The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutApril 1991AGENDA OF THE REGULAR MONTHLY MEETING OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Regular Monthly Meeting County Council Caucus Room, #411 7:30 p.m. County /City Building April 15, 1991 I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Public Hearing A. Certificates of Appropriateness 1. 1028 E. Wayne St. -- LL 2. 1209 E. Wayne St. -- LHD 3. 1426 E. Wayne St. -- LHD 4. 1521 E. Wayne St. -- LHD 5. 618 Leland -- LL IV. Regular Business A. Approval of Minutes- -March 18, 1991 B. Treasurer's Report - -March 1991 C. Correspondence D. Committee Reports 1. Certificates of Appropriateness -- (Report) a. 808 Riverside Dr. -- LHD b. 607 Leland Ave. -- LL c. Enforcement 2. Budget & Finance a. Staff Payroll b. State Review Board Meeting - April 17th 3. Legal 4. Historic Districts 5. Historic Landmarks a. 609 Portage Ave. - First Reading b. Cleveland Road Cemetery - First Reading c. 58666 Ireland Trail - First Reading 6. Public Relations & Community Education 7. Personnel a. Introduction of New Secretary 8. Staff Reports a. Bi- Monthly Report - b. Growth Management Conference - May 1st c. Midwest Regional Conference V. Old Business A. Maintenance Standards 1. 1248 Lincolnway East 2. 2nd County Courthouse VI. New Business II. Hearing of Visitors II. Announcements & Miscellaneous Matters IX. Adjournment historic I f k i.'' i i of south bend and st. joseph county ROOM 1123 COUNTY CITY BUILDING south bend, indiana 46601 (219) 284 -9798 M E M O R A N D U M TO: HPC MEMBERS FROM: LORI DIXON RE: APRIL MEETING DATE: APRIL 11, 1991 Our meeting is April 15 in the County Council Caucus Room at 7:30 p.m. In this month's packet you will notice that the minutes have been abbreviated, but still retain some of the dialogue of the meeting. You will also note that the pages have been +numbered and the motions underlined. I hope this meets with your approval. All tapes from the meetings will be available in the HPC office, should exact wording become necessary. Just a reminder. . . the 1991 Mayor's Conference on Historic Preservation will be on May 1st. This year's topic is Growth Management: Coordinating the Resources of Yesterday and Today. The Conference will begin with registration at 9:00 a.m., with the Conference itself beginning at 9:30. Since we are the primary sponsor, I hope several of you will plan to attend. Please make your reservations ($15.00 for lunch and breaks) with our office no later than April 25th. I will need to have a special meeting of the C. of A. committee within the next two weeks or so. We have a sizeable C. of A. project which I would like to act upon soon. They did not meet the deadline for this month's meeting, so I could not place them on the agenda. MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Fourth Floor Conference Room County /City Building County Council Caucus Room (411) 7:30 p.m. 18 April 1991 I. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 7:40 p.m. II. Roll Call Members Present: Mr. John Oxian,.Mrs. JoAnn Sporleder, Mr. Odell Newburn, Mr. Herb Herendeen, Mr. Jed Eide, Mrs. Janeanne Petrass, Mrs. Martha Choitz, Ms. Aladean DeRose - City Attorney, Mrs. Lori Dixon - Director, Mr. James Pastor - Survey Manager, Mrs: Tina Comer - Secretary. Members Absent: Mr. Bill Welsheimer Sr., Mrs. Jean Dennen. Others Present: Barbara Steele - Southhold Restorations, Fred Holycross'- Research Assistant, Susie Booker - Surveyor, Mr. Bower - Visitor, Mr: Fritz - Visitor. III. Public Hearing A. Certificates of Appropriateness 618 Leland - LL An in -kind replacement of roof. Owner was present to elaborate. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mrs. Petrass seconded; motion approved. 1426 E. Wayne - LHD Request for variance to approve skylights for third floor renovation. Owner was present to elaborate. Mr. Herendeen moved for approval; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion approved. 1028 E. Wayne - LHD An in -kind replacement of porch floor with bullnose boards. Commission would like - owner to submit drawings and samples. Mr. Eide and Mr. Herendeen will follow -up with owner. Mr Herendeen motioned to table discussion until upcoming C. of A. Meeting; Mr. Newburn seconded; motion approved. 1209 E. Wayne - LHD Request to build woodshed - accessory building in rear of property. Mr. Eide spoke with owner and requested a strong recommendation from the Commission to suggest a "custom built" shed instead of a "pre -fab ". Mr. Herendeen motioned to table discussion until up- coming C. of A. Meeting; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion approved. 1521 E Wayne Replace jalousie windows in rear sun room with Anderson brand casements. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion-approved.— IV. Regular Business A. Minutes - March 18, 1991 Mrs. Sporleder and Mrs. Choitz commended the minutes received. Mrs. Choitz moved for approval; -ji Mr. Herendeen seconded; motion approved. B. Treasurer's Report - March 1991 Mrs. Choitz inquired about the response to the request made by - Mrs: Dixon. additional computers for the H.P.C. Office. Mrs. Dixon stated she sent correpondence to the County Commissoners which passed the request to the Auditor's Office. Mr. Newburn stated the request had -been approved by the Commissioners. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval of Treasurer's Report; Mrs. Petrass seconded; motion approved. C. Correspondence Mrs. Dixon submitted the correspondence for review by the Commission. D. Committee Reports 1. Certificates of Appropriateness" Mr. Pastor reported on three staff approved C. of A.'s. a. 808 Golden Ave - LHD Renewal of certificate due to time expired on original C. of A. Work not yet completed. b. 607 Leland - LL An in -kind rebuilding of porch deck. c. 709 -711 Lincolnway East Edgewater Commercial Property (Apartments) An in -kind replacement of treads on rear stairs. 2. Budget & Finance a. Staff Payroll Mrs. Dixon followed -up with the County, City and Ms. DeRose (concerning legalities) about the H.P.C. Staff being put on either payroll. Anticipations were made as to whether the Commission would be responsible for employees' taxes, social security, insurance, etc., but Mrs. Dixon did not anticipate workman's comp., liability, etc., which are not affordable at this time. It was therefore strongly recommended to Mrs. Dixon that the payroll remain as is. Mrs. Sporleder inquired about the source of monies reed for Grants. The Grants are received from the Federal Government Dept. of Interior National Park Service. Mrs. Sporleder the`Commission of being in violation of "serious" federal regulations concerning payroll contracts. Mrs - Choitz inquired about a liaison (The State Historical Preservation Office) that can contacted concerning guidelines. Mr. Oxian suggested that an inquiry be made to the County Commissioner's Office about H.P.C. employees being put on the County Payroll. Mrs. Dixon will follow up. b. State Board Review Meeting - 4/17/91 Mrs. Dixon will be attending. The state will be determining the H.P.C. Grant Allocation. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mr. Newburn seconded; motion approved. 3. Legal No Report. 4. Historical District No Report. 5. Historic Landmarks Mr. Oxian reported there are three (3) first readings enclosed in the Commission's packets: 609 Portage Cleveland /Lynwood (Cemetary) 58666 Ireland Trail The second reading will be the Public Hearing. 6. Public Relations and Community Education No Report. 7. - Personnel The Commission has hired a new secretary as of 4/15/91, in the person of Mrs. Tina Comer. 8., Staff Report Mr. Pastor read the Bi- Monthly Report, which stated within the last two (2) months there has been a preparation of statements of significance for the Witter Cemetary, the potential landmark house at 609 Portage and the W.P.A. house. H.P.C. has acquired thru the efforts of Mr. Holycross, the 1932 Acessor's Card Collection in it's entirety. It will be very useful for research purposes. H.P.C. has chosen and purchased approximately $250.00 worth of camara equipment. In regards surveying on the West Side, Mr. Pastor reported Quadrant 54 has been completed and-Susie Booker is currently working on Quadrant 65. Assessment was made on the historic resources in the Bowman Creek area. Information will be forth - coming. a. Growth Management Conference - May 1st Mrs. Dixon elaborated on the brochure changes in the areas of registration and an additional sponsor. Brochures will be mailed this week. b. Midwest Regional Conference Mr. Pastor and Mrs. Dixon both attended the Quarterly Regional Meeting of Historic Landmarks Foundation. Topics of discussion were Rural Preservation and Tax Credits. Mr. Pastor also attended the National Trust Midwest Regional Conference in Toledo, Ohio. Information will be forth - coming. V. Old Business A. 'Maintenance Standards 1.`. 1248`Lincolnway East Owner is in violation of City Codes. The Commission requested Mrs. Dixon to follow -up with the Dept.' of Code Enforcement concerning this matter. Information will be available at the' next H.P.C. Meeting. `2. 2nd County Courthouse' Mr. Pastor Dixon sited deterioration in areas of the building that need to be repaired. Mrs. will contact the Historical Society. B. The Darden Road Bridge Several members of the Commission voiced their.'concern about the outcome of the ,Bridge Project.' Mrs. Dixon will correspond with the Board of County.Commissioners in _„'response,•to these concerns. Information will be forth- coming'at the next meeting. VI. New Business No 'Report. VII.- Hearing of Visitors No Report. VIII. _ Announcements & Miscellaneous Matters No Report. IX. Adjournment Mr. Oxian moved to adjourn; Mrs. Sporleder seconded; motion approved: MINUTES OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Fourth Floor Conference Room County /City Building County Council Caucus Room (411) 7:30 p.m. 18 April 1991 j t I. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 7:40 p.m. II. Roll Call Members Present: Mr. John Oxian, Mrs. JoAnn Sporleder, Mr. Odell Newburn, Mr. Herb Herendeen, Mr. Jed Eide, Mrs. Janeanne Petrass, Mrs. Martha Choitz, Ms. Aladean DeRose - City Attorney, Mrs. Lori Dixon - Director, Mr. James Pastor - Survey Manager, Mrs. Tina Comer - Secretary. Members Absent: Mr. Bill Welsheimer Sr., Mrs. Jean Dennen. Others Present: Barbara Steele - Southhold Restorations, Fred Holycross - Research Assistant, Susie Booker - Surveyor, Mr. Bower - Visitor, Mr. Fritz - Visitor. III. Public Hearing A. Certificates of Appropriateness Leland - LL � Q � in -kind replacement of roof. r %k- Owner was present to elaborate. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mrs. Petrass seconded; motion approved. 1426 E. Wayne - LHD Request for variance to approve skylights for third floor renovation. Owner was present to elaborate. Mr. Herendeen moved for approval; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion approved. 1028 E. Wayne - LHD / ,� in -kind replacement of porch floor with 'bullnose boards. Commission would like owner to submit drawings and samples. Mr. Eide and Mr. Herendeen will follow -up with owner. Mr Herendeen motioned to table discussion until upcoming C. of A. Meeting; Mr. Newburn seconded; motion approved. 1209 E. Wayne - LHD Request to build woodshed - accessory building in rear of property. Mr. Eide spoke with owner and requested a strong recommendation from the Commission to suggest a "custom built" shed instead of a "pre -fab ". Mr. Herendeen motioned to table discussion until up- coming C. of A. Meeting; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion approved. 1521 E Wayne Replace jalousie windows in rear sun room with Anderson brand casements. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mrs. Choitz seconded; motion approved. IV. Regular Business A. Minutes - March 18, 1991 Mrs. Sporleder and Mrs. Choitz commended the minutes received. Mrs. Choitz moved -for approval; Mr. Herendeen seconded; motion approved. B. Treasurer's Report - March 1991 Mrs. Choitz inquired about the response to the request made by Mrs. Dixon for additional computers for the H.P.C. Office. Mrs. Dixon stated she sent correpondence to the County Commissoners which passed'the request to the Auditor's Office. Mr. Newburn stated the request had been approved by the Commissioners. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval of Treasurer's Report; Mrs. Petrass seconded; motion approved. C. Correspondence Mrs. Dixon submitted the correspondence for review by the Commission. D. Committee Reports 1. Certificates of Appropriateness Mr. Pastor reported on three staff approved C. of A.'s. a. 808 Golden Ave - LHD Renewal of certificate due to time expired on original C. of A. Work not yet completed. b. 607 Leland - LL An in -kind rebuilding of porch deck. C. 709 -711 Lincolnway East Edgewater Commercial Property (Apartments) An in -kind replacement of treads on rear stairs. 2. Budget & Finance a. Staff Payroll Mrs. Dixon followed -up with the County, City and Ms. DeRose (concerning legalitilui about the H.P.C. Staff being put on either payroll. Anticipations were made as to whether the Commission would be responsible for employees' taxes, social security, insurance, etc., but Mrs. Dixon did not anticipate workman's comp., liability, etc., which are not affordable at this time. It was therefore strongly recommended to Mrs. Dixon that the payroll remain as is. Mrs. Sporleder inquired about the source of monies rec'd for Grants. The Grants are received from the Federal Government Dept. of Interior National Park Service. Mrs. Sporleder informed the Commission of being in violation of "serious" federal regulations concerning payroll contracts. Mrs. Choitz inquired about a liaison (The State Historical Preservation Office) that canj�ontacted concerning guidelines. Mr. Oxian suggested that an inquiry be made to the County Commissioner's Office about H.P.C. employees being put on the.Cbunty Payroll. Mrs. Dixon will follow up. b. State Board Review Meeting — 4/17/91 Mrs. Dixon will be attending. The state will be determining the H.P.C. Grant Allocation. Mrs. Sporleder moved for approval; Mr. Newburn seconded; motion approved. 3." Legal No Report. 4. Historical District No Report. 5. Historic Landmarks Mr. Oxian reported there are three (3) first readings enclosed in the Commission's packets: 609 Portage Cleveland /Lynwood (Cemetary) 58666 Ireland Trail The second reading will be the Public Hearing. 6. Public Relations and Community Education No Report. 7. Personnel The Commission has hired a new secretary as of 4/15/91, in the person of Mrs. Tina Comer. 8. Staff Report Mr. Pastor read the Bi- Monthly Report which stated within the last two (2) months there has been a preparation of statements of significance for the Witter Cemetary, the potential landmark house at 609 Portage and the W.P.A. house. H.P.C. has acquired thru the efforts of Mr. Holycross, the 1932 Acessor's Card Collection in it's entirety. It will be very useful for research purposes. H.P.C. has chosen and purchased approximately $250.00 worth of camara equipment. In regards to surveying on the West Side, Mr. Pastor reported Quadrant 54 has been completed and Susie Booker is currently working on Quadrant 65. Assessment was made on the historic resources in the Bowman Creek area. Information will be forth - coming. a. Growth Management Conference - May 1st Mrs. Dixon elaborated on the brochure changes in the areas of registration and an additional sponsor. Brochures will be mailed this week. b. Midwest Regional Conference Mr. Pastor and Mrs. Dixon both attended the Quarterly Regional Meeting of Historic Landmarks Foundation. Topics of discussion were Rural Preservation and Tax Credits. Mr. Pastor also attended the National Trust Midwest Regional Conference in Toledo, Ohio. Information will be forth - coming. V. Old Business A. Maintenance Standards 1. 1248 Lincolnway East Owner is in violation of City Codes. The Commission requested Mrs. Dixon to follow -up with the Dept. of Code Enforcement concerning this matter. Information will be available at the next H.P.C. Meeting. 2. 2nd County Courthouse Mr. Pastor and Mrs. Dixon sited deterioration in areas of the building that need to be repaired. Mrs. Dixon will contact the Historical Society. B. The Darden Road Bridge Several members of the Commission voiced their concern about the outcome of the Bridge Project. Mrs. Dixon will correspond with the Board of County Commissioners in response to these concerns. Information will be forth- coming at the next meeting., VI. New Business No Report. VII. Hearing of Visitors No Report. VIII. Announcements & Miscellaneous Matters No Report. IX. Adjournment Mr. Oxian moved to adjourn; Mrs. Sporleder, seconded; motion approved. April 3, 1991 STAFF..__ REPORT 1028 E. Wayne 5t. c/o Family and Children's Center 1411 Lincolnway West Mishawaka, IN 46544 { PROPOSAL Repair front porch as follows= 1) Replace tongue and groove flooring with five - quarter bullnose flooring. 2) Pour cement pads under 4X4 supports. Pads will be 3 ft. deep and 1 ft. wide. 3) Use 4X4 supports under flooring. 4) Replace damaged spindles. STANDARDS Group B Standards= B. Treatment ..... _......... ... _ ................. _..... Treatment shall be defined as any change of surface materials that will not alter the style or original form ... and may involve a change that can potentially enhance or detract from the character of the landmark. The Commission should review the proposed treatment for character and style consistency with the original surface. C. Renovation and Addi_t 1. Structure - Necessary structural improvements, where safety demands should be accomplished in such a way as to cause minimal visual change to the original style and construction. 2. Con st ruction a.nd_..Style - All work should be done in the architectural style and in a technique compatible with that of the original structure. 3. Mater..ial_s - Additions and improvements involving any new material in the landmark should be of the same material as the original. It should the same size and texture. RECOMMENDA TI ONS A site inspection by the staff revealed that the porch floor appears to be in fair to good condition. The staff recommends that the Commission carefully review the plans for the reconstruction of the porch flooring and structural system to determine its viability. The spindles, if in -kind replacements, should be approved. - J ^ S � . pp b Jra J,�S f4 - d00 'S.IJI� ti ti � ti :N l r� s r X S A— . s S t V, AL s r o - �►, 1 �Y, ��/ 4 �' -�- s r g / '(a Xu a 7 Zi /J 4d DSO N"'� 1 �?-A OOJ6 ' bv� R S - } ;' rr ,4_ ` April 3, 1991 STAFF _REPORT Steven Norton 1209 E. Wayne North South Bend, IN 46615 PROPOSAL, Replace existing metal shed in north -east corner of the property with either of two prefabricated 8X10, wood composition, gambrel- - roofed sheds as per attached specifications. The new shed will be identically situated as the current shed on an existing concrete slab. STANDARDS III. C. Accessory Buildings 1) Required Accessory buildings shall be located at the rear of residences and as unobtrusively as possible while preserving the historical relationships between the building, landscape features, and open spaces. Proportions and materials shall conform to those required for New Construction (see A -1 and B -1). 2) Recommended Accessory building designs should be compatible in character and mood to the residences and neighborhood. 3) Proh_i_bited Pre- fabricated, metal sheds may not be used. 4) Not Recommended Pre - fabricated wood composition sheds should not be used unless they conform to all other standards. RECOMMENDATIONS_ The existing metal shed is in deteriorated condition and has no historical or architectural significance. As installation of metal sheds is prohibited by the district standards, the removal of this unit is favorable. The owner of the property has proposed two replacement units which are relatively compatible to the fabric of the East Wayne historic district. Although they are pre - fabricated wood composition sheds, which the district standards suggest should not be used, the proposed units appear to conform to all other standards. DELUXE ESTATE The Estate has for w many years been one of our more popular styles. 4•' SIDE 8x 8x8 ........$ 599.00 8x 10x8 ........ 699.00 8x12x8 ........ 799.00 8x1 6x8 ........ 999.00 3 , 1 10x12x8'6" .. $ 999.00 10x16x8 .. • 1249.00 10x 18x8' 6" .. 1399.00 10x20x8'6" .. 1549.00 12x16x12 .... 12x20x 12 .... 12x24x 12 .... $699.00 � ,/ 799.00 Y� 899.00 1099.00 1099.00 1349.00 1499.00 1649.00 1799.00 2099.00 2299.00 Pric-es may va by location. All dimensions are approximate. Prices . wt 8x9'6" .... 8x1®x9 .... 8xi2x9 .... 8x16x9 ` .... 10x12x10 .... 10x16x10 .... 10x18x10 .... 10x24x10 .... t , Prices subject to change without notice 1035 E. 10'x12'x11'- 6 .. .... $1039 10'x16'x11'- 6 .. .... $1454 10'x20'x11'- 6 .. .... $1755 1 1 1 cKinley, Mishawaka, IN 46! t UHL iii YUUi yai U Pl "";O 8 8'x 8' -6 " ....... $659 8'x10'x8'- 6 ► $719 8'x12'x8'- 6 .. ...... $759 8'x16'x8'- 6"...... $929 10'x12'x9 ►- 6 .. ..... $ 929 10'x16'x9'- 6 .. ...... $1049 10'x20'x9'- 6 .. ...... $1320 6 D 6 oz 600 SERIES PERMA -LAST 6 foot sidewalls Pressure treated exterior never needs paint Pressure treated floor system with 5 /8" deck Lifetime warranty Built in your yard prices 7 8'x12'x10' -61' .. $ 929 / 8'x16'x10' -6 "...$1039 Je April 3, 1991 STAFF REPORT Marzy J. Bauer 1426 E .' Wayne South Bend, IN 46615 PROPOSAL Owner has submitted a request for variance of part II of a C of A reviewed and approved by the Historic Preservation Commission in January of this year. The owner wishes to install four skylights on the west side of the gable roof as per the attached specifications and drawings instead of the approved dormers. STANDARDS II. A. BuAId ng_.,_Materials. 1) Required Original exterior building materials shall be retained. B. Roofs and Roofing 1) Regg - i_ red . The existing shape and materials of the roof shall be retained. 3) Prohibited, Nothing shall be done to change the essential character of the roof as viewed from the thoroughfare by adding architectural features, large, unsightly fixtures, or by using roofing materials inappropriate to the style of the house. RECOMMENDATIONS The owner has received cost estimates from several contractors regarding the installation of dormers on the roof's west - facing slope and has found it cost prohibitive to carry out the project. The staff appreciates the owner's need for natural light and ventilation in their newly finished attic space; skylights can be installed in such a way that they are not unsightly and do not detract from the aesthetic integrity of the structure or the district environment. The staff recommends that the Commission consider the submitted design and propose alternatives if necessary. J� 1401M Roo Windows The Model' Roof W It opensfrom the sill and allows operation of the roof window and accessories without touching or removing the insect screen. The exclusive thru -screen scissor operator opens The Model TPS roof window pivots inward for and closes the roof window effortlessly. easy cleaning of the outside glass. a r� Venetian blinds Type PNDSgive you great control over light and privacy: Available with both manual lbvhand or tvith rod controls and electric control. The VELUX Model TPS roof win- dow pivots completely inward to allow cleaning of both panes of glass from the inside. You therefore have full freedom to position the Model TPS in the roof to provide a clear and unobstructed view of the outdoors while sitting or standing. The Model TPS has also been designed to include sash springs to assure easy, smooth operation. And special hinges allow sash removal enabling you to install the Model TPS without stand- ing on your roof. Special Features ❑ Exclusive thru- screen scissor operator secures bottom sash at two points. In addition, the spring balanced sash makes opening effortless and assures a tight weatherproof close. El Easy -to -remove integrated insect screen is fastened with spring bolts. Screen frame is color - coordinated to thru- screen operator. • Exclusive ventilation flap allows fresh air to enter when window is closed. The removable easy -to -clean filter keeps dust and insects out. • Barrel bolts allow firm positioning of window when rotated for cleaning. ", Window is prepared for a hidden and protected installation of an out- side awning. D Double -pane insulated tempered glass saves energy. Other glazings, including gas- filled Low -E, bronze tinted and laminated glass are readily available. Comfort and convenience accessories The Model TPS isn't just a roof window Its a system you can tailor to your functional needs as well as your comfort. Manual and electric controls and a variety of sunscreening accessories are readily available. VELUX awnings. venetian blinds and roller blinds enable you to reduce glare and heat in the sum- mer, and in winter they can help you retain heat. All of these accessories can be easily operated without removing the screen. For technical information see page 20. For flashing lashing information see page 16 -19 C A IA 8 j An attractive beige roller blind Type RUSIN is available to help reduce the sun's glare and provide privacy Easy operation in reach or out-of-reach. Exclusive ventilation flap lap allows fresh air to enter when window is closed. Our semi - transparent net awning Type MNCS blocks up to 70% of the sun's heat and glare. Easy operation in reach or out- of-reach. x ewNlz to 44 — � 1 ti- ti �r 1 1 F i - � T { � 1 � l ` i ♦ I go* 000 000* { t . 1 E] t , Jr �. t c j r�` March 28, 1991 STAFF REPORT David Fritz 618 Leland Ave. South Bend, IN 46616 PROPOSAL Remove deteriorated cedar shakes from porch roof and replace with asphalt shingle to match roof on remainder of house. STANDARDS Group B Standards: Treatment: ............ Treatment shall be defined as any change of surface materials that will not alter the style or original form. Such improvements include reroofing ... and may involve a change that can potentially enhance or detract from the character of the landmark ... The Commission should review the proposed treatment for - character and style consistency with the original surfaces. RECOMMENDATIONS .. ... .. ......................_........ The owner of this landmark structur porch is not the original, that the Years old. Within the last several metal supports and guard rails with spindle columns and balustrades. e claims that the current cedar shakes are some 15 years he has replaced the historic replica turned The proposed material change for the por(.h root of 607 Leland - Ave. i in keeping with the above standards and should be approved. April 3, 1991 STAEE REPQRT Chris Makris 1521 East Wayne St. South Bend, IN 46615 PROPOSAL Owner proposes to replace jalousie windows in sun room at rear -west corner of house with Anderson brand casements. STANDARDS No applicable standards for replacing non - original windows or windows on non - historic construction. RECOMMENDATIONS Anderson brand sashes are common throughout the structure. Replacing the existing, non - historic louvered glass with Anderson casements is an aesthetic improvement. �- J HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH COUNTY Staff Use Only date f i I ed 4 / rating S IZ- style fjz�m cLkSSjc APPLICATION FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION ADDRESS OF PROPERTY (p�� '�6� -r�(� LEGAL DESCRIPTION 0-r 3 cvw3 I / Z YaG . ct G.4 w - k , 2 - 16,r 5U KEY NUMBER I� 1 ` 010 OWNER'S NAME T &B F06L - Rr got H KS MAILING ADDRESS Cpoq -FO tp A Soom Bom , j r\f -l (,G I c, PHONE NUMBER (14 2BI cO I GG M ME -E ADDRESS OF PERSON COMPLETING APPLICATION IF DIFFERENT FROM OWNER: G/0 Rm 1123 , C�v,.r C iii �.rr • ` �o v� r t I N INFORMATION ON 140MI14ATTED PROPERTY: YEAR BUILT IdJ ORIGINAL OW14ER ORIGINAL USE 1 pp �E,5 I PtW ARCHITECT/BUILDER WR_ITC A_RQ.I_Cr — LCTADV_AC—rUC -.unu I errn nnr..�n�.• —,. -_- 6 I, the undersigned property owner, hereby grant the Historic Preservation Commission of South Bend and St. Joseph County the permission to have the building or buildings located at: 609 Portage Avenue, South Bend, Indiana ............................. ............................... Township of Portage, County of St. Joseph ............................. ............................... declared an architectural and/or historical landmark under ordinance. I do also approve of the classification of this building/build- IBn ings under Group t' standards. Signature of Property Owner q X91 Date ' Comments: 1. Rating El Outstanding 1XSignlficant /Notable ED Contributing I4. Historic Name Frederick W. Keller 6. Address 609 Portage 2. 3. Survey No. St. Joseph 141 - 45583 -598 5. Township Preliminary No. Portage Conservatory of 7. City 8. Quad Name South Bend, IN 46616 State of Indiana Department of Natural Resources State Form 16822 /Revised 1987 tAry 2 9. Common Name W. Visible 11. Endangered Explain South Bend Conservatory of Music I )CI Yes El No El Yes )U1 No 12. Ownership Owner's Address (if different) R7 Public ❑ Private 13. Use Present Past 14. Category 15. Surveys / Legal Protections 16. Location Notes / Legal Description 17. Condition Residence O LX n Building(s) Chapin Pk. Nat. Reg.Dis. Lot 3 and z vac. alley lX Excellent Commercial ❑ Conservaty❑ ❑ ❑ District F.W. Keller sub El Good (if Music g] ❑ ❑ El Site ❑ Structure ❑ Fair ❑ Deteriorated ❑ Object ❑ Ruins 19. Time Perlod(s) 1905 20. Style( dnne 21. Architect / Builder Queen W. W. Schneider 22. SPECIFY ALTERATIONS Removals Replacement Additions Other 1 story gabled room on ba k. 23. DESCRIPTION Stories 2 Plan Irregular Foundation Stone Chim: sap9htlr c protruding from gable end w /corbelled walls 4 " to weather clapboard first floor; shingles 2nd end gable /gable w�ll ov rnan wall. asphalt shingle, able d er; Roof �2in I , steep gable roof w /asDhalt singles. boxed, returned aves. rm w4 s reek revival brackets & pilasters. Porc � Bla� oorihis� paired, wooden, round columns /supporting broad entR (Openings w %sod �ib��wdo2rn�r�loor. av lgo oash/bay window dbl. w /glass (wood); engaged columns flanked & toped by entablatured wooden head. Interior (Grounds /Outbuildings Modern garage, considerable plantings in front of bldg. I vehicularr s north doe of lot_, 18. Integrity ❑ Unaltered ,'�] Altered minor ❑ Moved Date moved 24. SITE PLAN T I 25. No. of C 9 rtes I26. No. of Non-contributing Resources— 27. hrtviro rent ixe� residential & commercial uluunua 1 — k—lumya - I vehicular access on north eda_e of lot. W `1 I25. No. of Contributing Resources I26. No. of Non - contributing Resources 27. rtviro ent ixe & commercial , 28. Areas of Significance: ❑ Agriculture ❑ Architecture ❑ Art ❑ Commerce ❑ Communications ❑ Community Planning ❑ Conservation 29. Historic Context(s) / Statement of Significance/ Additional Description: The present house was built by Frederick W. Keller, who was for ATTACH NEGATIVE many years one of South Bend's most influential citizens. Keller ENVELOPE HERE 1 was the subject of many articles in the _South Bend Tribune. He was (born on Sept. 16, 1872, on his father's farm in German Township and later attended ❑ Economics lValparaiso University, as well as the civil enqineerinq program at the University of y ❑ Education I Mi chi qan ❑ Engineering . ❑ Entertainment /recreation While in his teens, he came to South Bend and in 1894 became its assistant civil ❑ Ethnic heritage • Exploration /settlement engineer. He h elped in the development of numerous projects• 1 the ronstructinn nf .__ • Health l medicine the present sewage system: 2. the c onstruction of the city Water pl an ; 3. tkL? ❑ ❑ Indian Industry foundation of the Riverview Cemeterv; 4. the dev elopment of t he N -J _ _ T_& I. RR and ❑ Invention dams along the St. Joseph River. He became the President of the C hamber of rnmmprro ❑ El Landscape architecture Law in 1911 and served the city as a progressive mayor from 1913. He is oerhaDs b est known ❑ Literature as the fo under-- with _t help of l eslle Whitrnmh— of Whitcomb & Keller in 1893. ❑ Military His sister, Mrs. Clara Keller Baldwin (see South Bend Tribune 8- 24 -47) was an out- 0 Performing arts 30. FOR STATE OFFICE USE ONLY "adventurer" E3 Philosophy spoken, sel f- proclaimed who her.ame a ❑ Politics / government pioneering homesteader in the untenanted areas of the NR ❑ Religion ❑ Science Dakotas, because she claimed she was bor by th e SR ❑ Social history "ordinary things most people do..." E El Transportation ❑ Vernacular /Construction F. W. Keller lived at 609 Portage fnr only a few NE ❑ Other I 31. UTM M SEE CONTINUATION SHEET t l eM 32. Information Sources Howard, History of St. Joseph Countv, p. 186; Chapman, History of St. Joseph Countv, P. 691. Keller family in German Twp.; South Bend and the M Wh o Made It; 1901, p. 172; South Bend Public Library clinoina file: News Times 5/21/27; South Bend Tribune 3/19/59 (lengthy obit) St. Joseph County tax assessors records, City Directories; 33. Surveyor Affiliation I Date DeFrees - 34. Revised by Affiliation Date CN 4/87 R J A Statement of Significance Contd.: years - -from 1905 to 1908. residence as 1732 E. Wayne of _the shingle style: -a no of F.L. Wright, helped to the use of highly textured with picturesque roofline of a modified Doric order His obituary, dated 3- 19 -59, records his later The house at 609 Portage is a superb example w rarely seen style which John Silsbee, the teacher make popular. The curved bays covered with shingles, contrasting materials, and the rambling appearance are all features of this style. Some classical detailing is used on the porch and facade. CLEVELAND /LYNNWOOD CEMETERY An 1875 plat map of German Township in Higgins' I_1.1_u_strat.ed H_istor.i. al.... „_At_la__ sof St. .._.Joseph County shows a swath of land dUU out between properties owned by two early white settler families, the Sweets and Witters; a local history text [1] attributes W. Witter as the donor of the land for use as a cemetery. Currently referred to as Witter Cemetery by many local citizens and the German Township Assessors Office, the property was actually donated by John and Eva Cripe; the Cripes were also among the first Caucasians to settle in what is now known as St. Joseph County. A public record dated February 12, 1844 shows the donation of the southwest corner of German Township's section 22 to the inhabitants of the township for use as a cemetery (as deeded by John and Eva Cripe). Also known throughout local history as Sweet Cemetery and Cripe Cemetery, this paper will refer to the site as the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery which depicts its general geographic location by relation to existing thoroughfares. The grave sites of numerous. early Caucasian inhabitants of the region are located on this plot of land. Members of the Hague, Miller, Wagner, Witter, Cripe, Stutsman, and Frame pioneer families are buried here among others. These early settlers of European descent were largely of German nationality and farmers by trade. Several became involved in the early politics, civic duties, public works, agricultural organizations, and religious denominations of the newly formed St. Joseph County. The Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery is one of the first established burial grounds in the county. The earliest known grave marker in the cemetery, that of Maria Miller, daughter of Elder David and Louisa Miller, is dated February 23, 1834; the latest known grave marker, that of Catherine Miller, 2nd wife of Elder David, is dated September 8, 1890. The following material is a collection of short biographical notes on the early settlers buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery as taken from local history texts written largely in the latter part of the 19th century (see bibiliography). In 1829, before St. Joseph County was organized, John and Sarah Hague settled a tract of land on the west side of the St. Joseph River within what was primarily known as Portage township, then in the latter part of 1830 as German township, and from 1840 to the present, Clay township. They were among the very first permanent white settlers in the area. A local history text [2] claims John Hague plowed the first furrow in the newly formed German township. John served as a petit juror on one of the county's first circuit courts in 1830 and was reappointed to the petit jury the following year. He died in 1857, Sarah in 1861; both died in - 14 c i Warren township but were returned to German Township's Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery for burial. Aaron and Elizabeth (Hardman) Miller settled in German township in 1831. Aaron was born 4/8/1785 in Virginia and moved with his parents to Ohio in 1800. He married Elizabeth Hardman in December of 1805; they had 7 sons and 4 daughters. In 1818 he and his family moved to Wayne Co. Indiana and came to South Bend, then an unincorporated trading post, in 1829. In 1831 they moved 4 miles north of South Bend and settled section 23 of German township where David Miller, Aaron's brother, had settled the previous year. The Miller brothers were heavily involved in the early politics of the county. Aaron was the county's second treasurer, appointed in September of 1831 and held the office through 1833; David was one of the 1st County Commissioners. He also organized the first German Baptist congregation in the area and became its first pastor;. Aaron was one of its first preachers. Aaron died 4/12/1839; Elizabeth died in 1861. Both are buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. David Miller is buried in German Township's Mount Pleasant Cemetery. John (Sr.) and Eva ( Roof) Cripe- are listed as early settlers of that part of German township which was later incorporated into Clay township. In 1830, they settled along the west side of the St. Joseph River and eventually acquired acreage along both banks. John was born August 5, 1798 to farming folk in Pennsylvania. He married Eva Roof, daughter of Peter and Margaret Roof on December 26, 1813. They had 12 children. The Cripes moved to Montgomery County, residing on a farm there until they moved to St. Joseph County's German township where they entered 380 acres - of land. Within two years their holdings included approximately 900 acres of land in the County. In 1844, they donated the land for the burial ground that is referred to in this text as the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. John died in February of 1847 at the age of 58. Soon after, Eva began to sell off the numerous acres that she and her husband had acquired. Deed records show land transactions between herself and Alexis Coquillard, Jacob and David Cripe. Eva died in December of 1863. Although not currently visible, recent field surveys [3] attest to the existence of John's grave marker in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. The existence of Eva's burial site has not been verified by these surveys although a local history text [41 notes the burial of both John and Eva within German Township. Samuel Witter settled in German township in 1831 on section 16 near Mount Pleasant. He was the eldest son of John and Anna (Mayer) Witter. He married in Union County, Indiana, settling in Cass County, Michigan in 1830. Samuel served on the Grand Jury of the St. Joseph Circuit Court in 1833. He is listed as an incorporator on the roster of the county's first agricultural society (1841). He was elected I director of German township when the society was reorganized in August of 1851 and again in 1852 and 1856. He was also appointed to a committee of 3 to work up membership in German Township. He held the presidency of the society in 1857. Samuel died in South Bend in January of 1880 and is listed as buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. Jesse and Nancy Frame settled section 22, Portage Prairie (Warren township) in 1833. They had 7 sons. They were natives of Virginia, moving to Ohio, then to Wayne County, Indiana in 1821 and finally to St. Joseph County. Their son, Neely, predated their arrival to St. Joseph County by several years, settling there in 1830. In November of 1833, Jesse was appointed by the Board of County Commissioners along with two other ealy settlers (including Aaron Miller's brother David mentioned earlier) to lay out 3 County roads. Jesse and Nancy died within a month of each other in the winter of 1865. Both were 78 years of age. Local history texts [5] conflict on the arrival of Daniel Wagner and his spouse to the St. Joseph County region. One source [6] reports the Wagners as settling in section 16 of German Township as early as 1832. They are documented as buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery [7]. Mrs. Wagner's grave marker, however, has not shown up in field surveys done in this century. In 1832, John Stutsman settled in section 24 of German township which later became Clay township. He died December of 1862 at the age of 80 years. A field survey done by the Daughters of the American Revolution lists a grave marker for him. Currently, this is not visible. The grave marker of Union Army soldier David R. Cripe, a recruit of the 48th Regiment of Indiana, Company B, is located in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. The 48th Regiment of Indiana consisted largely of St. Joseph County residents. Mustered at Goshen in December of 1861, the regiment saw action at Corinth, Iuka, and Vicksburg, serving under Generals Grant and Sherman throughout its career. In January of 1864, the regiment marched to Huntsville, Alabama, where it re- enlisted as a veteran organization and returned home on veteran furlough, reaching Indianapolis in Early February. The 300 plus veterans were publicly received and welcomed with speeches by the Governor of Indianapolis and others [8]. David Cripe's death apparently occurred during this furlough. Documentation as to the cause of death has yet to be found. His remains were returned to German Township and he was buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery; the grave marker is currently visible and intact. It is uncertain as to David's relation to the pioneer members of the Cripe family. John and Eva Cripe had a son named David, but the no documentation has been found linking this personage to the Civil War soldier. 6 The Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery was the original burial place of another Union Army soldier, Prosper Wagner, son of William and Sarah (Nichols) Wagner. The St. Joseph Valley Register, an early South Bend publication, lists Prosper in its August 28, 1862 paper as a volunteer soldier with the 20th Indiana Battery from St. Joseph County. A local history text [9] gives the account of Prosper's illness and stay at a Nashville field hospital until the end of the war, at which time he returned home only to die four weeks later. Prosper's remains were reinterred to Riverview Cemetery in 1908. Elder David and Louisa (0'Conner) Miller settled in German Township in 1839. Elder David (no apparent relation to Miller brothers previouly mentioned) was born in Northumberland County, Pennsylvania in July of 1806; he was a farmer by trade as well as a D_unkard (German Baptist) minister. Louisa was born in August of 1807. They had seven children, two of whom died in early childhood and are buried in the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. One of the markers, that of their, daughter Maria, predates their arrival to St. Joseph County as documented by a local history text [10]. Either the marker is honorary in nature or the printed account of Miller's arrival to the region is inaccurate. Louisa died prematurely in March of 1843. Within the next two years, Elder David remarried to Catherine Keltner, who was 18 years his junior. They had nine children by their marriage. One of their sons, Daniel C., died in early childhood and is buried at the Cleveland /Lynnwood Cemetery. Elder David died November of 1876, Catherine in 1890. Grave markers are still visible for Elder David, Louisa, and Catherine. { c BIBLIOGRAPHY Cook,. Toni. Survey of St. Joseph Co. Cemeteries. n.d.,n.p. Eisen, David. Biographical Index to St. Joseph County, Indiana, Histories. Unigraphic, Inc., Evansville, Indiana, 1978. . History of St. Joseph County Indiana. Chas. C. Chapman & Co., Chicago, 1880. Repr., Unigraphic, Inc., Evansville, 1976. General Index of Deeds of St. Joseph County, Indiana. n.p. St. Joseph County Recorders Office. Books 3 and 4. Howard, Timothy E. A History of .St. Joseph County Indiana, Volumes I & II. Chicago= The Lewis Publishing Co., 1907. . An Illustrated Historical Atlas of St. Joseph Co. Indiana. Higgins Belden & Co., Chicago, 1875. Reprinted by Unigraphic, Inc., Evansville. . John Gripe, Deed to Inhabitants, German Township. n.p. St. Joseph County Recorders Office. Deed Book H, p. 248. . Pictorial and Biographical Memoirs of Elkhart and St. Joseph Counties Indiana. Goodspeed Brothers, Chicago, 1893. Reprinted by Whipporwill Publication. F007NO1ES_ 1) Chapman, History of St. Joseph County Indiana, p. 688. 2) Chapman, p. 684. 3) Cook, Survey of St. Joseph County Cemeteries. 4) Chapman, P. 679. 5) Chapman, P. 684. Higgins, An Illustrated Historical Atlas of St. Joseph County, Indiana, p. 54. Howard, A History of St. Joseph County Indiana Vol I, p. 138. 6) Chapman, P. 684. 7) Chapman, P. 688. 8) Chapman, pp. 425, 426. Howard, Vol II, p. 724. 9) Pictorial and Biographical Memoirs of Elkhart and St. Joseph Counties Indiana, p. 145 10) Howard, P. 819. .I "i rOWN 38 NORTH RANGE Z EAST t e . - -�.— - - - -- -- .!. it /.Y [.ttctr ' ✓• cu[le I c.•, Ba.1/'t�-ltL — – p - - - -- -I S. 1 •: ++r3 I t ,��. `N I li is er 1. /iixel• I 3,20 \ �> , .1, ■ I - � 7 ' ° ■; , : -- - '`_�- � __ - - -_ -._ =-- ___ - �' � I , .'M.,V1 'ter I m U fY ! -- e �;- -- — --- 1--- - - -160 _ i Rartl• : /GI ' v I JJI..E F'.[' Z S. rro I Barre Ftikcr D. �!i!lr.l � `� Yellaer Way,ter e:::::- i I; t ✓. W G r t P. M i' w y y ju f a I +� 1 al�IrLP acraalrL J. E. D vtan, a° !sr.■fr■ (J (e. i eft. l zoo r \\ I I ryiJ p c I � ! � £ I N I!• St/tith/ ♦&[l rn. I R. fts ✓.BLCLLf �� ■ Ij �� i •b • n RO • I b �YR u lff'G Ir W, I D IVIA ubrl'Lirrrr I !• i z1 T. 4 V !« I I i L•hamhe, r ' T- GVVe ' \ >.1 suu4[aAz J. G a a d/ a rr/ -a e t •. raWrEl Cj t 14 v ,p ° ', 1. Jr n 71/ n" 2U so r t'Y j skys % ` 7 6 !••: 3 J a I R. Mrlar 1 � ' I ,� —6 C : 671crr 1 I C J. - !� � D. • E h p V p•wwr II ti I 1 ,, a. • f 7 I J. W.Jtn7tilt9J' - Arles W. T. la rb GCS' ',Z' =—� Jntit¢iI � • I ss�n MI I pp J. r -• �' I I ---- t7LY -- � ' I - -- P B. Doo� )r/ B y ., , I Lae%i -- II 1 O ".l yJ.F'. rrlcry - -' l �.rw � • rN�i =uLLr Id'+� i�.49 rwF.xiilr� L: iz GERMAN TOWNSHIP. �., ✓Ir • 7'lerr l l:Pparlta ffe• ;o ^jl ! r4l, ir i i J K• i�' J. _ • �. t .Y,!'dy.fc/..i L�irfR�G r I � i 1'hGf• ` . t J. (:. To LLmr a j \8 �\'x N (, M Wtbs✓ U yif I Stv r D J Z' � o a h o ire, %B�t�r •� 0. Kelber _K � I• Ir � . � �_ . ' ul_• a 4 be La irtI \ i X I• r ' T- GVVe ' \ >.1 suu4[aAz J. G a a d/ a rr/ -a e t •. raWrEl Cj t 14 v ,p ° ', 1. Jr n 71/ n" 2U so r t'Y j skys % ` 7 6 !••: 3 J a I R. Mrlar 1 � ' I ,� —6 -� J. 't J. Ritter .4.Smt6th1 7 I J. W.Jtn7tilt9J' - Arles W. T. la rb GCS' ',Z' =—� Jntit¢iI � • I 33 ` �2 D. \ i � � w.r. f_ I S.W. _J .f'. O n Oct \\ e l' a R. Jn ulr GLoI )r/ B y ., , I Lae%i -- II 1 O \\_ tz, u. �` p, f> I ss.i± - -- - '.ililLeil• bit I _ a rN�i =uLLr Id'+� i�.49 rwF.xiilr� L: GERMAN TOWNSHIP. John Smith was one of the first settlers in this township, 1829. Sev- 4 ,mt families of Mille David, A aron, Jacob and others came about 1833. 9 and perhaps before. J. D. Miller came in 1831, on Section 3 Christian .f Holler came in 1830; John and Jacob Ritter about the same - time. Abram 1cl and Jonathan Smith, Daniel Wagoner about 1834, also John and Samuel- ? Witter, who settled at Mt. Pleasant; John was killed by lightning. James and John Huston, Samuel Keltner, came April, r844. Nathan Hatfield, ;? Wm. Brookfield, the surveyor, Mr. Good, the father of Joseph, who was at c. r V i killed by runaway horses. David Hoover and others were quite early set- tlers. Reuben Dunn came in September, 1838, and stopped on Section 32; John F. Ulery and family in 1851, on Section 30; J. M. Whitner on Section 7, in 1832. There are three churches, Methodist, Universalist and Dunkards. The first was Elder Miller's, and he was one of the first preachers. The first school house was built at Mt. Pleasant. R . C Lr LAN>/ Gxht6TEr, -( .s•/r,,,,� / an ft-2 ", ^ -- ■ L• 'Pnren47 . - I _ - -.a... .w_�.._.._._.c� 7, !G rb,r.I V. U. •II �' H ,.,ilr 7Jl.S`rrr rZ /r �^ .. '. — L I 1 i'A"7& rirr. 3> I 1`I '. 1 r ''• - ' ''1 - "' T ►IrC17,rrnC I '` I �w ]1 •,� 1 [Za /! � � • I i ' r77edir ?i i I? j j • CJJrux•/c' � �- --_ 0 ., 1 r.o� W.C. j I • Iiir• : I � � .;a `o, ./. 1 %i , , /:.:. i ,_ � � rF ti 'F -ii- l�_._l.__ v. .5% r�perll C• co Gundmna7t 7 BaoZr I Gue71r I r "' .IkI7.BrZZcrli �7 v : •ambZr [c a arn, r, Y 9" ■ J .a ,[ I y - /. il TIoZP l% ( rnir ---- Xall. 17nn1n 7° �'�• S vl6uolrr ' ! • � .°, �'� 1 CNrnr rr I '� BuZmc -� I IL ✓ _ I _ .4R ;y klrrion .:9 I /� J %ibalrr• 1.+ h !°, a = i i p M t °, ° I • l 0 .. >r[r: J7rr• • r I jinanu t y' fini 17, '/ ' � Tt`rcrcti t[,[r ■ .ZB. .,f � , + _ CI _ � 4�C 1 M'[bncr �� - -_- �•k >(arrllarrili7AL GZorrrW a Rrctli j sSr d c i 7l. � - - -.� >. •/ • `> fan rs,r Cn !° 1 7hngk r - - -- N � • v .7Nrrrn F7LCou•Ir! " _ _� , ct.0 ' >s r w °' • " � 1l'. i ' IN'/r [an �- ■ LLa I Orr .1. [9 ■ , *s I 2J �, ■ < I -! ' i / i' - -- sO - 0-FS- Iu ex- I _�Jl ■ e Derr \ -��,� ill �I +1 7R trr '>F GeOXx [r Are ° ti 2 �i 1•! I - /t '. ,iA p 911 . I Trwzderhoof o I I _ :�. B a r r• of • �u � FJ ,. �, .'J. J'idrrr I ,-G. i � • a•J7uharl �� ,� Tso,t r7Z9- AJ �, lal .c. ' '7 � S J_.4- N o T.Boo Lel'.)1' • rr ,C :rr �.` I;.!'ook •uA,erG <. 1 L ?L + :11. !c u x a '°>.� 1' o7, ey Ina 1■ ■ ti y Boolc v: I F K # " ore } ?arhn - .Ar Ire cr b r2u N ±� ° ° !r 1 • I FG �r » ° : I n �� /. 6 5X.9 ro 600Zcy- W�ff eom3! IlfChearharZ XaZs 7 CD t7' M7 j UZ ;arc h S • zr :FO dead— S. n I I 1.1rr • •a1' 7Erd� fpr7lrr r W. i r • L. � =. •J � Jo r 2xtplinger i7z XR- i — a :i p lSorr[airr`q /to i. +III• 41) 41) J141 °� I . Z ■ ,■ r_ 4 v i�•. II C L J.T. I ` i • � �' s Is v F �S "Maryr t ■ � fZ er 54 . S I � • � ° ti ■Tl.'.DuLa /r.�'.B7[Z2 • h � � � �,•,, '•r S I L. �:_..zs so N �, ` i srr J. /i'rr _ Afs,Fn ,6J • /,• 1, r. ..>,:�,ij . I,•Xal' fl rnw ' l.Y. b c � k ' 3 ¢� C7C • ✓ , "f '� � ^ �.�a ` '� G ..S r .. i� PO. 76fktn • 1limnp I .,, � II • j/n arson � 7 n "� 1 o v 3 /� � /- [II.L71{rLfalc?• l tn. I 1 r- — � � u __1 rFr,[ ra rr J. T,So!lrrnranl Yran7.' r �Il 1 3t .. r..io .�i...b:c%rline, .i idi y....- CLAY TOWNSHIP. Benjamin Potter was one of the first :in this township, he came before 1829, on Section 24; John Hague came July, 1829; Wm. McCombs the same time on Section 26; John an e e Cripe on same Section in 1830; .Peter and Jacob Eaton on Section 13, in t83i�' somas Longley on Section 21, in 1830; Evan Chalf,,ut on Section 31, in 0.31; Wm. Smith on Section 14• John H. Smith, son of Carmon Smith, some say was the the oldest settler. Joshua Johnson came about 1831 ; John C. Stutsman on Section 24, 1832; Evan and Thomas B. Chalfant on Secton 31, the same year; James Stuckey on Section 3o. Win. and Thomas Bulls among the earliest, Samuel Brooks before 1833; Francis Jen. nings and his three sons in 1833 or 4; Joseph and Stephen Ulery on Sections 24 and 25, in 1834; Oliver P. Stuckey on Section 19, 1836; Menzo Webster on Section 23, in 1834; David Soosomen came in 184r, on Section t9, and Jacob Chearhart in 1845, on Section 3o; Gideon Drapier, 1832, on Section 31.' The first school -house was Stovers, on Section 28. The first church, Notre Dame, Catholic, on Section 36. tz ap \ z ,Irle, ,, o /ds John Hent same year; Jo} James, John, u Hupp on Sectit Section 32; He , Glenn, 4835 or 6 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH COUNTY Staff Use Only da to f i I ed�Yl� 1 1� rating .5-11 sty GC E APPLICATION FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION ADDRESS OF PROPERTY GI- 1r VEUdqD 9D, 13/+ AVEF. POP MIT Od AVE. LEGAL DESCRIPTION V� C J I /�} SCG+� cln zz +w P.3b?qy� �L-- - , yf �� 1 5. ern I S CC44 a' Z2 - 3 9 - Z E N urn b f f'�r t aye ct/vvd L- 11 n C- KEY NUMBER V .� , a L ASSFkiay OWNER'S NAME �RMPc1�9 ToW''jSH P C/ o &ERM� tDwN SH I P "i�t'"&I MAILING ADDRESS R�GI1F�Ip ljV'i�SCtj�lShc1 , ZI9 4 3 fkvi RV. PHONE NUMBER 'z7Z, — 9 020 NAME & ADDRESS OF PERSON COMPLETING APPLICATION IF DIFFERENT FROM OWNER: C-/o A i "o l �P f�S�YZn11 i G i+'t�I w Vvl s S 1 I 1 Z 3 Cm y - G1 t'Y INFORMATION ON NOMINATED PROPERTY: YEAR BUILT 1b14 ORIGINAL OWNER ORIGINAL USE C.,em E -re--12'y ARCHITECT/BUILDER WRITE A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE NOMINATED PROPERTY, BE SURE TO INCLUDE A BIOGRAPHY OF THE OWNERS AND /OR OCCUPANTS, IMPORTANT DATES AND EVENTS (use back of application if necessary). SOURCES OF INFORMATION: HPC85 -7 HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH'COUNTY Staff Use Only date filed rat ing'�l style APPLICATION FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION ADDRESS OF PROPERTY SM &G 1RG�A- N —rP; KPN\fA' A W LEGAL DESCRIPTION /as ITZ. , OV: KEY NUMBER I — lort 04 22 OWNER'S NAME M 150 WWfA A I M 1 CIPLe G 1"1 i.l - 'f L�5 M MIL M ILLEIZ AILING ADDRESS c I Z�, �1 . G NU � �f� �.� T' PHONE NUMBER Zy 163o MME & ADDRESS OF PERSON COMPLETING APPLICATION IF DIFFERENT FROM OWNER: 1 ac s `. INFORMATION ON NOMINATED PROPERTY: YEAR BUILT N39 — 1136 ORIGINAL OWNER Cj OF M1SHiWA -t — ORIGINAL USE 6ARIE Vk1. @1,5 PUA-R ARCHITECT /BUILDER (,Gl`t''t wIY'fil.%� �2�SE�2vCirr,� WRITE A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE NOMINATED PROPERTY, BE SURE TO INCLUDE A BIOGRAPHY OF THE OWNERS AND /OR OCCUPANTS, IMPORTANT DATES AND EVENTS (use back of application if necessary). SOURCES OF INFORMATION: HPC85 -7 L w H - .p /`�Z FK, L-AN P - M ' s k, I] , ICI(.,d 4,,l . it i� V., . 7- 1 � j _ f AA ` ' i4V i ` � � r .�i M� � f• t � EY �r f �� Fir s f ! \�Ki �• '1 r' t -'� _ ?i , 4 � 1 KL- t � i« : _ S. r. • C _ ��1e,. illit�. �� ..1 ply�dP, VIII Iflllllll - Iw s - 1 � j _ f AA ` ' i4V i ` � � r .�i M� � f• t � EY �r f �� Fir s f ! \�Ki �• '1 r' t -'� _ ?i , KL- t � i« : _ S. r. • C _ ��1e,. illit�. �� ..1 ply�dP, VIII Iflllllll - - s - ks S. r. • C _ ��1e,. illit�. s - 6k Doc.# Date 34129 4 \4 34314 4 \11 34320 4 \11 34414 4 \15 34395 4 \15 34396 4 \15 34397 4 \15 34398 4 \15 34413 4 \15 34416 4 \15 34478 4 \16 DP 4 \25 OP 4 \25 34320 4 \26 34634 4 \25 34715 4 \30 34627 4 \25 34766 5 \02 34765 5 \02 34764 5 \02 34763 5 \02 34762 5 \02 34633 5 \02 Vendor Description, P.O.# GAYTON GLORIA CONT 3 -10 TO 3= 23- 91_7OH @$6.0.,' /HR 47059 CBI GRAPHICS 21083.03 47237 DILLS CAMERA SHOP 12.00 47243 PDH BID POCKETFOLIOS 47335 BOOKER SUZANNE CONT 3 -24 TO 4 -6 70HRS @$6.25/HR 47317 HOLYCROSS FRED CONT 3 -24 TO 4 -6 60HRS @$6,20 /HR 47318 PASTOR, JAMES CONT 4- 15TO4 -30 $625. /PAYABLE 47319 STRICKLER RANDALL CONT 3 -24 TO 4 -6 24HRS @$6.00 /HR 47320 DIXON LORI REIMB FOR HOTEL PAID - PASTOR- CONFERENCE NAT'LTRUST 47334 GENE'S CAMERA STORE 121.88 47337 NATIONAL TRUST FOR H.P. CONF REG - J.PASTOR 47398 BOOKER SUZANNE MILEAGE DP DIXON LORI MILEAGE TO INDY FOR ST. REVIEW BOARD MTG. DP DILL CAMERA SHOP 2 PAK POLAROID 600 FILM /1 BLOCK PX 135 36 EXP FILM 47243 PASTOR JAMES REIMBURSEMENT FOR TRAVEL AT CONFERENCE 47548 INSTY -PRINT BROCHURE PRINTING FOR MAYOR'S CONFERENCE 47628 GAYTAN GLORIA PAYMENT FOR 3 -25 & 26 DUE TO DIRECTOR'S ERROR 47541 PASTOR JAMES CONT. MAY 1 -5, 1991 (SEMI - MONTHLY) 47678 BOOKER SUZANNE CONT.APR 7 -27 LESS 1 -1/2 HRS. TARDY ($9.38) 47677 HOLYCROSS FRED CONT. APR 7 -27, 1991 (90 HRS. @$6.20 /HR.) 47676 COMER TINA CONT. APR. 7 -27, 1991 (69.5 HRS. @$6.00) 47675 STRICKLER - RANDALL - CONT: - APR. - 7 -27, 1991 -(36 HRS. @$6.00 /HR.) 47674 NATIONAL TRUST PAYMENT FOR GUIDELINES BOOK - 47547 _ Deb - it cr... ,�a�ance__. _i 420.00 _ 21140.03 57.00 21083.03 121.88 20961.15 12.00 20949.15 437.50 20511.65 372.00 20139.65 625.00 19514.65 144.00 19370.65 130.00 19240.65 39.90, 19200.75 75.00. 19125.75 75'12 19050.63 78,50 18972.13 121.88 18850.25 � 48.73 18801.52 148.60 18652.92 84.00 18568.92 625.00 17943.92 646.87', 17297.05 558.00 16739.05 417.00 16322.05 216.00 1'6106.05 8.00 _ 16098.05 F� ra HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND AND ST, JOSEPH COUNTY • Staff Use Only date fi1ed0r/y f rating S IZ- style l`m cLksslc' APPLICATION FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION ADDRESS OF PROPERTY FO LEGAL DESCRIPTION �O? 3 ( yo, c. c ,w. k. KEY NUMBER f � — ) 0 19 — 0103 OWNER'S NAME TA,13 J�0 J3L-Rfi R0V- P K'S MAILING ADDRESS 6()q I O R - t,GE . Svvm BmD PHONE NUMBER (r, 2�3q GgGG AME E ADDRESS OF PERSON COMPLETING APPLICATION IF DIFFERENT FROM OWNER: Rmn 1123 , Cevrt C i�f f�,r -� • ` O u,>�t �a l 1� '+6(201 INFORMATION ON NOMINATED PROPERTY: YEAR BUILT 1905 ORIGINAL OWNER I��D �Ck ORIGINAL USE KF,5 PM ARCH I TECT /BU I LDER S C H wt ► pm WRITE A BRIEF HISTORY OF THE NOMINATED PROPERTY, BE SURE TO INCLUDE A BIOGRAPHY OF THE OWNERS AND /OR OCCUPANTS, IMPORTANT DATES A14D EVENTS (use back of application if necessary). SOURCES OF INFORMATION: HPC85-7