November 15 Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Minutes_SIGNED

Home Browse Search

GITY OF SOUTH BEND ! HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Commissioner Brazinsky (AYE): I move to deny based on everything that was spoken from Joanie and you know there are other alternatives that I believe they should go back and look at and you know at a later date come back to us with a different option and we look like to go ahead and look at something different. Commissioner Hertel (AYE): I am denying this application due to the standards and guidelines and that the ideal situation is restoration over replacement. Commissioner Deegan (NAY): Commissioner Andrews (AYE): I denied based on the standards and guidelines which reads when deteriorated beyond repair they should be replaced with units and trim to resemble the original. Adam and Ross had both said that these were not deteriorated beyond repair. Commissioner Gelfman (AYE): I agree with Sarah, that our staff, our director, Adam, and Ross have looked at those windows and that they can be repaired appropriately and that is my denial. Commissioner Wyncott (NAY): Commissioner Stalheim (AYE): I voted to deny for the standards and guidelines reasons and because this property is ranked as outstanding, so I believe that requires a much more stringent evaluation. Commissioner Downs-Krostenko (AYE): I voted no towards the proposal and for all the reasons that were stated by the others who voted the same way. Certificate of Appropriateness #2021-1029A-5 is denied. Vote: 6-2. Six in favor, two opposed. COA#2021-1029A-5 is denied. Upon a motion by Commissioner Hertel, being seconded by Commissioner Brazinsky and unanimously carried by vote, the applicant can reapply with a modified project and the fee will be waived, was approved. Vote: 8-0. Eight in favor, none opposed. Motion is approved. iii. 2021-1101411 West North Shore Dr West North Shore Drive LHD, Ordinance #6512-78 (Audio Position: 1:41:42) The staff report was presented by Adam Toering. Staff Recommendation: Staff recommends approval. The applicant was represented by: Bob Jones, 411 Northshore Dr. South Bend, IN 46617 Evan Morgan, 5022 W. Foster Ave Chicago, IL 60630 Jack Johannesson, 5022 W. Foster Ave Chicago, IL 60630 The public was represented by: One letter of support was submitted to staff. After due consideration, the following action was taken: Page 14