Laserfiche WebLink
CITY OF SOUTH BEND AND ST. JOSEPH COUNTY | HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION <br /> <br />Page | 4 Date of Meeting <br />footprint.” The large colonnade on this addition that wraps all three sides and <br />multiple individual dormers detracts from the modest Tudor features of the <br />original house. As stated in the Standards and Guidelines: “The number and <br />size of dormers should not visually overwhelm the scale of the primary <br />structure.” The option 2 reduced addition has a massing that overpowers the <br />original house as well. The reduction in number of dormers helps reduce the <br />distraction from the original house, however, the colonnade is still an <br />overpowering feature. Option 3 addition is the best massing that compliments <br />and maintains focus on the original structure. A simpler roof structure similar <br />to the front of the proposed carriage house could be suitable. The Carriage <br />house design is fitting with the style of the house and neighborhood. Overall, <br />the proposed additions fit in style and character of the neighborhood without <br />altering the feel of the street or harming the integrity of the original structure. <br />Based on the information provided prior to this public hearing, Staff makes a <br />FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION. <br /> <br />The applicant was represented by: <br />Scott & Meredith Hurley, 1225 East Wayne St, appeared in person to <br />present <br />The public was represented by: <br />Don Dietz, 1031 E Jefferson, spoke in favor of the applicant. <br />Teresa Kinney, 1336 E Wayne spoke in favor of the applicant. <br />Eugene& Virginia Bamber, East Wayne, send in a letter in favor of the <br />applicant <br />After due consideration the following action was taken: <br />Upon a motion by Michael Skaggs, seconded by Andrew Fowler, and <br />unanimously carried by vote of 5-0, the Historic Preservation Commission <br />APPROVES Certificate of Appropriateness Application #2026-0406. <br />Roll was called. <br />1. South Façade <br />Upon a motion by Michael Skaggs, seconded by Andrew Fowler, and <br />unanimously carried by vote of 5-0 <br />Commissioner Palczynski: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Fowler: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Skaggs: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Hough: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Andrews: (AYE) <br /> <br />2. East Façade <br />Upon a motion by Andrew Fowler, seconded by Michael Skaggs, and <br />unanimously carried by vote of 5-0 <br />Commissioner Palczynski: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Fowler: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Skaggs: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Hough: (AYE) <br />Commissioner Andrews: (AYE) <br /> <br />3. North Façade