HomeMy WebLinkAbout11132018 Board of Public Works MeetingAGENDA REVIEW SESSION NO'VEMBER 8.2018 340
facts were different, he would not recommend rescinding, noting bidders regret is different. Mr.
Mueller asked if this is in the Responsible Bidder Ordinance language. Attorney Clara
McDaniels stated this is just a scrivener's error and oversight on their part. Mr. Gilot added if
this was a pattern of habit, it would be different, and he is comfortable with this. Mr. Mueller
asked if the bidder is okay with the disqualification„ and does the Board have that in writing. Mr.
Schmidt stated they are fine with it and have provided that on their letterhead.
- Award Bid — Three Twenty at the Cascades — Glazed Assemblies
Ms. Sue Ellen Doudrick, Engineering, requested the Board table this item, noting they need more
time.
- Dedicated Improvements Agreement — KRG Eddy Street Land II, LLC
Ms. Doudrick stated as part of previous discussions with the Board, Kite needed to meet
requirements of the Board and she has received all of the items requested including the
performance bond. She added it took a while to come up with agreement because the city doesn't
have a lot of these situations. Mr. Gilot asked in the event of other projects, will they be able to
reuse this. Ms. Doudrick stated they will.
- Change Order — Erskine Clubhouse Renovation
Mr. Kyle Silveus, Engineering, stated this Change Order is for removing the intermediate
completion date due to running into some lead in the clubhouse that will need to be removed. He
noted the final completion date will not change.
- Professional Services Agreement — Forum Architects, LLC
Mr. Silveus stated this is for design of the O'Brien Center fitness center expansion.
- Memorandum of Understanding — Oaklawn Psychiatric Center
Ms. Fritzberg stated this is a donation for opioid addiction recovery coaching funded by 21"
Century CURE grant. She noted this will provide immediate counseling to those in need rather
than waiting for an appointment.
- Memorandum of Understanding — St. Joseph county Health Department
Ms. Fritzberg stated this donation is for support for the purchase and distribution of lead paint
analyzers and cleaning kits to be provided to the public.
- Professional Services Agreement — Zach Hurst
Mr. Mueller explained this is for a part-time consultant for Redevelopment to assist with
engineering services.
No other business came before the Board. Upon a motion by Mr. Gilot, seconded by Ms.
Maradik and carried, the meeting adjourned at 11:30 a.m.
BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS
Gary . Gilot, President
Elizabeth A, Maradik, Member
Therese J. Dor 'Member
F7 y"
Suzanna M. 1'rtzlaerg,l ember
James A. Mueller, Member
ATTEST:
Fida M. Martin, Cleik
REGULAR MEETING NOV'EMBER 13 2018
The Regular Meeting of the Board of Public Works was convened at 9:35 a.m. on Tuesday,
November 13, 2018,.by Board President Gary, A. Gilot, with Board Members 'Therese Dorau,
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBERU 2018 341
Suzanna Fritzberg, and Elizabeth Maradik present. Board Member James Mueller was absent.
Also present was Board Attorney Clara McDaniels.
APPROVE MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Minutes of the
Agenda Review Session, Regular Meeting and Claims Review Meetings of the Board held on
October 18, October 23, October 30, and November 6, 2018, were approved.
OPENING OF BIDS — 2018 DEMOLITIONS — PROJECT NO. 118-307 COIT
This was the date set for receiving and opening of sealed bids for the above referenced project.
The Clerk tendered proof of publication of Notice in the South Bend Tribune, which was found
to be sufficient. The following bids were opened and publicly read:
INDIANA EARTH INC
10343 McKinley Highway
Osceola, IN 46561
Bid was signed by: Keith Stevens
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
Five percent (5%) Bid Bond was submitted
BID -
Division A Total
$129,180.00
Division B Total
$144,955.00
Division C Total
$128,500.00
Total Bid (Sum Division A — C)
$402,635.00
Asbestos Abatement iJnit Prir.ino
Item No.
Unit Pricing if Required
Unit
Add Per Unit
Price
I.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Linear Feet
$25.00
Duct Tape Material Containin Asbestos
—__._
II.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
$22.00
Duct Wrap Material Containing Asbestos
Feet
IIL
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
$4.50
Floor Tile and Mastic Material
Feet
_
Containing Asbestos
N,
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
$17.00
Plaster Material Containing Asbestos
Feet
V.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
Corrugated Sheet Material Containing
Feet
Asbestos
VI.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
$17.00
Attic Insulation Material Containing
Feet
Asbestos
VII.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square
$7.00
Transite Siding Material Containing
Feet
Asbestos
RITSCHARD BROS., INC
1204 W. Sample Street
South Bend, IN 46619
Bid was signed by: Rachelle Dolniak
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
Five percent (5%) Bid Bond was submitted
BID:
Division A Total $98,635.00
Division B Total $134,529.00
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 342
Division C Total
$86,594.00
Total Bid (Sum Division A — C) $319,758.00
Asbestos Abatement Unit Pricing
Item No,
Unit Pricing if Required
Unit
Add Per Unit
Price
L
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Linear Feet
$25.00
Duct Tape Material Containing
Asbestos
II.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$21.00
Duct Wrap Material Containing
Asbestos
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
i Square Feet
$5.00
Floor Tile and Mastic Material
Containing Asbestos
IV.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$18.00
Plaster Material Containin Asbestos
V.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$7.50
Corrugated Sheet Material Containing
Asbestos
VI.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$18.00
Attic Insulation Material Containing
Asbestos
VII.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$8.00
Transite Siding Material Containing
Asbestos
R&R DXCAVA:I'INC 'INC.
2010 Went Avenue
Mishawaka, IN 46545
Bid was signed by: William Loudin
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
Five percent (5%) Bid Bond was submitted
on A Total
$205"'"0on
B Total01,100.00on
p
C Total
$232900.00Bid
(Sum Division A — C)
$739,380.00
Asbestos Abatement Unit Pricing
Item No.
Unit Pricing if Required
Unit
Add Per Unit
Price
I.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Linear Feet
$30.00
Duct Tape Material Containing
Asbestos
II.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$30.00
Duct Wrap Material Containing
Asbestos
III.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$10.00
Floor Tile and Mastic Material
Containin ) Asbestos
IV.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$20.00
Plaster Material Conta:inin x, Asbestos
V.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$10.00
Corrugated Sheet Material Containing
Asbestos
VI.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$20.00
Attic Insulation Material Containing
Asbestos
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 343
VII.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$10.00
Transite Siding Material Containing
Asbestos
_J
JW CONCRETE/EXCAVATION
1617 3`d Street
Osceola, IN 46561
Bid was signed by: John Ward
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
Five percent (5%) Bid Security Check was submitted
BID:
Division A Total
$88,000.00
Division B Total
$122,715.00
Division C Total
$79,225.00
Total Bid Sum Division A — C)
-$289,940.00
Asbestos Ahntement T Tnit Pricinnv
Item No.
Unit Pricing if Required
Unit
Add Per Unit
Price
I.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Linear Feet
$14.00
Duct Tape Material Containing
Asbestos
II.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$18.00
Duct Wrap Material Containing
Asbestos
IIL
Removal, Management, and Disposal of g p
Square Feet
$9.25
Floor Tile and Mastic Material
Containing Asbestos
IV.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$22.00
Plaster Material Containing Asbestos
V.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
'Square Feet
$9.00
Corrugated Sheet Material Containing
Asbestos
VI.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$24.00
Attic Insulation Material Containing
Asbestos
VII.
Removal, Management, and Disposal of
Square Feet
$11.00
Transite Siding Material Containing
Asbestos
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above bids were
referred to Engineering and Code Enforcement for review and recommendation.
OPENING OF QUOTATIONS — OLIVE PRODUCTION WELL NO. 6 REHABILITATION —
PROJECT NO. 118-102 (WATER WORKS OPERATIONS & MAINTENANCE)
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed quotations for
the above referenced project. The following quotations were opened and read:
PEERLESS MIDWEST INC.
55860 Russell Industrial Parkway
Mishawaka, IN 46545
Quotation was submitted by Frank Williams
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $50,930.00
OUTMAN DRILLING, INC.
241 N. 300 W.
Kokomo, IN 46901
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 344
Quotation was submitted by Deanna Ortman
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $72,571
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above quotations
were referred to Engineering for review and recommendation.
OPENING OF UOTATIONS — EDISON PRODUCTIONWELL NO, 2A
REHABILITATION — PROJECT NO. 118-103 (WATER WORKS OPERATIONS ,&
MAINTENANCE
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed quotations for
the above referenced project. The following quotations were opened and read:
PEERLESS MIDWEST INC.
55860 Russell Industrial Parkway
Mishawaka, IN 46545
Quotation was submitted by Frank Williams
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $49,991.00
ORTMAN DRILLI1w1G INC.
241 N. 300 W.
Kokomo, IN 46901
Quotation was submitted by Deanna Ortman
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $73,075
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above quotations
were referred to Engineering for review and recommendation.
OPENING OF QUOTATIONS -- FOUR WINDS FIELD LANDSCAPING (COVE NON -
REVERTING FUNDI
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed quotations for
the above referenced project. The following quotations were opened and read:
ACORN LANDSCAPING LLC;
3680 W. Sample Street
South Bend, IN 46619
Quotation was submitted by Jeff Ritschard
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $44,207.55
DOUGLAS LANDSCAPE, INC'
23590 Ardmore Trail
South Bend, IN 46628
Quotation was submitted by Douglas Pittman
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $53,127.60
FOEGLEY" LANDSCAPE INC
52215 North Lilac Road
South Bend, IN 46628
Quotation was submitted by Jonathan Guard
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $32,955.00
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBEII 13 2018 345
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above quotations
were referred to Venues, Parks, and Arts for review and recommendation.
OPENING OF QUOTATIONS - MORRIS THEATER MEZZANINE HANDRAILS -
PROJECT NO. 118-081 (MORRIS CAPITALj
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed quotations for
the above referenced project. The Clerk of the Board stated there were no quotations received.
OPENING OF QUOTATIONS -- ENGINEERING OFFICE IMPROVEMENTS BIRLDING
MAINTENANCE AND REPAIRS).
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed quotations for
the above referenced project. The following quotations were opened and read:
GIBSON-LE WIS, LLC
1001 W. 1I"' Street
Mishawaka, IN 46544
Quotation was submitted by Robert Lingenfelter
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $20,091
ZIOLKOWSKI CONSTRUCTION INC..
4050 Ralph Jones Drive
South Bend, IN 46628
Quotation was submitted by Bill Favors
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $7,800
PREMIER I CONSTRUCTION INC
105 E. Jefferson Blvd.
South Bend, IN 46601
Quotation was submitted by Alan Lusk
Non -Collusion, Non -Discrimination Affidavit Form was completed
QUOTATION: $17,700
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above quotations
were referred to Engineering and Central Services for review and recommendation.
OPENING OF PROPOSALS - INDOT SCHOOL ZONE FLASHING BEACON
ASSEMBLIES - PROJECT NO. 117-075 (MAJOR MOVES).
Mr. Gilot advised that this was the date set for the receiving and opening of sealed proposals for
the above referenced project. Mr. Gilot stated the proposals will be reviewed and scored based
on a matrix system, by a review team. He read the name of the following company submitting a
proposal:
TROYER GROUP
550 Union Street
Mishawaka, IN 46544
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above proposal
was referred to the review team for review and recommendation.
Ms. Kara Boyles, Engineering, informed the Board that one of the engineers, Scott Kreeger,
received an email at 10:00 a.m. this morning from Mark Herald with VS Engineering, Inc.,
showing that UPS had attempted to deliver his proposal on Monday, November 12. The Board
noted that City offices were closed due to Veteran's Day, Ms. Boyles stated UPS will try again
to deliver at 11:30 this morning and she requested the Board's approval to accept the proposal.
Mr. Gilot noted this was a proposal to be reviewed and scored based on a scoring matrix,
therefore there is no advantage gained by submitting the proposal after the name of the other
company was read. He noted if this was a bid, it would not be accepted, but there are no amounts
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13, 2018 346
read into the record on proposals. Therefore, Mr. Gilot made a motion to reconsider the Board's
earlier motion and accept two (2) proposals. Ms. Maradik seconded the motion, which carried.
The Board read the name of the following additional company submitting the proposal, from a
copy of the email sent to Mr. Kreeger:
VS ENGINEERING, INC.
10305-A Dawson's Creek Blvd.
Fort Wayne, IN 46825
RESCIND BID AWARD —ONE 1 OR MOI�E 2018 OR NEWER, COMPACT TRACK
LOADER — SPEC U
In a memo to the Board, Mr. Jeff Hudak, Central Services, requested the Board approve his
request to rescind the award of the above bid from October 9, 2018 to Hull Lift Truck, Inc.,
28747 Old US 33, Elkhart, IN 46516. Mr. Hudak stated Hull incorrectly transferred a number
from the manufacturers invoice to the City's bid sheet and the error resulted in a base bid nearly
50% lower than the competition and clearly incorrect. Mr. Hudak stated upon notice of the
award, Hull immediately contacted Central Services and explained the error and asked that its
bid be disqualified. He noted Central Services reviewed the entire bid and was able to easily
recognize the error simply by looking at the paperwork submitted in Hull's bid. He added no
other bidder will be prejudiced through the disqualification of Hull's bid. Mr. Michael Schmidt,
Purchasing, stated he was incorrect when the Board questioned him at the previous meeting on
whether there was a bid bond. He noted he based his answer that there was not on Statute
requirement, which would not require a bid bond. He stated the standard bid specs have a line in
them requiring a bid bond. Attorney MCDaniels stated this is clearly a scrivener's error, not
buyer's remorse. Mr. Gilot agreed and clarified this is a very narrow instance, this does not set a
policy for this Board. Therefore, upon a motion by Ms. Maradik seconded by Ms. Dorau and
carried, the Board approved the request to rescind the award and the contract as requested.
AWARD BID - TWO (2). MORE OR LESS. 2018 OR NEWER SINGLE AXLI DUMP
TRUCK -SPEC X SE`WER DEPARTMENT CAPITAT.
Mr. Jeff Hudak, Central Services, advised the Board that on October 23, 2018, bids were
received and opened for the above referenced equipment. After reviewing those bids, Mr. Hudak
recommended that the Board award the contract to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder
Selking international, 4849 W. Western Avenue, South Bend, IN 46619, in the amount of
$159,308 each for the base bid plus alternates 1, 2, and 4 for a total of $318,616 for two (2).
Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a motion that the recommendation be accepted and the bid be
awarded as outlined above. Ms. Fritzberg seconded the motion, which carried.
AWARD BID — ONE (1) Olt tvi'ORE 2018 OR NEWER„ COMPACT TRACK LOADER —
SPEC U (STREET DEPAR°I"MFN
Mr. Jeff Hudak, Central Services, advised the Board that on September 25, 2018, bids were
received and opened for the above referenced equipment. After reviewing those bids, Mr. Hudak
recommended that the Board award the contract to the second lowest responsive and responsible
bidder Hardings, Inc., 109 W. Commercial Avenue, Lowell, IN 46356 in the amount of $89,140
including all alternates, back up camera and trade-in discount. Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a
motion that the recommendations be accepted and the bid be awarded as outlined above, Ms.
Fritzberg seconded the motion, which carried,
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO REJECT BIDS — VENUES, PARKS AND ARTS
RESTROOM REMODELING -- PpOJECT NO. 118-043
In a memorandum to the Board, Mr. Scott Kreeger, Engineering, requested permission to reject
all bids for the above referenced project due to exceeding the budget. Therefore, upon a motion
made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above request was approved.
AWARD ouarATTON — R A" TIF"it EMERGENCY REPAIRS FOR CENTURY CENTER
BROKEN STORM LINE i�'L.00DING 1NS1.fRANCE FUND.
Mr. Roger Nawrot submitted two (2) quotes for emergency repairs done due to a burst pipe at
Century Center.
a) Company: Bob Frame, Inc., 2442 Jaclyn Ct, South Bend, IN 46614
(1) Amount: $10,344.96
b) Company: First Response Disaster Restoration Specialists, 1919 S
Michigan St., South Bend, IN 46613
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 347
(1) Amount: $5,590.93
Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a motion that the emergency quotations be awarded as outlined
above. Ms. Dorau seconded the motion, which carried.
AWARD PROPOSAL — CITY OF SOUTH BEND BRANDED APPAREL AND
ACCESSORIES
In a memorandum to the Board, Mr. Patrick Sherman, VPA, stated proposals were received for
the above apparel and accessories by the Board on October 23, 2018. Mr. Sherman stated after
review, the team is requesting the Board's approval to award the proposal to the highest overall
scoring vendor, The Dugout Sporting Goods, 3222 Lincolnway West, South Bend, IN 46628.
Upon a motion by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Board approved the
request to award the proposal.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 3 — DOWNTOWN CROSS STREET IMPROVEMENTS —
PROJECT NO, 117-041A RWDA 7
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Toy Villa, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 3 on behalf
of Walsh & Kelly, Inc., 24358 State Road 23, South Bend, IN 46614, indicating the contract
amount be increased by $786 for a new contract sum, including this Change Order, in the amount
of $1,671,938.60. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the
Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 6 — DOWNTOWN CROSS STREET IMPROVEMENTS —
PROJECT NO. 117-041A (RWDA TIF)
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Roger Nawrot, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 6 on
behalf of Walsh & Kelly, Inc., 24358 State Road 23, South Bend, IN 46614, indicating the
contract amount be increased by thirteen (13) days, for a new contract project completion date of
November 16, 2018. Mr. Nawrot noted there was no change to the dollar amount. Upon a motion
made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 3 — SAFE ROUTES TO SCHOOL: MONROE PRIMARY
AND STUDEBAKER ELEMENTARY -- PROJECT NO. 116-039 (FEDERAL/CITY'1
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Roger Nawrot, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 3 on
behalf of Indiana Department of Transportation, 315 Boyd Blvd., LaPorte, IN 46350, indicating
the contract amount be increased by $15,289.92 plus an additional seven (7) days for a new
contract sum, including this Change Order, in the amount of $1,951,731.71 and a new project
completion date of September 28, 2018. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms.
Dorau and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO, 2 — VENUES. PARKS AND ARTS MAINTENANCE
STORAGE BUILDING — PROJECT NO. 118-046R (PARK BOND SERIES 1)
Mr. Gilot advised that Ms. Alicia Czarnecki, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 2 on
behalf of The Robert Henry Corporation, 404 S. Frances St., South Bend, IN 46614, indicating
the contract amount be decreased by $20 for a new contract sum, including this Change Order, in
the amount of $348,954. She noted the dollar amount was due to the addition of new work and
the removal of existing work in the contract. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Dorau and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE. CHANCE. ORDER NO. 1 - H_ OWARD PARK REDEVELOPMENT AND ST
LOUIS BLVD. IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT NO. 117-047B PARK
BOND/RETIF/REGIONAL CITIES & CUMI )L.ATIVE CAPITAL
Mr. Gilot advised that Roger Nawrot, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 1 on behalf
of Larson Danielson Construction Company, Inc., 302 Tyler St., LaPorte, IN 46350, indicating
the contract amount be decreased by $843,275, plus an additional thirty (30) days, for a new
contract sum, including this Change Order, in the amount of $17,976,032 and a new completion
date of December 15, 2019. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and
carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 — RUM VILLAGE DOG PARK CONSTRUCTION
(2015 PARK BONDI
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Patrick Sherman, VPA, has submitted Change Order No. 2 on behalf
of R. Yoder Construction, Inc., 27453 CR 150, Nappanee, IN 46550, indicating the contract
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 348
amount be increased by $13,077,31 for a new contract sum, including this Change Order, in the
amount of $143,257.31. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and
carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. I WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT
HEADWORKS GATE IMPROVEMENTS - PROJECT NO. 117-026 CUTILITIFS
WASTEWATER CAPITAL)
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Jacob Klosinski, Utilities, has submitted Change Order No. 1 on
behalf of HRP Construction, Inc., 5777 Cleveland Road, South Bend, IN 46624, indicating the
contract amount be decreased by $351,345.56 plus an additional twenty (20) days, for a new
contract sum, including this Change Order, in the amount of $615,154.44 and a new project
completion date of November 16, 2018. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms.
Dorau and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 1 - ERSKINE CLUBHOUSE RENOVATION - PROJECT
NO. 116-108' CGOLF OPERATIONa)
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Kyle Silveus, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. I on
behalf of .Ziolkowsk:i Construction, Inc., 4050 Ralph Jones Drive, South Bend, IN 46628, to
eliminate Intermediate Phase I completion date of November 30, 2018. He noted there is no
change in final completion date or contract amount. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik,
seconded by Ms. Doran and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 - ERSKINE CLUBHOUSE RENOVATION -- PROJECT
NO. H6-108(GOLF OPERATIONS
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Kyle Silveus, Engineering, has submitted Change Order No. 2 on
behalf of Ciolkowski Construction, Inc., 4050 Ralph Jones Drive, South Bend, IN 46628,
indicating the contract amount be increased by $7,899 for a new contract sung, including this
Change Order, in the amount of $914,899. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Dorau and carried, the Change Order was approved.
APPROVE CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 FINAL AND PROJECT" COMPLETION AFFIDAVIT
DOWNTOWN BRIDGE STRIPING - PROJECT NO. 117-12'LRSA/LANE MARKINGS
& LRSA/S'.I'REET MAIN°I"FNANCEI
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Toy Villa, Engineering has submitted Change Order No. 2 (Final) on
behalf of The Airmarking Co., Inc., 1544 N. State Road 25, Rochester, IN 46975 indicating the
contract amount be decreased by $445.05 for a new contract sum, including this Change Order,
of $86,357.15. Additionally submitted was the Project Completion Affidavit indicating this new
final cost of $86,357.15. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and
carried, Change Order No. 2 (Final) and the Project Completion Affidavit were approved.
APPROVE PROJECT CC)11PLETTON AFFIDAVIT MISIIAWAKA AVENUE ROTO
ROOT"ER JE'"1'TER REMOVAL - PI.OJECT NO. l 18 069R :aE'WER CAPITAL
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Toy Villa, Engineering, has submitted the Project Completion
Affidavit on behalf of Selge Construction Co., I2833 S. 11 « Street, Niles, MI 49120, for the
above referenced project, indicating a final cast of $72,307. Upon a motion made by Ms.
Maradik, seconded by Ms. Doran and carried, the Project Completion Affidavit was approved.
APPROVE PROJECT COMPLETION AFF"1DAV1T - FLIR TRAFFIC CAMERA
REPLACEMENTS PROJECT NO. 118-006 `LRSA
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Toy Villa, Engineering, has submitted the Project Completion
Affidavit on behalf of Pemberton Davis Electric, I916 E. McKinley Ave., Mishawaka, IN
46545 for the above referenced project, indicating a final cost of $123,866.10. Upon a motion
made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Project Completion Affidavit
was approved.
APPROVE PROJECT COMPLETION AFl"CIJAVIT - FI,1R TRAFFIC CAMERAS,.
DIVISIONS A BAND C - IaROJECT N0. 117-122 LRSA
Mr. Gilot advised that Mr. Toy Villa, Engineering, has submitted the Project Completion
Affidavit on behalf of Pemberton Davis Electric, I9l6 E. McKinley Ave., Mishawaka, IN
46545 for the above referenced project, indicating a final cost of $l l 1,848. Upon a motion made
by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Project Completion Affidavit was
approved.
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 349
APPROVE REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS — SALE OF
ABANDONED VEHICLES
Ms. Kathy Eli, Department of Code Enforcement, requested permission to advertise for the sale
of approximately twenty (20) abandoned vehicles, which are being stored at Super Auto Salvage
Corporation, 201 West Sherwood, South Bend, Indiana. It was noted that all vehicles have been
stored more than fifteen (15) days, identification checks have been run for auto theft, and the
owners and lienholders notified. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau,
and carried, the above request was approved.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS AND TITLE
SHEET — MAIN AND COLFAX PARKING STRUCTURE REPAIRS 2019 — PROJECT NO.
11 5-043A (PARKING GARAGE FUND/RWDA TIF)
In a memorandum to the Board, Mr. Roger Nawrot, Engineering, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of bids for the above referenced project. Also presented at this time for
approval and execution was the Title Sheet. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Dorau and carried, the above request to advertise was approved, and the Title Sheet was
approved and signed.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST'I'0 ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS AND TITLE
SHEET — MCKINLEY AVENUE AND FREMONT PARK IMPROVEMENTS — PROJECT
NO. 11.8-072 (LRSA/UTILITY EXPENSE/CONTRACTUAL SERVICES)
In a memorandum to the Board, Ms. Alicia Czarnecki, Engineering, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of bids for the above referenced project. Also presented at this time for
approval and execution was the Title Sheet. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Dorau and carried, the above request to advertise was approved, and the Title Sheet was
approved and signed.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS AND TITLE
SHEET — SMALL DRAINAGE DESIGN AND REPAIR — PROJECT NO. 118-063 (LRSA)
In a memorandum to the Board, Ms. Sue Ellen Doudrick, Engineering, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of bids for the above referenced project. Also presented at this time for
approval and execution was the Title Sheet. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Dorau and carried, the above request to advertise was approved, and the Title Sheet was
approved and signed.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS AND TITLE
SHEET — WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT ADMINISTRATION BUILDNG
MASONRY IMPROVEMENTS — PROJECT NO. 118-087 (SEWAGE WORKS
OPERATIONS, BUILDING REPAIRS & MAINTENANCE')
In a memorandum to the Board, Ms. Sue Ellen Doudrick, Engineering, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of bids for the above referenced project. Also presented at this time for
approval and execution was the Title Sheet. Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by
Ms. Doran and carried, the above request to advertise was approved, and the Title Sheet was
approved and signed.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF BIDS — SEWER AND
MANHOLE REHABILITATION - PROJECT NO. 118-093 (UTILITY
EXPENSEXONTRACTUAL SERVICE)
In a memorandum to the Board, Ms. Sue Ellen Doudrick, Engineering, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of bids for the above referenced project. Therefore, upon a motion made
by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Doran and carried, the above request was approved.
APPROVAL OF REQUEST TO ADVERTISE FOR THE RECEIPT OF PROPOSALS
POLICE VEHICLE DECAL DESIGN AND APPLICATION (POLICE DEPARTMENT)
In a memorandum to the Board, Mr. Tim Lancaster, Police Department, requested permission to
advertise for the receipt of proposals for the above referenced decal design and application.
Therefore, upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the above
request was approved.
ADOPT RESOLUTION NO, 58-2018 — A RESOLUTION OF THE SOUTH BEND INDIANA
BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS ON DISPOSAL OF UNFIT AND/OR OBSOLETE PROPERTY
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 350
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the following
Resolution was adopted by the Board of Public Works:
RESOLUTION NO.58-2018
A RESOLUTION OF THE SOUTH BEND INDIANA BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS
ON DISPOSAL OF UNFIT AND/OR OBSOLETE PROPERTY
WHEREAS, it has been determined by the Board of Public Works that the following property is unfit for
the purpose for which it was intended and is no longer needed by the City of South Bend:
Various Machinery, Equipment, Computers, Electronics, Software Licenses, Furniture and Fixtures
(SEE LIST)
WHEREAS, pursuant to Indiana Code § 36-4-6-1 et. seq., the Board of Public Works ("Board")
has the duty and authority to have custody, control, use, and to dispose of all real and personal property
owned by the City of South Bend, Indiana; and
WHEREAS, the City, acting by and through the Board, desires to dispose of the personal
property that is more particularly described at Exhibit 'A" attached hereto and incorporated herein
("Property"); and
WHEREAS, in accordance with Indiana Code § 5-22-22-4, the Board may engage an auctioneer
to conduct a public auction in order to dispose of the City's surplus personal property if the property to be
sold is one (1) i`tern with an estimated total value of $1,000 or more, or is more than one (1) item with an
estimated value of $5,000 or less; and
WHEREAS, the Board has determined that the Property has an estimated value of more than
$5,000,and the Board has further determined that the property is unfit for the purpose for which it was
intended, and is no longer needed by the City of South Bend; and
NOW, THEREFORE, the Board of Public Works of the City of South Bend hereby finds that the
Property listed at Exhibit 'A" is no longer needed by the City; the Property is unfit for the purpose for
which it was intended, and has an estimated value of $5,000 or less.
BE IT RESOLVED that the Property may be transferred or sold at public auction. However, if
the Property is deemed to be worthless, such Property may be demolished or junked.
ADOPTED the 13TH day of NOVEMBER, 2018.
CITY OF SOUTH BEND
BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS
s/ Gary A. Gilot
s/ Elizabeth A. Maradik
s/ Therese J. Dorau
s/ Suzanna M. Fritzberg
ATTEST:
s/Linda M. Martin, Clerk
APPROVAL OF AGREEMENTSICONTRACTS/PROPOSALS/ADDENDA
The following Agreements/Contracts/Proposals/Addenda were submitted to the Board for
Type
Business
Description
Amount/
Motion/
;aroval:
Fundin
Second
orandum
Oaklawn
Donation to fund Addiction
$25,000
Maradik/Dorau
Psychiatric
Recovery Coaching
(COIT)
Understanding
Center
Certification and Services
at Beacon Emergency
Room and Other
Community Sites
Contract
Department of
Extend Free Wi-Fi
$300,000
Maradik/Dorau
Innovation
Accessibility to Low-
(CDBG)
Moderate Income
Neighborhoods via
Community Centers
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 351
Consulting
EnFocus, Inc.
2018-2019 EnFocus
$28,000
Dorau/Fritzberg
Agreement
Fellowship Program
(DCI
Mr. Gilot
Professional
Abstained
Services)
Dedicated
KRG Eddy
Eddy Street Commons
Maradik/Dorau
Improvements
Street Land II,
Phase II
Agreement and
LLC
Title Sheet
BOARD MEMBER EXCUSED
Ms. Fritzberg left the meeting at 10:07 a.m.
Agreement
Community
Community Investment
$15,000 to
Maradik/D
Homebuyers
Staff Services for
City
Corporation
administering Community
(Department
Homebuyers Corporation
Admin Fund
Homeownership
211)
Assistance Program
Agreement
Urban
Community Investment
$40,000 to
Maradik/Dorau
Enterprise
Staff Services related to
City
Association of
administering Urban
(Department
South Bend,
Enterprise Association's
Admin Fund
Inc.
Various Programs and
211)
Services
Fifth
Urban
Revise End Date of Vacant
$105,498.81
Maradik/Dorau
Addendum to
Enterprise
and Abandoned Property
(EDIT)
Agreement
Association of
Repair Matching Grant
South Bend,
Agreement from December
Inc.
31, 2018 to November 13,
2018
Professional
United Way of
Increase Number of
$100,000
Maradik/Dorau
Services
St. Joseph
Designated "High Quality"
(COIT)
Agreement
County
Pre-K Providers in South
Bend for Early Childhood
Education Provider
Capacity Grant Program
Amendment
Abonmarche
Additional Survey and
$92,800;
Maradik/Dorau
No. 2 to
Consultants,
Design Work for St. Louis
New Total
Professional
Inc.
Blvd. Festival Street
$265,400
Services
(Park Bond
Agreement
Series D)
Memorandum
St. Joseph
Lead Paint Analyzer
$26,516
Maradik/Dorau
of
County Health
Donation
(EDIT)
Understanding
Department
Professional
Huii and
General Environmental
$30,000
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Associates, Inc.
Consulting Services
(Studebaker
Agreement
Oliver
Grants)
Professional
The Troyer
Update Century Center
NTE $14,700
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Group
Exterior Landscape
(Hotel/Motel
A reement
Tax)
Amendment
Earth
Additional Design Work
NTE $600;
Maradik/Dorau
No. 2 to
Exploration,
for Howard Park
New Total
Professional
Inc.
Renovation
$13,169.50
Services
(REDA TIF)
Agreement
Professional
Lochmueller
Construction Inspection
NTE
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Group, Inc.
Services for Howard Park
$520,200
Agreement
Redevelo ment
(Fund 407
Professional
WBK
Design Services for
NTE $48,500
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Engineering,
Venues, Parks and Arts
(VPA
Agreement
LLC
Athletic Court Renovations
Capital)
REGULAR MEETING NO'VEMB:ER 13, 2018 352
Professional
DLZ Indiana,
...........
Design Services for
NTE $61,200
MaradikJDorau
Services
LLC
Pinhook Park
(Park Bond
Agreement
Improvements Project
Series H)
Agreement for
CM Buck and
Integration/Programming
$13,433
Maradik/Dorau
Goods and
Associates, Inc.
of New LED Lighting to
(Hotel/Motel
Services
dba Associated
Century Center River
Tax)
Controls and
Lights
Design
Professional
American
_
Renewable Fuel Standard
NTE $21,450
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Structurepoint,
Registration Assistance
(Utilities,
Agreement
Inc.
Sewage
Works/
Wastewater,
En ineerin )
Professional
Mpinsky LLC
Explore Capacity and
$40,000
Maradik/Dorau
Services
d/b/a Five/Four
Ability to Implement
(DCI
Agreement
Advisors
Community Development
Professional
Finance Strategy Friendly
Services)
Model in South Bend
Professional
Forum
O'Brien Recreation Center
$33,750
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Architects, LLC
Renovation
(SSDA TIF)
Agreement
Amendment to
Jones Petrie
EPA Required Offsite
NTE
Maradik/Dorau
Professional
Rafinski
Waste Delineation,
$291,000
Services
Groundwater Investigation
(Professional
Agreement
and Solid Disposal/SMP
Services
Implementation for CBRC
EPA)
for Beck's Lake Project
Amendment to
Richard T.
Manage Remedial
NTE
Maradik/Dorau
Professional
Brown/Veritas,
Investigation and
$300,000;
Services
LLC
Feasibility Study for
$100/Hour
Agreement
LaSalle Park Area of
(Professional
Beck's Lake Site and
Services
Assist City and City Legal
I EPA)
Team with EPA
Deliverables and Analysis
Projects
Agreement
Anthem Blue
Administer Self -Funded
Stop Loss
Maradik/Dorau
Cross and Blue
Medical Insurance for City
Premium:
Shield
Employees for 2019
$589,162.56;
Calendar Year
Medical
Administra-
tion Costs:
$793,879.80;
Prescription;
Varies
(Health
Insurance
Fund)
Agreement
Accordware,
Assist City with IRS
$1.25/Per
Maradik/Dorau
LLC
Reporting Obligations
1095-C
pursuant to Patient
Form,
Protection and Affordable
$1.00/Per
Care Act
Employee
Reporting
Fee, $1,250
Base Fee
(Health
Insurance
Fund
�AendmetAc=ivate
Employee Clinic Contract
$27.21/
Maradik/Dorau
1 to
Hecare,
Renewal for 2019 Calendar
Member)
REGULAR MEETING NOVEMBER 13 2018 353
Professional
LLC
Year
Month;
Services
Estimated
Agreement
Total Cost
$964,308
(Health
Insurance
_
Fund
Network
US Signal
Renewal of Connectivity
$2,520/
Maradik/Dorau
Master
Company,
Services to provide
Month for
Agreement
L.L.C.
Communications between
Thirty -Six
Remote Water Production
(36) Months;
Sites and SCADA
Total
Environment for Real-
$30,240
Time Control and
(Utilities
Monitoring of Water
O&M)
Systems
Professional
Zach Hurst
Engineering Consultant
$35.00/Hour;
Maradik/Dorau
Services
Services for Development
NTE $36,000
Agreement
Agreements
(TIF; Subject
to RDC
_AP roval)
Licensing
Azteca
Cityworks Enterprise
$60,000
Maradik/Dorau
Agreement
Systems, LLC
License Upgrade
(IT
Operations)
APPROVAL OF PERMIT AND LICENSE APPLICATIONS
The following, permit and license applications were presented for approval:.
Applicant
Description
Date/Time
Location/Comments
Motion
Carried
Downtown
Procession -
December 14,
On route as submitted
Maradik/Dorau
South Bend
DTSB Holiday
2018; 6:00 p.m.
Light Parade
to 7:45 p.m.
St. Joseph
Procession -
January 18,
On route as submitted
Maradik/Dorau
County Right to
March for Life
2019;11:30 a.m.
Life
and Rally
to 12:15 p.m.
St. Joseph
Procession - St.
December 1,
On route as submitted
Maradik/Dorau
Parish
Nick 6K Race
2018; 8:00 a.m.
to 11:00 a.m.
UNFAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION - PETITION TO VACATE THE NORTH
WEST/SOUTH EAST ALLEY EAST OF N. CUSHING ST. AND NORTH OF VAN BUREN
ST.
Mr. Gilot indicated that Ned Green, 723 Van Buren St., South Bend, IN 46616, has submitted a
request to vacate the above referenced alley. Mr. Gilot advised the Board is in receipt of
favorable recommendations concerning this Vacation Petition from the Fire Department and
Street Department. Mr. Gilot advised the Board is in receipt of unfavorable recommendations
concerning this Vacation Petition from Community Investment and Engineering who both stated
the vacation would make access to the lands of the aggrieved person by means of public way
difficult or inconvenient and would hinder the use of a public right-of-way by the neighborhood
in which it is located or to which it is contiguous. Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a motion for an
unfavorable recommendation for the request for vacation. Ms. Doran seconded the motion which
carried.
FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION - PETITION TO VACATE THE NORTH/SOUTH
ALLEY NORTH OF BRYAN ST., SOUTH OF CULVER ST., TO FIRST EAST/WEST
ALLEY
Mr. Gilot indicated that Willie Rogers, 1033 W. Bryan St., South Bend, IN 46616, has submitted
a request to vacate the above referenced alley. Mr. Gilot advised the Board is in receipt of
favorable recommendations concerning this Vacation Petition from the Area Plan Commission,
Streets, Community Investment and Engineering. Mr. Gilot advised the Fire Department states
the vacation would make access to the lands of the aggrieved person by means of public way
difficult or inconvenient, noting the water supply for structure fires is at the cross alley. Mr. Gilot
REGULAR MEETING N0VLN4BERjj 20j8 354
stated Community Investment recommends approval of the vacation with notification to the
petitioner that the vacated condition will result in a split of the 14' right-of-way with the
petitioner acquiring only half, a space that may not be sufficient for driveway access or vehicle
parking, the reason for the vacation request. The Board recommended that the petitioner be
notified that they will need a Cross Access Agreement with their neighbors to use the vacated
alley for a driveway. Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a motion recommending approval of the
request for vacation. Ms. Dorau seconded the motion which carried.
APPROVE TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICES
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the following traffic
control device requests were approved:
NEW INSTALLATION: Handicapped Accessible Parking Space Sign
LOCATIONS: 842 S. Albert Ave,
1711 Kendall St.
REMARKS: All criteria has been met
DENY TRAFFIC CONTROL DEVICE
Upon a motion made by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Duran and carried, the following traffic
control device request was denied:
NEW INSTALLATION: Handicapped Accessible Parking Space Sign
LOCATION: 3619 Pleasant St.
REMARKS: All criteria has not been met
APPROVE CONSENTS TO ANNEXATION AND WAIVER OF RIGHTS TO
REMONSTRATE
Mr. Gilot stated that the Board is in receipt of the following Consents to Annexation and
Waivers of Right to Remonstrate. The Consents indicate that in consideration for permission to
tap into public water/sarritary sewer system of the City, to provide water/sanitary sewer service
to the below referenced properties, the applicants waive and release any and all rights to
remonstrate against or oppose any pending or future annexations of the properties by the City of
South Bend:
A. William and Mary Kotinek, 19170 Stone Ridge Drive, South Bend, IN 46637
1. 51648 Audubon Woods Drive— Water (Key No, 002-1003-005747)
B. Allen Edwin Homes, 2186 E. Centre Avenue, Portage, MI 49002
1. 53127 Flowing Stream Court — Water/Sewer (Key No. 021-1037-059157)
Upon a motion by Ms. Maradik, seconded by Ms. Dorau and carried, the Consents to Annexation
and Waivers of Right to Remonstrate were approved as submitted,
RATIFY APPROVAT. AVID/OR PUT EASE CONTRACTOR,
'rNXT-rn A I- FOR, EXCAVATION, AND
UU,JJPANC Y BONDS
Ms. Donna Hanson, Division of Engineering, recommended that the following bonds be ratified
rsuant to Resolution 100-2000 and/or released as follows t
Business
Bond Type
Approved/ Released
Effective Date
Larson -Danielson Construction Co,, Inc
Contractor
Approved
October 29, 2018
M&J Concrete
Contractor
October 10, 2018
Beach House LLC
Excavation
_Approved
Apmoved
October 25, 2018
Braille Corn an T T C'
Approved
October 2, 2018
Sam Mar Tree
OccManc
y
�X roved
—
September 18, 2018
Ms. Maradik made a motion that the bond's approval and/or release as outlined above be ratified.
Ms. Dorau seconded the motion, which carried.
APPROVE CLAIMS
Ms. Maradik stated that request to pay the following claims in the amounts indicated has been
received by the Board; each claim is fully supported by an invoice; the person receiving the
goods or services has approved the claims; and the claims have been filed with the City Fiscal
Officer and certified for accuracy.
REGULAR MEETING NOV EMBER H 2018 355
Name
Amount of Claim
Date
Ci of South Bend
....___
$242,019.76
10/31/2018
City of South Bend
$2,388.61
11/06/2018
City of South Bend
$1,311,515.79
11/13/2018
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium
$14,757.04
$453.35
11/02/2018
11/02/2018
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium
$31,112.25
11/02/2018
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium
$60,000
11/0212018
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium
St. Jose h County Housing G nsortium
St. Joseph County Housing Consortium_
$60,000
$60,000
$5,504
11/02/2018
11/02/2018
11/08/202018
U.S. Bank National Association/Eddy St. Phase II
Project/Re uisition No. 6
$614,830.93
11/13/2018
U.S. Bank National Association/Charles Black Center
& Rum Village Dog Park/ Requisition No. 93
$64,647.88
11/07/2018
U.S. Bank National Association/Midwest
Meter/Invoice No. 105-909-IN
$155,798.06
11/07/2018
Therefore, Ms. Maradik made a motion that after review of the expenditures, the claims be
approved as submitted. Ms. Dorau seconded the motion, which carried.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR
Ms. Kara Boyles, City Engineer, informed the Board that she is in receipt of an email from the
President of C&E Excavating, Inc., Mr. Thad Bessinger, informing her that his company will no
longer bid on city projects due to the passage of the Responsible Bidder Ordinance. She
explained Mr. Bessinger stated it is not in the best interest of his company to provide certified
payrolls per APRA requests to the City by the local unions. Mr. Bessinger explained giving wage
information to his competitors far outweighs any potential benefit, noting once wages are
established, it's simple math to figure out material and sub costs and gain a competitive
advantage on bids. Ms. Boyles added Mr. Bessinger noted they pride themselves in being able to
offer their customers a great value with top notch work quality.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the Board, upon a motion made by Mr. Gilot,
seconded by Ms. Maradik and carried, the meeting adjourned at 10:33 a.m.
BOARD OF PUBLIC -WORKS
a�'c�I
Gary A. Gilot, Pre detrt
Elizabeth A. Maradik, Member
Therese J. Do. a.u, Member
Suzanna M. Fritzberg, Member
James A. Mueller, Member
ATTEST:
, .
`Undo M aMaMin, Cler
k _. _ .._ .