HomeMy WebLinkAboutRM 07-21-00I
SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
July 21, 2000
10:00 a.m.
Presiding: Robert W. Hunt, President
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present:
Member Absent:
Legal Counsel:
1308 County -City Building
227 West Jefferson Boulevard
South Bend, Indiana
Mr. Robert W. Hunt, President
Ms. Marcia Jones, Vice - President
Mr. Matt Kahn, Member
Mr. James Caldwell, Member
Mr. Philip J. Faccenda, Secretary
Ms. Cheryl Greene
Redevelopment Staff: Mr. Don Inks, Director
Ms. Debi Perkins, Recording Secretary
Mr. Owen Rock, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Michael Giulioni, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Robert Case, Economic Development Specialist
Ms. Hedy Robinson, Economic Development Specialist
Ms. Sandy Moran, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Tom Nichol, Intern
Mr. Jeff Meyer, Intern
Others: Mayor Stephen Luecke, City of South Bend
Ms. Cathy Roemer, City of South Bend Controller
Ms. Anne Bruneel, Baker & Daniels
Mr. Richard L. Hill, Baker & Daniels
Ms. Ernestine Ligon, Bureau of Housing
Mr. Jim Cierzniak, City of South Bend Resident
Ms. Joyce Boaler, City of South Bend Resident
Mr. Joe Velleman, Indiana Supply Corp.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
a. Commission approval of the Minutes of the
Regular Meeting of July 07, 2000.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded Mr.
Kahn, and unanimously carried, the Commission
,.r• approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
July 07, 2000.
-1-
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF
THE REGULAR MEETING OF JULY 07, 2000
a
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
3. CLAIMS
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted July 21, 2000 for approval.
212 CDBG COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Petty Cash
South Bend Tribune
Century Center Board of Managers
First USA Financial Bank
AEP
Ameritech
Dainty Maid Bake Shop
Marty Scharff s Deli
UIC /Great Lakes CNET
324 FUND
Shamrock Network Design
Abonmarche Consultants Inc.
Meadowbrook Golf Group, Inc.
414 SAMPLE -EWING FUND
Petty Cash
Taplin Environmental
420 SBCDA
Jerome E. Michaels
Wightman Petrie Environmental, Inc.
424 TIF- SBCDA - BUILDING OPERATIONS
CB Richard Ellis
Total
Upon a motion by Mr. Caldwell, seconded by Mr.
Kahn, and unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the Claims submitted July 21, 2000, and
ordered the checks to be released.
-2-
$34.84
$66.91
$50.00
$496.00
$13.23
$27.67
$24.95
$140.60
$650.00
$125.00
$7,800.00
$7,450.00
$16.00
$9,742.21
$5,000.00
$1,300.00
$712.51
$33,649.92
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS
SUBMITTED JULY 21, 2000, AND ORDERED
THE CHECKS TO BE RELEASED
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
4. COMMUNICATIONS
There were no Communications. THERE WERE NO COMMUNICATIONS
5. OLD BUSINESS
There was no Old Business.
6. NEW BUSINESS
THERE WAS NO OLD BUSINESS
Mr. Inks noted that there would be two additions to
the agenda, items 6.n and 6.o. Mr. Hunt requested
that item 6.b be heard first. There were no
objections and the agenda was amended.
b. Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 1784 determining to levy a
special tax in the amount sufficient to pay
lease rental payments in connection with the
lease between the South Bend Redevelopment
Commission and the South Bend
Redevelopment Authority relating to the Hall
of Fame Project.
Ms. Greene noted that the lease was previously
approved by order of the approval of the State
Tax Board in November 1993 and that approval
is sought pursuant to a pledge resolution that was
previously adopted by the Commission on
June 17, 1994.
Mayor Luecke noted that the Hall of Fame is
actually owned by the Redevelopment Authority
and that the authority has issued lease revenue
bonds, which leases the Hall to the
Redevelopment Commission.
Mayor Luecke noted that the Redevelopment
Authority is in the process of refunding the initial
bonds with a new series of bonds that will
-3-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
provide a level payment and a level interest rate.
The new bond will begin to make principle
payments immediately instead of waiting until
the year 2005, when they were initially scheduled
to begin.
Mayor Luecke noted that when the Hall of Fame
was first proposed, we had hoped that we would
be able to satisfy the cost of constructing and
outfitting the Hall through the sale of
sponsorships to corporations. Secondly, we had
pledged tax increment finance dollars to pay off
the lease revenue bonds if the revenue stream
from corporate sponsorship was not sufficient.
Third, the Redevelopment Commission provided
that if the first two sources of funds were
insufficient, the Commission would levy a tax to
make those payments.
Mayor Luecke explained that the City
Administration has come to the conclusion that
the first two sources of revenue are insufficient.
Clearly we have been unable to raise the
sponsorship dollars that we had hoped for, and
tax increment finance dollars are insufficient to
make the payments. We are asking the
Commission to levy the tax to support these
payments so that we can move forward on the
Hall of Fame.
Mayor Luecke noted that in connection with the
refunding, a number of things also are
happening. The original agreement with the
National Football Foundation said that they
would have to pay no dollars in support of the
College Football Hall of Fame here in
Q
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
South Bend, that the City would cover all
obligations, both for the financing of the building
as well as for operating the Hall of Fame.
However, the National Football Foundation has
been a partner in moving the Hall forward and
has made over a million and a half dollars in
contributions toward deficits in running the Hall
since it has been open. What we have today is an
agreement with the National Football Foundation
for the next 5 years that they will take
responsibility for operation of the Hall, so any
shortcomings in operating the Hall will be
covered by the National Football Foundation.
That agreement also calls for hotel /motel tax
dollars to come to the Hall for promotion and
marketing of the Hall. The sponsorship dollars
that are in place in the level that we expect will
be used for operational subsidy of the Hall. The
Professional Sports Development dollars that are
garnered by our local Professional Sports
Development area amount to about $150,000 per
year for the next 5 years. They will be available
for upgrading exhibits in the Hall and the interior
of the Hall of Fame. After that time, we expect
that those dollars will go into an escrow fund to
begin to build dollars to have money available
when it comes time to replace the roof on the
Hall, or to replace heating /air conditioning units,
or expenditures of that nature. I believe that the
agreement separates out responsibilities in an
appropriate manner.
The building is ours and we need to pay for it.
The operation of the Hall really is most important
to the National Football Foundation, though we
-5-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
continue to retain an interest in it. So for them to
step up to that responsibility, we believe that is
an important breakthrough, to be able to
have that commitment from them to cover
operational deficits.
In terms of what the impact of the refinanced
bonds will have on the City of South Bend tax
payers, we project that the bond rate will be some
where around 6% and that it will pay off in the
year 2017. The average impact of the bonds
would be twenty -five cents (.25) on the tax rate,
if so approved. As we calculate that for a
residential property, the average cost would be
around $15.00 for the average residential
property in the City of South Bend. Now
obviously, there are some homes that are below
that, others that are higher than that. One
resident homeowner in South Bend can figure
out what the impact would be for them
individually by roughly multiplying
their current tax bill by 1.3 %, so that if someone
is paying $1000 in property taxes, the increase
for them would be about $13.00; $2000 in
property taxes would be about $26.00 increase
for the year.
Again, we have worked hard to look for other
resources to pay off the Hall of Fame debt. At
this point I believe that this is the best method to
move forward and we appreciate your favorable
consideration of this action.
Mr. Cierzniak addressed the Commission with
the following:
541
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
The request for this body to approve Resolution
No. 1784 is being heralded by the news media
and by boosters such as Project Future's Patrick
McMahon as a much - needed solution to the
nagging problem of how to pay the $17.45
million Hall of Fame debt. Not so,
Commissioners, not so.
What this Resolution really means is that the
College Football Hall of Fame is a failure, one
which must be strapped on to the backs of South
Bend taxpayers for the next 17 years.
But it wasn't supposed to be that way, was it?
Who can forget that bold, confident statement of
Mayor Joe Kernan in his "State of the City
Address" on Jan. 24, 1994: "The one principle
on which there will be no compromise is that the
property taxpayers of the City of South Bend will
never see a bill, not today and not in 20 years,
for the construction or operation of the College
Football Hall of Fame. Period. "?
Do you remember all the "silver bullets" that
would be tried to redeem that reckless promise?
First, there were corporate sponsorships that
were supposed to pay for the Hall's construction.
Only a handful of those sponsorships were
obtained, not even enough to pay for the interest
on the bonds for the years 1996 through 1999.
In fact, the financing loss for those years was
$508,115 as you will be able to see in a revealing
document I'll give you at the conclusion of these
remarks. *(copy of document is attached to the
minutes)
-7-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
When it was apparent by 1994 that sponsorships
were falling far short of expectations, the Hall of
Fame team switched to the second silver bullet to
beguile an uncritical local media which would in
turn sell the Hall project to the public. At a
triumphal news conference on the eve of a key
vote by the Common Council in March 1994,
Mayor Kernan announced that he had $7 million
in "bond guarantees "from the National
Football Foundation and the Friends of the Hall
of Fame, a local group of boosters headed by
Phil Faccenda. Those "guarantees " caused the
South Bend Tribune's editorial board to declare
"He Did It" as the title of yet another lap -dog
editorial praising Kernan for supposedly raising
half the cost of the Hall.
To add luster to the bond guarantee scheme, a
very "risky scheme " as Al Gore might say,
Kernan further announced that two Notre Dame
stalwarts, Phil Faccenda and William Sexton
would embark on a major fund - raising campaign
to put the Hall over the top. Commissioner
Faccenda will no doubt remember that news
conference as Kernan playfully referred to him
as "Dr. " Faccenda. Oh that Joe Kernan! What
a sense of humor!
Within a month or two, it was apparent that the
bond guarantees were meaningless, and, in fact,
were off cially forgiven by the Kernan
administration. They were simply a ruse to gain
a unanimous 9 -0 vote by the Common Council to
approve the eventual $17.95 million bond to
build the Hall. And what about that fund - raising
venture of the Notre Dame Doctors, Faccenda
21:11
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
and Sexton? Not one word was ever said in
public about its results because there was
nothing positive to report. Chalk up another
shell game successfully played by the Kernan
administration.
A couple of years ago, yet another "silver bullet"
was promised as the great redeemer of the Hall
of Fame's flagging fortunes. Host
Communications was brought on board to gain
sponsorships and visibility for the Hall. Almost
nothing is heard these days about the Host group
outside of getting a plug for the Hall in college
football game -day programs. One more silver
bullet fired without hitting the target.
So, August Commissioners, the Hall people, i.e.,
now the Luecke administration, comes before you
today with an unspoken admission offailure: a
financial mess has been made and must be
cleaned up by you. Of course you must approve
Resolution 1784. Bills must be paid. Financial
obligations must be honored. It's time to fold up
the carnival offlim flam efforts to fund the Hall;
it's time to enlist the funds of the local taxpayers
to bail it out. What's one more millstone, one
more overly- expensive failed government project
to fasten around the necks of the taxpayers?
But when you pass this resolution, please don't
patronize us once again by telling us what a
good and necessary project the Hall of Fame has
become. It's a flop, a burden, and a
laughingstock around town. Don't try to tell us
otherwise about South Bend's most famous white
elephant. Thank you!
0
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
Mr. Hunt asked if there was anyone else who had
any comments. Ms. Boaler addressed the
Commission with the following comments:
I throughly agree with everything that
Mr. Cierzniak just said, and I congratulate him
for being one of the few Notre Dame graduates
who is not blinded by football. From the very
beginning, he, I, and others, said it would not
work. However, unlike others, Mr. Cierzniak has
doggedly stuck with his project: researching,
writing, communicating with unflagging ardor.
In case you don't know, he is seen as the local
"hero ". The man who told the truth about this
project and has stood up for the taxpayers
despite vilification by the media and the
administration. A true "hero". Thank you,
Mr. Cierzniak!
Now to remarks allegedly made by Mr. Kish. I
wish he didn't feel the need to say "we think the
attendance is doing just fine, we get better every
year ". No, we don't. He and the Mayor use the
words "think, believe, hope, trust ". We citizens
share none of those sentiments about this project.
We know that it will always be a failure. Should
never have been begun in the first place. It's a
bottomless pit into which our hard earned
dollars and pensions pour and will continue to
cascade for the next 17 to maybe 25 years. When
many of us alive in this room and in this city will
have passed on, leaving this terrible burden,
worthless burden, for our children. How dis-
graceful! At last the Mayor, has publically
stated, "You're correct to say, the Hall doesn't
make any money ". That's an understatement,
Coveleski Stadium, Century Center, the East
-10-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
Race, nor the golf courses. " He might just as
well have added the impending Aquatic Center
and the Studebaker Museum to that list.
The county juvenile detention palace and the
county jail, and of course Riley High School,
also will add to the disgusting compilation of
projects which are robbing us blind. And you in
this room are about to rubberstamp this fiasco.
A blighted monument to jaded jocks, and
irresponsible politicians whose pride has
overcome and overwritten their common sense
and intelligence. It's tragic. Thank God Dr.
Varner is not one of that maddening crowd.
Thank you!
Mr. Hunt asked if there was anyone else who
would like to address the Commission. Seeing
no one, he then asked Mayor Luecke if he would
like to re- address the Commission and he
indicated that he would. Mayor Luecke made the
following remarks:
I guess we are in agreement on one issue and that
is that we've not been able to make the payments
that we had proposed. That is why we are here
before you, we have an obligation to pay for the
building and the taxpayers have been
contributing towards this building for a number
of years through general fund dollars. I believe
it's best to establish the tax rate. Those general
fund dollars are essential for a variety of other
issues facing the City, including police and fire
salaries and benefits, street department and parks
issues. Obviously Ms. Boaler and I have some
philosophical differences in terms of what is
proper and appropriate for cities to invest in. I
-11-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
think it is certainly very appropriate for cities to
invest in facilities like Century Center,
Coveleski, College Football Hall of Fame,
Studebaker Museum. Those add to the quality of
life in this community; they add to a sense of
who we are, where we are. They are important
only for local citizens, but also for job attraction
to this community. I certainly further dispute
calling investing in the juvenile justice center, the
jail and Riley High School inappropriate, unless
I'm mis- reading you (Ms. Boaler) on that. Those
are needed investments in the community as
well. I believe that we have seen many positives
from the Hall of Fame. Is it a failure in terms of
a break -even business? Yes, it is a failure in
terms of a break -even business! Is it a failure in
terms of the community? I do not believe so! I
believe that it will continue to grow and be a
mark of pride for the City of South Bend. I
believe it has spurred additional investment in
the downtown area for the Leighton Center to the
Chocolate Cafe. It has been part of a package,
including the Morris Performing Arts Center,
that might be another, Joyce, that you want to
add to your list in terms of investments. I think
that it has really been part of what we are seeing
as a strong rejuvenation of the downtown and as
a city, we have public benefit and continue to try
to attract private investment to follow -up on that,
to make this a better community. So, thank you
for your consideration.
Mr. Hunt asked if there were any further
comments from the Commissioners. There were
none. Mr. Hunt noted that the Commission has a
fiscal responsibility to the City of South Bend to
protect their good standing in the credit market.
-12-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
b. continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Caldwell, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 1784
determining to levy a special tax in an amount
sufficient to pay lease rental payments in
connection with the lease between the South
Bend Redevelopment Commission and the South
Bend Redevelopment Authority relating to the
Hall of Fame Project.
a. Filing of Resolution No. 1783, a Resolution of
the South Bend Redevelopment Commission
amending the South Bend Central
Development Area acquisition list and setting
a public hearing for August 04, 2000 at
10:00 a.m.
Mr. Inks noted that Resolution No. 1783 amends
the South Bend Redevelopment Area by adding
to acquisition list the property located at 710 N.
Niles Ave. All interested parties have been
notified. We request that the Commission set a
Public Hearing date of August 04, 2000 at 10:00
a.m.
c. Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 1785, approving an application
for real property tax deduction for property
at Lot 14, US 31 Industrial Park. (Draga
Investments, LLC (Indiana Supply Corp.))
Ms. Moran presented the staff report for
Resolution No. 1785. She noted that the
petitioner proposes to build a 25,200 sq. ft.
distribution facility. The building will be
constructed on approximately 3.4 acres of land.
-13-
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION
NO. 1784 DETERMINING TO LEVY A SPECIAL
TAX IN AN AMOUNT SUFFICIENT TO PAY
LEASE RENTAL PAYMENTS IN CONNECTION
WITH THE LEASE BETWEEN THE SOUTH
BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION AND
THE SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY RELATING TO THE HALL OF
FAME PROJECT
FILING OF RESOLUTION NO. 1783; A PUBLIC
HEARING DATE IS SET FOR AUGUST 04, 2000
AT 10:00 A.M.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
c. continued...
The total cost for the building will be an
estimated $1,000,000 and will be used as a
warehouse and offices for Indiana Supply Corp.
It is estimated that the project will create six to
eight new permanent jobs within the first year,
representing a new annual payroll of $225,000 to
$250,000 and will maintain six to eight existing
permanent full -time jobs with an annual payroll
of $225,000 - $250,000. The petitioner has not
been granted any previous tax abatements. The
property is properly zoned for the proposed use
and is located in the Airport Economic
Development Area.
Mr. Velleman stated that Indiana Supply Corp. is
ASK a wholesale business for heating and air -
conditioning supplies, dealing with Trane furnace
products. He noted that presently the company
has $2.5 million in sales in this area.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 1785
approving an application for real property tax
deduction for property at Lot 14, US 31
Industrial Park. (Draga Investments, LLC
(Indiana Supply Corp.))
d. Commission approval requested for
Certificate of Waiver in connection with the
Rental Rehab Loan Program for property
located at 619 Sherman. (Neighborhood
Housing Services)
Mr. Inks noted that item 6.d and 6.e were
Certificates of Waiver in connection with the
-14-
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION
NO. 1785 APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR
REAL PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR
PROPERTY AT LOT 14, US 31 INDUSTRIAL
PARK (DRAGA INVESTMENTS, LLC (INDIANA
SUPPLY CORP.))
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
d. continued...
Rental Rehab Loan Program and that
Ms. Ligon was present to answer any questions
concerning the two items.
This Certificate of Waiver is for Neighborhood
Housing Services for property at 619 Sherman.
The amount to be waived is $1 ,763.47 as of
January 5, 2000.
Upon a motion by Mr. Caldwell, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Certificate of Waiver
in connection with the Rental Rehab Loan
Program for property located at 619 Sherman.
(Neighborhood Housing Services)
e. Commission approval requested for
Certificate of Waiver in connection with the
Rental Rehab Loan Program for property
located at 1526 S. Webster. (Neighborhood
Housing Services)
This Certificate of Waiver is for Neighborhood
Housing Services for property located at 1526 S.
Webster. The amount to be waived is $850.00 as
of February 21, 2000.
f. Commission approval requested for Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 310 E.
Bowman St. (Cleo Mitchell)
Mr. Inks stated this is a request for approval for
Loan in the amount of $6,350 for home repairs
for property located at 310 E. Bowman St. The
grant amount is $6,146.25.
-15-
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CERTIFICATE
OF WAIVER IN CONNECTION WITH THE
RENTAL REHAB LOAN PROGRAM FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 619 SHERMAN
(NEIGHBORHOOD HOUSING SERVICES)
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CERTIFICATE
OF WAIVER IN CONNECTION WITH THE
RENTAL REHAB LOAN PROGRAM FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1526 S. WEBSTER
(NEIGHBORHOOD HOUSING SERVICES)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
E continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for a Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 310 E.
Bowman St. (Cleo Mitchell)
g. Commission approval requested for Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 840 S. 28`h St.
(Ronald R. Cox & Shelly E. Cox)
Mr. Inks stated this is a request for approval for a
Loan in the amount of $4,450 for home repairs
for property located at 840 S. 28' St. The grant
amount is $4,279.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for a Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 840 S. 28`' St.
(Ronald R.Cox & Shelly E. Cox)
h. Commission approval requested for Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 115 N. Sadie.
(Charles Orgain)
Mr. Inks stated this is a request for approval for
Loan in the amount of $8,750 for home repairs
for property located at 115 N. Sadie. The grant
amount is $7,500.
-16-
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
A LOAN AND GRANT IN CONNECTION WITH
THE AFFORDABLE LOAN PROGRAM FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 310 E. BOWMAN ST.
(CLEO MITCHELL)
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
A LOAN AND GRANT IN CONNECTION WITH
THE AFFORDABLE LOAN PROGRAM FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 840 S. 28TM ST.
(RONALD R. COX & SHELLY E. COX)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
h. continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for a Loan and
Grant in connection with the Affordable Loan
Program for property located at 115 N. Sadie.
(Charles Orgain)
i. Commission approval requested for proposal
for professional services in the South Bend
Central Development Area. (Appraisal of
Crescent Ave. Properties)
Mr. Giulioni gave a staff report on items 6.I, 6j,
61, 6.1, and 6.m.
Mr. Giulioni noted that this item was tabled at
the last meeting due to the unavailability of
appraisers who were to submit quotations. He
stated that only two submissions were provided.
The first was from Jerry E. Michaels for $1,500.
The second was from Gregory P. Barkley of Baer
Barkley & Co. for $2,500. Both appraisers are
MAI certified and both of the proposals are
within the rate which we would normally pay for
professional appraisal services. Two appraisals
are needed for each property. Mr. Giulioni
recommended the Commission approve both
appraisers to complete the necessary work.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the proposals for
professional services in the South Bend Central
Development Area.(Appraisal of Crescent Ave.
Properties)
-17-
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
A LOAN AND GRANT IN CONNECTION WITH
THE AFFORDABLE LOAN PROGRAM FOR
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 115 N. SADIE
(CHARLES ORGAIN)
COMMISSION APPROVED THE PROPOSALS
FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES IN THE
SOUTH BEND CENTRAL DEVELOPMENT
AREA (APPRAISAL OF CRESCENT AVE.
PROPERTIES)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
j. Commission approval requested for proposal
for professional services in the South Bend
Central Development Area. (Removal of
Dead/Dying Tree at 613 South St.)
Mr. Giulioni asked that this item be tabled due to
lack of estimates from tree removal services.
k. Commission approval requested for proposal
for professional services in the South Bend
Central Development Area. (General lawn
maintenance of various South Bend Central
Development Area properties)
Mr. Giulioni noted that certain properties owned
by the Redevelopment Commission are not
receiving the attention to their exterior property
maintenance that they deserve. To ensure that
these properties are better taken care of, the staff
recommended that the Commission retain a
private company to be responsible for the
necessary maintenance, such as grass cutting and
weed control. He also noted that due to the
current seasonal demand for landscape
maintenance, the staff was only able to get one
quote. That quote was provided by H.S. Altman
Inc. The quote includes an initial clean-up and
then bi- weekly care. The cost of the initial clean
up will be approximately $225.00 for Parcel B
and $220.00 for ParcelC. Parcel A will not have
an initial clean-up cost. The cost of the bi-
weekly care will be $55.00 per parcel. Mr.
Giulioni stated that the staff considers the
estimate provided to be reasonable and
recommended that the Commission authorize
H.S. Altman, Inc. to proceed with the clean-up.
-18-
COMMISSION TABLED ITEM 6.J
TO THE NEXT MEETING ON
AUGUST 04, 2000
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
k. continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Caldwell, seconded by
Ms. Jones and unanimously, the Commission
approved the proposal for professional services
in the South Bend Central Development Area.
(General lawn maintenance of various South
Bend Central Development Area Properties)
1. Commission approval requested for proposal
for professional services in the South Bend
Central Development Area. (Lease Rate
Analysis for Palais Royale Retail Space)
Mr. Giulioni requested that this item be tabled.
m. Commission approval requested for proposal
CW for professional services in the South Bend
Central Development Area. (Lease Rate
Analysis for the Wayne St. Garage Retail
Space)
Mr. Giulioni requested that this item be tabled.
n. Commission approval requested for
Satisfaction of Obligation and Release of
Mortgage for the property located at 916
South Bend Avenue.
Ms. Greene explained that the Satisfaction of
Obligation and Release of Mortgage relates to
the Rehabilitation Loan Program. It declares
mortgage has been satisfied.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
-19-
COMMISSION TABLED THIS ITEM TO THE
NEXT MEETING ON AUGUST 04, 2000
COMMISSION TABLED THIS ITEM TO THE
NEXT MEETING ON AUGUST 04, 2000
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
6. NEW BUSINESS (CONT.)
n. continued...
Satisfaction of Obligation and Release of COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
Mortgage for the property at 916 South Bend SATISFACTION OF OBLIGATION AND
RELEASE OF MORTGAGE FOR THE
Ave. PROPERTY AT 916 SOUTH BEND AVE.
o. Commission approval requested for Contract
for Sale of Land for Private Development in
the Sample -Ewing Development Area.
(Charles S. Hayes)
Mr. Inks noted that the sale was previously
approved and that this is the Contract for the Sale
of Land. The purchase price is $1500.
Ms. Greene noted that all of the terms and
conditions of the agreed upon improvements are
listed in the Contract.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED THE CONTRACT
Mr. Caldwell and unanimously carried, the FOR SALE OF LAND FOR PRIVATE
DEVELOPMENT IN THE SAMPLE -EWING
Commission approved the Contract for Sale of DEVELOPMENT AREA (CHARLES S. HAYES)
Land for Private Development in the Sample -
Ewing Development Area. (Charles S. Hayes)
7. PROGRESS REPORTS
Mr. Inks reported that the staff is attempting to PROGRESS REPORTS
get the Commission packets out on Friday, the
week before the next meeting. He stated that it
may take a while to get to that point, but the staff
is working towards it. He also reported that the
staff is working on mapping out all of the
properties that Redevelopment owns. The
property list is being updated and then the
properties will be placed on a map.
Mr. Inks reported that the staff is reviewing the
-20-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting -July 21, 2000
7. PROGRESS REPORTS (CONT.)
lease books and the contract books in order to pull
together a comprehensive list of all of the leases with
the pertinent details of those leases and also get a list
of obligations from outstanding contracts. He also
reported that in a couple of weeks the staff would
start on the Economic Development Plan, which will
be a lengthy process. He noted that he is developing
a plan to increase our response time and improve
customer service.
Mr. Inks reported that the Tax Abatement Report
will only be highlighted at the Commission meetings
in order to shorten the meeting times. He noted that
he and Ms. Greene are working together to define
what the requirements are for bids and quotes with
the Redevelopment Commission and whatever
changes come up would brought before the
Commission for approval.
Mr. Inks reported that he had asked the Financial and
Program Management Division to put together a
balance sheet for Redevelopment. It probably will
not be until 2001.
8. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
The next Regular Meeting of the Redevelopment
Commission is scheduled for August 04, 2000, at
10:00 a.m.
• 1 Z�I1 X001 OWN I
There being no further business to come before the
Redevelopment Commission, Ms. Jones made a
motion that the meeting be adjourned. Mr. Kahn
seconded the motion and the meeting was adjourned
at 10:4 .
Robert W. Hunt, President
-21-
NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
ADJOURNMENT
Don Inks, Director