Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutChange Order No. 3 - Marriott Hotel Site Development at Hall of Fame Phase I Proj No 116-021 - Majority Builders1316 COUNTY -CITY BUILDING 227 W. JEFFERSON BOULEVARD SOUTH BEND. INDIANA 46601-1830 CITY OF SOUTH BEND PETE BUTTIGIEG, MAYOR BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS November 22, 2016 Matt Flick Majority Builders, Inc. 62900 US 31 South South Bend, IN 46614 PHONE 574/235-9251 FAX 574/235-9171 RE: Change Order No. 3 — Marriott Hotel Site Development at Hall of Fame, Phase I Project No. 116-021 Dear Mr. Flick: The Board of Public Works, at its meeting held on November 22, 2016, approved the above referenced Change Order for an increase of $1,267.49, bringing the current contract amount to $820,196.87. Enclosed is a copy of the Change Order for your records. If you have any further questions regarding this matter, please call this office at (574) 235- 9251. Sincerely, Linda M. Martin, Clerk Enclosure c: Rich Estes, Engineering Corbitt Kerr, Engineering Jitin Kain, Engineering GARY A. GILOT SUZANNA M. FRITZBERG ELIZABETH A. MARADIK JAMES A. MUELLER THERESE J. DORAU CITY OF SOUTH BEND DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PROJECT CHANGE ORDER DATE: PROJECT NO: PROJECT NAME: CONTRACT DATE: CHANGE ORDER NO. SUBJECT OF CHANGE ORDER: All items completed substantially as See attached Comparison of Fstim, etyou rhB�� b U O Y 1865 11-22-2016 116-021 Marriott Hotel Site Development at the Hall of Fame Phase I 6-28-2016 :5 Cost of additional work See attached explanation of work The original contract sum Net change by previously authorized change orders The contract sum prior to this change order By this Change Order, the project amount is The new contract sum including this change order This Change Order represents a total change of Total change for entire project and ® Increased ❑ Decreased $ 731,348.93 $ 87,580.45 $ 818,929.38 $ 1,267.49 $ 820,196.87 0.17 % 12.15 % Original contracted completion date/time 10-1-2016 Extension of date/time by previous change orders 27 days Date/time extension by this change order 0 days New completion date/time 10-28-2016 RECOMMENDED FOR APPROVAL CONTRACTOR Contractor Signature Printed Name and Title Majority Builders, Inc. Company name 62900 US 31 South 46614 Address South Bend Indiana City, State, Zip Project Manager CITY OF SOUTH BEND BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS Approved Date: Gary A. Gilo , President Elizabeth A. Maradik, Member Therese J. Dorau,Vembet James A. Mueller, Member Suzanna IfFritzberg, M(Onber INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS DIVISION OF ENGINEERING TO: Linda M. Martin, Clerk Board of Public Works FROM: Richard Estes, Engineer I SUBJECT: Marriott Hotel Site Development at Hall of Fame, Phase 1 Final Change Order Project No. 116-021 DATE: November 22, 2016 Here is an explanation for the Change Order being submitted. The reason(s) for the Change Order request is as follows: 1. Additional costs were incurred during the project including changes to the foundation and slab design, changes to the elevator pit design, permit fee reimbursements per the redevelopment agreement, placement of protective fencing around the pool excavation, adding bends and thrust blocks to accommodate the shifted alignment of the water main extension, and removal of a manhole structure that had already been purchased by the contractor. 2. Credit back to the City from the over -run and under -run quantities. The cost for the work will be $9,957.82. The balance from the over -run under -run quantities is $8,690.33. The resulting contract increase is $1,267.49.This represents an increase of 0.17% for the overall project cost. Please call me with your questions (5896). Change Order No. 3 Marriott Hotel Site Development Phase 1 Project No. 116-021 OWNER: City of South Bend ENGINEER: JPR CONTRACTOR: Majority Builders Inc. PROJECT: Marriott Hotel Site Development Phase 1 SUBJECT: Change Order Number 3, Explanation of Costs ISSUE DATE: November 22, 2016 This Change Order to the Contract document shall supplement, amend, and shall become a part of, and be incorporated as an Addendum to the Contract. The following is a summary and description of the revisions to the Contract by this Change Order: Per a directive from the project architect, a slab of concrete was left out in the area of the kitchen due to unclear direction from the site owner. This will be addressed in Phase II construction. The resulting deduct from this change was $1,143.00 Per a directive from the project architect, the elevator pit depth was increase by 1 foot. This change required thickening of adjoining pier footings, additional excavation, an increased thickness of the foundation wall, waterproofing, rebar, forming, and concrete material. The resulting increase from this change was $1,851.00 To satisfy the redevelopment agreement, all permit fees were to be paid for as a part of this contract. These fees included two water tap fees ($5,137.00), building department plan review fee ($348.00), foundation permit ($40.00), and sewer permit ($102.00). The total reimbursement for these fees came to $5,627.00 To protect the pit that was left open in the area of the pool, the contractor was instructed to place snow fence around the border of the pool. The resulting increase from this work was $228.00 Due to a design change during construction, a manhole structure that had already been purchased by the contractor could no longer be used. The city paid for the purchase of this structure at a discounted rate due to the labor not being required to install the structure. The resulting cost of this was $1,938.00 During the tapping process for the water main on Jefferson, the proposed location of the tap needed to be adjusted to both accommodate the future placement of the AEP vaults that would service this building, as well as avoid an existing bell that was in the location of the proposed tap. This adjustment required additional material (bends, couplings, and thrust blocks) to bring the lateral alignment back to the proposed location. Also, existing utilities were encountered while laying the pipe that required flowable fill to be used to backfill underneath the utilities. The total cost for this work was $1,456.82. The final balance of the contract, including all over -run and under -run quantities and the costs noted SHEET 1 OF 2 Change Order No. 3 Marriott Hotel Site Development Phase 1 Project No. 116-021 above, resulted in a contract increase of $1,267.49. A copy of the contractor's justification of additional costs is attached to this document. The following sections of the Contract Documents are revised as a result of the above changes: BID/PROPOSAL: Add Line Item No. 63: Est. Qty. 1 LS, "Permit Fees', Unit Price of $5,627.00 LS, Total Cost: $5,627.00 Add Line Item No. 64: Est. Qty. 1 LS, "Fencing Around Pool Excavation", Unit Price of $228.00 LS, Total Cost: $228.00 Add Line Item No. 65: Est. Qty. 1 LS, "Delete MH 101, Furnish Temporary Drainage Structure", Unit Price of $1,938.00 per LS, Total Cost: $1,938.00 Add Line Item No. 66: Est. Qty. 1 LS, "Additional Water Main Material to Work Around Existing Bell", Unit Price of $1,098.90 per LS, Total Cost: $1,098.90 Add to Line Item No. 54: Est. Qty. 1 LS, "Building Foundation and Slab", Unit Price of $708.00 LS, Total Cost: $708.00 Add to Line Item No. 22: Est. Qty. 16 CYS, "Structural Backfill Type 2", Unit Price of $22.37 CYS, Total Cost: $357.92 Total additional costs: $9,957.82 Under -run Over -run Balance Prior to Change Order 3: $8,690.33 Total Change Order Request: Increase $1,267.49 END CHANGE ORDER 3 SHEET 2 OF 2 October 18, 2016 (REVISED Nov. 11) Marriott Hotel Site Development Phase 1 121 S. St. Joseph St South Bend, IN Change Order Proposal No. 3 PROJECT# 2016-190 1. Block out 27' x 48' area of concrete slab in kitchen area per architect directive at October 26 progress meeting. Deduct: $1,143.00 2. As directed by architect, change elevator pit depth from 4'to 5'. Also required thickening the adjoining pier footings P-1/F-9 by 12" in depth. This cost includes additional excavation, depth of 8" thick concrete foundation wall, waterproofing, rebar, forming and concrete material. Add: $1,851 3. Reimbursement for water tap fees (two each 6" taps) obtained by Majority Builders, Inc. Add: $5,137.00 4. Install barricade fencing around pool. Add: $228 5. Reimbursement for Building Department plan review fee ($348) and foundation permit ($40) obtained by Majority Builders, Inc. Add: $388.00 6. Delete manhole 101 (turn over to City of SB) and furnish temporary structure for storm drainage. Add: $1,938.00 7. Reimbursement for Building Department sewer permit obtained by Boettcher Excavating. Add: $102.00 Total of above... $8,501.00 ✓oha 4819ef *tv BEWM b EXCAdAnM CONTRACTOR 3305 NORTH HOME STREET .MISHAWAKA, INDIANA46545 PHONE: (574) 259-1418 FAX: (574) 259-1417 November 16, 2016 Majority Builders, Inc. Matt Flick 62900 U.S. 31 South Bend, IN 46614 Matt, We are respectively submitting for your consideration for reimbursement of the additional cost we incurred, over and above contract line items, for the installation of the fire and domestic water supply for the Marriott due to the fact that an electric underground vault was buried as part of the City of South Bends streetscapes project occurring around the Marriott project. All saw cut was done at the time of the mobilization for clearing and grubbing and had to be re -sawed at a later date due the changes that had to be made to install the water utilities. Based upon the original plans we marked the pavement for saw cut between the time the pavement was sawed and the time of installation of the utilities, the vault was installed in the path of the new water. Once we excavated to the main we found that a bell existed in the water line we needed to tap. By the City of South Bend's spec we had to move the proposed taps locations away from the existing bell which also caused additional removals. With a time frame we needed to keep because of the streetscapes project and a scheduled reopening of Jefferson required by the streetscape project, our crew put in a 12 hour day on that Wednesday. We mobed in a saw subcontractor that had to travel from a job in Fort Wayne, removed the pavement and was ready for taps as scheduled for Thursday morning. As we were able, we proceeded in to the property and ran into many unmarked utilities, as many as 17 in a 15' long span of our trench (please see photos attached). This is nowhere near what is common in Downtown South Bend. At that time on Thursday the utilities were so tight together we needed a vac truck to speed the job along to be ready the next day for pavement by the next morning as scheduled. Once the new water was laid thru out of the r/w we began backfill. Since pavement replacement was to be 8:00 am, a decision was made to flow fill under all of the utilities as a time savings advantage. Even with all of the efforts, our crew still work another 12 hour day. Friday morning pavement replacement was set back until 2 pm that afternoon to give us the needed time for backfill completion and gravel placement. As you can see our crew put forth a high level of effort as to not damage any of the unmarked utilities causing delays and to make the necessary scheduled opening of Jefferson Street, as required by the streetscapes project. Should you have any questions or comments, please call or email. We believe that without a doubt our additional cost is justified, both fair and reasonable. R' gar s, John .Boettcher ✓oha R19effchea SEWER b EXrAdMN3 CONTRACTOR 3305 NORTH HOME STREET MISHAWAKA, INDIANA 46545 PHONE: (574) 259-1418 FAX: (574) 259-1417 November 16, 2016 Majority Builders, Inc. Matt Flick 62900 U.S. 31 South Bend, IN 46614 Re: Marriott Project -Water Taps on Jefferson Blvd. Thank you, for the opportunity to quote the above referenced project. All work per plans. Our scope of work and projected associated costs are as follows: Unit TOTAL Qty Unit Cost Total COST * 6" 45 DEG FITTINGS 2 EA 166.00 $332.00 * 6" FIELD LOCK GASKETS 4 EA 115.00 $460.00 * 6" X 24" ANCH. COUPLING 1 EA 133.00 $133.00 $925.00 X 10% 92.5 $1,017.50 * ADDITIONAL SAWCUT 1 EA 385.00 $385.D0 * ADDITIONAL ASPHALT REMOVAL 224.39 SFT 25 SYD $0.00 * ADDITIONAL #53 REC CONCRETE 6" THICK 8 TNS 8.50 $69.96 * ADDITIONA THRUST BLOCKS 2 EA 40.70 $81.40 * INSERV VAC FOR UTILITIES 1 EA 1,171.50 $1,171.50 * ADDITIONAL CURB REMOVAL 6 EA $0.00 * FLOWABLE FILL FOR UNDER EXISTING UTILITIES 16 CYD 78.93 $1,262.88 * EQUIPMENT, LABOR, O/T PREMIUM 1 LS 9,082.50 $9,082.50 $12,053.24 TOTAL $13,070.74 Exclusions: Materials and labor bonds, weather conditions, construction staking, materials testing, permit fees, utility assessments, tap fees for water or sewer, removal of unforeseen buried debris or obstructions, dewatering, environmental remediation or issues, removal or handling of any hazardous materials or site conditions; no asbestos abatement or remediation included. *NOTE: Any discrepancy or clarification resolution as to the intent of this proposal and as to its meaning will be determined by Boettcher. If you have any questions, please call. in ere' j 0 hn B e cher PRICING SHEET NAME �.1-r; `L ?�i...iC' !T of /T( ARCH, OR CONTRACTOR rN- ea ESTIMATE kO. LOCATION ^�I i e ter'iL"lj .J " �l V `PRICED TYPE OP WORK ESTIMATED BY BY EXTENDED BY CHECKED BY ppTE DESCRIPTION QUAIC EXTENSION X 34 a' TOTALS PRODUCT 235 < LL J JOO 3+ \ W K d pNZJ Y w U �U0z O U Qi j OZN Y j=0 z x w O aka I U. <UOOa 1t NKS n3 � I N b V)zz in I it C! t~ix�w 0 7 w 043�C�ai V / 1 QAla NOS83333f 3 I � n� I x m �D U > / / m z ml Q I F Z> ¢F 3x F z IL ¢ ¢ I w� if / o� r I �Q Ozc C9 x'ZO ion RZe rt V I ��tOW to ZQ �/ I Z wK I W>> I LJ �O �� wX I z%'WJnW �v Jo --z�' w -- z �M� W m 13m I s----Ls Z i J a ml i /i I ,t I i i I I / O I I LL W U � i m_wam w NF O I O /Y / w w z ,go V1MU z aZ0FP (AMU % >x >be� allo Y®N anp 17®go N z z U U I I CLEF yKW JWW �a�l JW pO a.NQ / LLJ �W Wmcn— j Z 0 m U w z WW / ELEV 70R AQ -is:LED TRIANGLE OF CONCRETE :Kx- POLE BASE 'PIPER] COCK X r_ ij 1 9 •---t- _. - CLEANOUT WA t= �r 1AX oLE+ SENDS i T� ra 'I�! I W Q LL LL 0 N ■ N U �Cl L y Cl 0 w v, N LL C .0 W a) c 0 o Q. Am .�. W mg: EL n P�\\Ply g KO, * _ 11011333 STATE OF c 0 Z W m N!! KI J v Z 0 w U T Oz mWz mF¢ w ¢tea w�W8 NSN3UO F N N N Z wZ ~ NQJ W sU a3`�..a.-vY e U I U w w Nf0 O:zoFuj F U Uo WU aOQO aMpO Z Z Z NM ®4Q/ M®N NZU I I IrIL 0 � 0 0 w �ww aNa wal- torn - ®N I 1 J w w MV) W c o m } > O > fir a a M zo . z 0, o: ooe ~UF F -woQ oo ow /� oZF ow —\ Oi O W m 43x �! ' ion �t mF j QXW � �N3 z z m S . U u� on W I a N arc N zd w <� zE a O aW O O z N to O Z Q / aE N q11 I 4 I u O QA- j mII z Z / N f4 O ~ O z z I < 6W w �Na �� a22o Nov 2z NZ� z, F. W N22 NN t aN0 a® aC 2 �Z o = ®N I 05cc) 5 O:,> I I LOU No 80 N ION- I ®N 3 f 1 Oin l- a o � FF% Q . D): 2 a w < oP tas o w I oaw oa---oe U W 0 1 BLS A 2�9 4anoS zsu'Evz j,LS 4 euaipu1,31S 13 .......... , v NI'dN38 H1f10S OC Zo N\r " dN39..H1f1 00'! 3svt z--3 W` A AO IIVH A ti� O� 0 N1�8 3. NOSN3333r1-4 o 'I I o , raro! , ' 'r o l -Z Y 2 w o (n C,QW �2m 6:2m +N 4) s iyb D to Z ZN 1 + ` W �N or Less, LLC. .O.$07i 907 Niles. V 49120 (574)272-2673 Bill To John Boettcher Sewer & Excavating 3305 North Rome Street Mishawaka IN 46545 Invoice E e Invoice # 016 2154 Terms P.O. No. Due on receipt Oh, Description Rate Amount 1 Saw cut 70' of 13". Minimum Charge. 350.00 350.00 Street Sawing Jefferson South Bend, IN (Brian) Total $350.00 x toyer INVOICE 3 Concrete Inc 3 2 Lincolnway West S nth Bend, IN 46628-1455 574-232-9911 Bffi To: JOHN BOETTCHER SEWERS & EXCAVATING 3305 N HOME ST MISHAWAKA IN 46545 W E Page 1 of 1 umber Ship Toe JEFFERSON & ST JOE ST / SOUTH BEND *** Total Cubic Yards: 16 *** _.. .-.. _ Customer_ i11._- 5967 PONumber Terms Description Net Due Date Disc Due Date DiscountAmount MARRIOTT $1.50/YD 20TH 1 11/30/2016 11/20/2016 24.00 Order Date Pick Ticket No Primary Salesrep Name Taker 10/7/2016 Andrew Moser Quantities Pricing Item ID UOM Unit Extended Ordered Sht ed Remaining UOM PP R 5 Item Description Ursit Size Price Price Unit S: O 8.00 8.00 0.00 CY FF-R / TICKET NO 102470 CY /ol x 71.7500 ° V.93 574.00 1.0 INDOT FLOWABLE BACKFILL-REMOVABLE 8.00 8.00 0.00 CY ECW / TICKET NO 102470 CY 0.5000 4.00 _ 1.0 ENVIROMENTAL FEE 8.00 8.00 0.00 CY FF-R / TICKET NO 102472 CY to% x 71.7500 - 78,93 574.00 1.0 INDOT PLOWABLE BACKFIU-REMOVABLE 8.00 8.00 0.00 CY ECW / TICKET NO 102472 _ _ - -1.0 ---£1,AIR4)ME'NTAb4T-E-- Total Lines: 4 0RTrUATAT. �v A service charge of 1.5% per month will be added to accounts not aid by the due date of the invoice. Ws CY 0.5000 SUB -TOTAL. INDL4AA SALES TAX: AMOUNT DUE: 4.00 1,15W 2 1,236.92 U.S. Dollars /6x79.93= /ZdZ.d8 ww virrseiv24.7.0drd 614 E. Marion St Mishawaka, IN 46545. Phohi #<574-966-0372; E-mail: ar@I Bill To BOETTCHER EXCAVATING 3305 N HOME ST MISHAWAKA, IN 46545 Service Date iP.0. No. S.O. No. 10/62016 Custohler # 6127 BOL 4169 Quantity Description HYDRO EXCAVATION ER - ER RATES APPLY 3 HYDRO VAC & OPERATOR / HR - ER RATES 3 ADDITIONAL TECHNICIAN / HR - ER RATES We Appreciate Your Business! Avoice Date Invoice # 10/1 D/2016 12948 Ship To BOETTCHER EXCAVATING MICHIGAN ST: /JEFFERSON ST. SOUTH BEND, IN 46601 Terms Due Date Net 30 11/9/2016 Rate Amount 265.00 795.00 90.00 270.00 Total "Flo, ' t if _. ... j Y r• .r t _, t Yir3 PrrAC"', 1� f I'. r rj r< w rr J .� •.�.4� T.�tr F y ry •M ��'AT'. r , •ilYi F'97 4P1 lei r e J 'i►ni.' -4 4 i fit � A tjA JC-44L, isr , 4;11 0 V 0 O -0. to o�< Z R 0 I nt", 0 LL W ¢ W ¢O ! W G UJ Q Z ¢ �j ¢ W r Y X �m x 0 O 2 U Q W ¢ f" Z g W ❑ a OJ r m ~ m U a Z N U G Q Y= m m m N m m N Y m M W O i W¢ W W 2¢¢ O C� O u_ 0 7 W f N � O G S Y m O ¢ r C ¢_ N e0 W O F tN4 N N ❑ 0¢ n 0 2 r n r r h n n 1� m m W !- F FL F N C o S Z 6 Wp pW W N CJ M M M M M❑❑❑❑ 1� n r n n n n � r❑❑� N< V m ONi ONI Omi Z O a All F 0 z Rli ca N�D`VN N J W M )a fl a a tAY� 1 W ` 6 Q Y I_ 3 n a a 6 � � O 3 u $ m �❑ N N 7 _0 W l/� Q z W rd Of F= F- m Q S F- O S' Z m P- F- 2 m Q W N F F- m W N M F- > N Y S rr X �L Z= U X m W m¢ W N U Q C=J o 3 O 2 W a. a iX U 212 rn Ir U C (¢ W 1- U ry 2 F- 2 a x J ° � ,- N W f c � O _ Or f i Y y 3 s ti 1�2 0 N O O mF'- N Z W a W N i Nl M IN4 tM�l � M � 1 O � O N 1� m n m n N n f` N pW w t\ S O M O m tUO O V O O n F• A V O O �c v�i a a m m mN m F- 2 7 O c or u C IUWJ Q g D�CID Z m UJ U oQc O � 0 w ' W 6 w< o m i- w < n m /- LL O 3 z W rn 1- W ° hQ- Of rn I= m N m F- 1= ¢ w N y m M > _ N 3 cY a W 2� m X U x ° v W W¢¢ F¢- C=fi0 ❑ < y 5 w 3¢~cr m W a p¢ 7 3 t% p W w CaJ Y= 5 a C7 O = z W N F� °' O LL M m °' O M uwi LL C f�A �� Q m L u� m m n m o 2 O 0 o N n O m p w M (O n W O N M O N oo O O O o o n� n n n n m m m F F� H 6 _ VC 2 w i O -If W N M N M [O N [�� M ttoO M M M❑❑❑❑ 0uJ f0 1� OJ n r O n0❑ w w O O N n h OI n O O c� O fD tD l0 V a O i0 if V Q Owi m m m o a WrL ~ Q U N¢ C U W N W X '" 0 6 f g W Z m¢ 5 W F V O m ¢ 2 W F Z ¢i a o tr LLm1 a< z L 'z lei aJ F 3 V W rn m m m y W g z W W fL 1- Q= p T v m [$¢ O S Y o m o ¢ Y FO g 3 ¢ m O !� r _ O S 2 W a d N m �M rNi m M O O n n r n n n w n n D w O co uni C V A ONi W � O a Date Name BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS AGENDA ITEM REVIEW REQUEST FORM 11/17/2016 Public Works Engineering BPW Date 11/22/2016 Phone Extension 5896 Richard Estes Department Division/Bureau Legal Attorney Name: Michael Schmidt Controller ❑ Controller review is required for all Contracts $5,000.00 or more and greater than one year in length per the City Purchasing Policy Purchasing ® George King Check the Appro riate Item Type — Required for Ali Submissions ❑ Agreement Contract EJ Proposal Addendum ❑ Professional Services ❑ Resolution ❑ Bid Opening ❑ Bid Award ❑ Req. to Advertise ❑ Title Sheet ❑ Quote Opening ❑ Quote Award ® Change Order No. 3 ❑ C/O & PCA No. ❑ PCA ❑ Ease/Encroach. ❑ Traffic Control: F1 Other: Company or Vendor Name New Vendor MBE/WBE Contractor MBE/WBE Contractor Requested Project Name Project Number Funding Source Account No. Amount Terms of Contract Purpose/Description Builders No LJ If Yes, Approved by 116-021 RW DA TIF 324-1050-460-3102 $1,267.49 Reflects additional slab and water main work, reimbursement of permit fees, payment for an unused manhole structure due to design change, and remaining balance on over/under runs LJ Required Contractor's Certification Forms Attached (Non - Collusion, Non -Discrimination, Non -Debarment, E-Verify, Iran, etc.) Amount of ZI Increase _ ❑ Decrease Previous Amount $ 81 Current Percent of Change: 0.17 New Amount Total Percent of py Original �1 ■ // ■ ired For I 1.267.49 Patrick C. Kerr, Jitin Kain Matt Flick, Majority Builders