HomeMy WebLinkAboutConfirming Tax Abatement - 330 North Kenmore Street - Elkhart Plastics, Inc.RESOLUTION
3678-07
Passed by the Common Council of the City of South Bend, Indiana
January 8,
Attest:
City Clerk
President of Common Council
20 07
Presented by me to the Mayor of the City of South Bend, Indiana
January 9, 20 07
Approved and signed by me January 9th 2007
City Clerk
RESOLUTION NO. 3 ~O ~~" ~ 1
A RESOLUTION CONFIRMING THE ADOPTION OF A
DECLARATORY RESOLUTION DESIGNATING CERTAIN AREAS
WITHIN THE CITY OF SOUTH BEND, INDIANA, COMMONLY
KNOWN AS
3300 NORTH KENMORE STREET
AS AN ECONOMIC REVITALIZATION AREA FOR
PURPOSES OF A (4) FOUR-YEAR REAL
PROPERTY TAX ABATEMENT FOR
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
WHEREAS, the Common Council of the City of South Bend, Indiana, has
adopted a Declaratory Resolution designating certain areas within the City as Economic
Revitalization Areas for the purpose of tax abatement consideration; and
WHEREAS, a Declaratory Resolution designated the area commonly known as
3300 North Kenmore Street, South Bend, Indiana, and which is more particularly
described as follows:
commencing at the Northeast corner of Section 28; thence South
89°48'OS" West, 966.00 feet along the North line of said Section 28;
thence South 00°00'23" West 40.00 feet to the South boundary of
Cleveland Road; thence South 89°48'OS" West, 289.0-0 feet along said
South boundary; thence South 44°54' 14" West, 14.17 feet to the East
boundary of Kenmore Street; thence South 00°00'23" West, 146.76 feet
along said East boundary; thence along said East boundary, Southeasterly
294.37 feet along an arc to the left, having a radius of 1,869.86 feet,
subtended by a long chord, having a bearing of South 04°30' 13" East, and
a length of 294.07 feet to the point of beginning of this description; thence
North 89°48'OS" East 581.88 feet; thence South 00°00'23" West, 472.86
feet; thence South 89°58'S6" West, 498.99 feet to said East boundary of
Kenmore Street; thence North 09°S9'37" West, 445.88 feet along said East
boundary; thence Northwesterly 31.98 feet along an arc to the right, having
a radius of 1,869.86 feet and subtended by a long chord, having a bearing
of North 09°30' 1 S" West, and a length of 31.98 feet to the place of
beginning
and which has Key Number 25-1010-0385.18, as an Economic Revitalization Area; and
WHEREAS, notice of the adoption of a Declaratory Resolution and the public
hearing before the Council has been published pursuant to Indiana Code 6-1.1-12.1-2.5;
and
WHEREAS, the Council held a public hearing for the purposes of hearing all
remonstrance's and objections from interested persons; and
WHEREAS, the Council has determined that the qualifications for an economic
revitalization area have been met.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Common Council of the City of
South Bend, Indiana, as follows:
SECTION I. The Common Council hereby confirms its Declaratory Resolution
designating the area described herein as an Economic Revitalization Area for the
purposes of tax abatement. Such designation is for Real property tax abatement only and
is limited to two (2) calendar years from the date of adoption of the Declaratory
Resolution by the Common Council.
SECTION II. The Common Council hereby determines that the property owner is
qualified for and is granted Real property tax deduction for a period of (4) four years, and
further determines that the petition, the Memorandum of Agreement between the
Petitioner and the City of South Bend, and the Statement of Benefits comply with
Chapter 2, Article 6, of the Municipal Code of the City of South Bend and Indiana Code
6-1.1-12 et sea.
SECTION III. This Resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its
adoption by the Common Council and approved by the Mayor.
--~
Member of th on Council
PRESENTED L ~~~
NOT APPROVED
ADOPTED 1 -'~-~ I
Filcd In Cierk's Office
~'.ii rL... C;1.C
1200 COUNTY-CITY BUILDING
227 W. JEFFERSON BOULEVARD
SOUTH BEND, INDIANA 46601-1830
PHONE 574/235-9371
FAx 574/235-9021
TDD 574/ 235-5567
CITY OF SOUTH BEND STEPHEN J. LUECKE, MAYOR
COMMUNITY ~ ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
November 2, 2006 SHARON T. KENDALL
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Council Member Roland Kelly, Chairperson
Community & Economic Development Committee
South Bend Common Council
4th Floor, County City Building
South Bend, IN 46601
RE: Commercial Real Property Tax Abatement Petition for:
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
Dear Council Member Kelly:
Please find attached the Department of Community & Economic Development's report on a
commercial real property tax abatement petition for the above-referenced petitioner for expansion
and rehabilitation of a facility located at 3300 N. Kenmore Street. Also attached is a copy of the
petition, Statement of Benefits form, and supporting information.
The report contains the Department's findings relative to the above petition. The petitioner, Elkhart
Plastics proposes to increase office space by 6,500 square feet and remodel an existing 3,700 square
feet. Elkhart Plastics is seeking a (4)four-year real property tax abatement, and a representative of
Elkhart Plastics will be available to meet with the Committee on Monday, November 27, 2006.
Should you or any of the other Council members have any questions concerning the report, or need
additional information, please feel free to call me at 235-5825.
Sincerely,
Sharon Terrell
Economic Development
Attachments
cc: South Bend Common Council Members
Mayor Stephen Luecke
Sharon Kendall
Don Inks
Bill Schalliol
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT FINANCIAL HL PROGRAM
PAMELA C. MEYER DONALD E. INKS MANAGEMENT
574/235-9660 574/235-9371 ELIZAEETH LEONARD
FAX: 5741235-9697 574/235-9371
1200 COUNTY-CIT7 BUILDING
227 W. ,JEFFERSON BOULEVARD
SOUTH BEND, INDIANA 46601-1830
PHONE 574/ 235-9371
Fax 574/235-9021
TDD 574/ 235-5567
CITY OF SOUTH BEND STEPHEN J. LUECKE, MAYOR
COMMUNITY $~ ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
SHARON T. KENDALL
EXECUTIVE. DIRECTOR
TAX ABATEMENT REPORT
TO: SOUTH BEND COMMON COUNCIL
FROM: SHARON TERRELL ,~
SUBJECT: REAL PROPERTY TAX ABATEMENT PETITION FOR:
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
DATE: November 2, 2006
On October 18, 2006, a petition for real property tax abatement consideration for property located at
3300 N. Kenmore Street was filed with the City Clerk by Elkhart Plastics, Inc. Pursuant to Chapter 2,
Article 6, Section 2-82 of the Municipal Code of the City of South Bend, this petition was referred to
the Department of Community and Economic Development for purposes of investigation and
preparation of a report determining whether the area qualifies as an Economic Revitalization Area
pursuant to I.C.6-1.1-12.1 and whether all zoning requirements have been met.
The Department of Community and Economic Development has reviewed the petition (a copy of
which is attached), investigated the area, and makes the following report.
PROJECT SUMMARY
Elkhart Plastics is a custom plastic processor, utilizing a rotational molding process. Products
manufactured include yellow crash barrels for highway safety and a wide variety of large, hollow
products shipped up to 500 miles away. The company plans to increase office space by 6,500 square
feet and remodel an existing 3,700 square feet to serve as the North American headquarters for
Promens, which is the largest rotational molding company in the world and is headquartered in
Reykjavik, Iceland. New construction guidelines for Industrial, City-Wide is 10,000 square feet as is
rehabilitation. The combined remodeling and additional office space totals 10,200 square feet. The
Department of Community & Economic Development believes the intent of the current tax
abatement ordinance was 10,000 square feet, whether it is new construction, rehab, or a combination.
Consideration of this tax abatement is requested by this office. Expansions are critical for the future
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT' ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT FINANCIAL HL PROGRAM
PAMELA C. MEYER DONALD E. INKS MANAGEMENT
574/235-9660 574/235-9371 EtizAeeTH LEONARD
Fax: 574/235-9697 574/235-9371
South Bend Common Council
RE: Tax Abatement for Elkhart Plastics, Inc.
November 2, 2006
Page 2
growth of the company. The estimated cost of the addition and remodel is $600,000. Total taxes to
be abated during the (4) four-year abatement period is estimated at $51,270. Total taxes to be paid
during the (4) four-year abatement period is estimated at $30,762.
EMPLOYMENT IMPACT
Per the petition, it is estimated that the total prof ect will create (20) twenty new, permanent, full-time
jobs representing a new annual payroll of $1,000,000. The project will also maintain (40) forty
existing, permanent, full-time jobs representing an annual payroll of $1,300,000.
ABATEMENT QUALIFICATION
A review of the tax abatements previously granted, finds that the petitioner has not been granted
or associated with any previous tax abatements:
2. The Building Commissioner has reviewed the petition and finds the property to be properly
zoned for the proposed project.
3. A review of the South Bend Redevelopment designation areas finds that the property is located
in the Airport Economic Development Area, which is a Tax Incremental Allocation Area;
therefore, the petition for real property tax abatement must f rst be approved by the South Bend
Redevelopment Commission.
4. A review of the Tax Abatement Ordinance No. 9394-0 finds that the petitioner does meet the
qualifications fora (4) four-year real property tax abatement under Section 2-82, Industrial
Development City-Wide.
Tax Abatement Schedule prepared for:
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
South Bend German Township 4 Year Real Property Abatement Schedule"
Total estimated Project Cost: $600,000
Base Assessed Value: $510,000
(base assessed value is estimated at 85% of project cost)
Assume constant tax rate of: 5.1376%
Assume constant SRTC of: 21.7293%
Assessed Gross
Year Value Tax
1 $510,000 $26,202
2 510,000 26,202
3 510,000 26,202
4 510,000 26,202
2-Nov-06
Less Net Percent Tax Tax
SRTC Tax Abated Abated Paid
$5,694 $20,508 100% $20,508 $0
5,694 20,508 75% 15,381 5,127
5,694 20,508 50% 10,254 10,254
5,694 20,508 25% 5,127 15,381
$82,032 $51,270 $30,762
Total Taxes Due During Abatement:
Total Taxes Abated During Abatement:
Total Taxes Paid During Abatement:
$82,032
51,270
30,762
' -This schedule is for estimation purposes only and assumes constant tax rates.
The true tax values will ultimately be determined by the actual
assessed valuation and the then current tax rates.
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
Additional Years of Abatement
Multi-family Development Projects:
From To Additional Years
0 141 0
142 183 1
184 225 2
226 267 3
268 309 4
310 351 5
352 393 6
394 & over 7
Other Development Projects:
From To Additional Years
0 300 0
301 357 1
358 414 2
415 471 3
472 528 4
529 585 5
586 642 6
643 1000 7
Subtotal from Points Summary: 312
Base Years of Abatement 3
Additional Years of Abatement:
Total Years of Abatement: 4
2-Nov-06
ELKHART PLASTICS, INC.
Public Benefit Points Summary
Qualify Earned Available
Public Benefit Item: Y or N Points Points
Project Related:
1. A. Redevelop a Site that has Special Needs N 0 49
B. Develop Based on Local University Research N 0 35
C. Achieve a Physical Element of a Plan Y 36 36
Sub-total Project Related: 36 120
2. Super Size Proiects (point values are cumulative):
A. 100% to 199% Y 25 25
B. 200% to 299% N 0 68
C. 300% to 399% N 0 65
D. 400% and Over N 0 52
Sub-total Super Size Projects: 25 210
3. Construction Related:
A. Employ Local Companies Y 20 20
B. Purchase Materials from Local Companies Y 20 20
C. Require Employees vs. Independent Contracts Y 19 19
D. Require Target Wage Levels N 0 22
E. Require Health Benefits Y 22 22
F. Require Pension Benefits N 0 18
G. Maintain Affirmative Action Plan Y 20 20
Sub-total Construction Related: 101 141
4. Wage & Benefit Related:
A. Pay Target Wage Levels Y 33 33
B. Provide Health Benefits Y 34 34
C. Provide Pension Benefits N 0 29
D. Provide Training N 0 28
E. Provide Child Care N 0 15
F. Provide Transportation Assistance N 0 14
G. Provide Employer Assisted Housing program N 0 9
Sub-total Wage & Benefit Related: 67 162
5. Workforce Related:
A. Create New Jobs Y 42 42
B. Retain Existing Jobs Y 41 41
C. Maintain Affirmative Action Plan N 0 35
D. Provide Targeted Hiring Preference N 0 34
Sub-total Workforce Related: 83 152
6. Pav for Municipal Infrastructure: (point values are cumulative):
A. Pay for Oversizing or Upgrading N 0 14
B. Pay for 26-50% of Extension Cost N 0 26
C. Pay for 51-75% of Extension Cost N 0 39
D. Pay for 76-100% of Extension Cost N 0 52
Sub-total Infrastructure Related: 0 131
7. Support a Municipal Facility:
A. Support a Municipal Facility N 0 84
Total Public Benefit Poi nts: 312 1000
* Qualification for each Public Benefit Item based on best available information at time of application or
good faith determination if no information available.
CITY OF SOUTH BEND
PETITION FOR REAL PROPERTY TAX ABATEMENT CONSIDERATION
The undersigned owner(s) of real property, located within the City of South Bend,
hereby petition the Common Council of the City of South Bend for real property tax
abatement consideration and pursuant to I.C.. 6-1.1-12.1-1, et seq.' and South Bend
Municipal Code Sec. 2-76 et seq., for this petition states the following:
1. Describe the proposed redevelopment or rehabilitation project, including
information about physical improvements to be made, the proposed use of the
improvements, and a general statement as to the importance of the project to
your business:
Increase office space by 6,500 sq.ft. and remodel existing
3,700 sq.ft. to serve as Corporate Headquarters for Promens
North America. Expansions are critical for the future growth
of company.
Land Size 6 acres; Building Size 77, loo sq.ft.
2. Describe the overall nature of the business and of the operations occurring at
the Property (attach additional sheet if more space is needed):
Elkhart Plastics is a custom plastic processor utilizing
the rotational molding process. Products manufactured include
yellow crash barrels for highway safety and a wide variety of
other large hollow products shipped up to 500 miles away.
3. Estimate the dollar value of the project (excluding land): $600,000
4. The current assessed valuation of the real property before rehabilitation,
redevelopment, economic revitalization, or improvement: $ 2,254,600
5. (a) The real property for «~hich tax abatement consideration is petitioned (Property) is owned
(Rev 8/11/03)
or to be owned by the following individuals or corporations (if the business organization
is publicly held, indicate also the name ofthe corporate parent, if any, and the name under
which the corporation has filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission):
NAlv1E ADDRESS INTEREST(%)
E. W. Marine 66480 High Meadow Court 100X
Edwardsburg, MI 49112
(b) The following other person(s) lease, intend to lease, or have an option to buy the Property
(include corporate information as required in 5(a) above, if applicable);
NAME ADDRESS INTEREST(%)
Elkhart Plastics, Inc. 51703 Packard Drive 100X
Middlebury, IN 46540
6. The commonly known address of the Property is:
3300 N. Kenmore, South Bend, IN 46628
7. The Key Number(s) of said property is:
025-1010-038518
8. A legal description of the above address is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit
A," and incorporated herein.
9. A map and/or plat describing the Property is attached hereto, marked "Exhibit
B," and incorporated herein.
10. Photographs of the property, taken within two (2) weeks of filing of this petition,
are attached hereto, marked "Exhibit C," and incorporated herein.
11. The redevelopment or rehabilitation project itself will create 20 full-time and
-o- part-time permanent jobs within the first year, representing a new
annual payroll of $ l,ooo,ooo and will maintain 4o existing permanent
full-time and -o- existing permanent part-time jobs including existing
permanent full-time minority employment of 9 and existing permanent part-
time minority employment of -o- with an annual payroll of $
$1,300,000
12. The projected annual salaries for each new position indicated above are
estimated to be as follows (If more space is needed, please attach a separate
sheet):
(Rev 8/ 11 /03) Z
•8 -Office/Adm:inistrative Professional positions - $70,000 Ave. _ $560,000
12 -Production/Labor - $35,000 Average = $420,000
$980,000
13. Provide current employment wage information including; base rate, cost-of-
living allowances, hazardous-duty pay, incentive pay including commissions
and production bonuses, on-call pay and tips. Do Not Include; back pay, jury
duty pay, overtime pay, severance pay, shift differentials, non-production
bonuses, and tuition reimbursements (average hourly rate or range):
Full-Time Part-Time
51-4os1 Laborers $ 11.00-16.oo/hr. $ N/A
51-4111 Technical $ 15.00-18.00/hr. $ N/A
~i1-0000 Managerial $ 45,000-80,000 $ N/A
13-1079 Administrative $ 40000 $ N/A
14. Indicate whether your company provides the following benefits (use Y/N):
Y Health Care Benefits
~_ Pension Plan
~_ Employer Provided Training (recognized or certified training/educational
courses or programs)
~_ Day Care (provide or contribute to the cost of child day care for its
employees)
~_ Transportation Assistance (provide direct or indirect support and
assistance to its employees without private transportation to get back
and forth from residence to place of employment)
~_ Employer-Assisted Housing Program (provide an employer-assisted
home ownership program)
~_ Targeted Hiring Preference (provide hiring preference for residents
of Census Tracts designated by the Community & Economic
Development Dept. that have the highest unemployment or the
highest percentage of low and moderate income individuals).
(Additional information may be requested for verification of the above
items)
15. List the real and personal property taxes paid at the location during the
previous five years, whether paid by the current owner or a previous owner:
Year
Real Property Taxes Personal Property Taxes
(Rev 8/11/03) 3
' Tax Year Real Property Taxes
2001 S ~.~974 06
2002 $ 83,856.98
2003 $ 86,152.80
2004 $ 86,095.22
2005 $ 90 662.78
(this information may be obtained from the St
9531)
Personal
Property Taxes Paid By
$ 54,433.22 Spin Cast Plastics
$ 23,498.54 Spin Cast Plastics
$ 17,847.54 Spin Cast Plastics
$ 17,847.54 Spin Cast Plastics
$ 26,114.00 Elkhart Plastics
Joseph County Treasurers office 235-
16. Please list the number of full-time and part-time minority employees for each
of the last three years:
Year 2006 o~oS 2004
Full Part Full Part Full Part
Black 3 - 4 - 5 -
Hispanic 6 - 7 - 9 -
Asian - - - - - -
Indian - - - - - -
Other - - - - - -
17. Does your business maintain an affirmative action plan or other similar plan
in order to achieve racial diversity? If yes, please briefly indicate specific
goals, objectives, and means as designated by your plan:
No.
18. Indicate whether or not your project meets any of the following criteria
(contact Community & Economic Development Dept. 235-9335 for information on
this section):
~_ Conversion to residential use of a commercial "Eligible Building" as
designated by the Community & Economic Development Dept.
.~L Rehabilitation of a building that is either designated as a National
Register or local landmark or is eligible for nomination as one, located
in a National Register or local landmark district, or rated as
Outstanding or Significant in the most recent Historic Preservation
Commission county wide survey.
~ Rehabilitation and reuse of a property that is designated a Problem
Property by the Community and Economic Development Department
N Pays for the cost of cleaning up a "Brownfield," which is any site,
building facility or complex that has been designated a Brownfield by the
(Rev 8/11/03) 4
Community and Economic Development Department.
y Achieves a physical element identified in a development or revitalization
plan that has been approved by the Council
19. Is your business based upon licensing intellectual property from research
conducted at a public or private university, college, or community college located
within St. Joseph County, Indiana? If yes, please include a description of the
research based aspects of the business (attach additional sheet if more space is
needed):
No.
20. Does your business financially support a Municipal Facility (i.e. municipally
owned park, recreation center, cultural, arts, or entertainment facility)?
No.
21. Is your company incurring any of the cost of extension or oversizing of municipal
~~=~`=>~, infrastructure serving the project site? This includes water, sewer, drainage
., -~
facilities, wastewater treatment facilities, road and street improvements, street
lighting, traffic control and related public improvements (attach additional sheet if
more space is needed):
No.
22. Information is required on the companies through which construction materials
. will be purchased for the project. (Please complete the table on page 8 of this
application).
23. Information is required on the construction companies that will be utilized for
construction of the project. (Please complete the table on page 9 of this
application).
24. No building permit has been issued for construction on the property in
connection with the improvement in question as of the date of filing of this
petition. (The Property Owners signature at the end of this application is
(Rev 8/11/03) $
verification of this statement).
25. The Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) or North American Industry
Classification Systems (NAICS) major group within which the proposed project
would be classified, by number and description:
NAICS - 326 -Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing
26. The Internal Revenue Service Code of Principal Business Activity by which the
proposed project would be classified, by number and description:
326100 Plastics Product Manufacturing
Industrial and the
27. The current use of the Property is
current zoning is Li (use) and N/A (height and area).
(This information may be obtained from tie BiilBi gg DD Partment 235-9554).
28. Has your business been granted previous tax abatement(s)? If yes, please
provide type (real and/or personal property) and date of approval.
No.
29. Other anticipated public financing for the project including, if any, industrial
revenue-bonding to be sought or already authorized, assistance through the
United States Department of Housing and Urban Development funds from the
City of South Bend, Small Business Association of South BendaMishgawaka, alnd
through the Business Development Corporat
St. Joseph County, Indiana, Industrial Revolving Fund, Neighborhood Business
Development Corporation, Corporation for Entrepreneurial Development; or
other public financial assistance, including but not limited to public works
improvements.
No.
30. The following person(s) should be contacted as Petitioner's agent regarding
additional information and public hearing notifications:
(Rev 8/11!03) 6
Name: Jack Welter
Address: 3300 N. Kenmore Street
City, State, Zip: south Bend, IN 46628
Telephone: 574-232-8066
31. Please indicate the name, address, and telephone number of the person who
will work with Employment Training Services (ETS) for employee recruitment,
and sign the ETS form attached to the petition if the real tax abatement is for
warehouse or industrial developments.
Name: Jack Welter
Address: 3300 N. Kenffiore Street
City, State, Zlp: South Bend, IN 46628
Telephone: 574-232-8066
WHEREFORE, Petitioner requests that the Common Council of the City of South
Bend, Indiana, adopt a declaratory resolution designating the area described herein
to be an economic revitalization area for purposes of tangible real property tax
abatement consideration, and after publication of notice and public hearing,
determine qualifications for an economic revitalization area have been met, and
confirm such resolution. Petitioner herein hereby verifies that the required $250.00
filing fee to cover processing and administrative costs pursuant to Section 2-84.7 of
the Municipal Code of the City of South Bend has been paid in full.
Name of Property Owner(s):
E. W. Marine
66480 High Meadow Court
Edwardsburg, MI 49112/p~
BY = ~ ~~10~
Jill Ford, Vice President
By: ~~~
(S ed Name) Jack Welter
President, Elkhart Plastics, Inc.
(Typed or printed name and capacity of signor if
signed. by an agent or representative of the
owner.)
(Rev 8/ 11 /0 ~) ~
22. In the following chart please indicate companies that were used for purchasing materials used in the construction or '
rehabilitation associated with the project. Include the location of the company, description of the materials, and cost of the
materials. Additional information may be requested for verification of this information. (If more space is needed, please
photocopy this page)
t~r,.._.,.....,~ ~ ,aa,..,~~ ~,f r'mm~nnv IlPCrrintinn of Materials Cost of Materials
Old Fort Su 1 Framin Finish Material 10 000
Big C Lumber Framing /Millwork $20,000
Werntz Supply Doors /Hardware $10,000
Marshall Building Supply Specialties $ 3,000
(Rev 8/11/03) 8
23. In the following chart please list the companies that will be used for the construction or rehabilitation associated w'
project. Indicate the name and address of each company; list the dollar amount of the work to be provided b each co lth the
indicate whether or not 100% of the workers are employees of that company or independent contractors; indicate wheth mpany;
the company pays workers wages that meet the wage rates for each classification of laborers and mechanics ublished b er or not
Department of Labor; indicate whether or not the company contributes to a health plan for its employees; indicate whethehe U.S.
the company contributes to a pension plan for its employees; and indicate whether or not the company maintains an affi or not
action plan or other similar plan to achieve racial diversity. Additional information may be requested for verification of tive
information. (If additional space is needed, please photocopy this page). this
Construction Company Cost of All Workers
Name and Address Work Pay Contribute Contribute Maintain
Employees or Wage to a
or independent Rate to a Affirmative
Health Pension Action
contractors ( /n) Plan ( /n Plan /n) Plan /n
Ma'orit Builders Yes ( )
No Yes Yes Yes
Ross Masonry 7 280 Yes
No Yes No Yes
Lue Manufacturing 7 200 Yes
No Yes No Yes
Momper Insulation 9,280 Yes
No Yes Yes
Yes
Marshall Count Glass 8,100 Yes
No No Yes Yes
Bear Acoustics 20,300 Yes
Yes Yes No Yes
Midwest Tile 45,000 Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lambie's Painting 20,000 Yes
No No .Yes Yes
VFP 13 000 Yes
Yes Yes Yes Yes
NCMI 70,000 Yes
No Yes Yes Yes
Cam bell Electric 80 000 Yes
No Yes Yes Yes
(Rev 8/11/03)
9