Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Signed Minutes - July 20, 2020

Home Browse Search

Commissioner Downs-Krostenko confirmed that the brick is all the same brick, but it is turned and faced differently. Commissioner Hertel stated that this uniqueness makes the preservation of the chimney even more important because it is more unique. Commissioner Downs-Krostenko confirmed that this is not the most common brick bonding in our community, and that it is a shame that the mason appeared to not know what he was doing. Commissioner Stalheim stated that the concrete cap was a logical choice. Commissioner Downs-Krostenko stated that there was originally a concrete cap, but it was probably tapered or sloped to the chimney pots. The concrete cap could have been designed differently to better mimic the original, understanding that they wanted it to shed water and other considerations. Commissioner Stalheim indicated that were it to last more than a year, it would need to have some sort of slope to ensure that water would shed off. Commissioner Gelfman indicated that in the future the homeowner should contact the staff in advance of projects like this for guidance. Commissioner Downs-Krostenko indicated that care should be taken when salvaging brick, because — even if there were bricks that were failing — that some of those bricks could be used to "face" the project, and that the bricks should be carefully cared for. Commissioner Hertel stated that the Commission could approve the project, but that she was leaning towards the stipulation that were any work done in the future the chimney were to be reverted to the original configuration and components, unless the homeowner would be willing to entertain the idea of having the chimney reconstructed now. Mr. Priebe indicated he would consider it. Commissioner Hertel expressed that the Commission wants to work with the homeowner, but there is a visual change to the structure indicated in the photographs. Mr. Priebe indicated he would like to get the information for the local company and bricks. Commissioner Downs-Krostenko stated she would convey it to Staff to convey to the property owner. PUBLIC DISCUSSION: N/A Commissioner Hertel made a motion to retroactively approve COA #2020-0616B with the provision that, if any more work is done in the future, it is returned to the proper components and proper style, and proper height. Seconded by Commissioner Andrews. Seven in favor, none opposed, one recusal. Vote: 7 — 0 —1. Motion to approve COA #2020-0616B with conditions passes. 3. 805 Arch Avenue #2020-0626B #6846-80 Edgewater Place Local Historic District Representation: Andy Czarnecki, 805 Arch Avenue, South Bend, IN 46601 Becky Czarnecki, 805 Arch Avenue, South Bend, IN 46601 STAFF REPORT CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Date: 10 July 2020