete material testing utilizing MDOT forms 1999 and 1174. Utilizing FieldBook software on his IDR’s, Chad reports all HMA paving results, tracks and documents contract quantities and tracks materials. After joining Abonmarche in 2018, Chad continues to gain valuable experience that will allow him to contribute construction services for numerous state and municipal clients. AREAS OF EXPERTISE: TRANSPORTATION US-12 Cold Milling and Resurfacing - Washtenaw County, MI Chad completed construction technician and paving inspection services on 3.67 miles on US-12. The project included cold milling and HMA resurfacing, centerline and shoulder corrugations. Chad provided contractor oversight, construction inspection, traffic and safety inspection measuring and documenting pay items, and performed QA material testing. HMA paving inspection included collecting HMA tickets and verified yields and depth checks, laying out and witnessing QC coring sampling, a preparing and submitting supporting documentation. Chad assisted the primary senior field engineer on this project working completing all project documentation and testing in accordance with MDOT specifications using FieldBook software for his IDR. Local Streets Resurfacing Project - Portage, MI Chad is completing lead inspector duties for the City Portage Local Streets Resurfacing project that combined two (2) fiscal years into one construction season. The project included sidewalk ramp replacement, utility replacement, retaining wall construction, and placement of 16,600 tons of HMA resurfacing. Chad completed in-place density Testing on HMA placement utilized a Troxler density gauge, collected HMA tickets and verified yields, performed concrete QA testing standard field tests and casting of concrete cylinders. On full pavement replacement sections on the project, he performed in-place density tests to verify compaction efforts on aggregate base materials met standards and specifications. He completed all documentation and testing in accordance with MDOT specifications using FieldBook software for his IDR. M-51 Two-course Asphalt Resurfacing - Berrien County, MI Chad assisted during HMA paving inspection on M-51 during the paving operations from the Indiana State line to Chestnut Lane. The project included cold-milling, two-course asphalt resurfacing, concrete joint and crack repairs, isolated drainage structure repairs and replacement, and sidewalk. He also provided inspection of coring and sampling locations and provided density testing on asphalt paving. 6 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross SUB-CONSULTANT INFORMATION MCCORMICK COMPANY OVERVIEW McCormick Engineering, LLC officially began on January 1, 2008 with one goal in mind: to provide outstanding customer service to the public sector. We are passionate about helping our clients provide improved quality of life to the general public through a variety of projects. McCormick Engineering, LLC is a Certified Women-owned Business Enterprise (WBE) through the Indiana Department of Administration, Minority and Women’s Business Enterprises Division as well as a certified Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) through the Indiana Department of Transportation. TRACY MCCORMICK, PE Engineer experienced in the planning, design and construction observation of civil engineering projects. Co- founder of McCormick Engineering, LLC, a firm recognized by the State of Indiana as a Women’s Business Enterprise (WBE) and Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE). PROFESSIONAL REGISTRATION AND CERTIFICATION • Professional Engineer - Indiana 19800331 • Indiana Department of Transportation Certified Technician • Indiana Department of Transportation SiteManager Certificate of Proficiency • Indiana Department of Transportation Construction Storm Water Certification EMPLOYMENT HISTORY • McCormick Engineering, Co-founder & Partner - South Bend, IN ◦Present - 2008 • Christopher Burke Engineering, Design Engineer - South Bend, IN ◦2008 - 2004 • Town Plan Commission, Commissioner - Brownsburg, IN ◦2003 - 2001 JOHN BEER Experienced senior construction technician with 30 years in the construction industry. Observation experience includes performance of material testing, monitoring daily construction activities and preparing Daily Work Reports for roadway reconstruction, bridge deck replacement and telecommunication fiber installation projects. PROFESSIONAL REGISTRATION AND CERTIFICATION • Indiana Department of Transportation Certified Technician • Indiana Department of Transportation SiteManager User • OSHA 10-Hour Training for Construction Industry • Indiana Certified Residential Appraisers License • Indiana Level II Assessor Certificate PROJECT EXPERIENCE • INDOT On-Call, US 24 Bridge Bundle, Fulton County, Indiana • INDOT On-Call, US 31 Reconstruction, St. Joseph County, Indiana • INDOT On-call, SR 49 Bridge Bundle, Porter County, Indiana • INDOT On-call, I-69 Bridge over Robinson Creek Reconstruction, Fort Wayne, Indiana • Coal Line Trail, St. Joseph County, Indiana • Olive Street Reconstruction (2 phases), South Bend, Indiana • Indiana Toll Road Concessions, ITS Phase II, Lake, Elkhart, LaGrange & Steuben County • Handley Elementary Safe Routes to School, LaPorte, Indiana • Bendix Drive Reconstruction, South Bend, Indiana 7 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross PROJECT UNDERSTANDING & APPROACH PROJECT UNDERSTANDING Muessel Elementary School and Holy Cross School lie in the Near Northwest Neighborhood northwest of downtown South Bend. The project area is bounded by LWW on the south, Allen Street to the east, Vasser Street to the north and Wilber on the west. The neighborhood is well connected regionally with the newly constructed Coal Line Trail that makes it way (currently) from LWW all the way to the University of Notre Dame along the former rail spur used to deliver coal to the power plant at Notre Dame. There is a dedicated bike lane and pedestrian paths along Lincolnway West on the south that connect the downtown and all neighborhoods along LWW to the South bend International Airport. East of this neighborhood is the locally well-known Riverside Trail that follows the St. Joseph River all the way from Niles, Michigan east to Elkhart and beyond. These regional trails highlight the importance of accessible and safe pedestrian access for all students and residents within these project limits. Not only will the project allow access to the schools and parks in the area, it will also allow the opportunity for all residents an accessible route to the regional trail systems that connect to the other areas of South Bend and beyond. Abonmarche Consultants is intimately familiar with the City of South Bend’s vision for safe and accessible routes for mutlitmodal transportation. We recently designed the newly constructed Lincolnway West Streetscape projects that provide the first dedicated separate bike and pedestrian paths, within the City, adjacent to Lincolnway West. PROJECT APPROACH We have tailored our scope of services based on the requirements of the RFP, our first hand experience with the design of SRST projects, and our extensive history and experience working in the City of South Bend and with INDOT. Abonmarche’s team is creative, innovative, and most of all very experienced with all aspects of INDOT construction projects. Our Project Manager, Rob Nichols, brings his extensive knowledge of construction on INDOT projects as a contractor now to the inspection side. He managed the successful completion of the Olive and Sample Street Overpasses, IR-30143 US 31 Connection on the south side of South Bend, the 2 Way Downtown Street Conversion project, and the Riverside Trail Project along the river NW of downtown South Bend. His in-depth experience of the INDOT process and public works construction will be invaluable in administering and providing oversight on these inspection projects. PROJECT INITIATION AND PRE-CONSTRUCTION Prior to initiating a kick-off meeting with the City of South Bend our Project Manager and INDOT certified construction inspection staff will do a thorough review of the bidding documents (plans and specifications) and pair it with a detailed site visit of the project area. After our review of the site, we will coordinate an inspection kick-off meeting with the City to discuss all aspects of the project prior to having a pre-construction meeting. We will use this meeting as a chance to discuss any potential subjects pertinent to the construction so that they may be addressed at the pre-construction meeting. Only then will be schedule the pre-construction meeting with all required parties for commencement of construction. We expect to have a pre-construction meeting within two weeks of the Notice to Proceed of the Construction contract. CONSTRUCTION PHASE Upon commencement of construction Abonmarche and McCormick Engineering will monitor, as necessary, the contract with a full-time Resident Project Inspector (RPR). Depending on the controlling operations of the construction other full-time inspectors may be added. In addition to the Inspector(s) the RPR will oversee and be available to answer any questions or issues that may arise during the regular course of daily construction. And overseeing the entire inspection contract will be the Project Manager. He will guarantee overall contract compliance and ensure a more than adequate amount of inspection and documentation is always taking place during construction. He will also provide the final QA/QC effort for all construction documentation generated for the project. If disputes with contract documents arise during the course of construction Abonmarche will ensure that all change order requests, and other such disputes are handled per INDOT’s very 8 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross PROJECT UNDERSTANDING & APPROACH clear and structured process. This process, when followed and administered correctly, will ensure contract compliance per all INDOT and FHWA requirements. This process protects the LPA and ensures that the contract is delivered in accordance with all requirements – Local, State and Federal. ALWAYS BE PART OF THE SOLUTION/PROBLEM SOLVERS PROACTIVE APPROACH Our past successes are based upon our attention to detail and our ability to look ahead and anticipate problems. Our Project Manager’s extensive project construction experience will allow us to proactively manage any potential questions and ensure that additional cost increases or time delays are minimized. Additionally, our staff understands the importance of providing timely solutions so that costly delays are avoided. We will draw on our experience to solve these issues with expert technical backup to apply engineering principles to provide creative solutions. This approach will allow us to stay abreast of any potential issues and ensure timely and cost-effective delivery of the project. 9 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross PROJECT EXPERIENCE PORTAGE PRAIRIE/AMERIPLEX SOUTH BEND, INDIANA CLIENT Holladay Properties CONSTRUCTION $100+ million Abonmarche provided planning and concept design for 500 acre, mixed-use project. Proposed land uses include light industrial, distribution, logistics, medical, office, commercial, retail, lodging, and residential sites. Multi-use paths were designed throughout the site to interconnect all amenities and properties. This site design minimized environmental impacts, using Low Impact Development (LID) techniques, without escalating costs. The storm water management system incorporated bio-swales (instead of large diameter pipes) and a series of bio-retention basins. The initial phase of this project included 2,800 feet of new roadway and other amenities that include ornamental lighting, sculpture nodes along the walking paths, and extensive native prairie landscape plantings that provide an interface between the roadway edge and the walking path. Abonmarche continues to provide planning, landscape architecture, engineering design and construction management for this project. U.S. 31 INDUSTRIAL PARK SOUTH BEND, INDIANA CLIENT City of South Bend CONSTRUCTION $2+ million For this project, Abonmarche was contracted to oversee the development of an 80-acre rural site, which would be home to new facilities for several trucking and distribution companies. These facilities had to be constructed on an accelerated time schedule. The most unique aspect of the project involved building the infrastructure during the same time period as construction of two trucking facilities was taking place - on the same site. Careful coordination and communication were required to complete the project on time and within budget. Abonmarche prepared all engineering plans for the project, which included roadways, retention basins, storm sewer, sanitary sewer, water main, a new regional lift station and all roadway lighting. The new lift station now services an area approximately 800 acres in size.10 Proposal for City of South Bend - Muessel Primary/Holy Cross PROJECT EXPERIENCE 9TH STREET MULTI-USE PATH GOSHEN, INDIANA This project created a multi-use path from College Avenue to Purl Street, providing improved pedestrian and bicycle access to both Goshen High School and Goshen College. Abonmarche’s role of construction inspection and administration involved ensuring the workmanship and materials were in accordance with INDOT standards. CLIENT City of Goshen CONSTRUCTION $180,000 (Construction Inspection & Administration) HIGHLIGHTS • Construction Inspection and Administration • Client Communication Coordination • Quality Assurance • Public Engagement EAST DIVISION STREET PHASE II DEMOTTE, INDIANA This second phase federal-aid LPA project included CE-1, topographic survey, route survey, a 46 parcel land acquisition, hydraulic design, utility relocations and road design for one mile of Division Street in DeMotte. This street is a major east/west corridor linking a residential area with the business district. The 18-foot road was replaced with two 11-foot lanes and 3-foot bituminous shoulders. CLIENT Town of Demotte CONSTRUCTION Phase I $700,000 Phase II $1.5 million HIGHLIGHTS • Environmental Assessment CE-1 • Topographic & Route Surveys • Land Acquisition • Hydraulic Design • Road Design • Construction Administration IRON HORSE HERITAGE TRAIL PORTAGE, INDIANA This project was designed to improve access to the parks and create more recreational opportunities. The design features a 1,700 foot long, 12 foot wide asphalt multi-use trail with painted cross walks at Portage Avenue and Hamstrom Road. CLIENT City of Portage CONSTRUCTION $180,000 HIGHLIGHTS • LPA Design & Construction Engineering • 1700 Linear Foot Path on Old Railroad Bed • Improved ADA Accessibility • Topographic Survey • Comprehensive Field Investigation & Analysis 11 OTHER DOCUMENTS Standard RFP Form Ver. 1/2023 6 (Rev. 06/27/18) Des. #: 1900447 Affirmative Action Certification (AAC) for Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBE) I hereby certify that my company intends to affirmatively seek out and consider Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBEs) certified by the State of Indiana’s DBE Program and the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet (KYTC) DBE Program to participate as part of this proposal. An Agreement between INDOT and KYTC established reciprocal acceptance of certification of DBE firms in their respective states under the Unified Certification Program (UCP) pursuant to 49 CFR §26.81(e) and (f). I acknowledge that this certification is to be made an integral part of this proposal. I understand and agree that the submission of a blank certification may cause the proposal to be rejected. I certify that I have consulted the following DBE websites to confirm that the firms listed below are currently certified DBEs: INDOT: https://entapps.indot.in.gov/DBELocator/ KYTC: https://transportation.ky.gov/Civil-Rights-and-Small-Business-Development/Pages/Certified-DBE-Directory.aspx I certify that I have contacted the certified DBE’s listed below, and if my company becomes the CONSULTANT, these DBEs have tentatively agreed to perform the services as indicated. I understand that neither my company nor I will be penalized for DBE utilization that exceeds the goal. After contract award, any change to the firms listed in this Affirmative Action Certification to be applied toward the DBE goal must have prior approval by INDOT’s Economic Opportunity Division. I. DBE Subconsultants to be applied toward DBE goal for the RFP item: Certified DBE Name Service Planned Estimated Percentage to be Paid* % % % % II. DBE Subconsultants to be utilized beyond the advertised DBE goal for the RFP item: Certified DBE Name Service Planned Estimated Percentage to be Paid* % % % % Estimated Total Percentage Credited toward DBE Goal:___________ Estimated Percentage of Voluntary DBE Work Anticipated over DBE Goal:__________ Company Name: ____________________________________________________________________ Signature: ___________________________________________ Date: ________________________ ∗ It is understood that these individual firm percentages are estimates only and that percentages paid may be greater or less as a result of negotiation of contract scope of work. My firm will use good faith efforts to meet the overall DBE goal through the use of these or other certified and approved DBE firms. McCormick Engineering Abonmarche Consultants, Inc. 11/28/2023 Construction Inspection 3 3% 3%