The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutNovember 1997AGENDA OF THE REGULAR MEETING of the HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Regular monthly meeting County Commissioner's 7:30 p.m. Conference Room Monday, November 17, 1997 7th Floor County City Bldg. I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III..Public Hearing A. Certificates of Appropriateness - 1) 1208 Lincolnway East - Changes to approved rehabilitation plan 2) 1704 East Wayne - Replace cedar siding with vinyl siding 3) 830 North Michigan - Window restoration for North Pumping Station 4) Leeper Park - Placement of rocks or posts along Riverside Drive 5) 117 West North Shore - Replace a tree that was previously removed 6) 201 West North Shore - Install railings and lights in front yard 7) 701 Riverside Drive - Replace front steps with concrete and brick 8) 1215 Riverside Drive - Demolish garage 9) 1602 East Wayne - Replace backyard chain link fence with privacy fence 10) 221 West North Shore - Installation of a backyard privacy fence B. Second Reading - Proposed Local Landmark 1) 1631 Lincolnway West . IV. Regular Business A. Approval of Minutes 1. October 20, 1997 • B. Treasurer's Report C. Correspondence D. Committee Reports 1. Budget & Finance 2. Historic Districts a. Project Access 1) Riverside Drive 2) West North Shore b. COA -_Chapin Park NRHD gate proposal 3. Historic Landmarks a. Status of recommendations to Councils 1) 804 N. Lafayette - Madison School 2) 513 Harrison 5. Standards & Maintenance a. 1333 East Wayne Street - proposed addition and alterations 6. Legal E. Staff Reports 1. C of A Staff Approvals (see attachment) 2. Legal 3. DHPA Grant status a. 1997-98 V. Old Business A. National Register nominations 1) East'Bank Multiple Property Listing VI. New Business VII. Hearing of Visitors • VIII. Announcements & Miscellaneous Matters IX. Adjournment 1 F)HIAvT we 70t 'e, 'N JeVii_c:c�a te- CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF -REPORT APPLICATION' --:1997=0502R PROPERTY -- 1208 Lincolnway East South Bend, IN OWNER -- Hubner Agency DESIGNATION -- LHD-LWE RATING -- Contributing C/10 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HI8TORICGCO3NTEXT Ovtners Elva. and Albert Harris built this Queen ,Anne house built i.n 'the mid -1890s. Mr. Harris began the South Bend Spark Arrestor Company in 1887;. PROPOSED CHANGE Amendment to 1997-0714. Modify west side entry door and canopy to allow . access by wheelchair, add handicapped access ramp on west side and excavate and provide basement entrance with concrete stairs at east side to provide second path of egress from occupied sections of the basement. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for Lincolnway East Local Historic District: b) .... The Guidelines for the Lincolnway East District follow the Rehabilitation Model.... I.B.2. Recommended New site work should be based upon actual knowledge of the past appearance of the property found in photographs, drawings and newspapers. New site work • should also be appropriate to existing surrounding site elements in scale, type and appearance. II.C.1 Required Existing or original windows and doors .... shall be retained or when deteriorated beyond repair, replaced with duplicates of the existing or original. II.C.3 Prohibited Existing or original windows, doors ... shall not be discarded when they can be restored and reused in place. New windows or door openings that would alter the scale and proportion of the building may not be introduced. IV.A.l. Required Code requirements shall be complied with in such a manner that the existing character of the building is preserved. IV.A.3. Prohibited Construction of new stairways and elevators that would alter the existing exit facilities or important architectural features and spaces shall be prohibited. RECOMMENDATION This application reflects changes in the previously approved rehabilitation program which have been motivated by requirements of the building code with regard to commercial use. These requirements have already been acted upon in the project development in response to the Building Department. Staff views this application as an object lesson in the reason for hiring professional architectural services for a commercial conversion project. Each of these requirements should have been foreseeable with a full knowledge of • the building program. Likewise each would have had a superior solution available at the outset, although at this time these features of the project CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT are both necessary and a fete -accompli. . Details not indicated in the photographs include railings which will be required at the handicapped ramp, basement stair, and at the front porch. The railings at the ramp are proposed to extend the detail features at the rear deck which, though more visible from the street, are consistent with other approved features associated with this project at the rear of the building and at the adjacent property to the west. The railings which will be required at the front porch and the stairwell will be more apparent from the street and should therefore be of a design more compatible with the historic architecture. These railing locations are necessary for life safety to prevent accidental fall into the stairwell. The protection at driveway along the side of the stairwell may be best be accomplished with masonry reflecting the character of the foundation. These details may be better defined by the date of the Public Hearing. Staff recommends approval so long as these considerations are addressed. DBD 11/7/97 • 0 4 C'm ' ice'' t - m -I �.✓"� a 1 li!n -1, IN; I V," �w CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT, • APPLICATION -- 1997-1008-2 PROPERTY 1704 East Wayne South Bend, IN OWNER -- Dave Bickel DESIGNATION -- LHD-EW RATING -- Non -Contributing STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT Whitcomb and Keller Corporation built this Colonial Revival stvle house in 1953. They sold the house to Haskell and Bessie Mitloff on September 22, 1953. Mr. Mitloff was a buyer for Robertson's clothing store, located in downtown South Bend. The Mi.tloff's lived in the house until 1987, they sold it to the current owner, Dave Bickel, in 1988. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to replace the cedar siding that is currently on the house with new vinyl siding. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for East Wayne Historic District state: b) .... The Guidelines for the East Wayne Historic District follow the Rehabilitation Model.... • II.A.1. Required Original exterior building materials shall be retained. II.A.2. Recommended Whenever possible, the original building materials should be restored. Metal or vinyl siding may be used when it is the only feasible alternative to maintaining or replacing the original surface material. When used over wood surfaces, this siding should be the same size and style as the original wood. Every effort should be made to retain the original trim around windows, doors, cornices, gables ... and other architectural features. Ample ventilation must be afforded the structure when metal or vinyl siding has been installed in order to prevent increased deterioration of the structure from moisture and/or insects. II.A.3. Prohibited Wood siding shall not be resurfaced with new material which is inappropriate or was unavailable when the building was constructed... RECOMMENDATION This house is -rated as non-contributing in the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Inventory due to its late date of construction in relation to the general district. None -the -less, the character of this house is consistent with the district featuring the metal casement windows, common on East Wayne Street. The massing is typical of the last generation of in -fill houses which commonly include a rectangular two story residence with one story wing at the side. The existing siding appears to be in serviceable condition although the texture of the shingle surface renders the scraping of flaking paint somewhat is problematic. Paint conditions here may indicated poor surface preparation related to previous re -painting or incompatible paint layering. Staff recommends denial of the application for re -siding. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT Staff would recommend spray powerwashing with a 15 degree minimum tip as part of a preparation program here and would recommend application of an opaque or solid color stain rather than paint to avoid additional 'paint layer build-up. In our experience oil-based opaque stain performs better in application over previously painted surf -aces than the latex based stains. DBD 11/7/97 • 11-17-97 • David P. & Brenda L. Bickel 1704 E. Wayne St. South Bend, IN 46615 219 233-1956 9 Our house was built in 1953 on the vacated part of Ester Street. Houses on the land would produce more tax revenue than a street. We have 1951 sq. ft., 3 bedroom, 1 '/z baths, with and unfinished basement that floods in heavy rain. Our house along with 30 other houses (14%)on East Wayne Street were built between 1952-1960 and are non -historic. In the following examples we would like to demonstrate why we feel we must be granted some latitude when it comes to up grading our property. Appreciation Value Home prices for and average, median, 2200 sq. ft. house as reported by the Indiana Association of Realtors, Indiana University Center for Real Estate Studies, Chamber of Commerce of St. Joseph County, and The Coldwell Bankers Home Price Comparison Index are as follows: Year Indiana South Bend/Mishawaka Our House 1987 $45,400 $89,900 1988 ------- $49,100 1989 ---- $52,200 1990 $52,500 1991 1992 ------ $98,500 1993 ---- $63,600 1994 $75,000 $64,700 1995 $79,500 $69,300 1996 -- $74,500f 1997 -- ;$108,000/ In the South Bend/Mishawaka area the average, median, home has increased by 5-7% per vear over the last 10 years while our house has increased less than 1.85% uer year. Attached: Articles from the South Bend Tribune dated 11/8/90, 03/14/91, 06/20/95, and 02/17/96. Our estimates are from the purchase of our home, the refinancing of the mortgage, and the equity loan Current Estimates for Siding Vinyl Siding, insulation board, and wrap will go over our existing siding, make the house more energy efficient. Before installing Cedar Siding and insulation board we will have to tear off the existing old siding and trim. 1704 E. Wavne St. Vinvl Siding Cedar Siding Proposal A $10,282 Proposal B $16,367.80 Proposal C $ 9,648 *Paint/Stain 2 coats first yr (1997 Prices) Labor 1997 prices $300.00 $2.125.00 $18,792.80 0 *Painting the cedar requires seasoning time of 1 to 1 '/2 years, depending on the weather. Staining the cedar will have to be completed in constant weather of over 50 degrees. page 2 Upkeep on Siding 1704 E. Wayne St. Vinyl Siding Cedar Siding Paint/Stain one coat (1997 Prices) 0 $166.00/$150.00 Labor 1997 prices 0 $1,062.50 Repeated every 3-5 years Intentions Our intention is to preserve our home in the best manor possible and to enhance the other homes in our neighborhood We must protect the existing structure and give our house a facelift. According to our Preservation Guidelines book, page 33, paragraph 3, the Historic Preservation Commission must consider 3 factors in determining the granting of a Certificate of Appropriateness. I . Appropriateness of the proposed work to the preservation of the building and district We all agree the house needs siding. 2. The detriment to the public welfare the proposed work is pennitted..... It is a moot point. 3. The potential hardship that the denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness would cause the applicant. The hardship is the Undue financial burden. Future Projects - 5 necessity items: 1. Chimney Repair The bricks are falling off our chimney and we have water damage on the inside walls by the chimney. We don't know it our chimney cap is cracked or if it is the flashing around the chimney or if tuekpointing the chimney will stop the problem. At this point the labor costs will range between $50.00-$60.00 per hour. The work will not be done until spring because the temperature has to be between 40 and 95 degrees. 2. Replace 3 Exterior Doors The costs of the doors alone are $998.00, $1400.00 and $578.00 totaling $2976.00. All doors have to be installed and are not standard fit doors therefore; we have not gotten any bids from contractors. 3. Replacement Windows The estimate for replacement windows is $10,360.77. 4. Plumbing repair Replace plumbing fixtures in both bathrooms and kitchen — Unknown $$$ 5. Basement Floor Repair drains in floor of basement to prevent flooding — Unknown $$$ Home Improvement will increase our property taxes. Unknown dollar amount Unknown Factor is the potential closing of John Adams High School. This will decrease our property values 0 Page 3 In Summary 1. We feel the commission would be placing an undue financial burden on us by requiring us to side our house with cedar siding at an additional cost of $9,144.00. Plus the upkeep of the painting/staining will be at a minimum cost of $1,212.50 every 3-5 years. 2. With the value of our house having only appreciating 1.85% annually it will take 36.37 years to break even on the additional cost. 3. The average house in the South Bend/Mishawaka has appreciated 5-70%, ours has not. We will not receive any financial benefit from the increased cost of the investment. We want to invest in our home and make it look attractive but not at a financial burden. 4. We have other projects to complete where this extra $9,144.00 can be more effectively spent. The potential hardship that the denial of the Certificate of Appropriateness would cause us, would be the hardship of undue financial burden. 0 ' EMERICK & ASSOC INC REAL EST APPRAISAL CO i� rile No. NA • September 22, 1992 Bob Marshall Notre Dame Credit Union 19033 Douglas Rd. Notre Dame, IN 46556 File Number: NA Dear Bob: In accordance with your request, I have personally inspected and appraised the real property at: 1704 E. Wayne St. South Bend, IN 46615 The purpose of the appraisal was to estimate the market value of the property, as improved, in fee simple, unencumbered by liens. A legal description of the property will be found herein. In my opinion, the estimated market value of the property, as of September 16, 1992 is: Ninety Eight Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($98,500) The attached report contains the description, analysis and supportive data for the conclusions and final estimate of value together with descriptive photographs. Sincerely, Dennis A. Em 'ek, IFA, CA -R DAE: jmw • 3524 Mishawaka Avenue, South Bend, IN 46615 (219) 289-6731 lj 10 � 9 � 0 Bonner Appraisal Real Estate Appraiser and Consultant June 19, 1997 Rick Burden Notre Dame Credit Union 19033 Douglas Road Notre Dame, IN 46556 File Number: 97U115 File No. 97 U 115 Thank you for the opportunity to be of service. In accordance with your request, I have personally inspected and appraised the real property at: 1704 E. Wayne Street South Bend, IN 46615 The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the market value of the subject property, as improved. The property rights appraised are the fee simple interest in the site and improvements. In my opinion, the estimated market value of the property as of June 19, 1997, is: One Hundred Eight Thousand Dollars ($108,000) The attached report contains the description, analysis and supportive data for the conclusions, final estimate of value, descriptive photographs, limiting conditions and appropriate certifications. Sincerely, Nancy G. Bonner, SRA NGB 2700 Portage Road, Niles, Michigan 49120 616 683-6029 V v Cos - I-, - 20 ""I's- a- -I'M NYSESTOCK PRICES Prl- SMAhDrnN3kN111-kA G JA , 1x&hnn C sMY, Fear; dYr Wmsnw $;3.000 �J`• - ; t7PX 57511,n 1 - 1 .; UG Mm.x, }•171Y.1 Ae4Y.r x, 110 Mur. x• F:J n n i IR ."8^ .. ._... IN fro. lr,r - 1r,•r •. a. ... i IS ' }rN ..... .,.,. .._.. a.., . ...... y, .,,,,. A 1 .. .... , a• S/ kjtlr «""'4,. 41:141•'• "Dr ,.�KK nu F C IV NtntlN•.,Gt bNiMe:t VQJ. dl I 'K �.Oi I wi.w 1 IT f,x ^a.r• •"fi�„x 1"1w • :iy`.°Odi'iiTe�»;ii,.'z.''�MuL::ilToo:'i,«. Lly nu Ovif5&� _ o,yityff :d.>r� r"i 1Mr .rii *0 n.. ...r, : j ."•`.,e.- iris iv �"h: U'r »„_n ';a N _iW' r I.NY,n 1a.•r Srrentn"'s slate. Lmd. Ch." OM<r/«Ylpx,.M ase a... s r -1T _..... a. 'iz swot rt.pptt•. r«. e.Mn..."r� aya M:4I R:43 0:43 r: 31 ...... ... Home prices rise ij-i Indiana NASDAQ STOCK PRICES Prl- SMAhDrnN3kN111-kA G Mrl,ift- C,ly inPtXtn , 1x&hnn C sMY, Fear; dYr Wmsnw $;3.000 G.vy tt.m vo V:nlen.ux„ �i0 H 57511,n L.lay.n. - 1 It"t,m O _IR Mm.x, }•171Y.1 Ae4Y.r x, }1.1 axt Mur. x• F:J n n ..C. •-'K L }NT `.kr 7. fro. lr,r HxbmMq x,M ......... 1r,•r •. a. tvrxY„rrxn, x• }rN ..... .,.,. .._.. a.., . ...... y, .,,,,. A 1 .. .... , a• S/ kjtlr «""'4,. 41:141•'• "Dr ,.�KK nu F S-11-11 uN1...,., IV NtntlN•.,Gt bNiMe:t VQJ. dl R,cn.ncnwt �.Oi ..,}r u�•x, d, •..rx.« ...rt- .... - IP f,x ^a.r• •"fi�„x 1"1w frord.da cYrrh «xX:yw urKX :iy`.°Odi'iiTe�»;ii,.'z.''�MuL::ilToo:'i,«. Lly AMEX STOCK PRICLS Ovif5&� _ o,yityff :d.>r� r"i 1Mr .rii n.. ...r, : j ."•`.,e.- iris :A �"h: U'r »„_n ';a r«.w11r:.°""Yi-M,af w E1ZP'r FYb�� r I.NY,n 1a.•r Srrentn"'s slate. Lmd. Ch." OM<r/«Ylpx,.M ase a... s r -1T _..... a. SMITH ZEIS2 swot rt.pptt•. r«. e.Mn..."r� aya IVDIANAPDIJS tAPt -- Singqletamily homes are Ixeeom ng 1- affordable In Indana• Ind that s K°ed nems In mal "We esp.Yt JeHmy D. Fisher '1f An area is stoma -Wolically them's going M he people moi M .1 -1, A_ Y r ar. andoue• Pugh-�prtrd ixrrr- air got"', an Mt bebu�lt "Thear betors -0 poalt the.4-61Nldy imp•. dmnf Md 0'x the -f of a h•«tih,Y ."nomy.- sold tTshrr. dmYtar rd the Ieli.nn Ilei-esity Cyder for It" 1:s LAW sttxiiL Indo -'a median to..- {Nd.• .mr• In $73a.A! throng Ow A.1 tpmrttr of Pl ,, up 12 1 fn«,1 Ito• tTt.1o!r nndinn boon' I.nn• rrlF,ialr•nvl hong On, 4mnh rpnnrr .f n«M I«n ,Nowt In«n ihr F;:krx.r 11x• Wn I.- IA- dum"! It.. f -i rpinn.•r .d I:wl, It.. b.h.- Axw ,ahem .I Il-4-,1Mn.Yt M.XuF.' hxlmn'is I..rs,1.r• a0twt hrbie x U -A .h.Ngxrl to I;A frrx. illi donne. Mx• yuan•Y TM• 4u1,•s Xw:taunr In - .qt a lxdmn nx,xe• f: Ill 1.111,111: 317,47,r r;m :d 4.1 it.. '-fou. I.i.-I Ix«rx• TI.- L.N.'t -W,; W.tM ••: flo-,nrvh:... uwnn... Lurnh vada akmt . het'. :A 1 u r ,•--ywmnv 11, 1r.,hnn txN A I I I, {a1 ,n•• a •'•i ., n Mr I.'I. ,� •.... rx lr'.,'•' "A: 4,11 11,4♦ al., n• loo, ;"ol.y-01, J W., M.- ll«• +NN«x. a mr4 a, dw fad chat d , drrq, Into. d t.r A ryn.-, mern F.0- "wl -R " ..ally « rix•Miw• 111.,1 mnIn.Nv1w, .,.n"ko Ix nYn:nnMR FTw rvrl«mar INro,nrg .,n,uWolay n«h•x r..a I27. d,1nng the N "I 'I m., '!'1w o-1 om naonmdtIt 1- wax Hn7.1..t donor. Ib.• quaver A1XMg 22 rtgxmc hunt 11 IM- Iie.ltiln, ihr hgh-1 wrlMo Ixn w 1 n th,• yvx r w ., 'boduM N:nur}ire F,mnty m 010 .d IndLm:yrd,a.M 1140.1.41 TI.- Iux..aI roe 14'.1 1x. m Mann. mm Cc,m fauna' I''.I r"otihr rirl•IN•Ix.. n Ch, un.lw+++ h.h.uu, Hurt HOME PRICES Mesion morn- p-, sm ,ro«ma M ird,Anx dummg ino Rist quant of im5..s l. -d ct by IM Met- Assr .NN, ,1 Irna.M. Reglan Prl- SMAhDrnN3kN111-kA $60000 Mrl,ift- C,ly inPtXtn %5.0W 1x&hnn C sMY, Fear; dYr Wmsnw $;3.000 G.vy tt.m vo V:nlen.ux„ $87,0011 mon WnY,X, mgxw 57511,n L.lay.n. 1704tA It"t,m O 1'.11 fY«t Mm.x, }•171Y.1 Ae4Y.r x, }1.1 axt Mur. x• F:J n n 111. ti;lnfn Vrr N'.n„x••, }NT `.kr CnY ,.nf4• fro. lr,r HxbmMq x,M ......... 1r,•r •. a. tvrxY„rrxn, x• }rN ..... .,.,. .._.. a.., . ...... y, .,,,,. A 1 .. .... , a• S/ kjtlr «""'4,. 41:141•'• 10001 ,.�KK J.,,- Arra 344, o", S-11-11 uN1...,., 3Ni5,0W NtntlN•.,Gt bNiMe:t VQJ. dl R,cn.ncnwt 1570(41 u:dxxurl loam• pan^. w18 n m•,. ":.a pvgdr foul bub ata man• drxlnlhlr nt:rnye 111 tn:,nr nt inr Mh,•r .•11'1, of .. ....rola that n r+l i,• M .dlr.r1111.. inn u, ,«.x •Y1N- m 1m• •rvxr. r,r r' lrnrl.4Yn. Steelworkers union targets new LTV minimill WINSTVIL Ind rAP- The Trite SI -I Co to huifd ihr• fi$D ih,Ims !lean. I-sidem ni Umled Stn•Iw.,rkrn .d A---.. in tndtimi ntmitnlif at I.W% Imlmns mord SW,1hers Isx'ai 1-11. trn+ls in wgamrr ..,rkerx 1t a num 111 -tow %V"k. in East Chicago, whwh npmsenLs at.nd 33(m mi - Ind nr a x th,, LTV !ant hr•n li tont"'no 1hrl- 1AWI.. 11x1 sRiEFCASE COMRLED FROM STAFT AND WIRE REPCRTS a Vhritmen planning stock repurchase CHICAGO tkhoo,n Carp aul M1Inn,Gt 11 plana n, n• iwn oda• : mr 1-, ,n .11 onomu ,h.u,•a .w A..." iA pmrmt nl .La .r, k .\I \IrnuL+v, .'4.,+ne Pn,r •.f Six_,", ., )khnm:m wh +m ih,• Iw,Nwk ,N x nn 3•.t _ mnln,n ' kkhn`t. ...ri :d.xli; n n"Ah",'It.+r,•an r, 1.. t. n into ha'+•ri tl helnr,l, , tl,r ,...r.�,i n„i iia. n,r.rrr 1 •r 4• AtEthnn Allen plans longer plant closing 1, k N Ili fly t•,nn Fthan.V Im....n I,. "Lyn, tr +A1C «• lunNtnn- n notaytNn R. b« iwN:,'r rt« 11..1, !h, ......... t t., 1o,.' ..t r......A de nrl nn,rl nr x1 tn., Ia.nx,la,r,.rr. 1r „rrwr �� lie n,•,+L,Ih .14 •4n,.1rxl thy. n«ttpitnt; ih,• ....... m to e,.lenrI IhI. 14•,me Ino an extra ,...k at A-4 ,ta rn. th.11 r«I 1vrnn+rn ft,a. At- id.4 ape rh . h.'h pl.nd, rill 1.- ann'1, rl .onll m Afahama that I.TV r,«p P ' ' a A.G. Edwards posts T .... XRti:Ax wanted the mm 8.• 'IY •4,vamn was dro'In1: , and IAo inn•mn noes an- WWI . 141 unr0 m Ila• s-ilw:rd to a• the r„hy Ix lwrY n if.. um,m and ixv 16% earnings gain 4rg.' n nn h -lo n sed rtwoo s grnAng: x1,0 market- and Count 4.114.1 Pi.m 111 mete, Yn ST 1111 iS A'; Fdrams The st-lo-krn had Men work tag smtr it•tr.it.•r In nm. om they anno.-I WI week they had day .Ih orrw shy rrvNn ihr ('Imam bekm, tYrnalmelion to Deralur. Al. 1, 1 hoard LTV inr ,.ml ne r.sra hat'lo-er e.l a i« {Y'n,,,i ,err the to p.«� C. �Cf) enm•s`IxrnAmg I.. -I , .e.tr ARC. WARD OF TRADE Imo_(, in, n•<nu Id h.•Aihv DOLLAR •1,.Y Ittrrk.•l .• nriMy oNtx Icon flu• In.tdmg , •rnfa,• xlo.h ,•'• °Yr" ell• » ••••'" 'm '�•,. w n , ,gN�r.dea Ilu• hn,kr agt firt,t .t e") «, xs r •«C+w+'«.yn,s. aur Cot •, s r " Vdwanl, h Srmc card Itearned ,W n �+~ a share. S: t.a -lb-In • •tr" ,. ,-,entre rd the Sara eY. . ps.l r•»r-, +9••.: InE.r taoo w w.,x„rrn ,pax. ear w..nM r1 l•.• l?l'• %1.,, 1; 1. h 44 � x' gn.,nrr e,xb+l 11.41+ tt in the r w»I �...•,r,.w-,} •�..• 1•r.•. the •amt M ,-- n "' '•«•`yn.r:irr u•. .-.. I 1..11 -pr ,.eT�«,a•.«ox• ... aye.-• ,«.. s ..n, r•, nr, Arf,HLro s syn M .Nw yw`« .. c•« n•. t:`I lirl.,r.f•r,q.. r ox t' •.,.t.vi + �xN,».vr r... • worse., coax roo , b1,ar' .,1 r ..rrr., , ,rr th. f " x.pm w a k•r• «x.nx V., .. • » DOW JONES AVERAGES ..... .,.,. .._.. a.., . ...... y, .,,,,. A 1 .. .... , a• S/ kjtlr «""'4,. 41:141•'• 10001 ,.�KK t :SA. r cJrrhn� .e;..,,;. n,-rr... Ih, li dw «nArny doy Q -`e, e.Cdeo7fedlSm.nvtct �. tan «•p: «t,rn Y1m eTiis�..rtivwma:�er•.�i s^ ^•iE'taY PmufC�a; (t BUSINESS RM A f . a ' i 1 • I A Markatnlarp Fnr r" W -x2 tr'1 ..,}r u�•x, d, •..rx.« ...rt- �MM� JpW��T�IIt � "Business to Business" L,a.a./ Nat 1.2-A i.�►.i it i (I- Y. Amer..•,,... r•I....Fn1 Hy LA�RYa MARGA$AA 1, by ..Jl.,nt ,hr 1 OppenNMtt.. ati •_ licxi.m•d•C. A. ManeRw,«n p, S.rv..i� to p.«� C. �Cf) tai ASuP .• nriMy x ^• 1 , i:"Mi'..� "iii".i.> ,o,"i ".',,. �.,;„. A „lx.tM y dor xd• _�+• p`„? `rv»1"iti �iim•»"%: the 1 «els O row ,-h rn«r ph- 111 !hr u.lr, ,ymM7 in, M«Mn.ry, Wtrri Ixxlpm Ma f.W qt Heaton. a Ulxrr wlunr •.r. d,en,ioct yp. -. by inn. q rine M ,-- n "' W.4,. Piot.. Mr b,Mn.m. 111 be dcugna,on urctxhrd to,rtit;T: ,.a^°,�d - F -.i irLir " cock tette. I- ho bebwl, old C,a r.:y'E"fh xC:rotY; ;119:;: .•hat rhe entire .,-hot •, r„e,ed 1"•2 said the xoom rror 3'Bi,fn°v x w'• «""'4,. 41:141•'• .o'or•y tlrronet ,.�KK t :SA. r cJrrhn� .e;..,,;. n,-rr... Ih, li dw «nArny doy Q -`e, e.Cdeo7fedlSm.nvtct �. tan «•p: «t,rn Y1m eTiis�..rtivwma:�er•.�i s^ ^•iE'taY add,4oti ifri yor bare n p+xdd•o of wc�t yox.c X<Nkng �"0.' '.;s4°tr�"PS" w' sr"""M.'i�ei.�,:r�r too yet n puc. o.d Iht1 -fir _1KG150tt,tAKD of the Ire top job -I the AFI. t tih,x- mon o" n , yn.,, f,x ^a.r• •"fi�„x She 1s the first ..man 41.+'r.' secretaIT tmasnrer of beet nr. frord.da cYrrh «xX:yw urKX :iy`.°Odi'iiTe�»;ii,.'z.''�MuL::ilToo:'i,«. The amrrrr vald doen,ty Yn.r ..,,rrr ir,.,r. «•v4 .x,rk'a Ovif5&� _ o,yityff :d.>r� r"i 1Mr .rii t±"'» "~.. : j ."•`.,e.- Swrrnry. prosd the Sono . i.w ra4•, ro v ..A, wl,�,•,k �"h: U'r »„_n ';a r«.w11r:.°""Yi-M,af w E1ZP'r FYb�� r I.NY,n 1a.•r Srrentn"'s slate. Lmd. Ch." OM<r/«Ylpx,.M ase a... s A: 21 1:77 413 D: 31 t:32 1:33 0:44 M: •t L43 1:31 K: $3 t: 33 SMITH ZEIS2 swot rt.pptt•. r«. e.Mn..."r� aya M:4I R:43 0:43 r: 31 ...... -_--. No" to eN KATHY M.i PLASO-1. Fe. w .nagdy .••« rLt. n F•'. ,i. itn•, n • • rk.. +i.•t .. and n .brat um• IN'•.; .\n0. to a Y• --t . wr Iwnrm.d , . p,nlnfur Th.. Mork pv n' a 1- Ml - -n Mln rrna�n ,t r k� •. mw 1. LAI a „- 1•almenlry •^ ••' • th14 hrn! p r•^ rrd1,,. of r: 1'� I'•'� v, miry int n t.. itn..br aero ,1.. . A TAI, •. «ka ix,n•I,. •.• arh Th v I-- •' inntd A p.n,r+J.,• •.. Annind Uri• .; .IN'n !nr tt ft, t .r,v 4 ,hand,! r ,m In. '. �.. I . I•.nnnoer •d ..:.. tion $tw rt r, •:.; • nanetal PL1m,.-,z lin. a,r • nd far-: ,^ p ^M. moat, In.I a the , r.. ,..., . n nlLttx.• I.." paH,.•.. t1 11111 n,prml`IH'11 . SNt,gN+n neri�• 1.111 thrnt S,rn•�out tt .'hrn the So,nn. t•r-r-. »N .rd,lmn -,-Z r; �N!•d n. Ind u1 IY •.n, An u, p• .rnTM• a.,h At m,111,1 p.••r Easterli _ /A 7r'�T A •%. ' k 1 �ikriJ i Hy LA�RYa MARGA$AA ONh.3 lar R...ft.o.. i>) OppenNMtt.. ati \k A'•lif\(:TII\ Ii1nt,+.r � Y 111 Ila• tunmmn- • Hbrkrrs nt ,lmrne. hu• W.,k DYw.N Prep..y +xprs•f•Mi to eh,sin to be the N m.g r. .Xr Set. of. _�+• p`„? Tom M the 11' pi:ii,.,;v-.:: Mt:.•r : " ,y,f• «'t�� o;o• Heaton. a Ulxrr wlunr •.r. t{.:'eo �d_>+ 'T' " 'tai •r» er,al,. Dunahur. the A17. 4114 iTrVff t "i`•e� ' d m of the la ntmm�r, her •, derii of the IaMu hdcrahnn. • 3�� .r yW.r rd �rt� a Y 3ir�i°'oi» make the 1• nTl{'n1 :.r>: w>• . _i 1"•2 said the xoom rror 3'Bi,fn°v x w'• trtannnwuemem N ow RM.^•Afx :,.vun•r nt MMff i•I ii t :SA. r cJrrhn� .e;..,,;. n,-rr... CENTURY Zi r1 -..d AR.011 a rn•b,n Jim DUNFEE • y "' ,rem ihr rima .+xa.1n to hr•+d SMITH ZEIS2n.. exp . »r.».•... ,:,.'� of the Ire top job -I the AFI. t xF.f.l�rr >,x s„fb..p, ••'p'�. f,x ^a.r• •"fi�„x She 1s the first ..man 41.+'r.' secretaIT tmasnrer of beet nr. .:. 55.S The amrrrr vald doen,ty Ovif5&� be an tAaur m the camPhm.. _ _..Mrs«_,. j ."•`.,e.- Swrrnry. prosd the Sono ww ftii'"wsw'P.'; ''/«'sxn �"h: U'r »„_n ';a FmPimr•ra SMr'- mahnnal !'rvnn Thr, only ¢maim candrdair • CENTURY], _ __ `C•w Srrentn"'s slate. Lmd. Ch." JIM DUNFEE • *',"T„T`J Thompson of the Amtn;,- F•.t.' SMITH ZEIS2 =FM - ,;.".i 3+ti." . AMIAA e,ndwal". , 'eflia TRIBUNE You"NOT Promises Nr 1 AGE, ONCERN cS of MOST MORTGAGE COMPARABLE HOME PRICE INFORMATION* LENDERS By. CAROL ' C - BRAITUY #a.Nr.,.lit DFAR 110 11 --d .; let' I TI 4 ...... bit V,=tly rdv,hHd.. I.. I. th ild r I,,9 b I f,i,.d li— w "I f hl't I . ....... =44'r Thr 1 of II.,- %V- ,A, nil;:,::1" .., is-.:.: Hard tocol rrd ruck ¢nrihn at Aithirh I I-r ..", Sim INK) it, (:Iw. 1-.d.. IF Hill it,fn y 1-4 . .. . ..... 1 1-11.4 f" 100 INN) Nb,h ...... N A, I - ...... ............. . . . 111 f-,, 912n . -M. I P. .. .... ... I . I-t 1225— NI1171;11 in t Tirt I,: 7. "I .... ...... 14 rr . . . ... .... ... ........ . ........ .. 0.01— SHOUILD ROME SELLER LIST WITH REALTY ..... ..... ... 0- " 1 WHO SOLD THE HOUSE? i! .. 1.111,11, At- . -AN 141-11- C,04-11 lik 11 1',1.r It if I 1.2 J.,. ......... •.1 fit, .1.11 -k. 1- . ..... If, , hr kiln»» 01 1 ........ I ....... .... . -1.1. . it, N till 1, -1. ..... ..... .. v-.14HUSBAND AND WIFE CAN AVOID TAX t8 E SALE OF THEIR HOMES _i -I .. I I. . ..... h" 11. A.H( I I., My aM. spring touch winterm-vt'LIiary hearts 1.1— noun .0 wi..I., A-111. th-ohl 6 ... IT I. The tarry IP.I.I. Ltrvnpvpr m I nd R-- r South Bend rank affordable ho -me by SUIT KLIMEK SOUTH MEND II'. .. -01 . ". - rnI ....... r,...4, ISMIL1111L s high on READER PHOTO OF ii -IF VIIEEK -P 1riceS2/1'71q1p STOPPING TO SMELL THE FLOWERS 7 r4, gar :,, rRict 1'w 3 nd,, %.Ie end I hi,pi.ff for . .,t .1--d `125,(m nn _y t h—, COMPARABLE HOME PRICE INFORMATION* of ai unr 'Ithl 'cult.. 1. 61 IN."" - 1 1, I.. I. th ild r I,,9 _7 ft;t,l, it i,d I .... it,fn y f" 100 INN) Nb,h ...... N A, I - [111 Inn 111 f-,, 912n . -M. I P. I-t 1225— NI1171;11 in t Tirt I,: Y."k . . . ... .... . ........ .. 0.01— '22' 141-11- C,04-11 lik 11 1',1.r at 0 a Photo Of THE wtf. 8, Fitly. ff,f—d ,/ ...,.+ •+rw••r+•. +9Mi, a.wr+Faw•wi ,•tr..•.1+ Bosh buyers and sellers profit from area median home prices By PAT M LELIaERTJr- + +.... n..••.w l a,w i nr meNan Met- for Rnak famd} M+mt5 made tM SnuIR Wnd NuM1araka real e-amarkM .liras e+r for hs- tmatn dunne the 11.10 mune, H.i .1 nIM Iran alerag, mffrav on IM rnrvban 1.••rr atv+ made 340 ani s Ira, r,'Uie marL,i alltat .. r rue M+n1r a•11Yr, ill v. 111nxll r.rrhlIing data tome-11Om the %a. •nal awe wlhrr. or Reaii.Irk a trade xrOCniwn int ♦ ill.Ilii 71,.16 of eel one homes -A- Along • • IM• Juh ♦.•ra-f- $-nod m tilt NMw,aT. The v uln IIv.l Mtsha-aka mark t, wnh A medun i r.e M ti9 :T' dunnq IM Ih+rd quanrr. r A -ow M !M •.+•1 dlrmYnr leek ft UM to S Por real -,late bar a ,l i.• ........ -I m+vtun Parr -as 1966(s0 -sib M ml•1 ••yI+f .rn areae al..ar $Rai k's i rw nrl;rw.f n•..Iun i, Nr, $,7$400, wall m linM'fuiU. . sea• iln• h....a iw .Ta war m Sagma-. NKM1 11 Ilw• .+n„ tour IM• b,ndl' /..d Mr+laaraka -rat a+A+•e r ret iif rn4dn NK -•1111\ i.nlfnY. A +In„,•r•nr 4'. '+IM• m.•,lraA Isl r I- an e-Nifn1: yI.• tan.+'. + . f.•iwn•n It.. Ion -1 19.0 IIuM �' h11.... , 1n n,_f ef•unUxiri♦ V..a 1w 1.1111,!N•11.1 MW .N. arra-: .. .• .•, +.u+rth u'rtaii nalu.•alir,. am+l • .. .... x la. •,.' \ .. ..ri.r ., mlua..l lar.n . _. ». " .. +: • r•.1 -I.0 1. l,x•!N rr•eahar+ ,. .11 Im ...••I ....,.Ih It •, +,x r,aa .•13R1. ttnt, the ;v AR sad The *,AR's IRI, of tacreaxe for the Louth ffr•n0• MVILWAILA arta mar be d0oned ep Use Wve of mode an pore- - the mM pond bel-een the hleb-1 aM MrtU - rather than -n" prlrM aftxudmx to Karen Rnuah, v- in -0.1 of the Sown Rend- -1'iha-aka Ana Board of Realises. "Nyle very WyTarat" -lie said, rmph-rg the South Rend-liftNa-aka area's reputation for afford. A bio, huuang "When pr pft - oln Ih-bol n-ty, d'S .-Fe. olwm•r - they " a greaitr +'aloe her, than worn 1fw+'re rom.ng fr-,- eaNd Rob," N. Naw kr, sal- manager for Sbn,th.Z,1n C'o. int Roush aAd ana real eslalt prkei lend to inese.- at a m,Nh•r.le fwl 4eady rale• en,vn.g A nA.anname •eitnwnt rrfurn wn Ie keel". Mres.srMrdabk 'n,M• nnlnl Uu'i '.1.111 P+'"'f' mnea-I'M fo tM ,lN+rt U' d, f.11-1 try falling fir- later wM•n rir u,anf ,h w Many MmarowM•ra "I rauY,hf .0N 1 1I Ilwy I.V wta In- are n»ng Awl m N wH mN,n Not— wf.n fn,rr♦dny+, Ma'.41•11 'Wer kwp ph.NUng NU,ng.151. A Prr-.1 AMually:' Saw Jem Nunl,r, Ill-, Irol of It MI+IItPM i.tdmq yv. vN4, M ..elh IM+ni M,h.-k.. He w rell-111y, 1•r IM ol,1 e 1 avenge (rAthrr It.. n -los.) anmut itvr IMin rvNdraM r, a nt IM• r.+unlrY r.1 -b. „i 1µ•n1 i-xt♦ rN,nnq tow 19"K, hdL.w+„1 NY .N-fiatnu, N•. finMv.nnrein. ..luw,.l, Iw wnl IINY 1.•Y •unt IM• Ir erMrdh Iwo» on., rNw• Iw1r ,+ Ih•+ty In.rrth In Uw t.dn11N, lY x/ r+nn4•fu{I•N i.+• -ml iu• nil, honsra still are ,D.P•r 1100!40 have e.r1y 1 Excel completes purchase of Johnson• division +i ktt 5RT - Fleet IMu-lms !y -dm the Auto Industry in the the firms ftseai ,n+dular window, Ire Bony+lei+•d tht I Ich-ol of fall loan- w9nrh have rewNedm HIG million I.hnv.n lnmrnl Int a Isobar \Ya. The mwfuiar produrt.a are aa in.nl- over the pad live Y'am he f.... Irf+n.,+•n f."o-d In ha-, -we PMrnusf thin lard fn•• farR ,lana. 111nn IM+k Plan :•.+Baa Irrmr ++I (M Mai ern ... I "bM1 , art I, IM only \nnh ,. nnl..• u+.-1 of ail .... ,1 a+ rel ,+w k- a•'r +rdrnx I I,•u+..r II,I••l ra.v t.i.harl h.l•,vi Klr.4 in Ind .,It odd st-I $IN n+lo t.vrrl frazes'third for Lai- L.hnr..1 .,d Aflaul !. nl.li,on -fll nc IbievtM 1n thr Ilk• plan$ he sad I �i•• -max r 111 t.+Yrs In.:u,IrM!' 11.,11 an r V, in, nxdular _.A.Z- Irnm 1 Ma rill tori, for+. Io'+1 tM _11" t'-, and t;acl•1 -,11 pi o,'dr -fork,- rvoN.. r. 1•. -11 e'4 r, noWular plod.fl 11 a sdt• . rob up eta, un,, m . ear. . n I. a ols,4d min a ... r .•1�,V J4"•+ i!•Mnan,.+M one .. ..•.li.,^.. i+rate•, 1+A iu tt• -Ntr•- Executone ANNOUNCES THE ADDITION OF: ISi)tcwTEC DiGITAL SYSTEMS to the traditional Executone Line MPETEC' is a product of Executone information Systems, inc. ,y t Executona, the Nationwide r - Ttfephoe Company In South Stood SMc9 1952 ''' " 237-0700 HOUSING VALUES Nero a,e rnwu n b -o w'Caf ,n Iht Dn•d ou.+ - of I M and 1989 lo, sever., maaopdn.n a-- ft- one NAhMnI A."Cioll(In of P6Mtw1. ' taw Itt. .vo«w «p+o+uru ews+ $373M0 1215000 36- 6.$1.. $1 .$06 3115 900 7.9 C-9. is"" tii+.p a5 Sas Nal SPO Wo 6 $ G+rurnoys Llys 363+00 sa, 30) 77 C- Mt 900 if/ Ace 53 Gas'.1 a,6600Bra no 31 x+0•u•.c+o••s /IS800 112600 .t f..ana R.ntla uses 'M S65 6M 43 n+rcibr. w9, no $63 am 99 L.'w•no .66700 Sol, ,5. 7$ .-I- S63" amlo0 "a a.un lian son.nwnt. a$.Ja9 151.wa I" Beat mfre..r In valet; be a P1AmM. Nawtq-lrmalM that 7Ato NO Prr-I fol -.1 all. ,,lila have Involv(d I. leired ai loci 1f1a11 SIrA1 Ods I turlhr agnrd, not'" that $40,010 in $15,(A10 h.-- rnnbnw in be it. sa..ef of list area hnunng market tiiroryf rMn'nnA lam r i.- fin- ay ex(ta+n wby ill, Y N'`-1nn r- here row ai A d ubir.hgll rale dunnq IIx fm.d year. he sax Any Aran• -1 in+uw well txirni Ir quuu: In .wit wed iwnr; NNuvh W Nf Whits- IM fair M I.— _Ms has xU.-I m rvnrnl N+rka, ffnnJ' ei ,yNllnlvlta• .1uu1 i!.• ku'r. 1. -nn •„N .a, "1 yr nowt p.gar untying in th-, 11-l-, x.1:' ,fw run-n.ntlni AYYn111nN; In tlw NAlt +txla, ilw r+rmi,nn.'n,yr tan. 7r lxn+n- rr:air IKu•e m if,, Soulh Items M.A.,.ak. arra has rt •n :.faddy ha' In" years, IMm MS.e001. Bill to 359,I00 In 1" Io M2.201is no BPM 1st Source caters to small business Sflt'AI Rk:SD - [jftl me hi-res.) stmem long avalfaWe only to fare, laMos- An now ayatlabk locally to -11 and b-oh-M»d b.,,neiv- id Snnrn Rank on W'edntala+ um 6040 it' Prra'nai -bnputer baW I.Touch ra.+h Manatee... W.In this +emr,. bust-- -- 11 art abtr io obtainuptodat, a enssit batanr- on ina2, mnnry market itrbunm and CMrklbx armonu% Ttn+ Aly A" aW in daily fa5n Pn.dlom, hM but rMn fMKk, have clearM. r -le arrounly, rn 1 Crl t"• iratv(rr fury .ni Rei dria,led arrnunl SUtYmeaL At rnmr pmol In the fulun a thsM r vnlre -nil In• nlrr"d '11,-g -S to makr loan Imyment by iransl,mnq furwt from ar ... The lnTnurh vrnwr +is.11.-are auqurat•vt 1.n a ln.l b+,+,m Ma ren Ma ruMnnn'fF In M1 I':+uw ia•1ny, nBl-I w .n M•r -1, ru,xnnrr, ami ,. ine iu lure ..It on, ai AHahir to new ru+l++mrra Srb. T1s 1 r-,..nl Ill - U SI,frl --1 fa Gr,uran• ,<Itw vsnant 1-1, In IN1,ana in otter tMr I aiw of rn +r in vraaRrr M++1rn».v.a IM• 1,r+1 +. t.•v.I ++, 1':v.nra+14• \Idr! v+.. Ih... nnia .+ a +hr+:n •• Innk, ..if., It., •,rax -+1+• v+4+14•r I �.• M ti a Iw+r ah r:xia i':.r nn tint •. n •: +.. nxi r+,xin .111+..1:•..1 e. •... ... $+t. Il,:at • n+iwdn .•n -.for r�l'n ........... •x..uu.•1 •aNNnf xul a,ni I, :,Mr11g In ,l In•rr A, al + a nun'IhW fn t n1 M01n 3H1 +Ir•fvmA hq n, tiw• ....... .1.1 r1 u+l,• n1 ai. n'rnt,'M+d+•.t + N-L"ll vN•iUarm•i'Mv,»nnr.3lM'uvr,jwlv,na! ' enlropdrr in rnlnprdrn .1 la ,nude Alfryvinga vrtanrifiM ai+M-:4,1 Hev S(1.1 sthe ion.. -pare -1.11, i. ss'-fl-Ill in.m611, An ody an un•rntrnk- lov-110 a hm j ,, gcd loin asdy.'MMI *, AH and..l.n-,ion 310:,lac Ika+ /� : N¢t4t•td'am-asel ill 1t nnittt136.x It lkvlr+vbI - ! /{ l:f lrtanrxaal en Nfr * "4 a+wi N.I,ii weal.,. al,l I mil- ter 1x'41 aekf awl♦iq tuft. nta•vl w,tNa. t ta}tww �,wra Il as., d I.I. e„ k,a- ...a,. +seal It,, -1 n. n U, Alfa M,"Nw Y♦IS r1• !, w+ll ak: all li--a rat, 4• xukr as +Iu"++1C yxwu r,tw Sk�raaak..Ikn. a+fvw Aralnryt f(y.� I i dnytrgt n y' � ' Llk- rvs -I- aav d Na /M woa•1. , .kers Y-r-arMr•i-w s iw.rr»9 Mar -+w. Iw w amfiM U.w. te,fw LEY -LEEP BUICK. INC. S302 N[ Awn t GRAPE -ROAD MISHAAAKA, IN ( 219) 2''2.4!990 '1 WEBS MAR _ h-. A marketplace far'"Business to Business" f:1 r r'� ' 1. ..._ ar .••-, w..+«r-rm. w _ tar a,r«a it,•4,.rn+ e.,.». «.-.-...... _..«. .,-......,........ ... 31.1./$ m tlwin,,awtl a tta•»14+ so wrwn-rar,Ya-r tlrrr MAXITA TOO( SAW (HI(AG0 fid IiMAII( ,.t •> _. "'„'T'j,:. A. Lw tilt+ "l' ;+71St^ PiAa i:,w.,. ,,.. ":U.;: '.t 'its Ai°1,"o9aL.;• niW "�:r.�:" .•::= „ �.... lu_•.•�,. :» ........ .+., ,......... .... '• Calk. feaatl +• .. . •. 3••9+'•w•W ortN as rte 9trarltw• 973 + •`M • "•.^ . • •.' + •.-..a om»+" w, w+ s -,.,II» ass - - - - "6•• •�.• HOOSI[It SUPPtT V,_ _ s«rr„ i"�«. ........ .......,...... +.. .. . +, • lid - - �� [0...-r'� .u. ,t x.• IZZ ARED CARPET `M _ a �,i:'r•... ..a+.:w <�•T oaf, tnuervw• -I_ _ <nw.u, p ,«i svun,.r, •rm aii,pr""• •+e.r. .w.. f HOOSIER SUPPL Starttn at » . a „». T rn .•n�a%r1 I.d l,.«. �,.«ta4+,...a 1V .alai-tlaa+lrw«1-...rl T°• -..S •.wr:'T,:,, 559.95 iNaa auvltr,,.re ,www•. you can run .. _.. 41n TARPSI _ sw,tlw -$sa I-II a. an G.afgo-C.ntn your a'i:+ itw" ..". ;+{u -- wi, •,' 1«otesaonalr i n•,•.r i'•"• ='y:e ;n a: �� "M' Ws+ yI i�,,,� „� +".r r+.... « SNACK WNDING� C?anti w, •1 w+i0a'i'O�„, i"r•„r ]1�Itl ,l` 4„161 qj••+> rs f�)pw <'rtl.+,nM + Cw•w+«� no. el ��, :i. x• 'w ywxtiw+• ..... .,".. t Pod ir.,• :.F:w. �«:.».' -r(tTso1. EAST +i: . r» c«wr++s-nw.- tw' y F- aw�e i «.,9i _a Hw1-wr $31 - + '.. ., tlrt..•+.'ie.,. " ..:�2M,,. Tom:' a.«--«t...,.„x.�.. ":rC�..r.•w�'::: t (a. - �/� -•_�r� - +E".""' '"' ...,, r wr r o, .'•'w..a _x,..w. � „wt nN estn,.�y.n1« tat -- -_ - - .ncwaYa-~4011+1 • '�^«7'e ;.^.... + n _ +m •r•, + ,+r tl,+ r+,u [M,Ao . o »", -- rens •..,�I,n ��+'+ �c :::s.`%;t,•x• i°w 'r«"r'.'t«'::9 ««'. .. tl.a »:w'.'.ri AI 1 CAN ~V:w.:s>ah i "iiim ATLAS t.,S°.r, -a.betwlf,ta,n, �Y „r Kt t, »+m+♦Sea -by lull 8 Dnd.klM buW,afaafl fw W $73 „3 .,;. '.•8trs� ua �+r �<, .....,«,.. . . ,e• Noy. t> 11 CENTtlPY CENTER .. v.�o-•. .'�.:«.' ':� r • f3wfe fou. BY.1,,... a."- 23 .~2-808t1 � - Jt`'�,ri i•: Ir.,.. a...._ ., .. „.,,nn«.r�.:.=r.. an:r•.. Our Succor 1.' Detesmined By Y.- Soles,...! e.f0+. low Dur a P.tk.glnq ana 1b'P..nq I+dn- _ Chili ilial i0<Ywf on In. Ir.nehlt or'T Ze'.ff• GO tat for Inlormallon on how w taut on You, tuCC.a. CowDar.lxn on0o •rywooan pall $tau OvprblS w' b any Ane•'+a+ 'St 00 oonamry Out .o a r i srsie+n •s q.a+t0 io nib fou .040.6 Aro •aa•" 'cryvomsrs io a ..-.. oe ar.. nwr «a.E a 4mnes •-'row or+x�n•ons Avd"aplt •Ih+n SUAS.s ac c,r . ronann 0..x1.-0 1•anrn+seas +n.:+ bave 26:111 to to _-M per 11., i^tln Intl .a e•t one 11- •s lora1.0 Ann Can ' IT } STOCKS OF AnEA By DPVOENTIAL-BAC-i. >» Saxj 1 h w 119 niY inu••- 11 nM: aV• T +h r1 1+a - wrs t w u«vrr . • ..... .. i+M n\ tar++•.• BOARD OF TRADE ren Ban -1:+R„ an ,rt�tuvw�rnre s"nn « rt'..a +s arni t foal iwt W .5•tl ly IW to lar ia«�. ay Jv+s 1-�ta`yih je` • • • BellrMw,.wn .•tr.srtYxaa tg9ntt4xnn ts+nd T,•b.••e. i' .•S T tJr "e t`I S r/ Ste} •.. Both buyers and sellers profit from area median home prices By RAY M. LELIAERT Jr. r. i7,/M er..w. Eawo - Low median prices for :nngle•famlIv homes made the South Brad-Mishaoraka real estate market attrac• illi for home buyers during the third nuarter But ahigher than 3'erage increase in the median price ri made the area s rel estate market attrac• lot for home sellers T his srtemuigh ronfhchng data comes from the Na. venal .1s,rk•lalloa of Reallom a trade association Thr CAR said of of esishng homes was stronx during the July Sepirmher penod In the Midwest. south and parts of It* west The South Rend.Muhawaka market, with a median l.nce of fig 2(10 dunng the third eivaner, was one of the rin,t attractive areas In this US for real estate ever gains Tla•Itahunal median price was 1196,600 with .54 met ropn ,,an areas above that It%0 Tia• h,gh•,t meshan juice_ 1t75lKk1, was 1n Ifonatulu, whir the lowed 119,:'110, war m Saginaw_ Merri li flu• .so it lime, the Stnnh trend Mishawaka read .•,t.dr malki•t showed strength for sa•ncrs, 1w MmC a ii S I.•nv..t Kaon m ih• metimin pried• for an a—Inij: ,ulgn• (anuli Isms• locl%ecn ito• 19" and 1990 third yuarlcr, Ila. %A It :add Utah- well h.•hli d llon oluhi r M4 lw•rri-rr t Scar 1'. • a.0 Cann m •,. priuitw• %. Illi-Itend Me,ha ka arra'•- ir of uo r rse• wa, lose lh w inset n:+h..xally, artvud o+g In Ihr �.t 11 .Lila ,tu, ,. de, iia• ,.••.e ...Its. Sl ales r•.1' wlm 1. lool a .....di..n . t••,•.' ••t i•'• nil .s,.) i • ....... It. pe... Ines rase ul If. 1.v cent, the NAR utd. The \AR's rate of Incrra.,e for the lout.'+ Rend• MLchtw'aka area may be distorted by it* use lir mea, an prices - the mad -point between the hier—I and Inwest - rather than a\erage likes,, accordine In Karen finish, rice president Of the South Bend. sdishawatla Area Board of Ibeallors. • We're very untypical' she said, emphasinng the South Bend•MLshawaka area's reputation for afford able hutisng •'w•h•n people come into thlvrommumty, it's an r„•. opener - they see at greater value here than who -re Ihey•re coming from:• said Robert M Ila -ley. sale, manager for Smdh•Zeta Co. Inc gnash said area real estate prices lend to Increa•:.• at a motlerair but shady rale, ensuring a reasn»hle mveriment return while keeping priers affordable She noted that rapid price mcrrase4 tend to tis short lived, follnwed try falling prices later when d, - viand slaws Many h.mwrwnrls get cauyhl sion If ilw•v tatY w'ta•n prices lire rising and must .•,iii srao after when lar res finip, she holed "Wye keep goindding along at Sin a percent annnaill ” said Jim flunk—e. lwcswirrit of the Multiple Iaslmg Svr vire of Sooth thrid Mishawaka. fir was reterrl,eC 1., the Wpical average iralher Own imethatil amot:d pre.- lm•ir.71,e for itselfIu 'Ontnld, nu.uv arras of Ila• chantry raja•cror,rl nurse• Ia19d pnrr Orr.•m during, Ila- 19a1ts. h.11swed by dethil'+m a•. Iia• rrunumy •.i„w, I. Ia. "M ltnwi.•y ,.o,l itw• 17 n doth lu -r o.e+ra•r• hear r.. fir. 1•: ):..+w.l E. ,.t the irgseh.l dl rt m•aWrntriy ixhr.i In.os•, 'The lames tihd ;off- want SIM.0rt0 tia,e enp»t,1 Excel completes purchase of Johnson- division f'I AIIART - Excel Industries h' mvalt in the auto Industry in the the firm's flied modular windows, Inc completed the pit rrhase of late 19510%. which have resumed in $410 million f..hns'tln l onlroL% Inc s floor Sys. The mrafular prralucts are ea. in sales over the past five years, he ii -m, Division la•chd to have more potential than said. fhe cash tran,achon look pUer -•- ...... rill, rill,sday Terms of the deal w'err . ':.•1 .11" I.saA renamed };vt t•I Popwi /� Execumne In,mn. •.,leen, Inc, 6 IOS"ehd t0 171..• M ■ R ,rile, tenet. and is the only ;Ill ANNOUNCES THE ADDITION OF. v•nrnran rnanuLu bur rl (of ail o hp•s of w,od•.w rrgul.,lm, ISt�CC' DIGITAL SYSTEMSa•s,l a, 11 cars and trucks. a,cordnog - ":'I',hain;tIh,Jktla sIr;;I to the traditional Executone Line •Is R7i•> _ Thr new unit will add about M _ MPE �C• is a million to hscel Industries' third. •�".'f1�_ "�T''� quarter sales. Lohman said About product of !I mlWon will be invested In the Executone 1',krSSllr plant. he salt Lohman said hsrrl Industries Information has re•celI'M an order for modular .. Systems, Inc. windows from Chrysler Corr for :he 1993 1,1d.senes cars, and F,scei -- - s,stems xill provide window rvyu. _ labors for those cars -•.w The modular product is a side. .a, Executone, the Nationwide w tndnw rot) up glass unit in s car r Tedtphoc- Company In trelKc IhaI call h• as,rmbled milli South Betid Since 1952 .N.0mi•I.d dour Lohman said thea '• �.'� 237-0740 •'.•w sy,h•m iso e\pet'ltd to be xlde. .•!i, . . HOUSING VALUES Here are -ea-a,, hor^r erns- toe tn„d ouaner of 1090 and 1989 to, :w -,era. mov000+dam areas it n I" rwahona• 1 A.SSOC,ai+On of AlialiOrS I aror•au+� Ln.taga us.as.an C•^r•nnn, Or+•o-t IMlni[%Y3 Grano a.+un• n«coin L ansn9 rwos. Bwr3•Ylan.r+aa• 11,114 IV" S3157Y7 1775" v. s... em Wt vn }. ; 1177 res) sn+e-C say 2110 SP^ :rel s W Y.+ Y! 1 i:4 $17 !77 d 115 K13 $72 41", 159 7rn S65 £<%) e 3 M9 MJ.rr7 93 sm }PO 161 -1) 356,too SS1.1loo 1. 1 trot Increase in value," he r.pWrocai. Ilawiey estimated trial 711 to m rier"rol M recent area sales have Involve. Mmrs pnrrwt at :rss If— i I oe.ow llunfie agrern, noting that 540.oro to $75.(M Mmrs continue In he ih• iwmn OI Ih• area Mu,InK marlo.•I Strltng demand for eta -,e home, may ryd.an -ht In,� ui„han Nice herr rose at a dnuliledigel rade dunce; Ila- $Iasi year, he said "Any reran, rival No— wish pru,d is X to waif -0 I.•u•; • It'n'st mod whd.• the rate Of home sale, has slhxef :n —.0 irks, Il st„1. 11 npinm,lw aloold Its• Will' I; lin .., Wr•k -1 ,,,• Il.nf.• 1r,r1,1.• ,1,.,, 1..e; .w 111:.1. ..... .... •,i' to IN- N alt dada. M, Ii—ban , u•I.• I:oo, 1, 1..mr Ir. -Or Ilw,- in the South Rrnd No. haxai.a area has n vi sivadily her 1hrM years, front Yds dna) in 19K, to 149.100 in 191*1 Ill 5.52..•00 1n I9a9 .A / - QWWT U1, a no n a ttE++oed Y.roWwJ•wna Lnw...sp ►iso -p..,*.. rr. , GURi_ 7Y IYEII 1W1(.K. ' - SAQ2 Nt)ItI'll (,R \Yi ;t. MISS IAXAKA. iN (2 11), _ BUSINESSMAy�i 4kuRT 14aln7k IB, ,'Ci (��M� (if• �.y�r .• A marketplace for '"Business to Businacc to I- JHIEFCASE y TME )RiOuNE STAFF ANO WIRE RERORjg { Patrick purchases manufacturer list of recreational vehicle awnings tl.k1, 481' — Pa -1, Indus. m\ Inr 111 - no It, bald %tad PATRICK INDUSTRIES j ..;a d Indurtnrr the ol(n ro. {1a Inr a unnaa. Input ,a n of du••Ira h, ! • nd.nN rat•• I+a. R it'. It rr I vnK, I'ntntk. riWm l rola di" Ito ♦IN.,..1. ui a RnWnf ha. • 1MI I'Card 11.':: Third M, ha Nuel 41.1liCard i»nInK3 . :Ja rmpl.r�r a pr•al,Ir mak Inr r.rl year, umnc,.. Fr Prl ten trent K-1,14 .u.•1 N• had a { n.`i : it I1n •'1 ; .N• r vn.rnr« h. twr tM• r• rrrhnN h. Arr nn.i.�l lrnpuk .,t,at "duny.W - wrN and 11 l„rrA, annual .alts TNI n .I'h of r(r lI,a'hall III mrllrnn amts LI'I.h I'll ne.'RV ool."'l, ,. laK,a ,nM tomrnl, ,WY I 'a pxlr'I..od .ru r., rnrpM,Ij .1111 L'tnnr(+.rnN[,'M.aaj I. ,, kankr'1 ,ani nna'rnd r' I,nlrl a ,aq, keep Voo-11 NL .a near fur (reel + 'rural . 1-111•1 '•., L.W un „ M! 1M + "1 11x• r, t+-•r:q 1oke. try 1':. a.n Lxd n. r I44t u.nlm�ra .x awl mNr A«hn IMa»n lir In.. in Imo IM n•. I.. Ire r..0 ,rMr t1 Automakers still in the doldrums I - despite war's end, low gas prices • 1•111'rll — •• err and ii : I'Nrrarll,rrr ••rel lel, I.n d.r. ,.i�ul , . , n.• I n ...• , ,.. • . I... .. . l n 1 .. . • , r. r 1. , I .. '..n r... .. .r• Al III I'.AlI 1` as r' i uI. , Ilk.. .nil I r ri.r f t••w I.r Ix,... , „ 11.1 •�..r' a••; ,.. ..r•... .ler... wl .. ..... .... r.., I•,tv.•n',., rx ,n..rrl.N l,i. 4xrr h 1101✓• •. ... nIIa I.�. ,I hi. Itw r.rt Nrr joI ,rolrm rat M. Inr I•.r. , ••••r r •. u.. Ian• n,rin.hal d"I,ul it ,he LFrl4rnakt.t > ill tl,.'r n,r .. >. .. ., ,.,r.. .. ., ... .,,. ... ... ... ., .. . ,,. .•Kan 'I..rnr. rin..,,l • ort Inn .. r\ In'Irxlrll la in+ ,1•t'] r .. ,.. I..,.. Lu .. a i10i nth., rasa +.9 ..r... ..,n r. L..... ..• r..•. ,r ..+ t1rN,f N• i9,ai 1.' ..tn ha, -r rt.r. la•KmmnK r..N•1•yA lr Urkp RHO MITIONED ... .. ,. . „ .n n. •q., u...... .....an,) Imp uhrrf .... �IM I•'eir.l Illi.'. ern'.rnr 1111 I. '•nl a ,nor\ ,.. ••+ ++ a..a ,arA mpan+l wen a 4 k !--til I- ..."1,1.,!..11.• Fru ,rn aN n, tne,P,Pa Jap iry'•nd�.. Lu lair. aan ,road. pIaal, In+Inr Iam,.j „rad . ,. A Northwest awaits final apprOal to take over four Pacific routes ., ... ,.I•,r NURTri LVEST AIRLINES , .. tr• rad ''1 ,• In .. ,. ., uldrtu.n li oe—ohN a -Pa aIh\ markrU 0Slim-1". the deal aLw ..old ptaude neodod Troll arum Im»nual 111101 (or IT..anan, ' p. ,.•'n �,-r' of Tran, wnnh Has def -UM on InaR of r,.ni f.1,•Ltr oda• wa, Ilhn m11- from 14, pnnr,lial r..at u, hna k••9nP. lender . int) ra,li{r Rank • r, . >-id. L:ld •r1 Thr .Mi hitch m the order for •. Ilau all an \Orinwr11 wa. the Rn,ern +• •rn h] IMrfr ante int• men'. relLLVl to grant aulMnl, „ •d•r is i+•a•nt Tnat yr d t•, (i\ tet NVrn t,, A -1r, aM ,nnr2, .W <fralla 1n.Wr]d •` I.,r •!urK "Irwp,l. lanhur,l well have 1. .—Io . .,,, ah•: •. Ilaw aeons r.rapnq taut• hr a Ilnratuln oil ,rterr ' -r n'rn n 1«nrlM•ie,<, \nn nwraF'Nnut U w . rd I wkr era ,aria .;y.. pH 'n”, 161 A-1 krt'• .. r.n fel.. ,. ..1.1. ... ... �. ..... .. .r, .. - ,t,l.•, tlanaa ./x..,I.mrn Inr .., r•I.^,;'•yet, - .. r. ... . „ ... 1,rr11faa•,1 ane Ilex. an.rn ,.r. ern • n ,il.r ....r.l .. ,. •.... n. ,rr„ rax .i. «r .. i. Coors beer in Indiana officially gets nod Or RAY M. t.EtIAERY lr, SnCI'll RhLCn .. ('ours Ikrr R- ftAlty n CominK to InNana will, A.katdtt CNN•' Mrwvrn• IM1an:, h the :Alh 10d wI.— pr..luet. M IN, ❑A y'ar oM ,Mtn Rre.,og IO well A` a"'hlhle ttuauKh rompany-Ap{NoN,d dLdn W.". Cham ran d'hr \i p• y', ('Unr,, tents I.IKAI. Kry.11-1 and K; Ione Ione t a¢ht 1'N•er, are Its h, aaatf.Nl 11 Kemm-tt MNMIay NF re,:ol nott'ts Ilootigh, I IM 01.1, hav h•rn Nvadnhlr In Ill, IlMae• 'I.., int Iwo nnndM n, draft INC, In tavern, aed rP,tNu- lanly In+IvtnM'I• Itu., 11, I•rr«t ra• , hvk'. u•h rw'uid lhr.nlrb d 1- 4.1,00 t 1". r„ ar«I IMh .m. , Aenl•nhd.+l I..., a,W,aru, oll • a.b'n...... d n' kw•y Ilw r Ibm, Itped lar ltrW tNrwrr iuf 1�f Illi• Wulr.ntd now ' 1'r•iidr hair 'alw. r h•lu•\r.l yen hnvr h• i«rp 1 .rp♦ I'll I,:rl al r+l,'.1..• tM•nl.w, a ,Ixdrl•rlrwn hN Ile• I;iMrn, 1'01., Iww+, ronr}waif p1t1u«no•v rhe nrIt x r N'wlr+^xlx\ ra}d.U,nvl Inn' rNll 1. rrpullla Wwnkl l.• kr(n Ird.l "Ip1.d to A 111 4' killeI." hr I. Id.mn'rf I.—Io l., have lie. valet nv vmu• art. n•IaArr. .rlMr 19:9. .1"No Kh w)thnul Ili. 1 .1 a alv pen+al nim+• S+Nltina »MTh•,; I hl inKhl Ihr IN•rl Into the 4.0, I.n Ilxrf .> a,.l m.Ml lrlddrrr lrr,rl Irl!' N NO, INI r,I pnrrnum 4.vr 1.•t auw of InNil It aradahA, Ir •huh L.I. rapn••I, mK .ale•, •'n N0M0' ,1]irr Int .H'I .ado. ntlu, krnl .m a natimt.d Cllr, prngran, In 1974 1u 1 ladirr 1nN..na rinnulalel urrall'A We, toll _ d,A.Ind•v, wen Kora. peat N•K1lINM, tadi,lna 9 rl'KUI:dmM1 allow re. ,.0.• 1.• purrha,e h," frnrn »hak••utrr, anvwhrrr In the dal' o mh, M tI, date in I _r Cd.M Untli now '1'h• P-1..� 111 muq ranee hal relullid In lower purrs and .,Ore ,anety n I ,Ptad [Fell', "111 the lie.•. .......— whrer 1•!nrli.lrl len I. hr rrr: v11u h.Ia.• I•• .I n.nnm:a pL• I'urnlr. ,.rel tlth.."An at; v th,) a U,r w I" r nMr'n :Mr InI„I+aln it, erwv,Ile a r•"'K I' laid, Irnnrs- nx{ Veno'l-1 ra .."d M\'t1IY all, A— v add hrr»enr, at almse 91tfp he lab fdfnlP. _d I -nor, has ,elCt'IM Pb;l,t lnNa,a d„ tnbutm,. who' ,he Moro M-LeraKes ler 1. K•aAh Bred and V4par"a' Re\e'a" I a to handle nn prodocis The dedrmu Inr+ Rad to agree to store Fent, lKnd.m. In rIf ,gerliled xarrnmLa'., hr •4rd s is �� ;e• + � rA.A1,N,: rrr fnmgwN. n •Nwawa.nnrl taw Coda, fl—o f r ., ....... •.rx p.n Iwrr Cruryun,y a tprN,. h+lunnn.onttdin.,... •,r.».elle .•�• .••.+. Coors drops spring -water advertising 'IIA W.N. yule, APi— ,Adnllfit CNN.ro .,It •'rnmrap• r.•irrrnr to , Hol k, 4..Uniatn 11-og 4'atrr' ,n d, nrh..r'r.m.! .na I•..r k.i. 111,:, aiglareall\ In .4nnplo »I'll an r S" Ion rel nlr.,lual TO.". aMl''ural in, I•ur, nthl't+rb a ld Inst fA, 1 •lupi'., m.t .err,. .. "lo uI'd UI 1.1 HH•n t i•to w'"A I'll, 11- k, 4n,mr •>, ,Ix.m' N,.I.. ' w,11 I,• 1.'{na r.l In Ilv� n •,t Ir» a .iv,h. .. Tlu• w ,I.n . rel 1..11. , nr. u..I .. n LII \,!•..tl hay rvtx eon hn n 1 Wan. vt .dl,, t. r`1.1h.nn u.r 1,,.. Ar.. la.a•r — C µ9nna,d In 1hr A t }'.,ail i rnN. �trr•t•-,n,n^ ' •• n udi w 'I.he add Wne.. Had hr•n a .nnl,in r, a•ir•, I.. plaint to r Lal hrrw.•r Anh•ury rrlfun, n IM fn,t II4;v Hvl 'u I,nv ATF' old I. NtrrLNp'I'd Iplarh Mmpi—Irl In., tr lo- t rwr. nMlw rent ...... —, ICI an F.IkIU,n, VA, Ilmlo,til h vow, uMrr .t , .. ,:.v, 1 Irp a' sllpp111s AM pal ka.M lar ,nrpmenl Inr 1-1.1,.1. nn err;. r n It it. It, trrn•r 11 tle—i .An 'Purr wv'kv al nl.nLn11 .;nnA 4 alrr " I MIC, .TN1ke—ronan.lxnel .Oltarra —wit no, +nnr,••,t tont I r.,T, Cha need It%.bean 10 r„mpllanre with the LII r4 r'r. hat I mr. nlhrlal, rnafltmM Nrhpr that Inr r.nyn. nv nen ni• ..0+, I r'. n . Lw. , Nan mr Mo. w, Ara,tnnr t'rw1, n w-, prod Ile, w:lp n90s ha,e rad,, .,I t ler talo IVA65 na.M ndl, nn f'n searrn that the laver »ou)l do N 11, ruente. cud "Ne veru' national woloit IP,I markebrK and (N»pi, In the mdu. tr, sa,d. 4hat art Inr. inmK to 'lar I—a-, nor -11, yod 111.1 do that he pard w e'ue.le, .11A In, rtonti— :u IN writ dlatnhNlP 1h,- a • 1'ilnlnd•r mat t. I.•a•r, In Ina.—. ni hnllaF• 1 r..-, a , .n ..el N,n "•Ctrl! ..rn! ke!ha r..•Nrn Ile elle' Chet r , adarrtrvac ranlpark`R. .rn•.v idem, H• ralhfr than b,et dnnk,nr and Ina, -hot .,L, are. rude n -, neo Ir mi, at In'pry Ilk, nem lel. 't in", ",I ultra beer Armkmq "('m , di 141 •+rad drink heel hr .. n, 'Nr V'he:e a,alN;a rrnc.•a rr ... ;earn r.afr i,r. ulnk ' •• r:•I h• pn•nn r, vdnilYn, . •.! L,"• ;d- i ,x11. i .. Fast-food foes aren't waddling after McLean .1 •.,r,.n M„nT,•ry .�.,'a',,a nrlMvn Ishan„ .n' IM•'. vl lhtef Fahina of 1441 rrlle.fmA Ar ffcavrl demon' a, . ftLWt of the rcP",,A N fn,rlrr lnl,r In II..1 f.xn, Mru'It�rk' attnntarmna ol IM• ,r.. The Anti nn M�u,rnq + paPrf ray ter {in..n.. t., •. r,.,,r rnfe, L.r Itre! !.W„rr ,1udN, in wl+rale• .•I'd.renA— to Co . Iv 1tr h.rnr. ...•rf , n.t r,.n• oral nett ,1 Ire, '1nln Inr \Iter '.•1. yhr .i.l •tu. r .•u... r .,, I.r .In.•. I. r l .. . r ..! , ,. r Ilr Yrn u•hn1.11M• .. .11'M n.h. i.•i, r •ti..d Hera, oolrr I:a. x .. .•n9wr+.1 \ Ix•n .. .., . ...I.mett•, Ian ,. nalur, , ti,a ii r, �.... r,• r ra to •1't4hnn .. ..t• . •. • , 111 i•• r ...., .r.n Sr» :rtrr ... r• r 9:.I MN r , irlw • I'll. I„w ..I . r twq ..1 rr I al up I -n, sav A(I in Inr. •14,4 ' # 1` -111 • r•a I'-,-n'Pa,r l r•r (p...1"Main , Ir•nn Iv" I•'n r rnr Ih,rtl rl,,, r,tr .ern I sr n I.n•• 14.9 R k ir—kn l aunt, IUdnhrluar 1.•r n rrll.+r. pry.,• }"r41aa9 IN, r hnrrr 1•im Inr fo.rrl 9..:Irt+•r 1 rr4rn, n•.r .nWtNr• lir Ialr 14x9 # 4.n•.oaF t puma mr.I�An nnr,t Imr„ NT 114 dawn Iran, a1: ,A, t and a..... 1..r Iieve. n.,l nnu +•I n�...rr . 1�: Mw rad i,: + in r • ire • too", .,IrI4++r River port granted foreign trade zone N N1.1111. Ile\,It" — T:n-Ip .fi i., . Irn,r. a 1••.^ .. r. .r. nl,r rah•„ f.`.`.r .'I4 Ird ... rl un. r•1 N rrl•rr Nln. (+n n•n• .nI Ind. � I. ,I rr I III, 4CIY I Art — klrnonald', Iv ',1 n,nmh at ell I". I•. r411hn, .la nail nal.., �1'r�.t..e •• 1'.•••i r .... .. . lo,,kohK .t a I— IM- Iraq I..vt w.l and ii : I'Nrrarll,rrr ••rel lel, I.n d.r. ,.i�ul , . , n.• I n ...• , ,.. • . I... .. . l n 1 .. . • , r. r 1. , unh rat new In. ltd hair, "It It h�+m the n+•rW I'. n, t•Nn: a1r Ia rn, I • ",I• .t.... .nn.. F I. r. ,.. ,..,I. ...... ,. ,, r I lini rr hnl yr Inr 1M' ,r Iij.:, r, . as r' i uI. , Ilk.. .nil I r ri.r f t••w I.r Ix,... , „ 11.1 •�..r' a••; 1.rx Ml. i•. t••Ik.»r•r, Ih.rI II In 1. a,r •.npl. ..l Ii.n rp.. n., .r kr+! ,,• .., ... ..d lk]I r.rt Nrr joI ,rolrm rat M. Inr I•.r. , ••••r r •. u.. Ian• n,rin.hal d"I,ul it ,he LFrl4rnakt.t > ill tl,.'r n,r .. >. .. ., ,.,r.. .. ., ... \rte aIt'lu he 01— TIN' •. . ....I. rr ...••....... .. ..... ..... ..... ..,.,..... . r.,.•. rin..,,l • ort Inn .. In . n.. .r . , ,r . .... ...r ...... .. . . .... ...... . . ................I N.. 1.kr• ' "'r•a wt, .. r. .. ... ,n. ..r. ..,.i. ... ,.,....1 ., . rl h k.'a rvl,r• 1 Fr rv,rn, m ...... .., . I . t.. ..., .. ....i . i. rap Ir+ltd 1 rurtliwnitrrrrt r+lydrrnnlnea luvrl ., Mn • •n. ha, -r rt.r. la•KmmnK 1,11 n1�nlp at Ilurk11r KIn\. L,rn rr,.rn, n,,r. .n, .•, ...., .. !m4' ,,'34 "INESS MART -4 W5 Nil Amar efp ace or "Business to Business" k f f B ATLAS RHO MITIONED PRESSBRAXIS n -r^•. - w igri` TaNNi Lawn (.nl.i tonne. (orp( 211 RSO 1 KtY;'x. _K I�iy �N-4Sfit �x•r ...a BAR N(A'•N01R1 04wf .. 4(Oa 6w,3 a+tee _ — epxa. `t :' �r.e. � _ � t rii�• )iLM r '! erast h��.b _&A LARGE ..... s,,ia L SOUTH BEND TRIBUNE !CONSTRUCTING -.THr; r"o AMERICAWDREAM"; occomm 10118.7 pato" of ON Wo" d:IrvIe9Ic pmd.0 In 1"Q M A SECTION D DG Do • SUNDAY, JtihJUAR I i i' --IP Getting Amtrak downtown will cost PAUL DODSON 114 I.F HW,111 SS Ill- I If .. . . . ...... ... L 00 • 1 ....... . ...... . ..... I . ..... S I Ikkl I.. . K .......... .... .... I. 10; 3JS 21IN . *L T A . C� . .. .... N C....1 I.b. — S-I!AI to sliVI I .... .. I 11-.l —.1 : ....... ... .. ... ... MRCsf M��— S:l5r .... .... ...... on ..on. 0 W.M., 1111 1111cl, 7- sts "j. S20 HOUSING BOOMING . . .......... ..... 1_,l -I ...... ...... 'There *r terms 1"3.4 1 1,11:1 . ..... . ... I* ' -" ""1, , III, h.,> ............ . recession TS of new - -*.". 11 1., nd It � III, 1 11 gh housing construction in ..'Id ---.1 1. ........... . ..... . . ..... ..... 11, ... ... -d _,uw —d It.. St. Joseph County in the .%. I':, 11"M .,."I past few yeat-0 _F. [N.ugh Elklud Irn .4"M 111." 11'.1 4 sl I III, .: . ......... I I rf". 'I ...II nnlr .ugh � 11—d d John P-k I III. Indiana U.N.,tilly S..Ih B..d N-Wr V,Ill ............. I. .... rl ......... .... A .. II ...... ...... fi..d —W . 21111...1 0. Il - I—, : . I I x.... : I ..... I --o da -:11 1. 7! .... . ..... .... . ...... ......... ...... ........ ... "M I..I I,. N ml,r rr in a ........... I ... "I. - .,I —M, III— III. 'I'-1 -h 'he it, d V 41 1,1,19 TI- lar .... . ..... .... I. ..... .. .. ... ........ . .... 11 b. It J.—TI I ..1.......11..1 .... ..... ........ . ..... Mortgages YER NomF S , BUHousing construction go to n-iore 1.� 11 . . ...... .... ... up along lake areas . .. . ...... .. I.... first -timers -, ": . ... ... .4 1 1, 1 By DAVID O*ISHNEAU A%l I .......... I. . .... ..... -.,k0 A S. ....... . .. .... ......... III IAL It .... ... ....... I... . ...... I ..........1111 . I. •.. ..... 1"0 1911 .. .... r,,,.. I.— rl . ..... I, AE S D2 .. .. ..... . 0 1 .4 1"", ..It -able V., A Home sale rnffk(�[ favoi ...... I. . .. ".0 111'\I. . ...... .... .... . ........ .... I . . .. ........... 1 1,; . . .............I .., ....... I .. ........ . .... -. Nil I . P, In1 It. 1'.. .. ........ I 0— h, vt NI—I IWA, I- 0 h I_ ; .,Ih 15 rvm I. .. I. ...... .. At!- I.,l I I. __• I-. 111 .1 .11 I'll 1�1 -i;1 1%.11"• ........ ... .. l,,, It: L1"1rt`.�I.11`. III.: III It. -A, xnUrl I,L"'t In I- III, "I", niwvrl by firm III- I— ,.al .—I I-- Ill, 1`11, ".— —.0h, Kh;.. . .,'• .I . III -Y Ir luulxrl I:n twine n.. r. .1 7, ... I. . ..... d ........ .... .... 1 r-1 It • .. ... .... .a.... ... I ....... . j. ......... HOUSING BOOMING I fly PAUL DODSON I- -Al. Thi, .,.all A, L.1 -.4, :*4 j--1 la Mr tial. Ilar taut �r I_Tla- W -ow oufa -I, I., If-* Pa, ......... .... 'There was no of ovalf. N, .1I_a I INIA . ... ..... ...... . .... :0I., -l, a recession loirns of new 4*4Ik' -",41 t -d IN' fWA f I Gtr A-It III NIII- Ila' ..."t WIWI- housing Alistruction in Zrl. It ,laud .1 1 W 2 I- Al I I ff I ..... ]A,. -,n".y -_ .,!III A. I -Li" . ... .... St. Joseph County in the ai la Plak- -d ll -k. ... ........... aad U.. .4 L. pis[ few years.) tha.aX Milan Calaal', h.4, , I -,,III a'. III lal.. 111,11 Ila, 4- daA It.". Ilan 14 14 .1'.. 111 :;:� a ih, I-- I, All _k I N sl b."I.I. I I III- ..I I ....... .......... Indlion, U"I,A, south Bead I.4W, It... INA I.., P-11 P.1aA I I -ANPIN,j F.W.- coAlay, I-Inat aalkr, A I- --f ..... . ...... a.. ;2 .... ...... ... I ...... ... ....... I I .. u,n,»x „rvf �d 1- 6 F. -N -f da -if 0, 1. ......... -1 J'al"I ", I m .1 --ph o-ty . haa`., I 'bl-P, anAll -d- -al. ff I Id'a, I ik" I! aI V.P'_AY at Ilauth 14-1. 1 ilat rah- Avd only Iljchtl�- jIuna'g W-0,11 Wa, 11 1:--, 1'.." if 139" A.., a 4-61 it.. Nvaa� l!"I. lall'.4 1, .61 I.-M."t IW- nl.n,..A Ill W I a'. ad V.al .4 IN,*, -.I, 4.iA,jt,, 0 -king Thr, A, W WIN, I;A --I 1-IIII ("'A'AY' )I-' ,.ag .mn.i.al k -m-,: fM Ill if,,- law -g At 11,12 rdh T'.. a I., If St J -1,h and F.11,11-1 N-- al LW_ j -"A. TOufa pa„ -I all ZZ.- .1 1. m;I. Ifk- . I .....e.. I ...... lq-, indl,i .14, 1., 4, wir-1 G I ..... I I . ..... I, ...k, 1- .11 .1 --ph 0ava, hn ILI I Flklaad 4*.A)'III ?-IA I-va. III ;.all 0-111- rI,�P I -MortgagesHOME Housing consu-uction BU I ..... I� go to more up along lake areas 13.,nq I., va, ,,at 1— 1 By PAUL DODSON .AN..first-timers ..... ...... .;a, Fla.:... h... 11", a.. D'ISKNEAU Ill, at -Ill I" 8, DAVID !,Z 3 V III Alkl..9.la ;,III w'. 'd 1.,:- _ A " l:" ,. I ..aa, rn laa .4 La.d Aaa: I.A.- I'Addala I .,I.. .. ix. r. .... a. . K-I 1AR: Wan 14,16h. a,01p.an! -1111 ;If a I.fl,, I [I.. 1-.W ._kj . alf A 1- It" a.a.". It, I. I. ........ "PI nxr At I.. h. Ill . ..... I ... ..... I Ill- 11.1-11".. ba, 4'.7 -,1. Mal IN. I ..... ..... I ad It.. Cl ra h.. A.;a lb., A— , I P"ll"I I ... . .... -1 It IW I. ...... .. ... .... .... ........ I ........ ... 1...".. .1 1.111 1.-1.. 4 N ; T,,k Ill -e- NI. Im"P, Ill.,.. 11 1.F- See L A.t S ..QI, D? a --a ..... ... . .. 11 Home sale miirk(N f(iivoi6 ... ...... I au ( I ('L mad .1.4ol !Turn 1.111.1l,1,11114: that 11 .),1,, NI) 0-1 a .......• 41.nd ba, 0.- -1,- a .1 1, Ih a 11 In I. -P all Ill 4-ond A ...1, -.60 Th., .1, plIal, and tla. L- P s w -al f.." It.. . .... ....... .. ... 1.1 l.k-.1, I.. \..I ;P -d P.K lag . ha", 'I, xa Ita, I I ""A 'a .11 \10al-ka IinaM .4 IP.an.a, b., . ...... aq. ILI. . I - WaNa., -1,11 alal It. Ilr�,.Ilh 11 1- A.- -1-A ... ...... Entil •1aNnyr, . ....... a.4 .1 fall 0"... .... ........ ... ... ...... . ..... See 8UYF RS•P*qr D7 "la m-ld fly 1.1 p'-.1'. n,,k,r. pm l. -Al 11 1110;- - BUYERS L� ..Ill VIN A Bums Harbor steel plant F_ Peg. Of FN>NN Page of vaihna P_ ta, 5 1 111., alL, i Itat 11 h ....... ....... 1 1-.. .a May become independent 1 -')I I.,..d Ah 1-111 :) I Am I Yix- I. I..." I -If a, r,l12 had It llarl't, ,putt 0 III HN". It 1101"It .11, li 11 I'l-I ". 11. fie 1410 fll, Ill. IN. a, I—- hal _.A,,' lal,a- 4 $111 67A The al Ill, all n-1 --d 1,�f I. IWO -N, -I.Ld craap la,.dlo III, -IP Af 2174 %fl than I IN, PA -1 Nold,", W A "Al" I'M "PI 6 -a, 00 --a-A At Ill.- -.1 11-- .......... ... I .... . ...... ........... 'It .... ... -It P.a, I.. Il`.III0 -0 ... ........ . I I . .... ... +Fran ion n. rrwla., -A 111'. 1. a'. a.• lh,k b., ., .... ad III,- W 114 ...... .Nk. A,a , da. ...a., ....... that 6.1 1,,. I 'a "l -I -1.,..r....1- Tia, .. 1:l 1.111 Ill, I. -II -IN "ar, a I I.; ". ... .. - I I ... 1-4 .alt 'd 2. 0.1 ll Ulal -1.1 1'. 1 ..... ....... ... I .......... Tia. " I`, - - - . " ...... . ..... ...... .... IIIIII.L. I a Mail, L -I I -A, t;, ,T a, -a A.. A 0- 1 %1. 1 IAL. I ...... .,I .... .... .... ...... ... ... .. . . I. ... .. .. ..... ... P, -'-l all, 1- 1". 1,• . ...... Mati'. i0l NA-oi "'all IN- Il'-, ...... .... .d fG•ahun .... ...... TI.- 11 1-2 Ill.. 0 1:-=.;: I . a ........ ...... •R la" H.-• "d, Iluvr aid ,I. I,- I ... . ......... ..... :n. ; -.4 1 a" 'd that .1 W.. I.. T .1141 NalaWry it, and I I"'Ala"I 1-1 A.Ih 1,71,; I_, -w .."1. .4 1", - 1.0., . - ".- W -l-, I.. w,: ll, I ........ I I., , ........... a, -0 IA, '%. 1.1 11- .1.1 vlN. .1.1 ..N. -0 1, 1-: A .... 1, 1 •Ill- Ih.,, 1-1-11 Wa, a ... . ..... .... .... T,,-- -,,,,A .. It it..,11 . ..... 11". 1 n fat a an'.a v.0 and %1a a.'a j What do you expect for $99? N1. -.1d.) l,fr-L tl+ k.,. tL-h, If,57 N IN, '..ah It,W Xerox Take anothMook. lalk X-ot . -pa,' k. W4 $11l, . (ft gf,� a .,It a rho Docu-ent Company His Xerox. '-,0Nv,A 1-800.382-2080, text. 403. ft ft'. C vcA:+1 .3 Pend Ut:02/06/96 SPY: $104,700 Sold Ot:02/29/96 FIn: CONY DOM; 35 Pts: Apr SgFt: 1,740 SO:CENTURY 21 JIM DUNFEE RE 272-5444 SA:BLACK. MARTIE w 235-3548 124321 Area: 1 $114,900 1332 WAYNE, E St: 1,740 Yr Bu11t:1955 B ms: 4 Baths: 1 118ths: 1 Garage:l CAR,ATTACHED Gar Sz: X Bsmt:FULL BLK Flr:CARPET Slyle:2 D/R:LR/DR Extr:WOOD/STN WtH:GAS WtSf:OWNED Wtr/Swr:MUN WTR,MUN SWR Ht/Cooi:GAS.FCD* CEN A/C EI:JEFFERSO 'Lev 1 2 L Jr:EDISON IL.R: 1 HI•ADAMS 1D.R: Tx#: 18610938891Kit: 1 Twnshp: SPOR 'F.R: 1 Tx Comp: WO ;Brs: 1 4 Tx Rate:15.4932 18th: I Taxes: 51,642 1HOt: 1 Asd Val: 17,200 ;Lnd: 1 CondoFee: ;Fpi: 1 AssocFee: ;Den: I Appl:SEE RMKS Lgl:LOT 162 SUNNYMEDE 1ST A Sub:SUNNYMEDE LtSz 67X148 Intr/Extr:CEIL FAN,ALL DRPS,OP PATIO,FENCO YO 4 BEDROMS W/DEN ON 1ST FLOOR 1 COULD BE STH BEDROOM. EXTERIOR PAINTED THIS SUMMER. LARGE PATIO. HUGE PRIVACY FENCED BACKYARD. BREAKFAST BAR IN KITCHEN PERFECT FOR KIDS. HARDWOOD FLOORS. 1ST FLOOR FAMILY ROOM W/ PATIO DOORS. VERY 6000 CONDITION. APPL NEGO LO:CENTURY 21 JIM DUNFEE RE Ph:272-5944 Owner:HAMMERLE LA•SM1T !AlfRA bM•T'i5-3171 (An Ph -f I?A-7nso SBD/vol4 .iiC 9c.J INFORMATION DEEMED REL Pend Ut:06/25/96 SPS: S116J.06 Sold Ot:07/25/96 Fln:CONV DOM:167 Pts: 00 Apr 1-1 1,838 SORE/MAX CONNECTION 271-5620 SA:SCOTT, SUE 235-3571 125615 Area: 1 $105,900 1141 ROSEMARY S t: 1,882 Yr Rillt:1963 B ST 4 Baths: I i-fBths: 1 Garagge:; CAR,ATTACHED,DR 0* Gar Sz:ISX18 Bsmt:FINISHED Fir•CARPET Style:2 D/R:LR/DR Extr:WOOD WtH:GAS WlSf:OWNED Wtr/Swr:MUN WTR,MUN SWR Ht/COdi:GAS.FCD* CEN A/C EI:MCKINLEY Lev 1 2 L Jr:EDI$ON IL R• 1 HI:ADAMS ID.R: Tx4: 1852087866Kit: 1 Twnshp: SPOR ;F.R: 1 ITx C: ITx Rate:16.6534 '81ho j ,Taxes: $2,156 ;fiat: 1 Asd Val: 19,940 ;Lnd: ,CondoFee: 1Fpl- AppI:DISHWSHR,DISPOSAL ;AssocFee: ;Den: 1 Lgl:LDT 78 COOUILLARD PARK SLb:CODUILLARD PARK LtSz 75XI08 Intr/Extr:CELL FAN.SME DRPS.DECK.GAS GRIL.FENCD YD.CABLE HK,DEN,FM LY RM NEW CARPET TASTEFULLY DECORATEDI NICE YARD LOTS OF FLOWERS JUST MOVE jISCHOOLS NOT DTEFY FOR SOUR SELFI DCINOTE NICE TRIM THROUGHOUTHOME. AXEXEMPTIONHAVE BEEN FILED HAVE NOT TAKEN EFFECT YET. LO:RE/MAX 100 REALTY Ph;255-5858 Owner:ALEXANDER C S S 1 A•AAN4 Mir11a F1 \(M•?4R-9nA1 fh.K+ Ph• Pend 01:04/29/97 SPY: flU4,000 Sold Ot:06/13/97 Fin:CONV ttt DOM: 13 Pts: 00 Apr SgFt: 1,995 SO:COLDWELL BANKER ANCHOR R 277-8000 SA:SCHULTZ, KAYE 235-3248 142256 Area: 1 $104.000 1540 HOOVER SpFt: 2,007 Yr Bu11t:1952 Bdrms: 3 Baths: 1 HBths: I Gerage:2 CAR,DETACHED.OR 0* Gar Sz: X Bsmi:PART PRO F1r:CARPET Style:1.5 0/R:FORMAL Extr:AL/Y/BRK WtH:GAS WtSf:OWNEO Wtr/Swr:MUN WTR,MUN SWR Ht/Cool:GAS SEE RMKS Ei:JEFFERSO Lev 1 2 L Jr:EOISON �L R• I HI:ADAMS ,D.R: 1 Tx#: 18613246831KIt: I Twnshp: SPOR IF R- 1 Tx Comp: �Brs: 3 Tx Rate:17.0047 'Bth: 1 Taxes: (2,150 ;HBt.- 1 Asd Val: 19,100 'Lnd: 1 CondoFee: 1Fpl: 1 AssocFee: ;Den: Appl:RNO/OVEN.DISHWSHR,DISPs LgI:LOT 905, 5TH AODM Stb:SUNNYMEDE LtSz 63X119 Intr/Extr:SEC SYS.ATTC FAN.CEIL FAN.ALL DRPS.FENCD YD,CABLE HK,FRP LC MS BEAUTIFUL HOME ....REFINISHED HARDWOOD FLOORS IN FORMAL DINING ROOM AND LIVING ROOM W/MARBLE FIREPLACE PLUS FRENCH DOORS TO FAMILY ROOM W/BRICK FIREPLACE. EAT IN KITCHEN W/DISHWASHER.DISPOSAL L RANGE/OVEN, HALF BATH... UPSIAIRS HAS THREE LARGE BEDROOMS (MASTER BEDROOM W/WALK IN CLOSET). OVERSIZED LO:POLACK REALTY Ph:299-2000 Owner:MS. MORRIS ! A•Pn! ArK .lnrF! YN \2jLZ35-3AR7 a,- Pi,. Quote q 4467 v, July 7, 1997 0 To: Mr. Dave Bickel North Central Roofing, Inc 1118 N Logan St Mishawaka, IN 46545 219-259-1643 (IN) 616-684-3629 (MI) Date: July 7, 1997 SUMMARY PROPOSAL/CONTRACT We offer the following services for reroofing your home at 1704 E Wayne St., South Bend, IN, 46615. Please see our detailed specifications which are on separate pages. I. FUNDAMENTAL SERVICES The following services are automatically included in the work: Provide Building Permit and Proof of Insurance Rig the Job as Needed for Safe Installation Tear off and Clean Up Existing Roof(s)1 Ice and Water Membrane New N30 Felts New Drip Edge/Aluminum Step Flashings at Siding Walls Install Shingle Roof. Choose from: XT 25 -Year 3 -in -1 Style............."............................g 45389.00 Optional Shingles: Horizon 25 -Year Dimensional Style ............ $ 4,534.00 Landmark 25 -year Dimensional Shingle ......... $ 4,582.00 XT -30 3 -in -1 Style 30 -Year ...................$ 4,629.00 Landmark 30 Dimensional Style 30 -year ........ $ 4,802.00 Independence 40 -Year Laminated Style ......... $ 5,200.00 Landmark 40 -Year Dimensional Style ........... $ 5,200.00 • "Sure Start" Factory Warranty Flash Penetrations Flash Masonry Chimney (Kynar Steel over Lead) Site Maintenance Warranties 'Roofs with wide -gapped decking must be overlaid with new substrate_ Sheet deck overlay is performed with OSB board and is extra at the rate of $ 1.85 per square foot. Deck repair and plank deck replacement are extra at time and material rates. 11. OPTIONAL FEATURES COPPER -OVER -LEAD CHIMNEY FLASHING ....................................$ 225.00 RECOMMENDED VENTILATION UPGRADE WITH RIDGE VENT ......................$ 230.00 INSTALL VINYL SIDING OVER EXISTING ON WHOLE HOUSE ....................$ 5,553.00 INSTALL NEW SOFFIT AND FASCIA ........................................$ 1,088.00 NEW GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOUTS ...........................................$ 1,092.00 PROVIDE AND INSTALL 7/16" OSB DECKING .......... .......................$ 2,477.00 Sketch of Work Area (Not to Scale) "NIC" ::"Not in Contract" 9 • C] Quote 6 44671 July 7, 1997 North Central Roofing, Inc 1118 N Logan St Mishawaka, IN 46545 219-259-1643 (IN) 616-684-3629 (MI) To: Mr Dave Bickel SUPPLEMENTARY PROPOSAL from We offer the following services for roofing your garage at 1704 E Wayne St., South Bend, IN, 46615 as we are reroofing the house. I. FUNDAMENTAL SERVICES The following services are automatically included in the work: Provide Building Permit and Proof of Insurance Rig the Job as Needed for Safe Installation New Drip Edge/Step Flashings Install Shingle Roof. Choose from: 25096.00 XT 25 -Year 3 -in -1 Style ..........................................$ Optional Shingles: Horizon 25 -Year Dimensional Style ............ $ 2,170.00 Landmark 25 -year Dimensional Shingle ......... $ 2,194.00 XT -30 3 -in -1 Style 30 -Year ...................$ 2,165.00 Landmark 30 Dimensional Style 30 -year ........ $ 2,304.00 Independence 40 -Year Laminated Style ......... $ 2,494.00 Landmark 40 -Year Dimensional Style ........... $ 2,494.00 "Sure Start" Factory Warranty Site Maintenance Warranties 'Roofs with wide -gapped decking must be torn off and overlaid with new substrate. Deck overlay is performed with OSB board and is extra at time and material rates. II. OPTIONAL FEATURES INSTALL VINYL SIDING --------------------------------------- $ 2,205.00 INSTALL NEW SOFFITT AND FASCIA ----------------------------- $ 608.00 INSTALL NEW GUTTERS AND DOWN SPOUTS ........................$ 280.00 Sketch of Work Area (Not to Scale) "NIC" = "Not in Contract" )} MID -STATES HOME DOCTORS, INC, 1515 Portage Avenue ; South Bend, Indiana 46616 Phone Fax 233-3348 287-7/751 Name: �vr� )JiCri� Date:t— Address: Ltl/�y` >-r. City: �' �� State: % Zip: Billing Address: Res. Phone: Z.33 9 �{. Bus. Phone: Insurance Company: ' Ins. Phone: Insurance Adjuster: Claim #: RECOVER / REPLACE ALL / PARTIAL AREAS: �'SIbI G• Brand: Style: Color: 'ro 41aT_" _ Supplier: �- ,f6jF3D Style: V W q 1, 2-3 G r ❑ Vented FASCIA- Style: Al"' `»/" GUTTERS: Style: DOWNSPOUTS: VENTS: ❑ Vented Color. ❑ Dryer Color: VOther % G,,+b4, . C" Color: -ro 6�-,VX -'ZS-' Color: G. pia- 5144.1 ADDITIONAL INSTRUCTIO o DOW WRAPS: % b 'Color: RS: ❑ New: ❑ Existing: Door Wraps: Color: W,,tV00-<.r- te.trliP�c PAYMENT TERMS: 1JP°�rU We hereby propose to,furnish labor andateriais in accordance with the specifications herein for the sum of- S Alt checks must be mad payable to�ID-STATES HOME DOCTORS, INC. THE kJRCR'gSER Aq*NOWLED�S: t , `1. That he or -she has read -this contract.-hamreceived a copy of this 6. Labor Warranty does not include damage to roofs or siding caused by agreement,`i�d agrees -tat it is a legal�d binding contract pro- tightening, gale (50 mph) force winds, hurricane, tornado, hailstorm. vided that thj provisions of the speciaNCstructions are met. impact or foreign objects, or other cracking to the roof deck due to 2. Replacement of deter�prated decking, ia,boards, roof jacks, settlement, distortion, failure or cracking to the roof deck, walls or ventilators, fiashingax other materials, unless otherwise stated, foundation of the building. This tabor warranty is non-transferrable. are not included and will be charged as n extra on a time and ?. All surplus materials belong to the company. Mid -States Home Doc - material basis. = c tors. Inc. Customers will supply electricity to perform the work. The J Any representations, or other commu cationsnot written in this company will provide all necessary building permits and perform_, contact are agreed to be immateriSl, a t no%jeiiedon by either all work in a workmanlike manner in accordance with job specifica- party, and do not survive the executn pf.t ' contract. tions. 4. Thepurchaser may canEcont-1l this coby1 ntractor receiving 8. This proposal will expire 60 days from contract date unless extended written notice at its ce prior to m ! it -Of the third business day in writing by the company. After 60 days, we reserve the right to after the date of this -contract. If matirilihs.td be reordered or re- revise the price in accordance with costs in effect at that time. stocked because of a2ancellation Y4customer, there will be a 9. Upon completion of the work, customer agrees to sign a completion rest tocking fee of fifteen percent (15"o f the contract price. certificate, or pay the balance of the contract. Purchaser hereby agrees that if the amounts due and owing here- 10. This contract is subject to final approval by the company. Mid -States un1fr are not paid when due. Pure r also shall be liable to pay all Home Doctors, Inc., and is the entire agreement. costs of collectiofi,lTtcluding buy n • 'mited to, reasonable attor- neys fee and costs which amounts, gether with all sums due and SER /( � (� owing hereunder,Mall bear interest. t 1 S90 per month. PCI JH�SEo Q �/ MID-STA'lyE� OME C. (date) t� � � � 7 (date) (Renresentative)� November 16, 1997 Mrs. Brenda L. Bickel 1704 E. Wayne St. South Bend, IN 46615 Residing house and garage at same address Quick Bid for cedar siding.... $16,367.80 Tear off all wood siding and trim Install insulation and Cedar Siding with 13 inch exposure River City Contracting Duane Fowler 56260 Elder Road Mishawaka, IN 46544 v PHONE: 255-8771 NAME: DA V 11) 1c, k '-,- L,, ADDRESS: PHONE: R A P 1) A L44 V .5) .l) t', -5 1 D �'AtCIA 7,?-, .,v 11 COAT 2 COATS I 4 R A 6= �F 5' ITHIS ESTIMATE IS FOrLAI83OR ONLY As- -' 3 J 3 7 31) '50 4 R A 6= �F 5' ITHIS ESTIMATE IS FOrLAI83OR ONLY As- -' '50 012, 12 -j—, . i House Trim Latex Stam* A% anOT—Sw 0B UTU'ULLT� 0Evk PMc. 40 Product Specifications OIYMP�C' OIYMA ' tc �5 j WHERE Semi-Trarisparent Colors: TO USE ► Wood siding, trim, and fences. ► To stain new or bare wood—smooth or rough ► To stain in a sirdar or darker color over a previous semi -transparent finish ► Not recommended for decks or other horizontal surfaces. Solid Colors: ► To stain new or bare wood, primed hardboard, stucco, and masonry. ► Ideal for use over previously stained or painted surfaces. ► Not recommended for decks or other horizontal surfaces. DESIRED Semi -Transparent Colors: LOOK ► Adds subtle color while letting the natural color, grain, and texture of the wood show through. Solid Colors: ► Adds rich, opaque color which hides wood grain and color while letting the wood texture show through. APPLICATION ► Apply by synthetic bristle brush or & CLEAN-UP sprayer. ► if spraying, back brush while coatin; is wet to ensure an even Finish. ► Clean brushes and tools �.vuh warm water and soap. APPROXIMATE ► On smooth wood: 250-350 sq. ft. COVERAGE per gallon. ► On rough wood: 150-250 sq. ft. per gallon. DRYING TIME P. Generally dries to the touch in 30 minutes. Drying is affected by weather conditions and wood type Plezc rcxal label (of complrtr InuJuU a +,1.. ,11 I i,.,, preparation, and application instruction. 4 ;0 Tuckpointing keeps bricks in tip-top shape 01 I"'goal off a p"'.1 7, Al., It wl It LI /I it, It to 1"' .111"',1 :-d 4, /hal fit- III,, k h hk. ofi o I . ..... .... ... LI, It ........ .... .......... Mot Cowed NILES 8, MICE m[�tllt fi-Od. -:1 F sI "Lurk 1;..,' Vkh"', 0— k --d in it., i,II, n 01 ... ........ I. I .......... t219) 272,3700 ........ ....... . I IL', - ::.!*!:,�"'.:::,:; ...... 01 NII.1,.L., "d k NI — ..... ... .... I ... I I I .1, Z-11 ..01 M , 611 111. I ... I ...... W. . , 7, ..... ... I. ..... I. ....... . I... I .. ... .... . ......... I. Fixed or adjustable,6iortgage; which is best today? ..... ..... .. (Real Estate Mailbag L_tly * . ........ . ...... . TT;IM 1,10b.1 -it qu— .. .... ...... 1-C ILAND "IFICHASE WON'T TOM NOME St'—u—Ii e.1w the "T)", 0:" -A SALE. IAN Ab , of RQ Fm-,* 11 Ieo pubb,hel, two monthy I. mew'...d I. the IIIAII HIM A. .0 111., /'Who, dthe b.Ik, -I*h. S-i ........ ... .4 119RA, Cir- .. ....... . If ft'. z II,bIj.h, 14.. yo yr, - -z NOW TO FOWIRSE 04 A 1010111. .... . ..... I-- N,fl ...... pro mny nM = 1. MIA,.. fitof - ", I build•. no'r m,r III,, "A- ,f - PI M NON uh.", I —Id m '1-- In...... unh—I — IT— —M-0, I',It 1. 111, I Im. k lit, y -y •1, 1-0 "o -h—, th.-il L -J. ... ....... I ... ...... I. .......... —.1 1. . .... ... 4_1 ... ........ 0-- 4 gh .......... II f ..... I ULZRA nVE- -IAL EST011 LICENSE TRANSFERS ... .... ... .... it, lidd.—I I L.—,_ 1�w ROUND COVERS 30% OF %OFF 30% Off 30% OFF 50% OFF 30% OFF amgvlk 4. 33" OL'AmIRAMA 620 We WISON # MISHAWAKA 0 _#Z� I BLOCK WEST OF GRAPE K -AN -13 III 10TO OF I HE Vd: EK A ROCK GARDEN OF HER OWN DESIGN & I .... I., I I I 1.., 1, o., -I .. .... ... .... ...... I- I--, READER PHOTO OF THE WEEK Aus Mli.o,a ......... 259 8362 674-991 1 Ookbrook Homs BRANCHING OUT FOR YOUR ". MORTGAGE Nl,*L-DS,,�.'..l""""'-"�'� JN im ' R laSt71149 I -I "AW ' KA AW 12101 272.3700 u 25/ NOVI Mot Cowed NILES "41SIIAWAXA t219) 272,3700 JN im ' R laSt71149 I -I "AW ' KA AW 12101 272.3700 u 25/ NOVI 71' rl 7oluindned 19894IZ244C NAMNAL ROORNG CONTRACTORS I ASSOCLATION "Equal Opportunity FUt ka Employer" 1118 N. LOGAN STREET - MISHAWAKA, IN 46545 - PH 219-259-1643 - FAX 219-259-1649 NILES OFFICE: 2238 WOODSIDE LANE - NILES, Mil 49120 - PH 616-684-3629 July 8, 1997 ;\ Dave Bickel 1704 E Wayne St South Bend, IN 46615 Ref: Window Replacement, Door Replacement Dear Mr. La Para, Thank you for the opportunity to offer our CertaiffeedTm replacement windows and other accessory items at your residence at. I am pleased to offer our quotations for replacement windows: UNIT NUMBER QTY WIDTH HEIGHT UNITED INCH 1.00 10.00 40.00 54.00 95.00 2.00 1.00 55.50 54.00 110.00 3.00 2.00 39.76 41.00 81.00 4.00 1.00 41.50 22.00 64.00 5.00 1.00 72.00 41.00 114.00 6.00 2.00 38.00 65.50 104.00 PRICE TAX INSTALLATION 427.36 21.37 85,00 462.12 23.11 85,00 363.30 18.17 85.00 328.66 16.43 85.00 499.80 24.99 85.00 462,12 2311 85.00 Total Price for windows......................................................................... S9020.77 Bow Window Installation includes removal and disposal of existing windows, installation of maintenance -free exterior window framing stops, installation of windows, fiberglass weather stopping insulation around new windows, sealants, interior maintenance -free window framing stops, checking for alignment, fitting and installing screens, cleaning thermal panes. No painting is included. Price for Bow window with casements attached ...................................................S3640.00 Sliding Glass Door by Silverline A 72"x81" sliding glass patio door will be provided and installed. The door will be vinvi clad (white) and contain double paned insulated glass. There will be an additional charge for Low -E, Argon filled glass. Price for door ................................................................. S998.00 0 S ( H U L1,E-R I 6KA/D I CertainTeed IN Marmllile Roofing Syll-�- 11 mill 01.111 MEMO CERTIFICATE'OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT APPLICATION -- 1997-1023 • PROPERTY -- 830 N. Michigan South Bend, IN OWNER -- South Bend Water Works DESIGNATION -- LL RATING -- Outstanding 0/13 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT The plans for the present North Pumping Station were drawn up on August 30, 1912, by the well known local architects, Freyermuth and Maurer. This firm preserved an earlier foundation on the northwest side of the present structure which dates to 1892. Work on the new building began in 1910 when a local. engineer, William S. Moore, had built a 6,000,000 gallon reinforced concrete reservoir. Freyermuth and Maurer's 1912 building was constructed for the cost of $250,000.00 and was equipped with a 78"x175' reinforced concrete stack, a brick suction well, 20 additional Supply wells and steam pumping engines. The suction well was subsequently replaced by a modern reservoir and the steam pumps were replaced by electricity, thus, leaving most of the pumping station empty. The exterior of the new pumping station is in the classical revival style, which was very popular in the mid -west as the Prairie School style began to fade, to make it better suit its park surroundings. Currently the interior is • divided into three parts, the old pump room, the new pump room and the boiler room. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to replace and restore, within the original style, the front and side windows at the North Pumping Station. I STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for Local Landmarks state: C. Renovation and Additions 2. Construction and Style All work should be done in the architectural style and in a technique compatible with that of the original structure. 3. Material ..Improvements involving any new material in the landmark should be of the same material as the original. It should be same size and texture. An alternative material may be allowed if it duplicates the original. RECOMMENDATION The application proposes the restoration (where integrity of existing material permits) of original metal industrial windows at the south wall and replacement of existing non -original windows at the west facade and north wall with new replacement windows designed to replicate the appearance of the metal industrial sash. These new windows, similar to those at the Stevenson Underwear Mill restoration are thermally efficient insulated units. The Architects have possession of original architectural drawings which verify the • design intention at the locations where units are to be replaced. The applicant also proposes the restoration of the side operable wood doors at the southmost bay of the front facade as indicated from the historical construction documents. Finally the application proposes deviation from the original architectural CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT pedestrian door. • The comprehensive restoration of the original window the historic character of the building. Within this modification of one window location at,a relatively reasonable concession to the programmatic use of the recommends approval. DBD 11/6/97 C, • scheme is consistent with comprehensive scheme the obscure location is a building. Staff 1 t �t wr i s et > t �7tq` ? fw y( 's i � r r�~ } ~ � .Jr�' �. �� e � r w �.« •"�'? ..��. li »:,t +1. f irF%i'�r' `tip ♦ t , +�+ t 't .k F. et 0 0 • 40 C / V �' 6ctr 4 le 45 csm " An � 9 � • --q Le �.a2�5 i ck 0 Z VV 0 vs Po Vol 0 EXISTING FLOOR PLAN • • WEST ELEVATION (BASE BID) ff — � YitYnYY� Y+unn IGnnYY iTYT•iC: SOUTH ELEVATION, ADD ALTERNATE NO. 1 4�Y WEST & SOUTH ELEVATIONS C] . a .....w jt t.. ..-.,> a ...... .. .. s ...: ..... ...� .... ,, , , v .. , v.. i .... ... . .. ....... i � .. . .... .... .. .. . t .. y • • 1 �1� 1106. littrlu� r noun � nuuu� � nuni� j � 7ila�u � i:snt noun noon umut utrs �,� .711ntp 111/t1t1 nUU1t It IIIIp It�lO1q s7111111� IIUIIt1 It 111111 MI111111 t 1111'ipt Nl 4V NORTH ELEVATION, . ALTERNATE NO. ,--T-, EAST ELEVATION, ADD ALTERNATE NO. 3 �.>:.,.,,�.:......, ,-.• >. i- :sic :y �.cvt:.c,�r�•,�„r3�"�: _,- �SO Q¢ NORTH & EAST ELEVATIONS • .... •..n .».t .i .... ., .X.. t.. ,. i_t.... -.. ..r ... .. .... � -.xi.. i ...... e+x >..... ... .,n.,. �. .,...Y-„i..euJ...... _... - 0 DE R]© fl, 147 D aD • DETAIL zID 1 x.www SaAm" um Qty Tff sm low" I txur rmcur�s 0 it j Q as z (� t l t 0 f 1 DETALA- ::. .:: "...� -.. - .,:<�,. r -::�::.��:.��'.._yv.....�„r„y�%�,c .�. � �f ..r '. �,; '.,=f��,Li',:�Z�'��'�� rr�ir.%�'�r.+✓�z.,, �,/O�iri ._- .. - • .. - : �He ,- -.. - .... - -' - .x-... " . r.v,::}V,'•, x ra{aY �<.a;,y-r si>�:y'^ r i•'"l_. ��-;!s'' — - .A,X � 0 . . . . . . . . . . . . Xgef::', &� Fa KNr lm nxfo FIXED P.O.NORLZDNTAE mffl FIXED kTi CROSS SECTIONS CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT APPLICATION -- 1997-1024 • PROPERTY -- Leeper Park South Bend, IN OWNER -- City of South Bend Parks Dept. DESIGNATION -- LL RATING -- Significant S/12 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT, In 1895 the City of South Bend purchased a large parcel of land on the east side of Michigan Street for the establishment of the Water Works who located and capped artesian wells there, thus, rendering the land usable for recreation. By 1900 the area around the Water Works had become referred to as Leeper Park. The following year, extensive plans and site development were undertaken. The zoo and lily pond were constructed in 1902. In 1904 the log cabin was moved into the park from 123 West Northshore Drive. This -building was rehabilitated and established as the "Pierre Navarre Cabin. In 1905 additional lands were acquired between Michigan and Lafayette Streets where they developed tennis courts. The following year acreage was added completing the west end of the park and a year after that the connecting wooden bridge was washed away and replaced with a new structure of iron and concrete. By this time the zoo located at the east end of the park boasted 132 animals of 50 varieties and the pond in the middle section of the park was stocked with ducks and geese. • In 1911, the Park Board engaged George Kessler of St. Louis for the development of master plan for the City's park -boulevard system. The present North Pumping Station and its reservoir were constructed in 1912. The present Michigan Street Bridge was constructed in 1915 as part of the Park -Boulevard plan proposed by George Kessler. During the Great Depression extensive work was done in the park funded by the Works Progress Administration (WPA) including the reconstruction of the retaining walls around the island which utilized salvage material from the earlier bridge. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to place large rocks or posts along Riverside Drive, north from Bartlett to Rose Garden to prevent parking on the grass. The neighbors on Riverside Drive requested this due to defacing of park property caused by parking cars on the grass. One portion of real parking will remain open. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for Local Landmarks state: C.3. Materials Additions and improvements involving any new material in the landmark should be of the same material as the original. An alternative material may be allowed if it duplicates the original. Building Site and Landscaping 1. Required Structures such as: gazebos, patio decks .... new walls ....and other similar structures shall be compatible to the historic character of the site and the • neighborhood and inconspicuous when viewed from a public way. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT t • RECOMMENDATION As noted above, this application arises from concerns shared by the residents of the River Bend Historic District and commission members regarding abuse of the lawn in Leeper park as parking space. Although the commission is currently commissioning a Preservation Plan for Leeper Park to address concerns such as this in the long-term, Staff sees no reason to delay addressing this problem. Subsequent discussion between Park Staff and HPC Staff has settled on round wood bollards (telephone pole) as the mutually preferred solution. Th exact spacing and height of these bollards has yet to be specified. Staff recommends approval. DBD 11/7/97 • r { •1 �� ., � w 4 r. w t _ . � . _ .� � ♦ .. w. fF w•� .�� .mow I (� • t��'� • .r r '�! : j ' } � K` '}''�R t' N_'ff • • .. `� r �;i•. ♦� i +N w r • mow+.- ,:� �': � "�•"" Ft#, 1 .. ♦y}!,'r"-fr✓i '! !�' f�%r �rWOR"' rt �} L �'}�i.' 1i ,s�1 i �.f�.i� �;1.r7• it �I�� ? �•i,. 'L��"�4�„��-'4 Pi h. { ` Yz • ; J YC'L .�c . �. VQ U RIVERSIDEON LEEPER PARK a to ,t41 S to PARK LANE 1 104 0 «a•UUM i R . t 7•e ♦i, w 4 .. S i 470 _ W ew� tit tl zjo T--t;T i u � LOt� tlr RRE 1 104 0 «a•UUM i R . t 7•e ♦i, w 4 .. �ttt � .r Ntt • inn r .r.�r.+�� t� ��If' ��ell ii+ I, lot r•a ^MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 4e1 P II-� •� CSC �' cu k9oS LEEPER ■ —tt PARK O7Ur i t STREET a?tt 1 .+ L •w.--� � r lot 4 �',M, 1" �?+ aGRI HAMMOND •' CXNi N �iSTREET u_; _ W ew� �ttt � .r Ntt • inn r .r.�r.+�� t� ��If' ��ell ii+ I, lot r•a ^MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 4e1 P II-� •� CSC �' cu k9oS LEEPER ■ —tt PARK O7Ur i t STREET a?tt 1 .+ L •w.--� � r lot 4 �',M, 1" �?+ aGRI HAMMOND •' CXNi N �iSTREET ti s j CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT APPLICATION -- 1997-1024-3 • PROPERTY -- 117 West North Shore Drive South Bend, IN OWNER -- Dan Hill DESIGNATION -- LHD-WNS RATING -- Significant S/12 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT William A. and Jennie B. Rutherford purchased lot 15 of Navarre Place for $3,055.00 in 1903. In 1904 they built the Queen Anne style home presently located at 117 W. North Shore Drive. Mr. Rutherford was born on October 16, 1850 in Madison Township. He was educated in the public schools of St.'Joseph County. In 1874, he joined his father's grocery business under the firm name of J.V. Rutherford and Son. Mr. Rutherford also served as City Treasurer from 1892 until 1902. He married Jennie Bucher, of South Bend, on May 19, 1875. They only lived in the house for a year do to Mr. Rutherfords failing,health they had to move to California in 1905, he died there in 1906. The current owners purchased the house in 1991. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to replace a tree that was already removed with a Tulip Poplar in the tree lawn in front of the house. • STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for West North Shore Drive state: b).. -..The Guidelines for the West North Shore Drive District follow the Rehabilitation Mode]..... C. Lawns The current or historic landscaping character of lawns should be preserved. Front yard areas, trees, and lawns must remain. Trees contribute greatly to the beauty and charm, and indeed the historic character of the North Shore Drive neighborhood. Street widening or other public developments calling for widespread destruction of large, healthy trees must be prohibited. Replacement of trees must be compatible in variety with those presently growing. RECOMMENDATION This tree is proposed to be planted as a replacement for a tree removed through the auspices of the City of South Bend's "Good Neighbors Program" which assists homeowners with maintenance concerns related to the public right-of-way. The Tulip Poplar is a variety recommended for tree -lawn planting in the West North Shore Historic District in the Pilot Tree Survey commissioned by the HPC. Staff recommends approval. With regard to the removal of the former tree: this was performed by a private tree service under subcontract from the Department of Public Works who maintain that COA responsibility rests with property owners as it applies to the activities of this program. In this case, the owner has stated that Public Works had previously notified him that the work would not be performed until • the next calendar year. Thus he did not file for a COA. DBD 11./6/97 ' •�1 i lr All�ikl t a ' s ,�t a {t +l�t l�ii it�.1"t4��I+. yt �t l� tt.♦ �'' t't •• t t f t - ��.1 .,�:(y,� tti _�` - •`Y �C� ter+ •4 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT • APPLICATION -- 1997-1027 PROPERTY -- 201 West North Shore Drive South Bend, IN OWNER -- Thomas & Joanne Broden DESIGNATION -- LHD-WNS RATING -- Significant S/12 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT This house was built by Solon & Clara Rider in 1906. They purchased the lot from the home Improvement Company in 1904 for $2,350.00. Mr. Rider was born in Watertown New York on July.28, 1867. He moved to South Bend in 1893 and started a successful shopping mall. His abilities and commercial genius' quickly brought him to the fore front of South Bend's business community.. He became the Vice President of the American Trust Company, the Michigan Avenue Addition Company and the South Bend Watch Company. However. Mr. Riders main method of employment was as the Vice President of the Home Improvement Company. The company was organized by a group of 27 men on April 2, 1903. The object of the association was to buy, sell, lease, exchange, plat, develop, improve and erect buildings. Mr. Rider and his wife lived in the house until 1912, he sold the house to Rome C. Stephenson on July 15, 1913. Mr. Stephenson was born in Wabash,.Indiana on February 29, 1865. He studied law and by age 21 was a practicing attorney. In 1904 in Rochester, Indiana he • founded the Rochester Trust and Savings Company. However, by 1908 he had been talked into moving to South Bend by J.M. Studebaker and Jacob Woolverton. Upon his arrival he became the Vice President of both the St. Joseph County Savings and the St. Joseph Loan and Trust. Mr. Stephenson also became active as the president of the Indiana and the National Banker's Associations. He died on December 5, 1934 at which time his business, the St.- Joseph Loan and Trust, became the executers of his will. They sold the house and other assorted properties in -1936 to Louis K. Manley for $9,500.00. Mr. Manley was the manager of the Studebaker Corporation Branches. He only resided in the house for 3 years, selling it to Jacob Gilbert in 1939. Mr. Gilbert, a graduate of Notre Dames Law School, was an attorney and real estate developer. He lived in the house for eight years, selling to Charles Price in 1948. Mr. Price was a University of Notre Dame professor who owned the house until 1954 when he sold it to Mabel Place Ziegler. Mrs. Ziegler came to•South Bend in 1887 at the age of two. She married Granville W. Ziegler, the president of the South Bend Lumber Company and National Lumber Company, in 1905. Mrs. Ziegler was'active in many local women's organizations and was the founder of the Garden of Fragrance, located in Leeper Park. In 1955 Mrs. Ziegler made her daughter, Marion Ziegler Brown, a co-owner of the house. Mrs. Ziegler lived in the house until her death in 1968, at which time one of her sons, Granville P. the South Bend Postmaster, moved in with his sister until she sold the house to the current owner, Thomas Broden, on June 2, 1970. PROPOSED CHANGE • Applicant proposes to install similar ornamental iron railings to the existing railing nearer the front door on the terrace steps located in the front yard. They also want to install light fixtures at each stair location. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for West North Shore Historic District state: CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT D. Structure • 4. Porches and Steps which are readily visible from the street Preferred: Retain and maintain porches and steps including hand rails, balustrades... RECOMMENDATION The application proposes'to install new black metal handrails of shorter run but similar design to the existing railing at the front steps to the house. The locations of the proposed handrails are at the short runs of steps where the lawn rises near the public sidewalk. The railings are to be located radiating to the outside of the property mounted in the runners to the side of the steps. A modest yard light is also proposed to illuminate each of these stairs. The proposed railings are consistent with existing architectural features of the house and are appropriate to their locations. The lighting fixture proposed will be generally obscured by the shrubbery surrounding these stair areas and are selected to cast a lateral light so as to best illuminate the steps. Staff recommends approval. DBD 11/6/97 • C] Ov, z qk if I's 44 W 31 ji 4�6 PA tv F w r Y •'c+ H r,il'� t � 1 �, ,r �'1 �^, 1` I •r r' r.. 1 • ♦• �t. �r i �� y , {, `/jJpl Ct i�., +' Mme+ •k. !�}{ f . �� .�.�lf► Sid M�lv •� 1 .,. � r`� 9 4,� .!: {{ ,, 1 ;b • x 4Lvv•• • J \ I �:�_ +] � f�� (�-�` � '1 � �i Sri • •+ t + t. ` rS 'l ' �;. r�^ 7 it r WC lk 10 :ji• ' r � t RSH ,r`• �, .. r •� , r3 1�1 • P5210-31 P5210-38 • DSCA1'. i52Q��Green. Cast aluminum. Cleor liner. Threaded `/z" fitting for permanent or installation. 6" dia., 7° ht. One C7 bulb, 1 0,1,•11?., max. 0 P5204-31 Block P5205-3T''Black. Etched glass. Threaded fitting for permanent or P5233 instollotion dia., 7'/4" ht. One CM7 bulb, 60w max. P8636-21 Directional ry aluminum reflector accessory for P5205-31. Surrounds ' bulb to direct light on one ddesisired direction. X599 Teen. Polypropylene. Clear liner. Threaded ''/z" fitting for permanent or ,-... installation. 6'A" dia, 8-1W' ht. One 7w fluorescent lamp. P5209-31 Block ,�-P5210-31 lack. Cast aluminum pr,!! driveway light. Clear gloss.Iiner. Thren&..r' fitting for permanent or P5233 installa, - dia.. 9'!2" ht. One CMl bulb, 100w max. t: -M210-38 Green) P5219-317Biock. Cast aluminum. C:r rr liner. Threaded ``/7" fitting for P8667 or P86• ' instoitation. 6" dia., 7" ht. One 12V, 24w SJ' bayonet bulb (#1156). See pages 162 once for 12V installation accessories. P5219-38 Green P5233 7" cost aluminum spike for portable installation.' 15' rubber covered cord. j1 Accommodates '/z' fitting. 0 / G I '�4 :.k CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT APPLICATION -- 1997-1029 PROPERTY -- 701 Riverside Drive 0 South Bend, IN OWNER -- Julia DesLauriers DESIGNATION -- LHD—RB RATING -- Contributing C/9 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT This house was sold William Mack and family by Hammond and Whitcomb on January 19, 1907 for $3,800.00. Mr. Mack co—owned the house with several other members of the Mack'family. The Macks used the house as a rental until they sold it to Edward A. Mechling on July 1, 1915. Mr. Mechling also used. the house as a rental. He sold it in 1918 to Frank 0. Camp. Mr. Camp rented the house out for two years,eventually selling it to Albert Leopold in 1.920. Mr. Leopold sold the house five months later to Burton Oliver. Mr. & Mrs. Oliver were the first known owners to have lived in the house. They resided there until 1944, however, they continued to own the house until 1952. Mr.. Oliver was the Vice President and manager of Oakland Motor Sales Company. Mrs. Georgia Oliver was a teacher in the South Bend Public Schools. The couple married on March 11, 1879 in Kalamazoo, Michigan. In 1944 they moved back to Kalamazoo where Mrs. Oliver got a job at Western Michigan University. When they left they rented the house to Irving G. & Edith Albert. Mr. Albert was a mail clerk. They rented the house until 1952 when they purchased it from the Olivers, however, the Alberts moved two years later. • Eventually the house was purchased by Barbara Sylvester who sold it to her son Mark in 1982. Mr. Sylvester lived in the house until he sold it to Peter Schilling in 1992. Mr. Schilling owned the property for two years, he sold it to the current owner, Julia DesLauriers, in 1997. - PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to replace exiting,concretesteps in front of house with new concrete steps overlaid with brick. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for River Bend Local Historic District: b) .... The Guidelines for the River Bend District follow the Rehabilitation Model.... I.B.2. Recommended New site work should be based upon actual knowledge of the past appearance of the property found in photographs, drawings. and newspapers. New site work should be appropriate to existing surrounding site elements in scale, type and appearance. II.D.1. Required Existing or original porches and steps, including handrails..... shall be retained or replaced by replicas of the same design and materials when deteriorated beyond repair. II.D.3. Prohibited Front porches and steps that are important to the building's style and development may not be altered or removed. 0 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT RECOMMENDATION The applicant wishes to replace existing concrete steps whi.ch are seriously deteriorated with new poured -in-place concrete steps with brick pavers laid in the tread and risers. The existing steps appear to be the original which consistently had a bull -nose detail at the tread. This detail has typically not been reproduced at locations where these steps have been previously replaced. The installation of brick pavers is here proposed to provide a consistent appearance with brick sidewalk paving above the rise of the front yard and connecting the steps to the front porch stairs. Staff believes that there may be some issue of continuity at the streetscape resulting from the introduction of the brick but feels that so long as the concrete runners are reproduced or remain .'in place that there will be a reasonable consistency with other front yard stairs. Though not addressed in the application, the existing railing should be retained in the new design. Staff has some concern with the wisdom of the brick application as it may introduce opportunities for deterioration which would not arise from a more monolithic installation, but this is not a concern of appropriateness. Staff recommends approval. DBD 11/7/97 • • VO • E • CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT APPLICATION -- 1997-1103 • PROPERTY -- 1215 Riverside Drive South Bend, IN OWNER -- Logan DESIGNATION -- LHD-RSD RATING -- Contributing C/10 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT This house was built in 1902 by the Portage Land Company, which was operated by the presided H.G. Miller and the secretary, Byron B. Miller. The Company rented the -house out to Howard & Emily Webster, a roadmaster for C.I. & S._ Railroad, for the first six years. In 1908 Byron B. Miller sold the house to Burr F. Augustine for $4,350.00. Mr. Augustine was born in New Carlisle on September 5, 1869. He married Ethlyn Baldwin on June 26, 1895, a year later the couple moved to Kansas City Missouri so Mr. Augustine could work for the Derdoff Lumber Company. In 1903 they moved to St. Louis Missouri where he worked for the Lewis Verner Sawmill Company. Three years later the -couple returned to South Bend where Mr. Augustine started his own wholesale lumber dealership, which he would continue to own and operate for over 39 years. Mr. Augustine remained an active in business as well as in community politics and associations until his death in 1945 at age 75. His wife Ethlyn continued to live in the house until 1951 • when she sold it to Harold W. Kinsey. Mr. Kinsey was the chief auditor of the Standard Oil Company.. He and his family resided in the house until 1969 -when they sold it to Deane and Judith Jenney. The house exchanged hands four more times before it was purchased by the current owners, Logan Council for the retarded of St. Joseph County, in 1984. The garage which is subject of this application appears to be original to the development of this site. It is indicated on the 1917 Sanborn insurance map. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to demolish the garage due to its poor condition. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for Riverside Drive Local Historic District: b) .... The Guidelines for the Riverside Drive District follow the Rehabilitation Model..... I.B.3. Prohibited No changes may be made to the appearance of the site by removing old plants.... outbuildings, and other elements before evaluating their importance to the property's history and development. V.A. General Buildings in th district should not be demolished except where a building poses a threat to the public safety, and demolition is the only alternative. Documentation of interior and exterior features of thb original building.... is encourage. Measured drawing and photographs may be submitted to the Historic Preservation Commission for safekeeping and future reference.. • CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT RECOMMENDATION • As noted in the above discussion of the property's significance, this garage appears to be original. or at least an early contribution to the property's development. The structure is of simple frame construction with Dutch—lap siding and original sliding doors suspended from rail mounted to the exterior of the alley side. The roof is hipped with an interesting flare to the slope near the bearing walls. The building does not appear to have foundation problems nor is it listing significantly out of plumb. Significant' deterioration apparent from the exterior is limited to roof related issues notably; badly deteriorated shingle and rot related deterioration of decking near roof edges and related facia board and beaded soffit at the enclosed eaves. Staff finds the above listed locations of deterioration to be easily addressed. The guidelines clearly discourage demolition and the minimum maintenance standards for historic districts which have been adopted by the Common Council would indicate the necessary repair of this structure. Staff recommends denial. Should the commission approve this demolition, Staif believes that the existing Sanborn map and photographs provided suffice as the required documentation. DBD 11/6/97 • 0 '•.p•r� ..• 11 1.`1r'.•` 1, 1r • �' �' � � 1.1.,141 ' 10 � tib. . �•il' ►.� ,} � •12 CO 1: c � a . 11, " a- Ag alley facing west. Note severe deterioration of the roof edge, fascia, and soffit. 0 r� u CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT r • APPLICATION -- 1997-1104 PROPERTY -- 1602 East Wayne Street South Bend, IN OWNER -- James and Charlotte Davis DESIGNATION -- EW-LHD RATING -- Contributing C/9 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT Whitcomb and Keller built this H.R.. Stapp designed Renaissance Revival house in 1926. It remained vacant until 1928 when T. Roy Moon, an agent with the Travelers Insurance Company, rented the house. The Moons rented the house. until 1933, then it subsequently was rented to several different families over the'next three years. In 1936 Whitcomb and Keller sold the house to Leroy Sellers, the legal advisor for the Associates Investment Company. The Sellers resided at 1602 E. Wayne until their deaths, Mr. Seller died in 1961 and Mrs. Seller passed away in 1973. The Valley Bank and Trust Company were left as the executers of Mrs. Sellers will, they sold the house to Bradford Brasel only a few months after her death. Mr. Brasel lived in the house until 1979 when he sold it to Bruce Gobdel, who eventually sold it to the current owner, James Davis, on September.l, 1982. PROPOSED CHANGE • Applicant proposes to replace a vinyl chain link fence with and Essex 72" high cedar privacy fence to follow code for fence heights in regard to pools. The fence to be replaced only encloses the back yard as will the new fence. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for East Wayne Street state: b) .... The Guidelines for the East Wayne Street District follow the Rehabilitation Model.... I.A.1 Required Major landscaping items, fencing, walkways.... shall be compatible with the character of the neighborhood in size, scale, material and color. I.A.3 Prohibited Signs.... fencing... which are out of scale or inappropriate to the neighborhood may not be used. RECOMMENDATION As noted in the discussion above, the height of fencing surrounding swimming pools id prescribed by law. Such a fence is therefore a necessity in this context. Staff is uncertain as to why the application does not indicate the fence returning from the west property -line to the house nor the closing of the space between the house and garage as the requirement for security at pools would indicate complete enclosure. Regardless of this safety concern about which the commission does not have authority, the location of the proposed fence is entirely obscured from the public view by the location of buildings on the property and by extensive landscaping planting between the • house and its west property lines as may be seen in the photo -documentation. Staff recommends approval. DBD 11/4/97 0 a.. _moi/► 2 b r« A w ��S'.N►• sly .� 'ii;'�'�"�F�T :w 0 a.. _moi/► 117. SITE PLAN 1 18. ENVIRONMENT Residential , adjacent to open lot. � 0 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS STAFF REPORT E APPLICATION -- 1997-1107 PROPERTY -- 9214es t orth Shore Drive ou BeA, IN OWNER -- Brenda Hosinski DESIGNATION -- LHD-WNS RATING -- Significant S/11 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE/HISTORIC CONTEXT This Mission Revival style home was built by Henry and Clara Hoover in 1920. Mr. Hoover was a whole sale lumberman. He lived in the house until his death in 1934. His wife, Marie, continued to reside in the house, eventually leaving it to their son Henry Hoover Jr.,. who sold it to Mr. and Mrs. Hosinski in 1995. PROPOSED CHANGE Applicant proposes to put up a privacy fence around the back yard and to brick the concrete terrace located in the front of the house. STANDARDS The Preservation Guidelines for West North Shore Local Historic District: b) .... The Guidelines for the West North Shore District follow the Rehabilitation Model.... 4. Porches & Steps which are readily visible from the street. Preferred: Retain and maintain porches and steps including hand rails .... tile and brick. Permitted: Replace porches and steps with materials matching the original as closely as possible. RECOMMENDATION The Guidelines for West North Shore Historic District do not specifically address rear yard fences. The proposed material for the fence is a 6' high reverse board and batten with 6" wide dog-eared boards over 4" square -cut boards. The wood is to be oil -stained red pine. The fence is restricted to the rear yard as shown on the site plan provided. Staff recommends approval. The existing concrete floors located at the porch and terrace are cracked and heaved. The installation of a brick paver will allow repair of this surface without removal of the original material. A bisque fired clay masonry unit is consistent with the Mediterranean style of the house. Staff recommends approval. DBD 11/12/97 0 '-i .y ! �: il_�4�'- �;c:t�' y .y:.,,yy r �+t.,u�i t'w ♦ ASS.: < ...�. vti�,,M � ... -. ti:.rµ �.i4. '�'4.' yr`4'K'°'r��'�2�'lC�d.l' � . . +t �'(?.�,, �.? +:'4''�:�ti 4`- `Z,�, ti.�'c.:,,:"c'�*, • .... :'i`t'.4s"?+-' ,F+r �� v _ ,� s{�'". �-r i� aFt "t .y � �� J't" gid" � cf. ` �= r�' � i .. �� ,f'' " s�Y �..: ' . iLYLYr*.1�`i�s`'c.`a�s'l.i Y_„-� =.s :_,� ►9.�sYs'1`� ..`"s....,c,aus: 1<..f L......1" Sr 11rl a; 1 tr�r • ------------ 10/09/1997 ~ 01:27 JILDHtl -5 HOSSI HSI 'I 0 Koval Jfjej4t'*trc wilrpatumn ALI 59905 Crumstown H1 hway 9 North Liberty, Indiana ,6 _` WE ARE A MEMBER OF FIA And 0-41wfit" to tht CA04t 0=t FMICt PHONE: 2191287- 0 8001779-3WI F.X. 2191289-2232 Purchaser %one Date Job No - Address Work Phone Appointment Time Cross 'street ale City Zip Code County Townsmip 7 C v SKETCH CHAIN LINK WOOD FENCE ';... NO. FT. HEIGHT STYLE GAUGE OSH LINE POSTS CORNER POSTS TOP RAP NO. FT. HEIGHT STYLE Lval TYPE WOO aOARD 61"r- POSTSIZE POST DESIGN rl/z POSTHOLES 9*114'�y11 BOTTOM TENSION WIRE__... STRINGERS IP -V41 POST HOLES -�-WALK GATESW —WALKGATES,_W—D-0-GATES — W —�APATES—W 0000 SIDE .�',6XOUT #1 Customer'�a bvraia dirt la to be &Ctltte�ed. rmers aro to be marked by customer. nce is to follow contour of ground, TERMS: Q once Is to have a straight top. 112 DOWN PAYMENT Customer must mark bul4d sprinkler SAL-ANCE ON system. COMPLETION. REMOVAL: TEAR OUT AND REMOVAL of FEET OF OLD L) Customer to proy;fjo plot plan. SEE REVERSE SIDE FOR CONDITIONS OF SALE. j0lf Ok 'If /.";;w sir WCmPTANCE, OF PROPOSAL- THE ABOVE PRICES, SPECI- twtoNs' 446 doNbrrioft ARE sAirisFACTORY AND ARE HEREBY ACCEPTED. YOU ARE AUTHORIZED TO 00 THE WORK AS SPECIFIED. OF ACCEPTANCE: TYPE FENCE IS I IS NOT INCLUDED - STATE SALES TAX TOTAL COST sy AUTHORIZ ROYAL F' CORPO�ATI StGNATURr PLEASE SIGN &A� Signature Signaturf WHITE C WITH WI: PAYMENT. Nf I 2,1 'I J�j 0 PROPOSED LOCAL LANDMARK 1631 LINCOLNWAY WEST SOUTH BEND, INDIANA Historic Preservation Commission of South Bend and St. Joseph County November, 1997 0 . HISTORICAL CONTEXT This property is located on Lincolnway West which is the twentieth Century, name for the Michigan road which was opened in the early 1830's as the first connecting road between Lake Michigan and the Ohio River. This lot was platted in 1904. However, the assessor's records indicate no structures constructed in that year and only a few in 1905 and 1906. The South Bend Brewing Association Brewery directly across the street was constructed in 1905. The building presently being considered was constructed in the first wave of major development of Augustine's Addition in 1907. The first resident known to reside at this address was William H. Wenrick, a foreman at Singer. ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION The house is a two story .foursquare type constructed entirely in split -rock faced concrete block with a pyramidal roof which features an attic gable to the front and east sides. These gable walls are finished in stucco/half timber effect. A one story covered front porch which is also constructed in the split -faced block including the porch knee -wall and piers which support tuscan columns. RECOMMENDATION Based on the Historic.Preservation Commission's Local Landmarks Criteria, -the building at 1631 Lincolnway West has been recommended by the Landmarks Committee of the Historic Preservation Commission as a as a Local Historic • .Landmark by Historic Preservation Commission. The building meets the criteria in at least three areas: 1.) Its character, interest and value as part of the development, heritage, or Culture of the city of. South Bend, St. Joseph County, the state of Indiana, or the United States of America. 2.) Its Embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail., materials, or craftsmanship which represents an architectural characteristic or innovation. 3.) Its suitability for preservation. The building fulfills criteria #1 as an example of a single family house which is among the earliest to be constructed on this section of Lincolnway West, one of the major growth corridors of the city. The building fulfills criteria #2 as an example of a single family house constructed entirely of concrete block molded to replicate split faced stone. Although this material was commonly employed in foundations for frame buildings, relatively few structures used this material so extensively. The building is rated Contributing/10 in the Indiana Historic Sites and Structures Survey. This rating should be reconsidered due to the rarity of its construction method. The building fulfills criteria #3 by the integrity of its original construction with only minor alterations. Is DBD 11/7/97 0 • MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING of the HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Regular Monthly Meeting County Commissioner's 7:30 p.m. Conference Room Monday October, 1997 7th Floor County -City Building I. Call to Order .John Oxian, President of the commission, brought the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. II. Roll Call Commission members present were: John Borkowski, Martha Choitz, Catherine Hostetler, John Oxian, Edward Talley, Joann Sporleder & Jerry Wiener. Commission staff present was: David Duvall, Director, Rhonda Saunders, Administrative Assistant and Aladean DeRose, Counsel. Also attending the meeting were: Patrick Lynch, Ed Smith, Laura Smith, Stan Molenda, Peg Luecke, Matt Costello, Maurice Hoban, Philip Schatz, Don Sporleder and Mr. and Mrs. Riley. III. Public Hearing . A. Certificates of Appropriateness 1) 1997-0911 - 800 Lafayette (Leeper Park) - Plant a new maple tree by the • ' duck pond to replace trees that were already removed. Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed photographs. Mr.. Duvall noted that, no one was present from the Parks Department. Mrs. Hostetler moved to approve the application as recommended by staff. Mr. Talley seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously 2) 1997-0901 - 800 Lafayette (Leeper) --Construct brick neighborhood entry markers that would be situated on either side of Riverside Drive at the top of Leeper Park east of 902 and 909 Riverside,Drive, just inside park property. Mrs. Saunders ,presented the .Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed photographs. Mr. Oxian recommended that if the gates were approved for the described location that the local landmark and local historic district that it will be situated in also be placed on the posts along with the national register name. Mrs. Choitz stated that she felt the location was wrong, that the marker should be located at Park and Navarre Streets if it is to be just for the Chapin National Register District. She further no that if it was going to include Riverside Drive then there should be one at Angela and one down by the tennis courts at Lafayette. Mrs..Choitz also mentioned that the entry markers were not appropriate to anything in the park. Mr. Duvall further clarified that the markers would be located just with in the park property line. Mr. Duvall noted that Stan Molenda and Peg Luecke, both members of the Park Avenue Neighborhood Association, were present. Mr. Duvall stated that there were going to be several markers placed at different entrances to Chapin Park. Mr. Molenda introduced himself, then went on to note that the Parks Association was planning on constructing eight similar pillars at various locations. He stated that their intent was to designate • the boundaries and natural entrances to the Chapin Park historic district. Mr. Molenda stated where the other markers were going to located; one at the far southwest corner of Madison and William, two more are to be placed at Navarre and Lafayette and Navarre and Portage, another will be located on Portage near Minklers Hardware Store and that there was a are proposal for one more to go where Portage, Forest and Lamont meet. The Park Avenue • Association wants to mark the Chapin Park neighborhood, and, bring out its uniqueness, through the special entry markers. Mr. Oxian questioned the location by Minklers Hardware. Mr. Molenda stated that the area chosen by Minklers is one of the ways that people enter the Chapin Park neighborhood and that is why it was chosen. Mrs. Luecke interjected that it was felt that this would be a way of enhancing peoples perception of the neighborhood and make them aware of it and its historical significance. The Parks Association chose the Leeper Park location because there'is no tree lawn available at the top of the hill on one side of the street. Mrs. Luecke further stated that if the location just inside Leeper Park.property did not meet with the Commissions approval then the Association would probably withdrawal the sight and go ahead with the others" sites. Mrs. Choitz interjected that the Commission was planning historic district _signs for the Riverside Drive area, she felt that these signs with the markers that were being proposed might lead to confusion with the different names, one saying Riverside Drive Historic District and the other saying Chapin Park National Register District. Mrs. Choitz expressed further concern ,over having monuments that only recognizes the national register district, even though, that. district also encompasses a local historic district and a local landmark. Mrs. Luecke stated the Parks - Association did not intentionally of exclude the local district or landmark and that they would be happy to get together with the Commission to come up with more appropriate wording to include all of the concerned properties. She further reiterated that the pillars were seen as a .way to improve the areas image and appearance. Mr. Oxian stated that the concern over the location proposed was do to the fact that there are 2 districts and a landmark all • coming together, thus all three should be represented on 'that particular monument. He suggested that the application be put into the district committee so that both parties involved could come to a mutual understanding of what should be done and have them give the Commission a recommendation at next months meeting. Mrs. Sporleder asked who was. paying for the pillars. Mr. Molenda stated that it was a joint venture between the Park Avenue Association and Memorial Hospital. _ Mrs. Luecke stated that the hospital had approached the Association with the idea of entry markers and that Parks Association had seen this as an attempt to better the relationship between the neighborhood and the hospital which has had a rocky past. Mrs. Sporleder questioned the size of the pillars. Mr. Molenda stated that they were close to 10 feet in height. Mrs. Sporleder asked if the Association was not afraid that these markers might make the district look like a gated community. Mr. Molenda said that it might be interpreted as gates but the Association views it simply as a method to draw attention to the neighborhoods uniqueness. Mrs. Choitz expressed strong reservation about the safety of having the pillars at the proposed location do to the way cars speed around that narrow curve. Mr. Talley moved to have the application placed in the District Committee for further discussion and recommendations. Mrs. Sporleder, seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Talley interjected that the groups involved might also consider Angela and Hudson as a location for entry markers. 3) 1997-0930, 231 South Eddy - Install a new sign, remove a pear tree and plant a new tree. Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed • photographs. He noted that the owner, Mr. Schatz, was present. Mrs. Hostetler moved to approve the 'application as recommended by staff. Mrs. Choitz seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 4) 1997-1002 - 1326 East Wayne Street North - Replace existing gutters and downspouts with a continuous length aluminum product. • Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed photographs. Ile noted that the owners, Mr. & Mrs. Riley, were present., Mr. Oxian questioned what the current gutters were made of. Mr. Riley stated that it was made of galvanized sheet metal in a half round configuration. He further stated that they propose to replace it with an aluminum material that has a box shape to it. ,There was some more discussion over the.shape of the existing gutters and downspouts and the proposed new design. Mr. Talley asked Mr. Duvall what style would have been original to the house, since both styles are .currently on the house.. Mr. Duvall stated ,that the half round design would have been the original style and that the new style that has been proposed is stylistically acceptable. Mrs. Choitz moved to approve the application as recommended by staff. Mrs. Sporleder seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 5) 1997-1001, 315 West North Shore Drive - Enclose the porch located next to the driveway by installing casement windows in the already existing masonry openings. Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed photographs. He noted that the owners architect, Mr. Lynch, was present and that he had an amended drawing that has five windows as compared to the original drawing that was submitted which has four. Mr. Lynch stated that the owners wanted the Commission to consider both options presented so that they could have a choice as to which design could be installed, being that they are not sure which design they like the best. He further explained that the house has window designs which match the four pattern design and areas that • match the five pattern design, thus, both designs, follow the architectural character of the house. Mr. Oxian questioned if the window frames would be made of wood. Mr. Lynch said that they would be made out of wood and that they were the Pella Architectural series windows. Mr. Oxian asked if -the door was also made of wood. Mr. Lynch stated that the door facing the front is the door that already exists leading from the house out onto the porch and that it too was made of wood. The door facing the back yard would be a replication of the other. Mr. Talley' asked if the windows and doors were combination storm and screen. Mr. Lynch stated that they were true divided light with thermal panes, and that the only operable windows would be in the center and that they would have detachable screens. Mrs. Sporleder asked if the windows would be custom made to fit the shape of- the masonry openings. Mr. Lynch responded that they would. Mrs. Sporleder further asked if the muntins were on the 'exterior or interior, of the window. Mr. Lynch again reiterated that they were true divided light windows. There was some discussion to clarify the design. Mrs. Hostetler moved to approve the application as altered at the meeting, to include either a four window design and/or a five window design to be decided by the owners. Mr. Borkowski seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. 1997-1006 and 1997-1006-2 - 1333 East Wayne Street South - Construct a 12`X16' addition over the family room on the rear of the house. The applicant also proposes to reroof the house with arch shingles, replace existing cedar siding with narrower cedar shacks, place a copper roof over the bay window and the front porch, install copper gutters and downspouts. and add a row of dentilation under the eaves in the front and the back of the house. In . addition to these alterations the applicant wants to remove existing steel casement windows and replace them with double, hung windows that would have a nine grid light pattern. Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report and Mr. Duvall distributed photographs and drawings. He noted that the owner, Mr. & Mrs. Smith, were present. Mr. Oxian reiterated that the staff was recommending the addition • but not the additional detailing, such as the windows, dentilation, siding, and copper roofing and that he felt that the aspects of the application were. too interconnected to have one piece approved and another not approved, so the application should be placed in the Standards and Maintenance Committee for further review and consultation with the owners to come up with a definite recommendation by Novembers meeting. Mr. Duvall noted that. the application came in at the very close of .the application period, so there was not enough time to discuss the issues with the owners. Mrs. DeRose asked the owners if they understood what the Commission was doing by placing it into a committee. Mrs. Smith. asked if the siding was .the only problem the Commission had with their design. Mr. Oxian said the siding was one problem and the windows were the other major problem. There was some discussion to clear up why the Commission wanted more time to consider the application and the segments of it that they was having problems with. Mr. Duvall stated that he felt that the proposed double hung windows did not look fundamentally different then the existing windows with their wood storm windows in. Mr. Smith stated that they chose the siding and dentilation to give their house an older look. Mr. Oxian stated that by trying to make their house look older they were taking away from the houses own architecture which expresses the time period it was built in. 'He further stated that it appears that the applicants were trying to make the house into something that it never was, which detracts from the houses own unique architecture. Mrs. Smith stated that there were other houses on East Wayne Street that are similar to their house which have the siding that they were proposing. Mr. Oxian stated that it may be original to those houses, however, it would not be original to their house, thus, it would detract from • the historical significance of the house. Mr. Smith stated that their intention is to have.an end result in which the house, the addition and the garage would all match. There was some discussion over matching the house and the garage. Mrs. Sporleder asked how the staff knew that the cedar siding was original. Mr. Duvall responded that the old assessors card should that the original siding was wood. Mrs. DeRose explained to the owners that some of their, proposal was acceptable and some was questionable and that the Commission would like to consider the application more fully and that they do this in their Standards and Maintenance Committee, which would study the proposal and then make a recommendation to the Commission. She further explained that such a process does cause a delay and that if the Commission decides to send the application to committee that they would like the owners consent in extending the deadline for a decision. Mrs. Smith showed concern over a delay, do to their need to line up contractors. Mr. Oxian stated that a decision would be in by next months meeting. Mr. Talley moved that the application be placed ,in the Standards and Maintenance Committee with a recommendation by November '17. Mrs. Hostetler seconded the 'motion. The motion passed unanimously. B. Recommendation for Local Landmark Designation 1). 1040 West Washington - Engman Natatorium Mrs. Saunders presented the Staff Report. Mrs. Choitz moved to forward the recommendation to the Common Council. Mrs. Sporleder seconded the motion, Mrs. Sporleder asked who the legal owner was. Mr. Oxian noted that the ownership of the Natatorium is not definitely understood. He further stated that it is believed that if the Natatorium is demolished or used for purposes • other than a Natatorium that the property may revert back to the owners or in this case his heirs.. Mrs. Sporleder asked if there were any heirs around. Mr. Oxian stated that this information is unknown. The motion passed unanimously. Mrs. Sporleder further questioned that if it proceeds then who would get notified. Mr. Duvall stated that for this meeting the city was notified, being, that according to the assessors records the City is the owner • of the building. There was more discussion over the possibility of the property reverting back to Engmans heirs. C. National Register Nominations Mr. Oxian asked how soon the nominations for the East Bank Multiple Property listing and Leeper Park had to be in. Mr. Duvall stated that there were no drop dead dates .on the nominations. He further stated that the action taken at the meeting would be transmitted to.the State Historic Preservation Office and that they would act on them when they receive them. Mr. Duvall went on to mention that the grant has been completed and closed out and that the State Office already has a copy of the nominations. Mr. Oxian stated that the Commission was giving a contract to do a plan on Leeper Park, but, he wandered how much of this nomination would affect that plan. Mr. Duvall responded that there was some urgency for the Leeper Park listing with regard to the planning document for the park. He stated that in order to get the grant for a plan the property must be listed on or soon to be listed on the National Register. Mr. Talley moved to suspend the reading of the Leeper Park Nomination and for the passage of the nomination. Mrs. Sporleder seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Oxian opened the floor up for discussion on the East Bank Multiple Property Listings and suggested that it be tabled to allow more time for the members to read it. Mr. Duvall noted that the Hoban family, who are the owners of the house at the corner of St. Louis' and Colfax, was present. He mentioned to the Hobans that the Certificates of Appropriateness applications that they have witnessed pertain only to local historic districts and not national register districts. Mr. Talley further noted that in national register districts there are no local • rules or regulations on the structures. Mr. Oxian asked if another one of the visitors, Mr. Costello, had a question. Mr. Costello stated that he wanted some more information on what it means to be in'a national register, more specifically, how would it affect his property at 120 N. Notre Dame Avenue -and the rest of the neighborhood. Mr. Oxian responded that. he could get all the information he wants from Mr. Duvall. Mr. Duvall stated that he had received two letters of objection, one letter was from the Sisters of the Holy Cross regarding the house at 1104 North Notre Dame Avenue which they maintain.as a convent. Since the house in question is an individually listed property the .Siste'rsobjection is sufficient to take the property of} the nomination along with their religious. affiliation. The second letter was from Jack Roberts of Madison Hospital, however, upon further correspondence with him he has withdrawn his objection. Mr. Hoban asked to have more information on .the nomination, specifically his individual listing. He further stated that some of the information on his house that the Commission has is inaccurate and he wants to make sure that the nomination is accurate. Mr. Oxian suggested that Mr. Hoban get together with Mr. Duvall to clear up any misinformation. Mr. Talley asked if the family had any photographs of their grandfather that the Commission could get copies of. Mr. Talley moved to table the East Bank Multiple Property Listing until Novembers meeting to allow more time for reading. Mrs. Sporleder seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously: Mr. Duvall explained how the notification of owners worked when a national register nomination was approved. Mrs. Choitz asked if the property owners would receive anything, such as the houses history or a plaque, when they are placed on the national register. Mr. Duvall said. that the owners are only sent a letter of • notification and that if the owner wished to have a plaque made they may, however, the owner would have to pay -for it. IV. Regular Business A. Approval of Minutes 1. September 15, 1997 • Mr. Oxian noted that in section seven 'pertaining to 1724 East Wayne Street, should say what style of door was approved. Fie further noted that in section five under Standards and Maintenance Committee it should state that he noted the need for the new standards to be sent to all Commission members and property owners. Mr. Talley moved to accept the minutes as corrected. Mrs. Choitz seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. B.Treasurers Report Nothing to report C. Correspondence Mr. Duvall stated that the Commission had received notification from Landmarks Foundation which stated that they did receive a Heritage Preservation Education grant for the publication of an educational pamphlet on the Hugart Settlement for $2,000.00 and they anticipate printing 5,000 for distribution at Potato Creek State Park. Mr. Duvall noted that a request for the Commissions comments on, a proposal to rename Chapin Street Alonzo Watson Boulevard had been received from the Department of Public Works. With this request were a. listof supporting companies, groups and individual residents and a list of groups and people in opposition to the,proposal. Mr. Talley expressed his opposition of the street chosen to be renamed, he reiterated that the idea was good, however, the location chosen was wrong due to the considerable amount of history connected with Chapin Street. He further suggested that a different street be chosen. Mrs. Choitz interjected that she felt the same as Mr. Talley, that Chapin • Street is too important a street to be renamed. She went on to stress that if a, street is, renamed that the entire street should *be renamed and not just a portion of it. Mrs. Choitz also suggested that there were many other more suitable streets that have meaningless names that could be made into Alonzo Watson Boulevard, such as Western Avenue or Elm Street. Mr. Oxian stated that when you have a street named after an important historical figure of South Bend and St. Joseph County that their names should remain because you will not find them in any other city, they are special to this area. Ile further stated that Mr. Watsons name could go on any number of roads with names that have no real meaning and then he would be another important historical addition to the city, instead of replacing one important man with another. Mr. Oxian suggested that any streets named after trees or United States Presidents would be fine. Mr. Duvall was asked why they had chosen Chapin Street. Mr. Duvall stated that he .did not know why that street was chosen and that he did not know much about the process of renaming a street. Ile also noted that most of the signatures on the petition in favor of the proposal came from people who live in the public housing project there and that the request originated from the Housing Authority and is signed by Frank Alfred. Mr. Talley mentioned that he felt it was ironic that the endeavor to name a street after Mr.. Watson was bein-- done is such a way that it went against the work and beliefs of the very man, they want to honor. Mr. Oxian moved to support the naming of a street in honor of Mr. Watson as long as it does not include a street already named after an historically important local personage. Mrs. Sporleder questioned the clarity of the motion. Mr. Talley further stated that it was important that the Commis,sion,be in support of the idea and that he understood the connection between the street and the housing projects future plans. Mrs. • Choitz said that it should also be mentioned that the entire street be renamed and not just a portion of a street. Mrs. DeRose stated that it should be a resolution and not a motion. Mr. Oxian resolved that the Commission was in support of the idea of naming a street after Mr. Watson, as long as it does not usurp an already important historical figure with an equally important figure from South Bend and St. Joseph Counties past. They believe that Mr. E • Watson should have a street named after him so his. name can add to the unique history of the area with out having to remove another important mans name, there are plenty of streets through out the city with meaningless names that would better serve as home for Mr. Watson. The Commission also resolved that which ever street is' chosen that the entire street be renamed and not just a portion of the street. Mrs. Hostetler seconded the resolution. The resolution passed unanimously. Mr. Duvall'stated that correspondence was received from Adrian Fine of.the Indiana Alliance for Historic District Commissions requesting a letter of support for the preparation of .a brochure which would cover three primary areas, one Historic Preservation Commissions their role, purpose, benefits and establishment, two Certified Local Governments their description, benefits and establishment and three which is the Indiana Association of Historic District Commission their role and membership. Mr. Duvall stated that after consulting with the President'of the Commission, Mr. Oxian, that he did write a letter of supportdo to the fact that it needed to be returned before the Commissions monthly meeting. .Mr. Duvall went on to disclose that a letter of concern from Linda Riley was received regarding the state of the street lighting in East Wayne Street. Mr. Talley stated that he was unclear as to the Commission stance on this issue and that he believes the Commission is lacking in its responsibilities and ,efforts where this case is concerned. Mr. Oxian stated that he was going to talk to the Mayor about the lighting problem. He further noted that there has been no response to their complaints other then having" all the lights made operable. Mr. Talley stated that he would be happy to get involved to see that the problem is resolved and that he is unhappy with the'lack of help from • the local representative. D. Committee Reports 1. Budget and Finance Nothing new to report. 2. Historic Districts Mrs. Choi.tz asked what the dates were for project access. Mrs. Hostetler stated that Riverside Drive is meeting on November 4 and North Shore Drive will meet on November 5 at.7:00p.m. She asked if there was a place set yet. Mrs. Hostetler stated that they were still waiting to hear from a few places. 3. Historic Landmarks Mr. Oxian stated that since the Commission has not heard from the school that Madison School will go on, he further noted that the Tower Building and the Eby House passed last Monday. Mr. Oxian stated that the house on Harrison' would continue in its landmarking since the Commission gave them six months and six months is up so action is to be taken. 4. Standards and Maintenance Mr. Oxian stated that since Mr. Fine was not present and that the owners requesting glass block were not in any hurry that it will be left until next month. ` 5. Legal . Mr. Oxian stated that the Legal Committee did meet and that it Was decided that the preservation plan, where it mentions' the public historic resource policy should include any public buildings. 'He further wants to change the, time period of Certificates of Appropriateness from 45 days to 60 days. Mr. Oxian mentioned that he had a discussion with the Council Attorney in which the attorney stated that 'she had no objections to such a change. Mr. Oxian moved to change the time period from 45 days to 60 days. Mr. Talley seconded • the motion. The -motion passed unanimously. Mr. Oxian stated that he had spoken with John Hosinski, the chairman of Zoning and Annexation, concerning the presentation of St. Joseph Street and Cushing Street between Lindsey and Portage as a local historic district 'in which it was decided to go with the 90 day Ordinance. This means the council has to give approval so the Commission could introduce the ordinance. E. Staff Report 1. Staff Approved Certificates of Appropriateness Mr. Oxian noted that there was a list of approvals in everyones packets, then he asked if there were any others that needed to be reported. Mr. Duvall noted that both of the fire damaged houses on River Avenue have purchased C of A's for repairs. 2. Legal Madison Center noise complaint Mr. Duvall stated .that he had received a letter from Jack Roberts which indicated that he felt that the Madison had. done what it could do, and more or less ignored Mr. Duvalls previous letters concerning a plan A and plan B. Mr. Duvall noted that the letter was only addressed to himself and was not copied to any other parties. Mr. Talley stated that he.had not been able to spend anytime on the situation. He also mentioned that Linda Fritschner along with an audiologist took it upon, themselves, during the previous negotiations, to advise Madison Center and their architects as to their personal opinions of what would be the best way to solve the noise problem. Mr. Talley went on to • dxpress his view that this excess aggravation by Mrs. Fritschner caused the change in the original plan and thus led to the unsatisfactory out come which still stands. He expressed his confusion as to how to proceed with the situation when Madison Center is more or less refusing to do anymore and the Riverside neighborhood is no longer a united front do -to the fissure between Linda Fritschner and Julia DesLuarier. Mrs. Choitz stated that the Commission had to come to some kind of a closure of the situation while leaving the door open for the liaison committee to continue fighting if they feel there is a need for it and when there is a. solid front against the problem then the Commission would be happy to help in their efforts. She further stated that a letter which expresses these views should be mailed out to all concerned parties. 3. DHPA Grants Mr. Duvall stated that the 1996-97 activities were closed out except for the final certified local government reports. He also reported that the Executive Committee met last week regarding the 1997-98 grants and that they determined to respond favorably to Corner Stone Designs proposal for the Portage Manor National Register Nomination and the Westerly Groups proposal' for a historic preservation plan of Leeper Park. Mr. Duvall stated that the up coming 1998-99 project for application, which is the Commissions proposal for the resurvey of the County, is in the writing stage. The grant being prepared by Water Works for the window work at the North Pumping Station was received this week. The Staff has not heard.from the other groups seeking grant support as of yet. 4. Oliver School Mr. Duvpll stated that he has had more discussion with Dwight Macon, President of the Michiana Academy of the Performing Arts, in which it came out that they are having difficulty in putting together a board and in getting financial help .in their repair projects. • V. Old Business Mr. Oxian stated that he wants the Staff to put together the enabling ordinance and all its amendments and have them sent to all the, Commission members. Mr. Oxian moved to have the attorney take legal action against the owners of 11.7 West North Shore Drive, the tree service company and the contractor for destruction of a tree in the tree lawn with out permits. Mrs. Choitz mentioned that the neighbor of 117 W. North Shore Drive, Mr. Kline, called her Saturday morning to tell her that there were people out front cutting down a hundred year old tree in the tree lawn with out a permit. She further stated that since it was a Saturday morning that no one was around to stop it. Mrs. Choitz seconded the motion. Mr. Talley asked if it was part of the cities sidewalk replacement project. Mr. Duvall stated that it was not on the list for the Good Neighbors Program. Mr. Talley stated that the Commission should send them a letter requiring them to replace the tree. The motion passed unanimously. Mr. Oxian stated that Mrs. Saunders should go.out tomorrow and take pictures of the area. VI. New Business None VII. Hearing of Visitors Mr. Sporleder, as president of Michiana Water Shed, shared his'summary report from the Urban Forest Conference in Atlanta. He also stated that Blake • Gardens was still on the table at Department of Natural Resource and the Army Corp of Engineers. VIII. Adjournment Mr. Oxian adjourned the meeting at,10:20p.m. • Staff Approved Certificates of Appropriatenesses 1. 1997-1016-2 517 River Avenue In -Kind Repair of fire damage 2. 1997-1020 513 River Avenue IN -Kind Repair of fire damaged siding and 2 window replacements 3. 1997-1020-2 1081 Riverside Drive In-kind Repladement of rear sidewalk 4. 1997-1024-2 117 W. North Shore Drive In -Kind replacement of aluminum storm windows 5. 1997-1103-2 1017 Riverside DRive Reroof, re-applied due to previous C of A expiring 6. 1997-1106 Leeper Park Plant a Blue Spruce tree to replace a tree that was already removed. 7. 1997-1016 Leeper Park Remove two dead Willow Trees. Remove and replace a Maple tree and an Oak tree. �J •