Laserfiche WebLink
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends denial of new steel door and recommends replacement with new wood door <br />to resemble original. If retroactive approval is given, Staff recommends painting door to coincide with existing color scheme of <br />• house. <br />Prepared by <br />Adam Toering <br />Historic Preservation Specialist <br />Recommendation by <br />Elicia Feasel <br />Historic Preservation Administrator <br />Commission Gordon made a motion to deny COA #2018-0727 as submitted. Seconded by <br />Commissioner Molnar. <br />Legal Counsel DeRose clarified that with motions for denial, Commissioners must express <br />their justifications for voting in the affirmative. <br />in cases of motion for denial, votes in favor of the motion in fact support the motion to deny the <br />application.. Roll was called: <br />Commissioner Canada: I agree to deny due to the failure of the applicant to show up to the <br />hearing, and that it did not meet the Standards and Guidelines for the area for replacing the door. <br />Commissioner Hertel: I vote to deny COA #2018-0727 due to the inability to question the owner <br />regarding the condition of the door that had been replaced, and the possibility of restoration versus <br />replacement. <br />Commissioner Molnar: I vote in the affirmative to deny the application due to no one being here <br />for questioning, and also that it does not fit the Standards and Guidelines of the district. <br />Commissioner Gordon: I vote to deny. The new door does not meet the Standards and Guidelines <br />for the area, and we cannot ask the applicant for any alternative closure. <br />Four in favor, none opposed. <br />Vote: 4 — 0 Motion to deny COA#2018-0727 is passed. <br />Application COA #2018-0727 is denied. <br />4. 528 Eddy COA# 2018-0803A #9089-00 Local Landmark <br />Representation: Shad Ennis, 1247 Mishawaka Avenue <br />Angie Dvorak, 216 W North Shore <br />STAFF REPORT <br />CONCERNING APPLICATION FOR A <br />CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS <br />Date: August 10, 2018 <br />Application Number: 2018-0803A <br />• Property Location: 528 S Eddy St <br />Architectural Style/Date/Architect or Builder: Unknown, 1925-26 <br />Property Owner: South Bend Community School Corporation <br />7 <br />