HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020 Annual Inclusion Contracting Procurement Report 3-27-21_
Annual Inclusion Contracting Procurement Report
Office of Diversity and Inclusion
FY 2020
Michael A. Patton, MNA-Diversity, Compliance &
Inclusion Officer
1
Inclusive Procurement Program Annual Diversity Purchasing report F.Y. 2020 Index
Table of Contents
Index Page: 1
Executive Summary Page: 2-3
2020 Annual Spend and Participation Page: 4
BPW Vendor Breakdown Q1-Q4 Page: 5-8
2020 Total Vendor Participation by State Page: 9
Four Year WBE/MBE Purchase Order Comparison Page: 10
Four Year Combined MBE/WBE Total Award Page: 11
Four Year WBE/MBE Vendor Participation Comparison Page: 12
Four Year Total Annual Purchase Order Comparison Page: 13
Economic Forecast Page: 14
Strategy/COVID Pivot Page: 15
Funding/Future Page: 16-18
Definitions Page: 19-23
Appendix/Procurement Forecast Template Page: 24-25
2
Executive Summary
At the beginning of 2020, South Bend's economy started with low unemployment rates, increased production, and a robust labor
market. It was projected to have a prosperous year, but COVID-19 hit our community and devastated our local economy.
The Pandemic caught everyone by surprise, and the local economy took a severe blow in April 2020. Our local business community
has drawn negative impacts due to the Pandemic. The hospitality industry, restaurants, and retail were most seriously affected.
Manufacturing was severely affected, but they have been able to bounce back. The Pandemic has affected the healthcare industry in
many ways. In some hospitals, this has led to delays in non-urgent surgeries. Some elective or nonemergency surgeries may be
postponed without a scheduled date. There is also fear, anxiety, and potential risk factors associated with surgical procedures.
Therefore, Health Facilities have canceled medical procedures.
Home improvement and construction appear to be doing well because people have been actively involved in working on home
projects while working from home. Small businesses have been hit with only 30-45 days of cash flow, which has caused some local
companies to close.
Mayor James Mueller confronted the unprecedented public health pandemic by teaming up with Dr. Mark Fox, St. Joseph County
Deputy Health Officer, to resolve public health concerns created by the Pandemic. The community was faced with new safety
precaution measures, including mask covers, social distancing, and frequent hand washing. Governor Eric Holcomb issued a stay-at-
home order requiring non-essential employees to work remotely. The Governor also issued a five-stage plan hoping that the State of
Indiana would recover by July 4. The State did not officially reopen and reach stage five until September 26 as the statewide mask
order remains indefinitely.
Our local Minority Women Business Enterprise (MWBE) and Minority Business Enterprise (MBE) community were deeply impacted
due to the Pandemic. Some businesses could not recover from the lack of resources, social distancing restrictions, and stay home
Executive Order by Governor Holcomb. The City of South Bend recognized the economic struggles of residents and the business
community by providing resources that would help those impacted by the COVID-19 Pandemic. Those resources included rent &
utility support, community health support, food, and Small Business Support.
3
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion is in its tenth year and has made tremendous strides while dealing with COVID-19 and our
current crisis's challenges. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion shifted as a department to address the needs of small
businesses/MWBE's who found themselves in trouble due to our economy coming to a screeching halt. Our office has provided tools
and information to companies within our community through webinars and funding opportunities.
The death of Ahmaud Arbery, George Floyd, and several other wrongful killings of black people created a spark that led to worldwide
protests to address systematic racism inequities, disproportionate health issues, employment, and housing.
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion has acknowledged the impacts of the COVID-19 Pandemic and the increased effects of race and
racism in society. We have taken steps to address structural racism by orchestrating a virtual team meeting to create dialogue within
the City of South Bend among Directors, Supervisors, and city employees to address race and unconscious bias within the workforce.
We also invited Angela R. Logan-BA, MBOL, Ph.D. Associate Teaching Professor of Management and Organization in the Mendoza
College of Business at the University of Notre Dame, Eric Love- Director of Staff Diversity and Inclusion at the University of Notre
Dame and Dr. Robert Einterz-St. Joseph County Public Health Department Officer to our Virtual Neighborhood Business Labs to
address the following topics, "Building Resiliency," "Conversations on Race," "Racism declared a Public Health Crisis," respectfully.
Our efforts have been targeted and intentional around supporting our community.
4
2020 OVERALL ANNUAL SPEND AND PARTICIPATION RESULTS
Total Overall
Annual Spend
Amount
Total # of
Payments
Total MBE
Annual Spend
Total MBE
Annual %
Total WBE
Annual Spend
Total WBE
Annual %
Total MWBE Annual
Spend
Total
MWBE
Annual % OVERALL
ANNUAL SPEND
$ 111,432,724 39,797 $793,590 0.71% $3,399,346 3.05% $4,192.936 3.75%
Total Annual Spend
Amount
Total # of
Transactions
Total MBE
Annual Spend
Total MBE
Annual %
Total WBE
Annual Spend
Total
WBE
Annual %
Total MWBE
Annual Spend
Total
MWBE
Annual %
PROCUREMENT OF
GOODS AND
SERVICES
$77,279,328 38,690 $680,520 .88% $1,828,162 2.3% $2,508,682 2.29%
Total Annual Spend
Amount
Total # of
Contracts
Total MBE
Annual Spend
Total
Annual
MBE %
Total Annual Spend
WBE
Total
Annual
WBE %
Total MWBE
Annual Spend
Total
MWBE
Annual % BPW
CONSTRUCTION
$34,153,396 58 $113,070 .33% $1,571,184 4.6% $1,684,254 4.9%
*Total Number include prime contractors only
Total Vendors
Total Certified
MBE's
Total Uncertified
MBE's
Total
MBE's
Total Certified
WBE's
Total Uncertified
WBE's
TOTAL VENDOR COUNT
8,363 No tracking data No tracking data 87 No tracking data No tracking data
No goal setting
No goal setting
measure 1.0% No Goal Set No Goals Set
Source: 2020 ALL Vendor Disbursement Department -Naviline, Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operation (DFO)
5
Board of Public Works Q1 Spend 2020
Vendor Vendor City Vendor State Contract Amount MWBE
MARTELL ELECTRIC South Bend IN 1,436,482.34$ No
LARSON DANIELSON CONSTR LaPorte IN 1,174,021.86$ No
ARCADIS US INC South Bend IN 383,220.38$ No
DC BYERS COMPANY Grand Rapids MI 275,358.19$ No
HIGH CONCRETE GROUP LLC Springboro OH 212,562.00$ No
INDIANA EARTH South Bend IN 183,846.25$ No
BOB FRAME PLUMBING & HE South Bend IN 182,029.61$ No
NIEZGODSKI PLUMBING INC South Bend IN 177,869.56$ No
BROWN & BROWN GENERAL C Elkhart IN 164,318.46$ Yes
GIBSON LEWIS LLC South Bend IN 156,420.07$ No
BOWEN ENGINEERING CORP South Bend IN 155,108.40$ No
NORTHERN INDIANA CONSTR South Bend IN 143,394.81$ No
ZIOLKOWSKI CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 119,505.56$ No
MIDLAND ENGINEERING CO South Bend IN 108,039.11$ No
ANCON CONSTRUCTION INC South Bend IN 106,853.39$ No
MAJORITY BUILDERS INC South Bend IN 96,179.55$ No
WALSH & KELLY INC South Bend IN 80,354.09$ No
JONES PETRIE RAFINSKI South Bend IN 74,642.19$ No
BLACK & VEATCH CORPORAT South Bend IN 72,781.00$ No
RIETH RILEY CONSTRUCTIO South Bend IN 64,516.43$ No
LOCHMUELLER GROUP INC South Bend IN 64,209.55$ No
MICHIANA CONTRACTING IN South Bend IN 45,520.53$ No
ABONMARCHE CONSULTANTS South Bend IN 39,887.85$ No
SELGE CONSTRUCTION CO I South Bend IN 26,815.00$ No
K&K EARTH MOVING INC Elkhart IN 19,693.00$ No
HOMEWORKS CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 13,550.00$ No
TRI M CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 11,840.00$ No
DA DODD INC Rolling Prairie IN 8,614.80$ Yes
HRP CONSTRUCTION INC South Bend IN 6,962.95$ No
DUDECK ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN 3,523.51$ No
LAWSON-FISHER ASSOCIATE South Bend IN 1,437.39$ No
WARDLOW CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 750.00$ No
Grand Total 5,610,307.83$ MWBE Total: $172,933.26
6
Board of Public Works Q2 Spend 2020
Vendor Vendor City Vendor State Contract Amount MWBE
HIGH CONCRETE GROUP LLC Springboro OH 901,193.99$ No
WALSH & KELLY INC South Bend IN 713,733.71$ No
BOWEN ENGINEERING CORP South Bend IN 611,721.86$ No
HRP CONSTRUCTION INC South Bend IN 595,452.90$ No
RIETH RILEY CONSTRUCTIO South Bend IN 340,208.56$ No
GIBSON LEWIS LLC South Bend IN 287,164.55$ No
HORTON EMERGENCY VEHICL South Bend IN 263,610.00$ No
NORTHERN INDIANA CONSTR South Bend IN 236,662.15$ No
MAJORITY BUILDERS INC South Bend IN 215,171.05$ No
MARTELL ELECTRIC South Bend IN 159,017.36$ No
LARSON DANIELSON CONSTR South Bend IN 148,173.33$ No
BROWN & BROWN GENERAL C Elkhart IN 143,899.20$ Yes
BOB FRAME PLUMBING & HE South Bend IN 129,014.75$ No
DUDECK ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN 126,649.55$ Yes
NIEZGODSKI PLUMBING INC South Bend IN 99,660.97$ No
LOCHMUELLER GROUP INC South Bend IN 99,587.81$ No
ARCADIS US INC South Bend IN 94,320.73$ No
DA DODD INC Rolling Prairie IN 57,626.34$ Yes
LAWSON-FISHER ASSOCIATE South Bend IN 51,069.44$ No
BLACK & VEATCH CORPORAT South Bend IN 34,971.00$ No
JONES PETRIE RAFINSKI South Bend IN 23,076.49$ No
DC BYERS COMPANY South Bend IN 14,941.60$ No
SLATILE ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN 14,142.50$ Yes
ABONMARCHE CONSULTANTS South Bend IN 13,150.00$ No
K&K EARTH MOVING INC Elkhart IN 9,610.00$ No
TRI M CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 7,880.00$ No
INDIANA EARTH South Bend IN 2,055.00$ No
Grand Total 5,393,764.84$ MWBE Total:$342,317.59
7
Board of Public Works Q3 Spend 2020
Vendor Vendor City Vendor State Contract Amount MWBE
WALSH & KELLY INC South Bend IN 3,547,937.13$ No
MARTELL ELECTRIC South Bend IN 1,273,918.71$ No
RIETH RILEY CONSTRUCTIO South Bend IN 1,020,093.64$ No
HIGH CONCRETE GROUP LLC South Bend IN 856,934.56$ No
MAJORITY BUILDERS INC South Bend IN 601,712.34$ No
BOWEN ENGINEERING CORP South Bend IN 470,648.05$ No
GIBSON LEWIS LLC South Bend IN 427,369.43$ No
BOB FRAME PLUMBING & HE South Bend IN 421,726.00$ No
NORTHERN INDIANA CONSTR South Bend IN 353,418.68$ No
HRP CONSTRUCTION INC South Bend IN 352,545.71$ No
ARCADIS US INC South Bend IN 318,553.09$ No
NIEZGODSKI PLUMBING INC South Bend IN 313,400.63$ No
SLATILE ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN 273,913.81$ Yes
INDIANA EARTH South Bend IN 273,562.69$ No
BROWN & BROWN GENERAL C South Bend IN 234,259.34$ Yes
LAWSON-FISHER ASSOCIATE South Bend IN 194,583.00$ No
BLACK & VEATCH CORPORAT South Bend IN 163,783.00$ No
DC BYERS COMPANY South Bend IN 141,975.44$ No
LOCHMUELLER GROUP INC South Bend IN 140,939.67$ No
ABONMARCHE CONSULTANTS South Bend IN 89,241.50$ No
CITY OF ELKHART Elkhart IN 80,000.00$ No
K&K EARTH MOVING INC South Bend IN 51,941.68$ No
SELGE CONSTRUCTION CO I South Bend IN 44,830.85$ No
DA DODD INC Rolling Praire IN 39,412.29$ Yes
JONES PETRIE RAFINSKI South Bend IN 30,415.00$ No
LARSON DANIELSON CONSTR South Bend IN 24,450.91$ No
ALLIANCE ARCHITECTS INC South Bend IN 22,831.00$ No
KIL ARCHIETECTURE PLANN South Bend IN 22,149.81$ No
TRI-M CONSTRUCTION, INC.South Bend IN 19,716.00$ No
EPOCH ARCHITECTURE & PL South Bend IN 12,980.16$ No
Shakesphere Lighting Design LLC Bloomington IN 12,187.50$ No
Ciorba Group, Inc Chicago IL 3,627.25$ No
DUDECK ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN 3,168.50$ Yes
AMERICAN STRUCTUREPOINT South Bend IN 2,680.00$ No
WBK ENGINEERING LLC St. Charles IL 1,574.00$ No
AIS CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT Grand Rapids MI 489.28$ No
TROYER GROUP INC South Bend IN 119.25$ No
Alpine Construction South Bend IN 70.45$ No
Grand Total 11,843,160.35$ MWBE Total: $550,753.94
8
Board of Public Works Spend Q4 2020
Vendor Vendor City Vendor State Contract Amount MBE/MWBE
HIGH CONCRETE GROUP LLC Springboror OH 2,603,276.61$ N
RIETH RILEY CONSTRUCTIO South Bend IN 2,544,707.07$ N
WALSH & KELLY INC South Bend IN 1,053,846.36$ N
MAJORITY BUILDERS INC South Bend IN 669,679.52$ N
MARTELL ELECTRIC South Bend IN 668,009.48$ N
PREMIUM CONCRETE SERVICE South Bend IN $406,809.45 Yes
SELGE CONSTRUCTION CO I South Bend IN 403,013.75$ N
GIBSON LEWIS LLC South Bend IN 369,415.40$ N
HRP CONSTRUCTION INC South Bend IN 351,781.80$ N
HARDINGS INC Lowell IN 323,876.00$ N
BOB FRAME PLUMBING & HE South Bend IN 194,564.11$ N
INDIANA EARTH South Bend IN 190,042.28$ N
ARCADIS US INC South Bend IN 174,149.17$ N
NIEZGODSKI PLUMBING INC South Bend IN 165,125.16$ N
DC BYERS COMPANY Grand Rapids MI 146,110.00$ N
SLATILE ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN $145,692.63 Yes
LAWSON-FISHER ASSOCIATE South Bend IN 141,518.22$ N
John Boettcher Sewer & Exc. Contractor Mishawaka IN 91,594.04$ N
LOCHMUELLER GROUP INC South Bend IN 72,328.46$ N
MIDLAND ENGINEERING CO South Bend IN 71,100.00$ N
ABONMARCHE CONSULTANTS South Bend IN 63,533.65$ N
LARSON DANIELSON CONSTR South Bend IN 56,079.53$ N
JONES PETRIE RAFINSKI South Bend IN 55,754.25$ N
BLACK & VEATCH CORPORAT Indianapolis IN 39,370.00$ N
ROADBOTICS LLC Pittsburgh PA 39,280.00$ N
BOWEN ENGINEERING CORP Indianapolis IN 34,115.69$ N
RITSCHARD BROS INC South Bend IN $28,500 Yes
DUDECK ROOFING & SHEET South Bend IN $24,557.50 Yes
AMERICAN STRUCTURE POINT South Bend IN 23,145.60$ N
PREMIER ONE CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 21,500.00$ N
CUSTOM FENCE COMPANY South Bend IN 21,237.11$ N
K&K EARTH MOVING INC Elkhart IN 19,646.55$ N
ZIOLKOWSKI CONSTRUCTION South Bend IN 16,760.85$ N
TRI-M CONSTRUCTION, INC.South Bend IN 14,477.00$ N
INDIANA DEPT OF TRANSPO Indianapolis IN 13,920.77$ N
PEMBERTON DAVIS ELECTRICAL Mishawaka IN 7,371.71$ N
KIL ARCHIETECTURE PLANN South Bend IN 7,053.51$ N
ALLIANCE ARCHITECTS INC South Bend IN 6,815.45$ N
BSR ROOFMASTERS South Bend IN 6,770.00$ N
KOONTZ WAGNER CONSTRUCTION SERVIC South Bend OM 5,079.52$ N
Shakesphere Lighting Design LLC Bloomington IN 3,240.68$ N
BROWN & BROWN GENERAL South Bend IN $1,750.00 Yes
WBK ENGINEERING LLC Battle Creek MI 1,195.75$ N
AEP South Bend IN 530.38$ N
EPOCH ARCHITECTURE & PL South Bend IN 450.84$ N
AIS CONSTRUCTION EQUIPMENT Grand Rapids MI (30.35)$ N
Grand Total 11,306,162.50$ MWBE Total: $607,309.58
9
The City of South Bend utilized a total of 2600 vendors in the fiscal year 2020. Most of the vendors, 64%,
are located within Indiana state limits. Regional vendors from Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio, 22%, with
the remaining 14% coming from a nationwide pool of vendors stretching from California, Georgia, Texas
to Pennsylvania.
Source: Naviline and Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations (DFO) January 2021
CA
3%FL
2%GA
2%
IL
12%
IN
64%
MI
6%
MN
2%
OH
4%
PA
2%
TX
3%
Top Ten 2020 Total Vendor Participation by State
CA
FL
GA
IL
IN
MI
MN
OH
PA
TX
10
Source: Naviline and Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations (DFO) January 2021
1,349
1,808
2,271
2,600
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
Participation Year
Four Year Vendor Participaiton Comparison
20182017 2019 2020
11
Source: Naviline and Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations (DFO) January 2021
$101,702,444
$1,895,571
$100,696,340
$4,857,749
$115,339,546
$4,561,377
$111,432,724
$4,192,936
$0
$20,000,000
$40,000,000
$60,000,000
$80,000,000
$100,000,000
$120,000,000
$140,000,000
Four Year Comparison MBE/WBE Participation Award
2017 Total
Procurement
Contracting Spend
2017 Total
MBE/WBE
2018 Total
Procurement
Contracting Spend
2018 Total
MBE/WBE
2019 Total
Procurement
Contracting Spend
2019 Total
MBE/WBE
2020 Total
Procurement
Contracting Spend
2020 Total
MBE/WBE
1.8%
Participation
3.9%
Participation
3.7%
Participation
4.8%
Participation
12
Source: Naviline and Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations (DFO) January 2021
The City of South Bend utilized a combined total of 24 WBE/MBE vendors for 2017. 2018 increase of 4 and a total of 28.
2019 demonstrated another increase of 43 and 71 combined total. 2020 had an increase of nine and a total of 80 WBE/MBE
vendors.
20
4
22
6
58
13
56
24
Four Year Vendor Comparison WBE/MBE Participation
2017 WBE
Vendors
2017 MBE
Vendors
2018 WBE
Vendors
2018 MBE
Vendors
2019 WBE
Vendors
2019 MBE
Vendors
2020 WBE
Vendors
2020 MBE
Vendors
13
Source: Naviline and Dynamics 365 for Finance and Operations (DFO)
5715
7189
6357
8363
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
Total Annual Purchase Order Comparison
2018 2019 20202017
14
Economic Forecast 2020
The COVID-19 pandemic crisis had a substantial impact on all aspects of our lives. Governor Holcomb announced a statewide
Executive Order to shut down the State of Indiana in March and eased restrictions beginning in late May. The average unemployment
rate soared to 9.7% in April 2020, delivering a severe blow to our local economy.
South Bend ranks as the fourth largest City in the State. A population of 101,000 - 61% of the population is white or Caucasian, 26%
is Black or African American, Hispanic, or Latino is 13% (U.S. Census Bureau 7/2019). The average weekly income is $896 and
below the national average of $1,188. The top three major business sectors are Education and Health Care Services, Transportation,
Utilities, and Manufacturing. The South Bend-Mishawaka area lost over 28,000 jobs in April, and these are the most significant one-
month employment declines in the history of South Bend. The local economy had come to a standstill, and some businesses did not
recover. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion will provide access to tools and resources to address unemployment needs and strengthen
our local economy.
Consumers and businesses are more conscious about customer safety and utilizing safety precautions by allowing employees to work
remotely. We will see fewer business activities in leisure and hospitality, personal services, and manufacturing in the 1st and 2nd
quarters of 2021. "Given the disproportionate representation of black workers in front-line occupations where they face a greater risk
of exposure to COVID-19. It is not surprising that illness and deaths are disproportionately found among black workers and their
families"-Valerie Wilson-Director of the Economic Policy Institute's Program on Race, Ethnicity, and Economy.
Source: US BLS Current Employment Statistics
Source: IBR/Business Review Source:
U.S. Census Bureau
15
Strategy:
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion will provide equitable and fair opportunities, access to tools and resources that foster inclusive
workplaces, workforces, communities, and city procurement opportunities. We deliver inclusive policy infrastructure and public-
private program partnerships that expand access to talent pools, enforce fair and equitable employment, public accommodations,
education practices, and assist in fostering vibrant and inclusive city economies. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion remains focused
on preserving Minority-Owned, Women-Owned, Local, and Small Businesses located in the City of South Bend during the
Coronavirus Pandemic. During the 2020 calendar, the three (3) significant support areas were integral in the assistance provided by
business groups: learning, funding, and COVID-pivots. Due to the unanticipated impact of COVID, many of the initiatives mentioned
within the 2020 strategy will require additional effort to reach maturity in the 2021 programmatic cycle.
COVID-PIVOTS:
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion has hosted 13 Virtual Neighborhood Business Labs series to help inform existing businesses and
cultivate new small business enterprises. Minority businesses, both small and large, have faced unprecedented challenges in 2020.
Throughout the shutdown, the Diversity & Inclusion staff has been working with multiple city departments to ensure the City of South
Bend procurement process is compliant and becomes more equitable for all residents. In addition to the Virtual Business Labs,
business owners were also counseled on dealing with stress by offering resources and certification opportunities with the Indiana
Department of Transportation (INDOT), Indiana Department of Administration (IDOA) City Indianapolis. One of our guests Ernie
Rivas- a US Marine veteran, provided a great example of pivoting from transportation shuttle service to making safety masks
mandated by the State.
16
FUNDING:
While information and opportunity are critical factors in business stability in a pandemic, businesses expressly owned and operated by
Minority Business Enterprises (MBE) and Women Business Enterprise (WBE) often work with some of the tightest margins and
smallest revenue streams. To address the impact of COVID-19, The Office of Diversity & Inclusion immediately sought opportunities
to increase inclusivity in each area; the City of South Bend provided funding to local businesses. Without proper financial support, the
formal and informal community sustaining businesses would dissolve overnight. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion team members
engaged in numerous policy, programmatic, and strategical discussions throughout 2020 to ensure funding choices were challenged
and pivoted to support South Bend. The Office of Diversity & Inclusion has developed sustainable resources to assist small businesses
in recovering from financial hardship.
The Federal Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) offered forgivable loan dollars to businesses nationwide to preserve the American
business infrastructure. During the first round, these funds were approved to support all American businesses; however, large-scale
corporations were the primary beneficiary of the funding, while small-scale businesses received little to no support. The first round of
the PPP loan program ran from April 3 to August 8; as published by the Associated Press in August 2020, minority business owners,
many of them just "hanging on" financially, had their applications and inquiries pushed back to the final few weeks of the Program.
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion supported the City of South Bend Emergency Assistance Fair (EAF) that awarded grants totaling
$600,000 to a pair of Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI's) to provide small loans affected by COVID-19. There
were breakout sessions with financial institutions about potential loans, contracts, and application information. The financial
institutions participating were 1st Source Bank, Accion Bank, Bankable, Brightpoint, Centier Bank, Notre Dame Federal Credit Union,
and Woodforest National Bank.
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion also provided direct engagement to support the application process and communication with
business owners applying for the City of South Bend Small Business Resiliency Grant. The Program made available 60 grants from a
total of $300,000 in money received through the Federal CARES Act. As a result of the Office of Diversity & Inclusion, $100,000 was
awarded to Minority and Women-Owned Businesses.
17
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion created The Small Business Assistance Suite to provide wrap-around services in legal counseling,
accounting, bookkeeping, business coaching, and financial coaching. The goal is to strengthen the small business eco-system through
investment in the professional service community, formal economic participation, and increasing utilization of small local minority
and women-owned businesses.
The City of South Bend received a $7.7 Million State of Indiana Grants to increase municipal lending access through the City of South
Bend Revolving Loan Fund (RLF). The funding will help grow the regional economy, implement strategies to grow the manufacturing
sector, support workforce growth development, and help the local economy recover. The Department of Community Investment will
administer the new loan program to small businesses impacted by COVID-19.
FUTURE LEARNING
Learning opportunities or filling the information gap is a top priority for every Diversity & Inclusion team. Both city employees and
local business owners must begin to understand where opportunities exist so that the City of South Bend can become regionally,
statewide, and nationally competitive.
The Office of Diversity & Inclusion provides training and business community networking opportunities through Facebook and
Microsoft Teams for viewers to access remotely. The Diversity & Inclusion Team has contacted approximately 3,000 statewide
certified vendors to register with the City of South Bend and promote inclusion for future construction, goods, and service contracts.
The goal is to offer the growing population of business owners and City departments a direct communication line for future
procurement needs.
Through Race and Gender Conscious measures, certified Minority and Women Business Enterprises (MWBE) can help bridge the
income, participation, and information gap to diversify the City of South Bend Labor Force. Given the legacy of discrimination and
well-documented isolation of minority/women firms within the construction industry, these firms are the most likely to offer an
organizational culture that will retain the workforce.
18
For this reason, the expansion of MWBE contracting opportunities will not only address equitable development and community
wealth-building goals but will also reduce labor force challenges within the construction industry. Strengthening accountability
mechanisms will ensure policy goals are met; this includes assigning a percentage goal for each applicable City of South Bend project,
per the narrowly tailored inclusion criteria put forth by the United States Supreme Court. This percentage represents the City of South
Bend's firm commitment regarding inclusive economic practices for all residents' benefit.
To achieve the above-stated outcomes, The City of South Bend has established partnerships with the Indiana Department of
Administration (IDOA), South Bend/Elkhart Regional Partnership, Latino American Chamber of Commerce, University of Notre
Dame: South Bend Entrepreneurship and Adversity Program, North Central Indiana Small Business Center at Indiana University
South Bend, the SPARK Program at Saint Mary's College, Indiana Small Business Administration (SBA), and the North Central
Indiana Business Conference for Minority and Woman‐Owned Small Businesses which provides local and regional business owners
exposure to best practices, networking with procurement leadership from major organizations, and financial resources for business
stabilization and scaling.
The City of South Bend must ensure that procurement policies are enforced and effectively implemented. The Office of Diversity &
Inclusion will also increase the utilization of race and gender-neutral measures: engage with community organizations to understand
local demand, promote business networking, and increase the opportunity for prime contractors to reach their MWBE
utilization. Challenges have existed on both the demand and supply side of the MWBE industry.
Leveraging City procurement and contracting alongside anchor institutions like The University of Notre Dame, Beacon Healthcare
Systems, South Bend Community School Corporation, AM General, procurement and contracting to intentionally support MWBE's
located within the City's geographic marketplace, especially those situated within The South Bend Opportunity Zones, and HUB zones
by using a Community Benefits Agreement designed to purposefully close the racial wealth gap for all City of South Bend residents.
South Bend will explore opportunities to identify other certifying agencies within our geographic marketplace whose vetting
requirements meet or exceed IDOA requirements. This vetting process increases our list of viable MWBE firms for local, regional,
and national invitations to bid, quote, or otherwise contract for procurement opportunities with the City of South Bend.
19
Definitions:
Agency means the City's "Purchasing Agency" as established in Ordinance No. 8956-98, which through its named agents has all
powers and duties under Ind. Code 5-22, including purchasing for the City and adopting rules and policies for the City's purchases
consistent with Indiana law.
Annual city goal means the overall target for MWBE utilization in City contracts (prime contracts and subcontracts combined) as
defined by the calculation method used in the City's most recent MWBE Disparity Study. It should be the basis for consideration of
overall annual spending targets for City funds. This target can be the City's goal for its overall spending with certified firms across all
industry categories.
Award means contracts approved by the Board of Public Works for award to a vendor in accordance with The City of South Bend
purchasing the policy.
Bidder means any person, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, association, or Joint Venture seeking to be awarded a
City contract.
City-means the City of South Bend, Indiana.
City's Geographical Marketplace means all of Indiana plus Berrien County, Michigan.
Contract means any contract over $50,000 that is awarded by the City, through any of its agents, boards or commissions for work,
labor, services, supplies, equipment, professional services, goods, construction, or construction-related activities, and materials or any
combination of the foregoing; the term specifically includes but shall not be limited to, any purchase or lease of materials pursuant to
I.C. 36-1-9.5, any public work project authorized pursuant to I.C. 36-1-12-4, or contract in which public bids are not required by law.
Contract goal means a calculation prepared by the Contract Compliance Coordinator with Program Administrator approval that
includes all the following factors: the detailed cost estimate of the work to be performed, or goods purchased; the City's marketplace
as defined in this Section, and the availability of MWBEs/DBEs and non-MWBEs/DBEs in the City's marketplace determined on a
contract-by-contract basis.
20
A Contracting agency means the City department, agency, board, or commission, having the power to award a City contract.
Contractor means any person, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, association, or Joint Venture that has been awarded
a City contract.
Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) means for-profit small business concerns where socially and economically disadvantaged
individuals own at least a 51% interest and also control management and daily business operations. African Americans, Hispanics,
Native Americans, Asian-Pacific and Subcontinent Asian Americans, and women are presumed to be socially and economically
disadvantaged. Other individuals can also qualify as socially and economically disadvantaged on a case-by-case basis. DBEs must
receive DBE certification from the relevant State- generally through the state Uniform Certification Program (UCP). To be regarded
as economically disadvantaged, an individual must have a personal net worth that does not exceed $1.32 million. To be seen as a small
business, a firm must meet SBA size criteria AND have average annual gross receipts not to exceed $23.98 million. Size limits for the
airport concessions DBE program are higher.
Discriminatory practice means the exclusion of a person or persons from equal business opportunity because of age, race, sex,
religion, color, national origin, ancestry, disability, sexual orientation, or gender identity.
Doing business means engaging in for-profit activities in the scope of the expertise of the firm and having a physical location from
which to do so.
Emergency contract means a contract that is awarded on an emergency basis due to a threat of harm to a person or property or threat
of disruption of governmental services.
Emerging business means a firm in a line of business formed around a new product or idea that is in the early stages of development
and or a disadvantaged business that has been formed to meet local market demand. An emerging industry typically consists of just a
few companies and is often centered around a new technology or new industry in the City's established geographic and target
marketplace.
21
Goal-Eligible Contract refers to a contract that can be divided in a way that would allow a subcontractor to perform a commercially
useful function AND that contains work represented by at least one of the NAICS codes listed in Table 4-9 ("Unweighted
Availability") in the 2019 City of South Bend Disparity Study. This Table 4-9 is reproduced as Attachment A to the Program Plan and
will be updated quarterly with new availability estimates. Goal-Eligible Contracts must be bid through the Board of Public Works.
Goal waiver means the acceptance of the lowest responsive and responsible bidder, despite an inability to meet the established
contract goals, as a result of the bidder's demonstration of good faith efforts to achieve the contract goals.
Good faith efforts mean actions undertaken by a contractor to achieve a contract goal, which, by their scope, intensity, and
appropriateness to the objective, can reasonably be expected to fulfill the Program's goals.
Inclusive Procurement and Contracting Board means the board established by City of South Bend Ordinance No. 10693-19.
Joint venture means an association of two or more persons, or any combination of types of business enterprises and persons
numbering two or more, proposing to perform a single for-profit business enterprise, in which each joint venture partner contributes
property, capital, efforts, skill, and knowledge, and in which the MWBE is responsible for a distinct, clearly defined portion of the
work of the Contract and whose share in the capital contribution, control, management, risks, and profits of the joint venture is equal
to its ownership interest. Joint ventures must have an agreement in writing specifying the terms and conditions of the relationships
between the partners and their relationship and responsibility to the Contract.
Local business means a small business located within the City's Target Marketplace, where at least 30% of firm employees live
within the City's Target Marketplace geographic boundaries.
Mayor means the Mayor of the City of South Bend, Indiana.
Minority individual means a person who is a United States citizen and is a member of any of the following:
a) "Black Americans," which includes persons having origins in any of the Black racial groups of Africa, such as African-American,
Sub-Saharan African, and Afro-Caribbean;
22
b) "Hispanic and Latino Americans," which includes persons of Mexican, Puerto Rican, Cuban, Dominican, Central or South
American, or other Spanish or Portuguese culture or origin, regardless of race;
c) "Native Americans," which includes persons who are enrolled members of a federally or state-recognized Indian tribe, Alaska
Natives, or Native Hawaiians;
d) "Asian-Pacific Americans," which includes persons whose origins are from Japan, China, Taiwan, Korea, Burma (Myanmar),
Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia (Kampuchea), Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines, Brunei, Samoa, Guam, the U.S. Trust
Territories of the Pacific Islands (Republic of Palau), Republic of the Northern Marianas Islands, Samoa, Macao, Fiji, Tonga, Kiribati,
Tuvalu, Nauru, Federated States of Micronesia, or Hong Kong;
e) "Subcontinent Asian Americans," which includes persons whose origins are from India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, the
Maldives Islands, Nepal or Sri Lanka;
Minority-Owned Business Enterprise (MBE) means a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, Joint
Venture, or any other business or professional entity:
a) Which is at least 51% owned by one or more minority individuals, or in the case of a publicly owned business, at least 51% of all
classes of the stock of which is owned by one or more minority individuals.
b) Whose management, policies, major decisions, and daily business operations are independently managed and controlled by one or
more such more minority individuals; and
c) For which minority individuals have an interest in the capital, assets, and profits and losses of the business proportionate to the
percentage of ownership.
23
Program Administrator- means the person designated by and reporting directly to the Mayor to support the City's inclusion,
diversity, equity, and access goals. At the passing of this ordinance, the appointee shall be the Diversity Compliance and Inclusion
Officer, the title of whom is subject to future change. The appointee shall work with the City's Inclusive Procurement and Contracting
Board, Legal Department, and contracting agencies to assist in making recommendations, overseeing, implementing, and enforce
Ordinance Chapter 14.5
Small business means a small business defined by the U.S. Small Business Administration size standard relevant to a firm's primary
category of work.
Small Local Emerging Business Enterprise (SLEBE) means a Small Local Emerging Business Enterprise recognized as such by the
City for purposes of this ordinance.
Subcontractor means any person is entering a contract with a contractor to directly furnish services or supplies toward the agreement.
Utilization Plan means the list of Minority and Women Business Enterprises that the bidder commits will be utilized to meet the
contract goals, the scopes of the work, and the dollar values or the percentages of the work to be performed.
Woman/Women means a person or persons who are United States citizens of the female gender.
Woman-Owned Business Enterprise (WBE) means a Small Local Business Enterprise, including a sole proprietorship, partnership,
corporation, limited liability company, Joint Venture, or any other business or professional entity:
a) Which is at least 51% owned by one or more Women, or in the case of a publicly owned business, at least 51% of all classes of the
stock of which is owned by one or more Women;
b) Whose management, policies, major decisions, and daily business operations are independently managed and controlled by one or
more such Women; and
c) For which women have an interest in the capital, assets, and profits and losses of the business proportionate to the percentage of
ownership.
24
APPENDIX
Summary of Procurement Process
I. Procurement Forecast Template – The purpose of this template is for planning purposes; help identify procurement
opportunities and reporting alignment with available projections of future contracting opportunities. Improve the quality of
integration supply and increase MBE/MWBE participation with The City of South Bend.
Please visit our website: https://southbendin.gov/doing-business/ for a variety of resources, including vendor registration, submit a city
contract bid, apply for a business license, and other helpful resources.
(*) Anne Fuchs-has transitioned into a new role as Clerk of the Board of Public Works and taking over the responsibilities of Linda M.
Martin as of January 2021.
25
Commodity Project
Code Description
Estimated Estimated
Value Term
Target Ad Subcontracting
Date Opportunities
FY 2020 Annual Procurement Forecast