HomeMy WebLinkAboutRM 01-19-96*'k 1.1_4
SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMIVIISSION
REGULAR MEETING
January 19, 1996
10:00 a.m.
Presiding: Paula N. Auburn
President
1. ROLL CALL
1308 County -City Building
227 W. Jefferson Boulevard
South Bend, Indiana
Members Present: Ms. Paula N. Auburn, President
Ms. Robert W. Hunt, Vice - President
Mr. William R Hojnacki, Secretary
Mr. Philip J Faccenda
Members Absent: Mr. Michael Donoho
Legal Counsel: Ms. Jenny Pitts Manier
Redevelopment Staff: Mrs. Ann Kolata, Director
Mrs. Cheryl Phipps, Recording Secretary
Mr. James Riggs, Economic Dev. Specialist
Bureau of Housing Staff
Business Assistance Staff
Media:
Others:
Ms. Ernestine Ligon
Mr. Michael Beitzinger
Mr. Don Porter, South Bend Tribune
Mr. Carter Wolf, Center City Associates
Ms. Auburn noted that Thom Howell passed away a week ago. The Commisson will miss him.
He was a professional journalist who always conducted himself with the utmost respect. Our
meetings will not be the same without him.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
a. Approval of Minutes of the Annual
Organizational Meeting of Tuesday,
January 2, 1996.
-1-
I r r_
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES (Cont.)
a. Continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Hojnacki
seconded by Mr. Faccenda and
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the Minutes of the Annual
Organizational Meeting of Iiiesday,
January 2, 1996.
b. Approval of Minutes of the
Rescheduled Regular Meeting of
Tuesday, January 2, 1996.
Upon a motion by Mr. Hunt,
seconded by Mr. Hojnacki and
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the Minutes of the
Rescheduled Regular Meeting of
Iliesday, January 2, 1996.
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF
THE ANNUAL ORGANIZATIONAL MEETING OF
TUESDAY, JANUARY 2, 1996
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
RESCHEDULED REGULAR MEETING OF TUESDAY,
JANUARY 2, 1996
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted January 19, 1996, for approval.
ADMIN 1995 (212
Mobile Comm
$20.15
Tri County News
$56.09
York Title & Escrow
$50.00
St. Joseph Title Corp.
$250.00
Indiana Michigan Power Co.
$6.65
Center City Associates
$365.00
SAMPLE - EWING DEVELOPMENT AREA (414
Cole Associates Inc.
$9,564.70
Charles Chambliss and J &D Contracting Inc.
$175.00
Charles Chambliss and Barany Sheet Metal
$335.00
Charles Chambliss and Kathie S. Brown
$250.00
Petty Cash (Recording Fees)
$331.00
Doug Carpenter
$800.00
Peirce & Associates
$4,225.00
Advanced Environmental Systems
$14,867.42
Larry MinkoR
$1,690.00
-2-
I L_
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS (Cont.)
SAMPLE- EWING DEVELOPMENT AREA (414) continued...
ATEC Associates Inc.
$9,166.00
York Title & Escrow Inc.
$281.00
The Troyer Group Inc.
$301.64
George Frison and Emma Frison
$42)639.54
St. Joseph County Treasurer
$194.46
Creekside Mortgage Surveys, Inc.
$225.00
St. Joseph Title Corp & Francis T. Farrell
$17,110.00
George & Emma Frison & York Title & Escrow Inc.
$10,064.00
B & J Excavation, Inc.
$7,393.75
Upon a motion by Mr. Hojnacki, seconded
by Mr. Faccenda and unanimously carried,
the Commission approved the Claims
submitted January 19, 1996.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
There were no Communications.
5. OLD BUSINESS
a. Correction to Certificates of
Waiver
Mrs. Kolata noted that at the
December 15 meeting there were
Certificates of Waiver approved for
properties at 239 Laporte and 431
Cottage Grove. The addresses were
switched on the forms and need to be
corrected. The corrected amounts to
be waived are $1400 as of May 1,
1995 for 239 Laporte and $1740 as
of December 22, 1994 and 1995 for
431 Cottage Grove. We would like
the Commission to approve these
corrections.
-3-
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS SUBMITTED
JANUARY 19, 1996
THERE WERE NO COMMUNICATIONS
. ,
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
5. OLD BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. Continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Hcjnacki, COMMISSION APPROVED THE CORRECTIONS TO
seconded by Mr. Hunt and THE CERTIFICATES OF WAIVER
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the corrections to the
Certificates of Waiver.
6. NEW BUSINESS
a. Staff report on disposition of
property in the Airport Economic
Development Area.
Mr. Riggs presented the following
staff report:
To: South Bend Redevelopment Commission
From: James M. Riggs
Blackthorn Project Manager
subject: Inn at Blackthorn - Proposal by The Management Consortium
Onto: January 30, 1996
The following report describes the most recent proposal submitted by the Developer,
The Management Consortium, for the purchase and development of Lot 3, Blackthorn
Corporate Park. Each point of the proposal is listed by item followed by the staff
recommendation for that point.
Purchase Price
The proposed purchase price is $120,000 for the 4.463 acre site, or $26,888 per
acre.
Recommendation: Acceptable.
-4-
I k
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Project
The Developers propose to construct a 150 -room hotel, for an estimated $10
million, which would be a part of the Choice Hotels International reservation
network. This network is the largest hotel reservation network in the world. The
hotel would contain 150 suites, of which, six would be convertible, double bay,
hospitality suites and six would include in -room Jacuzzi's. The hotel would also
include a 40 -seat table service restaurant and cocktail area, serving three meals
and room service. A fitness center complete with indoor pool and a business
center would also be included. Each suite would have separate living /working and
sleeping areas with one king or two queen beds (plus queen sleeper sofa); direct
dial phones; two TV's and video - player; telephone data -ports; and mini -bar with
refrigerator and microwave.
Recommendation: Acceptable.
Faithful Performance Guaranty
The required faithful performance guaranty of 10 % of the purchase price
($12,000) has been submitted by the Developers. The proposal states that the
guaranty would be non - refundable except in following circumstances: 1) the St.
Joseph County Airport Authority does not grant a non - compete agreement with the
Developers; 2) the Common Council of the City of South Bend does not grant a
ten -year tax abatement for the project; or 3) the State of Indiana fails to fund a
grant to the City of South Bend for the construction of the proposed Bypass
interchange. The guaranty, in the form of two checks submitted by the Developer
shall be held by the Commission, uncashed, until the Contract for Sale of Land is
executed.
Recommendation: The three circumstances that would provide for a refund of the
performance guaranty listed above are acceptable with the following modifications: the
Developer is limited to a time period ending April 30, 1996 to procure the necessary
approvals from the Airport Authority for the non - compete and from the City for the tax -
abatement. The third circumstance, should read as follows: the State of Indiana fails to
fund a grant to the City of South Bend sufficient to construct the proposed Bypass
interchange.
-5-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Project Schedule
The developer has proposed an extended time schedule from the typical
Commission project. The following represents the project schedule as proposed:
1. Staff - developer negotiations 12/15/95
2. Developer public presentation 12/15/95
3. Commission approval of proposal 1/19/96
4. Airport Authority grants non - compete 2/96
5. City approves Tax Abatement 2/96
6. Contract for Sale of Land executed 2/96
7. Preliminary plans submitted for design review 5/96
8. Design review completed and approved 6/96
9. Financing commitments obtained by developer 2/97
10. Final plans & specs completed and submitted 4/97
11. Building permit secured 7/97
12. Construction start date 8/97
13. Construction completed -open for business 9/98
The proposal states, however, that Event #6, Contract for sale of land executed,
is conditioned upon the prior or simultaneous happening of Events #4 and #5,
Airport non - compete and tax abatement approvals. Additionally, the proposal
further conditions the project schedule if there is a delay in Events #4, #5, #6.
The proposal states that the actual date of the last of the Events #4, #5, #6 (if
after 2/29/96) would become the new base date to measure the subsequent
Events #7 -13 using the same number of months intervening each event in the
above project schedule.
Recommendation: The project schedule as listed in Events #1 -13 is acceptable with the
following additions and clarifications: Event #6, Contract, will be executed by all parties
on or before February 19, 1996, without regard to the timing of Events #4 and #5,
Airport Non - Compete and Tax abatement. The Contract will clearly state that the failure
by the Developer to gain the approvals necessary for Events #4 and #5 on or before April
30, 1996, shall cause the termination Contract and the return of the faithful performance
guaranty to the Developer. If there is a delay with Events #4 or #5, the date of the latest
event will become the new base of measure for Events #7 -13 of the project schedule, as
stated in the proposal, however, in no event shall Events #4 and #5 occur later then April
30, 1996. At that time, the Developer or the Commission may cancel the Contract.
-6-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSEWSS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Additionally, after Event #9, Financing commitments, but prior to Event #11, Building
permit, the Developer and the Commission shall establish a time and place for the
closing of transfer of property from the Commission to the Developer.
Airport Non - compete
As mentioned above as Event #4, the Developer is seeking a Non - compete
agreement with the Airport Authority. This non - compete would bar the Airport
Authority from allowing a hotel to be built on its land. The agreement currently
being negotiated by the Developer with the Airport Authority would encompass
the first five years of the Inn at Blackthorn's operations, commencing on the first
day the hotel is open to the public. The agreement would also include rights to
advertise the hotel in the Airport terminal and to operate a courtesy van service
with direct phone lines from the terminal.
Recommendation: Acceptable. As stated above with regard to both the Faithful
Performance Guaranty and the Project Schedule sections, the failure by the Developer
to secure the Non - compete from the Airport Authority on or before April 30, 1996 would
cancel this proposal and the resulting Contract for Sale of Land and cause the full refund
of the performance guaranty.
Redevelopment Non - compete
The Developer is also seeking a Non - compete covenant from the Commission and
the City of South Bend for land controlled by them. This non - compete would
also extend for the first five operating years of the hotel. The proposal also
indicates that with respect to land privately owned, within the Airport Economic
Development Area, the Commission would agree to recommend to the Common
Council that zoning be withheld for any other hotel/motel use.
Recommendation: Staff recommends that the Commission establish a non - compete
covenant, with respect to the land it owns or may acquire, within the Airport Economic
Development Area, with the Developer, based on the terms and conditions of the
Airport's non - compete (exclusive of any terms regarding compensation paid by the
Developer). This represents the full extent of any commitments the Commission can and
will make with respect to hotel development within the Airport Economic Development
Area.
-7-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
CRegular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Tax Abatement
The Developer is seeking a ten -year tax abatement for the project. The Developer
feels that a tax abatement is critical to secure the financing necessary for the
hotel. In order to facilitate the approval of the tax abatement, the Developer has
requested that the Commission, as the current owners of the property, jointly
petition the Common Council for the abatement.
Recommendation: Acceptable. As stated above with regard to both the Faithful
Performance Guaranty and the Project Schedule sections, the failure by the Developer
to secure the tax abatement on or before April 30, 1996, would cancel this proposal and
the resulting Contract for Sale of Land and cause the full refund of the performance
guaranty to the Developer.
Bypass Interchange
The Developer has also conditioned this proposal on the acceptance by the State
of Indiana's Transportation Finance Authority of a grant request made by the City
of South Bend for the construction of the proposed Nimtz Parkway -US 31 Bypass
interchange. If the funding is not secured and construction documents put out for
bid by December 31, 1996, the Developer may, at it's option, cancel the Contract
for Sale of Land, Event #6, and the performance guaranty would be refunded to
the Developer.
Recommendation: As mentioned previously in the section Faithful Performance
Guaranty, the State of Indiana's acceptance of the grant request shall mean a
commitment by the State for funds sufficient for the construction of the project.
Financing
The Developer is proposing to have final financing commitments in place for the
proposed project by February, 1997 (or later if the project schedule is adjusted in
a manner approved by the Commission). However, the proposal states that the
Developer has the right to extend that deadline for an additional six months
(August, 1997) if it can prove to the Commission the Developer demonstrates that
it has been diligently pursuing such commitments.
Recommendation: Acceptable. However, the proposal did not include some of the
required financial information regarding the applicants and the proposed members of a yet
to be formed joint venture. This information must be provided to staff prior to the
execution of the Contract for Sale of Land. Receipt of this information is a condition of
C a
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
the acceptance of this proposal. Evidence of satisfactory financing must be provided to
the Commission prior to the actual transfer of ownership of the property.
Joint Venture
The proposal has been submitted by a corporation known as The Management
Consortium, Inc. (an Illinois corporation) or its nominee. The proposal states that
the final ownership of the project would be a joint venture (yet to be created)
between the key executives of the Management Consortium, Inc. and Venterra
and /or its key executives. The proposal also states that the yet to be created joint
venture would expand to include other equity partners.
Recommendation: The Developer should create the joint venture prior to the execution of
the Contract for Sale of Land. However, if the joint venture is not created by that time,
then the Contract for Sale of Land would be exclusively between The Management
Consortium, Inc. and the Commission. The Contract would require the Commission's
approval of any nomination or assignment of the Contract to any entity other than The
Management Consortium, Inc., including any assignment to the yet to be formed joint
venture described in the proposal. If at anytime throughout the period of the Contract,
until the Certificate of Completion is approved by the Commission, all changes of
ownership of the project, including the addition of equity partners must be approved by
the Commission. All financial information requested of Applicants in the Proposal forms
must be included with a request to change the ownership of the project.
Other Public Incentives
A reference in the proposal states "The only additional public development
incentives would be any that might be required by a potential lender. "
Recommendation: Acceptance of the Developer's proposal does not bind the Commission
or the City to any obligation to provide "additional public development incentives,"
beyond those specifically mentioned in this report.
Licensing Agreement
The proposals states that the proposed Comfort Suites would be known as the Inn
at Blackthorn.
C9
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Recommendation: The Developer and the Commission must enter into a separate
licensing agreement to allow the use of the Commission's trademark Blackthorn and the
Blackthorn "leprechaun" logo.
Mrs. Kolata noted that this is an
important step in the Development of
Blackthorn Corporate Park. The
timeline they put in for financing and
start of construction is a generous
one and, obviously, if they can put it
together faster they will do so; but it
allows them a reasonable period of
time controlling the land in order to
obtain financing.
It Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda
seconded by Mr. Hojnacki and
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the staff report and
accepted the Proposal from The
Management Consortium for land in
the Airport Economic Development
Area and authorized sending the
following letter showing the
conditions of this acceptance:
January 23, 1996
Mr. William T. Hurst
President
The Management Consortium
680 North Lake Shore Drive Suite 608
Chicago, Illinois 60611
RE: Inn at Blackthorn Proposal
-10-
COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE PROPOSAL FROM THE
MANAGEMENT CONSORTIUM FOR THE AIRPORT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA CONDITIONED ON
RECEIVING REQUIRED FINANCIAL INFORMATION
AND EVIDENCE OF SATISFACTORY FINANCING FOR
THE PROJECT
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IV Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Dear Bill:
This letter will serve as acknowledgement that the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission accepted your proposal to purchase the 4.46
acre hotel site at Blackthorn Corporate Park, however, subject to certain
conditions. The following items represent those conditions listed by issue.
When an Event is described by number, it refers to the Events as listed in
the Project Schedule included in the Modifications to Proposal letter dated
December 8, 1995.
Faithful Performance Guaranty
The three circumstances identified in the proposal as providing for a refund of the
Twelve Thousands ($12,000) performance guaranty submitted with the proposal
are the following: (1) the Developer fails to procure the non - compete from the
Airport Authority on or before April 30, 1996; (2) the South Bend Common
Council fails to award a 10 -year real property tax abatement for the Project on or
before April 30, 1996; (3) the State of Indiana fails to fund a grant to the City of
South Bend by December 31, 1996, in an amount sufficient to construct the
proposed Bypass interchange.
Project Schedule
The project schedule as listed in Events #1 -13 is acceptable with the following
modifications: Event #6, Contract, will be executed by the Management Consortium,
Inc. (or nominee, as described in the proposal) and the Commission on or before
February 19, 1996, without regard to the timing of Events #4 and #5, Airport Non -
Compete and Tax abatement. The Contract will clearly state that the failure by the
Developer to to secure those items listed at Events #4 and #5 on or before April 30,
1996, shall cause the termination of the Contract and the return of the faithful
performance guaranty to the Developer. If there is a delay in the satisfaction of Events
#4 or #5, the date on which the later of these two events is competed will become the
new base of measure for Events #7 -13 of the project schedule, as stated in the proposal,
however, in no event shall Events #4 and #5 occur later then April 30, 1996. If there is
a delay in the satisfaction of Events #4 or #5, the Developer or the Commission may
cancel the Contract or agree to revised project schedule.
Additionally, after Event #9, Financing commitments, but prior to Event #11, Building
permit, the Developer and the Commission shall establish a time and place for the closing
of transfer of property from the Commission to the Developer.
-11-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Airport Non - compete
As stated above with regard to both the Faithful Performance Guaranty and the
Project Schedule sections, the failure by the Developer to secure the Non -
compete from the Airport Authority on or before April 30, 1996 would cancel this
proposal and the resulting Contract for Sale of Land and cause the full refund of
the performance guaranty.
Redevelopment Non - compete
The Commission will establish a non - compete covenant, with respect to the land it
owns or may acquire, within the Airport Economic Development Area, with the
Developer, based on the terms and conditions of the Airport's non - compete
(exclusive of any terms regarding compensation paid by the Developer). This
represents the full extent of any commitments the Commission can and will make
with respect to hotel development within the Airport Economic Development
Area.
Tax Abatement
As stated above with regard to both the Faithful Performance Guaranty and the Project
Schedule sections, the failure by the Developer to secure the tax abatement on or before
April 30, 1996, would cancel this proposal and the resulting Contract for Sale of Land
and cause the full refund of the performance guaranty to the Developer.
Bypass Interchange
As mentioned previously in the section Faithful Performance Guaranty, the
Commission requires that the State of Indiana commit funds sufficient for the construction
of the Bypass Interchange project. Without a commitment from the State of Indiana at
this level of funding, the Commission cannot commit to construction of the interchange.
Financing
The proposal did not include some of the required financial information regarding the
applicant and the proposed members of a yet to be formed joint venture. This
information must be provided to staff prior to the execution of the Contract for Sale of
Land. Receipt of this information is a condition of the acceptance of this proposal.
Evidence of satisfactory financing must be provided to the Commission prior to the actual
transfer of ownership of the property.
-12-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Joint Venture
The Developer should create the joint venture prior to the execution of the
Contract for Sale of Land. However, if the joint venture is not created by that
time, then the Contract for Sale of Land would be exclusively between The
Management Consortium, Inc. and the Commission. The Contract would require
the Commission's approval of any nomination or assignment of the Contract to
any entity other than The Management Consortium, Inc., including any
assignment to the yet to be formed joint venture described in the proposal. If at
anytime throughout the period of the Contract, until the Certificate of Completion
is approved by the Commission, all changes of ownership of the project, including
the addition of equity partners must be approved by the Commission. All
financial information requested of Applicants in the Proposal forms must be
included with a request to change the ownership of the project.
Other Public Incentives
Acceptance of the Developer's proposal does not bind the Commission or the City to any
obligation to provide "additional public development incentives," beyond those
specifically mentioned in this letter. Any suggestion to the contrary, including the
statement referenced in correspondence to Jon R. Hunt from William T. Hurst, dated
June 20, 1995, page 4 (which was made a part of the proposal by reference) is rejected
by the Commission.
Licensing Agreement
The Developer and the Commission must enter into a separate licensing agreement to
allow the use of the Commission's trademark Blackthorn and the Blackthorn
"leprechaun" logo.
Zoning
It has come to our attention that we will need to seek a re- zoning from the City of South
Bend for this project. Please understand the South Bend's zoning ordinance actually
classifies property in two ways, one, use, and two, height and area. The Hotel site, is
currently zoned "D" -Light Industrial and "B "- Height and Area. "Hotels and Motels"
are a permitted use in the "D" -Light Industrial zoning, however, the "B" - Height and
Area classification limits the site to buildings no taller than forty (40) feet or three (3)
stories. We will move forward with the necessary paperwork to begin the
rezoning /variance process. While we are confident that this will not be an issue, the
failure to secure the necessary rezoning of the parcel is included as a fourth condition
under which the faithful performance guaranty would be returned to the Developer and
Contract for Sale of Land terminated. Again, we would treat this "circuit- breaker" in the
{
-13-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINFSS (Cont.)
a. continued...
Contract in the same matter as the Airport Non - compete, tax abatement and
Bypass funding.
We are looking forward to seeing this project progress forward. If you have any
questions, please call
me at 219 - 235 -9371. Thank you.
Sincerely,
James M. Riggs
Blackthorn Project Manager
b. Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 1412 approving an
application for real property tax
deduction for property located at
5820 West E Jay Nimtz Parkway
in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (The
Management Consortium)
Mrs. Kolata noted that since the
Commission still owes the land for
this development, the Commission
needs to authorize the signing of the
petition for the tax abatement.
Upon a motion by Mr. Hunt, COMMISSION AUTHORIZATED OF THE SIGNING OF
seconded by Mr. Hojnacki and THE PETITION FOR THE TAX ABATEMENT ON
unanimously carried, the Commission BEHALF OF THE MANAGEMENT CONSORTIUM
authorizated the signing of the
petition for the tax abatement on
behalf of The Management
Consortium.
-14-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
b. continued...
Mr. Beitzinger read the staff report
on the project. The Management
Consortium proposes to build a 4 -
story, 150 room, full service hotel on
approximately 4.5 acres of land in
the Blackthom Corporate Office Park
area. Each unit will feature a
separate parlor and bedroom with 2
TV's, a VCR, computer data ports,
stocked mini -bar, refrigerator and
microwave. The hotel, which will
overlook the 18th hole of the
Blackthorn Golf Course, will feature
a restaurant with cocktail area,
indoor pool, fitness center, business
center, conference facilities, spa
suites, full room service and courtesy
vans between Michiana Regional
Transportation Center and the hotel.
The total cost of construction is
estimated at $10,000,000.
It is estimated that this project will
result in the creation of fifty three
(53) new permanent jobs within the
first year, representing a new annual
payroll of $1,062,500.
The Management Consortium has not
been granted any previous tax
abatement. The property is properly
zoned for the proposed use. The
property is not located in an area
presently designated as a Tax
-15-
®South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
b. continued...
Abatement Impact Area, but is
located in the Airport Economic
Development Area, which is a Tax
Incremental Financing Allocation
Area; therefore, the petition first
requires the approval of the South
Bend Redevelopment Commission.
A review of the Tax Abatement
Ordinance finds that the petitioner's
use of the property is not an eligible
use for tax abatement purposes;
however, the petitioner is respectfully
requesting a special consideration of
a 10 year real property tax
abatement. The petitioner has
indicated that the tax abatement is an
integral and necessary part of the
project.
The tax abatement will assist in the
cash flow needs of the hotel,
especially during the startup years.
Once up and running, the hotel will
be a catalyst for the area. As future
projects are completed and the area
becomes further developed, the
hotel's utilization will increase
proportionately. Additionally, the
Blackthorn Golf Course will work to
benefit the hotel and the hotel will
work to benefit the golf course.
Weekend packages will be offered
with discount rooms and discount
rounds of golf. Lastly, the hotel will
be a complete full service hotel
offering the latest in amenities. This
-16-
®South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
b. continued...
greatly increases the cost and thus the
risk for the developers. Without the
ten year tax abatement the project
simply cannot move forward;
therefore, the petitioner is
respectfully requesting the special
consideration of a ten year real
property tax abatement. The staff
recommends the Commission to
approve this recommendation.
There have been other tax abatements
previously granted for hotels:
Marriott Hotel, Inn America, Old
Lathe Works and the East Race Inn
A review of the cost of the abatement
shows that, without abatement, the
project will generate approximately
$5,040,400 in new taxes over the ten
year period. With abatement, the
project will generate approximately
$2,545,402. Therefore, the cost of
the abatement is approximately
$2,494,998 over the ten year period.
Upon a motion by Mr. Hcjnacki,
seconded by Mr. Hunt and
unanimously carried the Commission
approved Resolution No. 1412
approving the application for real
property tax deduction for property
located at 5820 West R Jay Nimtz
Parkway in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (The
Management Consortium)
�1
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 1412
APPROVING THE APPLICATION FOR REAL
PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 5820 WEST F. JAY NIMTZ PARKWAY
IN THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.
(THE MANAGEMENT CONSORTIUM)
-17-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINESS (Cont.)
C. Commission approval requested for
Proposal from Peirce and
Associates for Professional
Services in the Sample -Ewing
Development Area. (Ivy Tech)
Mrs. Kolata noted that we need to
provide to Ivy Tech an Indiana Land
Title survey for the entire parcel that
the Commission will be selling to Ivy
Tech. Peirce and Associates has
submitted a proposal to do the survey
and to provide the Commission a
copy of the survey drawing and they
will stake and flag all corners of the
property. The work will be
performed at a cost not to exceed
$1250.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda,
seconded by Mr. Hojnacki and
unanimously approved, the
Commission approved the proposal
from Peirce and Associates for
Professional Services in the Sample -
Ewing Development Area.
COMMISSION APPROVED THE PROPOSAL FROM
PEIRCE AND ASSOCIATES FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES IN THE SAMPLE -EWING DEVELOPMENT
AREA
d. Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 1413 accepting the
transfer of real property from the
City of South Bend, Indiana.
Mrs. Kolata explained that Resolution
No. 1413 accepts the transfer of
property at 505 W. Washington from
the City of South Bend.
-18-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSEWSS (Cont.)
d. continued...
Upon a motion by Mr. Hunt,
seconded by Mr. Hojnacki and
unanimously carried the Commission
approved Resolution No. 1413
accepting the transfer of meal property
from the City of South Bend,
Indiana.
e. Commission authorization
requested for use of the Palais
Royale Ballroom and the Morris
Civic Plaza by Michiana Arts &
Sciences Council on May 16 -20,
1996 for Carnival of the Arts.
Mrs. Kolata explained that Michiana
Arts and Sciences Council has asked
to use the Palais Royale Ballroom
and the Morris Civic Plaza, on May
16 -20, 1996 for Carnival of Arts.
The building commissioner and the
fire department inspected the
building. There are a number of
items that need to be repaired before
using the building. Michiana Arts
& Sciences Council has agreed to
pick up the cost for the repairs and
provide us with a Certificate of
Insurance. The staff recommends
approving this request, subject to
MASC assuming all costs to meet
health and safety codes, making any
repairs on teh plaza for damage
caused by Carnival, and subject to
the Certificate of Insurance naming
the City, Commission, and Authoirty
as additional insured. Ms. Manier
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
RESOLUTION NO. 1413 ACCEPTING THE TRANSFER
OF REAL PROPERTY FROM THE CITY OF SOUTH
BEND, INDIANA
-19-
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSINFSS (Cont.)
e. continued...
suggested that an Agreement be
written that outlines all MASC's
responsibilities and that this
agreement come back to the
Commission for approval.
Upon a motion by Mr. Hcjnacki,
seconded by Mr. Hunt and
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the request for the use of
Palais Royale Ballroom and the
Morris Civic Plaza by Michiana Arts
& Sciences Council on May 16 -20,
1996 for Carnival of the Arts, subject
to the items listed by staff and
requiring a written Agreement to
come back to the Commission for
approval.
f. Commission approval requested for
Proposal from Pitcock Design
Group for Professional Services in
the Airport Economic Development
Area.
Mrs. Kolata noted that we're asking
the Commission to approve the
Proposal for Pitcock Design Group to
take the Blackthorn Golf Course ad
they prepared for the Notre Dame
Program and adapt it to the copy
needed for the February issue of
Midwest Real Estate News that will
highlight Indiana. Pitcock will
incorporate Blackthorn Corporate
Park into the ad. The cost would be
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR THE
USE OF PALAIS ROYALE BALLROOM AND THE
MORRIS CIVIC PLAZA BY MICHIANA ARTS &
SCIENCES COUNCIL ON MAY 16 -20, 1996 FOR
CARNIVAL OF THE ARTS, SUBJECT TO THE ITEMS
LISTED BY STAFF AND REQUIRING A WRITTEN
AGREEMENT TO COME BACK TO THE COMMISSION
FOR APPROVAL
-20-
- , " y a
®South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
6. NEW BUSEWSS (Cont.)
f. continued...
$1200. The ad will be coordinated
with the Project Future ad in the
same issue.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda,
seconded by Mr. Hunt and
unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the proposal from Pitcock
Design Group for Professional
Services in the Airport Economic
Development Area.
g. Commission approval requested for
Contract Amendment from The
Troyer Group for Professional
Services in the Sample -Ewing
Development Area.
Mrs. Kolata explained that The
Troyer Group has a contract to
provide general planning services as
well as project management
assistance related to our house move
program. The project has required
additional time and we are requesting
that the contract be amended to add
$15,000.
Upon a motion by Mr. Hcjnacki,
seconded Mr. Hunt and unanimously
carried, the Commission approved
the Contract Amendment from the
Troyer Group for Professional
Services in the Sample -Ewing
Development Area.
COMMISSION APPROVED THE PROPOSAL FROM
PITCOCK DESIGN GROUP FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES IN THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT AREA
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CONTRACT
AMENDMENT FROM THE TROYER GROUP FOR
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES IN THE SAMPLE -EWING
DEVELOPMENT AREA
-21-
q "!
M
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting - January 19, 1996
7. PROGRESS REPORTS
Mr. Wolf noted that National Main
Street Center wants to feature South
Bend as one of the four successful
programs in the United States. The
four programs will be featured in the
Spring issue.
Also, Adams Remco had their grand
opening downtown. They are a
local company and one of the largest
copier dealers in the United States.
8. NEXT COMNUSSION MEETING
The next meeting of the Redevelopment
Commission is scheduled for February 2,
1996 at 10:00 a.m.
9. ADJOURNNUENT
There being no further business to come
before the Redevelopment Commission,
Mr. Hunt made a motion that the meeting
be adjourned. Mr. Hojnacki seconded the
motion and the meeting was adjourned at
10:40 a.m.
Paula N. Auburn, President
-22-
NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
ADJOURNMENT
Ann E. Kolata, Director