HomeMy WebLinkAboutSeptember 2001John Oxian, President
South Bend and St. Joseph County
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
227 WEST JEFFERSON BLVD.
SOUTH BEND, IN 46601-1830
Phone: 219-235-9798 Fax: 219-235-9578
e-mail: historic@michiana.org
A Certified Local Government
NOTICE
ON MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 20015
Rhonda Saunders, Director
THERE WILL BE AN EXECUTIVE SESSION MEETING AT 8:30 PM, IMME-
DIATELY FOLLOWING THE REGULARLY SCHEDULED MONTHLY MEETING OF
THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION.
THIS NOTICE IS BEING GIVEN PURSUANT TO INDIANA CODE 5-14-1.5-
6.1(b)(2)(B)
Martha Choitz
Mary Jane Chase
Richard Morrison
COMMISSIONERS
Richard Helmus
Catherine Hostetler (Vice -President)
Joann Sporleder (Historic Architect)
Jerry Weiner (Treasurer)
Gerald Ujdak (Secretary)
Thomas Bodnar(Attomey)
7th Floor County -City Building
Monday, September 17, 2001 7:30 PM
I. Call to Order
II. Public Hearing
A. CERTIFICATES OF APPROPRIATENESS:
1. 2001-0803-2(b); 938 Riverside Drive
2. 2001-0824; Leeper Park—Riverside Drive
between Michigan & Bartlett
3. 2001-0825; 639 Lincoln Way East
4. 2001-0826; 209 North Shore Drive
5. 2001-0828; 519 Edgewater Drive
6. 2001-0829; 1624 East Wayne Street
7. 2001-0830; 721 Lincoln Way East;
8. 2001-0906; 1636 Lincoln Way West
9. 2001-0907; 510 River Avenue
B. Proposed Local Landmarks, 2nd Reading
1. Park Avenue
2. 2716 Vine Street (Old Nuner School)
III. Regular Business
A. Approval of Minutes (Regular August Meeting,
and Special Meetings Sept. 4 and Sept. 11)
B. Treasurer's Report
C. Correspondence
D. Committee Reports / Architectural Historian Report
E Legal
F. Staff Reports / C. of A. Approvals
VI. Hearing of Visitors
VII. Old Business
VIII. New Business
IX. Announcements and Miscellaneous Matters
SOUTH BEND & SAINT JOSEPH COUNTY
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
/7
2t 2001 MEETING
GUESTS: PLEASE SIGN THIS LIST SO YOUR PRESENCE CAN
BE NOTED FOR OUR MINUTES
co c-
, ft -i l/ Q��� ����
JOW Duee-
SOUTH BEND & SAINT JOSEPH COUNTY
HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 11, 2001 MEETING
GUESTS: PLEASE SIGN THIS LIST SO YOUR PRESENCE CAN
BE NOTED FOR OUR MINUTES
Gam. oma,
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number: 2001-0803-2(b)
Property Location: 938 Riverside Drive
South Bend, IN
Property Owner: Jan Pilarski & Jay Tidmarsh
Landmark or District Designation: Local Historic District — Riverside Drive
Rating: C-9
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
Built in 1900 or 1903, by Andrew DuShane, a pioneer and real estate developer. It is
called the Slusser House after its early occupants. Anne DuShane Nuner, a relative of the
locally -famous John Nuner who was such a pioneering founder of the local school system,
inherited the house from her grandfather, Andrew DuShane, upon his death, and rented the house
out, until 1927, when she sold it to George E.- Davies, president and part owner of the Davies
Laundry & Cleaning Co, and also the Superior Laundry Co. It is an American Foursquare with a
covered porch the full width of the house, and with dormers in the roof. In the last ten years or
so, the [present owners have done a great number of good things to this house, substantially
enhancing its appearance and structure.
APPLICATION: The owners' next planned repair is replacement of garage doors, and this
Application is for approval of that project. Previous repairs having been extensive, the cost of
new doors is a significant concern, and they are considering metal doors. If photos or contractor
estimates are not available by Monday evening's meeting, they will be requesting that this
Application be tabled until next month.
RECOMMENDATION
The Preservation Guidelines follow the Rehabilitation Model.
We cannot make a specific recommendation until the owners have more specific data regarding
the planned replacement. We do, however, note that the owners' previous improvements have
vastly improved the condition of the building, and that the present garage doors are likely not
adequate for wet, rough weather next winter.
O �/
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number: 2001-0824
Property Location: Leeper Park East
Property Owner: City of South Bend
Landmark or District Designation: Leeper Park Historic District
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
Leeper Park is a designed landscape located in South Bend, Indiana in a
residential area immediately north of the downtown commercial district of the city. The
park is situated on a tract of land at the base of a gently sloping terrace, fronting on the
St. Joseph River. The site is bounded by the river on the north and east, Bartlet Street
and Park Lane on the south; the western boundary of the park is defined by the toe of a
steeply sloping hill at the top of which are the rear yards of homes of the city's Chapin
Park Historic District. The park was designed by renowned landscape designer George
Kessler. He laid out the plans of the park in 1912. In 1895; the City of South Bend
purchased land east of Michigan Street and north of Bartlett Street for the purposes of
developing a well field and water pumping facility. This purchase formed the nucleus of
Leeper Park. In 1904, the city constructed a park drive along the riverfront extending
along the eastern section and under the old Leeper (Michigan Street) Bridge. The
roadway was officially named Riverside Drive in 1909.
RECOMMENDATION
The applicant is requesting the addition of new asphalt parking and streets along
Riverside Drive between Bartlett and Michigan Streets, which will include erosion
control and landscaping. This expanded parking should correct existing problems in the
adjacent neighborhood. No trees will be removed and only a few bushes will be
replaced. The design of the new lighting fixtures will match the existing lighting
structures. The staff recommends the approval of this project.
Stephen J. Luecke, Mayor
Bureau of Traffic and Lighting
SIGNAL DIVISION
Ray Dalgliesh, Signal Supervisor
November 19, 1999
TO: All individuals interested in Historic Lights
RE: City Historic for East Wayne.
1. Concrete Fixture: Herwig Lighting HWJ-33A-7" Post lantern w/7" post fitter -cast
aluminum alloy #356, dark green finish, crystal moss glass panels w/4 -mil
Armorgard, sealed with silicone, solid hinged roof w/gaskets, 70 watt Metal
Halide ballast kit, High Power Factor, 120 Volt (less lamp), medium base socket,
stainless steel screws.
a. Comer lights to have #275 Acrylic Type V refractor w/spun aluminum
ballast cover.
b. Mid or House Lights to have #275 Acrylic Type III refractor w/spun'
aluminum ballast cover.
2. Fiberglass Fixture: Same as above except 3" tenon fitter.
3. Concrete Poles: Traditional Concrete Inc. DB71 0 direct burial 700 series 10' Exposed
Pea Gravel Concrete Light Pole with Tip Inserts and Acrylic Sealer with Mounted
6 3/4" Tenon Rings.
4. Fiberglass Poles: Shakespeare Presidential Series. BP 20 -14.5' -F -S-1-2. Washington
Style, direct burial base.
5. Bulbs: Osrarn Sylvania Metalarc; Pro -Tech MP70/C/U/Med, with a color rendering
index of 75 and a color temp of 3000k. Initial lumens of 4800 and a Mean lumens
of 3600. ANSI number M98. Average life of 15,000 hours.
Thank You
Ray Dalgliesh
1045 West Sample Street - South Bend, Indiana 46619 - (219)235-9926 - Fax 235-9678 - TDD (219)235-5567
� r
uj ..
y
LAM
a g
� ` E w* s _"7► . i • � ; � i��. '� �+ � ` .,.E � �.'
Vt
��" "rA'a° ,,• i . . � � t .raw * h! Y �!4 �
.,i `'..t,,, "r ,."yw�' r:3:,.. fir, ` • w �J ,+1� � ` :mss t . • � '
•�- a , " e s4- ~1
�•,'�.�„-.. ., � it ,:; s,... � ,., . » .�
' *�. ., � a♦ .� a��A 'gyp., y`!i `a �~��+e��_� _
Y x
1 ��..r t. `'art #"t' \}} {`3 t `,�,� + r 1..;•
+� �"".y it ,.t^�. , • wry - «• •. A i .Y •« • .. Yom, -i.
E a�*a y.� � ~� . i ♦ �t J E . � a .. o
i� � `*'��"� � �� jf ; � `�'�� `� r . �k o�r� t y' ��� •, *.���� f �+t` • '..rtltys''Iy
XVIII. WARRANTY
A. Prevailing Specifications: None
B. Additions:
All parts shall include the following:
a. Performance specifications;
b. Bill of Materials;
c. Warranties on all parts; and
d. Installation and safety requirements.
XIX. PLANS
A. Design and Construction Standards
B. Additions:
1. The plans consist of X Sheets, including the title sheet.
2. The work shall conform to the plans.
3. The drawings are schematic in nature. The CONTRACTOR is responsible for exact
placement of the curb, conduit, and lighting.
4. The CONTRACTOR is responsible for estimating dimensions and quantities of
materials.
5. In the event that the Special Provisions and the Plans conflict, the Special Provisions
shall govern.
XX. DESCRIPTION OF WORK
A. Prevailing Specifications: None
B. Additions:
1. Construct approximately twenty-six (26) nine (9) foot wide by twenty (20) foot long
asphalt standard parking spaces and nine (9) twenty (20) foot wide by nine (nine) foot
long parallel parking spaces along the East side of Riverside Drive between Michigan
Street and Bartlett Street. This includes grading and compacting the existing ground,
placing and compacting four (4) inches of No. 53 crushed concrete as a sub -base,
placing and compacting a minimum of four (4) inches of HMA No. 5 base, and
placing and compacting a minimum of one (1) inch of HMA No. 11 Limestone
Surface.
2. A standard concrete curb will be placed on the east side of the parking spaces as
shown on the plans.
3. Construct the new parking spaces with a slope that provides drainage to the adjacent
non -asphalted areas. The Contractor will place sod from the edge of curb to the edge
of pavement in the designated drainage areas. This will include all necessary site
preparation.
SP -7
4. The inst"n of twelve new street lights (see plmmiiiDr type of pole, fixture, and
placemenwi r ations) along the curbed edge of the --parking areas. The conduit
containing the electric service shall be three (3) inch PVC Conduit at a minimum
depth of three (3) feet. The Contractor will be responsible for the exact placement
of the conduit as to not effect any trees that remain in the parking area. The electric
feed will be obtained from the existing line located on a pole near the bridge to
Leeper Island (as shown on the plans). The City will contact AEP prior to
construction for placement of a meter.
5. Compact fills and subbase materials 100 % compaction. Testing will be done by
nuclear gauge. Testing and inspection will be accomplished by the Department of
Public Works. The department personnel are certified for earthwork and bituminous
inspection and testing by INDOT.
XXI. TEMPORARY EROSION CONTROL,
A. Prevailing Specifications: 1999, INDOT Standard Specifications Section 205
B. Additions:
1. The Contractor shall be responsible for the preparation of the Erosion Control Plan,
as required by 107.14.1 of the Prevailing Specifications. Temporary Erosion Control
shall include the cost of the preparation of the plan, payment of fees and charges
associated with the filing ofsaid permit and legal advertisement, and implementation
of the plan, including maintenance of the erosion control elements. Should the
Contractor fail to' comply with the requirements of any agency having lawful
jurisdiction over the effectiveness of the Erosion Control Plan, or fail to adequately
implement or maintain the the elements of the plan, the Contractor shall be solely
responsible for fines, imprisonment or any other penalties lawfully imposed
therefore.
XXII. HOT MIX ASPHALT (HMAI:
A. Prevailing Specifications: 1999, INDOT, Standard Specifications Section 402.
B. Additions to Section 402:
1. The CONTRACTOR shall submit a job mix formula for approval five (5) calendar
days prior to any mix placed. The contractor shall notify the City 48 hours prior to
placing any asphalt. Mix placed without notification will be subject to no payment.
2. The CONTRACTOR shall hire an outside approved testing laboratory to perform
testing. Test results shall be given to the City within 48 hours. A City representative
shall be present and designate a random location for sample. A representative from
testing lab shall take immediate possession of sample taken and sign City form.
3. A minium of one (1) plate sample, for each type of mix placed shall be taken for each
day that 50 tons is placed, for more than 500 tons per day, one (1) sample for each
500 tons.
JUL 26 IOU id: Jlu
• - Application
S°U7Ne� - for-
°� Certificate of Appropriateness
Is, a , a $istoric Pretervution Commission of South Bend & St- Joseph County
I+ 227 West Jefferson Blvd - R.%,1 1123 — South Bend fN 46601-1930
Phone: 219-23:-9795 Fax: 219-235-9578 e -Ionil: historic a michiana.org
A Certified Local Government
OFFICE(ISEONLY.»»>U0 v0'rC(I&IVU,I'LANYE.YTRIESCOWAINEDw'ruisBOX«««OFFICEUSEONLY
Data Received !R -r � G 20.!�Y' Application Number: toot- 0 ?e2
Past Reviews: 0 'YES (JA'ii • r tas/ earn. n �NO
Zoning Type:
Staff Approval authorlred by:__.__..__
Historic Commission Review Date:
Local Landmark
National Register District c-6 -•r.
Lot Sicc
•title:
nNational Landmark
L"41 Historic District rk- : "",-/X
XC
Certificate of Appropriateness:
11 Denied El rabled Seat To Committee
11 Approved and issued
Address of Property for proposed work:
S th -B en ' d
°0
209 North Shore Drive
W1i YMrAYWllifl N(mA/
City: ou Township:
Name of PropertyOw»er(s):/.at.-r,- Eric and Mary Morgan
Address of Property Owner: 209 North Shore Drive
Contractors) Name: Gary Van Overberghe
Contract Company Name- Van Overberghe Builders,
Inc.
Contractor Address: 53922 Olive Road city: South Bend, IN 46628
Contractarrs Phone No: 219-289-0341 ' Owner's Phone No: 219-246-0639
Current Use of Building: Single family
(S—.h r wmurct.l-Go.o.—I. Industrial. parent.cin
Type of Building Construction: Wood frame
- (Wood f--Rika-.Ylone- Srrel. Co.erctt.fltkarl
Proposed Work: El Inkind [] Landscape l"New tK ft placement(auta-und/
(rnNw shot om ka: way b. ch.ck.d/
Dcmolition (Complerinn of St TWAte Form Also Re4uired)
Description of Proposed Work- New direct vent fireplace on east
side of residence, new 161 garage door in lieu of
two 81 garage doors, replace roof
Owner/Contractor: Fax: 219-289-1408 a-mzil:
rlj.yBlc. ZAAo
(//-sy/tgna�tu `o weer Signature *(Contractor
APPLICAT101\ jfQUlUFMLN'1S ARE LISTED ON REVERSE SIDE.
Any and alt business of this office I handled vitt a-nulll and firms with lens! preference m U.S. Aral!
Description of Work and Materials
1. New Fireplace on eastside of residence.
We will create a five-foot opening in the eastside wall of the residence. The floor will be extended
out one foot six inches to carry the weight of the new direct vent fireplace. The fireplace will be
installed and a three foot six inch wall will be built around the firebox, and a shed type roof will be
constructed on top of the short walls. The exterior of the fireplace will be finished to match the
existing house (# 1 cedar shakes, also painted to match existing house). The interior of the
fireplace will be finished with a wood mantel to keep with the elegant yet simple look of the
interior of the house.
2. New 16' garage door in lieu of two 8' garage doors.
Remove two 8' wood panel garage doors. Remove center post of those two doors; install a header
to span removed post. Reframe opening to accept a 16' wood garage door of same style and panel
layout.
3. Replace roof.
Remove existing shingles on roof down to the plank board sheeting, install ''/z" sheeting on entire
roof re -shingle roof with Certain Teed Landmark 30 Dimensional Laminated Shingles. Color to
be selected at future date.
1a
.1 =
� .. ,, jam.'
lap
40k.
40
0 Amp
it
PC T V
14
t
4o
+
ho
IL
0 .06
M
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number:
Property Location:
519 Edgewater Drive
Property Owner: William & Laurel Cochrane
Landmark or District Designation: Edgewater Place Historic District
Rating:
Contributing
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
The development of the neighborhood began in 1871 with the plating of a section
along the road leading to Mishawaka. In 1875, five houses were shows along the road.
Most of the district, however, was left undeveloped until the platting of the Edgewater
Place Addition in 1919 by Whitcomb and Keller, two of South Bend's important early
developers and realtors. The home was built in 1919, owned by Whitcomb & Keller and
rented until 1930. In that year, it was sold to Dow & Hazel Keim. He ran the Tyler-
Keim Tire Company. % � ` -T� /�3/
RECOMMENDATION
The homeowners are asking to replace the existing aluminum siding with vinyl
siding of the same eight (8) inch width. They also plan to replace selected wood -sash
windows with like wooden -sash windows. The standards and guidelines for this
neighborhood state that existing exterior building materials shall be retained. The staff
recommends approval. However, we would also suggest that when the existing siding is
removed, and if the origional wood is a smaller reveal, that the owners match the
origional wood if the cost remains within their budget..
Proposal for Renovation
1624 East Wayne Street
South Bend, Indiana 46615
Owner: The Episcopal Cathedral of St. James
Occupant: The Very Rev. Frederick Mann and family
Narrative Explanation
1. History
The house at 1624 East Wayne Street was built in 1.951. The accompanying site plan is a copy
of the original in possession of the Episcopal Cathedral of St. James. At the time of its
construction, there was no porch on the back of the house. Our research shows that the
porch was added about nine years after construction, when the property was purchased by
the second owner. A stab was poured and a screen enclosure created with a,corrugated
fiberglass roof. Dimensions of the porch are 11'x23'.
Footers were not used in pouring the porch stab and, over the years the stab has c i racked and
begun to pull away from the wall of the house. The wood of the screen porch is in advanced
stages of dryrot.
In 1993, the house was re -roofed and the roof line was extended over the porch to create a
continuous roof line. Skylights were added over the porch at that time.
11. Proposal '
The cathedral desires to create a year-round "sunroom" using the existing porch space and
dimensions. After seeking several bids, the cathedral representative, Mr. Jack Swope, has
chosen American Sunspace Additions to complete this project. This project as two elements:
A. The Porch
The attached construction contract will provide details. The existing roof will be utilized
along with the existing wall of the house - remodeled to have a more indoor appearance.
The concrete stab will be removed and replaced with a wooden floor that will be covered
with either indoor/outdoor carpeting or high grade vinyl flooring.
The screen area wilt be replaced with an eighteen inch "kneewall" whose external finish will
match the siding of the house, thus providing an aesthetic took of continuity with the rest of
the house. Instead of screen, double pain sliding window panels wilt be used that wilt match
exactly the existing windows of the house. The contractor will provide a picture of similar
construction following the submission of this application.
B. -House Siding
Current siding is eight inch aluminum. The original siding of the house was five inch wood
stat siding. The aluminum siding was added prior to the cathedral purchasing the house in
1970 for the residence of its Dean and family. There is no insulation between the siding and
the basic walls of the house. No former siding exists under the aluminum. The current
condition creates both extremes of heat and cold along with moisture to be present inside the
house - costing a great deal to both heat and cool the residence.
American Sunspace will reside the house, removing existing aluminum siding and replacing
with double -four vinyl siding that will exactly match that of the new garage, for which a
siding variance was obtained on 13 August. Foam board will be placed between house wall
and siding to provide an insulation factor of R-4 to R-8 (determined by what thickness of
board can be used). The trim will remain white as it is currently and peak vents will be
replaced with vinyl vents that match the current design. All other external features
(stonework, doors, etc.) will remain as they are presently.
ili. Conclusion
Our desire is to have a home that fits well within the existing neighborhood and conforms
more closely with the features of houses around it. We also want to provide our residents
with a home that is low maintenance and environmentally comfortable.. We want to provide
more living space for the family and for doing the kinds of entertaining often required of the
cathedral dean for the parish and diocese. The proposed changes will enhance the house and
its appearance while maintaining its historic lines and character.
We thank the Commission for its consideration and the opportunity to improve our property
and be part of a fine neighborhood in South Bend.
The Very Rev. Frederick E. Mann .
For the Facilities Commission of the Episcopal Cathedral of St. James
Project Coordinators: Mr. Jack Swope
Mr. Kirk Philippsen
Dr. Michael McCrea
Contractor representative: Mr. Scott Kopinski, American Sunspace Additions
. - `
r,
+� I� • �t�Y , F� Y
3^* u�th Bdnd Indiaae� _.'lo -.a �r�.�`�"�5
a t s� ., 4
h beretyy certify th��t' I hava purv4 ed, tkh� reare tete shaxzi" o the eket`ch
tax ktmnd'. that
:' tl�e m2e�+ lt�a 9141i s tare• �orri�st cad thi t the buf idirigs ' t to r
' e. I'i•►•w"trc �Y ^+I+flN n'- v++d M+�. 'e� 11 i : : tJ •4, A, ' .
i i '
Fr i.. s j �5 ;�
1.
S ..4 s i c c•7a n ,.• ay} 1i
E ,' a ••a r a a. r a t'•... s1' ��� yTi Li, S 'skr•
r T 4 ..} $ R - J3 t - t •i j E;';' 1 .. 1 t�Il O,
i. '� J t v' Y y t attw t i+Ji I'll -'--t t "x`
r.
'i �':'_'.�Z' �' *�-."' #-- � % *'. . . - � - ,
a # r t ti 1 .. + 1y1 -^.L� f ;y •� { '•+ .'f'r+*+b a t + � . i, }_ �5 .
#. 1 fi r
11,aa- - t t.1, /y�i�.4. j/+f' d -...- fL is i 71r 'r - at r f ;;N;a "�.Y ld„
" _ 1 r.' , rj*, A.-
I. ��q (I'4�I 1 T J- + -4 Y aCkitnt� a
•t 4..j t 7 . . m . 'I" 7._T'W.'__.--__i'o.' .,%"!;t
, T) tt +t t +•- r t r r % ..+t. S - %j _ t S t- +S'y.��" Lk t
.��.,�4 V WA .'e
at» t t. L 11;-Y ♦t - J
�.- ;2.'._.'___+y..� a ; 4� r. ._f ,r a S t f Sy -.,f i. -yk
i + { - a 7 tit _a•. t rY rl�'�r'1.` .. t
t
roo
t «f a t I�/I+R,(/J�`14 i.. f. tCf'l+'s r. 5.. 4 % t1,+ ��M r thrat �}j"'a-
t E•,S �.t .rI.J .r t r - r , }E.vP h a .`1 T "K f}? ..
�. (7b '' �►�r,�' `' #' 3
M -° �f r r ltftat7� �_7 ` + fr s'}�r .Y :< L. •�t�jf���aST�+,�:
rv_ < + til. )'�T :f J it a •t fi`r it ♦. f �i� ti a TM�'�_r_�
tt v. 4,. 1, t - .. aJ -.A t,+}1�, 2by-
./' a .rw.F ♦ t _ >t a_v ; r T;(� Y t fr'i Y ii + + t 3 {_•�`� ) +♦
.y.} !f t t a ,1 s p i ry u t T\ . Ai-� i ri t._i'k-3• .,3 4 yl s+"`tom 7v.a:rt 3.
1.i ,r .4 r t+f. J. .'•'r i 'c y. T. .+ > r,5 }' '+s ' ,{ r fF r . N 1 - T' Y •` r is 1w1{ ,v..
�1 .'� R i i r• c •j- i '' •v +.• \ Cti f n v f Ja .4 t �«�
Nt ,ijr. �(R tet' T '+ iIr ti b .!'f, yi Kx 'ri L2K4 r^.�7 t "a >s _. ,r r ! e .. rl er t t T, ri '�' a! s "+ {-2+'4,. <.i -
* '•# r o :'. r r t. +., SL T,.'t t" i Y p } ;r��rv`,/G� s; k ie r5. - s ., .tea .'? '�' - it3 t-
.Lw.:r ¢v,.i+yh,++5Tt1J�t t .1K; s'�' '7'1.:t7 1^ Sk y.5:. dtt'i�rt O ..t r i i ---M + ?r. '• } _.�' h�c'�4'.1 ,� A
W: !'' - � "; ylil't:r L t f t , A v t y • t _ ! '� ! h ( Y.� y :L i
q 4 Vi :?' ' > � + e .:a+. .P N e a. rt fy `^' T i i" -" •4 r :` J .4 ti v t �. § ._. s! �- l
lk .1 1 .'(� - 4 a. t x `3I' Z) . + f f y,L' F r ; . • ! t . [ i i. s .ra•+,
'f ` - Jt a = j .) r, r.r t s: t t �. •t rths i 2T J 4 s;>< t +"ii 5 r rt Y.. ,
:.`y _ t ^' i c+_ 'tY a r '+'iM '. r, r f- ` f - t -.7 �y a 1 4" r . i
`C�,!` ''tt - t':r L -L a .'+rr t } '..N'�. k T s y, i rt j..i �`»Y r
1 ' s� ` t •'+ '•{ •i. 7t 7Y .' � Y, %%'. wart 1 . �. F, sf 'I,-:. 7a). i Rt 'Y c Y.'t r a -` i A. i
'; • ,r1. Y t {y5-'" • + �r44� fi Siy„'1 �,,,�Ly _�y + " .. F ti -l�'�' v�y� �.'.r S~ r' '`t <.t. r -� i
mak_ ck` Kif c ♦ s t. �?" `�Jy, /�,�l�
? ` ,*�S't _ h �" +..; 1• r s t fI f49116 t ( 4"a. ^.r. n .+•. t '^ 7 !',tir rt f S j' ref f .ac '� t J r a. 4 y �t�
.e ;: > iT t x :., _ L + _ ?L }s �` Sr ?:tib ,.."T ♦ i i r _ i 1'+ ;
:. ti 1 - -4+5 t i.1 ♦ -, Y !� t3•; i f F,a;. -4 t a , y.t ; 7'S 'fit.'i ..r (• s r+
s T. 'OZi a i r :..+, j i +,i 9 .?e • ♦'t J- ?• T r .eta 7 +
Y ••hh�!" 4'.� - .. _ "r r tia, Yft ^� t C x i 1•i='� a`r 3 _ - y y 3
rd.. �r ��a ynt• - '.,k K r ftS y d"'S�t '':. / �y l�t �xr. - y 'y 'tJ.' Y! 3 e \ f
'S 5 1 •eri ..� ?7 � M . sa f' { x r �"7` + r4 ' J Nr'a ,Y• :5 L .1 a ? r f . .
,. i.. 5.. 5 V' I i (i..y�,�j7yr w n r A 91 `t --;. 1 k i s i r 1 a. ,u - s.-: I
J !'i +. � F a.. .,�2 ✓�J f•7 '` r,Ryd j7 t . v t r 4- s'- 7-7Jrt_s "a '4 7 ) i t7 .'"1 r
-, s $7a` a - ,` r •7, ti y' t +, - • t iT v` .: Y . - -a r ,+v yc T t.""L.1 1
�tr7
"t1 t�,y ; , S 1 v,� a ax.. J a 5 , J 't .. f `4` +y.,. t aR �Y'.J T �R tit S j r ., s a'.1 at +- .}..,: + 5 `
y..l A J ` "r' J % I area f�0 � P 1 *+ s t c "�%t Z. e+ y r
t„11
� 1. + r' r i + k / a t r J ` i 4 Tt v t J . ''+ r v - r `i atr. ♦ t j4• a r ; Y
`!,'Tags~ rl t -YN
t. r� i'r. r i +7. ,5 s' 4' �� s! •'Vfflk�-'" f7 } � i,s;jx } tlt� r� at. r`'
t 5 J , 1 4
� - }L ,.t s. f l r. t.; t. s .. i ,5 r! m. x. .I.A : 1• { r �. - 4 '.♦nr t' t P t4r'.7 ,.
1.
i i + a 'r" -T +,i rr}- '..a +7 �-y 'y " ..� R -j-,•- j.
1.
I.
i:r t
n. t. + r[ a i." •+ 1 F M.1 f.3 > + '! tYty
a
a4; �t tt `1 + J y x a t , s ♦ ,; t -ti . . 'a a ti' ..
z - ' t + +a d i .5
3' . 1 f .' {.x vi^• , r i t i k: t 'a a r J tt Y- t ..
tRa , Jt a -1 - *' ✓ii/�! f �t F'4
- t_ f tint t .r N I ;1'
r t: 4.w
�1 E '• as , tt. r:1 .r• a t -i., .t.
1-141 �
) ' ;: r t tp -
.
M..
i c 5.
�. .-
- I '. � - !�'�
-"�.:f��
lrp�- "..' .1,111. � : - ....
.,;. - . - I - -% '*;'..'' � _ I
.1 . .i� . .' _.:'*'�-"'.i'".'�";" -1 . %'..'_'.'"...... -, * ..� ..._
. . .. _;iI....' . �
�� � " .1 I '-*-'l't*:_;': , - * -�
. ' ..� - .
��
_. .. . .I.J.- i , . 1
. . -
. ..
.. �...'_. . . :�_. �' ��'* ,,I I �
. .' _'.: :+... ;..�....
.- - .. . , - t�'--"�'._'-'.-..
- I .. , -_:
, , . I '* _
I.
"-�.".�' . , .... ',": '"".�.�". - .+ � � � - . -::,...-."- +-..-'.-:--.'�' -'�': + I "
'. -
_ _�_
,,, J. . I-— '. -.: "' _ - ' �7.k I - .,
I - � . � . -, I I _Wl' I ,
7 .
...,:: I _� , 11 . ,
- .' -
- : - �-'_ , '�-_' . '.- ...' .'� -;'�',.7'*..'-'. ".'."".: �:' . : � L � I .� � - -1 � "'. � '�*' '�. .
� .
' -I;- �_ , . , :� _�. " �l � � .1 .. .' I . ... . �' .. '
_ � �
, :' . � � " ' .
� :.�_�' � . - : � , . ,.I.- . _. ''....' �" .. '. _.; I ,�. . ... A.- -I
'.'. .. I ' I �' ' . ':'_' .-.-_-:-_++�'� I :'� .'.."."' ,I'. -
. .:_ . I . �. "....� . .. .I.:1, �. � .�,�.,�...'�,�,.:�-�:.".,....,t..., _.'; ff " .'...' ..
� .. I.., ��.' - ..' _i. .. - ''. . . ' _... ....'ZI., '.� '�'44.*_1 I - � "... *_ - - . ��_. �'* ''
, � - * . ... .,.! � - ; � - %".- � " - , ,� . . � _ + � �' � . , 4� I- --I- ...'t
� I I � . , :. 4- .'� ,:.' , "j'. . � ,� I . . - � . , ...
�:;'__:� . ... - . � I .1- -!- .;"':;.*"'-. .. - _.' .. . ,` I . �
. ... - '_ , ' . . .
�: 1. � , �-'.'. �.. � .... , '. , ... - **,' ';" %.
+ ..' 'I �; !, ��'.-"-' -'. -, " ...... ..... - .:. .,* , , . - , _V, - " %'�.. .,* .... '.. - J. .�. , , .' '�:".�-�'.-N'
. � "�'.... . . �, "g 1;' .. .' . . .; . �. -
" � - ., - . .. _�_ "�'*:-'� � ... . � .
I .. �. I I I .�' -.1- , .-I'l . _ _ - �� �
., .:; 1. 11 - - It , " " � " %".� " ._'. ',.'. , ' - -" - - - ", -�'. .
- + , 1, ._'4�-.- ".".f., - . : :.
..0 "I �. .' I :� � e. .4 �'_' - '� -
, ;- , - ". i
!-r_ "
-s. ..r ..li ti r •F 1,.' .vv. ? c:at':WP '.{"'h_. i. .'r.:w tir a/ f ,� +,J •_ "a -^rt a ;'!. L' 1�t�,�
5.e' t� e., s •r. 1a.;, i ..ti
#•; •„fid. _t* , .-- 7.:wt - �r t .L +.`il _.-.,4.r .-ti. .. .- ". _*14.6 , Y�+s�:hh� - . _-. .ti. ,.r�' dF'i t. a.
fl
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number: 2001-0830
Property Location: 721 Lincolnway East
Property Owner: James Burk
Landmark or District Designation: Edgewater Place Historic District
Rating: non-contributing
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
The development of the neighborhood began in 1871 with the plating of a section
along the road leading to Mishawaka. In 1875, five houses were shows along the road.
Most of the district, however, was left undeveloped until the platting of the Edgewater
Place Addition in 1919 by Whitcomb and Keller, two of South Bend's important early
developers and realtors. The home was built in 1920, owned by Whitcomb & Keller and
rented for 17 years. In 1938, the property was purchased by William Phillip who used it
as an insurance agency. In 1951, he constructed the commercial addition to the side of
the home.
RECOMMENDATION
The applicant has recently purchased the property and saved it from demolition by
the City of South Bend. As he continues to progress, he will be asking the commission
for approvals and suggestions with his intended improvements. This request is for the
replacement of doors. He wishes to install full view, decorative beveled glass panel
doors between the home and the walled garden. He has submitted photos of several
available doors. He is seeking guidance from our historic architect in selecting the most
appropriate style for five or six other exterior doors. The staff recommends the approval
of his choices. The existing doors are not original and are extensively damaged.
SQ A � z.�-
'7
L lAr 20 Year
AS i Ud M
LINN 111) \\ARRAN I Y
�dlustabli:
Id Wood Lockblock For AddedSecurity. lik Ca
•Tough 24 Gauge Steel.
o4-9/160 Primed Frame With Exterior Brick Mould Applied. ' ',e Brass Hinge
• *Primed Door For Finish Coat
Pre -Drilled For Lockset & Deadbolt *Ufetlme Warranty Magnetic Weatherstripping—. -Seals Uke 7 !'All
'AddA Refrigerator. 1. %-, . A -
"'i
n,ft W - $1 84
ff,v,gular Price as ,.. `
0- gfaa
(71 r
ovv n iz%] SUR.
jff'j5 MADE IN
1:3 SPeach
22"W x 36"H tripl6 pane insulated beveled glass
with brass accents. 414-8641,8654
320V or 36"
Arch Top
Your Choice
SnIa
$154
221W x 3TH Insulated glas
414-7325-7370
3,
each
s ,,,
36" Colonial
Fullview
Sri? e
$169sach
22V x 64*H 15 -lite Insulated glass.
414-2825.2838
special Order At Some locations
In ApP_!_2W_ke.
412272832
like
If you find a loner Ill on an
Idenflealitem westock from anyother
local retailer, We'll MA 004 meet that Pike,
*` 411V
011the Spot just for ging
M_
each
pane insulated
liccents.
---.j Locations
lately 2 Weeks.
..s-,729 -5n4
36
Courtney
18 9
each
22*W x 36*H triple pane Insulated
beveled glass with brass accents.
414-840S. 8418
322" or 3611
mom
Jewel Elegance
Your Choice
Sochi~
each
$209.
22*W x 36*H triple pane Insulated
beveled glass With brass accents.
414-3743-3798
Sp%lal Order At sones locations
Approximately2 Weeks.
412-3747-3792
If you find a loner Ill on an
Idenflealitem westock from anyother
local retailer, We'll MA 004 meet that Pike,
*` 411V
011the Spot just for ging
M_
w
�, L J u-,"iri ral w� Low
y a
won u1mmiff - U
1V j� C,4, 6 V L� LO" V o Ed L
OVER SO STYLES! OVER 90 STYLESI
u 1 11,1411,1 Ali I I,lhlwi 6W61611i, III I11M61WINN YLtdJ�itidCNY�wJdluciAYY1.+�1':iF+.ti+L.lax.t:.::LiSi..��:ukail3Y�Jlill14il8irlfliltlYllidldua.l id lJi IN I I&IN I k6111111uI111111 iY alliIdII,EiII11p�VlYIi�I�IdYiilu�iidiYl7WIwY0lill l
4.!
•49/16" Maintenance -Free White, Bayport or Tan
Vinyl Clad Frame With Vinyl Brick Mould Applied.
*Magnetic Weatherstrip -Seals Like A Refrigerator.
•Pre -Drilled For Lockset & Deadbolt.
*Tough 24 Gauge Pre -Finished White Steel.
*Adjustable Threshold With Oak Cap.
• Brass Hinges.
No Need To
Paint—Evert
32" or 36"
Winslow
or Midwest
Elegance
Your Choice
Aveli In
ApIm
Wally
i
E
32" or 36"
Masters
Sale
1
,
X584
3991
o ' ' � uaeew '
AvaYMbh In �MOu.SA, :��':r
'°WAW WAffar w.
• 4-9/16" Maintenance -Free White, Bayport orTan — — - .• w MOL r k
Vinyl Clad Frame With Vinyl Brick Mould Applied.
• Magnetic Weatherstrip -Seals Like A Refrigerator.
•Pre -Drilled For Lockset & Deadbolt.
•Tough 24 Gauge Pre -Finished White Steel.
•AdjustableThreshold With Oak Cap.
*Brass Hinges.
The Durability It.�i , j rOf
Of Steel Outside !ming
,
kTrim Around Door'
of Ready -To -Finish C
ielsl
e -Finished 24 GaugE
Q @,
St. Thomas
C fa 4:
K
l
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number: 2001-0906
Property Location: 1636 Lincolnway West
Property Owner: Ethel Anderson
Landmark or District Designation: LL
Rating: S/11
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
The brick building at 1636 Lincolnway West was constructed in 1905 as a
brewery and office space for the South Bend Brewing Association. The building was
used for that purpose until 1919 with Prohibition. Between that year and the end of
Prohibition, the building was used for other manufacturing. The production of beer was
ended in 1950 with the dissolution of the company. Since that time, the building has
been used for a number businesses including, a paint company, glass company and
Harley-Davidson. This is a four to five story Gothic Revival style building with a single
story rear addition for loading and mechanics. The glass front was added in the 1960's
RECOMMENDATION
A Certificate of Appropriateness was awarded by the Commission on July 17,
2000 for changes of two second floor windows, installation of new parking, new two
headed street lights. To staffs' knowledge this work has not been started. Meanwhile,
additional work was started to add a door to the west side of the building within an
existing garage door. The west side of the structure has been altered several times
between 1905 and recent years, including the addition of the garage door. Architect Greg
Kil called the office on September 6, 2001 to give us an update on this project and asked
the Commissions' approval to do thrk.
Our inspector visited the property on September 14, 2001 and discovered that the
work had been done by Murdock Construction, but not to the drawings specifications as
provided by Mr. Kil. The staff will not make a specific recommendation other than to
suggest that the new brickwork be painted to match the existing side of the building.
1636 LINCOLSVVAY WEST
September 14,2001
EWA
..ILA
EWA
1636 LINCOLNWAY WEST
September 14, 2001
;4
KGAL DEPARTMEN
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO: HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION DATE: September 11, 2001
FROM: THOMAS L. BODNAR
ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY
RE: MEETING PROCEDURES
It is wise to remember that we are all public servants and that our bosses are the very
people who attend our meetings, the public at large and those who reside in historic districts or who
occupy historic landmarks. One way to serve them better is to make our meetings more professional
and, frankly, shorter. .
We can begin by starting promptly at 7;30 p.m., or as soon thereafter as a quorum is
present.. My limited observation is that if a member is not present by 7:32 p.m., he or she almost
certainly will not show, regardless of what Rhonda may have been told. It is insulting to ask members
of the public who did show up on time to wait to see if anyone else comes. We should remember that
our meetings start later than most (both the County Council and the South Bend Common Council
begin at 7:00 p.m.), and many of the people with whom we deal have to be up early in the morning.
We should take the COAs in the order in which the owners arrive, or at least hear all the
COAs for which the owner is present first. This is common in local courts and Code Enforcement
hearings in South Bend. Remembering that the owners are probably not that happy about having to be
present, making them wait while matters are discussed concerning someone who didn't even bother to
show up can be a further irritant. At the conclusion of the first COA hearing, the owner should be
advised that he or she, (and all subsequent owners) at the conclusion of their hearings, are welcome to
stay, but are certainly free to leave. In the long run we will avoid situations of someone saying "How
come you gave the next owner more leeway on the kinds of windows to use than me?", or something to
that effect. It would also reduce background noise throughout the hearing.
While sometimes the staff reports are, for good reason, not available until the end of the.
hearing, I know that a conscientious effort is made to circulate as many of these as possible prior to the
meeting.- You have with the agenda most of those reports no later than Friday and have all weekend in
which to review them. Reading the reports prior to the meeting is a good method of organizing your
thoughts, thinking through any questions you may have, deciding if you need to drive by the property
prior to the meeting, and otherwise being prepared to reach a sound decision. Asking the staff
questions the day of the meeting is not forbidden and even encouraged. Grammar and spelling errors in
those reports can be brought to the attention of the staff either before or after the meeting. Picayune
comments about the reports bring disrespect to all who participate in the process.
To further helpeed things along, the chairman sho"k at the start of each
property if the reading of the report could be dispensed- with, and the reading should be dispensed with
unless there is an objection or the report was circulated just prior to the meeting.
It is the job of the chairperson of the meeting to keep it moving. This may involve
asking a member to get back to the subject or conclude his or her comments. It is always a thankless
task, not arising out of any animosity towards any member, and in the long run it will force all of us to
concentrate on the issues.
The public comments section does not necessarily mean a public debate. A simple
"Thank you for your thoughts" could be sufficient. For example, the South Bend Common Council has
incorporated into its rules a requirement that no questions may be asked of the council members during
the public comments sessions and that matters which were on the agenda cannot be addressed either.
Since an item brought up at the public discussion is not something you are necessarily prepared to deal
with in detail like the speaker wants, a written response or a phone call the next day, when you have
your facts in order (and, perhaps, when tempers have cooled down) is often more appropriate than a
two-way discussion at that hour of the evening.
Finally, please remember that you are not being graded or paid by the number of words
you utter, nor are you paid by the length of the meeting. People don't go out of the meeting saying
"Commissioner X must be pretty dumb because he or she hardly said a word." It is late, -dark, and will
soon be cold when our meetings end. The Commission and the public would be well served if meetings
consistently ended earlier.
The purpose of this memo isn't to stifle debate or to criticize anyone in particular. I sit
there and try to put myself in the shoes of the property owners who are being asked to give up a night
of their lives because they happen to own an historically important house or live in an historically
district, a hardship to them which they would not endure if they lived in other parts of the community.
I reiterate that I will be available to questions from any of you at 235-5868.
H:\WPDATA\Tt"=oMWorkPmfim
Application
°yylSSlphr•
for.
o ph IttC/
Certificate of Appropriateness
2
Historic Preservation Commission of South Bend & SL Joseph County
ass 227 West Jefferson Blvd - RM 1123 - South Bend IN 46601-1830
Phone: 219-235.9798 Fox: 219-235-9578 e-mail: historic@michiana.org
A Certified Local Government
OFFICEftseo bY» 6MRILICOMAINr.D IN Tltlt ROA— c<OFF/CE USEONLr
Dote Received % 20,0/ - Application Number. 200,11- D 517'6 % '
post Reviews; DYES (rurrausr In , ❑ NO
Zoatal Type: toot Stu
StaftApproval authertttd byl Title:
Historic Comadsd" Review Date:
❑ Lasal Laadaazk - ❑ National Landmark
❑ Nadeaat Reakttr Dktdct ev.. J.
❑ J.4111stork District .
Certificate ofAppropriateness;
11 Dnkd ❑ Tabled ❑ Stat To Committee
❑ Appreved ad imaed 2d_
Address of Property for proposed work: S/o t� t!/U,
r..Ir..r.:Jb..
City : o &ZD Township:
Name of Property Owner(s):mnm,-s /�
Address of Property Owner: �7/n /r" ,P',-�� Q,a r'
Contractor(:)Name: '/rld�- (�_T✓,»
i T
Contract Company Name: '/f�/lQ%rt r_ i/ �Y2JrS�iJ�in J
Contractor Address: —.93
Contractor's Phone No: Owner's Phone No:
Current Use Of Building -
FS -01 +NtT'Crwawe!✓'GewnMeew-Ahm M-Yecwr.ae
Type of Building Construction:.- 62 //jst
OY Fnwe. drka-(rwr..GM+Cworw•ph
Proposed Work., Inkind D Landscape D New Z Reptacementr..lt•-at•n
prn la•e wr ar.wr k t+wa•4
Demolition (Vemulellon efSenente Form Also Prouirtdl
Description of Proposed Work:
Owner/Contractor. Fax:�d 7 lia.�i a -mail:
troa�dtnytaanaa.•t.sewy e.trip..y
r A
SlaaotarootOwaer g nroo 'oa nctor�` .
APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS ARE LISTED ON REVERSE SIDE.
day and all baslaess of this office Is handled via e-taall and fax, with least preference to U.S Mail
ON 7A LIST PRICES
'Goshen S a*sh& D
Combination Doom By CDC (Combination Door Co.) #55 Easy Change Door
1 Light 7 Design A Colonial 9 -Lite Grille-
$253.00(s)
rille
$253.00(s)
$311.40(s)
$350.30(s)
304.00
362.40
401.30
253.00(s)
311.40(s)
350.30(s)
304.00
362.40
401.30
258.70(s)
317.10(s)
356.00(s)
310.00
368.40
407.30
Designer Grille with...
Scroll Corner Half Moon
Fan Bracket
(s) stock sizes in bold
Door Rim, Screen
and Sash insert
are in one carton.
Grilles and
Gingerbread are in
separate cartons.
Scroll
�+ V
I� �I
$344.00
395.00
344.00
395.00
349.70
MAMA
PARK AVENUE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION, INC.
September 14, 2001
Mr. John Oxian, President
Historic Preservation Commission
227 W. Jefferson Blvd.
South Bend, Indiana 46601
Dear Mr. Oxian:
The Park Avenue Neighborhood Association has made a request to become a city historic
district. We have included a map of our proposed area and ask that our request is
obtained by a public hearing before the South Bend Common Council rather than by the
majority vote of our neighborhood.
Sincerely,
viz -
Wayne R. Doolittle
Historic district committee member
Park Avenue Neighborhood Association
Enclosure
r CAL-JORN1A AVE.
11 I R
fRs" F s t. ,oStPN
z N
� 1.1
REX ST. W `Y DR. RIVERSIDE
J
Y
7f
0 �y0 > C
t < W
W >> PARK —
m
ST.
a M
O < -
z a
t z -
_ FJ
MANITOU o
P*
•ARTLETT
�I FL
< LAMONT TERR, �
ST.
Y
41 et
NAVARRE ST. NAVAR.E
NAVARRE ST.
I
Its
:17
H W '
0 J -
u ST. MARION
N
MARION I
r,RIer ST., c
4
►-
$O r u eqy
ZO
ST. MADISON u
r.
z ~ _
= ST.
� t
u
4. .1
r NCO�N nr
h H
AVE, lA SALLE
f I 1 I I U N l 1111 I lid W 111111 1 I 1 1111
1
A _.r
M a' .l v�
�p '� �'Ki1 "1h •� h.
At
1`
F
h„
V. A
STAFF REPORT
CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A
CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
Application Number: 2001-0825
Property Location: 639 Lincoln way East
Property Owner: Michael P. Neal
1236 Hampshire Drive
South Bend, Indiana 46614
Landmark or District Designation: Edgewater Place Historic District
Rating: None, vacant lot
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT
The development of the neighborhood began in 1871 with the plating of a-section
along the road leading to Mishawaka. In 1875, five houses were shows along the road.
Most of the district, however, was left undeveloped until the platting of the Edgewater
Place Addition in 1919 by Whitcomb and Keller, two of South Bend's important early
developers and realtors.
RECOMMENDATION
The applicant is requesting the placement of a mobile office structure that is eight
(8) feet by twenty six (26) feet. The reported uge is as an office for a used car business.
The lot currently has no structure of any kind existing as the result of a fire many years
ago.. The staff has reservations about this project. There are no other temporary
structures along Lincolnway East in the historic_ district. However, we should consider
the value of some occupancy over a vacant lot. Some restrictions should be placed on the
owners. The trailer should look as permanent as possible with skirting being placed
around the bottom so as to cover the wheels and landscaping should be used to soften the
view. Also, additional landscaping should be required along the street to beautify the
entrance and help mask any fence should one be required.
50
1
8'wide
field office series
I-
' , �•� !` :.4„�'t; .•::'.1 : `ami
t',li
Model 824 FO
OPT.
r—'I AIR CONDITIONER 9DESK
PLAN RACK PENCIL j
DRAWER O
Z
io - 1•• FILE N
OPRONAL PENCIL r
HEATER DRAWER
MODEL 820 FO (Body 806)
(128 sq. ft.)
OPT.
OPT
r—'T AIR CONDITIONER
B' DESK
J 1
►LAN RACK PENCIL
1
DRAWER
OT
Z
Z J FILE
N
LIG
�f
PENCIL
LL
omoKAt PENCIL
•
HEATER DRAWER
n
-
MODEL 824 FO (Body 8 x 20)
(160 sq. ft.)
DRAWER
MODEL 832 FO
(Body 8 x 28)
(224 sq. ft.)
Standard Equipment
820FO-8214FO
• 8' desk with one 2 drawer metal file
and two pencil drawers
• Electric baseboard heat
• Plan table with cabinet base
• Plan rack with holders
=luorescent lights
—med for wall air conditioners
• Overhead shelf
8' DESK `vi �R V B' DESK
MODEL 830 FO
(Body 8x26) 9;;,
\.
(208 sq. ft.) 6F �.
OPT OPT
1 r—� AIR CONDITIONER --T AIR CONDI yi TONER
LL L J 10 L.. J PENCIL ,1
PENCIL OPT. BATH ►LAN DRAWER 1
W TABL
DRAWER E 10
N FILE 10' pT10Ka �'' 0 FILE ^N
i iURNACE
t1' LIGHTS m
O PENCIL PENCIL tTor
_ DRAWER STORAGE PIAN RACK DRAWER -- j
r�1
8'DESK B'DESK
MODEL
836 FO O
(Body 8 x 32)
(256 sq. ft.)
(Tandem Axle)
Optional
• Electric and gas furnaces
• Air conditioning
• 1/2 bathroom
4
Standard Equipment
830FO-832FO-836FO
• I'wo 8' desks with one two drawer
metal file and two pencil drawers
• Electric baseboard heat
• Plan table with cabinet base
• Plan rack with holders
• 4' fluorescent lights
• Framed For air conditioners
• Partition with door
• Overhead shelf'
• Closet in 832FO and 836FO
OPT
OPT
r—JAIRCONDITIONER
r-1AIRCONDITIONER
PENCIL
LL
OPT. BATH
II
PENCIL
J
DRAWER
PLAN
DRAWER
UJI
T _ J
TABLE
10
to
FILE
10'
0 FILE
_
=
NNACE
is,
LIGHTS
FDO
O
PENCIL
PENCIL
DRAWER
STORAGE
PLAN RACK
DRAWER,-_
DESK
B'DESK
MODEL 832 FO
(Body 8 x 28)
(224 sq. ft.)
Standard Equipment
820FO-8214FO
• 8' desk with one 2 drawer metal file
and two pencil drawers
• Electric baseboard heat
• Plan table with cabinet base
• Plan rack with holders
=luorescent lights
—med for wall air conditioners
• Overhead shelf
8' DESK `vi �R V B' DESK
MODEL 830 FO
(Body 8x26) 9;;,
\.
(208 sq. ft.) 6F �.
OPT OPT
1 r—� AIR CONDITIONER --T AIR CONDI yi TONER
LL L J 10 L.. J PENCIL ,1
PENCIL OPT. BATH ►LAN DRAWER 1
W TABL
DRAWER E 10
N FILE 10' pT10Ka �'' 0 FILE ^N
i iURNACE
t1' LIGHTS m
O PENCIL PENCIL tTor
_ DRAWER STORAGE PIAN RACK DRAWER -- j
r�1
8'DESK B'DESK
MODEL
836 FO O
(Body 8 x 32)
(256 sq. ft.)
(Tandem Axle)
Optional
• Electric and gas furnaces
• Air conditioning
• 1/2 bathroom
4
Standard Equipment
830FO-832FO-836FO
• I'wo 8' desks with one two drawer
metal file and two pencil drawers
• Electric baseboard heat
• Plan table with cabinet base
• Plan rack with holders
• 4' fluorescent lights
• Framed For air conditioners
• Partition with door
• Overhead shelf'
• Closet in 832FO and 836FO
I
ONE PIECE ROOF INSULATING TRUSS T-
- 30 GAUGE MEtAI BOARD RAFTED
SUB ROOF FIBERGLASS INSULATION
_ SEMI ACC. BENT
20 STUDS AT 16" OC REFLECTING CEILING
-STEEL STRAPS AT SILLS
PRE FINISHED AND HEADER
MAINTENANCE FREE
ALUMINUM SIDES I •
MT RAILS PER WALL
FIBERGLASS INSULATION -
FINISHED WOOD W ALL PANELING
HEAVY DUTY FLOOR til£
OR ROLL GOODS
S.6' FLOORING
FIBERGLASS
NOTE:
1. STANDARD EQUIPPED WITH 8 PLY 14.5 TIRES.
2. FULLY GROUNDED ELECTRICAL SYSTEM PROTECTED
BY CIRCUIT BREAKERS.
3. FULLY INSULATED WALLS, FLOORS AND CEILING.
Specifications
WINDOWS&DOORS
HEAVY DUTY FLOOR JOISTS
., 2t41&2. 6Y AT 16* OC
_INSULATING BOTTOM BOARD
HEAVY DUTY ELECTRIC WELDED
STEEL FRAME
HEAVY DUTY HITCH 2 6116
• Steel under frames with electric brakes
• Heavy duty tires -8 -ply 7:00 x 14.5
• 2-5/16" hitch ball with elevating jack
• Weather resistant bottom board
• 2 x 4 or 2 x 6 floor joists on 16" centers
• 5/8" floor underlayment
• One piece vinyl floor covering or block the floors
• 3" sidewall studs on 16" centers
• Two belt rails in all walls
finished V groove wood paneling
ss type rafters on 16" centers
ne piece galvanized roofing
+ Semi -acoustical ceiling board
36" entrance doors
• Hinged interior doors
• Aluminum slider type windows
• Circuit breaker panel
• Double receptacles every 10'
• 4' fluorescent lights
• Fully insulated
• Maintenance free aluminum exterior
field onice
lab units
8; 10,-i& 12'wide
specifications
Model 824 FO
8 wide desk
plan/table and
planlrack
12 wide desk and
plan table
to state sp
We offer a complete line of Field Office and Field Lab Units that
I-individual State Specifications. Simply give us a call for a quo -
I with drawings and specifications on your particular need.
Typical lab interior
3
1
JOHN WARD CONCRE TEE INC.
25295 STATE RD. 2
SOUTH BEND ,IN 46614
219-232-2012
ESTIMATE
JULY 9, 2001
ATIN.• GARVINMCINTOS11
FILL EXISTING GARAGE. WITH FI1,1, SAND
NEW 30X22 SLAB 4" T111CK IW 12"X 12" F'00'1'ER
IVIREMESII AND REBAR DOLLED TO EVIS77NG FOOTER
SLAB 70 BE 6"ABOVEASPHALT
2 X 4 IVALLS 16" ON CENTER
DOUBLE TOP PIATF. TREATED BOTf0j%f PLATE
ANCHORS P FROM CORNER 5' APART
2 X 12 READERS GARAGE DOOR AND SERVICE DOOR
ENGINEERED TR USSES 2' ON CENTER 4112 PITCH
7116 OSB WALLS, ROOF AND GABLE ENDS
15 LB. FILT AND 20YR. ROOF (COLOR BY OWNERS)
IV111TEALUMINUMDRIPEDGE, SOFFITANDFASCM
20 GARAGE PANELSALL IVALLSAND GABLE ENDS
(siding and trim color by owner)
1--16X 7 OVEIil1EAD DOOR NON INSULATED .
1-- 32" STEEL SERVICE DOOR K LOCKSET & DEAD13OLT
SLAB & GARAGEASPER SPECS = $12,980.00
115 LIFT. SEIVER & {PATER FROM IVALK TO GARAGE
CUT OUT PARKING LOT FROM BALK TO SLAB FOR SEINER & IVAT ER -
(REPLACE FOR ADDITIONAL $1.85 SQ.FI)
$4,800.00 (NOTE IFS7DEIfALKSTREET OR CURBNkEUS TO BE CUT WILL BE AUDIT(OAAL) - -
PAYMENT TO BE MADE AT COMPLETION OF EACH PHASE:
EXCAVATING.
CONCRETE
FRAMING
THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
OF SOUTH BEND & ST. JOSEPH COUNTY
MONTHLY MEETING
MINUTES
SEPTEMBER 17, 2001 7th Floor, Commissioner's Conference Room
7:30 p.m. County —City Building, South Bend, IN
MEMBERS PRESENT: John Oxian, Catherine Hostetler,
Mary Jane Chase, Martha Choitz,
Richard Morrison, Joann Sporleder,
Gerald Ujdak, Jerry Weiner, Richard Helmus
MEMBERS ABSENT: NONE
STAFF PRESENT: Rhonda Saunders, Director
Karen Hammond -Nash, Assistant Director
Thomas Bodnar, City Attorney
Wayne Doolittle, Inspector
ALSO PRESENT: Jack L. Swope, Kirk Philippsen,
Scott Kopinski, Frederick Mann,
Eric Morgan, Derek Cochrane,
Ed ?, Mike Deal, Gary VanOverberghe,
Jason Durr. Alfred Freel
I. CALL TO ORDER
CATHERINE HOSTETLER: Called the meeting to order at 7:35.
Il. PUBLIC HEARING
A. Certificates of Appropriateness
1. 2001-0803-2(b); Jan Pilarski; and Jay Tidmarsh;
538 Riverside Drive, South Bend, Indiana
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: . Received permission from the Chair to dispense with
reading the history of the houses for which Certificates of Appropriateness are sought,
because of the number of items on the agenda.
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff recommendations into the minutes. The
owners were not present.
1
ti
JOHN OXIAN: Moved that this application be referred to the Standards and
Maintenance Committee, and that Staff schedule a Standards and Maintenance
Committee Meeting after the property owners decide what sort of garage door they wish
to install.
GERALD UJDAK: Seconded the motion.
The motion carried unanimously.
2. 2001-0824; City of South Bend. Leeper Park -Riverside Drive
Between Michigan and Bartlett.
Z:
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff report and recommendations.
JASON DURR, an engineer with the City of South Bend. gave an additional explanation
of how its project is designed to accommodate fishermen, and prevent late-night fishing
from disturbing homeowners.
RICHARD MORRISON: Moved for approval of the application as submitted.
MARTHA CHOITZ: Seconded the motion. and it carried unanimously.
3. 2001-0825; Michael P. Neal; 639 Lincoln Way East:
Replacement of a mobile office structure.
KAREN HAMMON-NASH: Read the staff reports and recommendations.
MICHAEL P. NEAL, the owner. was present and responded to inquires by commission
members. He stated that if the lot becomes profitable, he hopes to put in a permanent
complex within a few years. He intends presently to reseal the lot, to take out overgrown
scrub trees, and to install water and sewer lines.
In response to a question from Martha Choitz, he explained that he wishes to put the
proposed mobile office on a concrete pad in the back of the lot, approximately 10 feet
from the alley.
JOHN OXIAN: Moved for approval of the application, contingent upon-,
A. Appropriate landscaping in front of the lot and bushes
around the trailer.
B. Skirting around the bottom of the mobile office.
C. A picket fence replacing the present deteriorating fence,
as proposed by the owner in his presentation.
2
V
�2=
D. That the mobile office be removed when or if the owner
sells or vacates the property.
RICHARD HELMUS: Seconded the motion, and the motion carried unanimously.
4. 2001-0826. Mary and Eric Morgan; 209 North Shore Drive.
South Bend, Indiana.
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff report and recommendations.
GARY VANOVERBERGHE, of VanOverberghe Builders Inc., gave an explanation and
description of the project.
JOHN OXIAN: Asked Eric Morgan several questions regarding the purpose of the
proposed alterations, which Mr. Morgan answered.
RICHARD MORRISON: Moved for approval of the application. -
GERALD UJDAK: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously.
5. 2001-0828; Laurel and William Cochrane; 51,9 Edgewater
Drive, South Bend, Indiana.
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff reports and recommendations.
ALBERT FREEL, the contractor for the proposed project, spoke on the original
application. The garage on his property has white "double -four inch" Dutch -lap vinyl
siding, and the homeowner wishes to match that siding on the house.
In response to a question from the Commission, Bill Cochran stated that previously
replaced windows had been Colby and Colby Window Manufactures.
JOHN OXIAN: Moved for approval of this application, specifying the following:
(a) "Double -four inch" Dutch -lap vinyle siding
(b) Wooden double -hung sash windows, as described by the
owner
0 that Inspector Wayne Doolittle inspect the project as it
proceeds
RICHARD MORRISON: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously.
6. 2001-0829; The Episcopal Cathedral of St. James; 1624 East
Wayne Street, South Bend, Indiana.
t h "I
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Summarized the proposal for renovation, and
recommended approval.
KIRK PHILLIPPSEN, and DEAN FREDERICK MANN, from The Episcopal Cathedral
of St. James, explained the desire to create a year-round 'sun -room- using the existing
porch space and dimensions. A man representing American Sunspace Additions was
present to answer any questions. if needed.
MARY JANE CHASE: Moved for approval of the proposal. as submitted. and Jerry
Weiner seconded the motion. It carried unanimously.
7. 2001-08330; James Burk, 721 Lincolnway East
KAREN HAMMON-HASH: Read the staff report and recommendations. The owner
was not present.
Members of the Commision expressed dissatisfaction with the owner's request that the
Commision recommend a historically appropriate door.
JOHN OXIAN: Moved that the matter be referred to the Standards and Maintenance
Committee.
RICHARD HELMUS: Seconded the motion.
Some discussion followed as to whether screens should be required, and whether the
doors should have horizontal panels.
The Chair called for a vote on the motion, and it carried with Richard Morrison casting
one opposing vote.
8. 2001-0906; Ethel Anderson, 1636 Lincolnway West
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff report and recommendation. The owner
was not present, nor was any representative.
Following some brief discussion. Richard Morrision moved that the Commision deny Mr.
Kiel request to have a Certificate of Appropriateness for the proposed altered door.
JOHN OXIAN: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously.
JOHN OXIAN: Further directed Commission Staff to communicate with Mrs Anderson
and Mr. Kiel regarding the deplorable state of the building located at 1636 Lincolnway
West, and directed legal counsel to look into the possibility of legal action to compel
Mrs. Anderson to undertake repairs and renovations for which a Certificate of
Appropriateness was granted last year.
4
V
�9
9. 2001-0907; Lynn Patrick, 510 River Avenue,
South Bend, Indiana.
,KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Read the staff report and recommendation. The owner
was not present.
The Commission examined photographs of the house, and a flyer from Goshen Sash and
Door describing the proposed storm door.
JOHN OXIAN: Moved that the Commission deny the application as submitted, and
specifically deny a Certificate of Appropriateness for a colonial style half-light screen
door, but direct staff to approve a sequitted light or vertical panel door, should the owner
amend to application to seek on of those.
MARY JANE CHASE: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously.
B. Proposed Local Landmarks, 2"a reading
1. Park Avenue Historic District
WAYNE R. DOOLITTLE: Presented to the Commission a map (revised) of the
proposed historic district, and briefly explained the proposed change in boundaries.
JOHN OXIAN: Moved that the Commission adopt a resolution in support of the
proposed area.
RICHARD HELMUS: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously.
2. 2716 Vine Street (Old Nuner Street)
- Brief discussion was held and no action taken.
III. Regular Business
A. Approval of Minutes tabled until the following meeting
B. Treasurer's Report
JERRY WEINER: Distributed copies of the monthly audit report, and had no further
report.
C. Correspondence
There was no correspondence
5
D. Committee Reports / Architectural Historian Report
JOANN SPORLEDER: Reported to the Commission her professional findin"s regarding
the recent alterations to the home at 729 Lincolnway East, concluding that the changes
made there were in general an improvement to the structure, but adding that the proposed
replacement of the main front door would be greatly inappropriate, and should not be
approved.
E. Legal
MR. THOMAS BODNAR: Had nothing additional to report at this time
F. Staff Reports / C. of A. Approvals
KAREN HAMMOND-NASH: Submitted a list of eleven staff approval Certificates Of
Appropriatness.
VI. Hearing of Visitors
There were no hearings of visitors
V. Old Business
There was no old business to discuss
VI. New Business
There was no new business to discuss
RICHARD HELMUS: Made a motion to adjurn,
JERRY WEINER: Seconded the motion, and it carried unanimously
I
PW