HomeMy WebLinkAbout05-07-04 Redevelopment Commission Minutes� 1
A
SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
May 7, 2004
10:00 a.m.
Presiding: Robert W. Hunt, President
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present:
Legal Counsel:
227 West Jefferson Boulevard
South Bend, Indiana
Mr. Robert W. Hunt, President
Ms. Marcia Jones, Vice - President
Mr. Philip J. Faccenda, Secretary
Mr. Matt Kahn
Mr. Hardie Blake, Jr.
Ms. Cheryl Greene, Esq.
Redevelopment Staff: Mr. Owen Rock, Assistant Director
Ms. Pamela Morris, Recording Secretary
Mr. Robert Mathia, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Tim Williams, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Andy Laurent, Economic Development Specialist
Ms. Jennifer Hughes, Economic Development Planner
Others Present: Ms. Pam Paluszewski, Legal Department
Mr. William Panzica, Crescent Michiana Properties III
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Commission approval of the Minutes of the
Regular Meeting of March 19, 2004.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Minutes of the
Regular Meeting of March 19, 2004.
B. Approval of Minutes of the Special Meeting
of April 8, 2004.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Minutes of the
Special Meeting of April 8, 2004.
1
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
REGULAR MEETING OF MARCH 19, 2004.
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
SPECIAL MEETING OF APRIL 8, 2004.
V ,
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
%0�1
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted May 7, 2004 for approval.
FUND 305 SBCDA 2003 BOND
Danch Hamer & Associates, Inc.
$ 1,250.00
Weaver Boos Consultants, LLC
354.00
Kone, Inc.
168,453.00
Nationwide
1,328.00
Kaser - Spraker Construction, Inc.
34,261.36
Sabre Demolition Corp.
171,500.00
324 FUND - AIRPORT
FM Stone Commercial 3,374.50
Blackthorn Golf Club 2,650.00
R. E. Pitts & Associates 1,500.00
Sopko, Nussbaum & Inabnit 26.57
Wayne Baney 2,500.00
414 SAMPLE -EWING GENERAL
Baker General Maintenance 300.00
Plews Shadley Racher & Braun 6,006.23
CA Studios 1,545.00
Crumlish & Crumlish Architects, Inc. 1,900.00
420 FUND TIF DISTRICT - SBCDA GENERAL
Hill's True Value Hardware
9.36
AEP
811.43
SBC
29.21
David J. Sassano
1,500.00
AEP
552.31
CB Richard Ellis
200.75
C & S Service, Inc.
60.00
City Of South Bend
2,022.06
L
I t
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IL Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS (CONT.)
Stuard & Associates
Ziolkowski Construction
424 FUND TIF SBCDA - BUILDING OPERATIONS
Mikolajewski & Associates, Inc.
FUND 428 AIRPORT 2003 BOND
The Troyer Group
Mr. Hunt inquired about the Sabre Demolition
Corporation claim in the about of $171,500 and the
Kone, Inc. claim in the amount of $168,453.
Mr. Rock reported that the Sabre Demolition claim
is related to the demolition of the St. Joseph &
Jefferson parking structure.
Mr. Williams reported that the Kone, Inc. claim is
related to elevator repairs within the parking
garages.
Mr. Rock noted that the contract with Kone, Inc. for
elevator repairs, at both the Wayne Street and
Main & Colfax garages, was reviewed and approved
by the City Engineering Department.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Claims submitted May 7,
2004, and ordered the checks to be released.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
There were no Communications.
[A
3
900.00
95,036.10
2,794.68
13,590.00
$ 112,320.78
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS SUBMITTED
MAY 7, 2004, AND ORDERED THE CHECKS TO BE
RELEASED.
THERE WERE NO COMMUNICATIONS.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
5. OLD BUSINESS
A. Clarification of Commission record related to
Contract for Sale of Land for Private
Development between the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission and The
Woodwind & The Brasswind. (Parcels 9B &
13B, U.S. 31 Industrial Park)
Mr. Rock reported that the property recently
sold to The Woodwind & The Brasswind were
Parcels 9B and 13B located within the U.S. 31
Industrial Park. At the Redevelopment
Commission Meeting of April 16, 2004, the
parcels were erroneously referred to as
Parcels 9A and 13A, although the April 16,
2004 agenda correctly referenced Parcels 9B and
13B in the US 31 Industrial Park.
ILUpon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission clarified the record related to
Contract for Sale of Land for Private
Development between the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission and The
Woodwind & The Brasswind.
Mr. Faccenda abstained from the vote.
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) Commission approval requested for
Management Agreement by and between
the City of South Bend and Ampco
System Parking. (225 S. Main, former
1" Source Lot)
Mr. Williams reported that the parking lot
located at 225 S. Main Street has been in
C 4
COMMISSION CLARIFIED THE RECORD RELATED
TO CONTRACT FOR SALE OF LAND FOR PRIVATE
DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN THE SOUTH BEND
REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION AND THE
WOODWIND & THE BRASSWIND.
MR. FACCENDA ABSTAINED FROM THE VOTE.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
ILI Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) continued...
operation since January 1, 2004. Submitted
for Commission approval is a Parking
Management Agreement between the City of
South Bend and Ampco System Parking.
Staff recommends approval of the
Management Agreement, retroactive to
January 1, 2004, subject to final approval of
legal counsel.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda, seconded
by Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved a Management
Agreement by and between the City of South
Bend and Ampco System Parking, subject to
final approval by legal counsel. (225 S.
Main, former Is' Source Lot)
(2) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2052 relating to
acquisition of properties within the South
Bend Central Development Area by
eminent domain. (209 Colfax & adjacent
lot, 230 -237 Sycamore & adjacent lot,
228 Sycamore)
Mr. Mathia reported that Resolution
No. 2052 sets the purchase price, and
authorizes offers to be made, for five (5)
properties in the South Bend Central
Development Area. Two (2) of the
properties are identified by tax key numbers
18 -5003 -0056 and 18 -5003 -0058. They are
contiguous and located at 209 Colfax Street
(commonly referred to as the Rink
A
COMMISSION APPROVED A MANAGEMENT
AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF
SOUTH BEND AND AMPCO SYSTEM PARKING,
SUBJECT TO FINAL APPROVAL BY LEGAL
COUNSEL. (225 S. MAIN, FORMER 1 hT SOURCE
LOT)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(2) continued...
Building). These properties were put on the
acquisition list by Resolution No. 2029
approved by the Commission February 20,
2004. The other three (3) properties are
identified by tax key numbers
18 -5003 -0059, 18 -5003- 0060.01 and
18 -5003- 0059.01 and are located along the
east side of Sycamore Street. Those
properties were added to the acquisition list
by Resolution No. 1843 approved by the
Commission September 7, 2001.
Acquisition of the properties will assist in
achieving the goals of the South Bend
Central Development Area Development
Plan and, more particularly, the objectives
for further development on the East Bank.
Staff recommends approval of Resolution
No. 2052.
Mr. Hunt asked if these were the final pieces
of property to be acquired within the area
around Sycamore Street.
Mr. Mathia responded that there is one (1)
more property still being negotiated.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Mr. Faccenda and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2052
relating to acquisition of properties within
the South Bend Central Development Area
by eminent domain. (209 Colfax & adjacent
lot, 230 -237 Sycamore & adjacent lot,
228 Sycamore)
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2052
RELATING TO ACQUISITION OF PROPERTIES
WITHIN THE SOUTH BEND CENTRAL
DEVELOPMENT AREA BY EMINENT DOMAIN.
(209 COLFAX & ADJACENT LOT, 230 -237
SYCAMORE & ADJACENT LOT, 228 SYCAMORE
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(3) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2055 adopting certain
findings related to property located at
305 East Colfax Street and approving the
temporary use of 305 East Colfax Street
by East Race Fire Arts, LLC.
Mr. Mathia requested that, due to its length,
the staff report relating to Resolution
No. 2055 be incorporated into the minutes
and highlighted the report as follows:
An artists group, East Race Fire Arts
(ERFA), has requested temporary use of the
property located at 305 East Colfax Street
(commonly known as the PAC Building)
which the Commission acquired in 2003. It
is the Commission's intent to demolish the
building and construct a parking facility that
would complement Holladay Corporation's
planned development on the old Wharf site.
In the interim, some of the benefits of
allowing use of the PAC Building by ERFA
would be postponed demolition,
maintenance of the property and building,
and added vitality to the area. Staff
recommends approving the temporary use of
the property by East Race Fire Arts, a
subsidiary of Sculptural Arts, LLC.
Ms. Greene advised that because of the
unusual circumstances being asked of the
Commission with respect to Commission
owned property, Resolution No. 2055 has
been prepared which adopts certain findings
related to the temporary use of the building
7
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(3) continued...
by ERFA. The findings include the fact that
the property, in its current condition, is not
suitable for commercial leasing, but for
significant financial investment by the
Commission. The property is not going to
be used as a commercial tenancy; therefore,
the Commission is not pursuing this as a
standard lease of property, and as such, is
not obtaining appraisals for the fair market
use of the property. The use of the property
is temporary and the recommendation,
which is incorporated in Resolution
No. 2055, is that the ERFA undertake the
assumption of liability for the premises,
including any repairs needed for suitable
occupancy on a temporary basis. The use
can be terminated by the Commission upon
written notification to ERFA. ERFA will be
required to provide proof of insurance
naming the Redevelopment Commission as
co- insured.
Mr. Hunt inquired about the time factor
related to written notification of use
termination.
Ms. Greene advised that Resolution
No. 2055 authorizes legal counsel to prepare
the necessary documentation consistent with
the resolution and also authorizes the
Redevelopment President or Vice President
and Secretary to execute the required
documents.
L 8
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
ILI Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(3) continued...
Mr. Mathia noted that the termination notice
would include a 30 to 60 day notification
period.
Mr. Hunt asked if ERFA understands that
today's action is not the Commission's long
range plan for the use of the PAC property
and there will be no relocation costs related
to termination of use.
Mr. Mathia responded that in discussions
with ERFA the terms and conditions of the
temporary property use were made clear.
Ms. Jones inquired as to the willingness of
ERFA to donate artistic services to the City
of South Bend.
Mr. Mathia replied that preliminary
discussions had taken place regarding a
trade -in -kind for sculptures to enhance the
downtown area.
Mr. Faccenda stated that a letter from
ERFA, or a representative, incorporating its
understanding of the details negotiated with
staff should be obtained for our records.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda, seconded
by Ms. Jones and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2055
adopting certain findings related to property
located at 305 East Colfax Street and
approving the temporary use of 305 East
Colfax Street by East Race Fire Arts, LLC.
Vol,
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2055
ADOPTING CERTAIN FINDINGS RELATED TO
PROPERTY LOCATED AT 305 EAST COLFAX
STREET AND APPROVING THE TEMPORARY USE
OF 305 EAST COLFAX STREET BY EAST RACE
FIRE ARTS, LLC.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IL Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(4) Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services in the
South Bend Central and Sample Ewing
Development Areas. (Appraisal services,
various properties within the Sample -
Lincolnway Triangle)
Mr. Williams reported that as part of a
continued process to acquire property in the
Sample - Lincolnway triangle, staff is
requesting the Commission approve
appraisal services on four (4) parcels located
in the acquisition area. Two appraisals are
required to establish area property values.
Two (2) proposals were received and the
information is as follows:
Jerome E. Michaels, MAI $4,800
R. E. Pitts & Associates $3,450
Staff recommends accepting the proposals
from Jerome E. Michaels, MAI and
R. E. Pitts & Associates.
Mr. Hunt asked what the purpose was for the
Commission to acquire the properties.
Ms: Greene responded that the properties are
not being acquired. A study is being
conducted to establish the value of property
in the Sample - Lincolnway triangle area.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
professional services in the South Bend
10
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IL Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. South Bend Central Development Area
(4) continued...
Central and Sample Ewing Development
Areas and authorized staff to retain
Jerome E. Michaels, MAI and R. E. Pitts &
Associates based on the scope of services
and fee proposed. (Appraisal services,
various properties within the Sample -
Lincolnway Triangle)
B. Sample -Ewing Development Area
(1) Commission approval requested for
Resolution No. 2053 approving and
authorizing the execution of an Agency
Agreement by and between the South
Bend Redevelopment Commission and
the City of South Bend, Indiana, Board of
Public Works relating to the Studebaker
Area A Redevelopment Project (Sample -
Ewing Development Area).
Mr. Laurent reported that Resolution
No. 2053 authorizes execution of an Agency
Agreement allowing the Board of Public
Works (BPW) to act as an agent for the
Commission regarding matters related to the
Studebaker Area A redevelopment project.
This includes the properties known as the
South Bend Stamping Plant, South Bend
Lathe, Huckins Tool & Die and
Underground Pipe and Valve. Resolution
No. 2053 allows the BPW to place projects
out for bid as well as award contracts and
proposals. Resolution No. 2053 is directly
in line with the Agency Agreement that
11
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES IN THE SOUTH BEND
CENTRAL AND SAMPLE EWING DEVELOPMENT
AREAS AND AUTHORIZED STAFF TO RETAIN
JEROME E. MICHAELS, MAI AND R. E. PITTS &
ASSOCIATES BASED ON THE SCOPE OF SERVICES
AND FEE PROPOSED. (APPRAISAL SERVICES,
VARIOUS PROPERTIES WITHIN THE SAMPLE -
LINCOLNWAY TRIANGLE)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IL Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
B. Sample -Ewing Development Area
(1) continued...
currently exists between the Commission
and the BPW regarding the Oliver Plow
Works redevelopment project.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2053
approving and authorizing the execution of
an Agency Agreement by and between the
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
and the City of South Bend, Indiana, Board
of Public Works relating to the Studebaker
Area A Redevelopment Project (Sample -
Ewing Development Area).
2 Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services in the
Sample -Ewing Development Area.
(Engineering services, former Oliver Plow
Works #2 Forge Shop)
Mr. Rock requested that Item 6.B.(2) be
withdrawn. There were no objections and
the Commission withdrew Item 6.B.(2).
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) Staff report on disposition of property in
the Airport Economic Development Area.
(Lot 40, Blackthorn Corporate Office
Park)
Mr. Rock reported that Crescent Michiana
Properties III, LLC submitted a proposal for
Lot 40 in the Blackthorn Corporate Office
12
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2053
APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
OF AN AGENCY AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN
THE SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT
COMMISSION AND THE CITY OF SOUTH BEND,
INDIANA, BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS RELATING
TO THE STUDEBAKER AREA A REDEVELOPMENT
PROJECT (SAMPLE -EWING DEVELOPMENT
AREA).
COMMISSION WITHDREW ITEM 6.B.(2).
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) continued...
Park. The proposed project consists of a
27,000 sq. ft. facility which will compliment
the existing Citigroup building. At its
meeting on April 16, 2004, the Commission
approved the concept of the development
project; however, negotiations continued
with respect to purchase price per acre.
Crescent Michiana Properties has agreed to
purchase the property for $55,000 per acre.
Mr. William Panzica, representing Crescent
Michiana Properties III, asked the
Commission if the right of early entry was
also approved.
Mr. Rock replied that an indemnification
agreement would be required.
Upon a motion by Mr. Kahn, seconded by
Mr. Faccenda and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the sale of property
in the Airport Economic Development Area
and authorized an agreement of early entry
pending the execution of legal documents.
(Lot 40, Blackthorn Corporate Office Park)
(2) Commission approval requested for
purchase of property within the
Blackthorn Corporate Office Park in the
Airport Economic Development Area.
(property south of Fiserv)
In March 1993, the Redevelopment
Commission executed an agreement with the
Airport Authority to sell approximately
13
COMMISSION APPROVED THE SALE OF PROPERTY
IN THE AIRPORT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
AREA AND AUTHORIZED AN AGREEMENT OF
EARLY ENTRY PENDING THE EXECUTION OF
LEGAL DOCUMENTS. (LOT 40, BLACKTHORN
CORPORATE OFFICE PARK)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(2) continued...
26 acres of property located in the
Blackthorn Corporate Office Park owned by
the Authority. This agreement terminated in
February 2000. Efforts were made by staff
to negotiate an extension to the agreement;
however, the negotiations were unsuccessful
and the agreement was not renewed.
While the agreement was in effect, the
Commission sold property to Trinity Health
and gave Trinity the first right of refusal on
two (2) acres of land located to their south
for future parking. These two (2) acres
IL reverted back to the Airport Authority in
2000 when the agreement terminated.
Fisery is currently moving into the former
Trinity Health building and additional
property is required to accommodate
company needs. Staff is requesting the
Commission purchase the two (2) acres from
the Airport Authority for the agreed upon
price of $35,000 per acre.
Ms. Greene noted that the present
transaction is directly related to the previous
agreement between the Airport Authority
and the Redevelopment Commission that
expired prior to the Commission exercising
its acquisition of the property in question.
Since the agreement has expired, staff is
asking the Commission to purchase the
two (2) acres of land from the Airport
Authority. As a transfer of property from
one governmental entity to another, Airport
Authority is agreeable to a purchase price of
I' 14
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(2) continued...
$35,000 an acre, which is well below the
current market values in the area of $55,000
per acre. Commission approval of the
purchase requires a finding by the
Commission that the price is reasonable and
acquisition is necessary to further the
Airport Economic Development Area
Development Plan.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda, seconded
by Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the purchase of
property within the Blackthorn Corporate
Office Park in the Airport Economic
Development Area. (property south of
Fiserv)
D. South Bend Medical Services District
There was no business in the South Bend
Medical Services District.
E. West Washington- Chapin Development Area
There was no business in the West Washington -
Chapin Development Area.
F. South Side Development Area
There was no business in the South Side
Development Area.
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(1) Filing of Resolution No. 2054 amending
IL the Northeast Neighborhood Development
15
COMMISSION APPROVED THE PURCHASE OF
PROPERTY WITHIN THE BLACKTHORN
CORPORATE OFFICE PARK IN THE AIRPORT
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AREA. (PROPERTY
SOUTH OF FISERV)
THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE SOUTH BEND
MEDICAL SERVICES DISTRICT.
THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE WEST
WASHINGTON -CHAMN DEVELOPMENT AREA.
THERE WAS NO BUSINESS IN THE SOUTH SIDE
DEVELOPMENT AREA.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
IL Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
G. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
(1) continued...
Area Development Plan and setting a
Public Hearing for May 21, 2004 at
10:00 a.m.
Ms. Hughes reported that the Northeast
Neighborhood Development Area
Development Plan will be amended by
Resolution No. 2054 which adds two (2)
properties to the acquisition list. Both
properties are proposed for acquisition
relative to plans for improvements to
Fredrickson Park. The properties are
identified as follows:
► Tax Key Number 18 -5102- 358901
1340 South Bend Avenue
Sears Warehouse Building
Tax Key Number 18 -5102 -3598
1405 E. Howard Street
Donald and Jeanette McCarty, owners
Funds have been allocated in the City CIP
budget for the purchase of these properties.
The public hearing on Resolution No. 2054
will be set for Friday, May 21, 2004 at
10:00 a.m.
Upon a motion by Ms. Jones, seconded by
Mr. Blake and unanimously carried, the
Commission accepted for filing Resolution
No. 2054 and set a public hearing on
Resolution No. 2054 for 10:00 a.m.,
May 21, 2004 at a Regular Meeting of the
Redevelopment Commission.
L, 16
COMMISSION ACCEPTED FOR FILING RESOLUTION
No. 2054 AND SET A PUBLIC HEARING ON
RESOLUTION NO. 2054 FOR 10:00 A.M., MAY 21,
2004 AT A REGULAR MEETING OF THE
REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
H. Other
(1) Commission approval requested for
proposal for professional services for
property located at 23977 Brick Road.
(Appraisal update)
Mr. Williams reported that staff is
requesting approval for updates to
previously completed appraisals on property
located at 23977 Brick Road. The property
is a voluntary acquisition and is one of
four (4) properties which are entirely
surrounded by industrial uses. The original
appraisals were completed by Jerome E.
Michaels, MAI and R. E. Pitts & Associates.
The cost for updating the appraisals is
$1,500 each. Staff recommends accepting
ILI the proposals from Jerome E. Michaels,
MAI and R. E. Pitts & Associates.
Upon a motion by Mr. Faccenda, seconded
by Mr. Kahn and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the request for
professional services and authorized staff to
retain Jerome E. Michaels, MAI and
R. E. Pitts & Associates based on the scope
of services and fee proposed.
Ms. Greene requested that an additional item be added
to the agenda under Other business. The item will be
611. (2) and relates to correspondence addressed to the
Commission by Robert W. Hunt.
(2) Mr. Robert W. Hunt is requesting that
the Commission accept his resignation as
President of the Redevelopment
Commission effective immediately.
Mr. Hunt is also requesting to remain on
the Redevelopment Commission in the
capacity as a Member.
17
COMMISSION APPROVED THE REQUEST FOR
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AND AUTHORIZED
STAFF TO RETAIN JEROME E. MICHAELS, MAI
AND R. E. PITTS & ASSOCIATES BASED ON THE
SCOPE OF SERVICES AND FEE PROPOSED.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
6. NEW BUSINESS
H. Other
(2) continued...
Ms. Greene advised that the Commissioners
have received prior notice of Mr. Hunt's
intended resignation as President of the
Redevelopment Commission. The By -Laws
of the Redevelopment Commission state that
"Should the office of President or Vice
President become vacant, the Commission
shall elect a successor from its membership
at the next Regular Meeting and the election
will be for the unexpired term of said
office." At the request of Mr. Hunt and by
unanimous approval of all Commissioners, a
special election could be held immediately.
ILThe Commission voted unanimously to
accept the resignation of Mr. Robert W.
Hunt as President of the Redevelopment
Commission and to hold a special election
immediately.
7. ELECTION OF OFFICERS
Mr. Hunt nominated Ms. Marcia Jones to serve as
President of the South Bend Redevelopment
Commission. The nomination was seconded by Mr.
Faccenda. There were no further nominations. The
vote being unanimous, Ms. Marcia I. Jones was
elected President for the remaining 2004 term.
Mr. Hunt nominated Mr. Philip Faccenda to serve
as Vice - President of the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission. The nomination was
seconded by Mr. Kahn. There were no further
nominations. The vote being unanimous, Mr. Philip
J. Faccenda, Sr. was elected Vice - President for the
remaining 2004 term.
W.
COMMISSION VOTED UNANIMOUSLY TO ACCEPT
THE RESIGNATION OF MR. ROBERT W. HUNT AS
PRESIDENT OF THE REDEVELOPMENT
COMMISSION AND TO HOLD A SPECIAL ELECTION
IMMEDIATELY.
ELECTION OF OFFICERS
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
7. ELECTION OF OFFICERS (CONT.)
Mr. Matt Kahn was appointed by Ms. Jones to serve
as Secretary of the South Bend Redevelopment
Commission for the remainder of the 2004 term.
8. PROGRESS REPORTS
Mr. Rock welcomed Ms. Sharon Kendall, the new
South Bend Executive Director of Community and
Economic Development.
Mr. Rock reported the following progress:
► The closing on The Woodwind and The
Brasswind property is complete. The proposed
project consists of the construction of a 200,000
sq. ft. building.
► Construction has begun on Olive Road which is
being expanded to four (4) lanes to coincide
with the new bridge completed in 2003.
Mr. Steve Cooreman will be hosting an Open
House at the Villas at Blackthorn tonight, May
7, 2004. The Commission is invited to join
other City officials for an evening of wine and
jazz.
9. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
The next Regular Meeting of the Redevelopment
Commission is scheduled for May 21, 2004 at
10:00 a.m.
10. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the
Redevelopment Commission, Mr. Kahn made a
motion that the meeting be adjourned. Mr. Blake
seconded the motion and the meeting was adjourned
at 10:35 a.m.
19
PROGRESS REPORTS
NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
ADJOURNMENT
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 7, 2004
MaLcia I. Jones, Presi
20
Donald E. Inks, Director
SOUTH B
Community & Economic Development
1865
1200 County -City Building, 227 west Jefferson, South Bend, Indiana 46601 -1830 ♦ Phone 574/235 -9371 ♦ Fax 574/235 -9021
To: Redevelopment Commission
From: Bob Mathia ' l
Subject: P.A.C. Graphic Building
Date• May 7, 2004
Last year, the Redevelopment Commission acquired the P.A.C. Graphic Building ( "PAC Building ")
located at 305 East Colfax ( "Property "). The Commission's intent is to demolish the building and
constrict a parking lot that would complement Holladay Corporation's planned development on the
old Wharf site in addition to other developments in the area such as the Commerce Center. While
preparing plans for the PAC Building's demolition, a group of artists approached Staff with a request
to use the PAC Building for artist studios. The group is newly forming and seeks to establish a
cooperative -based studio for themselves in the downtown area. At Staff s suggestion, the group
looked at the Marycrest Building and Union Station as alternative locations. They also looked at a
third facility near the Center for History. For various reasons they rejected all of those sites and have
renewed their request to use the PAC Building for the following reasons: (1) the building fits their
needs well; (ii) it is large enough to acconlnnodate the group; (iii) it is equipped with sufficient heavy
duty utility service to meet their needs (they are sculptures and potters that use kilns and a foundry);
and (iv) it has a glassed -in front where a gallery could be set up.
The artists have been moving quickly with their organizational efforts. They have chosen a name,
"East Race Fire Arts" ( "ERFA "), which is a subsidiary of Sculptural Arts, LLC. They are in the
process of writing by -laws for the organization, preparing a five (5) year business plan and have
opened a bank account. They intend to submit a formal proposal to the Commission to use the PAC
Building and they will include the by -laws and the five (5) year plan in their proposal. In addition,
they are in the process of contacting members of the community for support. For example, they have
already gotten Doug Hunt and Holladay Corp. to help with inspecting the building and preparing cost
estimates for repairs. They have also contacted Charlie Hays and others for possible financial support
and they have invited Common Council members Roland Kelly and Ann Puzzello to their meetings.
The Redevelopment Commission acquired the Property with the intent of demolishing the PAC
Building in order to carry out and complement future development projects which remains the
primary objective for the Property. However, delays in the Water's Edge Project and the
Commission's involvement and investment in other projects in the South Bend Central Development
Area have led Staff to conclude that it is advisable to delay demolition of the PAC Building at the
present time.
„ „ pdm, a,, ti „pd What We Do Today Makes A Difference!
l:
of believe that the PAC
Staff does n Building, in its g, p resent condition, is suitable for use as a
rental property without significant financial investment by the Commission. As such, Staff has
not obtained any appraisals to determine the rental value of the Property. During the period of
time pending demolition of the PAC Building, the Commission would be required to seal the
PAC Building in order to ensure that the Property does not become a public nuisance and invite
tresspass. However, even if the PAC Building is vacant and sealed, the Commission would be
required to make certain monthly expenditures in order to ensure that the Property does not pose
an unsafe condition for the community.
Therefore, Staff is recommending that the Commission permit ERFA to temporarily use the
Property until such time as the Commission determines to demolish the PAC Building and
proceed with development of the Property. Staff is requesting that the Commission approve
temporary use of the PAC Building by ERFA subject to: (1) ERFA's submission of a five (5)
year business plan and organization documents; (2) execution of an agreement between the
Commission and ERFA in a form acceptable to legal counsel providing for the terms of said use.
Staff further recommends that any agreement include language expressly noting the that ERFA's
use of the Property is temporary and may be terminated by the Commission upon written
notification in keeping with the Commission's primary objective for this Property which is
demolition of the structure to accommodate a larger development project. As consideration for
the temporary use of the Property, Staff is also recommending that ERFA be responsible for
cleaning and maintaining the Property during its use.
Staff believes that the addition of ERFA to the East Bank Area, even on a temporary basis, will
contribute greatly to achievement of the Commission's overall goal of establishing the downtown
as an entertainment and cultural center. Currently, the area around the PAC Building is deserted
with the three corners of the "T" intersection of Colfax and Sycamore all vacant. The former
Wharf site is located on the south side and the Rink and PAC Buildings are on the two north
corners. Permitting ERFA to use the PAC Building on a temporary basis will benefit the
community by bringing life and vitality back to the area which is currently a problem for existing
businesses. For example, Macri' s Restaurant recently cut back on its evening hours due to a
lack of customers in the evening resulting in part from a lack of other attractions in the area.
ERFA is comprised mainly of part-time artists who work at normal jobs during the day and
practice their craft at night. They have plans to establish a classroom in the building for art
classes, open an art gallery and invite other artists from outside the area for public showings all
of which will draw people to the area in addition to the artists themselves. ERFA has also
suggested that it may be willing to donate certain artwork to the community in exchange for the
opportunity to utilize the PAC Building.
Staff is requesting the Commission's approval of ERFA's temporary use of the Property
consistent with Staff's recommendations. Legal counsel has prepared a Resolution consistent
with Staff's recommendation.
H Wpdaw an 8 .pd
What We Do Today Makes A Difference!
:4
RESOLUTION NO. 2055
A RESOLUTION OF THE SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
ADOPTING CERTAIN FINDINGS RELATED TO PROPERTY LOCATED AT
305 EAST COLFAX STREET AND APPROVING THE TEMPORARY USE
OF 305 EAST COLFAX STREET BY EAST RACE FIRE ARTS, LLC
WHEREAS, the South Bend Redevelopment Conunission is the owner of certain real
property and improvements located at 305 East Colfax Street ( "Property ") ii the South Bend Central
Development Area ( "Area "), said property and improvements being more commonly known as the
fonner P.A.C. Graphic Building ( "PAC Building "); and
WHEREAS, the Coinimissionn acquired the Property in accordance with the South Bend
Central Development Area Development Plan ( "Development Plan ") and intends to demolish the
unprovements located on the Property to facilitate future development projects in furtherance of the
Development Plan; and
WHEREAS, the Commission does not anticipate demolition to occur until a undeteni ied
future date and as such, acknowledges that the Property will remain vacant for an indefinite period
of time which may detract from development of the Area and exacerbate the appearance of decline
in the Area; and
WHEREAS, until such time as the PAC Building is demolished, the Connilission believes
that the Property will likely deteriorate and the Commission would be required to expend certain
funds ii order to maintain the PAC Building in a condition that is not injurious to the health, safety
and welfare of the general public; and
WHEREAS, East Race Fire Arts ( "ERFA "), a subsidiary of Sculptural Arts, LLC, is an
organization consisting of several artists and ERFA is in need of a facility suitable for use as artists'
studios and for the display of art work; and
WHEREAS, ERFA has requested the temporary use of the Property for its artistic endeavors
and in consideration thereof is willing to undertake clean -up and nninor repair of the Property; and
WHEREAS, ERFA has expressed a willingness to donate its artistic services and /or dedicate
artwork to the conntnunity in exchange for the temporary use of the Property; and
WHEREAS, the Commission believes that ERFA's use and occupancy of the Property will
ensure that the Property is being maintained in a safe condition pendiig demolition and may have
the added benefit of bringing renewed interest to the Area as a catalyst for future development.
THE COMMISSION NOW FINDS THAT:
1. The hereinabove described Property is not suitable for commercial leasing because
it would require the Commission to make a significant financial investment in the
Property and such use would be inconsistent with the Commission's plan for
redevelopment of the Property.
2. It is unnecessary to -obtain appraisals as to the rental value of the Property because
the Property is not suitable for commercial tenancy in its current condition.
3. The Conunission does not anticipate leasing the Property now or ill the foreseeable
future and its sole intent for the Property is demolition of the improvements located
thereon in order to facilitate future development projects in the Area in furtherance
of the South Bend Central Development Area Development Plan.
4. The Connnission believes that any short or long teen lease of the Property would be
inconsistent with its intended use of the Property.
5. The Commission believes that the temporary use of the Property by ERFA will help
to ensure that the Property is suitably maintained until such time as the Commission
proceeds with its intended demolition.
b. The purposes for which ERFA intends to utilize the Property on a temporary basis
may help to spur renewed interest ill the Area and thereby facilitate future econnonnic
development of the Area.
7. Permitting the temporary use of the Property by ERFA will provide the Commission
with the nnaxunum flexibility to schedule demolition of the Property ill the future.
S. Temporary use of the Property by ERFA will not innpede iunplementation of the
Development Plan and will best serve the interest of the comnnurnity from the
standpoint of both human and econonnic welfare.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the South Bend Redevelopment
Conlunission as follows:
1. In accordance with the terms and conditions expressed herein, the Conmission
hereby grants East Race Fire Arts permission to utilize the Property on a temporary
basis for artists' studios and for the display of art work subject to:
a. ERFA's agreement to undertake clean -up and minor repair of the
Property; and
2
14
b. ERFA's agreement to assume liability for acts and omissions related
to ERFA's temporary use of the Property which may result in a claun
against the City of South Bend or the Commission and ERFA's
further agreement to indemnify and hold harmless the Commission
for same; and
C. ERFA's agreement to submit a proof of insurance to the Commission
naming the Commission as co- insured; and
d. Acknowledgment by ERFA that its use of the Property is temporary
and may be terminated by the Commission upon written notification.
3. Legal counsel is hereby directed and authorized to prepared the necessary
documentation effecting temporary use of the Property by East Race Fire Arts as
described herein
4. The Commission hereby authorizes the President of the Co>ninission to execute and
the Vice President or Secretary to attest any and all documents relating and necessary
to effectuate the transaction as described hereon upon the advice of legal counsel.
5. This Resolution shall be. ui full force and effect after its adoption by the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission.
ADOPTED at a meeting of the South Bend Redevelopment Conunission held on May 7, 2004 at
1308 County -City Building, 227 West Jefferson Boulevard, South Bend, Indiana 46601.
SOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT
COMMISSION
By:
Its:
ATTEST:
By:
Its:
H: \WPData\Resolut ions\ RESCOMMI\Res2055_PACGraplucBldo ERFAgD40507.wpd