HomeMy WebLinkAboutVPA Presentation Q1 2018Venues Parks
& Arts
February 13, 2018, Q1
Current Projects
•Online Learning Platform
•Discovery on Recreation/Special Event
Management software
•CAPRA Reaccreditation
•Recreation Reporting/KPIs Portal
Program Audit Update
•Dashboard Updates
•We revised the questions in order to make responses
feel less vague and open ended
•Still missing 2 Recreation staff members updated
responses
Program Audit Next Steps
•Determine the current lifecycle stage of each
program using the program audit data and
evaluations
•Does it have rapid growth or it is matured/saturated?
•Once we understand a program’s lifecycle stage,
then we can make decisions on the division’s
program portfolio
•Once the portfolio is set, we can decide on
strategic goals per program
Facilities & Grounds
Our Services
•Park System
•Mowing/Trimming
•Snow Removal
•Trash Removal
•Equipment/Shelter Repair
•Tree Maintenance
•Restroom Cleaning
•Trail Maintenance
•Leaf Removal
•Landscaping
•Downtown and Smart Street Maintenance
•Snow Removal
•Trash Removal
•Equipment/Shelter Repair
•Mowing/Trimming (Parks+Islands)
•Tree Maintenance
•Landscaping
•East Race Maintenance/Operations
•Trash Removal
•Snow Removal
•Mowing
•Trail Maintenance
•Restroom Cleaning
•Landscaping
•Cemetery Operations and Maintenance
•Mower Repair Shop
•Painting
•Security and Fire Safety
•Morris and Palais Facility Maintenance
•Golf Course Maintenance
•Mowing/Trimming
•Equipment Repair
•Storm Damage Removal
•Leaf Removal
•Four Winds Field
•Snow Removal
•Mowing/Trimming
•Trash Pick Up
•Swimming Pool Maintenance and Operations
•Athletic Field Maintenance
•Tennis Courts
•Basketball Courts
•Soccer Fields
•Football Fields
•Byers Softball Complex
•Park Facility Renovations
•HVAC Systems Repair and Maintenance
•Plumbing Repair and Maintenance
•Electrical Repair and Maintenance
•Greenhouse Operations and Tree Planting
•Tree Violation Enforcement
•Graffiti Abatement
Services Focus:
Grounds Maintenance
and Central Mowing
Grounds Maintenance &
Central Mowing
•3 Supervisors
•Entire Park System
•Downtown + Smart Streets
•Central Mowing (DCI + Code Enforcement lots)
•Over 70 Years Experience
•Many operations are not documented and completed based on personal knowledge
•Reason for Focus:
•1 supervisor eligible to retire this year
•We are concerned about a knowledge vacuum
Subconscious
Operations
Park Grounds Maintenance
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify what
equipment is
available
Verify Weather Rained out?
Check Special
Events Calendar
Enough Staff?
No
All equipment
ready?
Review special
projects and misc
tasks to assign
No
Yes Yes
Yes
Assign work
based on type of
staff (union vs PT)
Snow?No
Snow
Management
Yes
No
Give daily list of
jobs to staff
Review incident
notes from day
before
Determine which
regular
maintenance job
is impacted
Special Event
today?
Yes
No
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
Park Grounds Maintenance –
Key Takeaways
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify what
equipment is
available
Verify Weather Rained out?
Check Special
Events Calendar
Enough Staff?
No
All equipment
ready?
Review special
projects and misc
tasks to assign
No
Yes Yes
Yes
Assign work
based on type of
staff (union vs PT)
Snow?No
Snow
Management
Yes
No
Give daily list of
jobs to staff
Review incident
notes from day
before
Determine which
regular
maintenance job
is impacted
Special Event
today?
Yes
No
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
“What won’t we get
done today?”
Central Mowing
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
Give Crews
Property List
Rained out?Enough staff?
(min 2/crew)
Enough
Mowers?
Call/Text All Staff
to call off work
Verify Weather
Run report for
Code lots
Accela
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify Equipment
Availability
Yes
No
Yes
Assign Special
Project Tasks
Coordinate
Back-up
Mowers
Yes
Check recordings
for issues from
day before
Sort for oldest
due and
totals by area
Assign crews to
area based on
density
Create lists for
crew by area then
street
Note Priority
Lots/Complaints
Enough Staff
with Driver’s
License?
No
No
Yes
No
Central Mowing –Key Takeaways
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
Give Crews
Property List
Rained out?Enough staff?
(min 2/crew)
Enough
Mowers?
Call/Text All Staff
to call off work
Verify Weather
Run report for
Code lots
Accela
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify Equipment
Availability
Yes
No
Yes
Assign Special
Project Tasks
Coordinate
Back-up
Mowers
Yes
Check recordings
for issues from
day before
Sort for oldest
due and
totals by area
Assign crews to
area based on
density
Create lists for
crew by area then
street
Note Priority
Lots/Complaints
Enough Staff
with Driver’s
License?
No
No
Yes
No
Downtown + Smart Streets
Grounds Maintenance
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify what
equipment is
available
Verify Weather Rained out?Enough Staff?All equipment
ready?
Review special
projects and misc
tasks to assign
Yes
Yes
Review notes of
issues from day
before to assign
No
Coordinate
Back-up
Equipment
Give List of Jobs to
staff
Assign
maintenance
work
Determine Day of
Week
Prioritize Morris
Plaza and East
Race Walkways
Snow?
Snow
Managemnet
Yes
Meet Staff at
Downtown
locations
Yes
No
Downtown + Smart Streets
Grounds Maintenance –Key
Takeaways
Supervisor, Assigning Daily Operations
Verify Staffing
Levels
Verify what
equipment is
available
Verify Weather Rained out?Enough Staff?All equipment
ready?
Review special
projects and misc
tasks to assign
Yes
Yes
Review notes of
issues from day
before to assign
No
Coordinate
Back-up
Equipment
Give List of Jobs to
staff
Assign
maintenance
work
Determine Day of
Week
Prioritize Morris
Plaza and East
Race Walkways
Snow?
Snow
Managemnet
Yes
Meet Staff at
Downtown
locations
Yes
No
Process Pain Points
•Across the 3 supervisors, they share similar pain
points
•Weather
•Inconsistent Staffing Levels
•Equipment Failure
•Data entry from paper work orders/reporting
•Incidents: 311 requests, vandalism, etc
•Supervisors spend time monitoring crew’s work and
discovering incidents to assign the next day
•Unexpected special event or project requests
Pain Point Project
Proposals
Pain Point: Equipment Failure
Problem:
•Equipment failure prevents regular operations from
being done
•There’s data on downtime, maintenance, and usage
hours but in many places
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr; Mower Shop
Mechanic Labor
Issue Amount ~ 3 failures/week
Process Time Unknown
Pain Point:
Paper Work Order Data Entry
•Problem: Supervisors use paper for staff to
capture completed work, then enter the jobs into
a spreadsheet
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr
Issue Amount Over 500 entries in peak season
Process Time ~15 hrs/week (beyond standard 40)
Project Proposal #1
•Mower Shop Work Order Management in SharePoint
•Discover Mower Shop work order process
•Discover necessary equipment data points
•Elimination of paper work order through digital form(s)
•Centralized data repository on Mower Shop equipment
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Mechanic Labor
Issue Amount 3 Failures/Week
Process Time Unknown; 15hr/week
data entry
Future State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Mechanic Labor
Issue Amount 3 Failures/Week
Process Time Discovered Process;
10hr/week data entry
Pain Point: Park System Incidents
and Special Event Requests
•Problem: Incidents and unexpected special
events interrupt regular operations by diverting
labor and delaying maintenance
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Part-time staff $10-13/hr
Issue Amount ~350 311 Requests since 2016;
~1400hrs towards Special Events in
2017
Process Time Unknown
Project Proposal #2
•Community Beautification Team
•Create a small team that manages the 311 requests,
and is assigned special event set up/tear down
•Resources already available: Graffiti Abatement Crew
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Part-time staff $13/hr
Issue Amount 350 311 Requests
since 2016;
~360 Special Event
Work Orders 2017
Process Time Unknown
Future State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Part-time staff $13/hr
Issue Amount 20% Decrease in 311
Requests;
No change in special
event requests
Process Time Discovered
Pain Point: Code Enforcement
Lot Mowing
•Problem: Abating tall grass violations can take
anywhere from 10 –30 days and many don’t
need to be cut because the owner resolves them
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Seasonal staff $10-13/hr
Issue ~4,500 Cut By Owner
Amount ~3,000 Cut Lots
Process Time ~22mins/Lot
~1hr to assign work
~17days to cut
Project Proposal #3
•Code Enforcement Mowing Process Deep Dive
•Determine how the supervisor schedules and assigns abatements
and identify areas of improvement
•Find where managing “Cut By Owner” Properties can be predicted
•Gather average time for each step in the field and identify areas of
improvement
Current State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Seasonal staff $10-
13/hr
Issue ~4,500 Cut By
Owner
Amount ~3,000 Cut Lots
Process Time ~22mins/Lot
~1hr to assign work
~17days to cut
Future State
Money Supervisor $44/hr;
Seasonal staff $10-
13/hr
Issue ~3,000
Amount ~3,000 Cut Lots
Process Time ~15mins/Lot
~30min to assign work
~10 days to cut
Celebrating Our Values
Celebrating Our Values
Indiana Park and Recreation
Association Conference Awards:
•Creative Event Award for
Best. Week. Ever
•Inclusion Program of
Excellence Award for
My South Bend Parks and
Trails