May 2006 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

MINUTES OF A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION OF SOUTH BEND & SAINT JOSEPH COUNTY May 5, 2006 HPC Offices, South Bend 125 S. Lafayette Blva,1" Floor Members Present: Lynn Patrick [President], Todd Zeiger [Vice -President], Mary Jane Chase [Secretary], Timothy. Klusczinski [Treasurer], Catherine Hostetler, Martha Choitz, Diane Wrobel-Illes Members Absent: Jerry Ujdak, Joann Sporleder Staff Present: Catherine Hostetler [Director], Julie Schutte [Assistant Director], Shawn Peterson [Counsel] I. CALL TO ORDER: Lynn Patrick called the meeting to order at 5:03 pm. II. LANDMARK — FIRST READING & INTERIM PROTECTION —1013 E. JEFFERSON Current photos of 1013 E. Jefferson were passed around to the Commission members [Exhibit 1] and Catherine Hostetler described the significance of the property. The house was built in 1907 for Harry Johnson, the grandson of J. M. Studebaker, as a wedding present. Ennis Austin, a prominent South Bend architect, designed the residence for the new family. The house was also rated Significant/12 in the South Bend survey. Julie Schutte noted that the property is located in the Howard Park National Register District, two houses from another landmark. Catherine briefly described the situation that currently threatens the residence. A law practice located next to 1013 E. Jefferson would like to purchase the house in order to demolish it for parking. Their bonded agent, Kenny Kent, notified the building department of his client's desire to demolish the building. He is the agent for the seller, TCU, and the attorneys. The sale to the attorneys depends on the demolition of the residence. However, another serious buyer has submitted a bona fide counteroffer directly to the bank after some anomalies with Remax and the bank. She would like to purchase the building to rehab it. The Commission then considered if the building was architecturally and/or historically significant to proceed with interim protection and landmark status. Todd Zeiger reiterated that is does meet the criteria as the residence is rated S/12, is located in a National Register Historic District, was designed by a noted South Bend architect, and is connected to the Studebaker family. Lynn Patrick: I moved to accept the following findings of fact regarding 1013 E. Jefferson Blvd, the Studebaker — Johnson House and to place the structure under interim protection. The Studebaker — Johnson House located at 1013 E. Jefferson fulfills the three criteria for landmark status and should be placed under interim protection for six months or until landmark status is granted or denied by the Common Council. It fulfills the three criteria for landmark status: 1.) It is architecturally/historically important and connected to the development of the area because it was designed by Ennis Austin for Harry D. Johnson, Jr., the eldest grandson of J. M. Studebaker and a master mechanic at the Studebaker Corp; 2.) Its educational value as an architecturally significant home owned by a member of the prominent Studebaker family; and 3.) Its suitability for preservation because it is rated significant/notable in the South Bend survey and was designed by Ennis Austin in 1907 for Mr. Johnson. Ennis Austin was a partner for the prominent architectural firm of Austin and Shambleau. Diane Wrobel-Illes: Second. Lynn asked for discussion on the motion. There was none. Lynn asked for public comment. There was none. She asked for a vote: the motion on the floor passed 7-0 all in favor. III. ADJOURNMENT No other matters were discussed. Todd Zeiger moved to adjourn and Martha Choitz seconded the motion. All were in favor and the meeting adjourned at 5:20 p.m.