July 1992 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

original and are void of the character inherent in Queen Anne style porches. The proposed porch renovation would re -introduce some of this character, although it is not known specifically what the original supports looked like. I would recommend, however, that fluting be at the top half or top third of the posts, as full length fluting, on posts or columns, occurs only in ionic order porches, such as those found at 519 S. St. Joseph Street and 420 W. Washington Avenue. Most Free Classic style porches in South Bend utilize the tuscan and doric orders. Restoration work done recently at Dunbar Corner in the West Washington N.R. Historic District utilized partial fluting in porch restorations. The proposed engaged pilasters will visually blend with a wood wall anchor introduced when the balustrade was replaced in 1988. Although there is no evidence that engaged pilasters were ever an element in the porch, the proposed addition of pilasters will give visual purpose to the otherwise awkward appearance of the wall- anchors. The porch renovation, as proposed is in keeping with the pertinent standards. I recommend approval of this item with the stipulation that the posts be partially fluted. 6) Enclosure of the metal column at the rear entry porch as indicated would be compatible with the character and style of the building as analyzed in review of item #5. The proposal is in keeping with the pertinent standards. I recommend approval of this item as per item #5. 7) There -are no standards specifically addressing signage in the Lincolnway East Local Historic District guidelines. However, the general guideline governing compatibility with existing character and style (V.C.) applies. The proposed sign heavily emphasizes the classical tradition. and is thus incompatible with the more subtle use of classical elements in the turn of the century Queen Anne style. I recommend modification of -this proposal as submitted. 8) The side/basement entry door is not original and is in fair condition. Its removal would not compromise the character or style of the building. Steel doors with embossed panel patterns were approved at 1346 L.W.E. and 1322 L.W.E. within the past year (Aug. 1991 and May 1992 respectively). Therefore, I recommend approval of this item with the stipulation that the steel door replacement have an embossed panel pattern. 9) Crown moldings, fascia boards, and soffit boards are deteriorating in several areas and need replacement. The owner proposes to replace these in-kind. I recommend approval of this item as submitted. 10) This proposal as submitted is not in keeping with standard I.B.(2), which recommends that "[n]ew site work should ... be