Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOpening of Proposal - Safe Routes to School - Muessel Primary and Holy Cross Area Proj No. 122-006 - Abonmarche CITY OF SOUTH BEND SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL — MUESSEL PRIMARY AND HOLY CROSS SCHOOL AREA Des # 1900447 in LaPorte District February 22, 2022 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING COVER LETTER February 22, 2022 Mr. Finnian Cavanaugh, Project Engineer City of South Bend 227 W. Jefferson Blvd. South Bend, IN 46601 RE: REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS – PE Services for Safe Routes to School—Muessel Primary and Holy Cross School Area (Des #1900447) Dear Mr. Cavanaugh: Walkways and sidewalks are important amenities for our communities and neighborhoods. These sidewalks interconnect our neighborhoods and provide convenient routes to church, school, shopping, and human services. Safe and convenient sidewalks provide opportunities for neighbors to interact and access neighborhood amenities, while promoting a healthy lifestyle and benefiting our environment. Safe Routes to School Projects focus on safe and non-discriminatory access to our neighborhood schools. While sidewalk construction is relatively simple in comparison to other public works projects, they contain many pitfalls and challenges, especially when INDOT is involved, that must be managed through the design and approval process. As outlined herein, we have assembled our team based upon the needs of the City and the Neighborhood. I will serve as the Project Manager for this assignment and Zach Hauersperger will serve as the Project Engineer. We will use our experience with similar projects, our experience with INDOT, and our local understanding to anticipate the challenges of this project and work with the City to manage them successfully. We hope you agree and engage our Team for this assignment. We appreciate your consideration of our Team’s qualifications and look forward to working with the City of South Bend on this and many future projects. Sincerely, ABONMARCHE CONSULTANTS, INC. Chad Knip, PE Project Manager cknip@abonmarche.com 574.314.1018 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING COMPANY INTRODUCTION South Bend, IN Goshen, IN Valparaiso, IN Hobart, IN Fort Wayne, IN Lafayette, IN Benton Harbor, MI Grand Haven, MI Battle Creek, MI Civil Engineers Architects Land Surveyors Marina/Coastal Engineers Transportation Engineers Landscape Architects Structural Engineers Planners LOCATIONS Abonmarche began shaping communities for the better 42 years ago in the Midwest, providing clients with surveying, civil engineering, and marina development services. As our services, client base, and geographical service area expanded, Abonmarche continued to grow, opening additional offices to better meet our clients’ needs and carry on our tradition of client service. Today, we work across 9 offices on some of the most transformative projects in the region – in engineering, architecture, land surveying, site development, landscape architecture, coastal & waterfront, planning, financing strategies, and digital solutions. Through our wide array of professional services, providing superior customer value, and improving communities for a variety of private- and public-sector clients. This often includes grant and loan applications in coordination with state funding agencies. Rather than telling our clients what to do, we work closely with them to understand what they need to accomplish and what they hope to achieve. Then, we put our expert technical and creative skills to work – helping you create exceptional places. We harness the talents of our principals and staff so that we're bringing our best to each project - no matter the size. We are constantly honing our work processes and advancing our teams' skillset, so that our clients are always getting the best. Our strategy is to form a skilled project team that will add value to your project by providing excellent communication, ingenuity, and customer service paired with knowledge and experience. We undertake every project with our client’s best interests in mind and truly seek to become partners during the course of the project. Our business strategy is centered upon building long-term client relationships. During our proud history, we have attracted and retained clients by providing superior customer value; in fact, the majority of our work is repeat business from loyal clients. 1 CHAD KNIP, PE Project Manager DARYL KNIP, PE QA/QC ZACH HAUERSPERGER Project Engineer RITA ANN GABRIEL 12.5 Appraisal Review CONTACT Chad Knip, PE, Project Manager 574.314.1018 cknip@abonmarche.com RESPONSIBLE OFFICE 315 W. Jefferson Blvd. South Bend, IN 46601 abonmarche.com METROPOLITAN TITLE 12.2 Title Search ASC GROUP, INC. Environmental 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, 5.6, 5.7, 5.8, 5.9, 5.10, 5.13, 5.14 CITY OF SOUTH BEND FINNIAN CAVANAUGH Project Engineer JAKE MANZO Staff Engineer MICHAEL ROZYCKI, PS Project Surveyor ROGER NAWROT, PE, PS QC/Constructability Engineer ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING KEY STAFF Chad is responsible for the design of civil engineering projects and right of way management for transportation and municipal projects. He has over 20 years of experience in design and construction review. Chad has managed and designed several Federal Aid LPA projects that have included roadway design, streetscape improvements, water and sewer design, multi-use paths, and recreational projects. TRANSPORTATION AND MUNICIPAL Chad specializes in the design and implementation of new road projects and the reconstruction of existing roads, as well as streetscape beautification. His focus is on understanding client needs and staying up-to-date on local and industry standards. Chad is solution-oriented, figuring out how to complete a client’s vision for a project within site constraints, on time, and on budget. • Wilden Avenue Reconstruction, Goshen, LPA • Edison Road Added Left Turn Lane, South Bend, LPA • Heritage Iron Horse Trail, Portage, IN, LPA • Cotter Street Reconstruction, South Bend, LPA • East Shore Court Extension, La Porte, LPA • Bremen Highway, Mishawaka, IN • Douglas Road, South Bend, IN • Main Street, Mishawaka, IN • Jefferson Boulevard, South Bend, IN • Division Street, DeMotte, IN, LPA • Western Avenue, South Bend, IN • 1st Street, Goshen, IN • Supreme Court, Goshen, IN • Maple City Greenway Phase IV • Lake City Greenway CHAD A. KNIP, PE PROJECT MANAGER EDUCATION Purdue University Bachelor of Science, Civil Engineering REGISTRATION Professional Engineer Licensed: Indiana, Michigan PROFESSIONAL AFFILIATIONS American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 2 With over 47 years of Civil Engineering experience, Roger is responsible for quality control of transportation and municipal infrastructure projects. As the lead engineer, he directs the engineering design, land surveying and planning studies to successfully complete civil engineering projects. Roger performs client relations, quality control and quality assurance on infrastructure projects from proposal development through construction. Areas of special interest include the oversight of multidiscipline projects, traffic design, city revitalization, industrial development of property and trenchless technology. ROGER NAWROT, PE, PS QC/CONSTRUCTION ENGINEER Daryl has over 26 years of experience in design and management of civil engineering projects including roadways, sanitary sewer, lift stations, storm sewer, water main, detention and retention analysis, and site design associated with public works projects, federally funded projects and private developments. Daryl understands his client’s vision and is able to conceptualize it, so that it’s their vision guiding each project. He understands the area’s market and is able to think beyond our client’s needs to their client’s needs, creating a design that’s attractive to our client’s clients. DARYL KNIP, PE QA/QC ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING KEY STAFF Zachary has over Six years of experience. He works closely with Abonmarche engineers in designing lift stations, drainage solutions, site layouts and grading plans, and ADA compliant structures. He also has experience preparing Stormwater Pollution Prevention plans as well as assisting with the permit applications for DNR, IDEM, and ACOE. ZACH HAUERSPERGER PROJECT ENGINEER Jake has over three years of experience, and he has worked for Abonmarche since 2019. His experience includes utility, storm water and sanitary design as well road work and permitting. Jake is a team player and takes pride in his work. JAKE MANZO STAFF ENGINEER Mike is a results-oriented land surveyor with over 23 years of experience in topographic and boundary surveys, legal descriptions, and easement preparation. Mike oversees the day to day operations and management of the Indiana survey operations of Abonmarche. He has expertise in determining right of way, route surveys, and parcel plats for right of way acquisition on federal aided projects and locally funded projects. MICHAEL ROZYCKI, PS PROJECT SURVEYOR Rita Ann Gabriel, MAI, AI -GRS has been performing appraisal services for over 30 years and has been a Member of the Appraisal Institute (MAI and IA-GRS) for the past 20 years. The firm’s primary focus is appraisal and review of appraisal services, involving all property types including improved commercial and industrial; agricultural; single and multi-family residential; and special purpose, for right-of-way services on highway, utility, bridge, and recreational trail projects. RITA ANN GABRIEL, MAI, AI-GRS The owners of Metropolitan Title of Indiana, LLC are Margaret Klenar, Dave Smessaert, and Scott York. Between the three owners, there is over 100 years of title insurance and escrow residential and commercial closing experience. METROPOLITAN TITLE OF INDIANA, LLC ASC has been conducting environmental surveys in the state of Indiana since 1989 and we have completed more than 600 projects there. ASC is a certified DBE/WBE and is prequalified with the Indiana Department of Transportation to provide the following environmental services: 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, 5.6, 5.7, 5.8, 5.9, 5.10, 5.13, 5.14 . ASC GROUP, INC. 3 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING QUALIFICATIONS Abonmarche worked with the City of South Bend on this federally funded Safe Routes to School project. This project included replacement of over 550 sidewalk ramps along with +1000’ of sidewalk near Monroe Primary Center, Studebaker Elementary School and Riley High School. The work in this project included topographic survey, right-of-way engineering, an environmental categorical exclusion, engineering and design and utility coordination. The $1,500,000 construction project provides accessible sidewalk routes for students as well as residents. SOUTH BEND, INDIANA MONROE PRIMARY SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL This Safe Routes to School project will provide a safe pedestrian and bicycle trail away from narrow roads with poor visibility and link the DeMotte Christian School and DeMotte Elementary School with the surrounding neighborhoods, downtown business area, and the little league baseball and soccer fields. The project required a pedestrian crossing at the signalized intersection of U.S. 231 and 9th Street and working closely with the Town, businesses, and residents to determine the appropriate route for the new mile-long path. In order to achieve this, Abonmarche prepared an environmental report, designed the path and pedestrian bridge, led neighborhood meetings, and helped the Town acquire necessary right -of- way. In addition, Abonmarche coordinated the work between the INDOT LPA process and a separate, new water main project in the same area in order to maximize the benefit of the money spent on each project and to fully benefit from the $250,000 Safe Routes to School Grant. 9TH STREET & BEGONIA STREET DEMOTTE, INDIANA 4 Abonmarche provided construction engineering for this $600,000 LPA sidewalk project in a residential area within the City of South Bend. The project included replacement of numerous sidewalk ramps and over 6,000’ of sidewalk and was constructed in the summer of 2017. The project was a success and provided safe ADA compliant pedestrian routes for residents in the City of South Bend around the Perley Elementary School and added sidewalk ramps to assist those with wheel chairs and strollers. We found the key to this project was communicating with the residents and school prior to starting construction on their street and educating them about the construction process. We assisted in finding sidewalk detour routes when existing sidewalks were removed or under construction. The design of this project was done by others without the aid of a topographic survey. Abonmarche construction technicians closely reviewed grades during construction to determine compliance with ADA regulations. Several field changes were necessary to achieve the goals of the City. SRTS PERLEY STREET SIDEWALK PROJECT SOUTH BEND, INDIANA ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING QUALIFICATIONS Abonmarche was selected to work with the Town of Argos, IN to improve several streets in the Colonial Estates Neighborhood. The existing streets were gravel and lacked adequate drainage and sidewalk amenities. The project design incorporated plans for adjusting the horizontal and vertical alignments of the streets to facilitate the installation of curb and gutter and installation of drainage facilities. Sidewalk was designed on one side of the street to provide a safe and ADA accessible path for residents to enjoy. Abonmarche provided bidding service and oversaw construction of the project in addition to design. A field representative worked with Argos public works staff to coordinate adjustments to the existing utilities. The finished product was a beautiful asphalt road with rolled curb and ADA sidewalk. The improvements have stimulated the construction of new housing in the development. The Town, with assistance from Abonmarche, received funding from the Indiana Community Crossings Matching Grant Program which provided a 75 percent match on the Town’s 25 percent investment saving $392,000 in construction costs. COLONIAL ESTATES ROAD RECONSTRUCTION ARGOS, INDIANA 5 Imagination Glen Park and Woodland park provides residents and visitor of the City of Portage with numerous recreational activities a gymnasium, skate park, BMX race track, playgrounds, picnic areas, a dog park. The city envisioned a trail to provide more access to the parks. Iron Horse Trail, running over two miles between Max Mochal Road (SR 149) at the east end and Hamstrom Rd. at the west was designed to improve access to the parks and create more recreational activities. The design includes a 1,700 foot long, 12 foot wide asphalt multi-use trail with painted cross walks at Portage Avenue and Hamstrom Road. ADA ramps at the intersections of Portage Avenue and Crisman Road as well as Iron Horse Trail and Hamstrom Road improved accessibility for people for varying abilities. Topographic surveys and right of way certification were conducted to to prevent land disputes. And a comprehensive environmental field investigation and analysis was performed to comply with requirements of the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT). The end result is a trail passing through a greenway corridor among suburban back yards, though with a decidedly rural feel. Much of the route is wooded, and the trail provides access to Imagination Glen Park and Woodland Park. IRON HORSE HERITAGE TRAIL PORTAGE, INDIANA ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING QUALIFICATIONS 6 Abonmarche provided Construction Engineering services for the City of La Porte for this $420,000 sidewalk project in a residential area within the City of La Porte. The project included replacement of over 20 sidewalk ramps and over 6,500’ of sidewalk and was constructed in the summer of 2017. The project was a success and provided safe ADA compliant pedestrian routes for residents in the City of La Porte and added numerous sidewalk ramps to assist those with wheel chairs and strollers. We found the key to this project was communicating with the residents prior to starting construction on their street and educating them about the construction process. We assisted in finding routes in and out of houses when the sidewalks were removed or fresh concrete was poured. It can be tricky to find a good route to a front door with on street parking in front of homes. In order to save money for the City, our staff worked with the City, INDOT and the contractor to determine what soils were adequate and didn’t required subgrade treatment. LA PORTE, INDIANA LA PORTE SIDEWALK REPLACEMENT PROJECT This was an LPA multi-use trail project at various locations within and near the Town of Westville. The project connected the existing HMA Lincoln Memorial Trail to State Road 421, while installing ADA compliant ramps at road crossings. In conjunction to the trail, the project also installed ADA compliant ramps and concrete sidewalk with the Town of Westville providing a Safe Route to School for the neighborhood. This project involved multiple municipalities, INDOT, La Porte County, La Porte County Parks, and the Town of Westville. Throughout construction our inspection team worked with the county planner, INDOT Area Engineer and contractor to provide a cost savings at the end of the contract. LINCOLN TRAIL AND SIDEWALKS WESTVILLE, INDIANA Abonmarche assisted the City of Mishawaka in upgrading the Borley- Lynn-Maplehurst Neighborhood that was annexed to the City in the 1970’s and infilling the vacant lots with new affordable houses under the First Time Home Buyer Program through HUD Grants. Initially hired to do a study of needed right of way improvements City water service and sanitary sewer were provided along Lynn Street and Maplehurst Avenue but Borley Avenue lacked both water service and sanitary sewer because of the many undeveloped lots that fronted it. There were no sidewalks, curbing or storm sewers within the neighborhood. The study was the financial planning tool the City needed to construct the infrastructure improvements phased over a period of four years. Borley Avenue was the first street to be completely reconstructed in two phases with new sanitary sewer, water main, storm sewer, concrete curbing, asphalt pavement and sidewalk to accommodate the new homes to be constructed as part of the HUD Program. Maplehurst Avenue and Lynn Street followed each in its own phase. BORLEY, LYNN, AND MAPLEHURST MISHAWAK, INDIANA ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING QUALIFICATIONS This project was a joint effort between the City of Goshen, Goshen Community Schools, and the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) to alleviate safety concerns at the existing crossing located at Plymouth Avenue (SR 119) and Indiana Avenue. The existing crossing is used by students as well as the community to access Shanklin Park and the Mill Race Canal to the east. To help alleviate safety concerns, a mid - block crossing was added to the west, closer to the exit of the school parking lot on Plymouth Avenue. Abonmarche provided topographic survey, conceptual layouts and cost estimates, and engineering to incorporate the mid-block crossing (safety island) with rapid flasher beacons. This work also included design of new concrete curbing along both sides of the road with new storm sewer inlets and piping, and stormwater treatment prior to discharge. A new sidewalk/path was designed from Indiana Avenue along the school property to the mid-block safety island, crossed over and continued on the north side to connect to the City's existing trail. Cross-walk improvements at Indiana Avenue were re-designed to improve pedestrian visibility and provide a larger wait area for students leaving school, and incorporated both a new push-button pedestal and push- buttons on existing signal poles. The project also included preparing several easements along the north side of Plymouth Avenue for the sidewalk/path and a new sanitary sewer to service the existing homes. Other project elements included traffic and pedestrian signage, preparing legal descriptions for additional right -of-way, coordination with INDOT and utility companies, and potholing a main line gas main to help design the placement of new storm sewer inlet locations. PLYMOUTH AVENUE (SR 19) TRAIL MODIFICATION CROSSING GOSHEN, INDIANA CLIENT City of Goshen COST $764,000 HIGHLIGHTS • New Mid-Block Pedestrian Crossing • Rapid Flasher Beacons • INDOT Coordination and Permitting • New Storm Sewer and Treatment • Sanitary Sewer Design • Easement Preparation • Traffic Signage for Crossing 7 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING PROJECT UNDERSTANDING Vision The purpose of this project is to enhance the connectivity and access to the Muessel and Holy Cross schools by reconstructing intersection ramps and sidewalk systems to allow barrier free usage for all citizens. Additionally, enhanced pedestrian access to and from the Coal Line Trail will be created. The resulting improvements will increase mobility, ADA Accessibility and safety for students and pedestrians. Expertise The project is being funded through the Safe Routes to School program. The Grant funds 80 percent of the project cost with the other funds coming from the City. Due to the funding source, the project is an LPA project and must follow INDOT procedures for design, property acquisition, environmental and construction inspection. INDOT is demanding in the requirements for these type of projects. Abonmarche is experienced in dealing with these type of projects have completed multiple in surrounding communities. Our team will work with City staff to navigate the guidelines and complete a successful project the City can be proud of. Trusted Partners The City is seeking a partner for the project that has their best interest in mind. A consultant that will maximize the value of the dollars allotted for the project to give South Bend the best project possible. Abonmarche has been serving the South Bend Community for twenty five years completing over 50 million dollars of infrastructure improvements. Our team understands what the City’s vision is for its community and has been honored to assist in the transformation. PROJECT UNDERSTANDING 8 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING TECHNICAL APPROACH Abonmarche will utilize our extensive experience in project management, surveying, sidewalk and intersection design to create a project that maximizes the benefit for the citizens of the neighborhood. Our plan will cover the main goals outlined in our project understanding to create a project that will improve safety and improve interconnectivity. Field Assessment First, we will walk through the entire study area and assess the condition of all sidewalks, ramps, walls, stairs, etc. within the study area. We will identify issues and conflicts that will need to be addressed and resolved in order to reconstruct sidewalks, approaches, ramp to meet modern accessibility standards on a street -by-street basis. Preliminary Scope and Budget Next we will develop a preliminary strategy to most effectively use available budgeted construction funds. We will focus on streets and corridors that will likely have the most pedestrian traffic and benefit to the neighborhoods. Field Review with City Staff After we develop the preliminary scope and budget, we will do a field review with City Staff and present our rationale and recommendations for project scope given the construction budget. Modify Preliminary Scope Based upon feedback and input from the City, we will modify the project scope and begin the survey and design process. Drainage and Stormwater Management Whenever infrastructure is installed drainage patterns are effected. Abonmarche has a general knowledge of the drainage system within the City and will work with the community to avoid ponding issues. Utility Coordination Abonmarche will perform the utility coordination in accordance with INDOT’s policies. Existing utilities are a significant driver in coordination and design of any public works project. Accurate identification and location of underground utilities and coordination with the owner of the facilities are vital in minimizing change orders and keeping costs down and maintaining construction schedules. Right-of-Way Engineering and Acquisition Abonmarche will evaluate proposed sections and study alternate solutions to present to the City with a comparison of advantages, disadvantages, and cost. Any alternative will consider such things as utility relocation, presence of tree lawn, mail delivery, lane widths, and right of way impacts. While we do not anticipate that right-of-way acquisition will be needed, we would collaborate with Rita Ann Gabriel for appraisals. TECHNICAL APPROACH 9 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING Environmental Document The project will most likely only require a Categorical Exclusion environmental document. A cursory review of Indiana MAP did not identify significant areas of concern for this project. No wetlands, Section 4(f), Section 6 (f), historical structures or sites were identified in a brief review of the project area. An Archaeological Phase 1 report and Historic Properties Report will be prepared as part of the Section 106 process to verify that no historic structures or sites are present. The project does not appear to pose significant environmental obstacles. Public Information Meeting Our team will assist the City with a public information meeting to present the project and schedule to area residents, schools, businesses, and other interested parties. A public hearing is not anticipated for this project, but Abonmarche will assist the City in conducting any public hearings that may be appropriate. We will also communicate and work with Muessel Primary and Holy Cross School on the project schedule and timing. Maintenance of Traffic and Phasing Maintenance of Traffic, pedestrian and vehicular, often has a significant impact on the public’s perception of the success of a project during construction. Abonmarche will draft a maintenance of Traffic plan to ensure a safe project. For this type of project, only relatively short pedestrian detours are acceptable and the detour route must meet ADA accessibility standards. Cost Saving Alternative As part of our recommended approach, we will assist the City to see if INDOT-LPA Design Certification is applicable for this type of project. Design Certification provides municipalities with more decision -making authority and control over managing project design elements. This allows the project design to meet the actual engineering needs of the project. This in-turn saves costs and allows more improvements to be constructed within the allotted budget. Abonmarche will assist the City in their overall trail sidewalk plans by determining the best use the grant dollars in conjunction with other funding methods to maximize the South Bend dollars going to construction. TECHNICAL APPROACH 10 ENGINEERING • ARCHITECTURE • LAND SURVEYING TECHNICAL APPROACH PROJECT SCHEDULE Based on our experience on similar projects, we have programed the sequence and duration of the tasks that need to be performed. Below is our proposed schedule: The primary elements that drive the overall schedule and the timing of the letting are: • Environmental Clearance • Utility Coordination In order to ensure these critical issues are being accomplished timely, each task is broken into multiple sub - tasks, each with deadlines and intermediate milestones. As an example, below is a chart we use to drive the acquisition process. PROPOSED PROJECT SCHEDULE TASKS 2022 2023 Notice to Proceed Topographical Survey Stage 1 Plans Preliminary Field Check Environmental Document Utility Coordination Stage 3 Plans Final Tracings Letting 11 Standard RFP Form Ver. 3-01-2021 6 (Rev. 06/27/18) Des. # 1900447 Affirmative Action Certification (AAC) for Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBE) I hereby certify that my company intends to affirmatively seek out and consider Disadvantaged Business Enterprises (DBEs) certified by the State of Indiana’s DBE Program and the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet (KYTC) DBE Program to participate as part of this proposal. An Agreement between INDOT and KYTC established reciprocal acceptance of certification of DBE firms in their respective states under the Unified Certification Program (UCP) pursuant to 49 CFR §26.81(e) and (f). I acknowledge that this certification is to be made an integral part of this proposal. I understand and agree that the submission of a blank certification may cause the proposal to be rejected. I certify that I have consulted the following DBE websites to confirm that the firms listed below are currently certified DBEs: INDOT: https://entapps.indot.in.gov/DBELocator/ KYTC: https://transportation.ky.gov/Civil-Rights-and-Small-Business-Development/Pages/Certified-DBE-Directory.aspx I certify that I have contacted the certified DBE’s listed below, and if my company becomes the CONSULTANT, these DBEs have tentatively agreed to perform the services as indicated. I understand that neither my company nor I will be penalized for DBE utilization that exceeds the goal. After contract award, any change to the firms listed in this Affirmative Action Certification to be applied toward the DBE goal must have prior approval by INDOT’s Economic Opportunity Division. I. DBE Subconsultants to be applied toward DBE goal for the RFP item: Certified DBE Name Service Planned Estimated Percentage to be Paid* % % % % II. DBE Subconsultants to be utilized beyond the advertised DBE goal for the RFP item: Certified DBE Name Service Planned Estimated Percentage to be Paid* % % % % Estimated Total Percentage Credited toward DBE Goal:___________ Estimated Percentage of Voluntary DBE Work Anticipated over DBE Goal:__________ Company Name: ____________________________________________________________________ Signature: ___________________________________________ Date: ________________________ ∗ It is understood that these individual firm percentages are estimates only and that percentages paid may be greater or less as a result of negotiation of contract scope of work. My firm will use good faith efforts to meet the overall DBE goal through the use of these or other certified and approved DBE firms. Abonmarche Consultants, Inc. 2/22/2022 3% Rita Ann Gabriel Metropolitan Title ASC Group, Inc. 1 1 1