HomeMy WebLinkAbout2 May 24, 2011, MinutesSOUTH BEND REDEVELOPMENT COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
May 24, 2011
4:00 p.m. 227 West Jefferson Boulevard
Presiding: Marcia I. Jones, President South Bend, Indiana
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present: Ms. Marcia Jones, President
Dr. David Varner, Vice President
Ms. Nancy King, Secretary
Mr. Greg Downes
Mr. Donald Alford
Ms. Stephanie Spivey
Legal Counsel: Mr. Charles S. Leone, Esq.
Mr. Lawrence Meteiver, Esq.
Redevelopment Staff: Mr. Jeffrey Gibney, Executive Director
Mr. Don Inks, Director
Mrs. Cheryl Phipps, Recording Secretary
Mr. Bill Schalliol, Economic Development Specialist
Mr. Matthew Sikora, Economic Development Specialist
Ms. Debrah Jennings, Property Manager
Ms. Beth Leonard Inks
Others Present: Mr. Tom Price, Mayor's Office
Ms. Rita Kopala
Ms. Linda Wolfson, Community Forum for Economic Dev
Ms. Mo Miller, Prism Science
Ms. Patti Lesniewicz, Economic Development
Ms. Tamara Nicholl- Smith, Downtown South Bend
Mr. Jeff Parrott, South Bend Tribune
Ms. Christina Gerken
Ms. Geri Hathaway, Hathaway2, Inc.
Ms. Catherine Toppel, Director, Code Enforcement
Mr. Gary Libby, Neighborhood Code Enforcement
Mr. Mark Seaman, Prism Science
Ms. Autumn Psaros, CB Richard Ellis
Mr. Jonathon Burke, Energy Director
Mr. Don Reinke
Ms. Valerie Schey
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
A. Approval of Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
Tuesday, May 10, 2011.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr.
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission
approved the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of
Tuesday, May 10, 2011.
3. APPROVAL OF CLAIMS
COMMISSION APPROVED THE MINUTES OF THE
REGULAR MEETING OF TUESDAY, MAY 10,
2011.
Redevelopment Commission Claims submitted May 24, 2011 for approval
305 FUND SBCDA BOND
Wightman Petrie 35,394.50 Coveleski Stadium
ADG 2,100.00 Island Park Pavilion
Jefferson Blvd & Niles Ave
Abonmarche 2,854.00 Streetscape Modernization
324 AIRPORT AEDA
Sinco Pools
6,884.00
Additional Relocation Costs
Indiana Michigan Power
7.00
501 Wenger St.
South Bend Tribune
184.94
Tri County News
117.24
ACM
3,915.00
Asbestos Inspections
Big C Lumber
348.50
329 Lafayette
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit &
Legal Services
Kaczmarek
3,600.00
DHA
37,667.00
Engineering Plans & Services
ADG
725.00
Clubhouse Relocation
Plews Shadley Racher & Braun LLP
343.89
Oliver Plow Works Cost Recovery
Tuck Langland
45,000.00
Oliver Memorial Sculpture
Ritschard Bros. Inc
3,474.45
Demolition of 604 Scott St.
DHA
Oliver Trail System along Oliver Plow
1,996.00
Court /United Dr
Christopher B Burke
6,265.75
1505 Prairie Ave
Ken Herceg & Associates, Inc.
Sheridan Ave & Lincoln Way West
32,176.87
Design
Fossil Industries
348.00
C & E Excavating
73,292.30
Trade Dr
Dore & Associates Contracting
188,453.79
Studebaker Area A Demolition Ph IV
2
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Michaels Appraisal Service
Bid Pkg B / Escrow
DHA
700.00
1513 & 1518 Chapin
Meridan Title Corporation
6,400.00
Data Realty Site
271,073.50
Olive Road Extension
420 FUND TIF DISTRICT -SBCDA GENERAL
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit &
Legal Services
Kaczmarek
1,486.30
NIPSCO
32.10
329 S. Lafayette Blvd
1st Source Bank
10,700.00
Parking Garage
Ampco System Parking
2,103.16
225 Main St / St. Joe Street Surface
Michaels Appraisal Services
6,000.00
Indiana Electric Power
8.00
325 S. Lafayette Blvd
CB Richard Ellis
General Maint & Management Fee
Indiana Electric Power
835.03
LaSalle Hotel
8.75
755 S Michigan St.
ARC
175.10
Trade Dr
NIPSCO
45.36
755 S Michigan St.
Tri County News
52.94
Notice to Bidders
South Bend Tribune
93.92
Notice to Bidders
Rose Pest Solutions
96.00
LaSalle Hotel Pest Control
Enyart Electric Motor Repair, Inc.
9,189.45
Remove Morris fountain & motor
CB Richard Ellis
716.38
March Management Fee
Morris & Sons Roofing, Inc.
675.00
Roofing Repairs
Michiana Lock & Key Inc.
248.15
LaSalle Hotel Rim /Cylinder Rekeyed
CB Richard Ellis
286.00
LaSalle Hotel Outside Window
Wightman Petrie
362.50
Fred's Transmission & Clutch
South Bend Water Works
35.91
325 S Lafayette Blvd
422 FUND WEST WASHINGTON
DISTRICT
Meridian Title Corporation 100.00
R.E. Ptitts & Associates, Inc. 1,845.00
Michaels Appraisal Services 1,800.00
426 FUND SOUTH BEND CENTRAL MEDICAL DISTRICT
Walsh & Kelly, Inc
91,610.32
803 W Washington St.
601 -605 W Washington St
601 -605 W Washington St
Memorial Hospital Streetscape
Improvements
430 FUND SOUTH SIDE DEVELOPMENT TIF AREA #1
Christopher B Burke 20,913.00 Fellows St Corridor Improvement
It]
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Christopher B Burke
Christopher B Burke
Christopher B Burke
C & E Excavating, Inc.
Lawson - Fisher Associates, P.C.
431 FUND SOUTH CENTRAL MEDICAL DISTRICT
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit & Legal Services
Kaczmarek 3,600.00
438 FUND COVELESKI BOND
J.E.M Morris Construction, Inc
Ziolkowski Construction, Inc.
Larson - Danielson Construction Inc.
Daktronics, Inc
672,843.75 Coveleski Stadium
153,605.70 Coveleski Stadium Improvements
601,999.57 Coveleski Stadium
47,634.00 Coveleski Stadium Scoreboard
$ 2,483,120.88
Upon a motion by Ms. King, seconded by Mr. Downes
and unanimously carried, the Commission approved the
Claims submitted May 24, 2011, and ordered checks to
be released.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
A. Communication from South Bend Common
Council regarding proposed additional funds
for animal shelter at 521 Eclipse Place.
Mr. Inks noted that two communications were
received related to the proposed animal shelter.
The first was from seven members of the Common
Council. Mr. Inks summarized the following letter
at the meeting, which letter is included below in its
entirety.
May 25, 2011
Marcia I. Jones, President
Dr. David Varner, Vice - President
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS
SUBMITTED MAY 24, 201 1, AND ORDERED
CHECKS TO BE RELEASED.
COMMUNICATION FROM SOUTH BEND COMMON
COUNCIL
Erskine Detention Construction
17,051.25
Observation
3,978.00
1505 Prairie Ave
792.01
748 Hawbaker & 4215 Main St.
56,967.41
Erskine Detention Pond
South Main St./ Lafayette Blvd
51,909.09
Connector
Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit & Legal Services
Kaczmarek 3,600.00
438 FUND COVELESKI BOND
J.E.M Morris Construction, Inc
Ziolkowski Construction, Inc.
Larson - Danielson Construction Inc.
Daktronics, Inc
672,843.75 Coveleski Stadium
153,605.70 Coveleski Stadium Improvements
601,999.57 Coveleski Stadium
47,634.00 Coveleski Stadium Scoreboard
$ 2,483,120.88
Upon a motion by Ms. King, seconded by Mr. Downes
and unanimously carried, the Commission approved the
Claims submitted May 24, 2011, and ordered checks to
be released.
4. COMMUNICATIONS
A. Communication from South Bend Common
Council regarding proposed additional funds
for animal shelter at 521 Eclipse Place.
Mr. Inks noted that two communications were
received related to the proposed animal shelter.
The first was from seven members of the Common
Council. Mr. Inks summarized the following letter
at the meeting, which letter is included below in its
entirety.
May 25, 2011
Marcia I. Jones, President
Dr. David Varner, Vice - President
COMMISSION APPROVED THE CLAIMS
SUBMITTED MAY 24, 201 1, AND ORDERED
CHECKS TO BE RELEASED.
COMMUNICATION FROM SOUTH BEND COMMON
COUNCIL
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Nancy King, Secretary
Gregory Downes, Member
Donald Alford, Member
Stephanie Spivey, School Board Representative
Redevelopment Commission
1200 County -City Building
227 West Jefferson Boulevard
South Bend, Indiana 46601
HAND - DELIVERED
Re: South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Agenda Item
6.C. Airport Economic Development Area
(4)Request from Code Enforcement for
Additional Funds For Construction ofAnimal
Shelter at 521 Eclipse Place
Dear Honorable Redevelopment Commission
Members:
In yesterday's front page article in the South Bend
Tribune, we read for the first time, that the "soft
costs, such as architect and engineering fees,
landscaping, the parking lot and furniture and
equipment "for the proposed animal shelter were
not included in the $1.5 million TIF dollar
appropriation, which you unanimously approved
for this project in February of 2010.
The undersigned members of the South Bend
Common Council respectfully request that the
Redevelopment Commission table today's requests
for an additional $300, 000 of TIF dollars for this
project.
We recognize that under Indiana state law, the
Redevelopment Commission is charged with
overseeing TIF dollars. However, in light of very
difficult economic challenges facing all of us, we
believe that all alternatives should be considered
before approving additional funds for the proposed
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
animal shelter.
Exploring other alternatives we believe would be
the prudent thing to do, especially since the
proposed construction of the animal shelter was to
be completed by December 2010. When the Board
of Public Works opened bids in June 2010, the bids
came in over budget and were rejected. Since
then, the plans were reviewed in order to seek
greater energy efficiencies.
In light of the 3rd phase of the St. Joseph County
Humane Society's 22, 000 square foot building
being worked on, we believe that discussions with
that organization would be appropriate.
Consolidation of duplicate services, especially
those paid with tax dollars, is a viable and feasible
goal. There is no doubt that our community needs
quality animal care and control services, as well as
a facility to house these animals.
We ask that the Redevelopment Commission accept
the challenge to work together with the Council in
addressing this need, so that the fiscal concerns of
the South Bend residents receive top priority. We
further request that this letter to read into the
record at today's Redevelopment Commission
meeting.
The Common Council extends an invitation to meet
with you at your earliest possible convenience to
discuss this important community issue in greater
detail. Thank you for your consideration.
Most sincerely,
Thomas LaFountain
3rd District Council
Al "Buddy" Kirsits
Council Member at Large
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Ann Puzzello
41h District Council
Timothy A. Rouse
Council Member at Large
Dr. David Varner
5`h District Council
Karen L. White
Council Member at Large
Oliver J. Davis
6`h District Council
B. Communication from Community Animal
Rescue Effort (CARE)
Mr. Inks noted that the Commission received the
following letter from CARE in support of funding
the additional expenses for the animal shelter.
May 24, 2011
Dear Ms. Jones, Dr. Varner and members of the
South Bend Redevelopment Commission:
1 am writing to express my support of the request
for an additional $300, 000 from the Airport
Economic TIF Fund for the construction of the new
South Bend Animal Care and Control (SBA CC)
facility.
Every year, the staff at the SBA CC Shelter
manages over 4, 000 animals. The officers, who
are available 2417, 365 days of the year, do their
best to answer all calls regarding stray animals,
lost animals, abused animals and neglected
animals. The kennel staff, that is available 7 days
a week, year round, does its best to provide
compassionate care for all the animals that find
their temporary home at the shelter.
7
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Unfortunately, for the staff and for the animals, the
current facility is extremely inadequate for the
work that they do.
Since we presented the project to you on February
19, 2010, there have been a number of issues that
have impacted our progress on this project. The
first delay came when the original bids for the
project came in over budget. As a result, the bid
specifications needed to be reviewed and revised in
order to accommodate this issue. Next, the city's
increased commitment to Leadership in
Environmental Energy and Design, or LEER
standards, required that we review and revise
many of the building specifications. Sadly, for us
and for the animals, these delays increased our soft
costs (i.e., architectural and engineering fees).
These delays bring us to today and the request you
have before you. As a South Bend taxpayer, I
appreciate the oversight and scrutiny your
committee applies to these requests. We all need
to be responsible stewards of the city's resources.
The reasons I hope you will be compelled to
support this request for additional funding are as
follows:
L SBACC manages over 4,000 animals each
year. Due to the severely limited holding space in
the current facility, we are faced with having to
euthanize approximately 65% of those animals
every year. Many of these animals are healthy,
adoptable animals that we simply can no longer
hold.
2. SBA CC welcomes thousands of visitors every
year. Sadly for our handicap visitors, our building
is not handicap accessible.
3. SBA CC has several structural issues as a
result of its age. For example, the building has
appalling drainage problems due to the aging
plumbing.
4. Another issue with the building is the lack of
8
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
adequate ventilation and airflow. Air flow and
ventilation become a particular problem when
there are sick animals in the shelter. Many of the
common pathogens that affect animals are
airborne pathogens. Without adequate airflow
and/or the space to quarantine sick animals,
diseases spread rapidly throughout the building.
1 respectfully ask for your support today to help
make South Bend a model city for animal welfare:
a city that can balance safety in our neighborhoods
while providing humane treatment of animals. Our
goals for the new shelter are:
1. Increase adoptions and reduce euthanasia by
offering the best care for our animals and people.
2. Reduce stress to keep our animals healthier,
happier and more adoptable.
3. Prevent disease to keep our animals from
getting sick, thereby reducing euthanasia.
4. Create warm and welcoming facilities to
provide the best customer service possible and
bring in more potential adopters.
S. Allow more opportunities for socialization
between people and animals so they can bond
more quickly, thereby increasing adoptions.
6. Focus on education and prevention to address
the root causes of animal abuse, homelessness,
abandonment and overpopulation.
7. Create a more efficient and healthy work space
so we can do our work more effectively.
8. Become a better neighbor by being quieter,
more aesthetically pleasing, and more
environmentally friendly.
Thank you for your time and consideration of my
request.
Sincerely,
Valerie Schey
Founder and President
6
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
CARE of South Bend
Mr. Inks suggested moving item 6.C.(4) up on the
agenda to consider it at this time. It is the subject of
these two Communications. There was no objection and
the item was moved.
6. NEW BUSINESS
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(4) Request from Code Enforcement for
additional funds for construction of
Animal Shelter at 521 Eclipse Place
Mr. Downes said he believes that any
decision about privatizing the services of
animal control is the responsibility of the
Mayor, his administration and the Common
Council, not the responsibility of the
Redevelopment Commission. He agrees that
if they need to reevaluate the city's
commitment to providing its own animal
control, now is the time to do it.
Mr. Varner noted that the Council is not
questioning the quality of the South Bend
Animal Control operation. The St. Joseph
County Humane Society is building a new
facility. Perhaps it is time to consider again
having a combined facility. The anticipated
cost of $1,800,000 for South Bend's new
building may not be the final cost. Also, the
initial costs are minimal; the on -going
maintenance costs over the course of 20 or
30 years are extraordinary. He thinks the city
should evaluate the efficiencies of combining
operations with the Humane Society before
proceeding with constructing this new
facility.
Mr. Inks indicated that the Commissioners
10
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
wish to table action on this item until the
issue is resolved, but offered Ms. Toppel an
opportunity to make her presentation.
Ms. Toppel noted that the city received a
proposal from the Humane Society in March
of 2010 for combining operations. The
proposal was that the city would maintain its
current facility and current employees and
transport animals to the Humane Society. In
addition to an annual contract fee, the city
would pay a fee per animal transferred to the
Humane Society. The Humane Society
would keep all revenues from licensing,
reclaimed animals and adoptions. Ms.
Toppel, Gary Libby, Valerie Schey of CARE
and Mayor Luecke, met to consider the
propopsal. The proposal would cost the city
more per year than operating our own
facility. The current facility is in need of
major repairs. The suggestion to keep that
facility running is not an option. Ms. Toppel
stressed that the proposal is not something
the city has not considered. She does not
believe it requires additional time to
consider. It is urgent to begin construction
of a new facility.
Ms. Toppel reported that the initial estimate
for construction of the new shelter was
$5,000,000. At that time is was an educated
guess as to how much was going to be
needed. Code Enforcement /Animal Control
did not have building plans in hand at that
time because it did not have the funds to pay
the architect for building plans. They pared
the project down to a cost of $1,500,000, an
actual engineering estimate, then went out for
bid in June 2010. The bids came in over
budget. There was one contractor out of Ft.
Wayne who came in very close to the
estimate, however, they've since had issues
11
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
with regards to union and equipment failure;
therefore, we were not interested in using
that company. The next highest bid was
$200,000 over the $1,500,000. Staff then
looked at every aspect of the bid and tried to
pare costs further. Then the city hired
Jonathon Burke as the Energy Director for
the City of South Bend. Animal Control
worked with Jonathon Burke and Carl Littrell
from Engineering to find additional savings.
When all was said and done they were
looking at an overall reduction of 50% in
energy costs over the life of the building.
But ultimately the cost to construct the
building was the same.
Ms. Toppel noted that the $1,500,000 didn't
include all the soft costs for landscaping
(required by the rezoning) and for furniture
and fixtures. That is the reason we're back
before the Commission today for an
additional $300,000 which includes
everything that we've paid for to date:
architects, engineers, rezoning, and board of
zoning appeals. This additional $300,000
will make the final cost of the shelter
$1,800,000.
Mr. Inks thanked Ms. Toppel for that
presentation. Based on the Council's request
that this item be tabled for further
investigation, the Commission wished to
table the item.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission tabled item 6.0 (4)
5. OLD BUSINESS
There was no Old Business.
12
COMMISSION TABLED ITEM 6.0 (4)
THERE WAS NO OLD BUSINESS
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
6. NEW BUSINESS
A. Housing
(1) Loan and Grant in connection with the
South Bend Home Improvement Program
for property located at 1020 S. Grant
Street (Sharon James)
Mr. Inks noted that the loan is for $2,700.
The grant is $2,550.
Upon a motion by Ms. King, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Loan and Grant in
connection with the South Bend Home
Improvement Program for property located at
1020 S. Grant Street (Sharon James)
B. South Bend Central Development Area
(1) Commercial Lease for property located at
117 S. Michigan Street (Imagine That!)
Ms. Jennings noted that Imagine That! was
one of the pop -up holiday retailers. The
intent for the holiday pop -up shops was to
generate permanent occupancy in the
Redevelopment Retail vacant storefronts.
Imagine That! has agreed to a one -year lease
with the Redevelopment Commission, The
terms the staff plans to present to Imagine
That! are:
- 12 month lease term beginning 6/1/11, and
ending 5/31/12.
- base rent will be the greater of 10% of
gross sales or the minimum monthly amount
starting at $150 and increasing $50 each
month until month five.
- for months six through twelve, the base
13
COMMISSION APPROVED THE LOAN AND GRANT
IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOUTH BEND HOME
IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 1020 S. GRANT STREET (SHARON
JAMES)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
rent will be the greater of 10% of gross sales
or a minimum monthly amount of $453.46.
This set rent schedule includes Common
Area Maintenance (CAM).
- Imagine That will be responsible for
payment of all utilities.
- Either party will have the option to
terminate the lease at any time with a 30 -day
written notice to the other party.
Mr. Inks noted that the Commission
approved the terms of this lease at a previous
meeting. This lease is a draft, but
incorporates the terms already approved.
Staff recommends approval, subject to final
legal review.
Mr. Varner asked if utilities were in the name
of the lessor or lessee. Ms. Jennings
responded that the utilities will be in the
name of the lessor. The lessee will reimburse
the Commission. Mr. Varner suggested that
the Commission could get stuck with
unreimbursed utility expenses. He would
prefer to have the utilities in the name of
Imagine That!
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Commercial Lease
with Imagine That! for property located at
117 S. Michigan Street, subject to final legal
review.
(2) Downtown South Bend Window Galleries
Proposal
Ms. Nicholl -Smith noted that DTSB is
proposing a pilot program to fill the windows
of two spaces of the Michigan Street shops.
If it turns out to be something people enjoy,
then maybe the city would extend it to other
14
COMMISSION APPROVED THE COMMERCIAL
LEASE WITH IMAGINE THAT! FOR PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 1 17 S. MICHIGAN STREET, SUBJECT
TO FINAL LEGAL REVIEW
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
landowners in downtown. It's a proposal to
make the window spaces available to local
artists or art organizations for a temporary
window gallery. These are being used both
in Chicago as part of Pop -up Art Week and
in Evanston as part of Art Under Glass.
Downtown South Bend would like to create a
visual continuum for people when walking
from point A to point B. DTSB will follow
the Art Under Glass model because what
works about that one is other than swapping
out a painting occasionally, there is no other
access to the space. They just get the
window. We talk about downtown being a
cultural arts destination, so we will start this
up by July and have it running through Art
Beat.
The lease contains a 14 -day notice to vacate
clause included so that if a lease - paying
tenant is found, we only need to give 14
days' notice. Evanston, Illinois has done this
for some time. We have all their paperwork,
a very simple lease which details the artist's
responsibilities. It's the artist's responsibility
to take care of installation. It generates
excitement and we hope it continues to shine
good light on the shops in downtown and
shows downtown as the place to locate if you
want to be around creative innovative
environment.
Mr. Varner asked if there are hard costs. Ms.
Nicholl -Smith responded that there are no
hard costs and DTSB will be working with
CB Richard Ellis to make the sign for the
window. One of the DTSB Board members
has offered to do the graphic design for the
artist's sign for free.
Mr. Downes asked if the program is
successful do we plan to do it beyond
15
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
September. Ms. Nicholl -Smith responded
that Evanston only allows an artist three
months. They must move out, but could do a
window again later.
Ms. King asked whether the artist takes all
responsibility for the safety of his work. Mr.
Leone responded that we should be able to
protect ourselves with the right disclaimer
language in the lease. Ms. Nicholl -Smith
added that she will recommend to the artist
that they insure their work against theft.
Mr. Alford asked whether there will be any
guidelines for the type of art. Ms. Nicholl-
Smith replied that the rules of public art will
apply. We're planning to ask the South Bend
Museum of Art to display for the first round,
then maybe individual artists after that. She
assured the Commission that DTSB will
make sure that there's nothing displayed that
would be distasteful.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Downtown South
Bend Window Galleries Proposal.
(3) Proposal for professional services for
improvements in the Downtown Medical
Services District
Mr. Gibney noted that staff solicited a
proposal from The Troyer Group to prepare
preliminary design concepts for further
improvements in and around the Memorial
Hospital campus, to create a unified look for
Memorial owned buildings: the Memorial
Office Center, Nursing Education Building,
and the former MarMain Pharmacy along the
eastern side of Michigan Street, and the
Skywalk connecting the hospital with the
i
COMMISSION APPROVEDTHE DOWNTOWN
SOUTH BEND WINDOW GALLERIES PROPOSAL.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Office Center. The proposal is in the amount
of $14,900 and would be paid for from the
Medical TIF. The subsequent investment
that will follow will also come from the
medical TIF.
The Memorial Campus is the gateway to
downtown South Bend. It's a huge complex
and is sometimes hard for people driving in
to town to find their way around. The new
main entrance to Memorial Hospital is on
Bartlett Street, formerly a small residential
street. The city has been doing a lot of
infrastructure work around Memorial lately.
Mr. Gibney distributed a map showing recent
improvements around Memorial, upcoming
improvements, and the improvements being
requested in this proposal. The
improvements include curbs and sidewalks,
landscaping, lighting and building facades. It
is our goal to complete the work around the
Memorial Campus by 2012 so that we have a
nice look along the gateway coming into
town. The Downtown Medical TIF district
has an expiration date of 2017 or 2018. We
may be able to dissolve it sooner.
Staff requests approval today to hire The
Troyer Group to begin doing design concepts
that will unify the east side of that street.
Once we decide on those designs we'll come
back to the Redevelopment Commission for
the funding and appropriation.
Mr. Varner suggested that the Commission
consider extending the boundary and/or the
end date of the Medical TIF district to be
able to make improvements in Leeper Park.
The Park Department has difficulty finding
resources to make the improvements needed.
Mr. Gibney indicated that he would love to
do that. He agreed they are needed and that
17
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
the Park Department does not have the
resources to make them. Staff will look into
the possibility of funding the improvements
with TIF.
Mr. Gibney noted that as part of the existing
Medical TIF resources staff would like the
Commission to consider setting aside
$300,000 to participate in a $1.6M expansion
of the South Bend Civic Theater classroom
space. Ms. King questioned whether the
Commission would want to set a precedent of
contributing to a building campaign for a
non - profit agency. Mr. Gibney responded
that we have done so in the past, citing Ivy
Tech and WHIT as examples. The critical
criteria are location and neighborhood
revitalization. Our legal department would
need to determine if the expenditure fits the
law.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission accepted the proposal from The
Troyer Group for professional services in the
amount of $14,900 for the Downtown
Medical Services District.
(4) Resolution No. 2878 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement. (621 E.
Jefferson Streetscape Modernization
Project)
Mr. Schalliol noted that Resolution No. 2878
approves an addendum to the Master Agency
Agreement for curb and sidewalk work in
front of the new location for Michiana Lock
& Key and will serve as a complement to the
work being done to renovate their new
building. The design work has generally
18
COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE PROPOSAL FROM
THE TROYER GROUP FOR PROFESSIONAL
SERVICES IN THE AMOUNT OF $14,900 FOR THE
DOWNTOWN MEDICAL SERVICES DISTRICT
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
been completed as part of the Jefferson
Boulevard Streetscape Modernization Design
but the need for this contract is to modify the
plan scope to limit the documents only to this
parcel.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2878
approving and authorizing the execution of
an amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement for work at 621
E. Jefferson in the amount of $34,000.
(5) Consent to Assignment of Lease and
Release (131 S. Michigan Street, Bruno's
Pizza)
Ms. Jennings noted that the Redevelopment
Commission entered into a Lease Agreement
with Bruno Cataldo d/b /a Bruno's Pizza on
August 1, 2010. Mr. Cataldo has decided to
turn the business over to his business
associate, James Weldy d/b /a J. Weldy, LLC.
J. Weldy, LLC will assume all
responsibilities and terms stated in the Lease
Agreement with Bruno's Pizza.
Staff recommends approval of the Consent to
Assignment of Lease and Release.
Mr. Varner questioned whether the business
will still be operated as a Bruno's Pizza and
whether Mr. Weldy has operated other
Bruno's Pizza restaurants. Ms. Jennings
responded that it will still be operated as a
Bruno's Pizza. Ms. Psaros of CB Richard
Ellis added that Mr. Weldy is currently the
General Manager of the Bruno's downtown
and he worked at the main location for
several years.
19
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION N0. 2878
APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT FOR WORK AT
621 E. JEFFERSON IN THE AMOUNT OF $34,000.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED THE CONSENT TO
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the ASSIGNMENT OF LEASE AND RELEASE (131 S.
Commission approved the Consent to MICHIGAN STREET, BRUNO'S PIZZA)
Assignment of Lease and Release (131 S.
Michigan Street, Bruno's Pizza)
C. Airport Economic Development Area
(1) Proposal for general environmental
consulting services
Mr. Inks noted that the proposal from Hull &
Associates, Inc. is contracted as Not to
Exceed $25,000. The city has used Hull for
several years to do general consulting
services at the Oliver Plow Industrial Park
and Ignition Park site and this would
continue that arrangement. Hull knows our
properties very well. Staff recommends
approval
Upon a motion by Ms. King, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the proposal for Hull
& Associates, Inc. for general environmental
consulting services.
(2) Resolution No. 2880 setting a public
hearing on the appropriation of tax
increment financing
Ms. Leonard noted that Resolution No. 2880
sets a public hearing for 4;00 p.m., June 14,
2011 to review the possible appropriation not
to exceed $8,500,000 in the Airport TIF.
There are a lot of projects on the board and
additional money is needed.
Mr. Inks noted that in previous years the
Commission appropriated all the funds
available in each TIF area and, particularly in
the Airport TIF, staff would be unable to
9C
COMMISSION APPROVED THE PROPOSAL FOR
HULL & ASSOCIATES, INC. FOR GENERAL
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING SERVICES.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
accomplish all the projects for which funds
were appropriated. This year the Controller
asked staff to be more realistic in is expected
work program and appropriate only what it
thought it could accomplish. Today we're
coming back for an additional appropriation
because we have already contracted for the
work in original appropriation and expect we
can get more done this year. The
Commission has approved and we have
contracts that are pending subject to this
coming appropriation that would actually use
about half of the additional $8,500,000 that
we've identified here. So these aren't things
that we hope to do, these are things that are
actually happening.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by
Mr. Alford and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2880
setting a public hearing on the appropriation
of tax increment financing for 4:00 p.m.,
June 14, 2011.
(3) Easement and Right of Way for Indiana
Michigan Power along two properties in
Oliver Industrial Park.
Mr. Sikora noted that there are two
"Requests of Easement & Right of Way"
from Indiana Michigan Power for two
properties located in Oliver Industrial Park.
The purpose of the easements is for the
installation of electrical utilities. These two
requests have been reviewed by legal counsel
and vetted through the Department of Public
Works.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved the Easement and
Right of Way for Indiana Michigan Power
21
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2880
SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE
APPROPRIATION OF TAX INCREMENT FINANCING
FOR 4:00 P.M., JUNE 14, 2011
COMMISSION APPROVEDTHE EASEMENT AND
RIGHT OF WAY FOR INDIANA MICHIGAN POWER
ALONG TWO PROPERTIES IN OLIVER INDUSTRIAL
PARK.
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
along two properties in Oliver Industrial
Park.
(5) Resolution No. 2877 approving and
authorizing the execution of an
amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement. (ZCI
Demolition Inspection Services, former
Stokowski building on Lafayette).
Mr. Schalliol noted that as the city prepares
for demolition of the former Ziolkowski
Construction properties, the city needs some
additional outside services and staff to
provide environmental oversight. Wightman
Petrie has submitted a proposal in the amount
of $9,300 to provide such services. They are
also performing similar services during the
demolition of the AirGas property,
previously approved by the Commission.
Staff requests approval of Resolution
No. 2877.
Upon a motion by Ms. King, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2877
approving and authorizing the execution of
an amendment to the Addendum to the
Master Agency Agreement. (ZCI Demolition
Inspection Services, former Stokowski
building on Lafayette).
(6) Resolution No. 2882 approving and
authorizing the execution of an Addendum
to the Master Agency Agreement (Schaffer
Gear Metronet Conduit Project).
Mr. Inks noted and reported that staff is
requesting $60,000 for conduit to bring
Metronet services to Schafer Gear Works.
Currently the conduit ends at Moreau Court.
22
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION NO. 2877
APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
OF AN AMENDMENT TO THE ADDENDUM TO THE
MASTER AGENCY AGREEMENT. (ZCI
DEMOLITION INSPECTION SERVICES, FORMER
STOKOWSKI BUILDING ON LAFAYETTE)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
This project would extend the conduit down
Nimtz Parkway to Schafer Gear. It would
also make the Metronet accessible to other
businesses between Moreau Court and
Schafer Gear.
You may recall Schafer Gear (or related
entities) recently received approval for tax
abatement on a project approaching $18
million of new investment that was both real
property and new building as well as a large
amount of equipment put in that building.
There will be 26 new jobs created in the next
two years. This is part of the city's
investment for that project.
Mr. Varner noted that this is the sixth or
seventh year of construction on the Metronet.
He feels they should begin paying a lease or
fee of some kind to the city as do Comcast
and AT &T. Mr. Inks responded that as part
of the agreement between the city and
Metronet, Metronet is required to provide the
city a certain numbers of pairs (32).
Mr. Downes questioned the extension
beyond Schafter Gear. Mr. Inks responded
that it is in various parts of the corporate
office park, but the eastern part of Nimtz
still needs the Metronet to be extended down
to serve the other businesses.
Upon a motion by Mr. Varner, seconded by
Mr. Downes and unanimously carried, the
Commission approved Resolution No. 2882
approving and authorizing the execution of
an Addendum to the Master Agency
Agreement (Schaffer Gear Metronet Conduit
Project).
D. West Washington- Chapin Development Area
23
COMMISSION APPROVED RESOLUTION No. 2882
APPROVING AND AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION
OF AN ADDENDUM TO THE MASTER AGENCY
AGREEMENT (SCHAFFER GEAR METRONET
CONDUIT PROJECT)
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
There was no business in the West Washington -
Chapin Development Area
E. South Side Development Area
There was no business in the West Washington -
Chapin Development Area.
F. Northeast Neighborhood Development Area
There was no business in the South Side
Development Area.
G. Douglas Road Economic Development Area
There was no business in the Northeast
Neighborhood Development Area.
H. Ratification of Services Contracts
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr.
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission
24
COMMISSION RATIFIED THE SERVICES
CONTRACTS APPROVED BY STAFF SINCE MAY 10,
Commission
Role in
Service
Contract
Staff
Transaction
Contractor
Provided
Amount
Member
1518 Chapin
Acquisition
Michaels
Appraisal
$350
Relos
Appraisal Service
1513 S Chapin
Acquisition
Michaels
Appraisal
$350
Relos
Appraisal Service
604 S. Scott St
Acquisition
Michaels
Appraisal
$1,775
Sikora
Millenium
Appraisal Services
Environmental
604 S. Scott St
Acquisition
R.E. Pitts &
Appraisal
$1,750
Sikora
Millenium
Assoc.
Environmental
622 E. Sample St
Acquisition
Michaels
Appraisal
$400
Schalliol
Appraisal Services
622 E Sample St.
Acquisition
Witt Appraisal
Appraisal
$!
Services
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by Mr.
Varner and unanimously carried, the Commission
24
COMMISSION RATIFIED THE SERVICES
CONTRACTS APPROVED BY STAFF SINCE MAY 10,
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
ratified the Services Contracts approved by staff 2011
since May 10, 2011
I. Other
(1) Engagement Letter from Sopko,
Nussbaum, Inabnit and Kaczmarek for
outside legal counsel.
Ms. Leonard Inks noted that the Commission
has expended the $60,000 previously
approved for outside legal counsel. This
Engagement Letter approves an additional
$60,000 for legal services to assist staff in
some of its legal issues in the various TIF
areas.
Mr. Varner asked if this was additional
appropriation for 2011, meaning we could
spend $120,000 annually. Ms. Leonard Inks
responded that each $60,000 typically covers
more than one year. This is the first contract
for legal services in the year 2011.
Upon a motion by Mr. Downes, seconded by COMMISSION APPROVED THE ENGAGEMENT
Mr. Varner and unanimously carried, the LETTER FOR SOPKO, NUSSBAUM, INABNIT AND
Commission approved the Engagement KACZMAREK FOR OUTSIDE LEGAL COUNSEL.
Letter for Sopko, Nussbaum, Inabnit and
Kaczmarek for outside legal counsel.
7. PROGRESS REPORTS
Mr. Inks noted that there are two progress reports. One PROGRESS REPORTS
on the Morris fountain. The pumps have been repaired.
But when they were putting them in they realized there
was more work to be done; the pit they go into had to be
cleaned up at the cost of about $2,800. That was an
additional costs that the Commission will be picking up.
Mr. Inks reported on the property the City is buying for
a right -of -way. In the AEDA strategy there is a line
item for the extension of Olive Road north to Adams
25
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Road. There is currently no Olive Road in that stretch.
We want to put one in as part of the long -term
transportation plan for the development of Blackthorn
and the Portage Prairie development creating a new
north/south corridor. The property required to construct
the extended Olive Road is outside the city limits. It is,
therefore, being acquired through the Board of Public
Works, but the Board of Public Works would be using
TIF funds. There is a scheduled closing for this property
May 26, 2011, and we haven't come to the Commission
yet to do an Addendum to the Master Agency
Agreement requesting the Board of Public Works to act
on its behalf. But the project is moving forward. We're
at the point where we need to buy it. Mr. Inks wanted to
bring that to the Commission's attention before the
closing. Staff will be coming back the next meeting
with a retroactive action to be taken unless you have
concerns about proceeding at this point.
Mr. Varner asked what resources were being used to pay
for the acquisition and extension. Mr. Inks responded
that they will be TIF resources. Mr. Varner expressed
concern about an audit. Mr. Inks responded that our
legal department is looking at the legalities. The
anticipation is that we'll use TIF funds to close on this.
Approximately $269,000 for the Right of Way for
approximately 269,000 square feet. Funds are
appropriated.
8. NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
The next meeting of the Redevelopment Commission is NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
scheduled for Tuesday, June 14, 2011 at 4:00 p.m.
9. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business to come before the ADJOURNMENT
Redevelopment Commission, Ms. King made a motion
that the meeting be adjourned. Mr. Downes seconded
the motion and the meeting was adjourned at 4:55 p.m.
26
South Bend Redevelopment Commission
Regular Meeting —May 24, 2011
Donald E. Inks, Director
27