HomeMy WebLinkAbout03-08-10 Utilities~. ,` ~~~~
`°~R •~ Utilities Committee
2010 South Bend Common Council
The March 8, 2010 meeting of the Utilities Committee was called to order by its Chairperson,
Council Member Oliver J. Davis at 4:33 p.m. in the Council Informal Meeting Room.
Persons in attendance included Council Members Dieter, Puzzello, Varner, Oliver J. Davis, Rouse,
Kirsits and White; Mayor Stephen J. Luecke, Public Works Director Gary Gilot, Rita Kopola,Tom
Price, Dr. Jack Dillon, Dave Tungate, Jeff Parrott of the South Bend Tribune and Council Attorney
Kathleen Cekanski-Farrand.
Council Member Oliver J. Davis noted that the Committee consists of Council Members Kirsits,
Puzzello, LaFountain and himself.
Public Works Director Gary Gilot requested that the Utility Committee hear the presentation from
Mr. Tungate first.
Bureau of Water Works Update:
Council Member Oliver J. Davis called for a presentation from Dave Tungate, Director of the
Bureau of Water Works with offices loated at 209 North Main Street, Suite 207 in downtown South
Bend.
Mr. Tungate displayed old and new water meters to the Committee members. He noted that the
1960's technology is being replaced with new technology which enables the Bureau of Water
Works to take readings via radio signals. The new devices will also indicate if it has been tampered
with, whether there are leaks, flows, etc. There are a total of 42,000 water meters. 14,000 are
currently in the process of being replaced and an additional 14,000 are scheduled to be replaced.
Some one at least 18 years of age must be home to let the Water Works employee into the basement
to make the replace. The process takes about ten (10) minutes. Water meter exchanges can begin as
early as 7:30 am. He offered to show the Council Members how the exchange is done. He added
that appointments can also be made for this to take place on Saturday mornings beginning at 8 am.
Mr. Tungate stated that they are starting in the farthest portions in the northern and southern parts
of the city. About 45 meter exchanges are being done daily with that anticipated to be increased to
60 meter exchanges per day. 600 were completed in February 2010, and 1,000 are projected to be
completed this month. Each new water meter is equipment with a battery which has a life of
seventeen (17) years.
Mr. Tungate also stated that the Bureau of Water Works is implementing a new telephone system
which will enable customers to make payments over the phone, etc.
Council Member Oliver J. Davis thanked Mr. Tungate for his report and asked that he continue to
share information with his Committee on activities of the Bureau of Water Works.
Utilities Committee
March 8, 2010
Page 2
Proposed Sewer Rate Increase -Part 2 of 3:
Public Works Director Gary Gilot noted that a 27-slide handout was provided to the Council on
March 4th (copy attached). That power point presentation was then given highlighting:
• 20 year investment in the Wastewater Utility Operations
• Today's Utility Committee meeting is the 2°d of three scheduled meetings which will forcus
on the needs for 2011 -2014
• Summarized and described In Progress CSO LTCP
• Summarized and described Separation Projects in progress in the Kennedy Park area,
Twyckenham, Pleasant Street Phase 2, Diamond Avenue & north of Lincoln Way West near
Bendix
• Summarized and described CSO LTCP Operations Improvements Report and Status Report
• Summarized and described Phase lA and 1B Projects
• Described Wastewater Treatment Plant Upgrades which aze needed
• Highlighted some of the public education and outreach proposed on green solutions
• Purpose of the 3ra planned Utility Meeting which will be scheduled once the rate study is
completed on costs and rates
During the power-point presentation, Mr. Gilot noted that penalties of $27,5000 per day could be
imposed by the EPA for violations. He noted that Lawson-Fisher prepared the overall Master Plan
for the project and helped develop the various phases.
Council Member Oliver J. Davis requested summaries on other Indiana cities and how they are
addresses these same concerns mandated by the federal government.
Dr. Varner inquired whether the Green Ribbon Panel was being used. lvir. Gilot stated that they are
being used for suggestions, however they are using their consultants primarily.
Dr. Varner stated that he believes that the University of Notre Dame will result in receiving a
compounded benefit with across the board rate increases. Mr. Gilot stated that he sees it as a
balancing of various component parts.
Mayor Luecke noted that all of this is the result of the passed by Congress of the Clean Water Act.
Mr. Gilot stated that the Mayor did not want adouble-digit increase in any one year. He is looking
at a 9% increase each yeaz for four (4) years. This would result in the 1St year of a $.30 increase per
day and would generate about $17 million over the 4-year period.
Dr. Varner stated that the Common Council must have choices and suggested that the City
Administration provide data to the Council for more than just a 9% increase. He would like to see
what a 6.5% 7% 8% increase would generate in light of shifting priorities.
Utilities Committee
March 8, 2010
Page 3
In response to a question from Council Member Oliver J. Davis, Mr. Gilot stated that the rates and
priorities should be established on a cost/benefit analysis.
Council Member Kirists noted that it is his understanding that the streets may have to be swept
better in light of some of the proposals being made.
Mr. Gilot stated that "Best Management Practices" will be utilize rit is
evident in the Spring on the city streets. "Smart Valves" will helf
In response to a question from Council Member Rouse, .ewer
infrastructures are being built outside of the city for the past 2-3 ; CSO
Advisory Committee in existence. He added that once the Def omes
involved that individual Congressman are limited. -------_____ ___ __ __
Dr. Varner disagreed by stating that communities need to push back. Congress mandated
requirements through enabling legislation and authorized the EPA to develop the specifics. The
EPA then developed regulations. If Congress received updates from cities and towns on these EPA
regulations and the costs Congress would get involved, but without these updates they have limited
information on what the EPA is doing.
Council Member Oliver J. Davis asked that if any Council Member has further inquiries before the
3`d formal meeting is scheduled that they should send them to him. He thanked Mr. Gilot for his
update.
There being no further business to come before the Committee, Council Member Davis adjourned
the Committee meeting at 5:42 p.m.
Attachments