HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-24-12 Redevelopment Commission Minutes SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
April 24, 2012
4:00 p.m. 227 West Jefferson Boulevard
Presiding: Marcia I. Jones, President South Bend, Indiana
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present: Ms. Marcia Jones, President
Dr. David Varner, Vice President
Mr. Donald Alford, Secretary
Mr. Greg Downes
Mr. Henry Davis
Members Absent: Ms. Stephanie Spivey
Legal Counsel: Ms. Andrea Beachkofsky
Redevelopment Staff Mr. Don Inks, Director
Mrs. Cheryl Phipps, Recording Secretary
Mr. David Relos, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Jitin Kain, Senior CED Specialist
Ms. Debrah Jennings, Property Manager
Others Present: Ms. Beth Leonard Inks, Community & Economic
Development
Ms. Patti Lesniewicz, Economic Development
Ms. Kathy Hahn, Economic Development
Mr. Shawn Strohman
Mr. Marco Mariani
Mr. Pat Lynch
Mr. Dan Smogor
Ms. Mo Miller
Mr. Mike Morris, Owner, R2 Diagnostics, Inc.
Mr. Jeff McGowan,
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Approval of Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
Tuesday, April 10, 2012.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr. COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission REGULAR MEETING OF TUESDAY,APRIL 10,
approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of 2012.
Tuesday, April 10, 2012.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted April 24, 2012 for approval.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr. Alford COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS
and unanimously carried, the Commission approved the SUBMITTED APRIL 24,2012,AND ORDERED THE
Claims submitted April 24, 2012, and ordered checks to CHECKS TO BE RELEASED
be released.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
There were no Communications. THERE WERE NO COMMUNICATIONS
5. OLD BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) Agreement for Sale of Land for Private
Development (502 W. Western Ave.
(former Harmon Glass).
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION TABLED THE AGREEMENT FOR
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the SALE OF LAND FOR PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT
Commission tabled the Agreement for Sale (502 W.WESTERN AVE.(FORMER HARMON
of Land for Private Development (502 W. GLASS).
Western Ave. (former Harmon Glass).
B. West Washington-Chapin Development Area
(1) Resolution No. 3016 accepting the transfer
of real property from South Bend
Heritage Foundation, Inc.
Mr. Relos noted that on November 22, 2011,
the Commission and South Bend Heritage,
Inc. (SBHF) entered into a Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU), for the substantial
renovation of the Hansel Center, located at
1045 W. Washington St.
2
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
The MOU calls for the transfer from SBHF
to the Commission of the Hansel Center, at
such time as the use of WWCDA funds are
needed to carry forward renovations. This
past Tuesday, April 3rd, 2012, the Board of
Public Works awarded the Hansel Center
project contract to Gibson Lewis, and we are
now at the point in the renovation process
where transfer of the property will soon be
needed.
Upon approval of this resolution, a quit claim
deed will be prepared so formal transfer from
SBHF to the Commission can occur. Once
the Commission's responsibilities under the
MOU are completed, staff will present
another resolution to transfer the property
back to SBHF, so their final responsibilities
may be met.
At the last Redevelopment Commission
meeting, the resolution was presented subject
to legal review. That review is now
complete. The property was going through a
period of lead paint remediation. The on-site
remediation is now complete and the
property is being transferred to the
Commission in a remediated state. The
remediated window trim, subject to the
remediation, will be reinstalled after the
property is transferred back to South Bend
Heritage to allow seamless construction lines
that includes the installation of new
windows. There's also some brick tuck-
pointing work that will occur around the
windows. It made sense that once the
window trim was removed to wait until the
new windows got reinstalled and the tuck-
pointing got done, thereby not possibly
injuring the window trim that was subject to
remediation getting repainted and put back
up.
3
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3016 to allow the acceptance of this property
from SBHF and to fulfill its obligations
under the MOU.
Ms. Beachkofsky noted that this was still
under legal review.
Mr. Inks noted that Aladeen and Mr.
Nussbaum were going back and forth and
Aladeen is satisfied with this being put back
on the record.
Ms. Beachkofsky asked Mr. Relos to read the
following letter for the record. (Regarding
South Bend Heritage Foundation (SBHF) —
Hansel Center Environmental Remediation.
(CDBG Contract#CD-09-8148))
Mr. Relos read:
To Whom It May Concern:
This letter is to confirm that Bill Ricker
Remodeling (SBHF Contractor per
aforementioned contract) has properly
removed the window brick mold trim and
window sashes per the specified lead
abatement process. Moreover, it is the
understanding of SBHF that the on-site
remediation/removal activity is complete. As
specified, the remediated window materials
will be reinstalled by Bill Ricker Remodeling
upon notification from the City of South
Bend and Gibson-Lewis, Inc. that"Part A" of
the project is complete. SBHF also
understands that it remains fully liable for
completion of the aforementioned
remediation activity and for any claims
arising from its workmanship.
4
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
If you have any questions or require
additional information, please contact me.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Marco Mariani
Executive Director
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3016
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the ACCEPTING THE TRANSFER OF REAL PROPERTY
Commission approved Resolution No. 3016 FROM SOUTH BEND HERITAGE FOUNDATION,
INC.
accepting the transfer of real property from
South Bend Heritage Foundation, Inc.
Mr. Relos thanked the Commission and
noted that it's great to see an old historic
building repurposed on the West-Washington
Neighborhood.
Ms. Jones and Mr. Varner asked for timeline
clarifications. Mr. Inks noted today it is
being transferred to the Redevelopment
Commission. The City has already bid the
work and that work will be completed. Then
the property will be transferred back to
SBHF, where the balance of the work will be
done.
Mr. Shawn Strohman, of Varner
Construction Management Company,
Sacramento, California, noted the City is
issuing notice to proceed to Gibson Lewis
tomorrow, April 25, 2012. Construction will
begin on Monday, April 30, 2012. Mr.
Strohman will retrieve information from the
contractor's master schedule and relay the
information to Mr. Relos. His guess is this
portion of the work will run through late
summer. At that time, the ownership will be
transferred back, with final project
completion anticipated as late November.
5
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Mr. Varner asked for clarification as to
Varner's involvement. Mr. Relos noted that
Varner was a major donor to the project.
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. Tax Abatements
(1) Resolution No. 3031 approving an
application for personal property tax
deduction for property located at 1801
Commerce Drive in the Airport Economic
Development Area (R2 Diagnostics, Inc.).
Ms. Hahn noted that R2 Diagnostics, Inc.,
which she'll refer to as R2D, manufacturers
and sells clot based diagnostic kits that test
for bleeding and clotting disorders. R213
uses proteins from Enzyme Research
Laboratories (ERL)to insure the highest
quality final products with no lot-to-lot
variation. ERL is the primary supplier of
coagulation and fibrinolytic proteins for the
research community. The Company's
products are distributed worldwide to
researchers and pharmaceutical companies to
aid in the development of novel therapeutic
compounds and assays to diagnose and treat
coagulation/hemostatis disorders. R213
intends to purchase equipment in the amount
of$459,500 to complement current
equipment in order to support client demands
and higher volume.
Two of the tax key numbers are in Portage
Township and two of the tax key numbers
are in German Township. Using tax rates for
Portage Township results in $18,317 of tax
being abated and using tax rates for German
Township results in $18,421 of tax abated.
Total taxes to be paid using Portage
6
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Township tax rates during a five-year
abatement period are estimated at $28,964.
Per the petition, it is estimated that the total
project will create at least two new
permanent full-time jobs in the first year of
production representing a new annual payroll
of at least $65,000. The project will maintain
fifteen existing permanent full-time jobs and
one part-time job with a total annual payroll
of$800,000.
Ms. Hahn introduced Mr. Jeff McGowan,
CPA, R2 Diagnostics, Inc. for any questions
the Commission may have.
Mr. McGowan noted that there are 15
employees versus the 50 Ms. Hahn
mentioned. Ms. Hahn misspoke. Also, he
mentioned that the company has been a good
tax-payer throughout the last five years and
they've paid approximately $205,000 in real
property taxes. Enzyme Research
Laboratories has paid about $44,000 in
personal property tax and R2 has paid about
$3,500. Once the tax abatement is complete,
they estimate that the $460,000 equipment
that they're going to put into service, the
abatement would roughly add about $5,000
to the tax roles on an annual basis. He
offered a copy of what the specific
equipment is and also introduced Mr. Mike
Morris, owner, R2 Diagnostics to discuss his
business.
Mr. Varner recalled when ERL was on
Lafayette Street then moved to Commerce
Drive. Is R2 a separate business entirely?
Mr. Morris noted that it is a separate
company.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3031
APPROVING AN APPLICATION FOR PERSONAL
7
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the PROPERTY TAX DEDUCTION FOR PROPERTY
Commission approved Resolution No. 3031 LOCATED AT 1801 COMMERCE DRIVE IN THE
approving an application for personal AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA(R2
property tax deduction for property located at DIAGNOSTICS,INC. .
1801 Commerce Drive in the Airport
Economic Development Area (R2
Diagnostics, Inc.).
B. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) Ratify Certificate of Completion for East
Bank South Bend Development, LLC
(East Bank Townhomes).
Mr. Relos noted that the original site
presented with the contract for sale, showed
the six town homes have now been
constructed. There is room to do two more
on the southern end. Mr. Matthews was sure
those should be town homes or perhaps a
commercial development so the actual Phase
I of the project that was approved was the six
town homes. Mr. Matthew has met the
requirements.
Ms. Jones asked if the town homes were all
occupied. Mr. Relos said that they were all
sold. Mr. Downes noted and encouraged a
tour; it's an incredible project. Mr. Varner
noted there was significantly more
investment than what was originally
estimated so the property taxes will be more
than originally estimated.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION RATIFIED THE CERTIFICATE OF
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the COMPLETION FOR EAST BANK SOUTH BEND
Commission ratified the Certificate of DEVELOPMENT,LLC(EAST BANK
Completion for East Bank South Bend TOWNHOMES).
Development, LLC (East Bank Townhomes).
(2) Staff report on disposition of 609 E.
Columbia.
8
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Mr. Relos noted the request to proceed
regarding the proposed sale of 609 E.
Columbia, in the Monroe Park
Neighborhood.
On June 28, 2011, the Commission approved
bid specs, fair-market valuation, and
advertising of legal notices to begin the
disposition process for five properties in the
Monroe Park neighborhood. This property's
fair market valuation, based on the average
of two disposition appraisals, is $15,500.
On July 26, 2011, staff reported that no bids
had been received on any of the properties,
and they would then be able to be sold at a
negotiated price. On September 27, 2011,
the Commission approved a contract with
Bruce Gordon to list and market four of the
five properties.
On November 22, 2011, the Commission
rejected a $5,000 offer on this property, and
instead approved a counter offer in the
amount of$10,000. This price was accepted
by the interested party, and a purchase
agreement submitted. The interested party,
who lives in the neighborhood and purchased
two other properties, has let the purchase
agreement expire with no further action.
Recently, another party has submitted an
offer. This person would live in the house,
which is the goal of the Commission for
these houses to encourage owner occupants.
The offer was for $5,000. With guidance
from Mr. Gordon, staff recommends that the
Commission counter with a price of$8,000
and set this value as the lowest price it would
accept for this property.
9
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Ms. Beachkofsky noted that legal would like
to approve this as long as sale is as is where
it's been marked subject to that.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED DISPOSITION OF 609 E.
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the COLUMBIA SUBJECT TO LEGAL REVIEW FOR
Commission approved disposition of 609 E. FINAL APPROVAL.
Columbia subject to legal review for final
approval.
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) Facade Easement Agreement with Data
Realty.
Mr. Kain noted first updated the Commission
on the construction at Ignition Park.
Construction is in full swing with 30-40% of
the overall project complete. The streets
have been graded, utilities have gone in and
at the same time, Data Realty has broken
ground and hope to be open by fall this year.
Phase IA should be done by July.
Mr. Kain noted that in July, 2011, the
Commission approved the sale of Lot 4 at
Ignition Park to Data Realty Northern
Indiana LLC which is currently building an
approximately 50,000 sq. ft. data center.
Data Centers are typically built as bunkers,
however, Ignition Park is designed as a high
tech, high aesthetic park. There was a desire
to see the first building designed and built to
architectural standards established for the
park. As part of the contract for sale, the
Commission agreed to provide site
improvements (paving, landscaping, lighting,
etc.)to the Data Realty site equal to the
amount of the facade enhancement work
performed by Data Realty up to an amount of
$1,400,000.
10
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
The Facade design was done by BSA
LifeStructures, the firm responsible for the
Master Plan of Ignition Park. The initial
estimates for the first design came in over
budget so BSA was asked to revise the
Facade design. Earlier this year, a design
was submitted that was estimated to cost
$1,134,980. This design was later approved
by the Architectural Review Committee for
Ignition Park.
A recent estimate of site improvement work
at Data Realty was $400,000 which is
significantly less than the $1,134,980
estimated for the Facade work. Therefore, in
lieu of the site improvements, staff is
proposing the following combination to
fulfill the Commission's commitment
towards the Data Realty project:
1. Facade Improvement: Purchase
metal panels and screen wall
coverings for the approved facade
design in the amount of$747,576. In
order to do this, Data Realty would
grant the Commission a facade
easement for a term of seven years.
2. Equipment Purchase: Purchase
Computer Room Air Handler
(CRAH) units for the data center
portion of the building in the amount
of$387,404. In return, the
Commission would get an additional
five years worth of equipment rack
space at Data Realty. (Currently, the
Commission has the use of five racks
for 15 years, the value of which is
estimated at $1,080,000.)
The total of the two items is $1,134,980
which is equal to the total estimate of the
11
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
facade work and is under the budgeted
amount of$1,400,000 for this project.
Staff requests Commission approval of the
Facade Easement and Amendment to the
Use, Management and Operations agreement.
Mr. Varner asked why Data Realty would
grant the Commission a facade easement for
a term of seven years. Mr. Kain responded
that it was discussed between the attorneys
the fact that seven years was a reasonable
time for the City to own the equipment.
There are design guidelines in place that
would require in order to maintain the panels
and to keep the aesthetics of the park to
certain standards even if we did not own after
seven years, we would still control the way
the building looked.
Mr. Varner asked if the City would control
the facades of everyone in the park. Mr.
Kain expressed that that is not his
understanding moving forward.
Mr. Varner asked what the value of a rack is.
Mr. Inks responded that there is no value
unless they're in use.
Mr. Downes asked if it was the plan to use
the racks. Mr. Inks responded that the plan is
to look for opportunities to use them. Staff
spoke to the City's IT Department and he is
not aware of any great opportunity right now,
but perhaps down the road. In speaking with
other businesses, staff thinks we may be able
to use them as part of our business
development activities.
Mr. Varner misunderstood assuming these
are racks of equipment. Mr. Kain clarified
that these are empty shelves.
12
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Mr. Downes asked for clarification on the
Architectural Review Committee, that
committee because of the PUD, that
committee would in fact have to approve all
design. Mr. Kain answered yes.
Mr. Davis asked who won out the bid for the
construction contract. Mr. Kain responded
that Data Realty bid out their own project
and that Turner Construction is the general
contractor.
Mr. Davis asked if MBE and WBE were part
of the conversation. Mr. Inks responded that
staff did not put those in as requirements in
the agreements but we did have those
conversations. Turner was selected for this
project because of their work on the Kroc
Center and the success they had with the
MBE and the WBE's there.
Mr. Inks asked Mr. Kain to speak about TIF
eligibility as Mr. Metreiver requested. Mr.
Kain noted that there were some questions
raised about the use of TIF dollars inside a
private property especially as it relates to
purchase of equipment inside the building;
air-handling units that support the data
center. Staff confirmed with outside legal,
Mr. Randy Rompola, that this is ineligible
use of TIF money and that the purchase of
the equipment was allowable under the
statute. Mr. Inks noted there were some
revisions to the Use Agreement as a result of
Mr. Rompola's review. Mr. Kain added that
he had a revised agreement. The one change
in the agreement is for the ability for Data
Realty to purchase the equipment back from
the City in seven years. That was not
included in the initial agreement. Mr. Inks
asked if that was subject to going through the
13
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
redevelopment process for this position.
Mr. Davis asked for a list of TIF
requirements on paper on requirements for or
asking for the ability to use TIF dollars to
leverage participation. We use the state
code. Mr. Inks noted that the state code
prevails. In practice, folks are looking for
creative ways to use the funds within the
statute. The other aspect in using TIF, in
terms of how much TIF to put into a
particular project given the benefit is giving
back to the community, we have general
rules of thumb but those are being reviewed.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED FACADE EASEMENT
Mr. Davis and unanimously carried, the AGREEMENT WITH DATA REALTY SUBJECT TO
Commission approved Facade Easement LEGAL REVIEW.
Agreement with Data Realty subject to legal
review.
(2) First Amendment to the Use,
Management, and Operations Agreement
dated November 17, 2011 with Data Realty
Northern Indiana, LLC.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED FIRST AMENDMENT TO
Mr. Davis and unanimously carried, the THE USE,MANAGEMENT,AND OPERATIONS
Commission approved First Amendment to AGREEMENT DATED NOVEMBER 17,2011 WITH
DATA REALTY NORTHERN INDIANA,LLC,
the Use, Management, and Operations SUBJECT TO LEGAL REVIEW.
Agreement dated November 17, 2011 with
Data Realty Northern Indiana, LLC, subject
to legal review.
(3) Resolution No. 3022 related to acquisition
of property in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (1504 S. Kemble)
Mr. Relos noted the acquisition of 1504 S.
Kemble. This property was added to the
Airport Economic Development Area's
Acquisition List by Resolution No. 2668 on
14
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
May 21, 2010. It was added in an effort to
clean and clear the southern boundary of
Ignition Park and to help stabilize the Rum
Village neighborhood to the south. The Rum
Village Neighborhood Association strongly
supports the redevelopment of this area on
the north side of Indiana Avenue.
This particular property is a two story, two
bedroom, 1,174 square foot single family
residence. The property owner would like to
participate in the goals of the Commission to
clean and clear this area and contacted staff
of their interest in selling this property.
Resolution No. 3022 sets the acquisition
value of the property at $18,500. The
acquisition value is the average value as
determined by two independent appraisals.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3022, to allow for the acquisition of this
property.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3022
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
Commission approved Resolution No. 3022 AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.
related to acquisition of property in the (1504 S.KEMBLE)
Airport Economic Development Area. (15 04
S. Kemble)
(4) Resolution No. 3027 related to acquisition
of property in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (721 W. Indiana)
Mr. Relos noted the staff report for the
acquisition of 721 W. Indiana. This property
was added to the Airport Economic
Development Area's Acquisition List by
Resolution No. 2668 on May 21, 2010. It
was added in an effort to clean and clear the
southern boundary of Ignition Park and to
15
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
help stabilize the Rum Village neighborhood
to the south. The Rum Village
Neighborhood Association strongly supports
the redevelopment of this area on the north
side of Indiana Avenue.
This particular property is a large
commercially zoned double lot at the
northeast corner of Kendall and Indiana. The
property owner would like to participate in
the goals of the Commission to clean and
clear this area and contacted staff of their
interest in selling this property.
Resolution No. 3027 sets the acquisition
value of the property at $15,750. The
acquisition value is the average value as
determined by two independent appraisals.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3027, to allow for the acquisition of this
property.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3027
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
Commission approved Resolution No. 3027 AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.(721
related to acquisition of property in the W.INDIANA)
Airport Economic Development Area. (721
W. Indiana)
(5) Resolution No. 3028 related to acquisition
of property in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (913-915 W. Indiana)
Mr. Relos noted the staff report for the
acquisition of 913-915 W. Indiana. This
property was added to the Airport Economic
Development Area's Acquisition List by
Resolution No. 2668 on May 21, 2010. It
was added in an effort to clean and clear the
southern boundary of Ignition Park, and to
help stabilize the Rum Village neighborhood
16
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
to the south. The Rum Village
Neighborhood Association strongly supports
the redevelopment of this area on the north
side of Indiana Avenue.
This particular property is a 3,820 square
foot, one story office/warehouse building.
The property owner would like to participate
in the goals of the Commission to clean and
clear this area and contacted staff of their
interest in selling this property.
Resolution No. 3028 sets the acquisition
value of the property at $21,000. The
acquisition value is the average value as
determined by two independent appraisals.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3028 to allow for the acquisition of this
property.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3028
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN THE
Commission approved Resolution No. 3028 AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.
related to acquisition of property in the (913-915 W.INDIANA)
Airport Economic Development Area. (913-
915 W. Indiana)
(6) Resolution No. 3029 related to acquisition
of property in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (1522 Prairie Ave.)
Mr. Relos noted the staff report for the
acquisition of 1522 Prairie. This property
was added to the Airport Economic
Development Area's Acquisition List by
Resolution No. 2668 on May 21, 2010. It
was added in an effort to clean and clear the
southern boundary of Ignition Park and to
help stabilize the Rum Village neighborhood
to the south. The Rum Village
Neighborhood Association strongly supports
17
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
the redevelopment of this area on the north
side of Indiana Avenue.
This particular property is a 3,200 square
foot, one story warehouse building. The
property owner would like to participate in
the goals of the Commission to clean and
clear this area, and contacted staff of their
interest in selling this property.
Resolution No. 3029 sets the acquisition
value of the property at $28,500. The
acquisition value is the average value as
determined by two independent appraisals.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3029, to allow for the acquisition of this
property.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3029
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the RELATED TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTY IN
Commission approved Resolution No. 3029 THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.
related to acquisition of property in the (1522 PRAIRIE AVE.)
Airport Economic Development Area. (1522
Prairie Ave.)
(7) Resolution No. 3030 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Ignition Park
Phase 1A Infrastructure— Supplement
#1).
Mr. Kain noted Resolution No. 3030 and an
Amendment to the Addendum to Master
Agency Agreement for Ignition Park Phase
1 A Infrastructure.
On October 22, 2011, the Commission
signed an Addendum to the Master Agency
Agreement authorizing the Board of Public
Works to act as its agent and assist with the
18
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
engineering work for Ignition Park Phase 1 A
Infrastructure. As part of this, Engineering
staff authorized BSA LifeStructures to
subcontract with ATC Associates to provide
geotechnical services for Ignition Park. The
geotechnical work includes testing soil in
Ignition Park to understand the strength,
compressibility and other engineering
characteristics of the subsurface material.
This is key information required in planning
any infrastructure project.
This work was completed towards the end of
2011 to assist with the infrastructure
planning at Ignition Park. The proposal from
ATC Associates is for $9,750 and is in
addition to the reimbursable allowance
approved for BSA LifeStructures.
Staff is requesting an amendment to the
contract with BSA LifeStructures in the
amount of$9,750 accomplished through
Resolution No. 3030 and the Amendment to
the Addendum to the Master Agency
Agreement.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3030
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
Commission approved Resolution No. 3030 OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT(IGNITION PARK
approving and authorizing the execution of PHASE IA INFRASTRUCTURE-SUPPLEMENT#1).
an amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Ignition Park
Phase I Infrastructure— Supplement#1).
(8) Resolution No. 3024 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
Amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement
#1).
Mr. Relos noted that he passed out a map
19
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
prior to this meeting explaining what
Supplements #1, #2, and #3 do.
Resolution No. 3024 and Amendment to the
Addendum To Master Agency Agreement for
the Olive Road Right-Of-Way Acquisition -
Supplement#1.
For the last several years, the City of South
Bend has been working with DLZ on design
and plans for the remaining section of Olive
Road improvements between Lincolnway
West/US 20 and Nimtz Parkway. The
roadway plans are about 95% complete and
the staff is finalizing the acquisition of the
necessary right-of-way for this section of
improved roadway. This Supplement #1
specifically deals with Professional Service
work necessary to the design and bidding of
site improvements on the Olive Road Basin,
which is part of the roadway construction
project related to the future Olive Road
improvements.
The City is preparing to bid and construct
improvements to the pond as the work is part
of the acquisition agreement reached between
the City's Board of Public Works and the
Michiana Lutheran Education Association
(MLEA) for the acquisition of right-of-way
property at the southeast corner of Nimtz and
Olive. The improvements contemplated by
the work needed to be done during the
summer session so as not to disrupt the
education activities at the school during the
school year. Supplement#1 deals only with
the design and bidding work necessary for
this project and Supplement#2 will set up a
budget for the construction work to be done
on site.
Mr. Relos noted that these all deal with
20
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Olive Road improvements, north of
Lincolnway to Nimtz Parkway and the
third dealing with the Olive Road
connector south of Lincolnway. A map
was passed out that Mr. Schalliol had done
prior to this meeting that explains what
Supplement #1, #2 and #3 do. Supplement
#1 has to do with the design and plans for
the improvements north of Lincolnway,
basically at the corner of Olive Road and
Nimtz Parkway. As part of the Olive
Road project, there needs to be certain
retention basins along the stretch of road.
This one here, in particular, there's an
existing retention basin in the blue
rectangular area. What this does is
expand on the existing basin to allow
drainage. Right now that basin was built
for a capacity of north of Nimtz/Olive
Road in that area to accommodate
additional water flow into it along the
improved Olive Road. Where the
Supplement #2 box is, there is a hill there,
so this would feed into the basin north of
the hill, thus the road is improved. So
Supplement #1 basically is a contract for
$14,000 to design and plan for that
improved and expanded retention basin.
The second supplement deals with the
actual building, or expanding of the
retention basin as part of the right-of-way
acquisition. Right on the corner there is
the Lutheran Academy, if you will.
Working with them to gain what the green
line there is, is sewer easement that we
needed to get from the academy to run
from the guttering and the catch basin at
the bottom of the hill there to run it into
the new expanded basin. This supplement
#2 basically sets the budget for that work.
The engineers estimate was about
$110,000 and we're asking for not-to-
21
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
exceed of$125,000 to do this work. This
work does need to be done yet this year
before the academy starts their fall term.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3024 and the Amendment to the Addendum
To Master Agency Agreement for the Olive
Road Right-Of-Way Acquisition -
Supplement#1.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3024
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
Commission approved Resolution No. 3024 OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT(OLIVE ROAD
approving and authorizing the execution of RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION-SUPPLEMENT
an Amendment to the Addendum to the #1).
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement#1).
(9) Resolution No. 3025 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
Amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement
#2).
Mr. Relos noted Resolution No. 3025 and
Amendment to the Addendum To Master
Agency Agreement for the Olive Road
Right-Of-Way Acquisition - Supplement#2.
Supplement#1 specifically dealt with
Professional Service work necessary for the
design and bidding of site improvements on
the Olive Road Basin which is part of the
roadway construction project related to the
future Olive Road improvements. The
improvements to the pond and related site
work are part of the acquisition agreement
reached between the City's Board of Public
Works and the Michiana Lutheran Education
Association (MLEA) for the acquisition of
right-of-way property at the southeast corner
22
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
of Nimtz and Olive. The improvements
contemplated by the work needed to be done
during the summer session so as not to
disrupt the education activities at the school
during the school year.
Supplement#2 sets up a budget for the
construction work to be done on site. (A
copy of the project budget and plan were
provided.) The Engineer's Estimate for the
scope of work is $109,975. The goal is to
have the project go to bid in May with all
work be completed on school property before
the start of the fall term.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3025 and the Amendment to the Addendum
To Master Agency Agreement for the Olive
Road Right-Of-Way Acquisition -
Supplement#2 with a not-to-exceed amount
$125,000.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3025
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
Commission approved Resolution No. 3025 OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT(OLIVE ROAD
approving and authorizing the execution of RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION-SUPPLEMENT
an Amendment to the Addendum to the #2).
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement#2).
(10) Resolution No. 3026 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
Amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement
#3).
Mr. Relos noted Resolution No. 3026 and
Amendment to the Addendum To Master
Agency Agreement for the Olive Road
Right-Of-Way Acquisition - Supplement#3.
23
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
In 2007, the Board of Public Works entered
into a contract with DLZ to prepare Design
and Right of Way Engineering for
improvements to Olive Road from
Lincolnway West to Nimtz (Phase 1) and
from Edison to Lincolnway West (Phase 2).
The budget for the design of Phase 1 was
$502,900 and the budget for the design of
Phase 2 was $303,750. Due to changes in
work scope, the work on Phase 2 was started
but eventually held for a future point and the
funds that were approved for use were
reprogrammed within the project to be used
for Right-of-Way acquisition services for the
roadway.
The purpose of Supplement#3 is to add
$35,000 to the project budget to complete
some design and right of way engineering for
the section of roadway that connects Olive
Road to Pine Road at the intersection with
Lincolnway West. The St. Joseph County
Airport Authority is underway with
acquisition of a tract of land that would
allow, with the City's purchase of one parcel,
to construct the connector roadway necessary
to link this roadway network. With this work
complete, a continuous roadway corridor can
be developed from Adams Road to Western
Avenue/SR 2. These additional funds will
help finalize plans through the future airport
property and complete some intersection
redesign at Lincolnway West.
Supplement #3—there is some initial
planning just to get Olive Road,which
now runs from Lincolnway up to Brick.
Eventually we'd like to get this corridor all
the way from Western Avenue on the
south, State Road 2, all the way up to
Adams Road which really opens this area
up to a great development area on the west
24
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
side of South Bend. This particular
supplement is for $35,000 adding for us
some redesign work, preliminary redesign
work, south of Lincolnway where it would
come down and eventually tie into Pine
Road that would go into Western Avenue.
Right now the Airport Authority actually
has under contract the main area that this
connector would go through. As an
agreement with the Airport Authority,
there is just one property right at the
corner of Olive and Lincolnway that we
would need to acquire any access, which
seems to be very little, from that would be
granted to the Airport Authority in
exchange for them in order for them to
build the road through the property and
eventually tie into Pine and that would
take us from Western up Pine to Olive and
eventually all the way up to Adams Road.
So Supplement #3 is a $35,000 agreement
just to do some design work primarily at
the intersection.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3026 and the Amendment to the Addendum
To Master Agency Agreement for the Olive
Road Right-Of-Way Acquisition -
Supplement#3.
Mr. Davis asked what the homeowners
were saying on Olive Road. Mr. Relos
responded that most of the right-of-way
has been acquired. Mr. Davis inquired
about the new traffic coming down their
road. Mr. Relos noted that it really only
effects the east side of Olive Road.
Mr. Davis noted his concern for
Supplement #3 due to the change in traffic
patterns heading west and again,
diversions bypassing the City of South
25
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Bend. There are retailers there that could
potentially take a hit due to lack of traffic.
Mr. Relos said he didn't think the plans
are to open up Pine Road to do it from this
point north of Lincolnway but to be able
to cross Pine to continue heading south.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3026
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
Commission approved Resolution No. 3026 OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT(OLIVE ROAD
approving and authorizing the execution of RIGHT-OF-WAY ACQUISITION-SUPPLEMENT
an Amendment to the Addendum to the #3).
Master Agency Agreement (Olive Road
Right-of-Way Acquisition— Supplement#3).
Mr. Davis opposed.
D. West Washington-Chapin Development Area
There was no business in the West Washington- THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE WEST
Chapin Development Area. WASHINGTON-CHAPIN DEVELOPMENT AREA.
E. South Side Development Area
(1) Resolution No. 3023 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
Amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement (Main-
Lafayette Connector Design Project—
Supplement #5).
Mr. Relos noted Resolution No. 3023 and
Amendment to the Addendum To Master
Agency Agreement for the Main-Lafayette
Corridor Project, Supplement#5. The
purpose of this supplement is to add funding
to cover the construction cost for the Main-
Lafayette connector. After nearly nine years
of planning and design, the project will go
out to bid with a bid opening date of May 22,
2012. The engineer's estimate is $4.3
million (for the record, Mr. Relos noted it
26
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
should read $4.5 million and this needs to be
changed) for the entire project but several
alternate bid items have been created to help
give flexibility when reviewing the bids and
making an award. This project will take all
available South Side TIF funds from budget
year 2012 to pay for the project, but this is an
important tool for that area and will open up
a lot of development areas after the road is
redesigned.
Staff requests approval of Resolution No.
3023 and the Addendum To Master Agency
Agreement for the Main-Lafayette Corridor
Project, Supplement#5.
Mr. Varner asked if this included any of the
Chippewa work. Mr. Relos said no. Mr.
Varner asked how far down the road is that
work? Mr. Inks responded that the City was
hoping to do more of that this year. At least
the right-of-way and design work. Mr.
Schalliol would still like to do some
construction this year, but as Mr. Relos
mentioned, this project uses all the South
Side TIF funds for the year and that's
consistent with the strategy. Main and
Lafayette Streets were to be completed first
and then issue with Chippewa was to follow.
Mr. Relos noted that the Street Department is
going to be doing some water main work on
Barbie Street, east of Michigan Street. One
of the alternatives is to do some upgrade, tear
up the water main and patch the street. So if
the bids come in low enough, and the City
can do some curbing/guttering and resurface
the whole street. Once the Street Department
goes in there, the City will tear up one side of
the street and then go in and patch it. So now
there is a quarter of the street torn up and
patched verses resurfacing the whole street.
Mr. Relos also noted that Barbie Street will
27
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
stay the same. What is affected is Main,
Lafayette, the redesign of Main curving over
to connect with Lafayette at the light.
Separately, as part of SR31 redesign project,
the way it connects into Michigan Street,
when heading north, unless you get on at
Kern, and get on the new bypass, that will
end up where it is now. If you don't take that
Kern exit, then it feeds into the
neighborhoods on the east side of Michigan
around Johnson Road eventually working up
to Fellows Street to get over the existing
bypass and dump you out there at Ireland.
Mr. Varner noted then you are then diverting
traffic patterns. Have the potential results
been considered? Mr. Relos noted that was
INDOT's plan. They changed it. It's a very
convoluted path to get you up to Fellows
Street by Jackson High School. Mr. Varner
noted, if you don't take the Kern Road exit
... Mr. Relos, you can take Johnson over to
Miami. If you're coming up to the existing
SR31, you're still able to turn. There are
several ways to cross-over to Miami.
Fellows to Chippewa is a separate project
from this.
Mr. Davis asked whether there is an INDOT
plan that the City doesn't know anything
about. He's interested in knowing what
things will look like ten years from now. Ms.
Jones offered the idea of INDOT's web page.
Mr. Relos relayed that Engineering or the
Board of Public Works have been involved
with the design and worked with INDOT to
come up with the best possible plan for the
City. Mr. Davis asked who the
Commission's contact is locally then with
INDOT. Answered more specifically, Mr.
Gary Gilot. Mr. Relos offered to get the plan
for the Commission.
28
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No.3023
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
Commission approved Resolution No. 3023 OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT(MAIN-
approving and authorizing the execution of LAFAYETTE CONNECTOR DESIGN PROJECT-
an Amendment to the Addendum to the SUPPLEMENT#5).
Master Agency Agreement (Main-Lafayette
Connector Design Project— Supplement#5).
Mr. Davis opposed.
F. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
There was no business in the Northeast THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE NORTHEAST
Neighborhood Development Area. NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT UREA.
G. Douglas Road Economic Development Area
There was no business in the Douglas Road THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE DOUGLAS
Economic Development Area. ROAD ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA.
H. Ratification of Services Contracts
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr. COMMISSION RATIFIED THE SERVICE
Davis and unanimously carried, the Commission CONTRACTS.
ratified the service contracts.
L Ratification of Temporary Use Agreements
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr. COMMISSION RATIFIED THE TEMPORARY USE
Davis and unanimously carried, the Commission AGREEMENTS.
ratified the temporary use agreements.
7. PROGRESS REPORTS
A. Tax Abatement
Mr. Inks noted that Mr. Davis' committee
communicated to the Redevelopment
Commission from the South Bend Common
Council and indicated that they will, as the
local tax abatement requires, even numbered
years of tax abatement, so that is in the
29
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
forefront.
B. Common Council
C. Other
Mr. Inks noted that there is a special meeting
of the Redevelopment Commission from
4:30 p.m. to 6:30 p.m., April 25, 2012. All
are welcome to attend. The reason we did
the special meeting was in case we had a
quorum show up. Since Mr. Varner and Mr.
Davis are both on the Council, we would
expect they would be there tomorrow and if
anyone else wants to show up to give us a
quorum, we need to have a posted meeting,
so hence the special meeting. This is a TIF
presentation. Randy from Faegre Baker
Daniels will be there to talk about state law
and the rules regarding TIF. Mr. Inks will do
a briefing on the City's own TIF areas.
Mr. Inks noted that a quorum is not needed.
Mr. Downes mentioned he will be there. Mr.
Inks said then there will be a posted meeting
and there will be a quorum present.
Mr. Inks also noted that there is a revised
LPGA agreement. The Commission
previously approved an agreement and there
were some changes made to it. Legal is in
the process of reviewing those changes. Ms.
Beachkofsky noted that there are significant
and several changes made from the original
version. There is financial significance to it.
It's being reviewed right now. Mr. Inks
inquired whether there was a way the
Commission can get authorization to approve
it subject to final legal. Ms. Leonard Inks
added that the only number she heard was the
amount of insurance needed to increase from
30
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting—April 24, 2012
$2 million to $3 million. Mr. Beachkofsky
approved that it be approved subject to legal
review.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED THE LPGA
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the AGREEMENT SUBJECT TO LEGAL REVIEW.
Commission approved the LPGA Agreement
subject to legal review.
8. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
The next meeting of the Redevelopment Commission is NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
scheduled for Tuesday, May 8, 2012 at 4:00 p.m.
9. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the ADJOURNMENT
Redevelopment Commission, M made a motion that the
meeting be adjourned. Mr. Downes seconded the
motion and the meeting was adjourned at 5:08 p.m.
,.
31